we don’t talk about this enough, this version of black swan, the choreography, the aesthetic, the dancers, the place, this mv is beautiful and deserve more views and recognition!
Blinkhere the message is that bts are afraid to lose their love of music, and therefore not able to continue through this path. The message just doesn’t apply to them tho, it can happen to anybody who has a passion for what they do.
the most grammy worthy song i've EVER heard. from the lyrics to the music to the raw PASSION and PAIN that drips from this song. got me feeling some things fr
Its as sound had a visual I can see the lyrics. I can feel every movement with them. I can see every lyric. It's like being able to hear color. Its beautiful
BTS releasing a song about how an artist losing his passion is worse than death in their 7th year in the industry shows how genuine their love for music is. This whole comeback clearly wasn't made with breaking records in mind (even if they did pull out mind-blowing numbers anyway), it was about celebrating art in its many forms. For the making of the album they worked with many different artists, the marching band of 'ON', the choir in 'Friends', and now this dance company. They released 'Black Swan' as a single a month before the album and this was the MV that was released first. I do think that they truly wanted to spotlight these amazing dancers. I also want to highlight something : they released 'ON Kinetic Manifesto' the day of the comeback, and a few days later they released the official MV of 'ON', not caring if it was going to impact the views on the first 'ON' video. And a few days later again they released another video for Black Swan. I want you to understand that this isn't normal, this isn't common to release 3 MVs during comeback week. They also released the 'Shadow' and 'Ego' MVs. They didn't care about the views or money or whatever, they only cared about their work and art. I think that it's quite amazing that they did this knowing that they wouldn't get as many views as usual. It doesn't surprise me though, after years with them I've witnessed many times how passionate they were for music. I'm so proud of them and I'm really learning a lot about music besides them. I just wish more people would recognize that they are far from your typical boy band or even typical artists. They do this out of passion, which is not that common nowadays in an industry run by money, clout and mediaplay. I'm hoping that their music will get the recognition it deserves and that they will also get credited as the amazing songwriters, producers, singers, rappers, dancers that they are.
I changed my mind about views in youtube. And I will learn not watch views in mv, and just relax? Ahaha And when armys said that we should reach 700m(? I dont remember but it was really high) and i was like I understand that you trying to show your love and etc but relax and enjoy music. We don't need break records, cause we are only one who can break them in the world💜
This was one of the most extraordinary moments in BTS' career, and it was game changing. No Kpop group had ever done anything like this, and it was glorious. I miss them and can't wait to see what else they have in store for us when they all get back safely from the military. Black Swan is a classic and this art film and their MV were both wonderful.
I am not an army, i just found this video but let me say it: This is a masterpiece. This dance performance gives us such a powerful message and the song is wonderful. Good job to the dancers and BTS.
I still can’t believe BTS musical diversity and their level of artistry. They’re so complex. They don’t treat the music industry as a way of making money, they don’t try to release music just for the sake of releasing. Each song and lyric that is shown in front of their listeners/viewers is so well prepared, picked up with such a meticulous care. You can hear and feel their love for the music. Discovering their music is such an interesting ride. You don’t get bored at all with their sound and story. I wish more people could give them a real chance and listen closely to what BTS wants to delivers to the entire world.
the sea that they wished for is now full of dark waves consuming them except they have the strength and the will to jump and never be dragged again. this song speaks to me on a personal level and I must admit I have been crying all day but in the most cathartic way. if you listen with an open mind and expand yourself to the vast musical catalog of BTS's body of work you will find BTS are truly artists for healing and their attention to detail is remarkable.
can you please explain the song to me I truly dont get it. I'm trying so hard but i just cant understand it. I know you can put subtitles but i dont know the meaning of the song.
Brianna Castillo Well, I guess you don’t have a Twitter account, those @RMY$ come and explain every thing and all the theories are there, it’s very helpful for @RMY$! I will try to explain it as short as possible: in the beginning it says a dancer can go trough 2 deaths, the first one being the most painful one and that’s losing the passion for the thing they love the most. In B TS’s case, they talk how they fear of losing passion for music. The center dancer represents the swan,and the dancers in black the shadows. In the first they control him and they torture him, they don’t let him to fly, all the bad thoughts and the passion losing. Then feels like in a cage where again the shadow within fight him and they don’t let him to get free but in the end he menages to escape it! Later he even fights and accepts the shadows, he gets to control them in the end and they help him to fly this time! The swan represents BTS in their music career and how in the end they realizing that music represents them, music is within them, it’s all they have! They fought and accept their shadows allowing them to grow more as artists and continue to do what they love the most, music. I really hope you understand more of it
this isn’t music, it’s art. literal art. and it’s expressed really well with this version. it really expresses their fear for losing their passion in music. most artists would be more worried about their fame, but bts is different, and i find that so inspiring. i have the same fear with both music and acting so i can definitely relate. i thank them so hecking much for doing what they do.
It's been SEVEN years and they still put out surprising music that stays with you. I am so proud of you, BTS. Also, the dancers in this art film did an amazing job.
I always give this video a standing ovation because of how breath taking it is this is the best one yet because me as an artists felt this in my soul😭👏🏻
No other songs can beat THIS. I feel sorry for people who doesn't understand the magic behind this boy band. They truly one of a kind. Every time I listen to this, I feel some type of way. The dancers have portrayed the emotions so perfectly, the lyrics about the fear of losing passion for music and the song itself is a masterpiece. Now I understand why people think BTS isn't just a typical boy band, they're more than just handsome guys who can sing and dance, wear fancy clothes and colorful hair. This is some real musician stuff here. I hope people understand that BTS are where they are today is not because of their popularity but their love for music and what they do. The only thing their popularity did was to help getting recognized by the world. If only this song was released on the music platforms, this song would probably be the perfect candidate for SOTY.
You wrote such a masterpiece! I don't really understand why people always judge the picture before getting deeper. This group has such an insane popularity and loyal, hardworking and uncondicionally loving fans not only for their handsome faces and catchy dances. People must be more respectful and kind to others, because this undeserved hate that they give to those, who becomes a true remedy to millions around the world, is such a useless and unworthy timespending
@@ТимурГалаев-ч1в ikr.... and people refuse to listen to them, acknowledge their work and take them seriously because of the hate that's been surrounded.
"I'd rather die than live without passion." -Jungkook Black Swan is the struggle of losing the passion for music which is their shadow. However, in the end, accepting those shadows and overcoming them makes them fly. The song is so beautiful!
it is not an unpopular opinion, everyone agrees that black swan is bts best song (those who disagree are usually tasteless) now if only bh put this version on spotify it would be great
@@Rout_fams oh I get it, it would be underhype then, by the company too nnn Title tracks always get the most recognition and properly promote singles like dynamite. Black Swan could have being that song to locals
the dance is so powerful. MN Dance Company, thank you for giving such a phenomenal performance! It is super not easy and could be dangerous to performance in a venue like this with bear foot. somehow i still see little rocks on the floor. This performance, omg... it translate the message so well. the struggle, the resist, the change. At the end became like the king of the swan. I love it. This is beautiful.
I know right! I hope Big Hit releases the orchestra version someday. Maybe BTS could perform with this version. Ideally during the MOTS tour because I really want to hear it in a stadium, but I know that's definitely asking for too much lol
I think this “first death” applies to anyone who has lost their passion due to depression or something similar and the fact that BTS is able to capture the feeling of this in a single song is absolutely breathtaking
This is honestly one of the best arrangements. This is just ART Update: Do y'all imagine watching a performance like MMA 2020 in concert 🥺 I guess I'd die if that ever happens
No, but seriously, watching this again, and I cried. IDK just that I feel this song and performance, is not receiving the love and recognition it deserves. It's a masterpiece. I love it so much. I really do. I always tell my sisters, "Black Swan" is superior! That is just my humblest opinion. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Today marks one year since I discovered BTS, fell down the rabbit hole and became an ARMY. Finding hidden masterpieces like this video makes me really happy, realizing that BTS are 360° artists appreciated in all art fields, from people with different backgrounds and ages, this somehow makes me proud. I'm afraid, I'M IN THIS BANGTANSH*T FOR LIFE!!!!
This song portrays all the hardships that come with creating art. The fear of reaching a point where ur passion is gone and the moment where u rise from this struggle.
i can definitely relate, i did dance since i was 5 and i slowly lost interest in it even though my biggest dream was to be a professional dancer.i didn’t want to give it up cause it’s what i lived for but i also didn’t want to spend the rest of my life doing something i didn’t have passion for anymore. it truly is devastating having to move on from something you put your whole life and existence into. it’s a very hard choice to make. i bet a lot of people can relate to the song too plus it’s a bop 🤩
@@juno3281 definitely a bop/trap bts know how to keep us wanting more and yes the feeling that ur losing something you love so much and believed to be ur one true calling is scary. This album is going to be legendary
At first, the black swan was caged with their shadows. Then, they fight back the shadows and start to walk alone. But in the end, the shadows is the one who help the black swan to fly. The message is amazing.
