I attended art college in the early 2000's . During figure drawing classes , the professor would instruct us to NOT use lines to outline a figure ( the way this artist does in a lot of his works ) . When doing a painting or drawing of a figure - use varying gradients of shade to create the boundaries of your figures and subjects . When you use lines to define edges of the figure or subject - it gives the appearance of a cartoon . Go back and look at these drawings / paintings again . They would look much more life-like without boundary lines ( they look like a coloring book ) .
Thank you for showing me work by Balthus I haven’t seen before the watercolours were particularly interesting. Balthus remains one of my favourite painters.
Thank you for your lovely comment! I'm glad I could introduce you to new works by Balthus. His watercolours are indeed fascinating. It's wonderful to hear he's one of your favorite painters! 😊
Very interesting diversity of subject matter. His obsession with children and cats may be upsetting to modern viewers, but must be viewed in the context of the innocence that prevailed in the ancient art he drew inspiration from. Also different eras view nudity differently. I am old enough to remember that in the 20th century boys my age were required to swim nude at the YMCA, Boy Scout camping trips, college swim classes. Only gang shower rooms and locker rooms existed in gym class, and the US military. No one thought a thing of it. It was considered perfectly normal.
You bring up an interesting perspective on the context of art and societal norms. Balthus’s work definitely reflects a different time and cultural lens, and it’s important to consider those factors when analyzing art. The evolution of views on nudity and innocence throughout history is fascinating. Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
A true artist whose paintings have to be seen in the context of all his work. It is inconceivable in existing times that we judge when exploitation is our way of life.
@@madjidchouarbi3921 you can't deny its brilliance . Literally every brilliant artist from Mozart to Dali is a self confessed junkie of one sort or another . They simply cannot be "normal" . They have to push boundaries to exact the outcome of their work . , bless them 🙏🙏
Art should provoke. As I am wont to say from time to time: "First consider, then, and only then, criticize." I believe that applies to Balthus' work...
Perhaps art should provoke, although not always necessarily so. The thing with the 'provocation' of Balthus is that yes, it is very beautiful, but also pretty predictable, just another (yawn) male fantasy about pubescent young girls.
You realize what the controversy is about, right? Like Egon Schiele he was depicting young women and girls in a sexually provocative way. He was using girls as his models! Most of Society rejects such perversion.
Relatively unknown outside of art literary circles....& even rarely mentioned/studied in history of art. Seemingly because of the stayed & orthodox morality which duplicitously holds sway in tbe world of aristic appreciation. If art is to visualy explore the human condition, then his work is extreemly valuable if controversial. I personaly rate it as extreemly exciting....as it realy ruffles feathers & sows discomfort where the smug & self assured patronise those artists whose works may profit them most at auction.
Its about being human - a civilized animal. He's also an omnivorous artist. I see everything from Kokoshka to Gris in some figurative pieces as well as still lives and landscapes that evoke Cezanne. This also made me wonder: what if Egon Schiele had lived to 93?
The beauty of the opening flower, of the just ripening fruit, of the awareness of self as more than self, such paintings speak volumes about beauty and about human desire.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment! It's incredible how art can capture such profound moments of beauty and human experience. They remind us of the timeless nature of beauty and desire, and how art can communicate emotions and stories that transcend words.
These are beautiful art actually that show us how different the World was years ago, similar to what other user said. And also other artists walked the same path too. I guess these paintings cannot be exhibited nowadays? Very informative video for art enthusiasts!
Thank you for your kind words! I'm glad you found the video informative and appreciated the historical perspective of the art. You’re right... Thanks again for your thoughtful comment!
Hi there! Thank you for your comment. I’m glad you found some of Balthus’s paintings incredibly beautiful. He was indeed a remarkable artist with a unique vision. If you have any favorite works or thoughts about his art, feel free to share!
@@HarmonyArtNature His most known painting is Thérèse Dreaming (love it) but I also like his still lives very much. His most controversial and more or less pornographic artwork is Guitar Lesson by the way 🙂
20 years ago I saw a painting by Balthus in a Sunday newspaper… I cut it out and took it with me because it was impressive… This video is really cool, but in a way it is a bit frantic, because there is a lot of text and a lot of images… One suggestion: how about separating the images from the text? When narrating, show the transcription of the text on the screen; when you show the images, let the silence speak for itself… Thanks for sharing!
Sure, Balthus' art was exploitative. It certainly could be considered "creepy and pervy" by contemporary standards, especially in the U.S., where sex is used to sell everything, but people are condemned for allowing their gaze to linger for too long. Balthus clearly had a "creepy and pervy" preoccupation with "adolescent sexual awakening" but perhaps the horror and indignation felt by contemporary observers of his art says as much about our discomfort with the subject as it does about him. One role of art, whether it's literature, music, cinema, or visual art is to challenge societies views and ask us to sometimes think about things that make us uncomfortable, and ask us why we are uncomfortable. Balthus made us squirm sometimes with his subject matter, but he made great, although often quite provocative art.
