That doesn’t answer it still because if you ask the honest guard “what would the other guard say?” He’d say The guard would pick his, if you ask the lying guard the same question he’ll point to the honest guys door BUT YOU STILL DONT KNOW WHO IS BEING HONEST
If you ask "What would the other guard say?" to the honest guard, he will tell the answer according to the lying guard, which is a lie. If you ask "What would the other guard say?" to the lying guard, he will tell the opposite of the answer according to the honest guard, which is a lie. Given this solution, if you ask "Where is the door to heaven according to the other guard?" both will point to the door to hell, since both gives the lying answer, and you just pick the door they didn't point towards. If you ask "Where is the door to hell according to the other guard?" both will point to the door to heaven, since both gives the lying answer, and just pick the door they point towards.
@@sahilsharma1602 the idea is all you need to know, is that no matter which guard you ask this question to the answer given will lead you to the door you do not want to go through
The original riddle only allows you to ask 1 guard 1 question. You ask 1 guard what the other guard would say is Heaven and pick the opposite of what the guard says.
@@SmartSolutionsubscribe if I got ans=4 then the other guard is lier so I will ask to the other guard which door is for heaven ( I already know that he will lie to me cause he is lier) If I got ans= anything (except 4) then It shows he is lier guard and just simply ask to the other guard cause he will only give you right answer.
Here's the question that no one is proposing...all you have to do is ask one of the guards something like "how old am I?", or "is an alligator a reptile?" So if the guard answers correctly, you know that's the door to heaven, and if they answer incorrect, you know that's the door to hell. Cause if it's all about one lying and one telling the truth, that's all you have to figure out. So you don't have to ask any questions pertaining to heaven or hell.
What if the liar is guarding the heaven door? The riddle says : 1. there are 2 doors one to heaven and one to hell u don't know which door is which 2. Two guards are guarding the two doors one of the guard will always lie and one always tell the truth u don't which guard lies and which tells the truth 3. You don't know which guard is guarding the doors sometimes it might be the lying one or sometimes it will be the truth telling guard Therefore there's no point in asking those questions
@@hustler666100 You are correct I missed that the people making this video messed the riddle up then because the riddle only works if you don't know. People often tell the riddle with that mistake.
It wasn't specified that the question had to be about which one is hell, so my first guess was "which door is for reincarnation/going back on earth", the heaven guard should say "none" and the hell guard should pick any. This assuming that the liar guards hell but yeah he does, it was in the rules
The liar would SAY that the truth teller would point to heaven (when asked which door was hell…. Because he’d lie on the truth teller). The truth teller would SAY that the liar would point to heaven (when asked which door was hell, because he knows the liar will lie). So they both end up pointing to heaven.
@@WRBhammer think of it like this: ------ ------ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | __________ __________ Heaven Door Hell Door Heaven Guard Hell Guard If I ask BOTH of them, “what will the OTHER guard say the door to hell is?” It creates a reversal effect. Try to imagine that after you ask the question, you interview both guards as to *WHY* they said what they said. If I interview the Heaven/honest guard first, he would say “he knows I know which door is to Heaven and which is to hell; and he will say that I will point someone to the door of hell, which is a lie. So he points the other direction.” If I ask the hell/liar guard, he will say “well I’m a liar! I know which door is which, and I know he knows that as well! He will point to heaven if you ask him which is hell!” The solution lies (no pun intended) in the answer of the liar; he quite literally manipulated the truth. Whichever BOTH guards point to, is the door to Heaven.
I don’t see how this could work because if you ask the devil that first he knows the angel has to tell the truth and point to the door to hell and since he lies he would point towards the opposite door which is heaven.
Ask them which door will the other one say leads to heaven, the truthful guard will point to the other door, the lying guard will point to his own door the fact that both of them pointed to the same door means that it has to be the other one, because the liar has to lie and the truth teller had ti tell the truth
@@vigilanceplays8560 The liar said that the thruthful would point to his door. Which he did, therefore the liar said the truth, which contradicts the riddle & immediately makes this false.