It's such an incredible message! It makes me sad to think that a lot of people might watch this and not understand how deep and beautiful its meaning really is! 💜
People ask me why I love listening to BTS’s songs. This is why: I can feel the members emotions through every lyric, every note they sing. Those are their thoughts, what they go through right now. How can I not relate or appreciate this genuineness?
km same their music is so original and they are going through all of this and decide to put it into their music their music is interesting and intense it’s so addicting.
that is so trueeeeeeeeeeeee i love them so much for like everything. They are amazing at everything they do and they show us what they feel and express it through their performance💜💜💜💜
I used to be a dancer but I can't dance anymore because my arthritis makes it too painful and I'm currently getting evaluated for early onset Parkinson's Disease because I shake alot. Black Swan is heartbreaking because they hit the nail on the head, this is exactly what it feels like to not be able to do what made you passionate anymore. My 1st death truly was when I stopped dancing and honestly I don't think my next death will be as heart wrenching as grieving the person I was when I was enveloped in passion and love for dance.
I wish you nothing but peace, love, and healing moving forward, friend. It isn't quite the same, but due to mental health problems I've been unable to pursue my passions since around my early 20s. So I understand the pain of not being able to be the person I was when I had my passions. I hope we can both heal in time. 💜
For some reason, I really felt the song and the message there. I listened to the song a lot but now it hits me. Losing your thing, how terrifying and empty you feel although you can't do anything about it. I lost interest in my passion when I had my burnout and depression and I feel empty and changed from no longer being able to live it and spend time on it, dedicate my soul to it. It is an excruciating silence in your life....
Fact : This song and art film are the reason why I became a fan since, it triggered me. Those lyrics song made me realise what kind of artist they are. I had never heard something like this before ! Really
i hope people find them more the way you did, like through learning/seeing what they are as artist and musicians and not by idols who entertain others but not because of their music and talents. (i mean ofcourse their funny side personalities as individuals and as a group count too but they are much more than that💜)
"A dancer dies twice, once when he stops dancing and this death is the most painful." A beautiful and deep message, we must make this comeback the greatest that BTS has made!
Im not going to lie,i love the orchestral version of black swan alot better then the other one.This version really captures the beauty and sadness of the song,and i really wish they would put this version on spotify.Anyway thanks for listening to my ted talk.
It's been over 3 years since this song came out and it still gives me goosebumps. Black Swan is truly such a unique song specific for creators and artists
As a dancer, i for sure can relate to what the dancers have illustrated for us. i’ve hit a point where i lost my passion for dance...i felt like it was this weight which i was forced to carry, and i hated it. after that dance season ended, i stopped competing, and started to not show up to classes to train. at first i felt free like the invisible weight was lifted off of me...but then i felt like i lost a part of me. i felt clueless on what i wanted to do besides studying...i kept debating “do i want to go back to dance” but the thought of “what’s the point if i don’t feel this fire anymore” kept pulling me back. I later went to this show that my friends were performing in, and when i saw them, they relit this fire, this motivation in me. i saw how passionate they are for their craft and that just hit something in me. it pushed me to come back to dance, and start training again. yes it was rough at first, but then i slowly started to enjoy it. this opportunity then opened up for me where i’d be on the dance team for this pro basketball team and i felt like this was my chance. while at auditions, i felt so motivated and kept pushing myself. the energy in the room was amazing too; people were hyping each other up, saying “ayeee” and “let’s goo!”. it made me feel good. i realized that this is why i loves dance. this is why i’ve stuck with it for so long. i later found out that i made the team and i felt so happy, so grateful...i felt like my hard work indeed paid off...after that i began to train more, and get back into competitions and conventions. dance now is not just a sport, an art, a hobby. it’s now my passion that i am extremely grateful for. my wings have begun to work with me and eventually lifted me from one of the darkest times in my life. thanks bts for doing this :)
Natalie Bondoc that's exactly how sometimes I feel and so many time I ask myself if I want to continue but I just can't let go and I'm happy doing my dream and passion. I'm a dancer too 💜
yeah! totally agree! there is so much more to talk about this song; "Black Swan" in terms of the "BTS" as musicians, singers, dancers, instrumentalists, producers, songwriters... this goes everything in it as a "7"... you can see how well they meticulously made everything. for references.. deep dive... here are legit, genuine, true musicians, dancers, and squad RV for this, and also their RV. (BTS) 1. Classical Musicians React: BTS 'Black Swan (Art Film)' ua-cam.com/video/UAhtwpBDULE/v-deo.html (timestamp for scale degree 7 mentioned - 9:06) 2. [BANGTAN BOMB] BTS 'Black Swan' Art Film Reaction - BTS (방탄소년단) ua-cam.com/video/zR9q5iU-gJU/v-deo.html 3. [BANGTAN BOMB] BTS ‘Black Swan’ MV reaction - BTS (방탄소년단) ua-cam.com/video/LQK7tF1vH2w/v-deo.html
So very true. This song original version and orchestra version moved me beyond my imagination. A lot more people need to hear Black Swan and also watch the performances.
As a musician, this song encapsulates what I feel every time I feel depression, anxiety and doubts about my own ability... It always left me at the brink of tears and let me breathe again, when I think my own love for music is dead. This holds a place so dear in my heart that feels unreal every time it lifts me up from the ground, before my body sinks into a bad depression and it keeps me going to pursue a music career despite the odds against me. _This_ song, is a masterpiece, shining with it's own light, like the moon itself.
I’m a musician too and I relate to you in a very spiritual level. This song express our emotions and our feelings in a very intimate and accurate way, I can feel my own fear of leaving the music expressed rawly in this song, it makes me feel so blue but at the same time it encourages me to work hard and make me feel how much I actually love music. Thanks BTS for making this masterpiece, it really helps us musicians.
Imagine bts performing this version of the song with a large orchestra in the back of them with a spotlight on each of them in a really dark room while they are dancing
The indistinguishable voices in the song show how all of the members are one, this album is about BTS, not just for ARMY but for themselves too. Their love for creating music and art yet their fear for losing such passion is portrayed beautifully. Lets keep on supporting our boys and show love to the dancers. Stay healthy ARMY.
@@vmyhope4683 yeah the way tuned in live performance and over used of backing vocals bs just like those pop sht artist nowadays . this girl is a good dancers yeah i agree but their songs are straight trash
The lyrics really hit me. Whenever someone loses this thing they love so dearly, be it dancing, music, art or even things far from the traditional idea of art such as science and cooking, a piece of them dies and fades away. No matter what method leads to this loss (aging, losing popularity, injuries, financial issues etc), the hurt is the same- still so enormous that one feels swallowed up in a dark hole. And this could happen any second. My interpretation of the message is that knowing the importance of our passion, it is totally understandable that we fear losing it. But we should not stop pursuing our passion, because by doing so, we immediately cause its death, and thus the death of a part of us. Thank you BTS for such insightful lyrics in a beautiful song and thank you MN dancers for depicting this feeling physically and with lots of emotion. Wow, BTS never fails to impress us.
This is how I feel until now, when I worked so hard to become a nurse, got my diploma, and passed the licensure exam but look where I am now. I can't even use my nursing experience here in a foreign country. I have to let go of my passion, and now a caregiver. I'm not saying being a caregiver is a bad thing but my first and last love is being a nurse and it made me depressed that I don't have a way to continuing doing what I love to do (my first death, so to speak). So, yeah, I was crying watching this video and can relate so much.
The song and performance bring tears to my eyes. The emotional struggle of trying to break free then finally embracing the darkness is so moving and the lyrics hurt. The fear the guys feel in the possibility that one day it won't be enough is scary. Another amazing song to add to the list of songs that move me in ways no other artist's music ever has and I don't even speak the native language. Music truly does break all boundaries.
@@YukashiRK yes its completely fine. We support people who don't like their music after all its their choice but we don't like the antis who just hate on bts for no reason
This really speaks, an artist’s passion is their whole life, finding success in that passion and then losing it- that’s a double killer. Absolutely nothing else could hurt more
I _ugly cry_ EVERYTIME I watch this choreography. The _symbology!!!_ , the hurt, the frustration, the fight, the struggle, the lie of freedom aaaaahhhhh I LOVE _everything_ about this MV.
" a dancer dies twice -- once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful" wow this song has such a deep message and seing that in this mv it isn't BTS dancing and namjoon's verse where he says " if this can no longer resonate, no longer make my heart vibrate; then like this may be how I die my first death, But what if the moment is right now," the lyrics are so deep and as an artist, I do understand these feeling where we can easily lose apart of ourself and it can be hard... but that's just my interpretation of it. its truly so beautiful and thank you bts!! be happy army! stream this masterpiece!!!
The first half of the lyrics really got me. As someone who's been struggling with depression for years, when I'm at my lowest, it's truly scary the feeling of falling out of love for the things that used to make you happy. Suddenly, nothing seems to matter and you feel like your whole existence has no purpose. There's just this numbness. Fortunately, the song ends on a high note with a comforting sense of hope. Like Yoongi said in the intro, he's the shadow and the shadow is him. And he won't let it break him.
