wife salary 98000 per month asking for maintenance |Husband wife case| karnataka high court|

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @vukkumsp
    @vukkumsp 27 днів тому +229

    I guess Atul Shubham's voice will go unnoticed.

    • @abhishekmaity8980
      @abhishekmaity8980 23 дні тому +5

      It's Atul Subhash

    • @PronabDeori-xt1wc
      @PronabDeori-xt1wc 22 дні тому +4

      I think the same,bro.

    • @tipsyTrotter
      @tipsyTrotter 22 дні тому +6

      We should try not go unnoticed.

    • @NayanChandrakar-u5n
      @NayanChandrakar-u5n 21 день тому

      I think same

    • @santoshr4212
      @santoshr4212 21 день тому

      Sure, just like Kolkata case, another election or politics and no one will remember him. Both the judge and killer wife and his chakkkaaa brother will get released.

  • @vaibhavnioding783
    @vaibhavnioding783 3 місяці тому +258

    Marriage is a business for gold diggers!

    • @moovendhanr4063
      @moovendhanr4063 22 дні тому

      Don't know why then shit shut-up
      Pay before and after the marriage 😂

    • @cfctrans
      @cfctrans 20 днів тому

      @@vaibhavnioding783 true.. boys side they will ask money, gold, car, plot and certain amount.. marriage hall should be big , this that etc

    • @cfctrans
      @cfctrans 20 днів тому

      @@vaibhavnioding783 true specially boys side they will ask gold,car,plot .. they will also ask money but support to business or job .. need to book big hall.. grand reception.. big gifts for relatives.. girl should be beautiful with good package+ dowry.. they are big gold diggers.. after the marriage they will say this is not ur house..

    • @mrgaur9316
      @mrgaur9316 16 днів тому

      You are right bro 😮😮

    • @Worldwide505
      @Worldwide505 8 днів тому +1

      Not marriage, divorce is business 😂😂😂😂

  • @saurabhpatil8477
    @saurabhpatil8477 24 дні тому +97

    Lawyer shamelessly admitted that wife’s Brother is not taking care of their parents ( alcoholic) but is expecting husband to take responsibility of in-laws indirectly . Surprisingly even Judge not take this point.

  • @mandarp9472
    @mandarp9472 20 днів тому +77

    Per capita income in India is Rs 20,000/-. Alimony amount should be calculated based upon per capita income of Rs 20,000/- and not on wish list of wife and her family.
    80 crore people in India including women live on free ration and in few states receive Rs 1,000 - Rs 2000.
    Wife want to live separately without cooking for her husband but want life long money/ alimony/ maintenance in from ex husband after harrassing him and filing false cases on husband & his family.

    • @kumar-mi7rl
      @kumar-mi7rl 6 днів тому +2

      ys, thats the sad reality of indian judiciary, i wll prefer to stay in jail rather than payig

    • @SouravGangulyvloggingandmu-g2e
      @SouravGangulyvloggingandmu-g2e 5 днів тому +1

      Maintenance should be based on sustainability and not based on meeting the standard of living of husband. If she can sustain herself, no need of maintenance or alimony. Only thing she can do is ask compensation on ground of cruelty if proved.

  • @urlucky001
    @urlucky001 3 місяці тому +238

    Why is the husband punished?? Does the court believe in equal rights for both men n women? If she is able to maintain herself then why husband have to pay any amount?

    • @moovendhanr4063
      @moovendhanr4063 22 дні тому +4

      Then husband why married to that girl?😂

    • @ManasaS-j8n
      @ManasaS-j8n 21 день тому

      ​​​@@moovendhanr4063 then why wife married to that boy

    • @avinsegi
      @avinsegi 21 день тому +1

      @@moovendhanr4063 Is the girl a baby when she got married? Nonsense argument. When it comes to rights, the same people use the feminine card

    • @vijayclan1
      @vijayclan1 21 день тому

      @@moovendhanr4063
      If he didn’t he might have had a fake r_pe against him.
      But seriously society and Bollywood sells this fantasy of marriage. Men have to reject this fairy tale notion of romance and marriage in this age.
      But in this case, just because he made the mistake of marrying, he needn’t be punished all his life for it. Thinking otherwise is a clear case of victim blaming

    • @கதிரவன்-ங3ண
      @கதிரவன்-ங3ண 21 день тому +20

      He was hoping to lead a normal life with his wife. The Hope got shattered because of her adamancy. The wrong doer only should suffer , not the innocent victim.

