"You" won't even be asked if you accept or refuse, so whatever. Also western colonizers landed in my country exactly with contract and business opportunities (for the ruling class of course, workers don't get contracts and business opportunities, obviously) and yet my country is in ruins, still decaying, and at war anyway. Turned out almost as bat (though much more drawn out) as ww2. Also China uses the situation and just gets the cheap resources out of my country and sells Chinese goods for monopoly prices. That's some anti imperialism for you.
I’ve got 2 main questions for this video here, and apologies if they come off as rude but I think they are important questions. 1: What definition of imperialism are you using? It seems you start off with Lenin’s definition, then move into the more colloquial definition of military intervention. 2: have you read N.B Turner’s book “is china an imperialist country?”? If so, i think a response would be interesting since Turner argues the opposite point
@@BusinessGamesAI Yes. China has been an imperial power for two thousand years and they remain so today. The PRC currently occupies Tibet and Xinjiang and has brutally suppressed rebellions there. The PRC has always regularly expressed expansionism through claims on land in Bhutan, Nepal, and India since the 1960s. Many islands in the South China Sea are contested and claimed by China, the Parcel Islands being one example of expansionism leading to military conflict. While the 1979 Sino Vietnamese war was short, it can be cited as an example of China's imperialist motives. But hey, don’t let facts get in the way of delululand 😂
Hello Carlos, have you ever heard of Tibet? Are you aware of the Chine invasion and occupation that took place in 1950? Are you aware of the heavy militarisation and the cultural genocide ongoing in Tibet to eradicate the Tibetan language, culture and spirituality? What are you talking about when you say, China doesn't invade, doesn't suppress etc.? Which parallel dimension do you live in?
Read Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China is a family history that spans a century, recounting the lives of three female generations in China, by Chinese writer Jung Chang. First published in 1991, Wild Swans contains the biographies of her grandmother and her mother, then finally her own autobiography. Her grandmother had bound feet and was married off at a young age as the concubine of a high-status warlord. Chang's mother rose in status as a member of the Communist Party. Chang took part in the Cultural Revolution as a member of the Red Guards, but eventually her father was tortured and she was sent to the countryside for thought reform. Later, she earned a scholarship to study in England, where she still lives.
China has been an imperial power for two thousand years and they remain so today. The PRC currently occupies Tibet and Xinjiang and has brutally suppressed rebellions there. The PRC has always regularly expressed expansionism through claims on land in Bhutan, Nepal, and India since the 1960s. Many islands in the South China Sea are contested and claimed by China, the Parcel Islands being one example of expansionism leading to military conflict. While the 1979 Sino Vietnamese war was short, it can be cited as an example of China's imperialist motives.
Wow this was bad. 1. Talking about China and imperialism and not once mentioning the active colonial settler projects it has in Xinjang and Tibet (which they invaded btw, how very anti-imperialist). 2. Half the video is "but USA", I get it the US is bad but this video was supposed to be about China. 3. Using the imperialism definition of Lenin, who was himself an imperialist and merely reinvented the word so that he himself would not be considered imperialist by his followers 4. The side comments on the russian invasion of Ukraine, something incredibly imperialist, made me think he does not consider it imperialist for some reason? Because arming a country to defend against the most direct and brutal form of imperialism (yes there are worse ways to do imperialism than predatory loans, shocking, I know) is bad somehow?
Glad I didn't watch the video and found your comment. I'd just looked at the title and wanted to see if there were any informative comments, lo and behold I found yours, thanks
Xinjiang and Tibet had been integrated to China for more than a thousand yrs, they are historically, culturally (history records and archaeology shown Chinese people continuously lived in the area for more than 2000 yrs), heretically (proven by genetic tests) part of China. You are brainwashed by western propaganda (Adrian Zenz etc, right-wing Christian fanatic turned "China expert") and pushing western narrative. The west tries to divide China and destroy China, you are of that effort.
The West colonisers landed with guns and cannons. The Chinese land with contract and business opportunities. You are free to accept or refuse.
"You" won't even be asked if you accept or refuse, so whatever. Also western colonizers landed in my country exactly with contract and business opportunities (for the ruling class of course, workers don't get contracts and business opportunities, obviously) and yet my country is in ruins, still decaying, and at war anyway. Turned out almost as bat (though much more drawn out) as ww2. Also China uses the situation and just gets the cheap resources out of my country and sells Chinese goods for monopoly prices. That's some anti imperialism for you.
Headline : " Beijing clears US bombs before constructing China-Laos railway."
I’ve got 2 main questions for this video here, and apologies if they come off as rude but I think they are important questions.