I mean The fear of losing passion for music by practising nonstop, and becoming obsessed with music (because of fame) its really a big shout out to what bang pd said of treating their artists as humans before as artists, and with what the kpop industry is facing.. (sulli, go hara, jonghyun... and twice that are working nonstop) I think this comeback has the most meaningful meaning.
I'm glad they're communicating this through their music. Some people don't realize they are just people like the rest of us. I'm excited for this comeback. (・ｖ・)
So true, you put it so accurately. It is not money(although that's very good) it's their craft that's important to them.... I have never appreciate any artists like I do these artists and they are still young. I so 💜 them
@@yolodannyiny3263 well (at least from my perspective) many artists start out passionate and love the work they create. They do it for the art, the getting thier voice out,not the fame. The fame is collected along the way. And after a certian point they slowly pump out content just to stay famous,to stay relevant. Especially when they reach BTS's point. (Multimillionaires) The fact that BTS is saying they wish to forever love what they do, produce words of passion and Feeling. It shows that there is more than just "I wanna be famous"(basically the lines Yoongi state in Shadow) they want to continue being in love with music,dance,etc etc. I think this is what the op was saying but again this is my interpretation of the video as well as this comment. I hope this made sense for you as my wording can become confusing (so confusing I confuse my own self half the time😂)
I wish with all of my heart that this wasn't so underrated. Honestly this should have been a title track. The eerily poignant orchestral part, the haunting coreography and the vocals are just heart wrenching. As a violinist I can't help but think that this is my fears given a voice and wings
I cry every time I watch this video. It is terrifying to me, the lyrics talk about a death in everything but body. My biggest fear, to lose all motivation and will to live, to be completely numb and lost. This is their best song, it makes me so afraid, I can only stare and listen to it.
well it would've been the title track for shadow and then the next album was gonna be ego with on, but it got delayed or something like that so they decided to put everything together
During this comeback, we don’t see them as their stage names as we used to. This time they truly show their faces as an actual person and not as what they try to perceive as.
We truly are so lucky to be born on the same generation as BTS, to be alive while they are alive and active so we can witness all of this as it happens... Being able to be their fan is an honor
I have been saying this for a few years. It must be what people felt like when they met Mozart or Beethoven; being on the same planet as these brilliant young men has made me a happier person.
Dear black swan: My immortal queen, you have done so much for bts's discography. One day we will make justice and the world will know how much you shine. Love you forever
I appreciate that BTS and Big Hit promoted this STUNNING dance rendition of Black Swan before their own dance video. It displays their deep respect for art and dance even when it doesn't highlight the boys themselves. Great demonstration of humility. One of the reasons why I adore BTS. Bravo!
@@btsstuffs3058 i like the other version but this is just so much more emotional and expresses the lyrics so well and the choreo depicts the message of the song effortlessly
this isn’t just music. this is art. edit: i know that all music is art, but i really wanted to specify this in this case because, let’s be honest, some music in these past years tbh i don’t even define it music. when you start to care more about making a hit instead of doing it for the love of music, it’s when you lose music and your passion.
sigo sin entender por qué 'black swan' es tan infravalorada siendo una canción increíble que muestra facetas magníficas. literal, de toda la discografía de los chicos, está es como un abrazo al corazón.
I love how BTS did this just for ART and not to be mainstream. Because as you can see, most people won't even understand what kind of masterpiece is this video. This version of Black Swan is another level too. Strings are heavenly. Dancers did such an amazing job to deliver all emotions in this song, i'm really impressed. Contemporary dance is such a hard thing to understand but honestly i am glad that they chose to share this with us. Choreo is literally conveying a whole story. The story of artists who are afraid to lose their passion for art but ironically they know that only thing they have is art itself so they try to accept the fact that they always gonna live with these fears but they'll still continue to do their 'thang'. They're so brave for sharing their dark side with us. I respect them so much. This is beyond from just a song. With Art Film, with song itself, BTS did ART here. BTS is using their power to spread the art around the world. I couldn't be more prouder of them..
Here's a tidbit, string instruments are almost always used for horror film soundtracks. In the film Psycho, the composer exclusively used strings to represent mental strain. Joker also uses this trope as well, using deep cello's in his icnoic bathroom dance scene. I find it appropriate for them to be using these to especially when it comes to the context of the song.
Whenever I think Bts has reached their limits, they will not be able to do better than what they have done. But each time they show me the opposite, they are really talented and touch on all areas. I’m very proud to support them 💜
a year ago today, black swan was released. a song that tackles about an artist's fear of losing passion for doing a thing that once made their hearts race-music. an achingly beautiful masterpiece. and somehow, it deeply resonates with some of us because a few us might've already experienced our own "first death" where we lose our passion to the things we once loved doing. this is really a pure artistry and a proof that bts really values their craft to the point that they're not afraid of talking about their fear of loosing their passion.
i've had my first death and it is really painful. my biggest dream was to be an animator, but due to some circumstances, i wasnt able to pursue it and got into a different path instead, i was so discouraged that im slowly losing passion.... i cant say that i have moved on already because whenever it is brought up or i remember it, i feel like my insides are tearing, very painful, i feel like crying...
@@ai-tn5wd don't give up. Life has a way of moving on and it helps if we can move with it. New things and people will come into your life to inspire you and re awaken your creativity. You are alive and if all your senses are working you will in time respond. You are going through a loss so allow yourself to grieve and feel it and one day you will respond and say you need to feel again and something in you will reach for another beginning...Let it happen and it will come to you. Don't give up...just keep moving forward.... pat
It feels like the shirtless dancer is battling his “shadows”, the dancers in black clothing. Especially at the end where the “shadows” copy his movements, symbolising how he’s conquered them and they no longer control him and the video ends with him soaring above them. The choreography definitely encapsulates the whole message of Shadow.
To me, the dance feels like a version of The Ugly Duckling. I grew up with a book about ballet called Presenting Tanya: The Ugly Duckling and SO many pieces of the choreography are similar. The dancers are his siblings pecking at him, the dancers putting their feet on him are the village people making fun of him, the lazer cage is the ice he has to escape during winter, Etc. I was surprised that they look so similar, but I like it.
Magnae Rose The choreography definitely does give the impression of wanting to conquer your demons, or the negativity in your life. I think that message is very universal and apparent in many other forms of art; in fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if this choreography was an allusion to that.
I'm not army but seriously this is the best BTS song. This version is beautiful, hits u in the soul and u can feel it in ur bones. IS AMAZING! I cried the first time that I hear it.
SAME literally just started listening to BTS like this week but i've had this on replay for like an hour and it makes me feel every emotion possible all at once
I love when Locals Give Opinion after Listening to Thier song instead of Calling Thier Music Trash and Lyrics Useless without even listening to any song 😭💖
@@rxtelll of course! I think even if I had listened to this and not liked it (which I don't because it's fire) I would at least listen to it first and give it the benefit of the doubt always. It's never okay to shit on other's people hard work or interests.
@@funwitharya4429 are you a new ARMY? because you can't just tell people to become an Army , recommending songs is different and Telling people to be an Army is different, hope you understand
The more I listen to this song, the more I feel really touched by it. This is not just a song, it's not a hit, this is art. It tells a story, a message; and it's so deep and true. While other artists care of how to win more fans, more money, more famous; BTS care of not losing their passion for music and for not losing their essent in their message. I love them so much.
Hello, army💜💜 help our very beautiful post on WEVERSE! Hashtag : #Hot_Hearts_RuARMY Author of post: Diahka Don’t distribute our hashtag!! If only in comments under other army's posts!!! Please, support our post with a bomb so that it advances in the trend! Thanks💜💜💜💜
It really feels like your dead when you start to feel like you're losing your passion and when you stop feeling the hope. But you know what? That passion comes back once we overcome the battles within ourselves. And that's the best feeling ever. "I'd rather die than living life without passion." - Jungkook I remember these words from him. He said this during their rookie days. THEY for once lost it and came back having that same passion and HERE IT IS NOW. Their passion that came back made Map Of the Soul.... made these masterpieces telling their story.
@@KeelyJalissa Let's not deny it... they're already singing it to us. They will not write this if they haven't gone through this. I also felt the same. And remember what they shared in 2018? About the pressure and that they talked about disbandment? I feel like it has something to do with that. But you know what's great? The fire and love is still there that's why the didn't give up and came back stronger, which also stated in the middle of the song... they refuse to lose it. Their story will inspire many artists :))
Even Bts is not there in this video but still I can feel all the pain they go through and now they are a strong pillar standing straight and ruling the word with their talents. That is really touching that at last they made their pain as their feathers to fly high in the sky . *I'M CRYING*
BTS has transcended KPOP. They are now not only immersed and experimenting with music of all genres but also, exploring and experimenting with Art of different fields. They're truly redefining what it means to be an 'Artist'. They are bringing forth the styles of great artists like Leonardo Da Vinci, Mozart, Michael Angelo, Beethoven etc., who used to combine, philosophy, music, art and the world around them. Many years down the line, Bangtan Sonyeondan will be known as Pioneers of their era.
