"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries. As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
WWI, initiated by serbia through killing an austrian king or sth, Austria pulling germany into the war WWII, austria gave birth to funny mustache man, he took over germany basically Both times it was due to Austria so i aint so sure if Germany is the only one to blame
Imagine being a German watching Star Wars your whole life, becoming an actor, finally getting the chance to be in a Star Wars film and you find out you got the role of fucking Hitler
@@barettam9577 Star Wars is very much an anti-fascist franchise. While it owes much stylistically and structurally to Kurosawa and samurai movies, narratively it draws much more from the history of WWII and Vietnam, with the Empire playing the role of the Nazis and the USA respectively. As you pointed out, plenty of Nazi design cues also made it into the Empire too, just to really send it home
There were a lot more weapons influenced by WW2 weapons than you think. T-21 is the Lewis gun (or Owen gun?? I forget if they are two different or similar weapons). A-280 or A-280C is the STG-44, the DLT-19 is the MG-42, the DL-44 is the C96 broomhandle Mauser, the stinger pistol or ELG-3A is similar to a nambu pistol and so on. I imagine there are plenty more references than I am aware of
Well... I, as a native german speaker, have never felt this speech as threatening. But now I can understand again why so many people think that german is an aggressive language. But if you scream every language can sound aggressive...
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries. As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries. As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
Watched this in a German cinema, like a day after release, with my Japanese wife. Everybody, except her was chuckling and laughing straight out, while I did the Picard Facepalm.
Why? it’s obviously an intentional reference to WW2, laughing is perhaps a surface level reaction, but ultimately it sounds like they understood the scene better than you did. It’s a heavy hitting gut punch of a move from the directors and of course audiences would laugh in pure disbelief or confusion. It’s not really about the WW2 themes, but rather the subversion of expectations, that’s what people were laughing for. The theme could’ve been anything but the execution is what matters.
@Guy Whose opinions will offend you In most of the new star wars films, the imperial remnants are a bit of a joke. If you now think that seems weird with this nazi aesthetic, then I can assure you yes, it is an utter tonal mess. These movies can genocide entire villages and then abruptly give you a comedy sequence.
@Guy Whose opinions will offend you Nah, gas chambers would be too unrealistic, even for a StarWars movie, or burning that many corpses in such little time, even with their technology it would be impossible
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries. As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
@@ColdMarty not really, when you salute like nazi or roman you tap your heart with right arm and then you bring your arm to the air, they just lift up their fists which many armies done after listening to a speech from their superiors
Litteraly the Plot of "Er ist wieder da" (englisch: "He is back again") The book version was really good (especially the audiobook), but the movie kind of sucked.
There are probably Russians out there who thinks some random jewish comedian who spoke Russian as his first language up until 2017 is the reincarnation of Hitler.
Fun fact This Voice Actor, Sebastian Schulz, is a very well known one for his instantly recognizable voice. For example he is the German voice for Prince Zuko, Future Trunks, and Jean-Pierre Polnareff (also Howard Wolowiz but yeah)
At this scene, where Hux was introduced, he seemed like such an interesting character. A complete fanatic who would rather see the galaxy burn than in the hands of the New Republic. But after this movie they really wasted him so much. He had the potential to become one of the most threatening non-Sith villains of Star Wars along with Tarkin and General Grevious. Perhaps even as good as Admiral Thrawn. Such wasted potential
Hux really embodies what a poorly written mess the sequel trilogy turned out to be. In Ep7 he is a full-on unhinged Nazi. In Ep8 he is a goofy comic relief In Ep9 he is a secret good guy all along? Just absolutely baffling writing choices, and clear evidence the producers had no overall plan at all.
Unhinged Nazis were always pretty goofy when you scratch the surface (see: Jojo Rabbit, the Producers, the Great Dictator etc). And he was never a good guy, he just cared more about his personal rivalry with Kylo Ren than winning the war.
@Justin batchelar as native German Speaker I can only hear Howard Wol lowitz from Big Bang Theory. It's the same Voice Actor... And in this scene Howard sounds very pissed.
@Guy Whose opinions will offend you People say that. But as someone who's spent hundreds of dollars, and even more hours on Joseph Campbells lectures, and books; I don't believe it.
