A brief Debate on the Aryan Invasion /Migration Theory (AIT) vs Indigenous Aryans theory (IAT)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 чер 2021
- Download the Success Plus Academy App :
clpamy.page.link/SUKL
Use the web Portal :
study.successplusacademy.com/...
By connecting with app and web portal you can access free and premium content prepared by Success Plus Academy team.
In this video we have covered certain facts on debate of Aryan Invasion theory (AIT) vs Indigenous Aryans theory (IAT) . There is a big political and scientific debate on the origin of Aryans. In this video we have covered following aspects on the topic:
Archeological Evidence
Linguistic sources
Mythology and Scriptures
Genetic analysis
Lets have a look to get informed.
World History playlist :
• World History Series -...
Follow us on Telegram and ask your Queries :-
Telegram - t.me/successplusacademy
Connect with us on Instagram :
successplusacad...
Follow us on Facebook :-
m. Success-Plus-A...
So authentic, so extensive, so explanatory, so informative, so investigating, so unimaginable, so applauding!!!!!!!!!!!
Thanks, thanks, thanks a thousand thanks!
What a discourse!
Thanks Subodh ji
Kindly see archiological evidences,.
Oldest evidence of Sanskrit language,,,
Oldest copy of any vedas
@@dryudhvirsingh7782.
@gh hg jhandu baam hai tu.. tujhe kuchh nhi pata..😆 ignorant hokar kisi jaankaari ko haasil nhi Kar sakte
@@SuccessPlusAcademy Bro tumne facts ke Saath baat ki lekin AIT ke khilaf hoke baat zayada ki hai. Overall lecture bahut accha tha. Main bhi jab study karta Hun to kahin na kahin Meri biasness aa hi jaati hai.
एक दिन सच उजागर होगा जल्दी जब भारत के मानसिक गुलाम आजाद होंगे
मानसिक गुलाम लगता तुम हो या फिर मूलनिवासी वाली अवधारणा
Arya word Buddhism ke Pali Bhasha se Sanskrut Bhasha me bana hai
Ariy ka Arya hua
Jambudweep me Jo ghusse the unki koi identity nahi thi
Weh Euresia se aaye
2m
Mai tu India may peda Hoya na
@@goravmachal2111 कोई भगा भी नहीं रहा बस सच्चाई बताई जा रही है
बहुत सुंदर व ज्ञान वर्धक चर्चा ।यहां पर राखिगढी (हिसार)में मिले 4500वर्ष पूर्व के कंकाल के DNA पर भी थोड़ा प्रकाश डालना चाहिए।
Sir rakhighadi pr saparate video jldi hi aayega
@@SuccessPlusAcademy sir Iran ke kuch log ab protest kar rahe he ki vo aaryan he vo muslim bad me bane. Aur vahape hanuman aur devtao ki murti bhi mili mandir me Sanskrit lipi bhi mili panch hajar sal purane. To is bareme kuch bataiye.
@@shitalsurushe7496
उन्ही ईरानीयों को पुराणों में असुर कहा गया हैं
✌️✌️✌️
@@user-bo6se6vu4r किसको सही माने asiके खुदाई करनेवाले वैज्ञानिक को या आपको
@@user-bo6se6vu4r r heplogroup desh ke 35% population me paya jata hai.. R1a and R2
Awesome lecture... I salute to your efforts to expose the conspiracy of dividing native Indians (both Dravid and Arya). Keep it up.
NO ARYAN INVASION THEORY..ULTIMATE PROVE.
ua-cam.com/video/1bsyi4zYHP0/v-deo.html
🤣😂😂🤣😃😃😂
3500 years ago, Dravidians Buddhists Tamils Indians ruled Afghanistan, Pakistan, Sri Lanka(still ruled by Buddhists) & All of India ( giant Buddha statues built by Tamils),
Dalits, Adivasi were destroyed, looted, enslaved by Aryans that originated from zorastrians empires of iran - with recent evidence of Adolf Hitler Massacre & oppression of Jews, he proudly claimed himself an Aryan bloodline & preached Aryans as superior Race & only rightful race to Rule, same concept of upper caste,
The Great Mohenjedaro - Harappa, Indian vally civilization build by Dravidians Buddhists Tamils, the most sophisticated way of life of the time were erased, the most peaceful society were pushed to South India & Adivasi excaped to mountains, still naxalites are fighting adivasi wars but sadly many were systematically looted & enslaved & their womens made s*x slaves & childrens forced into labour by making them unjustified lower caste, sadly this injustice is going on till today - may God give refuge to the oppressed of all societies, subscribe my channel for more information ***Vield Facts** know more
bolna chahta hu....Jharkhand Bihar Odisha Chhattisgarh ..some Gujarati people ...yeh sab Kale hote hai but....tum log South Indian ko hi target kyu karte ho
बहुत 👍बहुत अच्छा ब्यौरा देने🙏💕 का प्रयास किया गया है। धन्यवाद। जयहिन्द🙏💕।
जो भी भारत में जन्मे देवी देवताओं गुरु धर्म को मानता है वहीं असली भारतीय हैं
जब तक हम हमने धारण की हुई गुलामी से नहीं निकलेंगे, हम अपने मूल, संस्कृति, उत्पत्ति को नहीं ढूंढ पायेंगे।
Bharat. Kea. Dusman. Vo. Lalchi. Hindu. Neta. Jo. Gulam. Bannea. Ko
Teyar. Hea. Lalchi. Desh. Bechnea
Arya word Buddhism ke Pali Bhasha se Sanskrut Bhasha me bana hai
Ariy ka Arya hua
Jambudweep me Jo ghusse the unki koi identity nahi thi
Weh Euresia se aaye
Sindhu Ghati Sabhyata Buddha Sankruti hai
@@anjalib2210 ye reference galat hai pali se pehle sanskrit tha aur ek aur baat arya shabd vedic Sanskrit me bhi tha aur vedic Sanskrit ke baad pali ayi! Samjhi
@Morning Star seriously 1000 ? Do you mean that sanskrit was created 1000 year ago? Then how sahe patanjali wrote yog shastr in sanskrit who was in the court of sunga gupta around 185 BC and this means it was in administrative use and if it was in use its script must be at least 1000 year ago created from that time this means it's ...at least developed 3000 ... don't say anything if you are not aware of it !