I really hope that this version is performed in year end award shows because this version deserves to be heard by other artist.
This is art.
Yes IMAGINE THEM DANCING TO THE INSTRUMENTAL PART🥺
yesss
They always do such beautiful remix of their songs at the end of year awards show, pretty sure they will perform this version :3
if there is end of year award shows :'(
we don’t talk about this enough, this version of black swan, the choreography, the aesthetic, the dancers, the place, this mv is beautiful and deserve more views and recognition!
It is hard to believe that this piece of art has only 37 million views. For a BTS MV is so low. Black Swan is ahead of his time.
That's really true, sad this MV's not recognised much
exactly
I indeed supoort that!!
yeah I like the orchestral ver. more
I personally really adore the orchestral version it gives off a bit more of a sad vibe which makes the message of this song even more clear.
I agree
Yes :')
What is the message?
L
Blinkhere the message is that bts are afraid to lose their love of music, and therefore not able to continue through this path. The message just doesn’t apply to them tho, it can happen to anybody who has a passion for what they do.
the most grammy worthy song i've EVER heard. from the lyrics to the music to the raw PASSION and PAIN that drips from this song. got me feeling some things fr
Grammys are a joke
Grammy is racist , they wouldn’t let Korea band win
LITERALLY ITS THE BEST SONG EVER
you get it
i love both versions of black swan and think they’re both beautiful but the orchestral version hits different
I agree like the orchestra really hits different with black swan
Me too, it's Very perfect
Yeeeeshhh i agree with you, i wish we can get this ver on spotify
@@jennytaehyung9704 q q www
Vc falta em português?
The orchestral version of black Swan is something else
True, others dont see the art
They think it auto tune while
Its as sound had a visual
I can see the lyrics. I can feel every movement with them. I can see every lyric. It's like being able to hear color. Its beautiful
True
yes
Iy really is..
BTS releasing a song about how an artist losing his passion is worse than death in their 7th year in the industry shows how genuine their love for music is. This whole comeback clearly wasn't made with breaking records in mind (even if they did pull out mind-blowing numbers anyway), it was about celebrating art in its many forms. For the making of the album they worked with many different artists, the marching band of 'ON', the choir in 'Friends', and now this dance company. They released 'Black Swan' as a single a month before the album and this was the MV that was released first. I do think that they truly wanted to spotlight these amazing dancers. I also want to highlight something : they released 'ON Kinetic Manifesto' the day of the comeback, and a few days later they released the official MV of 'ON', not caring if it was going to impact the views on the first 'ON' video. And a few days later again they released another video for Black Swan. I want you to understand that this isn't normal, this isn't common to release 3 MVs during comeback week. They also released the 'Shadow' and 'Ego' MVs. They didn't care about the views or money or whatever, they only cared about their work and art. I think that it's quite amazing that they did this knowing that they wouldn't get as many views as usual. It doesn't surprise me though, after years with them I've witnessed many times how passionate they were for music. I'm so proud of them and I'm really learning a lot about music besides them. I just wish more people would recognize that they are far from your typical boy band or even typical artists. They do this out of passion, which is not that common nowadays in an industry run by money, clout and mediaplay. I'm hoping that their music will get the recognition it deserves and that they will also get credited as the amazing songwriters, producers, singers, rappers, dancers that they are.
this comment deserves way more likes
Omgg!!!!💜💜💜
I changed my mind about views in youtube. And I will learn not watch views in mv, and just relax? Ahaha
And when armys said that we should reach 700m(? I dont remember but it was really high) and i was like
I understand that you trying to show your love and etc but relax and enjoy music. We don't need break records, cause we are only one who can break them in the world💜
well said :3
couldn’t have said it better myself 💜
This was one of the most extraordinary moments in BTS' career, and it was game changing. No Kpop group had ever done anything like this, and it was glorious. I miss them and can't wait to see what else they have in store for us when they all get back safely from the military. Black Swan is a classic and this art film and their MV were both wonderful.
2 years and i still think that this song is a unique and incomparable piece in the entire bts discography. black swan is a true masterpiece.
@@jbambo3121 yes but Troye Sivan wrote louder than bombs for bts!!! Indeed both songs are masterpiece
Totally agreed 💯
It’s on SoundCloud tho at least 😅
no frl, i can never get tired of listening to black swan
I am not an army, i just found this video but let me say it: This is a masterpiece. This dance performance gives us such a powerful message and the song is wonderful. Good job to the dancers and BTS.
Thanks for all these appreciation😇
And plz check out their other mv’s too i’m sure you’ll love them too
Gracias la apreciación a bangtan y su trabajo es por lo que estoy tan orgullosa que todo los puedan ver , THANKS
Update: Y'all i think i became army.
@@mila5565 how did you become an army. pls tell us your story ;)))
@@mila5565 welcome to our family😍💜
I still can’t believe BTS musical diversity and their level of artistry. They’re so complex. They don’t treat the music industry as a way of making money, they don’t try to release music just for the sake of releasing. Each song and lyric that is shown in front of their listeners/viewers is so well prepared, picked up with such a meticulous care. You can hear and feel their love for the music.
Discovering their music is such an interesting ride. You don’t get bored at all with their sound and story.
I wish more people could give them a real chance and listen closely to what BTS wants to delivers to the entire world.
Absolutely right... One of the biggest reasons I became an Army
I hope that by ‘BTS’ you meant the whole creative team included. 😊
Well said !
Bighit and bts' artistry👌
Absolutely
this version of black swan is seriously the peak of bts's artistry! this was so surreal and it is still as impactful as ever!
the sea that they wished for is now full of dark waves consuming them except they have the strength and the will to jump and never be dragged again. this song speaks to me on a personal level and I must admit I have been crying all day but in the most cathartic way. if you listen with an open mind and expand yourself to the vast musical catalog of BTS's body of work you will find BTS are truly artists for healing and their attention to detail is remarkable.
can you please explain the song to me I truly dont get it.
I'm trying so hard but i just cant understand it. I know you can put subtitles but i dont know the meaning of the song.
couldn't of said it any better
Brianna Castillo Well, I guess you don’t have a Twitter account, those @RMY$ come and explain every thing and all the theories are there, it’s very helpful for @RMY$! I will try to explain it as short as possible: in the beginning it says a dancer can go trough 2 deaths, the first one being the most painful one and that’s losing the passion for the thing they love the most. In B TS’s case, they talk how they fear of losing passion for music. The center dancer represents the swan,and the dancers in black the shadows. In the first they control him and they torture him, they don’t let him to fly, all the bad thoughts and the passion losing. Then feels like in a cage where again the shadow within fight him and they don’t let him to get free but in the end he menages to escape it! Later he even fights and accepts the shadows, he gets to control them in the end and they help him to fly this time! The swan represents BTS in their music career and how in the end they realizing that music represents them, music is within them, it’s all they have! They fought and accept their shadows allowing them to grow more as artists and continue to do what they love the most, music. I really hope you understand more of it
A totally agree with you well said
@@flori-xs6zy oh i do i just didnt check yet 😂
this isn’t music, it’s art. literal art. and it’s expressed really well with this version. it really expresses their fear for losing their passion in music. most artists would be more worried about their fame, but bts is different, and i find that so inspiring. i have the same fear with both music and acting so i can definitely relate. i thank them so hecking much for doing what they do.
an idiot I think they’re afraid of both. It would be a lie to say that they aren’t
Uhm music is a form of art-
music IS art tho, but I agree this song is perfect
music is a form of art so 👉👈
Music IS art, my friend.
Black Swan is so underrated. For me this is BTS rawest song it’s so beautiful.
I agree
For me it's the best song of 💜BTS
ppl loves sleeping on masterpieces like this
fr this song has the best beat
I get goosebumps whenever i heat this song
100 percent CORRECT
I'm not a dancer, but I can't not to cry everytime i watch this. This performance and song resonate with me a lot more than all people in my life.
It's been SEVEN years and they still put out surprising music that stays with you. I am so proud of you, BTS. Also, the dancers in this art film did an amazing job.
Ashrada
ua-cam.com/video/XJuo6MBVUUY/v-deo.html
@Estela Lopez almost
Yasss
This is the most beautiful thing that BTS has ever released, lyrically, musically, artistically wise , the producing team did an amazing job
unbelievable arent they 💜💜
I always give this video a standing ovation because of how breath taking it is this is the best one yet because me as an artists felt this in my soul😭👏🏻
NAMJIN DADS ma’am/sir we are not blind to realize we are complimenting
What about the dancers
Agreed
No other songs can beat THIS. I feel sorry for people who doesn't understand the magic behind this boy band. They truly one of a kind. Every time I listen to this, I feel some type of way. The dancers have portrayed the emotions so perfectly, the lyrics about the fear of losing passion for music and the song itself is a masterpiece. Now I understand why people think BTS isn't just a typical boy band, they're more than just handsome guys who can sing and dance, wear fancy clothes and colorful hair. This is some real musician stuff here. I hope people understand that BTS are where they are today is not because of their popularity but their love for music and what they do. The only thing their popularity did was to help getting recognized by the world. If only this song was released on the music platforms, this song would probably be the perfect candidate for SOTY.