Děkuji za váš podnětný komentář. Umění má skutečně jedinečnou roli v tom, že zpochybňuje společenské názory a nutí nás přemýšlet o našich nepříjemných pocitech. Díla Balthuse vyvolávají silné reakce a kladou důležité otázky ohledně našich vnímání a hranic. I když mohou být jeho témata znepokojivá, zároveň nás vybízejí k zamyšlení nad tím, proč se tak cítíme. Váš pohled přidává cennou hloubku do diskuse o jeho umění.
A painter paints what seems beautiful to him, that's all. The moral elevation of his audience is surely not the concern that guides him in the choice of his subjects.
Thank you! Balthus had a unique way of capturing the beauty and complexity of real life. His art offers a harmonious perspective that resonates with many. I'm glad you enjoyed it! 🎨😊
🌹💙 New Subscriber here! I only recently discovered this great artist! Thank you immensely for your amazing video covering the life of Balthus, and the extra pictures at the end was very nice! 🙏Bright Blessings from the Mojave Desert 🏜️.
Hi and welcome to our subscribers! I'm really glad you discovered this amazing artist and enjoyed the video about Balthus. I'm also happy you appreciated the extra pictures at the end. Sending you greetings and best wishes from the Mojave Desert! 🌞✨
No one ever mentions the faces in his paintings not the people faces but the hidden faces in the trees and curtains and in the floor in the sofas. Pause the video when it shows different paintings and see for yourself.
I'm glad you found it interesting! Balthus is definitely a unique artist with a fascinating body of work. If you have any more questions or need recommendations on other artists, feel free to ask!
@@HarmonyArtNature thank you, I’ll take you up on your nice offer: would you have some suggestions for artists (any age and style) focusing mainly on what we nowadays would define as fantasy and myths?
There is often a character difference between the image of a man's or women's art work conveyed through his or her music, theatre, painting, dance etc. and his or her true inner self. Not with Balthus. His views, feelings, obsessions, thoughts are all there to be admired or detested. Fascinating, controversial personality. I stopped many time by his splendid, imposing traditionally decorated chalet at Rossinière, Switzerland.
You make a great point about the distinction between an artist's public persona and their true self. Balthus was indeed unique in how openly he expressed his thoughts and emotions through his art. His chalet in Rossinière is truly a remarkable place, reflecting his fascinating and controversial nature. Thank you for sharing your insights!
I was not aware of Balthus although I know much about fine art over the centuries. Where can his paintings be found? Are they mostly privately collected??
Thank you for your thoughtful comment! You're absolutely right-cultural attitudes have evolved significantly over the decades, and the differences across countries were even more pronounced. Balthus's work certainly reflects the complexities of his time, inviting us to explore how art can challenge societal norms. It’s fascinating to see how perspectives shift and what that means for contemporary discussions in art.
@@jonathanwetherell3609 exactly which bit is narrow ? Native cultures aren't prudish . Native cultures weren't Catholic until indoctrinated by Whites . Native cultures have more liberated sexual norms . Its Whites that are repressed , no ?
You’re welcome! I’m glad you enjoyed discovering new art pieces. It’s always exciting to explore and experience artworks you haven’t seen before. If you’re interested in more recommendations or have any questions, feel free to ask!
his name is pronounced "BAULL-TOOOS' " as per his own pronunciation at a meeting with a friend of mine in a Paris bookstore. The accent is on the 'TOOOS'
Thank you for sharing that! It's always great to learn the correct pronunciation, especially from someone with firsthand knowledge. We appreciate the insight and will definitely keep that in mind. 😊
Yes his work is difficult. But look at children playing. They don’t know how we might interpret girls sitting with their legs all over the place. They’re children, they are innocent. Some of these paintings push the boundaries definitely, especially the first one shown here, and some are quite awful in this way, but we see things through eyes now trained to spot deviance and we are the ones who’ve lost that childhood freedom and innocence. And we are responsible for our own behaviours, otherwise we’ll have children covered from head to toe, moving stiffly with their emotions constrained, taught from birth it’s their fault if they’re seen as provocative.
Two observations: 1/ In terms of colours, Balthus' figures and locations are like fat Lowerys. 2/ Up to the 20th century, the age of consent for British girls was 12 years. In France, I'm not sure that such concepts as age of consent or incest even existed legally. They have only recently broached these questions, I believe?
Sorry to disagree. I like the authenticity and genuine connection this UA-camr has for his subjects, There's already slickness overkill owing to the tiresome use of robo-voices.
I too, find this narrator's voice to be far more interesting than that of professional voice-over artists. I wouldn't want to hear these words from the same voice that is used to sell me a car or persuade me that a=b in an upbeat baritone American accent at 109 decibels!!! This narration reflects the muted, somber colours in this art. There is no hint of crescendo, nor does the voice ever drop off at the end of any sentence, yet there is still recognizable value and texture to the narrator's voice which is a gentle and original one, and for me, lends his words a sense of honesty. I don't think this would result in the same feeling that I get if it were read by a professional voice-over actor. Their deliveries sound too similar to each other, and they lack the individual personality of the untrained, and most likely the original author of the texts, which I prefer instead, even if it were for no other reason than hearing what the author of their own text, or better, the artist themselves, actually sounds like. For the latter, what could beat that? What would be more exciting?? As you said, "A professional voice-over narrator would make a world of difference, though.". You are right. In my opinion, however, the difference would not be for the better. I am interested in why you think it would, if you care to elucidate, if not, that is fine as well. Thank you, everyone, for your time.
