igot7-lu infinite have members, but sunggyu lines too dominant than the others, especially sungjong and my bias (sungyeol). Sungyeol can rap but i hope sungyeol got rap for next album
i think they use main vocalist too much..its not like other member cant sing at all.... in whatta man, somi, doyeon, chungha and pinky can slay without sejeong and yeonjung...
It's a strategy that they adapt (maybe to earn more money?). But I get you. I think it would only work if the company is stable (like SM). They know how to use the number of members to attract fans and projects. But for smaller companies, it's actually a very big risk 😕 I don't know of any large groups outside of SM that had equal success so far...
Weeaboo Faggot Wtf. I understand there's like 13 girls in WJSN but if an 11 member group like IOI can do relatively even line distribution then so can they.
i dont think laughter by svt is that bad. everyone has some lines, even dancers. this is one of the best svt's ln, not like boomboom, where junhui and minghao get 2-3 sec
If it's a ballad song, obviously the main vocalists are going to have a lot of lines. If it's a hip-hop style song, the rappers will have more lines. The only time you should be mad is when a few members continuously get the least lines.
Starship its terrible in line distribuition , are you see of Trespass of Monsta X ? Omg .... The debut its so good, but the lines ... sorry my english xD I'm your fan from Brazil ♡♡
Of course there's going to be unfair line distributions. They have to make the main vocalists sing the majority of the song so that it actually sounds decent. The majority of people in each group have weak voices and are given one line.
Sorry, but I do not agree. Most of them can sing. All I.O.I members are good vocalists maybe Sohye needs to improve more but she can sing. (I will fight with those who say otherwise). Soyou from Sistar is so talented but can not shine because of the amount of lines Hyorin gets. In Seventeen, for a ballad song, even the rap line get more lines than Jun and The8. And I'm not even going to talk about WJSN, only 4 members get lines for 13 members.
sanatozaki all of ioi members are not good vocalist sohye Mina chaeyeon are all really bad.yoojung doyeon and sometimes pinky are unstable when singing live.sometimes you guys need to realize singing in the studio then actually performing it live is another thing.
because there is so called 'main dancer', 'rapper', 'visual' etc. not all member who have good voice can do rap or have a charisma. thats why they put them into one group. there is a reason why they called 'group'. be mature
The main vocalists will always have the most lines. Why are people shocked. Lines have to be distributed like this in order for the song to actually sound good.
woozikookie agreed, it all makes a lot of sense for their positions. however, the profiles do say that china line are vocalists so if they got more, it'd be great but I don't think that's happening so, but it's mostly quite fair. Blessed By Jisoo's Half of your comment is cut off, so I'll just respond to what I see. Yes, they do have unique voices, but to not match the song? No way. Like in No F.U.N, the no lines for Jun & Minghao was quite unnecessary, they could have fit in well. Actually, I'm a bit skeptical about Minghao due to his accent (that seems to be the one big restraining factor for him, poor kid), but Jun? His tone fits right in, it's deep and sounds cool, he could've at least gotten one line. 'The songs Jun was in he sang in a lot. Whereas, Minghao got barely any lines in the songs he was in.' Jun didn't get a lot compared to the others. In Boom Boom, Minghao has more lines by a lot. In Beautiful, Minghao gets like 15 lines if you just count like actual lines, not seconds (I'll update with seconds when I have more time). While in Well/I don't know, Jun gets 6 lines. Jun's parts are sung considerably slower, so if we had to compare it to Minghao from estimates, maybe around 12-14 lines? Close to Minghao, but not above.
Blessed By Jisoo's it's not 6 lol unless your counting them in a different way I am? But Jun legit just gets one 'Everyday boom boom' I think lol and Minghao gets the repeating part of the 'Make a hit come on' so that keeps repeating so it's more also I saw boom boom line distributions and Minghao gets more
Blessed By Jisoo's also, how'd jun get 8 lines in highlight? Highlight's chorus happens 3 times, if I'm not mistaken. That's 3 lines, then 2 for the part at the beginning? So it'd be more like 5? I'll actually get to second counts in a bit, just need my laptop and I'll update with that
I know that... my point is that the line distribution doesn't reflect the fact that they have lots of girls with vocal potential. And also the fact that the Unit achieved all that without either main vocal.