The Best Comment Award goes to YOU💜
You wrote such a masterpiece! I don't really understand why people always judge the picture before getting deeper. This group has such an insane popularity and loyal, hardworking and uncondicionally loving fans not only for their handsome faces and catchy dances. People must be more respectful and kind to others, because this undeserved hate that they give to those, who becomes a true remedy to millions around the world, is such a useless and unworthy timespending
@@ТимурГалаев-ч1в ikr.... and people refuse to listen to them, acknowledge their work and take them seriously because of the hate that's been surrounded.
spring day says yo
When people say that BTS songs are now boring I listen to this song and I don’t get what their talking about
Let's be honest
BLACK SWAN DESERVE A GRAMMMY
Can’t believe this masterpiece will be 1yr soon, just like yesterday.Edited…. Happy 2yrs to this pure art
1yr ???!!!!! It seems like they uploaded this recently...
@@alexa2262 no, it’s 1yr and 2days now
GEEZ TIme flies
Indeed
It feels like a century ago. Still sad we can’t see them on tour yet.
"I'd rather die than live without passion." -Jungkook
Black Swan is the struggle of losing the passion for music which is their shadow. However, in the end, accepting those shadows and overcoming them makes them fly. The song is so beautiful!
"y'all jungkook is gonna die soon" -Suga
Woah-
Queen is my kink by suga? In what reference?
@@serenelynika he said that as a joke right after jungkook's phrase "i'd rather die than live without passion"
I can't stop thinking about the movie. The swan dies for trying to achieve perfection. I think her last words were "I'm perfect now."
Unpopular opinion - black Swan is one of the bts best song but is very underappreciated as many people don't know this song exist
I agree
it is not an unpopular opinion, everyone agrees that black swan is bts best song (those who disagree are usually tasteless) now if only bh put this version on spotify it would be great
@@lookatthat2438 it's just that this song didn't get much promotions so most people don't know about this song (idk how to explain ):)
@@Rout_fams oh I get it, it would be underhype then, by the company too nnn Title tracks always get the most recognition and properly promote singles like dynamite. Black Swan could have being that song to locals
@@lookatthat2438 yes that's what I mean
the dance is so powerful. MN Dance Company, thank you for giving such a phenomenal performance! It is super not easy and could be dangerous to performance in a venue like this with bear foot. somehow i still see little rocks on the floor. This performance, omg... it translate the message so well. the struggle, the resist, the change. At the end became like the king of the swan. I love it. This is beautiful.
Those people are my dance teachers😂
@@SimplyMisha have they ever talked with you about the performance? Like what it was like for them or what it took to put it together?
The fact that the orchestra version of black swan is not on Spotify is a crime
Aysha Huma the biggest crime
100% true
I know right! I hope Big Hit releases the orchestra version someday. Maybe BTS could perform with this version. Ideally during the MOTS tour because I really want to hear it in a stadium, but I know that's definitely asking for too much lol
RIGHT?! This version hit hard and I fell in love with it and it makes me sad that I can’t listen to it on Apple Music
IKR THE BIGGEST CRIME EVER
I think this “first death” applies to anyone who has lost their passion due to depression or something similar and the fact that BTS is able to capture the feeling of this in a single song is absolutely breathtaking
Roxanne Dare لا تحط ايموجي انها تجمد المشاهدات
Roxanne Dare i made a bs&t version of black swan on my channel !!
100 % agree
Roxanne Dare “dancing” can be applied to any action. It’s really amazing.
PERIOD !!
This is honestly one of the best arrangements. This is just ART
Update: Do y'all imagine watching a performance like MMA 2020 in concert 🥺 I guess I'd die if that ever happens
EXACTLY
Yes
Right!♡
Right
fact!
No, but seriously, watching this again, and I cried. IDK just that I feel this song and performance, is not receiving the love and recognition it deserves. It's a masterpiece. I love it so much. I really do. I always tell my sisters, "Black Swan" is superior! That is just my humblest opinion. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Can't believe this didn't get nominated for a grammy
For real
Those ppl automatically turn deaf and dumb when it comes to BTS or anything highly popular I blv
@@Autumn_613 true
IKR black swan and life goes on deserves grammy nomination in more but those "racists" chose an English song...
@@aarushikishore1417 ON too
This song is better than so many tracks released this year.
This is literally the best song of the year,it hurts me that it didn't get any win in sk or that it's not going to win SOTY...
FACTS
totes!
all bts song is the best ^_^
Let's be honest
BLACK SWAN DESERVE A GRAMMY.
Yes T.T
Nah even better than a Grammy
@@Samisamsam19 yes their is something about this song that make her deserve everything in this world
Yes, BTS deserves a grammy but Grammy doesn't deserve BTS.
Blackswan deserves tons of grammy s
Today marks one year since I discovered BTS, fell down the rabbit hole and became an ARMY. Finding hidden masterpieces like this video makes me really happy, realizing that BTS are 360° artists appreciated in all art fields, from people with different backgrounds and ages, this somehow makes me proud. I'm afraid, I'M IN THIS BANGTANSH*T FOR LIFE!!!!
💜💜💜
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜+💜
This song portrays all the hardships that come with creating art. The fear of reaching a point where ur passion is gone and the moment where u rise from this struggle.
Mind blowing
We found worst than art block : lost of passion and interest
i can definitely relate, i did dance since i was 5 and i slowly lost interest in it even though my biggest dream was to be a professional dancer.i didn’t want to give it up cause it’s what i lived for but i also didn’t want to spend the rest of my life doing something i didn’t have passion for anymore. it truly is devastating having to move on from something you put your whole life and existence into. it’s a very hard choice to make. i bet a lot of people can relate to the song too plus it’s a bop 🤩
@@juno3281 definitely a bop/trap bts know how to keep us wanting more and yes the feeling that ur losing something you love so much and believed to be ur one true calling is scary. This album is going to be legendary
BTS's Upcoming Single "Life Goes On" Will Be Here November 20th!
*'BE' On The Lookout!*
OMG
Okayyy
Release this version of black swan please!!!!!!!!!
hayyyy😳‼️
аа..эээм.. как это понимать а? я сейчас такой скандал учуню!!!!
At first, the black swan was caged with their shadows. Then, they fight back the shadows and start to walk alone. But in the end, the shadows is the one who help the black swan to fly. The message is amazing.
Shalimar Riza
ua-cam.com/video/XJuo6MBVUUY/v-deo.html
It's such an incredible message! It makes me sad to think that a lot of people might watch this and not understand how deep and beautiful its meaning really is! 💜
After watching BTS reaction to Black Swan art film, namjoon said that in the end the swan can't fly free bcs get caught by the shadow. Perspective.
Beautiful
Love this interpretation!
How does BTS have so many amazing, heart wrenching songs? I don't get tired of this. I think 50 years could pass and I'd still be here.
100% true
People ask me why I love listening to BTS’s songs. This is why: I can feel the members emotions through every lyric, every note they sing. Those are their thoughts, what they go through right now. How can I not relate or appreciate this genuineness?
km what i was thinking ty for saying it
YES
Correction: Because they're hot
km same their music is so original and they are going through all of this and decide to put it into their music their music is interesting and intense it’s so addicting.
that is so trueeeeeeeeeeeee
i love them so much for like everything. They are amazing at everything they do and they show us what they feel and express it through their performance💜💜💜💜
Okay but like let’s take a moment to appreciate the dancers. They did amazing and made me feel the meaning of the song deeply
I used to be a dancer but I can't dance anymore because my arthritis makes it too painful and I'm currently getting evaluated for early onset Parkinson's Disease because I shake alot. Black Swan is heartbreaking because they hit the nail on the head, this is exactly what it feels like to not be able to do what made you passionate anymore. My 1st death truly was when I stopped dancing and honestly I don't think my next death will be as heart wrenching as grieving the person I was when I was enveloped in passion and love for dance.
Wishing you massive strength. Sending you light.
I don't know what else to say, except sending all the strength your way
As a dancer, reading this hurt me. I am deeply sorry and wish you all the strength and passion in the world.
I pray for your complete recovery, healing, and health! Lots of love, strength, and light to you!
I wish you nothing but peace, love, and healing moving forward, friend. It isn't quite the same, but due to mental health problems I've been unable to pursue my passions since around my early 20s. So I understand the pain of not being able to be the person I was when I had my passions. I hope we can both heal in time. 💜
For some reason, I really felt the song and the message there. I listened to the song a lot but now it hits me. Losing your thing, how terrifying and empty you feel although you can't do anything about it. I lost interest in my passion when I had my burnout and depression and I feel empty and changed from no longer being able to live it and spend time on it, dedicate my soul to it. It is an excruciating silence in your life....