  • @96praveen
    @96praveen 24 дні тому +104

    Why husband is punished ... Atul subhash commmitted suicide bcz of this courts atrocities ...

    • @avinsegi
      @avinsegi 21 день тому +2

      We should question the politicians, not the courts

    • @vijayclan1
      @vijayclan1 21 день тому +4

      @@avinsegithe politicians only enacted what the society demanded post nirbhaya

  • @somaadak7285
    @somaadak7285 24 дні тому +47

    If money is not involved such type cases, than whole false case will be automatically removed..

  • @urlucky001
    @urlucky001 3 місяці тому +115

    Finding a good women is difficult, getting her agree to marry you is impossible, then if she leaves you it's sad and if court punishes husband is infuriating. The whole marriage system is scary.

    • @logicx9384
      @logicx9384 23 дні тому +18

      Staying alone till lifetime is better than pay alimony

    • @urlucky001
      @urlucky001 23 дні тому +3

      @logicx9384 mrg is so scary

    • @farooqrizvi6078
      @farooqrizvi6078 22 дні тому

      Thailand lifestyle is much better

    • @AnonymousCitizen7
      @AnonymousCitizen7 7 днів тому

      No logic in marriage if u r well earning

    • @urlucky001
      @urlucky001 7 днів тому

      @@AnonymousCitizen7 next 10 -20 years today's kid boys will never find a loyal caring obedient women who will follow his lead. Girls will become Alpha males.

  • @mayank-mayank6559
    @mayank-mayank6559 3 місяці тому +81

    I saw one case where husband income was 12k and reputed and educated and honest court approved maintenance of 10k...😢😢😢😢

    • @BhanuPrakash-hk5iu
      @BhanuPrakash-hk5iu 25 днів тому +19

      Living on 2k and paying 10k for wife after divorce is unimaginable

    • @jitendragadhave
      @jitendragadhave 24 дні тому

      ​@@BhanuPrakash-hk5iui know that case. Guy joined another job. So he does 2 shifts per day

    • @redemptionneeded
      @redemptionneeded 24 дні тому

      Mental judgements

    • @donkey3251
      @donkey3251 23 дні тому +4

      Even if he leaves the job and begs, the wife wud still want part of it.

    • @CryptoFeeders
      @CryptoFeeders 22 дні тому +5

      he has to go high court, family courts are corrupt.

  • @yamankummarala607
    @yamankummarala607 15 днів тому +7

    What the hell with indian Judiciary, Wife earning 98000 and she has been granted maintenance of 7000 again. Has the Judge gone nuts ??

  • @amruthsrisrimal9590
    @amruthsrisrimal9590 3 місяці тому +45

    When she left her husband then why she want maintenance ??
    Is marriage is an agreement that husband will be liable to her even when she left husband and it's her fault she left husband is it fair to husband?

  • @Masteroflifestar
    @Masteroflifestar 17 днів тому +9

    I used to think that beggars live on roadside...but realized that biggest beggars lie in the courtroom 😅😂

  • @ssingh8726
    @ssingh8726 3 місяці тому +37

    Poor law is always a weapon.

  • @gowthamanwara2589
    @gowthamanwara2589 24 дні тому +26

    Maintenance is legal dowry killing the man with stress,

  • @devarajdev1683
    @devarajdev1683 21 день тому +15

    Wife is earning 98k , and the husband still has to pay maintenance? ....was law not made for women to support for dignified life?

  • @MichaelScott69
    @MichaelScott69 21 день тому +15

    Any woman who's earning should not get maintenance. This is legal extortion.

  • @sheelasoren9234
    @sheelasoren9234 Місяць тому +33

    Husband extorsion act in india

  • @hailsatan98
    @hailsatan98 24 дні тому +27

    We must appreciate to our ancestors for using Dahej. It's very relevant to use it for this kind of women

  • @gumpusuryanarayana7119
    @gumpusuryanarayana7119 3 місяці тому +27

    Now a days lawyers fee included in maintenance . So courts are directing to pay monthly maintenance at the cost of husband life. What about biological need of the husband. Why court is not thinking on this point.