@Morning Star it's sung not shung....misspelld!
मार कर कोई भगा नहीं रहा है लेकिन सच हिम्मत से बोलो 👍। उलझाव भाषा मत बोलो
Right
Baba saheb ko padh lo
Aryan culture Originated In India. Jai Aryavrata
यूरेशियन है आर्यन ये खुद एक ब्राम्हण ने बोला
@@djrnktaram7086 bhai terse ek sawal puchhu agr ek Russia ka citizen terse ye keh dega ki russia phle india ka part tha to tu maann lega gjb logic ek brahman saare aryo ko represente nhi kr skta h
I think Aryans came to India around 3000-4000 BC , maybe earlier and coexistence with people of Indus Valley civilization. The Aryan represented priests , warriors and cow herds while IVC represented traders , craftsmen and farmers.
Rochak , I guess you are not a good listener. The tutorial has already smashed the Aryan Invasion Theory, with proper facts.
Just try to finish the tutorial this time, with proper concentration. 👍
दयानंद सरस्वती मुर्ति पुजा का विरोधी था तो उसने वेदों में मुर्ति पुजा को शामिल नही किया मुझे यह चिंता हो गई है क्रपया रिसर्च कर मेरा मार्गदर्शन करें
This river has dried ten thousand years ago as per modern scientists this proves ramayan and mahabharat are much older than that time and these two epics have always given importance to chaturvedas in their culture which shows again that vedas are much older than these epic periods so none of Aryan invasion theories won't stand infront of sensible logic
Exactly Man
the Migration was from India to outside, There are studies which says, Genghis Khan didn't invade india was because he believed their gods and culture originated from India, which is a clear indication to justify that The Migrations is from India to globe
Ramayan and mahabharata are fictional 🤣
@@anamelessmonster ok and how can u say that
@@anamelessmonster 😂, just like Muhammad flying on donkey to 7th sky?
Explained so well.I am a medico by profession but found it very interesting and knowledgeable
Sir, this aryan invasion theory was created by english men and in post independence India supported by muslim educationists with the sole aim to divide us Hindus. In my book " A Homeland for Your Children " available on Amazon and flipcart, I have dicussed this and other issues dividing and plotting us against each other. Some theories in our religion are responsible for our cowardly behaviour which I have discussed thread bare. It is a must read for every Hindu if they want to see their children survive as Hindus.
@@madanlal3178 appreciate for ur work👍💯
@@madanlal3178 yess
Sir, could you highlight the time period, from where and when onwards Hindu strated funneral of pyre?
Sir I am very impressed with your teaching method
Debating Is the best way to understand things in depth by comparing facts
I request you sir to kindly carry on for us
Thanks for requested video.. I am CA by profession not preparing for any exam still i watch your video coz i find your video pretty knowledgeable and interesting..
The Avesta (holy text of iran) refers to ‘Airayana Vajjo’, i.e. Aryavarta ( North India) as the homeland of the Zoroastrians( Iranians were followers of Zoroastrianism before Muslim invade in 650 bc) . Clearly indicates that the migration was from India to iran.. not from the iran to India.The ancient Persian sources also know the famous Dasharathi Rama of Ayodhya and his teacher Vasishttha, who is mentioned in the Avesta as Vahishta! There is even a gatha to him - the Vahishta-Ishti-Gatha. There is a reference in the Vedas about a decisive conflict, known as the Battle of Ten Kings, in which King Sudas is reported to have inflicted a crushing defeat on the Prthus (Parthians) and the Parsus (Persians), an event that may have caused a geographical and cultural rift between the Indians and the Persians.
Yup, Aryans are indigenous they are from Sapta Sindhu area
After battle of ten kings many tribes spread iran and other northwestern parts
@@gouravdey497 yes..😊
@@gouravdey497 British ka bas chle toh ye v narrative aajyega kisidin k Indians migrate krke aaya hai Pakistan se 😂😂.. jyse battle of ten kings ki division ko aryan migration bol diya
You are only quoting stories from text those are not even authentic, there is no real live text which was written in that period that we have with us today, the form of Vedas that we read were written during Vijay Nagar Empire 1400AD (Earlier Vedas were destroyed by Muslim Invasions).And the scientific DNA marker theory won't agree with you. Moreover the earliest Inscription of Aryans gods are -
1⃣Kassi Inscription(1700 B.C)➡️ Found in Central Asia.