@@potatus082 yes but he tells a lie about what he thought, he thought the truthful guard would point to his own door, and he didn’t, he pointed to the other guards
@@vigilanceplays8560 the question is which door will take me to hell. If the truthful guard pointed to his own door, he'd be lying. If the lying guard would poing to his own door, he'd be saying the truth, therefore it doesn't work.
Left - Door to heaven Right - Door to hell Person: What would the other guard say if I asked him for the door to hell? Truthful Guard: Picks left (The lying guard will pick heaven, to trick you to going to hell.) Lying guard: (The truthful guy will pick left, because I will definitely say that hell is heaven, so I will lie about my answer and pick hell itself.) Picks right. Second attempt Lying guard: Picks left (The truthful guard will pick this.) Truthful Guard: (The lying guard will pick heaven, and trick the man to put him to hell. ) Picks left.
@@felixheredia4570 yes ask one of them if I have two arms. If one says YES, they are guarding heaven. If you asked the other, he would say NO. He is guarding hell One question.
@@samgriffin6221 This version of the riddle is messed up. It's a very old riddle. If asked correctly you're not supposed to be told which guard (lying or truthful) is guarding which door.
Well, the guard who was lying didnt tell the truth. This is because the liar said that the guy whom tells the truth (heaven) would point to the hell door however (since he is lying) he would be forced to point at the heaven door because of him being forced to lie.
"If I were to ask the other guard which door leads to heaven, what would they say?" Explanation: If you ask the truthful guard, they'll truthfully tell you what the lying guard would say. The liar would point to the wrong door. If you ask the lying guard, they'll lie about what the truthful guard would say. The truthful guard would point to the correct door, so the liar will tell you the opposite. In both cases, the door they indicate will lead to hell. You then choose the other door.
But here it isn't mentioned that, the honest guard is standing at the door of Heaven only, here is just mentioned that the guards are standing at each of the door. He/she might stand in front of the door to hell.
all i can say for ya’ll to understand this is, the lying overpowers the truth. The one guarding heaven is telling the truth about the lie and the one guarding hell is lying about the truth
Video: The answer is obvious since u could ask the guards what's 2+2 and whoever says the truth leads to heaven. Original Riddle: HOWEVER if the riddle in the video didn't state that the one who always tells the truth leads to the heaven door then thats where the REAL problem starts. I mean its possible for the one who always tells the truth guard the hell's door in this case.
Because it says so in the video at 00:15 and that dilutes the puzzle because it's trivial to figure out which one is the liar so we know which door is which.
Just say “Do I like ……?” And if you do or don’t like it, the right door will say either yes or no depending on wether you like the thing or not. Stupid riddle
Where should the other guard point to heaven : the guard of hell will point to his door because he lies while the guard of heaven will also point to doors of hell because he is saying the truth that what his partner will say
We ask one of the guards what door will he point to if i ask whats the door to heaven and if he is right that means that he was the truth one and you know wich door to go to but if you asked the lie guard that question you will find out when you ask the truth one and he dosent point to the door the other guard told you
But here it isn't mentioned that the honest guard is standing at the door of Heaven only, here it is just mentioned that the guards are standing at each of the door. He/she might stand in front of the door to hell.
Mr. Guard, i am asking u to lie me which is the door to hell? True guard honestly lies and points entrance to heaven is the door to hell. While lier guard with intention to hide the truth points door to heaven is the door to hell.