  • @simplyzulu1426
    @simplyzulu1426 22 дні тому +10

    Divorcee is a blank cheque for women. They can put any amount they want, even if they are employed and earning. Indian legal system is pathetic when it comes to divorce. 498 A should be banned.

  • @rajenderkarupakala
    @rajenderkarupakala 23 дні тому +17

    The beggars begging and extortion must go on, no matter what!

  • @yellowsnowman8971
    @yellowsnowman8971 24 дні тому +16

    Horrible state of judiciary and we still trust on Indian law

  • @AlokSingh-sd9mm
    @AlokSingh-sd9mm 21 день тому +12

    Best business model with no capital involved

  • @donkey3251
    @donkey3251 23 дні тому +125

    98000 salary
    Independent woman
    And still begging.
    Shame on her.

  • @kishore0550
    @kishore0550 3 місяці тому +25

    Worst 😔....... R.I.P Husbands

  • @John-ng5ow
    @John-ng5ow 2 місяці тому +57

    If I was in this situation, I wud definitely be in jail but no maintenance to wife when she is no more !

    • @cmntkxp
      @cmntkxp 25 днів тому +2

      True

    • @somu87i
      @somu87i 23 дні тому +4

      You mean ?
      Yeah men has to be smart

    • @logicx9384
      @logicx9384 23 дні тому

      ​@@somu87iyup Hitman will handle this kind of situation...

    • @ijolamskian
      @ijolamskian 22 дні тому

      Problem is with people who have parents, some bitches trouble the parents and sisters ... launching false case on them too..

    • @JamesNorington-ql7ub
      @JamesNorington-ql7ub 18 днів тому +1

      Bro I thought also the same but after investigation and learning about law I got to know that even if you serve the imprisonment of about 3 or 4 years, you still have to pay after jail. So sad😢

  • @metarock3054
    @metarock3054 23 дні тому +7

    My god. I truly understand the meaning of Law for women and Lauda for Men phrase 😢😢
    The way the ex wife lawyer is digging deep into extorting money out of ex husband is shameful and evil. 😢😢
    Hope kalki punishes these thieving bastards

  • @amolkhobaragade
    @amolkhobaragade 20 днів тому +7

    If wife earns 98000. No alimony for her.

  • @CryptoFeeders
    @CryptoFeeders 22 дні тому +7

    This is joke, courts are joking. so how much she will pay to husband if husband lost job, get sick = nothing.

  • @nitishniks3076
    @nitishniks3076 3 місяці тому +43

    What if the husband parents are ill will she contributes.

    • @djhdud68
      @djhdud68 3 місяці тому +9

      No she will not

    • @sabkabhala5892
      @sabkabhala5892 24 дні тому

      fucking system is itself is bullshit. marriage is a knot once tied you get screwed up by self.

    • @jitendragadhave
      @jitendragadhave 24 дні тому +14

      Bro they don't look after husbands parents even in married life. Forget after divorce.

    • @No_one_is_right9
      @No_one_is_right9 21 день тому +7

      Never she will file another case of harrassment 😂

    • @mogleesh-22
      @mogleesh-22 4 дні тому +1

      She will file one more Dowry case. 😅

  • @gourabsaha8577
    @gourabsaha8577 22 дні тому +6

    Why wife is not paying husband she is also earning 1 lakh. It should be eaqual right, this is logical in a democracy.

  • @கதிரவன்-ங3ண
    @கதிரவன்-ங3ண 21 день тому +6

    The advocate pleading the case of the wife is the root cause of the problem. When the wife pleads for the annulment of the marriage and is earning sufficiently, why the poor boy should pay even a farthing.

  • @mintt7056
    @mintt7056 Місяць тому +16

    Big clap for indian judiciary 😂

  • @drpkc007
    @drpkc007 19 днів тому +6

    When the witch is earning 1 lakhs why maintanance??????

