But it’s way too obvious for ppl to really think this is her actually singing? The audio alone gives it away. And I didn’t even catch the inhale until you pointed it out. Just like people being so gullible and refusing to believe Whitney lip synced the national anthem when it was painfully obvious.
Well, actually on studio you can do anything. You can record two different vocals and just combine it to make it like one long belt. That’s why Live is much harder than on studio
That's why she doesn't sing this song live nor many of her songs completely live. They are arranged to be nearly impossible to sing. That's why it irks me how many lambs could be so critical of other singers who sing her songs completely live when they do not do as great a job as the "studio Mariah". They seem to forget that Mariah usually lowers the key, lips difficult parts, lets her back up singers sing some parts or finish some lines for her, dodge big notes, and many other things just because in reality, she cannot sing many of her own songs the way they were written to be sung. She is human after all. That is also why I give props to other singers who cover her songs without doing any of her antics to get through the song.
That is a stupid argument that's been debunked from the 90s. One of her hardest songs to sing ever is emotions and she has song that song thousands and hundreds of times so the narrative, that she's a studio singer. That's the reason why she doesn't sing most of her songs live is complete bullshit. She can sing them, but it just doesn't make sense for her to constantly keep singing. No, songs, and she's not doing the cut and paste that you're portraying her to do in the studio. It doesn't work like that. Don't say shit about somebody. You have no idea of. You sound completely ignorant.
You really want to believe that Mariah is not that good, when she has so many incredible live performances, with songs even harder to sing than Lead The Way, completely live (If It's Over, Emotions, Vision of Love, Fly Like A Bird). She doesnt sing that song live or other ones because her voice was really tired between 1998 and 2002, and that affect her voice forever, this is why the vocal inconsistences. But, the healthy Mariah, is better than 99% of the singers you know, you can be sure of that.
It's just because it was for TV, she had to pretend to sing. The long note that she really sings without the camera and without breathing is the 'Way' at the end
When “the way” part comes in, you can see that she doesn’t pronounce the word “the”, but immediately goes for the word “way”.
Місяць тому+3
0:29 - “the way” was quite possibly recorded in one breath, but the earlier part where she transitions from a chest/mix tone to a breathy tone (0:25) was definitely a separate take clipped together. So, yes, this was lipped.
This one is most likely dubbed witht he final version. But I don’t doubt that she recorded this in multiple takes. As there are no clear proof of her doing it 💀
@@jjarchibald2926 How is it tho? And it doesn’t really matter if its live in this specific moment or not as this is literally in studio anyways. What is mostly factual is that this whole thing was recorded in a single take without the vocals being glued together.
@@DaydreamCarey1234 No proof. This is not Live/Raw vocals from studio. This is the post edit vocals. We don't know if it's really a long single take or separate and just combined. Again, that's the magic happens only on studio.
@@jjarchibald2926 That is true thst whatever it is its not live cause this is literally STUDIO, we also dont have prove that this is anyway spliced, as what we hear is leaning towards that its taken in 1 long take (I dont doubt that this isnt her first attempt in studio tho) Knowing Glitter (2001) had one of the most raw studio vocals out of her other albums. (Except for loverboy ig)
@@DaydreamCarey1234 I don't think it's one long take. She can't even do that on LIVE what more on studio. That only means it's combined. She can't even replicate this LIVE. All long notes of hers are mostly from Studio. And whenever she does sessions it's mostly played the post edit vocals not the RAW vocals. I mean, other singers expose their RAW vocals on studio sessions. Few examples are Christina Aguilera, Celine Dion.. and many more.
U guys just don't appreciate how great Mariah Carey is. What if she wasn't inhaling...there are a lot of things that happen to the body when singing. Btw, Mariah is able to sustain long notes...Listen to Without You live...There's many more performances that prove she can sustain her notes.❤
Nobody said she can’t sustain notes. They said she didn’t sustain THAT one bc that’s longer than anything she’s ever done. Could she have surpassed her limits? Sure. She did have good breath control. But that’s not the case when she’s obviously not actually singing in this clip. We know Mariah is great, I mean we hear the beautiful vocals and runs in the audio. But she was lipping here. Singers lip sync sometimes. It’s okay. And in the studio, there are usually multiple takes and the audio producer pieces together the best parts from each take. This has been stated by actual audio producers multiple times
Mariah's voice change after Daydream, i noticed a lot of struggling when she sing during Butterfly album, if you grew up following Mariah since 1990 you will know that.