Heaven and Hell Guard Guard Truth Lie 0:34 Which Door Goes To Heaven, 2 different answers. 0:42 Which Door Goes To Hell, 2 different answers. 1:15 What would the other guard say if I ask him for the door to Hell? Ask for Hell, they'll point to Heaven Ask for Heaven, they'll point to Hell, pick the other door Of course, these are both principled guards, who stick to their Truth and Lie dynamic 100%
What will the other guard say if it is asked of him for the door to Heaven? The guard to the door to Heaven never lies, it is his priviledge to indicate the door the liar will call the door to Heaven. However, the liar has been appointed by Satan, who had his most tortured makeover artist really heap the goody-two-shoes style on the guard to the door to Hell. Satan says to the guard, "Look, I don't so much want you to lie, I want you to be DISHONEST. See if you can trick people when they come a-calling and querying about the doors to Heaven and Hell, the doors to Heaven or Hell you might say." Well that dishonest guard, true to his master, has got a finger- and that finger is on the end of his hand- and that hand is on the end of his arm. In eight hours, he and Mr. Natural Goody Two Shoes are going to turn in from their shifts and another couple of splendids will step forth in front of the doors. Along comes some sap who was reading manga and stepped in front of a bus being driven by a blind German Shepherd. He asks, "What will the other guard say if I ask him which is Heaven's door?" The guard to the door to Heaven points to Hell's door, and the guard to the door to Hell points to the door to Heaven. Mr. Manga shrugs, this kind of thing been his whole life, and true to form, he steps up to the door to Hell and confidently strides in. That's life.
It's not right i mena ans is right but originally you can ask 1 question to 1 guard only & those who are saying just ask 1+1 if he says 4 then his door is heven then who said truthfull guard is guarding heven door 😉
Okay guys this one is the right one you say :(what well the other guard say if i say point to the door to hell) Why because reminder you can only ask one ONCE so and you don't know who's always lying from the one who always tells the truth by that logic if you ask any of them:(what well the other guard say if i say point to the door to heaven) the one who always lies well point to the door to hell because the guy who tells the truth will point to heaven but we asked the one who always lies so he point to hell , so if we ask the guy who always tells the truth he well point to hell as well because the other guy is the guy that always lies who well point at hell if we ask him what door is heavens Hoop you understood
When you ask either guards the following question: 'If I asked the other guard, which door is the door to hell, which door would he point at'? The lying guard: Knowing that if the same question was asked to the truthful guard, he would point to hell; hence, the guard points to heaven. The truthful guard: Knowing that if the same question was asked to the lying guard, he would point to heaven; so, this guard will also point to heaven. This is also removing all assumptions that the lying guard is guarding hell and the truthful guard is guarding heaven.
If you ask them that question, Liar would lie and say left is hell, Truth would tell what the lying guardian will say (left is hell) truthfully. Since both of them is saying what the "lying" guardian is saying now, the opposite is correct.
Yeah, it wasn't stated clearly that only one question can be asked total, there is room for interpretation that one question per guard due to the ambiguity in the wording. Even worse mistake is that it is stated that truthful guard is guarding heaven, just ask something trivial and you know which guard is which, so you know which door is which. This is not the way. :D
I'll ask one of the guard what's 1+1 Honest one will say 2 and liar will say other than 2 . This will let me know who is honest and who is dishonest. I'll then simply ask which way to heaven End of story
If you have believed on the Lord Jesus Christ like what Acts 16:31 KJV says on what the Lord Jesus Christ did for you on the cross for your sins then you have entered the door of Heaven and you will be in Heaven forever.
If they could speak it would be a lot easier u can ask one of them what color is my t-shirt if he answers correctly he is the honest guard if he lies he is the lier and then u know the heavens door
This is self contradictory and false. The better question would just be something like "What's 1+1". & Since the hell one has to lie, they'll say something other than two.
@@crazy_physics7524 both of them are going to point to the door for heaven. In the video above they are pointing. Even without this assumption, you can just ask them to point to the door they are guarding.
@@ayushrathi9275 lying guard is at hell door, he will lie and say it's heaven door. truthful dude will say his door is heaven. both will answer heaven. Look, bro, I know it's been 5 years.. that's over 1500 days.. you must be older and wiser now and see above is true. The puzzle screws up at 00:15 in the video, it clearly says liar guards hell and honest dude guards heaven, so just ask 2+2 .. then you know which dude is which and which door is which, because the the video here has a mistake in it, usually this puzzle doesn't say which guard is guarding which door..