2⃣Bogazkoi Inscription(1400 B.C)➡️ Asia Minor ➡️4 Vedic God
1) Indra 2) Maitra 3)Varun 4)Nasatyo➡️NVIM
Untill India finds a Archeological site within 🇮🇳 which is older than above sites, that can testify the presence of Aryans before this period it will be believed they were outsiders.
And to add this, the oldest swastika sign is found in Ukraine which was carved in 10,000 BC.
Well explained..we may have come from anywhere. Knowing past is good but live in present and not make differences
आपने लगभग 99% सही आकलन किया है आभार। धन्यवाद भाई। शाबाश।
Sir apne bahut si cheeze chupa li bass Aryans ko bacane ke liye
Hindu Dharm ka janm IndusValley Civilization ke baad hua tha
Aryans ke India me Akramn krne ke baad hindu religious ka janm hua tha
Puri knowledge dijiye sir
Well explained. I am not preparing for any Compitative exam but just for curicity I have watched this video. As a hindu and as an indian we have to know our history.
Same sister ✌Panda😁🐼
@@varshagangwar614 Same! Here, " Varsha " 🌦️🌦️ " GangWar " 🧔⚔️🔪🔫 😁✌️
@@YashSharma-zp8yu we sanatani are older than history.
@@emmanuelmacaron4648 ?
@@YashSharma-zp8yu sanatan dharm ka na koi aarambh hai na ant
Sir , I was not aware of this channel but suddenly I got it and the way you teach is really awesome!
Very in depth presentation.. So many things get cleared, beautifully simplistically explained👍
NO ARYAN INVASION THEORY..ULTIMATE PROVE.
ua-cam.com/video/1bsyi4zYHP0/v-deo.html
Thank you so much for sharing this precious and totally unknown historic information to us .
You are the one sir who discuss this issue openly with argumently.
Hats off
The important point is , are we utilising that ancient values, we are claiming for.
Salutes to ur deep study of history & appreciation for ur made easy explanation. Never mind for English pronunciation Sir. Ultimately we should be proud of Hindi & Sanskrit which has described unknown Cosmos to the whole world much early. Thank U Sir for ur propagation of less known facts.
Thank you Shriram ji. Your kind words means alot.
Your lecture was very well structured and was very informative. I'm subscribing you
Swastik sign can be found in both IVC and Vedic age , it means Indus Valley Civilization and Aryans have some similarties also , both the cultures do worship of God's but Rudra dev was common , both worshiped the trees !
It indicates that they have some common rituals also , so we can't say very clearly that Ayrans are Invaders!
But our history books are following Maxx muller , instead of teaching both the aspects !
there is no Aryan as ethnicity
@@nitishnayak1005 Aryans existed, whether or not they came from outside is the debate.
@@parthmudgal9270 Aryan is a adjective at that time..... first time Aryan used as race is very latter of Persian Empires and white huns
@@nitishnayak1005 It was definitely a race. Even in Ramayan , Ram is called Aryaputra ( descendant of Arya vansh). The battle of 10 kings also points to Aryans by name.
@Rajesh Pal they losers of the battle moved towards east and central India. Not west. Puru tribe was soundly defeated by Sudas, and before the battle of 10 kings, Puru tribe occupied the area East of Indus river. Punjab was occupied by Sudas with his victory, which means the only viable option left for the puru tribe was to move eastwards towards modern day Haryana and Western UP.
I have studied evolutionary biology from Dr. Gyaneshwar Chaubey whom you mentioned at 42:26, He is a Professor of Genetics in BHU
🏳️🌈
Sanskrit bolne me telngu jaise hai aur likhn me devnagari (hindi) jaisi jo ki ye saf darshata hai ki hm sb ak hi hai ❣️🇮🇳
telgu pali bhasa se bana sanskrit pali bhasa se hai
भाषा महत्वपूर्ण नहीं है सर जी,काफी दिनों बाद एक सुन्दर lectur सुन कर मन को तसल्ली हुई ,🙏🙏
अगर आर्य बाहर से अपने साथ हिन्दू संस्कृति लेकर आये तो रामायण और महाभारत का क्या ?? उनमे तो भारत का ही जिक्र है। अगर हिन्दू संस्कृति यूरोपियन है तो उसमे यूरोप का जिक्र क्यों नही है?
Yeh kisne kaha ki wo Apne sath hindu or Vedic Sanskriti leke aaye? Vedic knowledge or Vedic Sanskriti bharatiye. Rig Veda jo ki Sabse purana hai usme bhi kewal bharat ka hi jikra hai
Woo yhii aake bnayii gyii haii..... Woo bhi bhut late likhi gyii haii...... Chooroo
@@user-kd8pr4zr4i look @4:00
@@user-kd8pr4zr4i सनातन धर्म ही सत्य है बाकी सब पाखंड है हर हर महादेव 🙏
@@kapildutt7402 SANATANA DHARM JHUT HAI OR CHUTIYA HAI
What we have to learn from your informative lecture is that, we are all one human race. The Nature has created diversities to make our life more purposeful & enjoyable.
