Makita TD171D VS TD172D | Makita DTD171 VS DTD172 | Makita XDT16 VS Makita XDT19 2 SCREW REVIEW #10
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
- The Makita favourite, the DTD171 Vs the Hot off the press DTD172
US Model numbers XDT16 VS XDT19
Full review of the TD172D • NEW Makita TD172D Impa...
►►►Handy Hardware www.handywareho... 1/79 Wairau Rd Auckland
►►Get some 40v tools in the UK & Europe amzn.to/3306Htf
►Worldwide ebay.us/SIMFJs
MORE VIDS
My Top 5 18v Makita • My TOP 5 Makita 18v Co...
My Top 5 36v (18v x2) Makita • My TOP 5 Makita 36v Co...
Homemade Hot Tub • How to Build a Hot Tub...
MY AMAZON STORE www.amazon.com...
My main tool channel: / toolsstuff
Any above links may or may not be affiliate links.
#2ScrewReview
#DTD172
#ToolsandStuff
#BuildsandStuff
I put my 170td in a bucket of water and ran it and it looked like a jetski. 4 years later, thing still runs amazing. I only blew the fuse shortly after doing the water test.
172 clearly faster although I really like the way 171 looks tbh. I own the 171 and I personally love how the back is completely flat, it comes in handy lol. The rounded shape of the 172 is meh
Project farm and AVE really did miss the ball.
They didn't even know where the ball was.
Yeah I commented on that myself
Forget the ball, they couldn’t find the pitch!
I've got the dtd171arx1 (limited edition red/maroon) that was released in Australia last year and I absolutely love it. I think it looks better than the 172 as well, not a fan of the rounded back end motor housing.
Yer I got the same one. Cracking tool!!!
Agreed, 171 looks better
I’ve got a 172 and I love it. Authentic red, looks as good as it performs.
Hey can you tell me how to buy one? I see them on e-bay but I don’t know what to trust. Any info would be great! Thx.
This is the guy I buy from ebay.us/uKVUoM I have purchased 4 impacts from him so far. They usually take a week to arrive from Japan to NZ with FEDEX priority shipping which he only charged $18US for I think. Great service.
click on his name and you will see other colours. He also does 40v stuff and currently has the 172 in DeWALT yellow.
Have you noticed the made in Japan batteries are way better than all the non Japan makita batteries?
Phillips head screws vs torx screws,...slow speed in pl , high speed in torx ....
What are the differences between the 2? Do they both have the same controls on the touchpad? Is the DTD172 the Chinese-made version of the DTD171? Anybody? Bueller?
ua-cam.com/video/IhPQqWyKrNA/v-deo.html
Been looking around for a 172 vs 173, hope this earlier compare can give some insight!
ua-cam.com/video/YU9E8JKCow4/v-deo.html
Can you test hilti brands
Great information, thanks for these reviews. In another video you commented on how the 172 seemed to heat up more, have you had any issues with overheating?
I am hoping to do a video on this topic at some point. I haven't been using it enough to notice it being a problem, but would like to do some tests with a heat sensor and see how it behaves compared to other models.
So what you say is both are doing the job and are great tools, but is no semnificativ difference.
Got the 171 best impact I’ve ever put my hands on I had the dewalt 887 the makita feels sharper and better all round
Can you do a 12v makita vs the m12 ?
Not the worst idea, but I think m12 would kick ass
@@Un-informed-genius yeah I know the Milwaukee has more power but I’d like to see how the makita holds up
@@mofedzoubi456 I have already done it.
@@BuildsStuff I mean you did try the surge vs the makita but how does the regular m12 compare to the makita 12v
Did you noticed the lesser vibration from the 172?
Also as seen in PF video, they have a different anvils, and probably the 172 is a newer and better one..?
Primarily it is the shape of the anvil to fit the slimmer housing. The Japanese anvil also has a different fitment for bits, international bits will have three millimeters of in-and-out slop in the Japanese one.
