good heart feels... in a bitter way. I can't help but feel bad for Whitestorm, knowing that this is the side of Thistleclaw he got to experience before shit hit the fan. ig it's kinda like when most people find out that their loved ones did very, very bad things- you have a hard time connecting the two sides. it's almost like they died.
I wish we couldve seen how it affected him a little bit more. I have some loved ones who have done some awful things and i feel this in my soul. Ive spent many nights crying over it because i wish i could just have what i knew them as back, crying over the things they did, wondering how it ended up like that, etc. I wish the Erins couldve planned their story out a bit more so we couldve seen how everything effected him
CAN CONFIRM. I found some *VERY NOT OKIE DOKIE* things about a relative of mine recently. Fortunately...? He died a few years back, so now I just have to focus on compartmentalizing this new information..
I wish we saw more cute, natural father-kit relationships like this in the books. Honestly, I wish families were handled better in the books in general.
This is so cute I might cry Whitestorm supremacy Edit: guys. This wasn’t meant to be racist in any way, shape, or form. I’m literally just saying WhiteSTORM is my all time favorite warrior cats character. Where the hell do you get “white supremacy” from me saying how much I love a fictional character?
Bringing in the wholesome Thistleclaw and Whitekit content that makes me not 100% quit this fandom, my crops are watered and I love that you used this audio especially for them
this is like… agaggaga it gives me the feels!!! whitekit is absolutely adorable, but i can’t help but feel sad that this wouldn’t last forever, that thistleclaw would still have his downfall. this video is so wholesome, yet it makes me so sad. :’( in terms of art, great work! your designs are super creative, and the expressions are super neat! you have so much creativity, and it translates so well into your art. awesome job, in total!
The contrast between Tigerpaw thistle and whitekit thistle makes thistleclaw’s character so much more complex and interesting as it is sad, I wonder what it would have been like if he’d never been involved in the dark forest
I was so very excited for this as soon as I recognized the audio! It's so sweet, like, so casual and like a normal day with an unexpected delight! Ioved all your changes to fit Warriors!
Litterslly crying right now dude. I don't know why this made me so emotional. I suppose it's because Thistleclaw ended up not being the cat Whitekit/storm thought he was hurts.
I like how you made Thistleclaw kind. It's just, ya'know, unique. I felt pretty much sad, looking at how one of the most-hated cats is so good to his kit. Thistleclaw actually DID love his son, yet he didn't know how to raise him. I don't think he deserved to be made a pedo. Sometimes characters are just ruined in a bad way that people shouldn't do.
Oh boy spottedleaf heart is pure shit to me I really liked thistleclaw like a rough guy with a good heart misunderstood by bluefur but NOOO they had to ruin in to me
Bro there’s literally a part in Bluestar’s Prophecy where Goosefeather basically says to keep Whitekit away from Thistleclaw because he’s a pos. He also beat the shit out of a kitten with his apprentice. Dude was never “misunderstood” he was always pure garbage even without the grooming in Spottedleaf’s Heart
@@sockonmarshe had such a track record of harming young cats, people say spotteds heart was out of character for him, but no, it absolutely wasn’t, he was 100% in character
@@_The_Lizard_King well unfortunately for Spottedleaf and *you* until the authors say anything, the book IS canon. And even if it wasn't canon there's still other reasons for me to hate him. I didn't even say anything about Spottedleaf's Heart so what made you think I was even referring to that one?
This… this made me get tears in my eyes. Thistleclaw sucked, he was a predator to Spottedpaw and just a generally evil dude. But it hurts, because I love this side of him.
@@0xenfreeArt - I’m not normally a part of the “disregarding canon” camp, but that book was so shit. Not just because it handled the subject matter horribly and, iirc, only one Erin signed off on it. But it managed to ruin so many characters from Bluestar’s Prophecy. Not just Thistleclaw (for no real reason?? He broke the code by encouraging violence against Tiny. That’s enough to be sent to the DF) but it also made Spottedpaw/leaf _ANOTHER_ cat forced into the medicine cat lifestyle for, again, ~absolutely no reason.~ It even makes Bluefur/star look worse for somehow not knowing about that whole situation when she’s been looking for any reason to hate Thistleclaw. Just, ugh, such a sloppily written book.