Hugs 🫂 I hope you ate finding your way back🥰💜
Fact :
This song and art film are the reason why I became a fan since, it triggered me. Those lyrics song made me realise what kind of artist they are. I had never heard something like this before ! Really
Welcome to the fandom!
How's the black hole so far?
Anyways, welcome Fam..
i hope people find them more the way you did, like through learning/seeing what they are as artist and musicians and not by idols who entertain others but not because of their music and talents.
(i mean ofcourse their funny side personalities as individuals and as a group count too but they are much more than that💜)
Artist, idol, musicians, healer, comedians, legends, philosopher,....many more...purple you BTS 💜
welcome baby army!!!
"A dancer dies twice, once when he stops dancing and this death is the most painful." A beautiful and deep message, we must make this comeback the greatest that BTS has made!
@@YoungAlienBoy what?
@@leizrain9087 lmao right... Wth?
Wtf was that😂😂😂
I'm ready!
@@yonahonah1160 Spooky Filmz Ent. Posted a comment so they get views, don't click it if you haven't done so yet 💀
Im not going to lie,i love the orchestral version of black swan alot better then the other one.This version really captures the beauty and sadness of the song,and i really wish they would put this version on spotify.Anyway thanks for listening to my ted talk.
Me too
Me tooo. The feels of this version hits differently.
I'm not gonna lie too. This is really true.
Yeah me too . 😍😍💗💗💗💗💜💜💜💜😭😭😭
We need more nctzen like u
Cant we be friends
It's been over 3 years since this song came out and it still gives me goosebumps. Black Swan is truly such a unique song specific for creators and artists
As a dancer, i for sure can relate to what the dancers have illustrated for us. i’ve hit a point where i lost my passion for dance...i felt like it was this weight which i was forced to carry, and i hated it. after that dance season ended, i stopped competing, and started to not show up to classes to train. at first i felt free like the invisible weight was lifted off of me...but then i felt like i lost a part of me. i felt clueless on what i wanted to do besides studying...i kept debating “do i want to go back to dance” but the thought of “what’s the point if i don’t feel this fire anymore” kept pulling me back. I later went to this show that my friends were performing in, and when i saw them, they relit this fire, this motivation in me. i saw how passionate they are for their craft and that just hit something in me. it pushed me to come back to dance, and start training again. yes it was rough at first, but then i slowly started to enjoy it. this opportunity then opened up for me where i’d be on the dance team for this pro basketball team and i felt like this was my chance. while at auditions, i felt so motivated and kept pushing myself. the energy in the room was amazing too; people were hyping each other up, saying “ayeee” and “let’s goo!”. it made me feel good. i realized that this is why i loves dance. this is why i’ve stuck with it for so long. i later found out that i made the team and i felt so happy, so grateful...i felt like my hard work indeed paid off...after that i began to train more, and get back into competitions and conventions. dance now is not just a sport, an art, a hobby. it’s now my passion that i am extremely grateful for. my wings have begun to work with me and eventually lifted me from one of the darkest times in my life. thanks bts for doing this :)
Voted youtube sensation. ua-cam.com/video/tTsOJRXHtIY/v-deo.html
What a wonderful story! I wish you all the best in fufiling this beautiful passion!! ♥️♥️
Natalie Bondoc that's exactly how sometimes I feel and so many time I ask myself if I want to continue but I just can't let go and I'm happy doing my dream and passion. I'm a dancer too 💜
@Theresa Bui (705TheBui) ua-cam.com/video/Go4uf8SBgQA/v-deo.html
Can you support my channel by subscribing and sharing or the end screen and life of your father?
black swan is just art. its not even a song anymore, its way beyond that
yeah! totally agree! there is so much more to talk about this song; "Black Swan"
in terms of the "BTS" as musicians, singers, dancers, instrumentalists, producers, songwriters...
this goes everything in it as a "7"...
you can see how well they meticulously made everything.
for references.. deep dive...
here are legit, genuine, true musicians, dancers, and squad RV for this,
and also their RV. (BTS)
1. Classical Musicians React: BTS 'Black Swan (Art Film)'
ua-cam.com/video/UAhtwpBDULE/v-deo.html
(timestamp for scale degree 7 mentioned - 9:06)
2. [BANGTAN BOMB] BTS 'Black Swan' Art Film Reaction - BTS (방탄소년단)
ua-cam.com/video/zR9q5iU-gJU/v-deo.html
3. [BANGTAN BOMB] BTS ‘Black Swan’ MV reaction - BTS (방탄소년단)
ua-cam.com/video/LQK7tF1vH2w/v-deo.html
Exactly 😭😭😭😭🔥
True
I agree so much with this. So true omg
THIS
oh man Black Swan deserved better. Black Swan deserved to be treated like Dynamite and Butter were and you can't change my mind
Yeah this song is an absolute masterpiece. Like literally I really feel like this song is the only song that fits that name perfectly
Back Swan is literally my favorite BTS song
truuuuu black swan deserve better
I'm glad that we talk about the song here. Not like nonsense spam comments
So very true. This song original version and orchestra version moved me beyond my imagination. A lot more people need to hear Black Swan and also watch the performances.
Considero que Black Swan es una de las mejores creaciones de BTS, todo es perfecto, la versión de orquesta es MAGISTRAL.
As a musician, this song encapsulates what I feel every time I feel depression, anxiety and doubts about my own ability... It always left me at the brink of tears and let me breathe again, when I think my own love for music is dead.
This holds a place so dear in my heart that feels unreal every time it lifts me up from the ground, before my body sinks into a bad depression and it keeps me going to pursue a music career despite the odds against me.
_This_ song, is a masterpiece, shining with it's own light, like the moon itself.
I teared up with this.
Hug tight for u♡
I’m a musician too and I relate to you in a very spiritual level. This song express our emotions and our feelings in a very intimate and accurate way, I can feel my own fear of leaving the music expressed rawly in this song, it makes me feel so blue but at the same time it encourages me to work hard and make me feel how much I actually love music. Thanks BTS for making this masterpiece, it really helps us musicians.
Does the moon shine with its own light, though? I thought its light was from the sun 😭
@@Kakkorin I saw your channel and their two videos. No matter your decision, I'm rooting for you💜 From a musician to another😊
Imagine bts performing this version of the song with a large orchestra in the back of them with a spotlight on each of them in a really dark room while they are dancing
I genuinely want to see this
I'm not gonna survive this.
That would be the most beautiful performance I would ever see.
I wish they do perform in year end shows
Adnyesha Bari ikr armys are just Str34ming other songs from other years
The indistinguishable voices in the song show how all of the members are one, this album is about BTS, not just for ARMY but for themselves too. Their love for creating music and art yet their fear for losing such passion is portrayed beautifully. Lets keep on supporting our boys and show love to the dancers. Stay healthy ARMY.
indistinguishable voices=auto
also what tf are those voice , worst than those edm sht songs
And the way the song being tuned carefully that feelings are built and message are delivered perfectly.. chef kiss..
I agree.. powerful meaning and great dancers, great song.. I don’t have words..
@@vmyhope4683 yeah the way tuned in live performance and over used of backing vocals bs just like those pop sht artist nowadays . this girl is a good dancers yeah i agree but their songs are straight trash
@@amiranarvaez9985 well this song was no1 trending in our country few days ago . i clicked it then sht on it
The song "Black Swan" is truly a masterpiece forever.
" Not just a song This is an emotion an artists inner voice. "
The lyrics really hit me. Whenever someone loses this thing they love so dearly, be it dancing, music, art or even things far from the traditional idea of art such as science and cooking, a piece of them dies and fades away. No matter what method leads to this loss (aging, losing popularity, injuries, financial issues etc), the hurt is the same- still so enormous that one feels swallowed up in a dark hole. And this could happen any second. My interpretation of the message is that knowing the importance of our passion, it is totally understandable that we fear losing it. But we should not stop pursuing our passion, because by doing so, we immediately cause its death, and thus the death of a part of us.
Thank you BTS for such insightful lyrics in a beautiful song and thank you MN dancers for depicting this feeling physically and with lots of emotion. Wow, BTS never fails to impress us.
I agree. It was a beautiful message
This is how I feel until now, when I worked so hard to become a nurse, got my diploma, and passed the licensure exam but look where I am now. I can't even use my nursing experience here in a foreign country. I have to let go of my passion, and now a caregiver. I'm not saying being a caregiver is a bad thing but my first and last love is being a nurse and it made me depressed that I don't have a way to continuing doing what I love to do (my first death, so to speak). So, yeah, I was crying watching this video and can relate so much.
let's take a moment to also appreciate the dancers; the dance expressed every emotion so clearly and in a way that it delivered the message fully
I agree the facial expressions were excelent and the dance was pure and clean 👌♥️:3
Totally art.
Javeria Tahir
ua-cam.com/video/XJuo6MBVUUY/v-deo.html
Had to comeback to this absolute masterpiece. What was BTS & Bighit on!? They outdid themselves with this one
The song and performance bring tears to my eyes. The emotional struggle of trying to break free then finally embracing the darkness is so moving and the lyrics hurt. The fear the guys feel in the possibility that one day it won't be enough is scary. Another amazing song to add to the list of songs that move me in ways no other artist's music ever has and I don't even speak the native language. Music truly does break all boundaries.