"Whether his work was exploitative or a commentary on the complexities of adolescence and sexuality." The commentary misses out the word GIRLS!!! Certainly a gifted painter. What did his daughters think of him.
This is a very nice portrait of the artist. But it would be respectful to art and europeans in general if you‘d learn how to spell the names of famous european places and artists correctly. This is a little bit disturbing…
Thank you for your feedback! I apologize for any mistakes and appreciate your perspective. Learning is part of the journey, and I’ll strive to improve. Your support and interest in art mean a lot to me! 😊
Very interesting, difficult subjects dealt with. Depends which glasses you have on, from an innocent beauty lense or predatory lense. 🤔 We can see from the comments both. Of courses modern values change those lenses narrative and in time they will likely keep changing. Is nakedness wrong/bad, at what age does that stop, is nakedness predatory or only when via the male gaze. As a middle aged male into amature photography I see very sweet beautiful innocent and potential images in daily life of families and children but dare not capture that beauty because we know a man with a camera is suddenly a predator to be called 'paedo' at any hint of capturing a child in film even clothed. Of courses understandable too as there are predators out there but there is very much a sense of any depiction of any kind of nakedness of child, let alone erotic or not is a troubling issue today that may not have been so much a hundred years ago or would it, has society changed much, are we more conscious than we used to be, maybe less niave, more weary now then years ago. I'm still in two minds, I see beauty in many images but also squirm at others but maybe thats the lense my society created for me. 🤔
When a woman paints perverted pictures with children - people have no criticism. When a man paints the same - then people start criticizing. Double standards and hypocrisy. Why ?.
There’s a great question and one to ponder. Perverse behavior isn’t exclusive to either sex. As well as age. Thought and desire blooms at different times.
But that's a statement about you, not him. The fact that you claim to be a 'professional artist' is simply an attempt to establish the authority of your view over that of - whom? - 'amateur' artists? Non-artists? Casual viewers of Balthus' work?
I've always had somewhat of a discomfort with the preoccupation with pubescence in Balthus's work, yet I understand it in a way and think that's part of the disquiet in otherwise reflective unconscious moments. The sitters and inhabitants in his paintings may be together yet are somehow removed and lost in thought, their own reverie and inner world. Oftentimes there is barely any acknowledgement of anything outside themselves and their own individual involvement(s). It seems they are all metaphors for internal involvements caught awkwardly unaware. The "odd" akimbo of their poses and transitioning distortions only adds to the heightened tension just below the surface. Whatever it is, it's his unique employ and statement which engages the viewer in ways uncommon to usual perceptions. Great/High Art does that.
That is one of the most wonderful and unsettling aspects of his work. The tension in his figures is definitive. Egon Shiele's work also is defined in this way. Bravo!
I’m afraid I think he was treading a very fine line between artist and paedophile, using his talent to mask what I think are some uncomfortable images….wouldn’t get away with it today and I don’t think people would feel buying the art
I understand your perspective. Many people do find Balthus's work troubling, especially considering contemporary views on age and representation. It raises important questions about the boundaries between artistic expression and ethical considerations. Today, there's a much greater awareness of these issues, and the conversation around art and morality has evolved significantly. It's interesting to see how societal values shape our interpretation of art over time. Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
Your comfort or lack thereof with his artwork doesn't constitute proof of anything, other than having an opinion. Nor does the matter of whether a modern artist would "get away with it today" have much bearing. Prevailing thoughts and opinions change from decade to decade and century to century. Both say a lot more about the societal problems and moral hangups of the present time than anything else. ---- Some of his art is definitely more out there than other pieces, in my opinion. The "cover" image for the video is definitely one of them. Many of the other pieces which depict an individual girl or woman could be seen as erotic, but only from the perspective of "male gaze" and with assumption of the artist's intent.
Hi there! Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I can see how some of Balthus’s paintings might be seen as controversial. It’s important to remember that art often sparks different reactions and interpretations. Considering the time period when these works were created might also provide some context. I appreciate your perspective and think it’s valuable to discuss art from different angles.
Da steckt frühkindliche Vergewaltigung, kaum verschlüsselt: eine Gewalt, die man der Öffentlichkeit (eben auch Kindern) nicht unsortiert zumuten sollte, will man nicht Zestörung in Kauf nehmen oder gar absichtlich betreiben.
Es klingt, als ob du über ein sehr ernstes Thema sprichst. Es ist wichtig, solche Themen mit Sensibilität und Bedacht zu behandeln, insbesondere wenn es um Kinder geht. Diskussionen über Gewalt und Missbrauch sollten immer respektvoll und verantwortungsbewusst geführt werden.
@@HarmonyArtNature Eben! Wenn ein Maler, Fotograf oder Filmer seine Traumata (wenn auch unbewusst) veröffentlicht, bleibt das bei besonders verletzlichen Menschen wie Kindern nicht ohne Wirkung: Sie spüren unmittelbar, um was es geht und können es kaum oder gar nicht artikulieren. Filme von z.B. Steven Spielberg sollten auch nicht auf Kinder losgelassen werden! Balthus stellt Kinder in erotisch-lasziven Posen dar. Solche jungen Mädchen als Modelle her zu nehmen, ist schon mehr als obszön..