![[CC] Girl Crush [Cinderpelt/Sandstorm PMV]](/img/n.gif)
good heart feels... in a bitter way. I can't help but feel bad for Whitestorm, knowing that this is the side of Thistleclaw he got to experience before shit hit the fan. ig it's kinda like when most people find out that their loved ones did very, very bad things- you have a hard time connecting the two sides. it's almost like they died.
this, this comment here
I wish we couldve seen how it affected him a little bit more. I have some loved ones who have done some awful things and i feel this in my soul. Ive spent many nights crying over it because i wish i could just have what i knew them as back, crying over the things they did, wondering how it ended up like that, etc. I wish the Erins couldve planned their story out a bit more so we couldve seen how everything effected him
Same feeling but if you're loved one does something horrible to you instead of someone else
CAN CONFIRM. I found some *VERY NOT OKIE DOKIE* things about a relative of mine recently. Fortunately...? He died a few years back, so now I just have to focus on compartmentalizing this new information..
I love how you replaced the snapping with him just popping his claws in and out. Perfect for a cat with no thumbs to snap lmao
There's a songbird called a shrike that is a predator and it impales its prey on branches and thorns exactly like that
Shrikes are my favorite borbs
I wish we saw more cute, natural father-kit relationships like this in the books. Honestly, I wish families were handled better in the books in general.
I admit, I was waiting for some tragic moment to disrupt the cuteness, but this was just cute! Love it!
I love whitekit so much omg. that 'I love you' at the end,, pls Im dying
This is so cute I might cry Whitestorm supremacy
Edit: guys. This wasn’t meant to be racist in any way, shape, or form. I’m literally just saying WhiteSTORM is my all time favorite warrior cats character. Where the hell do you get “white supremacy” from me saying how much I love a fictional character?
Don’t ever forget that storm part
Bruh “whitestorm supremacy”
😐😐😐😐😐
@@chxrryfxygo3630 yeah as a black person im not feeling this
@@tegueggu FR, WHY WOULD ANYONE WRITE THAT
Bringing in the wholesome Thistleclaw and Whitekit content that makes me not 100% quit this fandom, my crops are watered and I love that you used this audio especially for them
This is the only Thistleclaw I accept
Saaaame 💙
this is like… agaggaga it gives me the feels!!! whitekit is absolutely adorable, but i can’t help but feel sad that this wouldn’t last forever, that thistleclaw would still have his downfall.
this video is so wholesome, yet it makes me so sad. :’(
in terms of art, great work! your designs are super creative, and the expressions are super neat! you have so much creativity, and it translates so well into your art.
awesome job, in total!
I really like this cute, simplified version of your style, it works really well
I love this verison of Thistleclaw???? Canon thistleclaw sucks so much but I love this little guy
Whitekit is so cute I want to die for his cuteness
Why is this so wholesome 😭
I prefer this over canon thistleclaw
Not to be overdramatic or anything but I’d die for Whitekit.
"All good things take time"
This line after reading Spottedleaf's Heart is so 😬 coded
Thank you for blessing our holidays with such a sweet and wholesome video
whitekit making the little phbhbhpbhph noises made my day
happy holidays sad machine!
The contrast between Tigerpaw thistle and whitekit thistle makes thistleclaw’s character so much more complex and interesting as it is sad, I wonder what it would have been like if he’d never been involved in the dark forest
It's sad that their relationship wasn't like that in the books.
BRO THIS HAS ALWAYS BEEN ONE OF MY FAVORITE AUDIOS about time someone did something warrior cats related
I live in a world where absolutely nothing happened between spottedpaw and thistleclaw and he's simply an evil guy who loves his kid.
I feel like the fans could rewrite the books better than the erins
@@unequippedinv yeah
@@unequippedinv
They absolutely could
Half of them have stories better than the series itself
At this point, we all that any song with an unusual name is a Jack Stauber song.
It’s just sad of what thistleclaw did, whitekit didn’t know about it and bet when he figured it out it felt like he just got stabbed in the heart..
the way you draw whitekit in this video... he's perfect. i'd die AND kill for him.
this has such a bittersweet feeling to it, knowing how things turned out in the end. lovely work.
I really like when you do these, the VHS filters and the spastic animation, it reminds me of Home Movies! Happy Holidays!
I was so very excited for this as soon as I recognized the audio! It's so sweet, like, so casual and like a normal day with an unexpected delight! Ioved all your changes to fit Warriors!
weeping. god what could have BEEN
Litterslly crying right now dude. I don't know why this made me so emotional. I suppose it's because Thistleclaw ended up not being the cat Whitekit/storm thought he was hurts.
Why is this so cute tho???
i owe you my life for such wholesome content, bless 🙏
this is so adorable yet such a bummer at the same time
I love how cute Whitekit is 😭😭
this makes me so happy you can’t imagine
i love people that draw cute thistleclaw and whitekit
Never thought i'd see a Thistleclaw video thats so wholesome
Whitekit is so precious.