That doesn’t answer it still because if you ask the honest guard “what would the other guard say?” He’d say The guard would pick his, if you ask the lying guard the same question he’ll point to the honest guys door BUT YOU STILL DONT KNOW WHO IS BEING HONEST
If you ask "What would the other guard say?" to the honest guard, he will tell the answer according to the lying guard, which is a lie. If you ask "What would the other guard say?" to the lying guard, he will tell the opposite of the answer according to the honest guard, which is a lie.
Given this solution, if you ask "Where is the door to heaven according to the other guard?" both will point to the door to hell, since both gives the lying answer, and you just pick the door they didn't point towards. If you ask "Where is the door to hell according to the other guard?" both will point to the door to heaven, since both gives the lying answer, and just pick the door they point towards.
But you can ask only 1 guard and 1 question, how do we know other guards answer
@@sahilsharma1602 the idea is all you need to know, is that no matter which guard you ask this question to the answer given will lead you to the door you do not want to go through
@@freddymintarja2186 well said i understood after this comment
@@sahilsharma1602 it’s impossible, you can’t ask a two answer problem with one question
Ask one of them “do I have two arms?”
This Riddle is awful.
Yeah literally just ask them which way up was, so simple
It's not a matter of the fact that the lying guard is guarding hell and vice versa.
@@flamingchillihd728700:22
@@dagreatleaf9003 the only problem is you get one question the original riddle is that you only get to ask them one question
The original riddle only allows you to ask 1 guard 1 question. You ask 1 guard what the other guard would say is Heaven and pick the opposite of what the guard says.
just ask 2+2
then one will say 4 and one will say 5 but we still didn't know that which door is heaven.
@@SmartSolutionsubscribe I will ask this question to only one guard and based on his answer i can find which one is truth and lier
@@harshu2651 then how will you know the doorm
@@SmartSolutionsubscribe if I got ans=4 then the other guard is lier so I will ask to the other guard which door is for heaven ( I already know that he will lie to me cause he is lier)
If I got ans= anything (except 4) then
It shows he is lier guard and just simply ask to the other guard cause he will only give you right answer.
@@harshu2651 but you can ask only 1 question
Here's the question that no one is proposing...all you have to do is ask one of the guards something like "how old am I?", or "is an alligator a reptile?" So if the guard answers correctly, you know that's the door to heaven, and if they answer incorrect, you know that's the door to hell. Cause if it's all about one lying and one telling the truth, that's all you have to figure out. So you don't have to ask any questions pertaining to heaven or hell.
What if the liar is guarding the heaven door?
The riddle says :
1. there are 2 doors one to heaven and one to hell u don't know which door is which
2. Two guards are guarding the two doors one of the guard will always lie and one always tell the truth u don't which guard lies and which tells the truth
3. You don't know which guard is guarding the doors sometimes it might be the lying one or sometimes it will be the truth telling guard
Therefore there's no point in asking those questions
U only get 1 question so then you know who the liar is and be left with 5050
Are you a genius?
No but that doesnt mean the guard who always tells the truth is guarding the heaven
The narrator of this video says the guard for heaven tells the truth, and the hell's guard lies.
Since the one who tells the truth is in front of heaven
Can't we just ask for the universal questions to check which one of them is liar
The liar will say right one is liar and the right one says liar is liar 😂 well same story
@@gurukirans266 Right
But you will loose your one question
Just go “hi my name is Oliver” and then ask “do you know my name?” Heaven will say yes and hell will 100% lie and say No.. easy😂😂
@@oliveranker252 But you are only given one question to go through the door to heaven, so asking about your name is kind of wasting your only bullet
if you know the truthful one guards heaven you just ask a factual question. the hard riddle is when you dont know who guards which door
1 year late but that’s what I was thinking. You just ask em “what color pants am I wearing?” And the angel will answer with the correct color.
@@Ishl exactly, ask something like what’s color eyes you have. One will always lie talking you which door to go through
No one said the truthful guard is in front of heaven.