Art that evokes a strong emotional reaction, whether it’s discomfort, curiosity, or awe, often serves to challenge our perspectives and provoke thought. It’s perfectly valid to feel uneasy about certain pieces; sometimes discomfort can be a powerful tool for reflection and growth. If the artist’s intention is to make you think or feel deeply, then they’ve certainly achieved their goal. Thank you for sharing your honest reaction!
Every single painting in this video was beyond ugly. This includes his landscapes. Colours were all wrong and many faces were distorted. I don’t understand why anyone would have anything positive to say about his work.
FYI: Balthus always painted the children with their mothers attending the session besides him. He didn’t have any relationship with his models other than painting them. The child models came always accompanied by their mothers that attended the whole painting session sitting beside the painter. At the end of it, the mothers got ( very well ) paid by Balthus for the modeling work of the children. This may be disappointing for many of you but it is the truth.
Here's some advice ! DANGER ! DANGER ! STAY AWAY !!!! DO NOT LOOK ! I've been to many galleries and art shows across the world ! NOT ONCE did ANYONE HANDCUFF ME and FORCE me to go to ANY OF them.Some I liked ,Some I grew to like and Some I'm STILL thinking about ! IF YOU don't like some ARTWORK you will know rite away or maybe if ur really courageous before u look at it ! !
Thank you for sharing your perspective! It’s great to hear that you’ve had such diverse experiences with art. I totally agree that everyone’s reaction to artwork is personal and unique. It’s all about exploring and discovering what resonates with you. Art is meant to be experienced in our own way, and sometimes it takes a bit of bravery to step out of our comfort zones. Thanks for the reminder that it’s okay to have different reactions to art!
I'm not against the existence of this video, but the thumbnail is too extreme to be public-facing. This wouldn't be the case for an adult depiction. I know these things are subjective, but you don't want to be in mixed company and have that thumbnail pop up on your algorithm just because you like adult oil paintings. ❤
Ugh! Just bad art. Life's too short to waste a moment of it on this awkward trash. Give real art a chance by consigning Balthus's entire collection to the nearest land-fill!
A French artist. Artists stand apart, and the French artist most of all. Balthus makes me think, therefore he is successful. I don't particularly like all his works, but what does that matter?
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! It's true that Balthus, like many French artists, has a unique ability to provoke thought and emotion. Art isn't always about liking every piece; it's about the impact and the reflection it inspires. Balthus's success lies in making us think and feel.
@@HarmonyArtNature Thank you for keeping art alive and in the minds of people. That's as important as the artist who puts their mind and soul into their work.
The freedom to express parts of the spectrum of existence that exist out of what conservatives deem acceptable or normal is what makes art exciting. Nabokov, Bukowski, Goya, Chapman Brothers etc… even Ellis with American Psycho.
This a superficial overview of an important if controversial artist. There are some ludicrous statements - such as Balthus not being influenced by Modern art movements when he moved to Paris despite his close association with many artists such as Picasso and the Surrealist nd Futurist movements. This is just bad Art History - for instance no mention ofnthe blatantly obvious influence of Cezanne. The AI VoiceOver is obnoxiously bad - please choose one (preferably the correct one) pronunciation of his name.
I'd never heard of him. His painting's colors, seem to me, like photographs shot thru filters. A faded, washed appearance. His subjects seem to reflect his time period when indoor plumbing was not common. A repetitiveness of poses,and an admiration of young feminine beauty don't seem, to me, to reflect eroticism. Sweating indoors in summer shows girls attitudes about their too-hot clothing's inappropriate for summer heat.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! Balthus's unique style does evoke a distinctive mood, often characterized by a faded, almost nostalgic palette. His portrayal of subjects, including their poses and attire, indeed reflects a specific historical and cultural context. It's fascinating how his work invites such varied interpretations. Your perspective on the connection between his art and the era's social conditions is insightful. If you have more questions or want to explore other artists, let us know!
Это важный комментарий. Работы Бальтюса действительно вызывают много споров и дискуссий. Интересно, как искусство может отражать сложные и иногда тревожные темы.
Interesting, only women ,children, female body is beautiful but male interesting muscular. Wish poses were were more structured. What do you suppose he was trying to say? Understand why he is not popular. Not close to being a favorite of mine. But educational.
There is a very interesting film about him, his models and Japanese wife. Very eccentric man with very subtle view about erotica - to modern porn-drowned or puritan world totally incomprehensible.
Hi there! Thanks for your comment. We always strive to pronounce names correctly, and we based our pronunciation on Wikipedia. However, it's possible there might be an error. We appreciate your feedback and would be glad to know the correct pronunciation.
Hi there, as far as I'm aware, the artist was commonly referred to as 'Balthus' pronounced with a hard 'th' as it is pronounced in his full name, Balthazar. So it could sound like Ball-thus if you pronounce the 'a' one way, or Bal-thus if you pronounce the 'a' as in balloon. Hope that's helpful.
@@jonfield2964 Thank you so much for your clarification. I really appreciate your insight into the pronunciation of ‘Balthus.’ It’s always great to get accurate information, and your explanation was very helpful. Thanks again!