This is so cute!!
and then nothing bad ever happened after this the end
I like how you made Thistleclaw kind. It's just, ya'know, unique. I felt pretty much sad, looking at how one of the most-hated cats is so good to his kit. Thistleclaw actually DID love his son, yet he didn't know how to raise him. I don't think he deserved to be made a pedo. Sometimes characters are just ruined in a bad way that people shouldn't do.
This is honestly underated and very wholesome
Nice to see someone else who LOVES Whitestorm
I feel like this is more legit than the cannon material
Wholesome footage of father-son time
Ok but Whitekit is absolutley ADORABLE IM CRYING 😭💕
NOOOOOO STOP IM GONNA CRYYY baby whitestorm is so damn cute
This is wonderful
STOP MAN I NOW HEAD-CANON THIS IS HOW THISTLE WAS WITH WHITEKIT
Whitekit is so cute
STOP MAKING ME SAD
YESS I KNEW THIS WAS FROM JACK STAUBER
ouughh this is adorable!!!
Be right back, im sobbing
NOOOO THIS IS TOO CUTE
auuooighghgghghgh i love this so much
Awww Whitekit is SO CUTE
not to be dramatic or anything but i'd die for Whitekit
i really wish thistleclaw was displayed more as a caring father than went wrong rather than a gr00mer and a villain
Ik gojng to cry bro.
adorable🥺
I am indeed sad
Adorable 😭😭
AWWWWWW WHITEKIT LITTLE BAYBEEEEEE
If ONLY Thistleclaw had been such a good dad :/ Frankly how did Whitestorm turn out as well as he did???
Thanks to Bluestar, sadly. Hate her.
@@brolylook no thistleclaw chose his own actions dude-
@@mightyleafster uh huh… I’m talking about whitestorm. He turned out good because of that awful character bluestar
somehow
@@brolylook wh- well yeah?? He wasn’t raised by someone crazy and disgusting
@@mightyleafster She is crazy and disgusting. Just not as bad as thistle.
i hate thistle sm but this is so cute ahhh
Oh boy spottedleaf heart is pure shit to me
I really liked thistleclaw like a rough guy with a good heart misunderstood by bluefur but NOOO they had to ruin in to me
Bro there’s literally a part in Bluestar’s Prophecy where Goosefeather basically says to keep Whitekit away from Thistleclaw because he’s a pos. He also beat the shit out of a kitten with his apprentice. Dude was never “misunderstood” he was always pure garbage even without the grooming in Spottedleaf’s Heart
Thisleclaw taught violence to his apprentice and told him to beat up a baby, i don't think the man was misunderstood
@@sockonmars well yeah but still I wanted to be the way im saying
@@sockonmarshe had such a track record of harming young cats, people say spotteds heart was out of character for him, but no, it absolutely wasn’t, he was 100% in character
Can we not bring spottedleaf's heart into a sad machine video?
It would be so much cuter in the books if kits had to actually learn how to speak and didn’t just pop out with a full vocabulary
I legitimately went "Oh that looks like Sad Machine's style + designs lol" and then I looked at the channel name
Tldr: I'm stupid lmao
Stop trying to make me like him
@@_The_Lizard_King it isn't a relationship dude
@@_The_Lizard_King well unfortunately for Spottedleaf and *you* until the authors say anything, the book IS canon. And even if it wasn't canon there's still other reasons for me to hate him. I didn't even say anything about Spottedleaf's Heart so what made you think I was even referring to that one?
@@_The_Lizard_King he trained in the df and abused apprentices idk how you think that's "not that bad"
@@twist_ending7545 how many other cats trained in the dark forest?
@@_The_Lizard_King Many. He abused apprentices.
This… this made me get tears in my eyes. Thistleclaw sucked, he was a predator to Spottedpaw and just a generally evil dude. But it hurts, because I love this side of him.
Sad machine doesn't acknowledge that book as canon but the rest is fair
@@0xenfreeArt - I’m not normally a part of the “disregarding canon” camp, but that book was so shit. Not just because it handled the subject matter horribly and, iirc, only one Erin signed off on it. But it managed to ruin so many characters from Bluestar’s Prophecy. Not just Thistleclaw (for no real reason?? He broke the code by encouraging violence against Tiny. That’s enough to be sent to the DF) but it also made Spottedpaw/leaf _ANOTHER_ cat forced into the medicine cat lifestyle for, again, ~absolutely no reason.~ It even makes Bluefur/star look worse for somehow not knowing about that whole situation when she’s been looking for any reason to hate Thistleclaw. Just, ugh, such a sloppily written book.
@@KlutzyNinjaKitty amen