  • @IndraKukreja-v3m
    @IndraKukreja-v3m 20 днів тому +8

    Why always husbands are harassed for money... Not even single penny should be allowed as alimony

    • @rhythmrealm3026
      @rhythmrealm3026 14 днів тому

      Bcz they are males, law only supports females

  • @venugopal-lb3gj
    @venugopal-lb3gj 18 днів тому +4

    What the hell....if wife is earning. ...why should husband pay alimony?

  • @mogleesh-22
    @mogleesh-22 4 дні тому +1

    *"Women Marry to retire and Man marry to never retire."* 💖✨🔥
    9:49 Yeah, take care of woman and her family even after the divorce. 😮

  • @dasaritra007
    @dasaritra007 23 дні тому +7

    Why is it considered that it is husband’s responsibility to take care of the wife unilaterally and not participatory, when both are financially independent and working?

  • @V-pr9jy
    @V-pr9jy Місяць тому +14

    Gold digging marital laws of India 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @vishnupratapreddy4136
    @vishnupratapreddy4136 22 дні тому +5

    if already separated no children and she is earning then how people ask money there should be self respect

  • @parthochatterjee1677
    @parthochatterjee1677 19 днів тому +3

    Wow she will take care of her parents with her salary and she will not do anything in the marriage her salary is high but husband needs to run his own family and court is granting maintenance what a law..

  • @surekhac5249
    @surekhac5249 23 дні тому +5

    No maintenance to these earing and educated wife's.Boys used to marry those girls who are educated. Then why these girls demand for maintenance in case of divorce. They can do jobs to maintain there life.miaintance for child for particular things should be listed not for mother necessities. Government should be strict action and make law and instruct courts so that. Innocent boys should not suffer.

  • @satyakiguha415
    @satyakiguha415 4 дні тому +1

    He says " I will be taking care of my parents, he will take care of me"...wow

  • @moinshaik794
    @moinshaik794 20 днів тому +3

    Independent women shouldn't get maintenance...she can earn naa...now everyone is educated...all can earn..so remove maintenance and alimony

  • @caamitisrani5554
    @caamitisrani5554 5 днів тому +1

    Only the lower class is happy, no income no tension...

  • @carcamp5451
    @carcamp5451 22 дні тому +7

    Earning 98000 and unable to take care of parents??

    • @shvk3439
      @shvk3439 20 годин тому

      Apne liye makeup aur stylish handbags ke liye bhi toh paise chahiye

  • @avanaresident
    @avanaresident 22 дні тому +2

    She doesn't want to stay with husband but wants money from him to take care of her parents. What an irony

  • @Dkuraba
    @Dkuraba 20 днів тому +3

    Even these advocates are supporting alimony 😢😢😢 . So that these ppl can earn

  • @avinsegi
    @avinsegi 21 день тому +4

    Stay alone guys, and enjoy life. This is absurd.

  • @CryptoFeeders
    @CryptoFeeders 3 місяці тому +15

    Shadi became Dhandha now bcoz of these rubbish/dirty mind/junglee laws.

  • @Abdul_faruki
    @Abdul_faruki 2 місяці тому +17

    This is call cheap women agar men ka paresnts sick hota tho keya wo rand paisa dati

  • @AnkitSingh-zo6dl
    @AnkitSingh-zo6dl 20 днів тому +4

    Why a husband should pay??? Where r those feminist now...

  • @CryptoFeeders
    @CryptoFeeders 22 дні тому +4

    earning 98k still case for alimony, this is clearly scamming menz nothing else.

  • @BH19555
    @BH19555 20 днів тому +3

    If after divorce husband has to pay maintenance for his ex wife. Then parents of wife should also pay maintenance to husband for maintenance of wife while in wedlock as wife also should live in same standard as before marriage. Which is the rule of alimony money.

  • @sachinisg
    @sachinisg 9 днів тому +1

    Why husband has to pay when there is no child and wife is earning more than majority of average Indian household???? She has no interest in the relationship but want His money.....
    I suggest that once the two seperate, the person with weak financial status should apply for support from government and not the spouse.....that is only if the both were paying income tax promptly since they started earning....
    Currently, the husband has to pay wife and also pay income tax on his income, if he has to take care his wife's expenses, then who should take care of his expenses???
    Societal norm should change now and its long due because if the people are well educated and are from major cities then both parties are eligible of earning on their own....
    Its been soo long since women have been going outside and working hard to earn money and be strong and independent....