It just occurred to me, that I should have mentioned that my pronunciation is that of a native English speaker. A French speaker would possibly make it sound like 'Baltoos' with no hard 'th' and the 'a' pronounced as in 'balloon'.
художники это особенная группа людей с оригинальным взглядом на мир всегда интересно смотреть как они его видят и отражают свое видение в картинах попросил мурзика написать картину с его взглядом на мир он лапой покрутил у своего виска и я догадался что он имел ввиду
но если говорить без юмора весь мир искусства науки литературы хореографии и религии построены на воображении и воплотили его продукты в жизнь человечества жизнь которого очень далека от идеала
Thank you for this video maiking .Long time since I have looked for this artist's name, it has my deep unconscious.
I attended art college in the early 2000's . During figure drawing classes , the professor would instruct us to NOT use lines to outline a figure
( the way this artist does in a lot of his works ) . When doing a painting or drawing of a figure - use varying gradients of shade to create the
boundaries of your figures and subjects . When you use lines to define edges of the figure or subject - it gives the appearance of a cartoon .
Go back and look at these drawings / paintings again . They would look much more life-like without boundary lines ( they look like a coloring book ) .
Thank you for showing me work by Balthus I haven’t seen before the watercolours were particularly interesting. Balthus remains one of my favourite painters.
Thank you for your lovely comment! I'm glad I could introduce you to new works by Balthus. His watercolours are indeed fascinating. It's wonderful to hear he's one of your favorite painters! 😊
Very interesting diversity of subject matter. His obsession with children and cats may be upsetting
to modern viewers, but must be viewed in the context of the innocence that prevailed in the ancient
art he drew inspiration from. Also different eras view nudity differently. I am old enough to remember that in the 20th century boys my age were required to swim nude at the YMCA, Boy Scout camping trips, college swim classes. Only gang shower rooms and locker rooms existed in gym class, and the US military. No one thought a thing of it. It was considered perfectly normal.
You bring up an interesting perspective on the context of art and societal norms. Balthus’s work definitely reflects a different time and cultural lens, and it’s important to consider those factors when analyzing art. The evolution of views on nudity and innocence throughout history is fascinating. Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
@@HarmonyArtNature You are welcome.
No, he was sexually attracted to young girls
I never thought communal showers were perfectly normal when I was at school ! 🥴
Bullshit
Balthus (Baltoose) was one of David Bowie's favourite artists. They lived close to each other in Switzerland.
David Bowie interviewed Balthus. A long and interesting interviews
I love both
I didn't know that. Thanks.
That's hardly surprising in view of his penchant for adolescent girls ...
@@probono3284 did you read that Dylan Jones book
I saw the Tate show as a student and was knocked out by it. It was just so different and powerful.
Art like this is a gift that cant be taught, youhave it or you dont.
I agree , when looking at the dark backgrounds and lit up faces . Oh , so sublime 🙏
I'm in awe of humans when they are artists ❤
A true artist whose paintings have to be seen in the context of all his work. It is inconceivable in existing times that we judge when exploitation is our way of life.
Back to those days, just like nowdays, it wasn't normal to have sex with children. Art isn't an excuse. Those paintings were and still are disgusting.
@@madjidchouarbi3921 you can't deny its brilliance . Literally every brilliant artist from Mozart to Dali is a self confessed junkie of one sort or another . They simply cannot be "normal" . They have to push boundaries to exact the outcome of their work . , bless them 🙏🙏
@@madjidchouarbi3921
Exactly!
And why are we seeing this crap?
@@chateaupig826it's fine to be a junkie, not A child molester!
Art should provoke. As I am wont to say from time to time: "First consider, then, and only then, criticize." I believe that applies to Balthus' work...
Perhaps art should provoke, although not always necessarily so. The thing with the 'provocation' of Balthus is that yes, it is very beautiful, but also pretty predictable, just another (yawn) male fantasy about pubescent young girls.
You realize what the controversy is about, right? Like Egon Schiele he was depicting young women and girls in a sexually provocative way. He was using girls as his models! Most of Society rejects such perversion.
Relatively unknown outside of art literary circles....& even rarely mentioned/studied in history of art.
Seemingly because of the stayed & orthodox morality which duplicitously holds sway in tbe world of aristic appreciation.
If art is to visualy explore the human condition, then his work is extreemly valuable if controversial.
I personaly rate it as extreemly exciting....as it realy ruffles feathers & sows discomfort where the smug & self assured patronise those artists whose works may profit them most at auction.
Its about being human - a civilized animal. He's also an omnivorous artist. I see everything from Kokoshka to Gris in some figurative pieces as well as still lives and landscapes that evoke Cezanne. This also made me wonder: what if Egon Schiele had lived to 93?
Love your perspective.
Well done drawing a connection to Schiele. And Gris, I had not considered it but do now.
Somethings never change. Naked girls and cats rules the internet even in old painting.
ROFLMAOOOOOO Thanks
And? It would seem you had your eyes closed when quite a number of these artworks were shown!
Also lesbians
The beauty of the opening flower, of the just ripening fruit, of the awareness of self as more than self, such paintings speak volumes about beauty and about human desire.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment! It's incredible how art can capture such profound moments of beauty and human experience. They remind us of the timeless nature of beauty and desire, and how art can communicate emotions and stories that transcend words.