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries. As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
The analogy doesn't quite make sense seeing as the speech is in support of the Republic and the NASDAP was against republicanism calling the Wiemar Republic, Das Republik Der Strolche (Republic of theives). They saw republicanism as a system of thievery where political bosses stole from the coffers of the state to give to their friends in exchange for influence that would help them get reelected. Basically in the starwars universe the Nazis would have been the good guys who opposed the Republic. But I get it, all people who are mean must have the same politics.
Unfortuantely they're NOT allowed to do that. Germany bans all depictions of Nazi imagery or symbolism, because something something propaganda, something something neo-nazi. Right, because preventing the modern generation from knowing the grave evil their ancestors committed DEFINITELY ends well. It's totally not like there's literally a phrase of those who don't know history are doomed to repeat it... (And don't say they learn it in school, you know that's not enough. Nobody remembers half the shit they were taught...)
I remember watching this on TV with my mom and my grandpa (was a teenager at the time of nazi germany). Lets just say he looked very skeptical and i dont think he enjoyed the movie
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries. As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries. As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
As a german, this isn't nearly as bone-chilling as Palpatine's speech in Episode 3 where he turns the Republic into an Empire. Hux' voice actor is well-known for largely friendly roles, his speech pattern is timid, there's not enough roughness in his intonations. Doesn't hold a candle against most of the other Nazi-inspired speeches that float around in entertainment media. I actually found it way more threatening in english, despite english not being my first language and therefore not conveying the same emotional gravity that german does.
@@festivefish1103 The guys who made the movie? You don’t have to like their work but calling people literally Nazis because you think their movie sucked is … peak online discourse.
To be fair, I think when anybody who speaks a certain language understands that certain language, it impacts them more. I got chills hearing how incredibly well the actor for hux delivered his lines in English
@@joshuacollins3729 Okay? Do you think attention seekers respond to random one-off comments nobody gave a shit about? Jesus. If you think I'm bad, check yourself dude.
This just reminds me, of when The Empire Strikes Back was originally released, in Japan they changed the name removing Empire from it because they didn’t want the film to stir up what must’ve been still present Imperialist sentimental mindsets, and here we are in this scene which is beautifully shot and also attempting to capture the Rally at Nuremberg feel
@@wadewilson6628 I disagree, this film is a mess, but this scene is amazing, regardless of how bad this trilogy turned out, this scene showed its potential
@@sethalbert9661 unfortunately I do not remember what it was called in replacement, but iirc they would not translate any mention the word Empire for the films script
Can someone tell me why this got so popular ?
cause its funny
Racism
why did you unpin the Voldemort comment :(
@@deantheperfect idk
Austrian Painter
As a German I can confirm that's how I order in a restaurant
🤣gefühlt auch
Lmao
Страшно думать как ты показываешь продавцу вешь которую собираешься купить.
So all the guys in white are the waiters?
@@jjtpo69 ich auch😂😂😂😂😂😂
Not even Voldemort could cast a spell like this
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries.
As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
@@RenneDanjoule The hell does this have to do with Voldemort or Star Wars?
Edit: Nevermind I discovered it was bot a few seconds later
the spell that makes everyone wearing a futuristic armor suit in a 10 km radius to raise their hands
@@vehicleboi5598 That's the same spell officers use in BF2.
Agree, I do.
Angry man standing in front of a big red flag yelling in German to a bunch of stormtroopers, sounds like a certain Austrian to me
👀
ADOL-
🇦🇹👨🎨
Jew, Hitler was a jew
And dont forget the raising of the hands in the audience
The part when they raised their hands really completed this 💀
It's almost like it's supposed to represent something...
@@Vengar_🫠🫠 It’s crazy to see some ppl are supporting him these days
@@kigatomi33yeah..
@@kigatomi33well they're just making fun of it, I think so
@@genosootaku8649 no, some people are serious. Never heard of the word Neo-Nazi ? btw it just means New Nazi.
well, not only did germany lose two wars they lost an intergalactic war aswell
Germany by its self fighting the rest of the world.
Especially the storm trooper reference
Only because the Kraut Space Magic™ didn't make it to production
They made it look kool
WWI, initiated by serbia through killing an austrian king or sth, Austria pulling germany into the war
WWII, austria gave birth to funny mustache man, he took over germany basically
Both times it was due to Austria so i aint so sure if Germany is the only one to blame
the fact that they raised their hands after the speech really got me
their right hand even more
they got questions
Not very subtle
@@user_of_the_force_15.74 It's their left.