I do know that. But some delulu lambs are creating lies. Even making dubbed performances like that duet with Patti putting a whistle note came from a 2002 performance.
The one thing that irks me about lambs who comment on videos like this is that they take moments like these as “I gotcha moment”. They act as if Mariah invented combining multiple recordings lol yes Mariah Carey songs are impossible to sing, in part because of her voice but always bc they are kinda inhuman, however not once did I hear Mariah say she became an artist to be the best undeniable singer, she has referred to herself as a good singer, but she as always put the artistic side and specially the studio aspect first. The songbird supreme, vocal trinity labels were thrust upon her. She’s an artist songwriter first, there to give you and herself an experience not an operatic performance. After 34 years “lambs” continue to come after her for not keeping up to their idea of a prime vocalist when she never did it for that. The woman has an entire show now about the celebration of Mimi now, her evolution as a person and her battles, she clearly puts the art first.
i mean it's pretty obvious that its a video recorded after the song is already done, no way she's hitting all of that in one go, while looking effortless (during the 90s maybe, but this is already the 2000s and well, yeah)
How could you pretend you’re recording when it’s obvious she singing. She obviously sang it all in one breath. Stop over analyzing. Just expect that she’s talented.
LOL Delusional. Try doing it then.. make a long note and then do the inhale thing like Mariah did in the video for sure you will be force to stop when you do that inhale chest thing
But it’s way too obvious for ppl to really think this is her actually singing? The audio alone gives it away. And I didn’t even catch the inhale until you pointed it out. Just like people being so gullible and refusing to believe Whitney lip synced the national anthem when it was painfully obvious.
Well, actually on studio you can do anything. You can record two different vocals and just combine it to make it like one long belt. That’s why Live is much harder than on studio
That's why she doesn't sing this song live nor many of her songs completely live. They are arranged to be nearly impossible to sing. That's why it irks me how many lambs could be so critical of other singers who sing her songs completely live when they do not do as great a job as the "studio Mariah". They seem to forget that Mariah usually lowers the key, lips difficult parts, lets her back up singers sing some parts or finish some lines for her, dodge big notes, and many other things just because in reality, she cannot sing many of her own songs the way they were written to be sung. She is human after all. That is also why I give props to other singers who cover her songs without doing any of her antics to get through the song.
That is a stupid argument that's been debunked from the 90s. One of her hardest songs to sing ever is emotions and she has song that song thousands and hundreds of times so the narrative, that she's a studio singer. That's the reason why she doesn't sing most of her songs live is complete bullshit. She can sing them, but it just doesn't make sense for her to constantly keep singing. No, songs, and she's not doing the cut and paste that you're portraying her to do in the studio. It doesn't work like that. Don't say shit about somebody. You have no idea of. You sound completely ignorant.
You really want to believe that Mariah is not that good, when she has so many incredible live performances, with songs even harder to sing than Lead The Way, completely live (If It's Over, Emotions, Vision of Love, Fly Like A Bird). She doesnt sing that song live or other ones because her voice was really tired between 1998 and 2002, and that affect her voice forever, this is why the vocal inconsistences. But, the healthy Mariah, is better than 99% of the singers you know, you can be sure of that.
What Tori Kelly did was what was really impressive.
@@alissonoliveira7960go take your meds, lamb
I always knew this shit was lipped.
It was for tv they was recording during an interview
It's just because it was for TV, she had to pretend to sing. The long note that she really sings without the camera and without breathing is the 'Way' at the end
totally agree
When “the way” part comes in, you can see that she doesn’t pronounce the word “the”, but immediately goes for the word “way”.
0:29 - “the way” was quite possibly recorded in one breath, but the earlier part where she transitions from a chest/mix tone to a breathy tone (0:25) was definitely a separate take clipped together. So, yes, this was lipped.
Right the way is obviously a separate thing she still sustained a 18 second run
This one is most likely dubbed witht he final version. But I don’t doubt that she recorded this in multiple takes. As there are no clear proof of her doing it 💀
That's why it's questionable
@@jjarchibald2926 How is it tho? And it doesn’t really matter if its live in this specific moment or not as this is literally in studio anyways. What is mostly factual is that this whole thing was recorded in a single take without the vocals being glued together.