Vanessa Alexandra 🤍🤞🏾
Jungle book
@@MarcelReuling no emoji please
Krai mano BTS é meu pau,uma Br se passando de americana é foda
Brother country Turkey 🇹🇷❤️🇰🇷
🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
After this masterpiece I don't understand how people can hate BTS' music.
They don’t really hate BTS , they just can’t be like them 🤩🤩
people just want every excuse to be xenophobic
I just don’t like they’re music it doesn’t sound that good in my opinion. I have nothing against the seven of them though.
@@YukashiRK yes its completely fine. We support people who don't like their music after all its their choice but we don't like the antis who just hate on bts for no reason
Jealously, periodt
This really speaks, an artist’s passion is their whole life, finding success in that passion and then losing it- that’s a double killer. Absolutely nothing else could hurt more
True
@@محمدالهذيلي-ي3خ ua-cam.com/video/miGsn4AaWlE/v-deo.html
Kimberly Vergara watch my version of black swan + blood sweat & tears on my channel please!
So BTS don’t find passion in music anymore?!
Kimberly Vergara Yes exactly!!! So beautiful!!
I _ugly cry_ EVERYTIME I watch this choreography. The _symbology!!!_ , the hurt, the frustration, the fight, the struggle, the lie of freedom aaaaahhhhh I LOVE _everything_ about this MV.
" a dancer dies twice -- once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful" wow this song has such a deep message and seing that in this mv it isn't BTS dancing and namjoon's verse where he says " if this can no longer resonate, no longer make my heart vibrate; then like this may be how I die my first death, But what if the moment is right now," the lyrics are so deep and as an artist, I do understand these feeling where we can easily lose apart of ourself and it can be hard... but that's just my interpretation of it. its truly so beautiful and thank you bts!! be happy army!
stream this masterpiece!!!
This is so beautiful 💙💜
@@MarcelReuling no entendí ni mergas :v
@@erinoritaimae8285 ua-cam.com/video/miGsn4AaWlE/v-deo.html
Yes the lyric is deep but I love the message they're trying to interpret
I purple u bangtan boys
"BTS's music has no boundaries like language." And all the comments in different languages proves it.
This is the first and last English comment I will find
Bitch that is a huge fact yaaaas💜💜💜
You're right!
Así es!!!
Exactly what i wanted to say
The first half of the lyrics really got me. As someone who's been struggling with depression for years, when I'm at my lowest, it's truly scary the feeling of falling out of love for the things that used to make you happy. Suddenly, nothing seems to matter and you feel like your whole existence has no purpose. There's just this numbness. Fortunately, the song ends on a high note with a comforting sense of hope. Like Yoongi said in the intro, he's the shadow and the shadow is him. And he won't let it break him.
Virtual hug for u ＼(^o^)／
@夏 Thank you! I'm finally getting psychological support, so I'm doing better. 💜
I know how it feel, going through my low point rn and these lyrics just hit so close... and those crying strings in the background...
Awww. Stay strong. 💜💜💜💜💜
Much love and big bear hugs💜AJA AJA FIGHTING😘xx
This is MAJESTIC. This is why BTS is different.
I mean
The fear of losing passion for music by practising nonstop, and becoming obsessed with music (because of fame) its really a big shout out to what bang pd said of treating their artists as humans before as artists, and with what the kpop industry is facing.. (sulli, go hara, jonghyun... and twice that are working nonstop) I think this comeback has the most meaningful meaning.
True. You are a human with passion and feelings that had chosen to express it through art. BTS really is that goat.
Go army we close to 100 County stay strong keep streaming in charts go to genie and kill this chart go army.....
I'm glad they're communicating this through their music. Some people don't realize they are just people like the rest of us. I'm excited for this comeback. (・ｖ・)
the diversity in the comment section shows how bts’ music really reaches everyone, regardless of language or cultural barriers (:
yes hun preach
Yep 💯💯💯
hannah mae
ua-cam.com/video/XJuo6MBVUUY/v-deo.html
*Their voices blend together as one here. This comeback is for them, where they unite together and speak their heart out. Seven is equals to one.*
💯✨👌
@@prastuty2887 :))
#ترتيل 👉🤲
@@__-mu5lf I don't understand sorry..
Yes 🙏❤️❤️ it's awesome
i love the orchestral version and need this on spotify!
The fact that they're scared of losing their passion not their fame says A LOT tbh
What do you mean?
Josedavid Maltos it’s means that their art is more important to them than how successful they are. It’s part of their identity
So true, you put it so accurately. It is not money(although that's very good) it's their craft that's important to them.... I have never appreciate any artists like I do these artists and they are still young. I so 💜 them
@@yolodannyiny3263 well (at least from my perspective) many artists start out passionate and love the work they create. They do it for the art, the getting thier voice out,not the fame. The fame is collected along the way. And after a certian point they slowly pump out content just to stay famous,to stay relevant. Especially when they reach BTS's point. (Multimillionaires) The fact that BTS is saying they wish to forever love what they do, produce words of passion and Feeling. It shows that there is more than just "I wanna be famous"(basically the lines Yoongi state in Shadow) they want to continue being in love with music,dance,etc etc.
I think this is what the op was saying but again this is my interpretation of the video as well as this comment. I hope this made sense for you as my wording can become confusing (so confusing I confuse my own self half the time😂)
@@maymaecat5149 ooooohhhh okay i understand Thank tho
Black Swan is a classic example of "do not judge BTS by their title songs."
Its funny how their best hits are not even their best songs.
Yes 👏 Their b-sides are the créme de la créme of BTS' discography!
Believe me all groups b-sides songs are 100× better than their title track...
Exactly my point why their other MVs rather than DNA and IDOl
Have more views....
Soooo true this one deserve so much
@Hazel coz bts are album artists, every song in the album has meaning and is not just put their to fill a spot
If western artist release this song, they will be swimming with grammy already
The xenophobia I cant-
True which is very sad
Fr
Accurate af
._.
2024 anyone?
what a wild question
저용
Here
Mee
Still here
I wish with all of my heart that this wasn't so underrated. Honestly this should have been a title track. The eerily poignant orchestral part, the haunting coreography and the vocals are just heart wrenching. As a violinist I can't help but think that this is my fears given a voice and wings
YES this shouldve been the original track :\
My fears given a voice and wings that's exactly the way I feel with this song
I cry every time I watch this video. It is terrifying to me, the lyrics talk about a death in everything but body. My biggest fear, to lose all motivation and will to live, to be completely numb and lost. This is their best song, it makes me so afraid, I can only stare and listen to it.
well it would've been the title track for shadow and then the next album was gonna be ego with on, but it got delayed or something like that so they decided to put everything together
@@intivate6813 i believe they meant this version of the song, but you're right
During this comeback, we don’t see them as their stage names as we used to. This time they truly show their faces as an actual person and not as what they try to perceive as.
True
ㅋ
True...
true
So is this the official comeback? Like I’m so confused
We truly are so lucky to be born on the same generation as BTS, to be alive while they are alive and active so we can witness all of this as it happens... Being able to be their fan is an honor
i was saying this to myself too im so happy and proud ♥
indeed it is. these boys are incredible. so proud to be an army since the beginning ❤️
YEAHH! 💜
Indeed! 💜💙
I have been saying this for a few years. It must be what people felt like when they met Mozart or Beethoven; being on the same planet as these brilliant young men has made me a happier person.
Dear black swan:
My immortal queen, you have done so much for bts's discography. One day we will make justice and the world will know how much you shine.
Love you forever
Yes!!!! I'm with you on this!!! She's gonna sit with spring day someday!!!
In some time black swan orchestra will be up there with spring day people will recognise this piece of art
@@Ivnreya totally agree
@@Ivnreya they better it’s amazing 🤩
This
the fact they are using their popularity to give artists a chance at being recognized still makes me emotional
Yeah! I 100% agree!
Me too
Kashaf Hussain They are so genuinely nice.
Me too. I love that they do that!!!💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
one reason I love them
*black swan deserve grammy.*
True
Periodt!!
Nope because it's not English and non English songs are not valid for United Statians
@@andriana7414 I didn't know but still
@@andriana7414 thats kinda unfair
I always come back to this performance when I’m especially saddened by the world to remind me of happier times. Thank you for this!
I appreciate that BTS and Big Hit promoted this STUNNING dance rendition of Black Swan before their own dance video. It displays their deep respect for art and dance even when it doesn't highlight the boys themselves. Great demonstration of humility. One of the reasons why I adore BTS. Bravo!
Exactly!! 💜
KEEP ON $TR@3M/NG BTS - ON! LET'S GET 100M V/3WZ IN 48HRS!
FIGHTING! "TEAMWORK MAKES THE DREAMWORK"!
