To the untrained ear this was a moving performance for all the different reasons - I respect the views expressed by those more educated - I thank the Omnipresent Lord for UA-cam which has helped to open my eyes, ears but more importantly the locked doors of my mind and thoughts - 🙏
You are missing the point of this, there are two sarangi players, the shabad is farsi, with a Muslim Hindu and sikh has never been done before, it is also difficult to sing and play sarangi at the same time
@@ggsengh I understand the musicality of it and have studied gurbani, all 1430 ang of SGGS with all meters used in the SGGS. I know when meter is forced on poetry. But, I do agree with you that sarangy, being a fretless instrument, is difficult to master. At the same time, when we learn classical music. Its taught with vocals. So, it goes hand in hand.
Whilst I recognise what you're saying there's probably a less douchey way of saying it that doesn't detract form all the positive in this rendition. Non-Sikh ustaad playing a sabd, great student, great tabla etc..
This is really amazing so soulful Ustad ji u r really blessed ...n a true soul u r
Very good
This Shabad was recited by Guru Nanak Patshah ji When HE visited middle east- Meccah, Medina, Baghdad।
Wonderful thank you Sabri Bhai.What classic combination of great music and Amrit Gurbani.
Beautiful...amazingly recited...
I'm listening two years later. But why other Sikhs were unaware. Do u people not love pure kirtan.... Or not bother to understand the persian
To the untrained ear this was a moving performance for all the different reasons - I respect the views expressed by those more educated - I thank the Omnipresent Lord for UA-cam which has helped to open my eyes, ears but more importantly the locked doors of my mind and thoughts - 🙏
Lajawab wahhh wahh
Wonderful presentation.
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕਾ ਖਾਲਸਾ
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕੀ ਫਤਹਿ
Wah wah what a Classical
Wah
Super Duper
Super Class Performance
.
It's a forced tune on a shabad that has very different meter. Amrita kaur from New Zealand sang in better tune and meter.
You are missing the point of this, there are two sarangi players, the shabad is farsi, with a Muslim Hindu and sikh has never been done before, it is also difficult to sing and play sarangi at the same time
@@ggsengh I understand the musicality of it and have studied gurbani, all 1430 ang of SGGS with all meters used in the SGGS. I know when meter is forced on poetry. But, I do agree with you that sarangy, being a fretless instrument, is difficult to master. At the same time, when we learn classical music. Its taught with vocals. So, it goes hand in hand.
Whilst I recognise what you're saying there's probably a less douchey way of saying it that doesn't detract form all the positive in this rendition. Non-Sikh ustaad playing a sabd, great student, great tabla etc..
ua-cam.com/video/cIm67Q9nCY4/v-deo.html
Listen to this
Need not to be critical here....must appreciate the efforts
.