@@arikalamari19 hahahaha
As a Jewish person, when I watched this scene with my grandpa, he went absolutely insane! He began to break dance on the floor! Truly powerful scene
This was unexpected…
Lmao
💀
hahaha💀
🎩✡️👃☠️
The storm troopers doing the salute at the end really completes the vibe.
fr
Damn, they should've accepted Anakin in the Jedi counsil.
Damn right, maybe then this would’ve been avoided.
Instead he got accepted into art school.
@@Stef8988 The Sith arts school.
Your comment made me loagh thanks 4 that
Rank of master?
My Argentinian grandpa says this stuff a lot with the his arm rising
XD
Mine was an electrician, found his old helmet with two lightnings
He must be a big star wars fan.
Mine was hindu, found an old flag in the attic
XD
Imagine HlTLER at the end of WW2 says “I AM THE SPY!”
Yes, I'm the spy and I'm working for Beria and Sudoplatov.
JFC 😂😂😂
...points his finger on a random dude who is over 80 jears old😂
I mean he did end the war after all...
The Allies' spy could be me, it could be you, it could even be... *Shotgun blasts Hitler in the bunker*
As a german I can confirm that this man loves his empire.
verneige dich vor der ersten Ordnung und werde dies als den LETZTEN Tag der Republik!
So does Merkel. She's a true friend of the Blake Association. Dilly dilly.
As they march to Erika 😂
Remember: he is a spy...😂
Don’t you mean….reich
Imagine being a German watching Star Wars your whole life, becoming an actor, finally getting the chance to be in a Star Wars film and you find out you got the role of fucking Hitler
Still better than rey
@@7th.son7 probably would get payed more aswell
Fun Fact: As a native German I recognize his voice actor as also being the German voice for Howard Wolowitz on The Big Bang Theory. Man what a duality
@@ampharosgames7526 oh no I dont like him now
@@ampharosgames7526 bem....só basta um alemão começar a falar alto que dá até um calafrio...porque isso lembra algo não muito agradável
Even as an german this hits 💀
It hit your bass brain
@@BotulinSpikedMarzipan не пон
Fd3s rx7
@@tonystony259 cultured man
@@tonystony259 AKA the spigot
As a German I confirm that this is how we demand bread if stocks are low
I actually heard Hux was massively interested in art and tried to get into an art school before joining the first order after they turned him down.
German grand parents taking their kids to the movie must have had one hell of a dejavu moment
Especially hux screaming like hilter and the red banners with white and black on them. I am still thinking this can‘t be a coincidence.
@@Carlo_von_Habsburg are you kidding? It's clearly made to resemble Third Reich.
Probably snap into attention!
@@Carlo_von_Habsburg isn't starwars inspired by the third Reich? Stormtroopers etc
@@barettam9577 Star Wars is very much an anti-fascist franchise. While it owes much stylistically and structurally to Kurosawa and samurai movies, narratively it draws much more from the history of WWII and Vietnam, with the Empire playing the role of the Nazis and the USA respectively. As you pointed out, plenty of Nazi design cues also made it into the Empire too, just to really send it home
Star wars does have tons of WW2 references. The blaster imperial officers used is basically a space luger.
plus stortmtroopers were based off of the German Sturmtruppen
Lmao, the game Wolfenstein 💀
@@hardiecuizons you got this black girl rebelling against the nasis, common jewish game 💀
@@hardiecuizons yea
There were a lot more weapons influenced by WW2 weapons than you think. T-21 is the Lewis gun (or Owen gun?? I forget if they are two different or similar weapons). A-280 or A-280C is the STG-44, the DLT-19 is the MG-42, the DL-44 is the C96 broomhandle Mauser, the stinger pistol or ELG-3A is similar to a nambu pistol and so on. I imagine there are plenty more references than I am aware of
Idk why but the spinning skeleton gets me, and the hand raise
So glad my cousin Vincent (nicknamed Spinny Vinny) is getting recognized for his efforts of spinning
Most calm german politician
Well... I, as a native german speaker, have never felt this speech as threatening. But now I can understand again why so many people think that german is an aggressive language. But if you scream every language can sound aggressive...
I'm pretty sure most people just kinda thought of h¡t|ərs speeches when this meme was made
@@SharkyCartelRailroad Me too. My comment was more an addition than criticism or something^^
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries.
As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
@@RenneDanjoule I don't understand what you want to tell me with that
It honestly seems a bit more threatening in English imo.