Если, как я понимаю, каждый имеет право на свое мнение.... Скажу.... Живопись----уродство..... Большей частью, из предьявленного....
I love it ❤❤❤
Excellent comment
These are beautiful art actually that show us how different the World was years ago, similar to what other user said. And also other artists walked the same path too. I guess these paintings cannot be exhibited nowadays?
Very informative video for art enthusiasts!
Thank you for your kind words! I'm glad you found the video informative and appreciated the historical perspective of the art. You’re right... Thanks again for your thoughtful comment!
some of his paintings are incredible beautiful. For shure he was a great artist.
Hi there! Thank you for your comment. I’m glad you found some of Balthus’s paintings incredibly beautiful. He was indeed a remarkable artist with a unique vision. If you have any favorite works or thoughts about his art, feel free to share!
@@HarmonyArtNature
His most known painting is Thérèse Dreaming (love it) but I also like his still lives very much. His most controversial and more or less pornographic artwork is Guitar Lesson by the way 🙂
20 years ago I saw a painting by Balthus in a Sunday newspaper… I cut it out and took it with me because it was impressive…
This video is really cool, but in a way it is a bit frantic, because there is a lot of text and a lot of images…
One suggestion: how about separating the images from the text?
When narrating, show the transcription of the text on the screen; when you show the images, let the silence speak for itself…
Thanks for sharing!
Sure, Balthus' art was exploitative. It certainly could be considered "creepy and pervy" by contemporary standards, especially in the U.S., where sex is used to sell everything, but people are condemned for allowing their gaze to linger for too long. Balthus clearly had a "creepy and pervy" preoccupation with "adolescent sexual awakening" but perhaps the horror and indignation felt by contemporary observers of his art says as much about our discomfort with the subject as it does about him. One role of art, whether it's literature, music, cinema, or visual art is to challenge societies views and ask us to sometimes think about things that make us uncomfortable, and ask us why we are uncomfortable. Balthus made us squirm sometimes with his subject matter, but he made great, although often quite provocative art.
Děkuji za váš podnětný komentář. Umění má skutečně jedinečnou roli v tom, že zpochybňuje společenské názory a nutí nás přemýšlet o našich nepříjemných pocitech. Díla Balthuse vyvolávají silné reakce a kladou důležité otázky ohledně našich vnímání a hranic. I když mohou být jeho témata znepokojivá, zároveň nás vybízejí k zamyšlení nad tím, proč se tak cítíme. Váš pohled přidává cennou hloubku do diskuse o jeho umění.
I would be interested to know what his relationship was with his models.....
@@scathatch I read he liked to be nude in front of them, as did some of his friends. So we can guess it's a dark and disgusting story.
@andychase7693 🎯
Well said.
A painter paints what seems beautiful to him, that's all. The moral elevation of his audience is surely not the concern that guides him in the choice of his subjects.
Beautiful art that reflects views that are real and harmonious to life
Thank you! Balthus had a unique way of capturing the beauty and complexity of real life. His art offers a harmonious perspective that resonates with many. I'm glad you enjoyed it! 🎨😊
🌹💙 New Subscriber here! I only recently discovered this great artist! Thank you immensely for your amazing video covering the life of Balthus, and the extra pictures at the end was very nice! 🙏Bright Blessings from the Mojave Desert 🏜️.
Hi and welcome to our subscribers! I'm really glad you discovered this amazing artist and enjoyed the video about Balthus. I'm also happy you appreciated the extra pictures at the end. Sending you greetings and best wishes from the Mojave Desert! 🌞✨
Life is beautiful in all its forms. What one makes of it is a personal journey. If it doesnt impact on others , let it be so.
It's not so beautifull for one who's life has been ruined by another when they were young .
No one ever mentions the faces in his paintings not the people faces but the hidden faces in the trees and curtains and in the floor in the sofas. Pause the video when it shows different paintings and see for yourself.
Never heard about him, that was most interesting, thanks for sharing it
I'm glad you found it interesting! Balthus is definitely a unique artist with a fascinating body of work. If you have any more questions or need recommendations on other artists, feel free to ask!
@@HarmonyArtNature thank you, I’ll take you up on your nice offer: would you have some suggestions for artists (any age and style) focusing mainly on what we nowadays would define as fantasy and myths?
There is often a character difference between the image of a man's or women's art work conveyed through his or her music, theatre, painting, dance etc. and his or her true inner self. Not with Balthus. His views, feelings, obsessions, thoughts are all there to be admired or detested. Fascinating, controversial personality. I stopped many time by his splendid, imposing traditionally decorated chalet at Rossinière, Switzerland.
You make a great point about the distinction between an artist's public persona and their true self. Balthus was indeed unique in how openly he expressed his thoughts and emotions through his art. His chalet in Rossinière is truly a remarkable place, reflecting his fascinating and controversial nature. Thank you for sharing your insights!
There's a difference between provocative and porn.
If he were a photographer, he'd have been arrested.
I was not aware of Balthus although I know much about fine art over the centuries. Where can his paintings be found? Are they mostly privately collected??
Two shown here are in The Metropolitan Museum Of Art in NYC. If that helps.
@@josephpetrino1741 thanks!