@@85set05 he does
@@hustler666100 You are correct I missed that the people making this video messed the riddle up then because the riddle only works if you don't know. People often tell the riddle with that mistake.
It wasn't specified that the question had to be about which one is hell, so my first guess was "which door is for reincarnation/going back on earth", the heaven guard should say "none" and the hell guard should pick any. This assuming that the liar guards hell but yeah he does, it was in the rules
Wouldn't the liar point to the door opposite of the door the truth teller is posting to? Isn't that still paradoxical?
The liar would SAY that the truth teller would point to heaven (when asked which door was hell…. Because he’d lie on the truth teller). The truth teller would SAY that the liar would point to heaven (when asked which door was hell, because he knows the liar will lie). So they both end up pointing to heaven.
@@ThePhoenixx2012I genuinely can't wrap my head around this. I'm an idiot haha
@@WRBhammer think of it like this:
------ ------
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
__________ __________
Heaven Door Hell Door
Heaven Guard Hell Guard
If I ask BOTH of them, “what will the OTHER guard say the door to hell is?” It creates a reversal effect. Try to imagine that after you ask the question, you interview both guards as to *WHY* they said what they said.
If I interview the Heaven/honest guard first, he would say “he knows I know which door is to Heaven and which is to hell; and he will say that I will point someone to the door of hell, which is a lie. So he points the other direction.”
If I ask the hell/liar guard, he will say “well I’m a liar! I know which door is which, and I know he knows that as well! He will point to heaven if you ask him which is hell!”
The solution lies (no pun intended) in the answer of the liar; he quite literally manipulated the truth. Whichever BOTH guards point to, is the door to Heaven.
Yes. If he always lies and knows how the other guard will answer. But…No. He’s not disagreeing with the other guard. He’s just answering the question.
I don’t see how this could work because if you ask the devil that first he knows the angel has to tell the truth and point to the door to hell and since he lies he would point towards the opposite door which is heaven.
Ask them which door will the other one say leads to heaven, the truthful guard will point to the other door, the lying guard will point to his own door the fact that both of them pointed to the same door means that it has to be the other one, because the liar has to lie and the truth teller had ti tell the truth
@@vigilanceplays8560 The liar said that the thruthful would point to his door. Which he did, therefore the liar said the truth, which contradicts the riddle & immediately makes this false.
@@potatus082 yes but he tells a lie about what he thought, he thought the truthful guard would point to his own door, and he didn’t, he pointed to the other guards
@@vigilanceplays8560 the question is which door will take me to hell. If the truthful guard pointed to his own door, he'd be lying. If the lying guard would poing to his own door, he'd be saying the truth, therefore it doesn't work.
@@potatus082 no, the question is “if i ask the other guard what door will take me to heaven, what will he say
Left - Door to heaven
Right - Door to hell
Person: What would the other guard say if I asked him for the door to hell?
Truthful Guard: Picks left (The lying guard will pick heaven, to trick you to going to hell.)
Lying guard: (The truthful guy will pick left, because I will definitely say that hell is heaven, so I will lie about my answer and pick hell itself.) Picks right.
Second attempt
Lying guard: Picks left (The truthful guard will pick this.)
Truthful Guard: (The lying guard will pick heaven, and trick the man to put him to hell. ) Picks left.
Just ask one of them if you have two arms. This riddle isn’t as clever as it wants to be.
@@samgriffin6221 but you can only ask one question. You would have used it to know who is the liar and truth but still not know which door is correct.
@@felixheredia4570 yes ask one of them if I have two arms. If one says YES, they are guarding heaven.
If you asked the other, he would say NO. He is guarding hell
One question.
@@samgriffin6221 ok 👍🏽 I get it now
@@samgriffin6221 This version of the riddle is messed up. It's a very old riddle. If asked correctly you're not supposed to be told which guard (lying or truthful) is guarding which door.
We could have asked whether or not u can answer 1 more of my questions?
The hell guard would have replied with yes 🤣.