You are right but jatwad ke adhar par atyachar kiya jata hai tab koi nahi bolta, sachchayi to samne ani chahiye, kon galat hai kon sahi,
Aryans are Indian originally
0o7ouu8kikkii
@@ravi711983 vedic period ko do bhago me bata gaya hai. Early vedic period aur later vedic period. Early vedic period me Jatiwad kuchh nahi tha , jo chahe vo apna varg ko badal sakta tha jaise brahman se sudra , worrier se trader . But later vedic period me ye system change ho gaya ,jo jis varg me kary karta tha vo apne varg ko badal nahi sakta tha. Jatiwad kuchh nahi ye samay ke sath ek mat ho gaya.
Tumhare majhab walo ko ye bat samjao to duniya me shanti rahegi.
Please provide some information about IVC. How old it is? Is it older than Vedas? Is there any mention of IVC in Vedas? If not mentioned, than surely the period of IVC should be much more older than what we taught. Otherwise the scripts of IVC would be intelligible.
This is a sensitive topic for many Indians since they have their identity attached to greatness of noble Vedic culture and Aryan ancestry.
A few questions that pop in mind:
* If India's political boundary today also included all the ancient Vedic cultures (Europe, Iran etc) and was called "Bharata", would one still be trying to prove "Out of India" theory?
* Why not have a "Out of Kishkinda" theory where forest dwellers of Kishikinda jungles moved northward and mixed with Indians living in the gangetic plain (sure they do have some common genes)? or an "Out of Mexico or Brazil" theory where European migration into Americas never happened but it was the reverse?
* How does one account for the fact that Europeans and most other Indo-European speakers in West Asia DO NOT HAVE any (that is, zero or virtually zero) South Asian IVC-related admixture in their DNA? (IVC = Indus Valley)? Does it not clearly show the direction of migration?
I think an Aryan "Migration" happened and not invasion - IVC was already on a decline when Aryans came to India. Sure there were some initial violent interactions between Aryans and early settlers people in IVC, but that was a norm between different tribes/races around the world at that time and shouldn't be judged by today's moral standards (Classic books such as Sapiens or Third Chimpanzee is a great read in this area). My admiration for "Maryada purushottam" Lord Rama or Vedas still stands tall despite Aryan migration.
An example of invasion is what Putin is doing in Ukraine today which is totally immoral.
I do understand there could be a political ramification of this where a certain section calls "descendants of these Aryan settlers" (read "upper castes") as "foreigners". Many fear this has the potential to divide India and I acknowledge that sentiment, however in today's connected globalized multicultural world, people of all cultures/castes/races are "melting", does it matter anymore?
If one reads books such as Sapiens and The Third Chimpanzee, we would understand how homo sapiens around the world are all connected, and have continuously migrated & come together to bring about big changes in how we live since we were hunter gatherers. No ethnic group around the world can claim an “original” homeland anymore, including the aborigines in Andaman or in Papua New Guinea. People need to be educated about this and the one-ness of entire humanity and not fall into trap of "one group is more exclusive/superior than other". Ironically, isn't this what "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" is about which we Indians are so familiar with?
We shouldn't judge history by today's moral standards. History should be accepted as it is without any shame - be it good or bad. Glory of our ancient past doesn't become any less, and I am still proud of our Aryan forefathers.
In conclusion, I would like to say that choice of words do matter as it has the power to send subconscious messages when we hear them. The words "invasion / raiders / annihilators / barbarians" isn't the right one to use for reasons mentioned above - context and history should be taken into account as well. Historians have a moral responsibility to be sensitive to perceptions created by the words they use.
The findings of escavations from Keezhadi village near Madurai in Taminadu and recent escavations in Haryana have been left put in the discussion. Inclusion of above escavations would have given mor. clarity.
Those are further evidence of the Continuing Hindu/lndus civilization theory. If "Dravidians" were driven out of Indus valley in 1500 BCE, how come there is such volume of evidence in all excavations from Keezhadi in TN, Puducherry to Rajasthan - Haryana on highly advanced civilization before 5000 BCE? Everything from Archeology through Genetics to Astronomy points to Continuing Hindu civilization.
@@SJ-zo3lz desperate. Vedic epoch started 2000 years after IVC. They are beef and are not Hin-dus.
@@SJ-zo3lz there's been zero evidence of any advanced civilisation in or around 5000 BC.
Horse bone discovered in surkotoda and spoked wheel in lothal and Rakhigarhi
🐎😜
@@jattmoosewala83 in sinauli not spoked wheel..it was solid wheel with copper designs
That was horse of Kangana Ranuat
Sir, In genetics you should talk about diversity in same genetic group. It tells about flow of genetics with time(ie sublineage). This will clarify about out of India theory.
i would recommend Dr. Niraj Rai and Vasant shinde for this topic..
Is there any archeological or any inscription proof that Chanakya was teaching at Taxila University?