Seventeen-Laughter might look bad but the song has no rap only singing as such the vocal line has there normal vocal lines amounts but the rap line has substantial decrease because they have little to none singing experience
CasqueHD Its not like they have no singing experience because they were trained as vocalist (maybe except Vernon) but the song would have the worst flow and a bad sound if they were to sing DKs or Seungkwans parts. Its fair tbh looking at there positions. But i agree its not that bad
CasqueHD actually the hip hop team is fine (except Mingyu) but Minghao and Jun keep on getting way less even if they have great voices and would have been fit to sing more
Blessed By Jisoo's Jun actually does get hardly any lines when compared to others. In most songs, Jun does get more over Minghao but by milliseconds, really. Jun's lines have seen an increase, as distributions are getting better for SVT as time goes on. The reason why people say Minghao and Jun are because they both when compared to others and their skills don't get the amount they deserve. For Minghao, I guess he is just in a really awkward situation, since he has a good voice but his accent makes it hard for him to really show that, and fit his voice well into more cool, darkish songs. For Jun, though, I really mean there isn't an excuse?? Basically, what I mean is that even though Jun gets slightly more than Minghao, it still isn't enough for all his talent that can be shown. It's the same case for Minghao, therefore the two get grouped together. (and most people think that most of the problem is just from their accents too, which a good amount of it is, and ofc only the Chinese members have accents different from the rest.) Also, about Vernon, I just don't think he's good at singing?? Like, I remember back when you'd see him sing in like Mansae era, to put it kindly, it was a mess in ways.. He's improved, but definitely not as great as the others, therefore that's why they didn't give him more lines. If it was being shy, I think it would've changed the amount of lines in general. I think Vernon does have quite the confidence in himself on stage, so I don't think it's about being shy. I just realized how long this is whoops
I wish Woozi would try out more with Minghao's voice. I was thinking about this earlier but his voice is kinda high pitched actually and if they trained him more, he could make Seventeen's songs even more special just like Sunyoul kind of does in Up10tion. They could also try training him more in rapping since his voice suits more songs then because it gets a little deeper. The thing is just that they don't try and Woozi always just has a slot for him in the second verses.
Svea Winter i dont think Woozi distributes the lines, Pledis does so maybe he is trying to cater for the members but the Pledis team distribute it differently
but other member have very. good vocal too even tho not good as both of them.. whatta man is the prove that other member can slay without both of them...
What a lot of people don't understand is that they choose lines to make the best possible song, not make it the fairest song of all time. Most people listening to the songs on radio or in department stores will care about how good the song sounds, not who gets the least lines. For that to happen, companies make it so the buyers of music will have honey to the ears, making main vocals sing most of it.
Besides, it's easier to cater to the biggest fandom within that group and feed them a shit ton so the whole group will be more popular in general. It's easier money making, and also faster too. Once the whole group is popular after that, they get richer in general.
Well then you don't put those other people in the group. If some members are only going to get 3-4 seconds what is the point putting them in the group? Groups with over 10 people always fuck up so bad in line distributions, you don't need more than 10 members in my opinion, unless it's for a specific reason and unless you know that all those people will contribute to the group and the songs produced.
lol poor sohye she barely got any lines. but can you blame the producers? i love her, and she improved a lot during the show, but there were at least 50 other girls with more talent, andliterally 100 other girls with more experience as idol trainees. props to her for her determination tho
What's the point of having that many fucking members in a group anyway. Anything over 9 is pretty ridiculous. When SNSD and 9 muses were both 9 member groups they always made line distribution work. It may have not shown in title tracks but it definitely showed in other songs. Shit I even SUJU as a 12 member group made line distribution work. But damn these groups just don't get it.
most of the agencies make groups with many members but doesnt do fair line distributions,or just put least members and make it worse by putting a member's lines too much
well I never thought like that about these songs. It's great, I mean by lookin at the potential of the singer. If the best got the most part and the not that good only got a bit part, it's already fair... and also the line distribution consisted the high note and adlib so it's really fair that the main vocal got alot more part... (expect WJSN's catch me is just a too much) well my opinion sooo ^.^
There's a reason why B1a4 songs sometimes have unfair line distributions. Baro is the rapper of the group and that song didn't have that much rapping in it clearly. Gongchan the visual is very shy when it comes to singing. Their recent song "A lie" was composed by one of the members, Jinyoung. In a interview, He said he wanted to give more lines to Gongchan but he pleaded he doesn't want it.
starship REALLY sucks when it come to distribution. first i was thinking it's was only for monsta x but then i checked sistar and cosmic girls and i am totally chocked like what the hell???
Well, Starship tends to apparently treat their idols the best (seems like idols there NEVER want to leave Starship, and all of them at Starship look healthy and well), but Starship at the same time is best known for how awful they distribute lines... BOYFRIEND: I feel like it's Donghyun & Minwoo ft. Hyunseong/Jeongmin. The twins BARELY get lines (especially Youngmin). SISTAR: Hyolyn ft. Dasom/Soyou and Bora WJSN: EXY & Yeongjung ft. the rest (and sometimes likes to leave Cheng Xiao in the cold). Not too sure if Monsta X's lines are badly distributed or not. EDIT: Monsta X - Kihyun & Friends.
I always have disliked IOIs line distributions with some songs since my bias is Sohye ;-; They will be disbanding soon and Sohye hasn't had more then 1-2 lines.
She's lucky to be in I.O.I considering her dancing and singing talent (I know, I know the public voted for her). That is why the actual lines are given to the members than can actually carry out the song and why she has be given less than four lines.