But then you still wouldn't know which was the right door as you only have 1 question
@@ngmhhh I would know the hell gaurd right
That obviously will be the hell door
Well that assumes that the hell guard is always next to the hell door and I guess that's valid in this case
@@ngmhhh Well the riddle says that the person telling lies will always be next to the hell door at the start.
I get it but I also don’t get why no one ever asks their own name is? There’s never a rule that says it can’t be that
Because u don’t know if they’ll lie or not
That only works if your name is original. If your name is John both guards can say Jon cause Jahn can be spelled multiple ways.
why would the guard who is a lier tell the truth???
better to introduce some logical questions not like this one 😂😂😂
Well, the guard who was lying didnt tell the truth. This is because the liar said that the guy whom tells the truth (heaven) would point to the hell door however (since he is lying) he would be forced to point at the heaven door because of him being forced to lie.
Low IQ, it seems😒
I think you haven't understood the answer clearly.
I just had a stroke reading this
"If I were to ask the other guard which door leads to heaven, what would they say?"
Explanation:
If you ask the truthful guard, they'll truthfully tell you what the lying guard would say. The liar would point to the wrong door.
If you ask the lying guard, they'll lie about what the truthful guard would say. The truthful guard would point to the correct door, so the liar will tell you the opposite.
In both cases, the door they indicate will lead to hell. You then choose the other door.
Basically every IF+question gives you the answer
the lying angel will point to the door to hell and the truth angel(knowing that the other angel will lie) will also point to the door of hell
Not satisfactory! The other guard would still lie thus pointing the opposite side!
I will simply ask 1+1=?
But here it isn't mentioned that, the honest guard is standing at the door of Heaven only, here is just mentioned that the guards are standing at each of the door.
He/she might stand in front of the door to hell.
@@fu8zy bro first i will identify which ome is homest then ask what is door to heaven
@@shiv2811 Buddy here it has been said that you can ask only one question. If you ask that 1+1 is equal to what, then you will lose your chance.
@cancrucify I don't think you watched this video. To be fair, they messed up the riddle by adding that the hell guard always lies.
@@fu8zy bro if I will get 2 answer of 1+1 then I will ask To another guard who is sure to say wrong and I I will reverse his answer
all i can say for ya’ll to understand this is, the lying overpowers the truth. The one guarding heaven is telling the truth about the lie and the one guarding hell is lying about the truth
just ask how many guards there are and you’ll find out
Video:
The answer is obvious since u could ask the guards what's 2+2 and whoever says the truth leads to heaven.
Original Riddle:
HOWEVER if the riddle in the video didn't state that the one who always tells the truth leads to the heaven door then thats where the REAL problem starts. I mean its possible for the one who always tells the truth guard the hell's door in this case.
or just feel the heat of the door then u will know which one goes to heaven 😂
Why the hell are you all assuming that the liar guards the entrance to hell and the truthful is guarding the entrance to heaven?
Because hell signifies bad and heaven signifies good. Either way, even if it were the other way around, the answer would be the same.
Because it says so in the video at 00:15 and that dilutes the puzzle because it's trivial to figure out which one is the liar so we know which door is which.
Are you guarding doors that will determine if I go to heaven or hell?
you can also ask them both " Which door are you the guard of " the door they are pointing at is the door to the heaven
Nope
You don’t know which one is lying
@@eoingracie1678 they both point to the same one so it doesn’t matter
@@eoingracie1678 you don't need to identify who's lying, your main purpose is to go to heaven and not hell.
thank you! this is a way better answer than the video, because if you ask them what the other guard would say he would lie
Just say “Do I like ……?” And if you do or don’t like it, the right door will say either yes or no depending on wether you like the thing or not. Stupid riddle
Still wrong cos the liar would point at door to heaven and the truthful guard will point at door to hell.
Yes to heaven... Because he lies.... Easy
Truth guard will point to heaven because he is truthfully pointing to the direction liar guard would point.
Ask the guard if he is the guard.