  • @dhanukota3482
    @dhanukota3482 20 днів тому +4

    They don't want husband.why he need pay the even she is working. This complete cheating.that . This punishment to Hindu

  • @avicgboy2298
    @avicgboy2298 13 днів тому +2

    Guys today I need one promise from you all. We will not marry if a girl wants to stay she will stay without marriage 🎉 like to Promise this

  • @rahult.m7932
    @rahult.m7932 Місяць тому +6

    😳 several people work for 15k 20k 30k something and live a happy life having with family and I'm seeing 98k salaried person need money from divorced husband is this cooked up video all this i don't understand what they say 🤯🤯👀👀

  • @abhaypandey2668
    @abhaypandey2668 17 днів тому +2

    is there bargaining going on in a court ? marry a man stay for 1year then ask 60 lakhs very thriving business idea

  • @rajang9349
    @rajang9349 23 дні тому +4

    What type of indian law is this... RIP for indian husbands it's purely harrasment on indian men.. because of some cheap women law is misused..

  • @gumpusuryanarayana7119
    @gumpusuryanarayana7119 3 місяці тому +5

    Husband should beg any pay maintenance if salary is not sufficient.

  • @MB-my4ik
    @MB-my4ik 2 місяці тому +46

    There should be capping on maintenance amount. 25000/- per month or 30% of salary of Husband. Whichever is minimum.

    • @futureiaspriyanshushekhar4852
      @futureiaspriyanshushekhar4852 29 днів тому +3

      Yea galat hai

    • @BhanuPrakash-hk5iu
      @BhanuPrakash-hk5iu 25 днів тому

      👍

    • @jitendragadhave
      @jitendragadhave 24 дні тому

      Yes ​@@futureiaspriyanshushekhar4852, alimony must be good enough for females
      Min alimony for women must be equal to husband monthly take home salary x 12 x 100 x 7
      7 life time salary of husband assuming he lives 100 years each life time

    • @somu87i
      @somu87i 23 дні тому +9

      No man
      It should be zero
      Why alimony to women who has studied
      You take care child for 6 months and she do take care for 6 months at their own expenses

    • @logicx9384
      @logicx9384 23 дні тому +3

      She's earning more than my entire family income 🤣🤣we are still donate few of our money still happy whatever we have..greed have no limitation..

  • @motahar08021987
    @motahar08021987 22 дні тому +3

    This is not correct. Court working as broker. Shameless.....

  • @wowitis
    @wowitis 11 днів тому +3

    Dahej mat lo
    But maintain ki nam par loot lo larke ko .. tab kaha jata bap ka paisha

  • @theraghavs
    @theraghavs 24 дні тому +3

    Why a men should give maintenance to an independent, strong separated women?
    Is it she looses her mind and sense and capability the moment divorce happen?

  • @dhanamjayas
    @dhanamjayas 21 день тому

    I salute this judge!🎉🎉

  • @aasifjalil7235
    @aasifjalil7235 2 дні тому

    She is one of the best judge.

  • @abhisheksalvi8317
    @abhisheksalvi8317 20 днів тому +1

    Beggar wife. She has a brother its his responsibility to maintain their parents. Why burden the husband. If they can't maintain themselves don't expect others to do it.

  • @Bhavesh-z7q
    @Bhavesh-z7q 6 днів тому +2

    Truck Accident 5 lakh game over

  • @omkarsalunkhe9132
    @omkarsalunkhe9132 День тому

    I don't understand why the court hasn't decided how much maintenance should be given to the wife.

  • @SouravDey-x8f
    @SouravDey-x8f 12 днів тому +1

    My age is 38 and I'm not marry i promise never. I'm very happy and free man 😊

  • @kirankommi5271
    @kirankommi5271 22 дні тому +1

    Better go to jail and get bail than paying alimony

  • @am-m-1
    @am-m-1 4 дні тому

    Shame on Indian Judiciary, Laws must be amended for Men's rights

  • @bigbulk688
    @bigbulk688 11 днів тому

    "I will be taking care of my parents, and he will be taking care of me"...gosh the irony in that sentence. Why should a husband take care of a well earning woman?