I don't get it when there is more than 10 mmbrs and one mmbr is getting more than 40 s ... or when there is 4 to 7 mmbrs group and a mmbr is getting 2 min of the song ... WHYYYYY WOULD U DO THAT
It's obvious that main vocals have the most lines to sing (for example Seventeen - mostly sing DK, Seungkwan and Woozi). Producers don't want to give lines to someone, who doesn't sing well or who is chinese/japanese and doesn't speak korean (Like WinWin from NCT 127). That's why rappers have less lines too if song is a ballad :)
Honestly, if they don't plan on giving the other members a decent amount of line why didn't they just make those favored go solo? It's like plus everyone else instead of an actual group.
Poor Cheng Xiao, it makes me think that her only line in 'I Wish' was well deserved, she literally said 'Just Tell Me Why', 'Tell Me Why' and 'Please Tell Me Why' and her only line in 'I Wish' was better then Chase Me
To be honest I'm not shocked that Infinite and Lovelyz are in this chart. Woolim did it because those with a few lines have weaker vocals. Like L, Sungyeol and Sungjong have difficulties in controlling their voice because of the dance. But know that their getting stronger in their vocals, they started to help the others with the lines as well. =)
Half of the songs IOI released have horrible line distribution, yet almost every member has more than just a decent voice.. Oh well.. WJSN took over the top 2, if they already have this many members, there really should be more consideration when disturbing the lines. On a positive note, it can only change for the better right😅
more members = lesser lines it makes sense for ioi to be included, considering that yeonjung and sejeong have many lines and sohye was signing up as an actor anyway..
Melinda Chen Sohye can't dance, sing or rap. Her talent is acting and the fact that she made it into the group was purely based on popularity. Don't get me wrong I love her but you can't complain about her not getting much when her voice doesn't suit a lot of the songs. The fact that she even gets acknowledged should be good enough. Mean while we have people with incredible voices like Chungha who gets slept on
Y'all will say main vocals are suppose to get more lines especially in ballad songs. But rappers can sing too. What's the point of getting 2 seconds of line while the main vocal gets 50 seconds. Don't say the group can't sing. That's not the case everyone. They never even get a chance to tried at least once. Example in IOI songs Nayoung is the only rapper, when there's a rap part she never gets more than 11 seconds. If they give me 2 second to sing I wouldn't even bother to go to the studio. IOI: Sejeong and Yeonjung & others Sistar: Hyolyn ft. Soyou and Dasom & special appearance of Bora SNSD is mostly Taeyeon Gfriend= Yuju and Eunha Twice: Nayeon ft. Jihyo and back up dancers
I don't see why members whose training specialized in vocals shouldn't get more lines, I mean I don't expect a main dancer to sing as much as a lead singer, you know? Also, I think it was fair Dawon got so many lines in Catch Me, you know why? Because she's a barely getting any lines in WJSN's songs now, so at least she got to sing a little bit for once in her life T_T
Lmao it’s mostly Yeonjung and then there’s Dawon and Dayoung at first and second WJSN queens of unfair line distributions. (Honestly though, Luda, Mei Qi, Cheng Xiao, Xuan Yi and Yeoreum deserve so much better.)
I don't know many of these kpop groups but for BTS there are some songs that are meant for the rap line or the vocal line only but you can easily take that out of context and say that they have the worst line distributions or something. Is that true for these groups or just for bts?
BTS do that on purpose. Like WINGS album has each members solos,there are mini albums which were more focused on vocal line or rap line. They have done that since beginning. Like they made a Butterfly version completely taking out rap lines. But yeah..... Jin doesn't have a lot of lines in some songs.
7 років тому
HawkEye One thing I'm getting tired of is the 'jin gets no lines' discussion, I get it in Butterfly, but in BS&T? Be honest, do you see Jin singing that chorus? His falsetto isn't as stable/controlled as the other three vocals, even if he would manage to sing it in the studio, he probably wouldn't be able to sing it live. The one line he got is literally the only line in the song he could comfortably sing. Jin is a visual. Yes we love him. Yes he can sing (I mean, Awake is my favourite track of the album, it made me cry and everything). But he still can't sing difficult stuff like the chorus in BS&T. And no, they can't just 'make' a part for him, that's not how it works. You make a song, then you distribute the lines, if you base songs off of line distributions, the song will turn to shit simply cause because when the line distribution is equal it doesn't mean the song will sound nice.
I get that and I know that he is more of a visual than vocal and I am alright with that. Just stated a fact that he is getting few lines,but I didn't say that it saddens me. As well I stated the fact that they make every track different,so maybe in one one gets few lines in other that person gets more lines,it's how groups work. Of course those who have poor skills in some techniqie are learning them,but won't sing those notes or in that technique while they won't be 100% sure they can get them right even in lives,hence why Jin has fewer lines. I have listened to his parts in lives many times and I know that he can't belt notes which,example,Jimin can (their voices and vocal range are different),but in no way did I say that I was sad that Jin gets fewer lines,just stated a fact.
7 років тому
HawkEye I didn't mean you in particular, it's just that I'm tired of people complaining about it in general, I completely agree with you ^o^
Seventeen's Laughter might looks bad but its quite fair actually. Dk and Seungkwan only gets many lines since they're main and they sang the powerful parts. while Pristin's We, other members didn't get lines since the song composed of most chorus where everyone sings, and ofcourse Seungyeon gets the most since she sang the adlibs and high note.