Where should the other guard point to heaven : the guard of hell will point to his door because he lies while the guard of heaven will also point to doors of hell because he is saying the truth that what his partner will say
There's an extension of this which has one guard instead of two
The solution is to do the same, but instead replace "the other guard" with "you"
We ask one of the guards what door will he point to if i ask whats the door to heaven and
if he is right that means that he was the truth one and you know wich door to go to but if you asked the lie guard that question you will find out when
you ask the truth one and he dosent point to the door the other guard told you
What would the other guard say if I ask him for the door of hell
What an animation! 😎
Who knows rick's question to one of the gaurd😂😂😂
Say "I am wearing a t shirt, true or false" honest says true and liar says false so go to the honest one and walk that arse through that door
But here it isn't mentioned that the honest guard is standing at the door of Heaven only, here it is just mentioned that the guards are standing at each of the door.
He/she might stand in front of the door to hell.
@@fu8zy 00:15 what does it say where the guards are stationed? Ooops.. the puzzle got instantly diluted..
Mr. Guard, i am asking u to lie me which is the door to hell? True guard honestly lies and points entrance to heaven is the door to hell. While lier guard with intention to hide the truth points door to heaven is the door to hell.
Why can't i just ask one of them how many fingers are on my palm?
The liar would say the honest guard would say the door to hell is the heaven door since it's a lie. This is incorrect.
WHAT WOULD THE OTHER GUARD SAY IF 1 ASK HIM FOR THE DOOR TO HELL?
yaaas now i can go to heaven. LESSSSGOOOOOOOOOOOoo
When I first heard this puzzle there were demons at each door. I guess they've been downgraded.
Heaven and Hell
Guard Guard
Truth Lie
0:34 Which Door Goes To Heaven, 2 different answers.
0:42 Which Door Goes To Hell, 2 different answers.
1:15 What would the other guard say if I ask him for the door to Hell?
Ask for Hell, they'll point to Heaven
Ask for Heaven, they'll point to Hell, pick the other door
Of course, these are both principled guards, who stick to their Truth and Lie dynamic 100%
When you realise this must be dumbest question to exist
Just ask if 2 + 2 is 4 then go to the door with the guard that responds yes
Nevermind she's actually right, but they're more then one way to answer that lol
What will the other guard say if it is asked of him for the door to Heaven? The guard to the door to Heaven never lies, it is his priviledge to indicate the door the liar will call the door to Heaven. However, the liar has been appointed by Satan, who had his most tortured makeover artist really heap the goody-two-shoes style on the guard to the door to Hell. Satan says to the guard, "Look, I don't so much want you to lie, I want you to be DISHONEST. See if you can trick people when they come a-calling and querying about the doors to Heaven and Hell, the doors to Heaven or Hell you might say." Well that dishonest guard, true to his master, has got a finger- and that finger is on the end of his hand- and that hand is on the end of his arm. In eight hours, he and Mr. Natural Goody Two Shoes are going to turn in from their shifts and another couple of splendids will step forth in front of the doors. Along comes some sap who was reading manga and stepped in front of a bus being driven by a blind German Shepherd. He asks, "What will the other guard say if I ask him which is Heaven's door?" The guard to the door to Heaven points to Hell's door, and the guard to the door to Hell points to the door to Heaven. Mr. Manga shrugs, this kind of thing been his whole life, and true to form, he steps up to the door to Hell and confidently strides in. That's life.
Bro just say is someone standing in front of me and that the angel will tell you yes and the devil will tell you no
If you ask assumption from honest guy he will answer I don't know
I will ask them both are you a guard
It's not right i mena ans is right but originally
you can ask 1 question to 1 guard only
& those who are saying just ask 1+1 if he says 4 then his door is heven then who said truthfull guard is guarding heven door 😉
i understood this story 😮😮😮
Ask point to where you work no matter who you ask they will point to heaven
Who are the other guards
Eat five star do nothing😅
Ask them do you see me. 😁😁
The true one may be at the hell's entrance.
The true one is the one to heaven, according to the video.
Just ask them which door are they guarding respectively.