When its dynamite era but you're still not over this masterpiece
Thank you for the 3k guys 😭😭
this will forever be superior
@@btsstuffs3058 yeah this version just hits differently
Serena wini FRR
@@btsstuffs3058 i like the other version but this is just so much more emotional and expresses the lyrics so well and the choreo depicts the message of the song effortlessly
Serena wini YESSS!! and the instrumentals are 🤩🤩
If this version is not presented at any awards ceremony by the end of the year or some festival I will be sad :(
same here
True
Maybe in the end of the year but yes I sad too :(
I love this version tooo!! They should release this version
JIMIN performed today to this version!
I'll never stop talking what a piece of art this is
this isn’t just music. this is art.
edit: i know that all music is art, but i really wanted to specify this in this case because, let’s be honest, some music in these past years tbh i don’t even define it music. when you start to care more about making a hit instead of doing it for the love of music, it’s when you lose music and your passion.
fact
Yaaaas
music is literally a form of art.
@@iluvhating yessss. i mean every music is an art.
One part of art is music.. tf?
BTS doesn't need Grammy, Grammy needs BTS
Black Swan is pure art, and this is a fact.
Yeah 💜💜💜💜🤝
fact
that's for sure💜🔮💅
Why is this so underrated? it's one of the most beautiful song of BTS
Very aesthetic💜
@We are Armies💜 it deserves more than 1B
I love the song ….it’s beautiful
It's not underrated tho
@@boongi9829 yeahh
sigo sin entender por qué 'black swan' es tan infravalorada siendo una canción increíble que muestra facetas magníficas. literal, de toda la discografía de los chicos, está es como un abrazo al corazón.
I love how BTS did this just for ART and not to be mainstream. Because as you can see, most people won't even understand what kind of masterpiece is this video. This version of Black Swan is another level too. Strings are heavenly. Dancers did such an amazing job to deliver all emotions in this song, i'm really impressed. Contemporary dance is such a hard thing to understand but honestly i am glad that they chose to share this with us. Choreo is literally conveying a whole story. The story of artists who are afraid to lose their passion for art but ironically they know that only thing they have is art itself so they try to accept the fact that they always gonna live with these fears but they'll still continue to do their 'thang'. They're so brave for sharing their dark side with us. I respect them so much. This is beyond from just a song. With Art Film, with song itself, BTS did ART here. BTS is using their power to spread the art around the world. I couldn't be more prouder of them..
Yoon's Piano
ua-cam.com/video/XJuo6MBVUUY/v-deo.html
Here's a tidbit, string instruments are almost always used for horror film soundtracks. In the film Psycho, the composer exclusively used strings to represent mental strain. Joker also uses this trope as well, using deep cello's in his icnoic bathroom dance scene. I find it appropriate for them to be using these to especially when it comes to the context of the song.
Whenever I think Bts has reached their limits, they will not be able to do better than what they have done. But each time they show me the opposite, they are really talented and touch on all areas. I’m very proud to support them 💜
This is so true
No Emojis pleassssssssssssse
@@YoungAlienBoy plz go away
Ikkk💜
@@ann97088 delete the emojis!! They freeze the vi**s
a year ago today, black swan was released. a song that tackles about an artist's fear of losing passion for doing a thing that once made their hearts race-music. an achingly beautiful masterpiece. and somehow, it deeply resonates with some of us because a few us might've already experienced our own "first death" where we lose our passion to the things we once loved doing. this is really a pure artistry and a proof that bts really values their craft to the point that they're not afraid of talking about their fear of loosing their passion.
I can resonate with this. How I am loosing passion for things I once loved doing 😭
right On.....................................pat
That is the best part of BTS
i've had my first death and it is really painful. my biggest dream was to be an animator, but due to some circumstances, i wasnt able to pursue it and got into a different path instead, i was so discouraged that im slowly losing passion.... i cant say that i have moved on already because whenever it is brought up or i remember it, i feel like my insides are tearing, very painful, i feel like crying...
@@ai-tn5wd don't give up. Life has a way of moving on and it helps if we can move with it. New things and people will come into your life to inspire you and re awaken your creativity. You are alive and if all your senses are working you will in time respond. You are going through a loss so allow yourself to grieve and feel it and one day you will respond and say you need to feel again and something in you will reach for another beginning...Let it happen and it will come to you. Don't give up...just keep moving forward.... pat
this version of black swan will always be iconic
It feels like the shirtless dancer is battling his “shadows”, the dancers in black clothing. Especially at the end where the “shadows” copy his movements, symbolising how he’s conquered them and they no longer control him and the video ends with him soaring above them. The choreography definitely encapsulates the whole message of Shadow.
I do saw it like that.. 😢
That's how I exactly explained it Yesss
To me, the dance feels like a version of The Ugly Duckling. I grew up with a book about ballet called Presenting Tanya: The Ugly Duckling and SO many pieces of the choreography are similar. The dancers are his siblings pecking at him, the dancers putting their feet on him are the village people making fun of him, the lazer cage is the ice he has to escape during winter, Etc. I was surprised that they look so similar, but I like it.
Magnae Rose The choreography definitely does give the impression of wanting to conquer your demons, or the negativity in your life. I think that message is very universal and apparent in many other forms of art; in fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if this choreography was an allusion to that.
yes JUST YES
I'm not army but seriously this is the best BTS song. This version is beautiful, hits u in the soul and u can feel it in ur bones. IS AMAZING! I cried the first time that I hear it.
SAME literally just started listening to BTS like this week but i've had this on replay for like an hour and it makes me feel every emotion possible all at once
I love when Locals Give Opinion after Listening to Thier song instead of Calling Thier Music Trash and Lyrics Useless without even listening to any song 😭💖
@@rxtelll of course! I think even if I had listened to this and not liked it (which I don't because it's fire) I would at least listen to it first and give it the benefit of the doubt always. It's never okay to shit on other's people hard work or interests.
If You like this song Then Be ARMY
@@funwitharya4429 are you a new ARMY? because you can't just tell people to become an Army , recommending songs is different and Telling people to be an Army is different, hope you understand
BIGHIT RELEASE THIS VERSION ON SPOTIFY PLEASE
It’s bts hidden gems
Completely unrelated but so is Ddaeng😳
@@eliza3120 really? Officially?
i can’t find it anymore
@@layanmasri4124 look up bts hidden gems on spotify and click the playlist
Never gonna forget that this masterpiece made me be an army
The more I listen to this song, the more I feel really touched by it. This is not just a song, it's not a hit, this is art. It tells a story, a message; and it's so deep and true. While other artists care of how to win more fans, more money, more famous; BTS care of not losing their passion for music and for not losing their essent in their message.
I love them so much.
Hello, army💜💜 help our very beautiful post on WEVERSE! Hashtag : #Hot_Hearts_RuARMY
Author of post: Diahka
Don’t distribute our hashtag!! If only in comments under other army's posts!!! Please, support our post with a bomb so that it advances in the trend! Thanks💜💜💜💜
It really feels like your dead when you start to feel like you're losing your passion and when you stop feeling the hope. But you know what? That passion comes back once we overcome the battles within ourselves. And that's the best feeling ever.
"I'd rather die than living life without passion." - Jungkook
I remember these words from him. He said this during their rookie days.
THEY for once lost it and came back having that same passion and HERE IT IS NOW. Their passion that came back made Map Of the Soul.... made these masterpieces telling their story.
They didn't lose their passion lol
She's Fine I’m gonna crrry ;-;, , I’m so happy they have their passion back enough to produce such an amazing single and soon to be album
@@KeelyJalissa Let's not deny it... they're already singing it to us. They will not write this if they haven't gone through this. I also felt the same. And remember what they shared in 2018? About the pressure and that they talked about disbandment? I feel like it has something to do with that.
But you know what's great? The fire and love is still there that's why the didn't give up and came back stronger, which also stated in the middle of the song... they refuse to lose it. Their story will inspire many artists :))
Even Bts is not there in this video but still I can feel all the pain they go through and now they are a strong pillar standing straight and ruling the word with their talents. That is really touching that at last they made their pain as their feathers to fly high in the sky .
*I'M CRYING*
ua-cam.com/video/Ql05ZX5WqGw/v-deo.html ARMYS NEED TO SEE THIS.
I think this song is special for every dancer. When Black Swan plays, I feel like it's just me and him in the world. It runs through all my veins
BTS has transcended KPOP. They are now not only immersed and experimenting with music of all genres but also, exploring and experimenting with Art of different fields. They're truly redefining what it means to be an 'Artist'. They are bringing forth the styles of great artists like Leonardo Da Vinci, Mozart, Michael Angelo, Beethoven etc., who used to combine, philosophy, music, art and the world around them. Many years down the line, Bangtan Sonyeondan will be known as Pioneers of their era.
Angelina Jamir even your comment gave me some goosebumps! BTS ARE SLOWLY MAKING IT HAPPEN!
I think a lot of credit should go to the genius of Bang PD, Namjoon and other leaders in Big Hit. They are forerunners spearheading this revolution👏👏👏
Well said
It's not that deep.
Please remove the emoji