Seventeen's Laughter is kinda fair because it's a ballad song... the rap and dance line will of course got a little amount of line and the vocal line will have the most lines
What's all the fuss about? Kpop is not merely for singing. That's is why there are dance line, visual line, rap line, even people meant for variety shows and charisma. I really don't get why people want a fair line distribution. I mean, some groups give justice to members like for WJSN, if I am Cheng Xiao, even if I don't have any line if in almost part I get the center or the face of the group, I am quite fine with that. :)
from my opinion, seventeen-laughter is fair enough since dk, and seungkwan are seventeen's main vocal and woozi is the lead vocal. i think this song are one of the fairest from all svt song seriously. i'm saying this and kpop fans generally and as a carat.
I have never seen a worst line distribution than Catch Me, Starship sucks when it comes to line distributions. What you guys think?
yes! they're so unfair with distributions
how does one member not have any lines at all???
in my opinion, infinite the eye should be here because sungyeol only got less 10s while sunggyu got 1minute for this song
Ananda Rizky thats like almost all infinite songs. but i think this is based on the persons video, and she didnt make a distribution for that
igot7-lu i agree with you, almost all infinite song are unfair for line distribution, for title track, sunggyu line more dominant than the others
igot7-lu infinite have members, but sunggyu lines too dominant than the others, especially sungjong and my bias (sungyeol). Sungyeol can rap but i hope sungyeol got rap for next album
Mostly IOI's songs are unfair .....so sad
If Sohye singing skills better,her lines will be more
i think they use main vocalist too much..its not like other member cant sing at all.... in whatta man, somi, doyeon, chungha and pinky can slay without sejeong and yeonjung...
sohye can't sing so she deserve that amount of line lmao
Cherry Little that's right. Look at 'I love you I remember u'
Cellila Aditama you wouldn't know if she can sing now or not, because she barely ever gets lines.
Loved your video
I'll never get why companies make groups with so many members when they won't ever sing.
It simply doesn't make any sense to me.
It's a strategy that they adapt (maybe to earn more money?). But I get you. I think it would only work if the company is stable (like SM). They know how to use the number of members to attract fans and projects. But for smaller companies, it's actually a very big risk 😕 I don't know of any large groups outside of SM that had equal success so far...
Wtf Cheng Xiao of Cosmic girls got no lines? Wtf is this.
Firstly she had no lines for 1-2 songs (Probably?) and then got a little bit.Like 5 seconds.
Weeaboo Faggot
Wtf. I understand there's like 13 girls in WJSN but if an 11 member group like IOI can do relatively even line distribution then so can they.
Agreed
cheng is centre tho and main dancer ... she actually gets the most attention
yes, at their debut, momomo n catch me -__- im shock too at first
ah catch me makes me so sad.... cheng xiao my poor girl
cheng xiao maybe wasn't fluent in korean at the time
She was about to do a front flip the mic will fall
She asked for no lines because she didn’t trust her Korean
i dont think laughter by svt is that bad. everyone has some lines, even dancers. this is one of the best svt's ln, not like boomboom, where junhui and minghao get 2-3 sec
and they all sing in the chorus, so...
Moti
If it's a ballad song, obviously the main vocalists are going to have a lot of lines. If it's a hip-hop style song, the rappers will have more lines. The only time you should be mad is when a few members continuously get the least lines.
Momo and ChengXiao might not be getting lines, but when they breathe on that track 😩😩😩💦💦💦😻😻😻
LMFAO
Star ship has the worst line distributions in general...
Starship its terrible in line distribuition , are you see of Trespass of Monsta X ? Omg .... The debut its so good, but the lines ...
sorry my english xD I'm your fan from Brazil ♡♡
Of course there's going to be unfair line distributions. They have to make the main vocalists sing the majority of the song so that it actually sounds decent. The majority of people in each group have weak voices and are given one line.
Sorry, but I do not agree. Most of them can sing. All I.O.I members are good vocalists maybe Sohye needs to improve more but she can sing. (I will fight with those who say otherwise). Soyou from Sistar is so talented but can not shine because of the amount of lines Hyorin gets. In Seventeen, for a ballad song, even the rap line get more lines than Jun and The8. And I'm not even going to talk about WJSN, only 4 members get lines for 13 members.
sanatozaki all of ioi members are not good vocalist sohye Mina chaeyeon are all really bad.yoojung doyeon and sometimes pinky are unstable when singing live.sometimes you guys need to realize singing in the studio then actually performing it live is another thing.