Attitudes were different 60, 70, 80 years ago. Not better, not worse, different. They varied across different countries far more than now.
Thank you for your thoughtful comment! You're absolutely right-cultural attitudes have evolved significantly over the decades, and the differences across countries were even more pronounced. Balthus's work certainly reflects the complexities of his time, inviting us to explore how art can challenge societal norms. It’s fascinating to see how perspectives shift and what that means for contemporary discussions in art.
@@HarmonyArtNature 19th Cent. England changed so much of our attitudes and shaped them in a way the late Victorians never imagined or intended.
It depends where you lived .
Most native cultures have ALWAYS been liberal . Seems to be Whites that always wax and wain about how they feel
@@chateaupig826 That is a very narrow view point.
@@jonathanwetherell3609 exactly which bit is narrow ? Native cultures aren't prudish . Native cultures weren't Catholic until indoctrinated by Whites . Native cultures have more liberated sexual norms .
Its Whites that are repressed , no ?
thank for so many artpieces, that I have never seen
You’re welcome! I’m glad you enjoyed discovering new art pieces. It’s always exciting to explore and experience artworks you haven’t seen before. If you’re interested in more recommendations or have any questions, feel free to ask!
If he lived and created in this time, he would be censored or even lynched. He was an absolute genius.
we like to think of people in the past as dogmatic and hysterical but it really seems to be at a peak now
It's crazy that this isn't modern art , is so controversial and yet so brilliant ❤❤❤
his name is pronounced "BAULL-TOOOS' " as per his own pronunciation at a meeting with a friend of mine in a Paris bookstore. The accent is on the 'TOOOS'
Thank you for sharing that! It's always great to learn the correct pronunciation, especially from someone with firsthand knowledge. We appreciate the insight and will definitely keep that in mind. 😊
Yes his work is difficult. But look at children playing. They don’t know how we might interpret girls sitting with their legs all over the place. They’re children, they are innocent. Some of these paintings push the boundaries definitely, especially the first one shown here, and some are quite awful in this way, but we see things through eyes now trained to spot deviance and we are the ones who’ve lost that childhood freedom and innocence. And we are responsible for our own behaviours, otherwise we’ll have children covered from head to toe, moving stiffly with their emotions constrained, taught from birth it’s their fault if they’re seen as provocative.
Ok. So the painting of the two girls in this video's thumbnail innocently means what?
Two observations: 1/ In terms of colours, Balthus' figures and locations are like fat Lowerys.
2/ Up to the 20th century, the age of consent for British girls was 12 years. In France, I'm not sure that such concepts as age of consent or incest even existed legally. They have only recently broached these questions, I believe?
Japanese manga have this fascination
It really only became obvious around 10 years ago. Now, they don't even try to hide their pedo fantasies.
There's so much trash on UA-cam now. It's good to see something worth watching.
I think he lost it when he lost the cat. He mentions that cat in many paintings. I guess can’t blame the guy.
I don't think 'highly suggestive pose' adequately describes the young girl in 'The Guitar Lesson'
All artists are weird by nature, otherwise they would not "suffer for their art". He is no more weird than the others.
Except most artists aren't pedophiles.
Great homemade doc, really enjoyed it. A professional voice-over narrator would make a world of difference, though.
Sorry to disagree. I like the authenticity and genuine connection this UA-camr has for his subjects, There's already slickness overkill owing to the tiresome use of robo-voices.
I too, find this narrator's voice to be far more interesting than that of professional voice-over artists. I wouldn't want to hear these words from the same voice that is used to sell me a car or persuade me that a=b in an upbeat baritone American accent
at 109 decibels!!!
This narration reflects the muted, somber colours in this art. There is no hint of crescendo, nor does the voice ever drop off at the end of any sentence, yet there is still recognizable value and texture to the narrator's voice which is a gentle and original one, and for me, lends his words a sense of honesty. I don't think this would result in the same feeling that I get if it were read by a professional voice-over actor. Their deliveries sound too similar to each other, and they lack the individual personality of the untrained, and most likely the original author of the texts, which I prefer instead, even if it were for no other reason than hearing what the author of their own text, or better, the artist themselves, actually sounds like. For the latter, what could beat that? What would be more exciting??
As you said, "A professional voice-over narrator would make a world of difference, though.". You are right. In my opinion, however, the difference would not be for the better. I am interested in why you think it would, if you care to elucidate, if not, that is fine as well. Thank you, everyone, for your time.
Very informative and interesting Thanks 🙏
Thank you so much! I'm glad you found it informative and interesting. Your appreciation means a lot! 🙏😊
Психика художника не здорова.
Но, пейзажи и некоторые ню - великолепны.
100%. Такое писать может только не совсем здоровый человек..с тараканами в голове
"Whether his work was exploitative or a commentary on the complexities of adolescence and sexuality." The commentary misses out the word GIRLS!!! Certainly a gifted painter. What did his daughters think of him.
😅. Dad… you’re such a perv! Eww!
