I’ve been hard on your 41 & 42 rankings but this one was better. No doubt Jesse #1. I loved Cody but his placement is fair. Karla was excellent & I hope to see her play again
Why have Karla higher than Cody. Despite technically going earlier, Cody was way more likely to reach the end, and more likely to win a jury vote too, even if both beat a lot of people. 2nd to 5th is crazy.
@@maxhook9862 natalie and phillip shepard finished 2nd and 3rd in survivor redemption island, that doesn't mean they played well, your placement in the end doesn't mean you are better or worse than the next or the previous boot
@@MorganLefeuvre Cassidy played a good game, anyone who targeted her went home, she managed to play from a disadvantaged position throughout the endgame, which Karla struggled to do, clearly. And besides, who do you care, it’s my opinion?
@@maxhook9862 and I am not saying Cassidy didn't deserve to be in final 3, I mean she had bonds with others, was socially decent I think, was really good in the challenges and managed to vote where the votes were going.... but she honestly added nothing to the strategic point, she never hold a move throughout the season, we never even saw her arguing to defend her spot, it's like she just voted right for her interest but let the others do the job. That's a good strategy to go to the end, not to win it all... While Karla may have been on the out sometimes, made some mistakes, it was because of how big of a threat she was perceived by the others : she played a perfect pre merge game, managed to remain trustworthy and likeable after the merge so that everyone was willing to work with her. Her move at final 10 to rally the vote on James could be seen as idiot but I see here an attempt to lower her threat level and put this threat on other players, and at final 8 she is not left out of the vote, as she blindsides Noelle alongside Cody, Jesse, Cassidy and Gabler. She lost her allies after that, and started to blow her game a little, but she clearly is an aware player, like she was able to see the danger in not voting Sami at final 7... at least she made moves and thought by herself, that's why I think she is a better player than cassidy
That's a pretty good list!
I’ve been hard on your 41 & 42 rankings but this one was better. No doubt Jesse #1. I loved Cody but his placement is fair. Karla was excellent & I hope to see her play again
Why have Karla higher than Cody. Despite technically going earlier, Cody was way more likely to reach the end, and more likely to win a jury vote too, even if both beat a lot of people. 2nd to 5th is crazy.
I still dont get it why Cass didnt win UGH!
Not good enough
She deserved to win. I just wish the jury saw that.
@@emmawebsdale6363 don’t you think the jury knows more than you?
Lmfao, this controversy is so lame. This is the most watered down version of the Aubry vs. Michele debate I've ever seen.
because she's not that good of a player
Id switch cass and karla but the rest is fine
Uh.... Cassidy got carried through the entire game so I feel Karla is at her right place imo
@@MorganLefeuvre and yet Cassidy came second, karla misplayed an idol and was out of the vote from f8
@@maxhook9862 natalie and phillip shepard finished 2nd and 3rd in survivor redemption island, that doesn't mean they played well, your placement in the end doesn't mean you are better or worse than the next or the previous boot
@@MorganLefeuvre Cassidy played a good game, anyone who targeted her went home, she managed to play from a disadvantaged position throughout the endgame, which Karla struggled to do, clearly. And besides, who do you care, it’s my opinion?
@@maxhook9862 and I am not saying Cassidy didn't deserve to be in final 3, I mean she had bonds with others, was socially decent I think, was really good in the challenges and managed to vote where the votes were going.... but she honestly added nothing to the strategic point, she never hold a move throughout the season, we never even saw her arguing to defend her spot, it's like she just voted right for her interest but let the others do the job. That's a good strategy to go to the end, not to win it all...
While Karla may have been on the out sometimes, made some mistakes, it was because of how big of a threat she was perceived by the others : she played a perfect pre merge game, managed to remain trustworthy and likeable after the merge so that everyone was willing to work with her. Her move at final 10 to rally the vote on James could be seen as idiot but I see here an attempt to lower her threat level and put this threat on other players, and at final 8 she is not left out of the vote, as she blindsides Noelle alongside Cody, Jesse, Cassidy and Gabler. She lost her allies after that, and started to blow her game a little, but she clearly is an aware player, like she was able to see the danger in not voting Sami at final 7... at least she made moves and thought by herself, that's why I think she is a better player than cassidy
ok
I’d switch Gabler and Cassidy
why?? Gabler demolished her at ftc.
Sorry owen is worse than everyone but Jeanine here
LOL JEANINE? she played the worst game of any person that has ever made the jury period I have never seen an more awful player.
Who would you have on the list instead? I needed 10 players of course.
@@dinohall2595 Dwight is better socially and strategically, Ryan for outlasting her and Elie. I'd go as far to say Nneka played better