Well then if they have weak voices don't put them in the goddamn group like son it ain't hard
Btsexo Bxo I mean, if they're going to be underestimated might as well take them of the group
because there is so called 'main dancer', 'rapper', 'visual' etc. not all member who have good voice can do rap or have a charisma. thats why they put them into one group.
there is a reason why they called 'group'.
be mature
The main vocalists will always have the most lines. Why are people shocked. Lines have to be distributed like this in order for the song to actually sound good.
honestly i think seventeen's laughter was fair, tho its really hard to distribute the lines to 13 members :/
woozikookie
agreed, it all makes a lot of sense for their positions. however, the profiles do say that china line are vocalists so if they got more, it'd be great but I don't think that's happening so, but it's mostly quite fair.
Blessed By Jisoo's Half of your comment is cut off, so I'll just respond to what I see. Yes, they do have unique voices, but to not match the song? No way. Like in No F.U.N, the no lines for Jun & Minghao was quite unnecessary, they could have fit in well. Actually, I'm a bit skeptical about Minghao due to his accent (that seems to be the one big restraining factor for him, poor kid), but Jun? His tone fits right in, it's deep and sounds cool, he could've at least gotten one line.
'The songs Jun was in he sang in a lot. Whereas, Minghao got barely any lines in the songs he was in.' Jun didn't get a lot compared to the others. In Boom Boom, Minghao has more lines by a lot. In Beautiful, Minghao gets like 15 lines if you just count like actual lines, not seconds (I'll update with seconds when I have more time). While in Well/I don't know, Jun gets 6 lines. Jun's parts are sung considerably slower, so if we had to compare it to Minghao from estimates, maybe around 12-14 lines? Close to Minghao, but not above.
Blessed By Jisoo's it's not 6 lol unless your counting them in a different way I am? But Jun legit just gets one 'Everyday boom boom' I think lol and Minghao gets the repeating part of the 'Make a hit come on' so that keeps repeating so it's more
also I saw boom boom line distributions and Minghao gets more
Blessed By Jisoo's also, how'd jun get 8 lines in highlight? Highlight's chorus happens 3 times, if I'm not mistaken. That's 3 lines, then 2 for the part at the beginning? So it'd be more like 5? I'll actually get to second counts in a bit, just need my laptop and I'll update with that
And to think IOI got 5 first place wins with Whatta Man, which had No Sejeong and no Yeonjung.
Magnus Ludvigsen Because it was a unit
I know that... my point is that the line distribution doesn't reflect the fact that they have lots of girls with vocal potential.
And also the fact that the Unit achieved all that without either main vocal.
Seventeen-Laughter might look bad but the song has no rap only singing as such the vocal line has there normal vocal lines amounts but the rap line has substantial decrease because they have little to none singing experience
CasqueHD Its not like they have no singing experience because they were trained as vocalist (maybe except Vernon) but the song would have the worst flow and a bad sound if they were to sing DKs or Seungkwans parts. Its fair tbh looking at there positions. But i agree its not that bad
CasqueHD actually the hip hop team is fine (except Mingyu) but Minghao and Jun keep on getting way less even if they have great voices and would have been fit to sing more
Blessed By Jisoo's Jun actually does get hardly any lines when compared to others. In most songs, Jun does get more over Minghao but by milliseconds, really. Jun's lines have seen an increase, as distributions are getting better for SVT as time goes on. The reason why people say Minghao and Jun are because they both when compared to others and their skills don't get the amount they deserve. For Minghao, I guess he is just in a really awkward situation, since he has a good voice but his accent makes it hard for him to really show that, and fit his voice well into more cool, darkish songs. For Jun, though, I really mean there isn't an excuse?? Basically, what I mean is that even though Jun gets slightly more than Minghao, it still isn't enough for all his talent that can be shown. It's the same case for Minghao, therefore the two get grouped together. (and most people think that most of the problem is just from their accents too, which a good amount of it is, and ofc only the Chinese members have accents different from the rest.)
Also, about Vernon, I just don't think he's good at singing?? Like, I remember back when you'd see him sing in like Mansae era, to put it kindly, it was a mess in ways.. He's improved, but definitely not as great as the others, therefore that's why they didn't give him more lines. If it was being shy, I think it would've changed the amount of lines in general. I think Vernon does have quite the confidence in himself on stage, so I don't think it's about being shy.
I just realized how long this is whoops
I wish Woozi would try out more with Minghao's voice. I was thinking about this earlier but his voice is kinda high pitched actually and if they trained him more, he could make Seventeen's songs even more special just like Sunyoul kind of does in Up10tion. They could also try training him more in rapping since his voice suits more songs then because it gets a little deeper. The thing is just that they don't try and Woozi always just has a slot for him in the second verses.
Svea Winter i dont think Woozi distributes the lines, Pledis does so maybe he is trying to cater for the members but the Pledis team distribute it differently
Personally I didn't think seventeen's line distribution was that bad since the people with most line time are the people in vocal team
Yeonjung and sejeong 😂😂😂.they are main vocals anyway
but other member have very. good vocal too even tho not good as both of them.. whatta man is the prove that other member can slay without both of them...
Wonho Is Mine yeah they are really good but there's clearly a huge gap.when they all come together
Yeonjung Squishycheeks yeah but they have to be a team. not a duo
but to much
Yeonjung is not the only main vocal in WJSN
catch me caught me off guard. Lol. Really? No lines? What did she do there? Just Dance?