आपके वीडियो में बहुत अच्छी जानकारी है लेकिन
दुनिया के कई देशों में मौजूद जाति व्यवस्था को खत्म कर दिया गया है लेकिन भारत में इसे खत्म क्यों नहीं किया गया, इसकी आलोचना की जानी चाहिए।
मैं आपकी राय से बिल्कुल सहमत हूं ।
यह तब खत्म होगी जब आप यादव लिखना बंद कर दोगे |
@@panditsatishattri306 or aap pandit likhna band kar denge
NO ARYAN INVASION THEORY..ULTIMATE PROVE.
ua-cam.com/video/1bsyi4zYHP0/v-deo.html
@@panditsatishattri306बहस करने का कोई फायदा नही है यादव ओर ब्राह्मण ही आर्यन है DNA report me saabit ho chuka hai or rigved me clearly mentioned h aryans ke 5 ancient tribe usme sabse phla naam yadav ka hi h yadu, puru, anu, dhuruyu,turusvu ye paanch aryo ke vansh the baaki koi nhi
*Mujhe IVC script me (jo aap dikhaye ppt slide me) swastik symbol bhi dikh raha hai jo hinduism ka sabse sacred Nishan hai*
Swastik symbol was also used by nazis so this means aryans cames from foreign
@@amit_601 no we went there
Or German ka bhi
Thank you wholeheartedly for talking about this topic so well
Sir, is it may be possible that language similarly is because we migrated towards west. Reverse migration/ invasion from bharat. Also in sanskrit Arya means shresth. This was a common word to say someone but britishes pickup this word and created narrative.
Video full of knowledge, appreciates your hard work 🙏
It clears my mind about this debate... thankyou so much sir🙏
Hy dear
आर्यों के अस्तित्व के बारे में दी गई जानकारी बेहतरीन एंड तर्कपूर्ण है
धन्यवाद
आर्यन थ्योरी मनगढ़ंत है। गोरो और काले लोग मौसम और जलवायु के कारण है साउथ में बेहिसाब गर्मी है और नार्थ में सर्दी। अंग्रेजों ने इसका फायदा उठाया और मनगढ़ंत कहानी बनाई
Can anyone give the summary of this debate and what was concluded??…..please
Great job, thanks for lots of information, keep up the good work.
Excellent analysis. Indian culture which we know as sonatoni exactly reflected in this narrative.
🙏 nicely explained very informative. Please keep doing this research 🙏
विदेशियों के साथ ही हमारे यहां के सआमयवआदइयओं और कथित बुद्धिजीवी भी यह झूठ गढ़ने में शामिल रहे हैं। आपके सटीक विश्लेषण केलिए साधुवाद।
आदिवासी इस देश का मूल मालिक हे ।
Pandu lacture sun le
Aadiwashi sabd ki utpatti kishne kiya
Ek dm shi baat hai, Vaisya, shudra and dalits all are true Indians
Saraswati river is still here in Gujarat exact the same place where you indicated in video map
Really impressed. This deserves millions of views. Thank you so much for it ❤️
NO ARYAN INVASION THEORY..ULTIMATE PROVE.
ua-cam.com/video/1bsyi4zYHP0/v-deo.html
@@blueocean7037 budha bhgoda🤣 🙏,, apko aggr kuch nhi malum to bta de ki Arya sanskriti word hai jo ki elders ke leye prashansha ke rup me istemal hota tha dravid kha gya hai 3 nadiyo ki jagha ko geography location ke tor pr aur Sindh me geography location ke tor pr hai to dravid aur Arya alag alag ho ye sawal hi nhi banta dravid yha ke log hai geography ke karn aur Arya sanskrit word hai jo unke culture ko define krta hai.....
Brilliantly presented!. I am watching your content for the first time and I am very impressed with the way you have presented such a complex topic. I am an Indian from the South, and I am sure the world will one day know that all non-Africans on this planet are populated by a tribe that has migrated out of India. Mother India, Indeed. Human history is older than we imagine. It is not just 4000 years old as it is mentioned in the holy Bible. Western historians are trying to fit everything within this 4000 years range, and that is a major mistake. Saptha rishis travelled out of India in all directions to spread the knowledge, we know it but we just need to prove it scientifically. It is just a matter of time. Jai Hind! Jai Sanathana dharma.
Very informative video. I was looking for such comparison since long time. You explained it very well.
One suggestion -If you could provide a final conclusion on both the theories (AIT/Indigeneous) wrt to language, culture, excavations, haloggroup that which theory looks more justifiable. I think this will improve your content quality multifold.
Thanks for sharing this knowledge. Keep it up.
Toward reality
You are great personality of world history
Follow history principles
Thank you sir.
You did fantastic work.
Subscribed
Thank you so much sir for this beautiful explanation. Many doubts have cleared now.
That's a reasonable and Fair analysis of the most controversial point of our entire history.
👍
Aryans and David both our that's it...
That's real.the great fridom fighter of our country are written this..on his book.who where the shudras
Harrapan civilizations kisi likhwat chitr jaisi aur vedic ki alag kyu agar vedic purankal se hai toh harrapan ko hindi sanskrit word use krna tha confused hu
Excellent and interested, Sir, a lot of thanks!
Thanks for the comprehensive overview of a subject that I am only getting to know. 🙏
Sir,
I believe india was reach in sweat water resources and when human converted from aap it was all around many sweat water rivers in world wide. Since india had a rich resources of sweet water all around so huge population may leave around and after that they move to Eurasian.