@@DaydreamCarey1234 No proof. This is not Live/Raw vocals from studio. This is the post edit vocals. We don't know if it's really a long single take or separate and just combined. Again, that's the magic happens only on studio.
@@jjarchibald2926 That is true thst whatever it is its not live cause this is literally STUDIO, we also dont have prove that this is anyway spliced, as what we hear is leaning towards that its taken in 1 long take (I dont doubt that this isnt her first attempt in studio tho) Knowing Glitter (2001) had one of the most raw studio vocals out of her other albums. (Except for loverboy ig)
@@DaydreamCarey1234 I don't think it's one long take. She can't even do that on LIVE what more on studio. That only means it's combined. She can't even replicate this LIVE. All long notes of hers are mostly from Studio.
And whenever she does sessions it's mostly played the post edit vocals not the RAW vocals. I mean, other singers expose their RAW vocals on studio sessions. Few examples are Christina Aguilera, Celine Dion.. and many more.
U guys just don't appreciate how great Mariah Carey is. What if she wasn't inhaling...there are a lot of things that happen to the body when singing. Btw, Mariah is able to sustain long notes...Listen to Without You live...There's many more performances that prove she can sustain her notes.❤
Nobody said she can’t sustain notes. They said she didn’t sustain THAT one bc that’s longer than anything she’s ever done. Could she have surpassed her limits? Sure. She did have good breath control. But that’s not the case when she’s obviously not actually singing in this clip. We know Mariah is great, I mean we hear the beautiful vocals and runs in the audio. But she was lipping here. Singers lip sync sometimes. It’s okay. And in the studio, there are usually multiple takes and the audio producer pieces together the best parts from each take. This has been stated by actual audio producers multiple times
Mariah's voice change after Daydream, i noticed a lot of struggling when she sing during Butterfly album, if you grew up following Mariah since 1990 you will know that.
I do know that. But some delulu lambs are creating lies. Even making dubbed performances like that duet with Patti putting a whistle note came from a 2002 performance.
The one thing that irks me about lambs who comment on videos like this is that they take moments like these as “I gotcha moment”. They act as if Mariah invented combining multiple recordings lol yes Mariah Carey songs are impossible to sing, in part because of her voice but always bc they are kinda inhuman, however not once did I hear Mariah say she became an artist to be the best undeniable singer, she has referred to herself as a good singer, but she as always put the artistic side and specially the studio aspect first. The songbird supreme, vocal trinity labels were thrust upon her. She’s an artist songwriter first, there to give you and herself an experience not an operatic performance. After 34 years “lambs” continue to come after her for not keeping up to their idea of a prime vocalist when she never did it for that.
The woman has an entire show now about the celebration of Mimi now, her evolution as a person and her battles, she clearly puts the art first.
This is for the comments, not the video
This is obviously lipped no question. Why was this video even made
It was for tv
i mean it's pretty obvious that its a video recorded after the song is already done, no way she's hitting all of that in one go, while looking effortless (during the 90s maybe, but this is already the 2000s and well, yeah)
Of course , its 2 parts pasted together and this is lipped
Yeah after the 90s, she always looked like she was hurting or struggling to sing. It never looked as effortless as in the 90s.
Your dedication to making these hate videos is appalling.
Thank you! Glad you're here to witness the truth 🤣
How could you pretend you’re recording when it’s obvious she singing. She obviously sang it all in one breath. Stop over analyzing. Just expect that she’s talented.
Still blind lol How could you pretend not to see the inhaling while belting LOL
She didnt inhale she pushed her chest out that's clear as day
LOL Delusional. Try doing it then.. make a long note and then do the inhale thing like Mariah did in the video for sure you will be force to stop when you do that inhale chest thing
@@jjarchibald2926 i wont actually because id do it all the time
@@Bambam12340 LOL when you do the inhaling (chest expands) while still belting your voice will stop because you inhale.
@@jjarchibald2926 no it dosent you can do it yourself pushing your chest out doesn't stop you
@@Bambam12340 What are you talking about? I don't get it-