But because of that song she gain more popularity... not because she didn't get some line but because she slay the dance floor
Catch was a disaster what was starship thinking lmao
She asked for no lines because she didn’t trust her Korean
i didnt know that cheng xiao got zero lines in catch me...... wow
Catch me is the legend of WJSN cuz no line for Cheng Xiao :)))
seeing Sohye in the tumbnail, I know this one's real. She never have that much of line in their songs ._.
Poor Cheng Xiao...
JUSTICE FOR I.O.I
SCoupstastu tru
What a lot of people don't understand is that they choose lines to make the best possible song, not make it the fairest song of all time. Most people listening to the songs on radio or in department stores will care about how good the song sounds, not who gets the least lines. For that to happen, companies make it so the buyers of music will have honey to the ears, making main vocals sing most of it.
Besides, it's easier to cater to the biggest fandom within that group and feed them a shit ton so the whole group will be more popular in general. It's easier money making, and also faster too. Once the whole group is popular after that, they get richer in general.
ichigomiruku unless its wjsn. popularity = more lines
Finally someone that understands! :D
Well then you don't put those other people in the group. If some members are only going to get 3-4 seconds what is the point putting them in the group? Groups with over 10 people always fuck up so bad in line distributions, you don't need more than 10 members in my opinion, unless it's for a specific reason and unless you know that all those people will contribute to the group and the songs produced.
The point is not to be fair but to have a descent amount of line that's not only one second.
when ioi is officially worst at distributing lines, and twice is right behind
Don't forget Sistar... :'(
I think it is:
WJSN > SISTAR > I.O.I > TWICE
This is from 2016 or 2017 but I don't care
Wjsn says hi
In Sistar it's like Hyorin and friends. I once think Hyorin is the only Sistar and the other 3 are just backup dancers
IS THERE APRIL?
WELL IT IS A GROUP THAT GIVES 0s AND 1s TO THEIR MEMBERS EVEN THOUGH THEY HAVE 6 MEMBERS.
oh! you forgot I.O.I--I love you I remember you
Maeko Tang
I think nothing is there in that song to distribute......the almost entire song is sung by chungha
Exactly what I'm thinking!!! Chungha sang more than a minute while Sohye for mere second 😂
Chillax!! There are so many unfair line distributions on kpop songs!!
2:13 well at least Jeongyeon is being treated like lead vocal and Tzuyu has lines, but it’s still kinda bad
lol poor sohye she barely got any lines. but can you blame the producers? i love her, and she improved a lot during the show, but there were at least 50 other girls with more talent, andliterally 100 other girls with more experience as idol trainees. props to her for her determination tho
What's the point of having that many fucking members in a group anyway. Anything over 9 is pretty ridiculous. When SNSD and 9 muses were both 9 member groups they always made line distribution work. It may have not shown in title tracks but it definitely showed in other songs. Shit I even SUJU as a 12 member group made line distribution work. But damn these groups just don't get it.
💖💖
can you make line distribution for K.A.R.D Oh NaNa please?
most of the agencies make groups with many members but doesnt do fair line distributions,or just put least members and make it worse by putting a member's lines too much
well I never thought like that about these songs. It's great, I mean by lookin at the potential of the singer. If the best got the most part and the not that good only got a bit part, it's already fair... and also the line distribution consisted the high note and adlib so it's really fair that the main vocal got alot more part... (expect WJSN's catch me is just a too much)
well my opinion sooo ^.^
There's a reason why B1a4 songs sometimes have unfair line distributions. Baro is the rapper of the group and that song didn't have that much rapping in it clearly. Gongchan the visual is very shy when it comes to singing. Their recent song "A lie" was composed by one of the members, Jinyoung. In a interview, He said he wanted to give more lines to Gongchan but he pleaded he doesn't want it.
Can you please do fiestar's vista?
I have noticed it's bigger groups that have the really bad line distribution
its hard to have an even line distribution in a vocal heavy song ofcourse the rappers will get less
You should do a throwback and do Sorry Sorry because 8 out of 13 SUJU's members at the time sing while 5 get no lines at all
starship REALLY sucks when it come to distribution. first i was thinking it's was only for monsta x but then i checked sistar and cosmic girls and i am totally chocked like what the hell???
Why would you put 12 members in a band If you only give 5 of them lines, so unfair
The fact that most of these are I.O.I makes me sad... they were with us for only a year and got such unfair line distributions :/
and aside of this list there are songs where members doesn't even get 1 line
plss can u do fast pace?of seventeeb
I mean i know it's unfair for some groups but groups that they have many members it's not so easy to have the same amount of lines for everybody
IOI Crush: Sohye gets 1.3 seconds WTF like 2 and half words?
I watched 3 videos of these from different youtubers and literally all three of them has a twice song somewhere around the top 5 😂
i think i love you, i remember you is most unfair but idk if youve made a line distribution of it
It's always the groups with 10 thousand members that never have fair line distributions.