In Eurasia reason sweet water resources was available in less quantity so obviously population of that reason may less than indian reason how less dense people invaded indian dense population. Rather people of indian reason advanced to Eurasian countries.
Nice lecture sir..... Thanks for the precious knowledge....
Lekin sir idus civilization ki script ke kuch letter roman aur Greek se match kar rhe hai jaise, U,K,,
8 H X S inverted A,D
I am constrained to say that I don't find any debate but simply wrong representation and distortion of facts.
Then you must listen to Mr shrikant talageri and DR. Neeraj Rai on charvaka podcast UA-cam channel
Kudos to you Sir, the way you explain & the most important is the facts you have presented are mind blowing.🔥🔥
बहुत ही शुन्दरतम तथ्यात्मक व्याख्यान
विजय प्रकाश तिवारी
Super lecture sir to all the history aspirants who keen desire to know it's background theory ...
Thank you sir .. plz make more interesting historically vedios!!
Most logical explanation on this topic I've watched till now.
Thanks for such a scientific conclusion.
SC ST OBC Bharat ke Mul nivasi hai Jay Bheem Jay sanvidhan
Sabse bada jaat paat wala to tu he hai
Hats Off 🎩 Incredible , Amazing,, Knowledge📚. No Words to Describe This Presentation.
Sir apne bahut si cheeze chupa li bass Aryans ko bacane ke liye
Hindu Dharm ka janm IndusValley Civilization ke baad hua tha
Aryans ke India me Akramn krne ke baad hindu religious ka janm hua tha
Puri knowledge dijiye sir
Very authentic and very precise... You have covered almost everything which i have find on internet till date about this theory and compiled beautifully... Kudos to you for such an enlightening video on AIT.... I hope more knowledge and proofs we can find to conclude about the false interpretation of this theory....
So nice of you
2500 BC me Rik ved like kiske diye
Pather pe to likha nahi mila
Or carvan dating use 400-500 sal purani hi batata
Ho sakta h tum time travel ker ke tum paper deke aye ho ved likhne ke liye
सर आप बुद्धिसम के उपर भी व्हिडिओ बनाओ.
@@SuccessPlusAcademy Hi, excellent video ; very concise. I disagree on 2 areas though:
1. Script is not language ; Not just in Indus Valley, but across the world, script did not start being used till 2500 BCE. This means that the Indus Valley people would have spoken Vedic Sanskrit before 2500 BCE (as this is the language they composed Vedas in the same period and geography ) but did not WRITE IT DOWN before 2500BCE. Even today we have " illiterate " people who can chant Vedas for hours without error. So not being able to read or understand a script does not mean its an alien language! Besides, the lVC script is analysed to be a close ancestor of Brahmi script which later became Devnagari (using which we write Sanskrit, Hindi etc. today) , Kadamba (Kannada-Telugu script) , Grantha (Burmese, Tamizh-Malayalam script) etc. You can refer Subhajit Ganguly's paper on this.
2. It's a myth that horses were not found in Indus Valley excavations. They were found but in small numbers when compared to population as they were presumably possessed by the elites (like today). In Indus seals , the animal that looks like a unicorn is likely to be a bull-horse combo "sankalpa" , both animals of immense importance to the Indus / Sindhu/ Hindu / Vedic civilization; Reference :
swarajyamag.com/culture/the-missing-horses-of-harappan-seals-are-not-really-missing/
Hope you would revisit this otherwise-excellent video and bring out a revised version.
As someone who has been researching on this topic for Iong, would recommend you to follow works of Nilesh Oak and Raj Vedam, if not done already. Both of them base their conclusions on facts, evidence and objective inquiry.
All the very best ! You are sure to have a very successful future !
@@hemsahirwar3900 Script was not discovered by humans till at least 2500BCE!
Nice explanation, I watched full video without pause and getting bored, does not happen often 😂
Sir khilji ne agar library burn ki to uski naam se district aur railway station government ne kyu banaya
Jo sinauli me kankal Mila hai uski size kya hai ?
Because dwapar yug me human ki length 11 feet hoti hai
Even Nazi Germans called themselves "Aryan".
There are many similarities between Brahmanism & Persians. Aryans are outsider. It can be myth, but possible too. There is many similarities between Holy book Rigved & Zend Avesta, which is Persian holy book.
People migrated from India to Iran and Europe
For ricebags : Biblikal stories are histories but vedas is myth .Heights of hypocrisy 🙂🙂
Europeans aren't Aryans. What Nazis called themselves doesn't change reality. Only Indo Iranian are Aryans.
@alan hembrom Only indo Iranins are Aryans.