Star Wars take a whole different meaning now, damn even the troopers were in it
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries.
As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
@@RenneDanjoule What a lot of words.
Too bad I don't care.
Bro the stormtroopers were originally based on Nazi stormtroopers, it’s the same meaning it’s always been.
You clearly didnt understand it
Storm troopers were designed after the German ss. Then again i missed the part where that's my problem
Watched this in a German cinema, like a day after release, with my Japanese wife.
Everybody, except her was chuckling and laughing straight out, while I did the Picard Facepalm.
Why? it’s obviously an intentional reference to WW2, laughing is perhaps a surface level reaction, but ultimately it sounds like they understood the scene better than you did. It’s a heavy hitting gut punch of a move from the directors and of course audiences would laugh in pure disbelief or confusion. It’s not really about the WW2 themes, but rather the subversion of expectations, that’s what people were laughing for. The theme could’ve been anything but the execution is what matters.
The hands raising at the end was too perfect💀
It’s the echo that really makes it eerily similar to some old infamous speeches given in the same language.
@Guy Whose opinions will offend you In most of the new star wars films, the imperial remnants are a bit of a joke. If you now think that seems weird with this nazi aesthetic, then I can assure you yes, it is an utter tonal mess. These movies can genocide entire villages and then abruptly give you a comedy sequence.
@@termitreter6545 hmmm now that you've mentioned it, I wonder who also used to genocide villages
By WHO? Please explain!!!!!
@Guy Whose opinions will offend you
Nah, gas chambers would be too unrealistic, even for a StarWars movie, or burning that many corpses in such little time, even with their technology it would be impossible
No shit really? Literally no o e k ew that until you said something wow thanks bro
I'm learning German, and I can confirm he just politely asked for Wiener Schnitzel.
With Kartoffelsalat
@@immanuelrundel6643 Und Bier
@@immanuelrundel6643nd Rahmsoße
@@TheKnifeRaven eine Schneemass
Can confirm, he just said
"Hallo, Darf ich bitte ein einteiliges Wiener Schnitzel haben, bitte?
My Argentinian grandpa says he’s getting flashbacks and I don’t know why 💀💀💀
The fact that there were storm troopers 💀
Storm Department
Sturmtruppen
The voice actor : ah sht here we go again
Ach Scheiße, hier gehen wir wieder."
The best part: this is the same voiceactor who plays howard wolowitz from big bang theory, who, as most people know, plays a jew.
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries.
As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
Ah, that poor guy.
WW2
Great now there’s space nazis
Just like they planned...
Nah dude zeon already got that covered
@@sanity1433 Zeon? Are you a fellow Gundam fan? If so, I see you're a man of culture as well.
They've been there since iron sky
What did you think they were based on?
Thank you for putting this in my recommendations😊
Pov: you're German and understand it💀
The imperial is basically just star wars version of the Germans in WW2
They were inspired by the n*zis
@@SharkyCartelRailroad I KNEW IT!
You mean nazis
i mean just look at their flags , iconic red
But, the Inperials are not the first order…
Considering that germany currently is a federal republic, this hits hard on 3 levels.
Even hits harder when you realised Germany had a brief republic before the austrian man showed up
@@Eagle-od1im even harder when you realize that France was a republic before mustache man went west
hits even harder then you realise we live in a ISLAMIC REPUBLIC almost now 😂
@@XenoxRaider elaborate further
@@XenoxRaider what?
In a galaxy far, far away... A mediocre painter wasn't accepted into art school...
The fact that the audio quality is degraded perfectly to the point it sounds like the funny Austrian painter makes me just 💀
This sounded better than I could have ever expected
As someone who can speak some German, this was hilarious as hell
Same
Guten Tag wie gehts?
@@adidascap9441 gut, wie geht es dir
Whatd they even say the captions didn't work
@@a.chavez5808 "... in front of the First Order and remember this special day as the last day of the Republic!"
after his speech ends insert the sound track hell march 1 from command and conquer red alert 1
Person: speaking German
Captions : that’s definitely music
It's quite hilarious to me because his german voice actor also voices german Yami Yugi
And Howard Wolowitz 😂
And Watson in the BBC "Sherlock"
And Turk from Scrubs. Also Zuko
And Future Trunks
And prince Zuko from Avatar
When I originally watched this I watched it in German because I couldn't speak English fluently then but wasn't aware of the let's say similarities.