Well, Starship tends to apparently treat their idols the best (seems like idols there NEVER want to leave Starship, and all of them at Starship look healthy and well), but Starship at the same time is best known for how awful they distribute lines...
BOYFRIEND: I feel like it's Donghyun & Minwoo ft. Hyunseong/Jeongmin. The twins BARELY get lines (especially Youngmin).
SISTAR: Hyolyn ft. Dasom/Soyou and Bora
WJSN: EXY & Yeongjung ft. the rest (and sometimes likes to leave Cheng Xiao in the cold).
Not too sure if Monsta X's lines are badly distributed or not.
EDIT:
Monsta X - Kihyun & Friends.
well its their fault if they cant sing that well. of course main vocal is going to have more parts than member thats lacking in singing.
yeonjung is eating good, both in ioi and wjsn
Can make FAIREST LD?
I always have disliked IOIs line distributions with some songs since my bias is Sohye ;-; They will be disbanding soon and Sohye hasn't had more then 1-2 lines.
Cesca Sara If you're really a Sohye biased, you would know why she gets a few lines.
She's lucky to be in I.O.I considering her dancing and singing talent (I know, I know the public voted for her). That is why the actual lines are given to the members than can actually carry out the song and why she has be given less than four lines.
Wait in pit a pat Tzuyu has so much?? Oh what a blessing!!
I don't get it when there is more than 10 mmbrs and one mmbr is getting more than 40 s ... or when there is 4 to 7 mmbrs group and a mmbr is getting 2 min of the song ... WHYYYYY WOULD U DO THAT
It's obvious that main vocals have the most lines to sing (for example Seventeen - mostly sing DK, Seungkwan and Woozi). Producers don't want to give lines to someone, who doesn't sing well or who is chinese/japanese and doesn't speak korean (Like WinWin from NCT 127). That's why rappers have less lines too if song is a ballad :)
A Sohye do I.O.I é tipo o Jin do BTS, sempre pega as lines mais curtas :(
Honestly, if they don't plan on giving the other members a decent amount of line why didn't they just make those favored go solo? It's like plus everyone else instead of an actual group.
Every simple song of infinite. I really love them but their line distribution is even worst than my social life
Poor Cheng Xiao, it makes me think that her only line in 'I Wish' was well deserved, she literally said 'Just Tell Me Why', 'Tell Me Why' and 'Please Tell Me Why' and her only line in 'I Wish' was better then Chase Me
pls include here exo's "for life".....how could they😢my sehunnie😫
he didn't get many lines because he is a rapper, and for Life doesn't have a rap
To be honest I'm not shocked that Infinite and Lovelyz are in this chart. Woolim did it because those with a few lines have weaker vocals. Like L, Sungyeol and Sungjong have difficulties in controlling their voice because of the dance. But know that their getting stronger in their vocals, they started to help the others with the lines as well. =)
Half of the songs IOI released have horrible line distribution, yet almost every member has more than just a decent voice.. Oh well.. WJSN took over the top 2, if they already have this many members, there really should be more consideration when disturbing the lines. On a positive note, it can only change for the better right😅
All songs of APRIL is unfair. Poor Yena :((
more members = lesser lines
it makes sense for ioi to be included, considering that yeonjung and sejeong have many lines and sohye was signing up as an actor anyway..
honeypopcorn's debut is a bop but in wjsn catch me cheng ciao got 0 FUCKING LINES MEANS 0 SECONDS
lol well I.O.I is consistent
Kelsey McGuire yeah really "consistent" to give sohye less part haha
Melinda Chen Sohye can't dance, sing or rap. Her talent is acting and the fact that she made it into the group was purely based on popularity. Don't get me wrong I love her but you can't complain about her not getting much when her voice doesn't suit a lot of the songs. The fact that she even gets acknowledged should be good enough. Mean while we have people with incredible voices like Chungha who gets slept on
Okay but this is why artists go solo. that's the only way they get lines sometimes!
Y'all will say main vocals are suppose to get more lines especially in ballad songs. But rappers can sing too. What's the point of getting 2 seconds of line while the main vocal gets 50 seconds. Don't say the group can't sing. That's not the case everyone. They never even get a chance to tried at least once. Example in IOI songs Nayoung is the only rapper, when there's a rap part she never gets more than 11 seconds. If they give me 2 second to sing I wouldn't even bother to go to the studio.
IOI: Sejeong and Yeonjung & others
Sistar: Hyolyn ft. Soyou and Dasom & special appearance of Bora
SNSD is mostly Taeyeon
Gfriend= Yuju and Eunha
Twice: Nayeon ft. Jihyo and back up dancers
I don't see why members whose training specialized in vocals shouldn't get more lines, I mean I don't expect a main dancer to sing as much as a lead singer, you know? Also, I think it was fair Dawon got so many lines in Catch Me, you know why? Because she's a barely getting any lines in WJSN's songs now, so at least she got to sing a little bit for once in her life T_T
Any body notice that the most unfiar distributions are larger groups and fairest li e distributions are smaller groups???