Aryans are indo European language speaking people but not all Indo European language speaking people are aryan. Persians and Vedic people called themselves Aryans. Arya word only found in Vedas and Avesta not found in other Indo European languages
@alan hembrom there are today 8 sub language families of Indo European family. One of them is Indo Iranian. People of indo Iranian are Aryans. other Indo European people aren't Aryans
प्रश्न यह है कि मानव की उत्पत्ति क्या एक स्थान पर हुई अथवा पृथ्वी पर अनेक स्थानों पर एक साथ हुई? इस विषय पर आप वीडियो बनाएं। होमोसेपियन्स की उत्पत्ति अफ्रीका में ही क्यों? वन्दे भारत मातरम।
Please read a book called SAPIENS. YOU WILL GET YR ANSWER
छान,लेकचर,,आहे,सर,आपले,,,खूप,सरव,,गोष्टी,,,नीकष,करून,तौलनीक,अभयास,करून,आपण,लेकचर,देत,आहे,,,छान,,,,,,,आभारी,आहे,,,
perfect analysis & factfull views ..... appreciated . Big THUMBS-UP
Aryan are outsiders.
And you are Bonafide student of Baman meshram University 😃
@@rannu7081 you are stupid.😂😂😂😂
@@rannu7081 baman nahi vaman he. Aaryan bahari he ya nahi ye to nahi pata par nagawanshi log mulnivashi jarur he. Aur Sindhi log bhi Sindhu ghati ke origin he.
@SHRIKANT LITKE dimak hai ki ghutane me hai abhi bhi 😂😂😂
You have nailed the point.
However, why there's no reference of this so called migration, no such reference to the migration is there in any of the later religious books of the world.
Why would religious book have references to migration?
All Brahmins will deny the Aryan invasion theory....
जो भी हो हम हाल में है वही हमारी हकीकत हे ओर हमें उसे ही मानना चाहिए
You did good job. It takes lot of time to prepare and share. Thank you
Explained well...and in support of Out of India theory, u can also add the fact of continental drift theory that once peninsular India, Antarctica and Africa etc were one, so no one migrated to India from Africa instead India itself travelled to its current position.
Have you checked Continental drift kitne saal pahle huya tha or human kab pairo PR chalna sikhe the
@Bob Marley ok chawal bori, Tera yesu ka baap kon tha wo Pata nahi chale ye sab khojne.
@@infinite5795 Wo Jo bhi baat ho lekin continental drift to bilkul possible nahi hai.
@@SURJEETSINGH-sn7hm kyu? Continental drift is true and makes more sense than the alternatives.
NO ARYAN INVASION THEORY..ULTIMATE PROVE.
ua-cam.com/video/1bsyi4zYHP0/v-deo.html
So many people say that sanskrit is mother of all languages !!
Means if you know sanskrit so you can easily learn any language. (Statements by Sushma Swaraj, Subramanian Swamy and many more)
If you noticed that similarities between sanskrit and tamil language ....
That's point also deny Aryan invasion theory.
Plz Keep continuing this series because your videos clear my doubts ✌
Mayank sir, we need more detailed videos and people like you to interprete and simplify for beginners like me. To add anything or comment I MUST watch this video again. Very sincere effort and highly balanced views. For English pronunciations, I woud suggest to consult and make sure since English is not a phonetically accurate like Sanskrit where sound and words match. I enjoyed watching and reading all learned viewer's Comments.
Who says sankrit is mother of all languages? The Sanskrit language itself desecended from proto Indo-Iranian branch. It is part of broader Indo European language family. Tamil belongs to totally different language family. Tamil is least influenced from Sanskrit. Even if you remove the Sanskrit words from Tamil, it will still survive. Aryan Invasion has long been denied but not Aryan Migration. Aryan Migration is a fact.
@@vighig1903 Tamil has 40% Sanskrit vocab 😂🤦 rice bag
But your so called sanskrit langauge was not found in harrappa civilization
Well explained.You tried ur best.
In kannada there is one saying "one should not try to search for d origin & birth of a Rushi ,a river & a woman."
It means that you cannot true origin & birth & it will have destorted ,hidden.....it can be any thing we can never find.
Bhohat mehenat se aap yeh video banaye🙏
Muje bhohat achha laga..aur sikne mila🙏
Great presentation. Thank you.
Maturity is when you realise we all are Native Africans 🤣🤣
Ha ha ha
kch bi mat bolo
Mixture of both I think
U r
😂😂😂
Fir Dravino se DNA mil jata hai par savarno se nahi.
Abhi haal ke khudayi me nar-kankal mile jo sabit karte hai ki ham dalit aur hinduo me alag hone ke ek pukhta sabut hai.
Nahi barosha to pata kar lo.
I understand everything THANKYOU ♡ SIR
There was no hindu word in scriptures too.
Hind derived from Sanskritic term Sindhu.. Persian conquerer called them hindu people ( means sindhu people).. this is vedic or Sanatan dharm.. Aryans are indigenous.. the Iranian inscription mentioned hindu as a district of indus.. the term is corrupted.. vedic Sanatan dharm follows by hindu people/ dharm of hindu's known as hindu Dharm.. likewise dharm of Christian, Christianity, dharm of jain people jain dharm, dharm of Buddhist people, boudh Dharm.. am not a fanatic religious person, bt what am trying to say is our scriptures are gems..our heritage our culture are enrich with knowledge..but it is sad to say that its been distorted..
BCE का मतलब हम समझे नही
@@govind.verinicekulkarni1865 before the birth of Jesus Christ
@@pujadas4566 are kion jhoot faila rha hai .. 5 September 2019 ko DNA report aayi tab se hajaro portal per yahi chupane ki koshi ki ja rhi hai ki ve euresian nhi hai....asli name YAMNAYA hai...ab koi fayada nhi...