Both will reply with heaven, you can simply show the 2 fingers and ask how many fingers are in my hand. Boom both will reply differently
Just ask if there are two doors 🗿
Okay guys this one is the right one you say :(what well the other guard say if i say point to the door to hell)
Why because reminder you can only ask one ONCE so and you don't know who's always lying from the one who always tells the truth by that logic if you ask any of them:(what well the other guard say if i say point to the door to heaven) the one who always lies well point to the door to hell because the guy who tells the truth will point to heaven but we asked the one who always lies so he point to hell , so if we ask the guy who always tells the truth he well point to hell as well because the other guy is the guy that always lies who well point at hell if we ask him what door is heavens
Hoop you understood
Can anyone please explain me this?
I can't... Brain now hurts
@@chrisblivorno 😂😂😂😂
When you ask either guards the following question: 'If I asked the other guard, which door is the door to hell, which door would he point at'?
The lying guard: Knowing that if the same question was asked to the truthful guard, he would point to hell; hence, the guard points to heaven.
The truthful guard: Knowing that if the same question was asked to the lying guard, he would point to heaven; so, this guard will also point to heaven.
This is also removing all assumptions that the lying guard is guarding hell and the truthful guard is guarding heaven.
i dont get it
Are u a guard?
Moksh ke praapti ho gaye
Are u in front of a door
just ask what is 1+1 ? XD
Point home.
Hahaha no explanation at all? Rofl
If you ask them that question,
Liar would lie and say left is hell,
Truth would tell what the lying guardian will say (left is hell) truthfully.
Since both of them is saying what the "lying" guardian is saying now, the opposite is correct.
You actually did this wrong...
Yeah, it wasn't stated clearly that only one question can be asked total, there is room for interpretation that one question per guard due to the ambiguity in the wording. Even worse mistake is that it is stated that truthful guard is guarding heaven, just ask something trivial and you know which guard is which, so you know which door is which. This is not the way. :D
No explanation though
Oh well it will forever remain a mystery why there is always inversion in the answer.
You ask which door leads to hell
Just ask 2+2 is ???
I got it. Have I sinned?
I'll ask one of the guard what's 1+1
Honest one will say 2 and liar will say other than 2 . This will let me know who is honest and who is dishonest.
I'll then simply ask which way to heaven
End of story
Just ask.. Are you gay? 😂
If you have believed on the Lord Jesus Christ like what Acts 16:31 KJV says on what the Lord Jesus Christ did for you on the cross for your sins then you have entered the door of Heaven and you will be in Heaven forever.
Easy
Ask them how much fingers holding up one of them will tell lie one of them tell truth
If they could speak it would be a lot easier u can ask one of them what color is my t-shirt if he answers correctly he is the honest guard if he lies he is the lier and then u know the heavens door
just ask the guards is 2+2=4 the liar will always lie he will say no go to the other door problem solve
WHAT, is your favorite color?
This is self contradictory and false. The better question would just be something like "What's 1+1". & Since the hell one has to lie, they'll say something other than two.
Fake!! No such thing as heaven!!
You can also ask both of them which door they are guarding. This is simpler than such a complex answer.
Then both will say that they are guarding heaven
@@crazy_physics7524 both of them are going to point to the door for heaven. In the video above they are pointing. Even without this assumption, you can just ask them to point to the door they are guarding.
Nope
@@ayushrathi9275 lying guard is at hell door, he will lie and say it's heaven door. truthful dude will say his door is heaven. both will answer heaven.
Look, bro, I know it's been 5 years.. that's over 1500 days.. you must be older and wiser now and see above is true. The puzzle screws up at 00:15 in the video, it clearly says liar guards hell and honest dude guards heaven, so just ask 2+2 .. then you know which dude is which and which door is which, because the the video here has a mistake in it, usually this puzzle doesn't say which guard is guarding which door..
I know better
Ask the guard what is 2+2 who one will answer correcy is the heaven
That is correct, it dilutes the puzzle that this video states that truthful guard is guarding heaven and lying guard is guarding hell.