I bought a 172 and the collet started dropping bits. I love this driver otherwise and wanted a replacement instead of a refund. I can't find info on collet replacement. Am I just thick? Can u help?
sorry im 2 years late and you probably dont have it or know the answer now but it will be japanese industry standard and will require a differnt bit
@kylehocking420 I figured it all out. It is still in use as my 40 hour driver and I have a 173 I use as a weekend contractor. The 173 is really great. Thanks for trying help. That's awesome.
Question for you. How is the trigger control with the TD172D while in the highest speed setting compared to the XDT16? I notice with the XDT16 the variable speed starts nice and smooth as you slowly begin feathering the trigger but as you increase the speed to about medium speed it then jumps to high speed. Its like there's no gears in between medium speed and high. This is a real pain when feathering the trigger while putting in different size screws all day when you don't feel like messing with settings. I would totally get the TD172D if they improved this.
Thanks!!
Yeah your correct they was wrong
Its feels like Milwaukee is falling behind by staying 18v. Makita is getting a jump on everyone especially once it's new platform is fully expanded. 80v chops and planes. 💪
There is only so much power the batterys can put out. Doesnt matter if its 18v at 20 aps or 36v at 10, same same. Has nothing to donwith voltage but the motors and battery packs and management
Only thing needing that much power is a mitre saw and I'd rather just plug it in.
@@0j0nn your right about same output battery power but the higher voltage runs much more efficiently especially if your using it constantly all day. Watch other video on UA-cam and you will see m18 circular saw with high output battery overheat and kick the thermal protection while the flexvolt jus keeps going. The higher voltage will do the job with more ease which should also lead to longer tool life. O and 18v requires a larger motor to even try to handle it which increases size of tool.
Regarding the 172 - it takes JIS bits, but is it still able to use regular (American?) bits? If both bits do work is it not advisable to use the bits the drill wasn’t designed to take? Or, do the American styl bits work just fine
I don't use JIS bits and it's fine. Just a little more back and forward play than other impacts.
I chopped an old 1/4" bit way down and stuffed it in the TD172's collet and boom problem solved, now all my American bits fit right in with no more slop/play when not using the JIS bits.
@@clarkfos3447 is that ever going to come out and has it become a problem at all? How longs it been in there?
Project farm you talking about
Hey Scott, I just wanted to know if the Japanese versions are trustworthy i.e. reliable or should someone wait to get the North American version when it arrives? Your answer would be greatly appreciated. Thanks
Makita is a Japanese company who makes these impacts in Japan for the Japanese market. The North American ones will be made in China. So which one would you go for? And my name is not Scott.
@@BuildsStuff my sincere apologies for calling you Scott!
You'll like it more with made in japan ritten on it.
No difference for me
DTD171Z and xtd16 same?!
Yes
I've seen vids of both models being taken apart and they're the exact same, I was considering getting the Japan version but I watch two separate vids of them being taken apart and they're the exact same, just the us version is made in china, same your money
@@Isaiahlp which video was this??? Could’ve sworn I stumbled on a dissemble video of it before and there was certainly something different, I may be wrong though lol.
And what is essential difference?
ua-cam.com/video/IhPQqWyKrNA/v-deo.html
I have 2 of both and the DTD171 has more features, get less hot than the DTD172. The DTD171 looks a lot nicer than the DTD172 especially at the rear of the impact driver. If I had a choice of just one DTD171 all the way, best impact in the ramge so far. The DTD173 is not available in the UK yet, so you can't compare to that model.
The 173 is super nice.
@@BuildsStuff Not available in the UK, Japanese import only.
Yes I know that, (as are the 2 featured in this video in this colour) but I've had one for 6 months, hence why I say it's super nice.
And I have compared all 3 on my main channel.
@@BuildsStuff Yes, I will be getting the DTD173 in Teal when it comes out, can't wait. Thanks for the endorsement. 👍