Space h!tler
... how? They literally did the salute. Couldn't be more blatant than that. Closed fists, I know, but still
@@ColdMarty they used the left arm in the movie, the real salute was done with the rigth arm.
@@NecroTree-vm5oj I know, still doesnt change the fact it directly references the nazi salute.
@@ColdMarty not really, when you salute like nazi or roman you tap your heart with right arm and then you bring your arm to the air, they just lift up their fists which many armies done after listening to a speech from their superiors
Best part, THIS IS UNEDITED
“Hey I’ve seen this one” - Marty McFly
"well comrades of the motherland , despite all odds , somehow mr. adolf returned" - some russian guy probably
Time to show them some love for the motherland 😉😉😉
Litteraly the Plot of "Er ist wieder da" (englisch: "He is back again") The book version was really good (especially the audiobook), but the movie kind of sucked.
@@ryanschork7487
I thought the movie was better in it's execution of the message.
There are probably Russians out there who thinks some random jewish comedian who spoke Russian as his first language up until 2017 is the reincarnation of Hitler.
@@George_Wong Hitler was anti Jewish stupid
Fun fact
This Voice Actor, Sebastian Schulz, is a very well known one for his instantly recognizable voice.
For example he is the German voice for Prince Zuko, Future Trunks, and Jean-Pierre Polnareff (also Howard Wolowiz but yeah)
Yo Polnareff?
YOOO TRUNKS AND POLNAREFF
Yooooo he really voice this guys
...go on...
Yugi aswell XD
Sound like one famous Austrian painter
Bro is the spy btw
That German voice actor probably had a fun time.
Not realy. Those takes take many tries since shouting like this aint easy.
Funnily enough he also voices Howard in Big Bang theory.
@@royalbluegooner3921 Now I have the mental image that Raj enters the scene ...
@@HagenvonEitzen Sounds interesting.
Hux sounds a lot more impressive and a lot less like a squealing little girl than he did in the original.
Hux's speech scene is one of the only good parts in the entire sequel trilogy imo
@RubyTwoBears Agreed
@merc4higher Rey Solo would have been just as bad as Rey Palpatine. I really with they committed to Rey from nowhere and not rehired JJ Abrams.
But the Problem is... They used the german voice actor of Howard Wolowitz from the big bang theory. So I really cant take him serious xD
The ending caught me off guard 💀
😭
Oh... They'll never live it down....
At this scene, where Hux was introduced, he seemed like such an interesting character. A complete fanatic who would rather see the galaxy burn than in the hands of the New Republic.
But after this movie they really wasted him so much. He had the potential to become one of the most threatening non-Sith villains of Star Wars along with Tarkin and General Grevious. Perhaps even as good as Admiral Thrawn. Such wasted potential
I know right
Indeed. Psh.
Im the spy
@@Daniele63 I knew it!
Wasted potential describes the new star wars movies to a T
Hux really embodies what a poorly written mess the sequel trilogy turned out to be.
In Ep7 he is a full-on unhinged Nazi.
In Ep8 he is a goofy comic relief
In Ep9 he is a secret good guy all along?
Just absolutely baffling writing choices, and clear evidence the producers had no overall plan at all.
Unhinged Nazis were always pretty goofy when you scratch the surface (see: Jojo Rabbit, the Producers, the Great Dictator etc). And he was never a good guy, he just cared more about his personal rivalry with Kylo Ren than winning the war.
@@vanceunderwood5364 notice how all the films you listed were comedies?
Star Wars can have some funny moments, but it sure as hell isnt a comedy.
Granted. The point is it makes a kind of sense for a blustering fascist like to turn out to be kind of pathetic.
@@vanceunderwood5364 like darth vader?
Just like in real-life, fully unhinged Nazis aren't real but in the pocket of the "good guys". Here in Germany, we call them V-Men.
Captions be like:
[Music]
Okay, NOW I understand why they raised their hands 💀
As a german this felt like something i havent heard in a long time
Zhong Xina your German 🤯
I didn’t know Asian was the new German?
I have a weird feeling in my right arm
I’m no German, and I didn’t live in 1939 but I know what you mean.
@@AnakinLanz Well, given how they act, they are about to be.
i think what set me off laughing was the soldiers raising there arms at the end
At least it’s the left arm
@@thorbjrndalsgaard5199 its in the movie, not sure about the version edited for Television but definitely HD DVD.