1: What definition of imperialism are you using? It seems you start off with Lenin’s definition, then move into the more colloquial definition of military intervention.
2: have you read N.B Turner’s book “is china an imperialist country?”? If so, i think a response would be interesting since Turner argues the opposite point
Vijay Prashad has some answers on this.
Well said, more people need to hear this! Thanks!
😀 Excellent Factual Statements😃
Excellent talk
According to Lenin's definition of imperialism, China is imperialist.
prove it
@@BusinessGamesAI 她说的对也不对，只根据列宁的定义是陷入教条主义了，你得看现在的中央代表的是哪个阶级的利益了，目前来看我很开心他代表的还是无产阶级，人的主观能动性永远无法忽略，单纯的唯物主义是不存在的，中国不是修正主义🎉🎉
@@BusinessGamesAI Yes. China has been an imperial power for two thousand years and they remain so today. The PRC currently occupies Tibet and Xinjiang and has brutally suppressed rebellions there. The PRC has always regularly expressed expansionism through claims on land in Bhutan, Nepal, and India since the 1960s. Many islands in the South China Sea are contested and claimed by China, the Parcel Islands being one example of expansionism leading to military conflict. While the 1979 Sino Vietnamese war was short, it can be cited as an example of China's imperialist motives.
But hey, don’t let facts get in the way of delululand 😂
Hello Carlos,
have you ever heard of Tibet? Are you aware of the Chine invasion and occupation that took place in 1950? Are you aware of the heavy militarisation and the cultural genocide ongoing in Tibet to eradicate the Tibetan language, culture and spirituality? What are you talking about when you say, China doesn't invade, doesn't suppress etc.? Which parallel dimension do you live in?
Read Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China is a family history that spans a century, recounting the lives of three female generations in China, by Chinese writer Jung Chang. First published in 1991, Wild Swans contains the biographies of her grandmother and her mother, then finally her own autobiography. Her grandmother had bound feet and was married off at a young age as the concubine of a high-status warlord. Chang's mother rose in status as a member of the Communist Party. Chang took part in the Cultural Revolution as a member of the Red Guards, but eventually her father was tortured and she was sent to the countryside for thought reform. Later, she earned a scholarship to study in England, where she still lives.
China has been an imperial power for two thousand years and they remain so today. The PRC currently occupies Tibet and Xinjiang and has brutally suppressed rebellions there. The PRC has always regularly expressed expansionism through claims on land in Bhutan, Nepal, and India since the 1960s. Many islands in the South China Sea are contested and claimed by China, the Parcel Islands being one example of expansionism leading to military conflict. While the 1979 Sino Vietnamese war was short, it can be cited as an example of China's imperialist motives.
Good news, thanks
🎉🎉❤❤❤
But Carlos, have you considered that China big?
Imperialism is when big.
UK is not an imperialist ,
@@LawasSarawak 😂
Is India small?
Wow this was bad.
1. Talking about China and imperialism and not once mentioning the active colonial settler projects it has in Xinjang and Tibet (which they invaded btw, how very anti-imperialist).
2. Half the video is "but USA", I get it the US is bad but this video was supposed to be about China.
3. Using the imperialism definition of Lenin, who was himself an imperialist and merely reinvented the word so that he himself would not be considered imperialist by his followers
4. The side comments on the russian invasion of Ukraine, something incredibly imperialist, made me think he does not consider it imperialist for some reason? Because arming a country to defend against the most direct and brutal form of imperialism (yes there are worse ways to do imperialism than predatory loans, shocking, I know) is bad somehow?
save it we the world know what USA and the west is, you are defending a lost cause . and it was lost long time ago
Glad I didn't watch the video and found your comment. I'd just looked at the title and wanted to see if there were any informative comments, lo and behold I found yours, thanks
@@thearchives1094 but you didn't watch the video .......😆
Deng, do count how many times he mentioned the word China.
Xinjiang and Tibet had been integrated to China for more than a thousand yrs, they are historically, culturally (history records and archaeology shown Chinese people continuously lived in the area for more than 2000 yrs), heretically (proven by genetic tests) part of China. You are brainwashed by western propaganda (Adrian Zenz etc, right-wing Christian fanatic turned "China expert") and pushing western narrative. The west tries to divide China and destroy China, you are of that effort.
Dude, get out n see more of the world
He did. That's why he's right.
Is this a case of the pot calling the kettle black?
the world isn't juts USA or the west
Didnt u guys just gotten rid of dat suharto shit...now u got islamic fundalist running ur country n setting up morality police.....dats real progress