Lmao it’s mostly Yeonjung and then there’s Dawon and Dayoung at first and second WJSN queens of unfair line distributions. (Honestly though, Luda, Mei Qi, Cheng Xiao, Xuan Yi and Yeoreum deserve so much better.)
damn the last one.. 0 second part...
A lot of songs of IOI are there but they still kicked your favs ass~
I don't know many of these kpop groups but for BTS there are some songs that are meant for the rap line or the vocal line only but you can easily take that out of context and say that they have the worst line distributions or something. Is that true for these groups or just for bts?
BTS do that on purpose. Like WINGS album has each members solos,there are mini albums which were more focused on vocal line or rap line. They have done that since beginning. Like they made a Butterfly version completely taking out rap lines. But yeah..... Jin doesn't have a lot of lines in some songs.
HawkEye One thing I'm getting tired of is the 'jin gets no lines' discussion, I get it in Butterfly, but in BS&T? Be honest, do you see Jin singing that chorus? His falsetto isn't as stable/controlled as the other three vocals, even if he would manage to sing it in the studio, he probably wouldn't be able to sing it live. The one line he got is literally the only line in the song he could comfortably sing. Jin is a visual. Yes we love him. Yes he can sing (I mean, Awake is my favourite track of the album, it made me cry and everything). But he still can't sing difficult stuff like the chorus in BS&T. And no, they can't just 'make' a part for him, that's not how it works. You make a song, then you distribute the lines, if you base songs off of line distributions, the song will turn to shit simply cause because when the line distribution is equal it doesn't mean the song will sound nice.
I get that and I know that he is more of a visual than vocal and I am alright with that. Just stated a fact that he is getting few lines,but I didn't say that it saddens me. As well I stated the fact that they make every track different,so maybe in one one gets few lines in other that person gets more lines,it's how groups work. Of course those who have poor skills in some techniqie are learning them,but won't sing those notes or in that technique while they won't be 100% sure they can get them right even in lives,hence why Jin has fewer lines. I have listened to his parts in lives many times and I know that he can't belt notes which,example,Jimin can (their voices and vocal range are different),but in no way did I say that I was sad that Jin gets fewer lines,just stated a fact.
HawkEye I didn't mean you in particular, it's just that I'm tired of people complaining about it in general, I completely agree with you ^o^
Ah,then I have misunderstood and thought you aimed it at me as well,forgive me for making a mistake there. :)
Girl Group, Girl group, girl group oh another girl group..
hey wait you left out one girl group!
Oh sorry girl group xD xD xD xD
1:07 B1A4 Lonely라니ㅠㅠ 근데 진짜 찬오빠가 적긴 해... 바로오빠는 그래도 랩이라 귀에 훅 들어오는데
근데 진영오빠 자작곡도 몇개 있네ㅠㅠ
00:40 벛꽃이 지면
01:36 잠깐만
STAN BRAVE GIRLS!!
Literally almost all of Sistar's songs have unfair line distributions.
so after seeing #2 i was thinking "how much worse can it get?" AND THEN CHENG XIAO CAME IN WITH HER 0 SECONDS OF LINES--
Don't think you have done any LD videos on Teen Top, but they would have definitely ranked high on this list if you did. Lol
And IOI is the winner of the worst!!
What criteria is used to chose and rank them?
Seventeen's Laughter might looks bad but its quite fair actually. Dk and Seungkwan only gets many lines since they're main and they sang the powerful parts.
while Pristin's We, other members didn't get lines since the song composed of most chorus where everyone sings, and ofcourse Seungyeon gets the most since she sang the adlibs and high note.
Seventeen's Laughter is kinda fair because it's a ballad song... the rap and dance line will of course got a little amount of line and the vocal line will have the most lines
of course IOI and Twice will be here... poor Jungyeon and Sohye
Cosmic girls were pretty dang even in "Secret "
Hyungwon my heart Blame Starship
iam starship stans, but i feel starships always push one member like sistar hyorin, kihyun monsta,jeongmin boyfriend, yeonjung wjsn.
I think all TWICE's song should be on the list
Not hater
TWICE1020 ONCE0920 not really all of it, signal and candy boy are actually fair
chengxiou.. ..
Syazwin Azmi *xiao
What's all the fuss about? Kpop is not merely for singing. That's is why there are dance line, visual line, rap line, even people meant for variety shows and charisma. I really don't get why people want a fair line distribution. I mean, some groups give justice to members like for WJSN, if I am Cheng Xiao, even if I don't have any line if in almost part I get the center or the face of the group, I am quite fine with that. :)
Seventeen's Smile Flower is a little fair cause not all of them can sing stably and better and because it's a ballad song
IOI needs to get it together...
from my opinion, seventeen-laughter is fair enough since dk, and seungkwan are seventeen's main vocal and woozi is the lead vocal. i think this song are one of the fairest from all svt song seriously. i'm saying this and kpop fans generally and as a carat.
I'm a simple person
I saw Sohye
I clicked
Elvis from AOA too, Seolhyun didn't have lines.
welcome to the world of kpop