@@deepakarya4208 Rakhigarhi dna analysis also said that agriculture started here before invasion, means aryans are not those of pastoralise people who came from Eurasia..no traces of r1a1 gene in Rakhigarhi female cause r1a1 is a sex biased gene, only found in males.. female skeleton 16614 also reveals its ancestry similarities with indo ariyan and andamanis tribe
कुछ लोग मुँह से पैदा हुए हैं। उनका डी एन ए कैसे मूलनिवासियों से मेल खायेगा??
Chopo pahele aacha se pad
🤣🤣🤣
Thanks for information 👍,
Great job 👏,
Keep it up
हम भारत वासी ही थे और भारत वासी ही रहेंगे
हर हर महादेव ❤❤❤
JAY BHIM
Who are you then???
@Vikram singh Sabharwal No no buddhuram ko puch raha hu
Tathagat budha hi bidesi he...is liye usko sakya singh kaha jata he....bidesi saka😃
@@rannu7081 yes..gadhagat ajit ke andh bhakt hai yeh buddhiram
@@rannu7081 shakas were central asians who migrated to India and established kingdoms between 1000 BC to 300 BC ...shakyas were indo scythians (shakas)...parsavas ,hun ,kushan yeh sab central asians the jo bharat me ake base...buddha bhi central Asian the...
Aryan migration issues are actively discussed online in the main English-speaking segment.
Some commentators jokingly describe the tendency of the Aryan theme as an attempt to transplant them on horses. I think the historical data do not tend to this. But there are pressing problems faced by politicians, economists, the military, etc., these are communications around the Himalayas.
Communication is possible when there is peace in the region.
Therefore, around the Himalayas we need: Trust, Consent, Goodwill.
It would also be understandable and expedient:
1 transport: road and rail links.
2. “Circular Caring Grid.
Where energies are accumulated and sent to the addressee through correlated consolidated power systems. Logistically connected gas and oil pipelines.
3. Tourism. The Himalayas is a nuclear-free zone, such should be, with a clean ecology, clean energy associated with tourism, sports, and recreation along the entire route.
The Peace March can become an additional conductor of a new outlook on life, the prospects for mutually enriching good intentions around the Himalayas.
4. “information flows.
Nonviolence around the Himalayas. Information resource conducting the ideas of peace and non-violence
(M. Gandhi, Abay and others).
4. What do we have on this issue.
Almaty, monument to Mahatma Gandhi, School named after M. Gandhi on the street. M. Gandhi.
Cultural heritage of Abai as a peaceful coexistence of countries and peoples.
Start near the monument to M. Gandhi. Photo for memory, media, television and radio broadcasts. New opportunities for a world without violence, which were guided by M Gandhi. “… Central Asia is located at the crossroads of Eurasia. He was caught in the streams of history, and that is also his form. He has seen the rise and fall of empires. He has witnessed trade and prosperity, the ebb and flow. For monks, merchants, and monarchs, it was like a destination and passage. It was the mediator of cultures and faiths from all over Asia. Your gifts to human civilization have been rich. Your imprint on the progress of mankind lasts ...”(from the speech of the Prime Minister of India N. Modi at Nazarbayev University, Astana).
Stops on the route.
1. Stop in Lhasa (China), speeches of gratitude to the Chinese leadership for the opening of the M. Gandhi center in Beijing, and the possibility of creating a working corridor on the parikrama route along the Himalayas.
2. Stop in Delhi, near the centers of M. Gandhi, puja, offering flower petals to the place of Gandhi. Peace through culture program.
3. Stop in Multan (Pakistan), suggests a rally on the occasion
on the occasion of the end point of the passage of TAPI for peace and non-violence, in the region, the entry of TAPI through the Fazilka point into India. Opportunities for advancing to the borders of China, mention of Gandhi
4. Stop in Herat, confirmation of the ideas of non-violence for peace in the region on the occasion of the passage of TAPI through Afghanistan, a short meeting - a demonstration for peace and non-violence, a mention of the construction of a dam by the Indians.
5. Stop in Mary (Turkmenistan), involves a rally on the occasion of the completion of the passage of TAPI, with slogans for peace and non-violence, a mention of the Gandhi monument in Ashgabat.
6. Stop in Dushanbe (Tajikistan) involves a rally near the monument
R. Tagore, mention of what R. Tagore called Gandhi - Mahatma. Mahatma is an Aryan term in the Mahabharata it is applied to the vizier Vidura.
Guest speeches for peace, non-violence and prosperity.
7. Stop, Tashkent (Uzbekistan), a meeting for friendship and non-violence, it is also possible to visit the M. Gandhi corner at the University, or the L. Shastri monument.
8. Stop in Bishkek (Kyrgyzstan) involves a rally, near the monument to M. Gandhi, for peace and non-violence.
Arrival in Almaty means the successful completion of the parikrama route around the Himalayas, for the happiness and prosperity and peaceful future of the peoples of the region.
Sad that you wrote such a big explanation, but probably no one will read it....good job though.
@@mrigamonmrigamon2615 Thank you for your attention
Bahut hi sahi bataya hai sir aapne aisa pahle kabhi nahin suna ya padaa mene