@@thorbjrndalsgaard5199 of course it’s in the Movie.
The Empire always was space clone of the 3 Reich.
@@Neorok117 Not always. Only since Episode VII.
Sends shivers through my spine.
That german dude from f is for family leaving the theatre " oh schiesse oh schiesse oh schiesse! Not again!"
Grandpa suddenly stands up straight, heels together, raising his right arm and I think you know where I'm going with this
Nahhhh
._./
If anyone who fought in WWII saw this, they for sure got flashbacks
guess that was by designe, the first order (even more than the empire) has more than a fair share of simularty to the nsdp.
u need to get him in art shool
Bro casted the most unforgiving spell ever casted 💀
Well, all i hear is a pretty accurate translation of this scene, with a talented voiceactor who matches the original voice of the actor pretty good.
@Justin batchelar as native German Speaker I can only hear Howard Wol
lowitz from Big Bang Theory. It's the same Voice Actor...
And in this scene Howard sounds very pissed.
@@danielg.7211 That's hilarious ngl
incredible that you can ignore the nazi similarities but ok
@@fwoqma i know, there are similarities, but that is wanted you know?
@@danielg.7211 Waaas? hab die serie wohl nicht genügend geschaut...
Imagine being shocked that Star Wars has WWII themes.
The franchise who's main villain is literal space Nazis? Nah of course not no way
wow how did you find that out, complete wow
@@sdg131 have you only watched the movies?
@Guy Whose opinions will offend you People say that. But as someone who's spent hundreds of dollars, and even more hours on Joseph Campbells lectures, and books; I don't believe it.
Well the average star-wars fan has the IQ of a gnat, even Star Wars and its heavy-handed use of the nazi/ww2 tropes seem subtle to them.
I needed this today 😂
bro have failed the art school 💀💀
He's just ordering some food at McDonalds
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries.
As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
@@RenneDanjoule can you not?
@@RenneDanjoule Based
@@RenneDanjoule 🤓
@@RenneDanjoule And the Nazis were a anti-bourgeois party which borrowed Socialism from the Left, partly due to the failure of Marxism.
As a german I can confirm this guy was holding back.
As a German I can confirm that’s how I speak to my friends
Space Hitler isn't real, he can't hurt you.
Space Hitler:
Imagine if the Stormtroopers chanted "SIEG HEIL! SIEG HEIL! SIEG HEIL!"
And then Gesundheit! Gesundheit! Gesundheit!
@@lollikabosso.w.n7153 I see you're a man of hellsing as well
The analogy doesn't quite make sense seeing as the speech is in support of the Republic and the NASDAP was against republicanism calling the Wiemar Republic, Das Republik Der Strolche (Republic of theives). They saw republicanism as a system of thievery where political bosses stole from the coffers of the state to give to their friends in exchange for influence that would help them get reelected.
Basically in the starwars universe the Nazis would have been the good guys who opposed the Republic. But I get it, all people who are mean must have the same politics.
Unfortuantely they're NOT allowed to do that. Germany bans all depictions of Nazi imagery or symbolism, because something something propaganda, something something neo-nazi. Right, because preventing the modern generation from knowing the grave evil their ancestors committed DEFINITELY ends well. It's totally not like there's literally a phrase of those who don't know history are doomed to repeat it... (And don't say they learn it in school, you know that's not enough. Nobody remembers half the shit they were taught...)
@@JasonMitchellofcompsci in support?,
Buddy, have you seen the movie?
I remember watching this on TV with my mom and my grandpa (was a teenager at the time of nazi germany). Lets just say he looked very skeptical and i dont think he enjoyed the movie
When you said "Was a teenager at the time of Nazi Germany" I thought you were reffering to yourself
I dont think anyone enjoyed the movie...
@Linkingx2 funny, did laugh
Probably had more to do with the actual movie itself. The Disney sequels were atrocious.
@@Linkingx2 Really? Idk man, when it came out it got a lot of praise from the fans and the critics. So...
2 movies later: "i'M tHe SpY"
Disney: We need a German actor for this part
The actor:
This needs a remix!
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries.
As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
@@RenneDanjoule Bot
Well the soldiers are called Stormtroopers
I forgot about that
I’m sure the name Darth Vader was a give away decades ago, with his chad Wehrmacht helmet.
Sturmtruppen*
@@seizuresalad91 Darth Vader's helmet is actually a samurai helmet.