  • @Worldwide505
    @Worldwide505 8 днів тому

    *Believe me, men will soon stop getting married. after seeing this cruelty done to men by this wife-sided law(giving alimony/maintenance that too to a working wife)* 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

  • @mkumar176
    @mkumar176 13 днів тому

    If wife to take of husband at home and ignoring it left to divorce must also be considered by the Judge...

  • @mkumar176
    @mkumar176 13 днів тому

    Husband as to ask alimony from wife too.. there are equal rights for men in country😢😢😢😢😢

  • @medhasu_Ai
    @medhasu_Ai 29 днів тому +2

    right to equality

  • @reddysena
    @reddysena 24 дні тому +3

    finally it all comes to money

  • @BhuvaneshwariC-m2c
    @BhuvaneshwariC-m2c 21 день тому +1

    Men should be rice the voice all over india. Why should men give compensation.

  • @vadagamavenkat
    @vadagamavenkat 14 днів тому

    Shame on this biased laws and judiciary systems.

  • @No_one_is_right9
    @No_one_is_right9 21 день тому +1

    Wow what a business, first marry, then divorce and claim alimony free incremental income for life time.

  • @ravindraprasad5486
    @ravindraprasad5486 11 днів тому

    Justice is due My Lord

  • @kandrabalu
    @kandrabalu 16 днів тому

    When both together, she was not taking care but now she want to take care the parents 😢😮

  • @AnkitSingh-zo6dl
    @AnkitSingh-zo6dl 20 днів тому +1

    Time to stop paying maintenance guys... it's enough of bullshit we have seen

  • @AnupamKumar-yq9jj
    @AnupamKumar-yq9jj 24 дні тому +1

    You can't and should not reduce the lifestyle of husband

  • @கதிரவன்-ங3ண
    @கதிரவன்-ங3ண 21 день тому

    The advocate pleading the case of the wife is the root cause of the problem.

  • @shockingmoment1710
    @shockingmoment1710 13 днів тому

    It is very unfortunate in our country only a husband is bound to pay maintenance, even after the wife is earning a handsome amount of money.
    But there is no such case where the wife is paying maintenance and half of her property.
    In India being married is only punishment

  • @anilkumarkuriti7661
    @anilkumarkuriti7661 10 днів тому

    Lesson learnt - so men should not take care of in laws great judiciary

  • @Gautam7721
    @Gautam7721 20 днів тому +1

    This is a mockery!!! Law was made to help weak women, here the women earns similar to the men and that too in lakhs 🤦 have some shame, u dont even have a child!!! "Strong, independent, women and we r equal" drama ends here

  • @anitagupta735
    @anitagupta735 11 днів тому +1

    ATM vs luxmi

  • @Sanjeev1353
    @Sanjeev1353 15 днів тому

    What about Atul Subash's case alimony maintenance seeker by wife Singhania murdered husband Atul n kept his son isolation as for any criminal act by women extra entitlement kommittee commission laws and judge Reeta Kaushik bribing asking for 5 lakh as settlement

  • @girishchhabria2597
    @girishchhabria2597 18 днів тому

    Independent Women in real life... Will always be dependent in Court !!! 💵💵💵

  • @senthilmuruganm8592
    @senthilmuruganm8592 20 днів тому

    Marriage business profitability in India for women>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> startups, AI JoBs, Doctors, Even Elon Musk!

  • @manivasnaidu2696
    @manivasnaidu2696 9 днів тому

    Shameless Indian judiciary

  • @rajivmishra1309
    @rajivmishra1309 17 днів тому

    Power of Indian judiciary
    Correction: poor Indian judiciary

  • @chandandacchufan3242
    @chandandacchufan3242 20 днів тому +2

    Bring down this entire system
    Husbands are not ATM

  • @nayijaankaridaily
    @nayijaankaridaily 12 днів тому

    I don’t understand what kind of system this is. Why are husbands always punished? If the wife is earning so much, why is she demanding maintenance? This is disgusting.

  • @shashanks631
    @shashanks631 Місяць тому +4

    case banana bhi nhi ata...
    time pass chal raha hai...

  • @veerababuvaitla7751
    @veerababuvaitla7751 14 днів тому

    If dowry is a crime, alimony is not