Russia and the War
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
- In the context of the ongoing war in Ukraine, PSIA was pleased to welcome Vladimir Milov, a leading member of the Russian democratic opposition. An economist and energy expert, he analyzed Moscow’s military performance in Ukraine, and discussed the economic and political consequences for the Putin regime and for society.
Vladimir Milov is a leading member of the Russian democratic opposition and a former deputy minister of Energy of Russia (2001-2002). He is an adviser to Russian opposition leader Alexey Navalny. He is the co-author, with Boris Nemtsov et al., of Putin. Corruption (2011), and recently published Why Sino-Russian Economic Cooperation Is Not Working (Martens Centre for European Studies, 2021).
Following his presentation, Vladimir Milov engaged a discussion with the audience which was chaired by Marie Mendras, political scientist with CNRS and CERI, and a Professor at Sciences Po.
---
Sciences Po is an international research university, both selective and open onto the world, ranking among the finest institutions in the fields of humanities and social sciences. Click for more information about Sciences Po. bit.ly/2bQkwiG
---
Follow us on social media!
---
UA-cam: / @sciencespo
Facebook: / sciencespo.en
Twitter: / sciencespo
Instagram: / sciencespo
TikTok : / sciencespo
Snapchat: / sciencespo
LinkedIn : / sciences-po
Facebook group: / sciencespogroup
Our newsletter: bit.ly/2NPQ6yo
Sciences Po App - Google Play: bit.ly/3sH5LpR
Sciences Po App - App Store: apple.co/3Bl43OC
Milov is the most reasonable and intelligent member of Russian opposition. Navalny is Extremely charismatic and Nemtsov also was very bright, but Milov is so experienced and he understands Russia so well, that i see him as one of the most perspective and promising politicians of the future democratic Russia. Thanks for inviting him.
Thanks God, there is such person as Vladimir Milov. He is intelligent, knowlegable and very warm. He gives me hope!
С большим восхищением и благодарностью посмотрела выступление Владимира Станиславовича. Спасибо, что продолжаете быть нашим голосом и совестью. Спасибо европейским организациям, что даёте площадку и ведёте диалог 🙏🏻
I am amazed by how calmly and constructively Vladimir handles the same questions over and over again. I feel that such strong argumentative position, not fencing off from “difficult questions” is something that can really persuade people. Thank you for the great speech, Mr. Milov!
Thank you Vladimir. It's always nice to listen to your detailed and expended analysis of the current state of affairs in Russia. Keep up the good work.
Russia is without Putin! Glory for Ukraine!
Death to all NAZI'S and their enablers.
Спасибо, Владимир! То, что вы делаете - имеет огромное значение!
Thanks for your work Vladimir!
Great talk
Amazing to see Vladimir Milov.
nyet
@@JameBlack da
Thanks for the interview and especially for the answers to the questions.
спасибо Милову что защищает демократическую Россию
Down with Putin's power! For a democratic liberal Russia! I'm also a Siberian and fully support everything that Milov says. He is 100% right
What a smart and attractive Man.
thank you SciencesPo for inviting Vladimir Milov for conversation. Thank you for helping people in other countries to remember that we exist: people who are against p*tin
A pleasure listening to you Vladimir 👍
Félicitations Monsieur Vladimir Milov, Bravo pour votre courage, Respect, vous risquez votre vie tous les jours en continuant à porter votre message d'espoir d'une Russie démocratique
Good speech!
44:40 questions: where is the leader of opposition? where is a light in the tunnel? When is the time to act?
Some questions are really weird... That's really strange to find those at Sciences Po
Thank you for using English !!
Who would have thought that Russia’s military was so pathetic.
Dommage qu'on organise une telle organisation qu'en anglais... On invite que des invités qui parlent la langue des Etats-Unis et que ceux qui comprennent cette peuvent y participer.
Когда пропаганду отключат?) через французские спутники вещание идёт...
по сути везде одно и то же говорит.
That’s called consistency
@@natasha_vee ну да, не спорю.
А что он должен говорить, если тема разговора одна и та же.
"let us speak about the ruSSian war in Ukraine without Ukraine or any nasty Ukrainians at our side" - that is how I see that talk. Even more - both speakers ae related to russia , even if they are opposing a side of the russian policy of now they are most interested in that terror state continuation. Why no Ukrainians at your side? You wouldn't like to hear eny critics? cause you are the ones who are also guilty
Вообще впервые слышу чтобы милова критиковали, по пунктам можешь объяснить в чем Милов не прав. И каким образом он поддерживает Путинский режим? Он борется с ним с самого начала становления диктаторского режима.
Сами придумали, сами обиделись 🤦🏻♀️
Muddying the waters and blaming all Russians unfoundedly is what the majority of Ukrainians on the media do today. If u want to hear all that whining and pointless accusations a few thousand times more u're welcome. Internet is full of that. Here however we see a constructive discussion and a lot of reasonable statements about the future of Russia. And let me disappoint u: Ukrainians are not the ones who have the right to decide anything about it (except of reparations). The Russians are. So let the most deserving of them say their word not being interrupted by "nasty Ukrainians"
Часто вижу такую неадекватную и непримиримую позицию россиян. Украинцы могут растерять союзников, требую поклонения в свой адрес.
Он виноват в чём? Несёшь полную ересь. Сказать кто виноват помимо террориста Путина? Европа виновата, потому что, где живёт вся родня этих бандитов? Правильно в Европе. Кто строит яхты российским олигархам? Правильно, европейские компании. Самая популярная судостроительная компания среди российских олигархов - Lurssen Yachts. Европа все эти годы поглощает кровавые российские деньги, не обращая внимания на преступления против человечества. Что случились после аннексии Крыма?? Правильно, Европа УВЕЛИЧИЛА импорт российских энергоносителей-> финансирование террористов. Вот теперь думай, кто на самом деле виноват.
Protest now or never. In all other cases, your protest matters nothing.
your opinion matters nothing.
Sorry, but Putin is really popular. Calm down and live your life.
@@intershull you couldn't be further from the truth. His popularity has noticeably plummeted. He may be popular with those who distance themselves completely from politics or with those whose perception of the reality is primitive and superficial, who would buy into any nonsense they are fed on the federal television. Or those who completely depend on him, hence have no other choice but support him
If you see it differently, you may consider seeing an eye doctor