"Engels's Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany of 1851 blamed the failure of the German revolution on the timidity of the bourgeois liberals who led it. But some share of the blame might also be allotted to the extremism of the communist program, which frightened workers as well as bourgeois liberals and gave a pretext for repression to reactionaries.
As was to be the case later-in Italy on the eve of Mussolini and Germany on the eve of Hitler-extremism on the Left played a role in preparing the way for reaction on the Right. Marx's own postmortem was concentrated on France. He had translated Blanqui's blunt aphorism "Who has iron has bread" for the Banquet of Equals in February 1851. But by the end of the year he realized that the established authorities had all the iron and could dispense the bread to the weary masses. Blanqui remained in prison; and the last great popular uprising of the era (of one hundred thousand rebels against Napoleon III's proclamation of dictatorship) in December 1851, was crushed with five hundred killed and twenty thousand convicted. There was no major upheaval in France and no further mention of the "dictatorship of the proletariat" anywhere until the Paris Commune twenty years later."-James H Billington, 13th Librarian of Congress
The cut at the salute had me wheezing
Dawg the salute is crazy 💀
As a german, this isn't nearly as bone-chilling as Palpatine's speech in Episode 3 where he turns the Republic into an Empire. Hux' voice actor is well-known for largely friendly roles, his speech pattern is timid, there's not enough roughness in his intonations. Doesn't hold a candle against most of the other Nazi-inspired speeches that float around in entertainment media. I actually found it way more threatening in english, despite english not being my first language and therefore not conveying the same emotional gravity that german does.
It's the difference between good writing and bad writing.
The Disney trilogy has clown baddies and their idea of what Evil is is very cartoonish.
@@rovhalt6650 it's intentional, they don't want people to know what actual evil is cause people might see it in them.
@@festivefish1103 oh shit
@@festivefish1103 “did a full 180 crazy”- dua lipa
@@festivefish1103 The guys who made the movie? You don’t have to like their work but calling people literally Nazis because you think their movie sucked is … peak online discourse.
To be fair, I think when anybody who speaks a certain language understands that certain language, it impacts them more. I got chills hearing how incredibly well the actor for hux delivered his lines in English
Ah, a fellow "to be fair" user. I too wish to be fair.
@@Kyrieru this is the part where “you got everybody laughing”
@@joshuacollins3729 Okay? Do you think attention seekers respond to random one-off comments nobody gave a shit about? Jesus. If you think I'm bad, check yourself dude.
@@Kyrieru BAHAHAHA 🤡 might wanna reread what you just said there pal and think about it nice and carefully 🤡🤡🤡🤡
No, i an from Brasil but this sounds better in german.
Damn, we should accept him to artschool
German Gen Z explaining his life during a robbery
This just reminds me, of when The Empire Strikes Back was originally released, in Japan they changed the name removing Empire from it because they didn’t want the film to stir up what must’ve been still present Imperialist sentimental mindsets, and here we are in this scene which is beautifully shot and also attempting to capture the Rally at Nuremberg feel
best scene of the trilogy imo.
@@wadewilson6628 I disagree, this film is a mess, but this scene is amazing, regardless of how bad this trilogy turned out, this scene showed its potential
So they just called it "Star Wars: The Strikes Back"?
@@sethalbert9661 unfortunately I do not remember what it was called in replacement, but iirc they would not translate any mention the word Empire for the films script
@@manticorephoenix The movie is called 帝国の逆襲, literally The Empire Strikes Back, in Japanese
When I first watched this in theaters I remember thinking "they're not even hiding it at this point, imagine it in German"
translate "hail to the chief" into german
------
95% of the tex you can find in NS songs
Least passionate speecher in Germany:
The end tho 💀
When Steiner's counter Attack works:
I guess he also has been rejected from art school
As a ferman i can confirm star wars is weird in german.
I SPAT MY SODA ACROSS MY LAPTOP HELP-
The spinning skull really adds a lot to the experience 😃👍
Hmmm…I’m wondering if these guys are the baddies
@@warlordofbritannia Are we the baddies?
Every other storm trooper: doing their job and acting
That one guy who got the job for fun: wait wtf is this-
Teacher telling us to prepare for a fire drill
Guys, calm down. He was just trying to teach his subordinates how to Heil a taxi.
Looks like the guy saying the speech didn't pass in art school 💀
Hmmm, those 1930's vibes make me nostalgic.
He definitely got rejected from art school