His style is really good
“I like Balthus, at least he is original, everybody else wants to be Picasso” ( Pablo Picasso )
Beautiful, breathtaking, sensual, awwwwwwww
Thank you❤
very good.❤
This is a very nice portrait of the artist. But it would be respectful to art and europeans in general if you‘d learn how to spell the names of famous european places and artists correctly. This is a little bit disturbing…
Thank you for your feedback! I apologize for any mistakes and appreciate your perspective. Learning is part of the journey, and I’ll strive to improve. Your support and interest in art mean a lot to me! 😊
@@HarmonyArtNature Now that’s how a mature person responds to criticism. Thank you.
A bunch of paintings were named incorrectly. Like about six were off by a slide.
Very interesting, difficult subjects dealt with.
Depends which glasses you have on, from an innocent beauty lense or predatory lense. 🤔
We can see from the comments both.
Of courses modern values change those lenses narrative and in time they will likely keep changing.
Is nakedness wrong/bad, at what age does that stop, is nakedness predatory or only when via the male gaze.
As a middle aged male into amature photography I see very sweet beautiful innocent and potential images in daily life of families and children but dare not capture that beauty because we know a man with a camera is suddenly a predator to be called 'paedo' at any hint of capturing a child in film even clothed.
Of courses understandable too as there are predators out there but there is very much a sense of any depiction of any kind of nakedness of child, let alone erotic or not is a troubling issue today that may not have been so much a hundred years ago or would it, has society changed much, are we more conscious than we used to be, maybe less niave, more weary now then years ago.
I'm still in two minds, I see beauty in many images but also squirm at others but maybe thats the lense my society created for me. 🤔
Classically influenced modern sensuality
Colour harmony in his pics + design layout excellent...who cares about controversy.
Fantastico❤
You're welcome! Enjoy the video!
When a woman paints perverted pictures with children - people have no criticism. When a man paints the same - then people start criticizing. Double standards and hypocrisy. Why ?.
There’s a great question and one to ponder. Perverse behavior isn’t exclusive to either sex. As well as age. Thought and desire blooms at different times.
As a professional artist, I dislike his subjects and never understood the odd proportions and weird poses that he produced.
But that's a statement about you, not him. The fact that you claim to be a 'professional artist' is simply an attempt to establish the authority of your view over that of - whom? - 'amateur' artists? Non-artists? Casual viewers of Balthus' work?
I've always had somewhat of a discomfort with the preoccupation with pubescence in Balthus's work, yet I understand it in a way and think that's part of the disquiet in otherwise reflective unconscious moments. The sitters and inhabitants in his paintings may be together yet are somehow removed and lost in thought, their own reverie and inner world. Oftentimes there is barely any acknowledgement of anything outside themselves and their own individual involvement(s). It seems they are all metaphors for internal involvements caught awkwardly unaware. The "odd" akimbo of their poses and transitioning distortions only adds to the heightened tension just below the surface. Whatever it is, it's his unique employ and statement which engages the viewer in ways uncommon to usual perceptions. Great/High Art does that.
That is one of the most wonderful and unsettling aspects of his work. The tension in his figures is definitive. Egon Shiele's work also is defined in this way. Bravo!
@@davidwright8432truth
You realize, of course, that this discomfort comes from within you, that you view this work through the lens of this prejudice?
I’m afraid I think he was treading a very fine line between artist and paedophile, using his talent to mask what I think are some uncomfortable images….wouldn’t get away with it today and I don’t think people would feel buying the art
I understand your perspective. Many people do find Balthus's work troubling, especially considering contemporary views on age and representation. It raises important questions about the boundaries between artistic expression and ethical considerations. Today, there's a much greater awareness of these issues, and the conversation around art and morality has evolved significantly. It's interesting to see how societal values shape our interpretation of art over time. Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
Your comfort or lack thereof with his artwork doesn't constitute proof of anything, other than having an opinion.
Nor does the matter of whether a modern artist would "get away with it today" have much bearing. Prevailing thoughts and opinions change from decade to decade and century to century.
Both say a lot more about the societal problems and moral hangups of the present time than anything else.
----
Some of his art is definitely more out there than other pieces, in my opinion. The "cover" image for the video is definitely one of them.
Many of the other pieces which depict an individual girl or woman could be seen as erotic, but only from the perspective of "male gaze" and with assumption of the artist's intent.
Some of these pictures are paedophilic we will never know if he was
Hi there! Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I can see how some of Balthus’s paintings might be seen as controversial. It’s important to remember that art often sparks different reactions and interpretations. Considering the time period when these works were created might also provide some context. I appreciate your perspective and think it’s valuable to discuss art from different angles.
Da steckt frühkindliche Vergewaltigung, kaum verschlüsselt: eine Gewalt, die man der Öffentlichkeit (eben auch Kindern) nicht unsortiert zumuten sollte, will man nicht Zestörung in Kauf nehmen oder gar absichtlich betreiben.
Es klingt, als ob du über ein sehr ernstes Thema sprichst. Es ist wichtig, solche Themen mit Sensibilität und Bedacht zu behandeln, insbesondere wenn es um Kinder geht. Diskussionen über Gewalt und Missbrauch sollten immer respektvoll und verantwortungsbewusst geführt werden.
@@HarmonyArtNature Eben! Wenn ein Maler, Fotograf oder Filmer seine Traumata (wenn auch unbewusst) veröffentlicht, bleibt das bei besonders verletzlichen Menschen wie Kindern nicht ohne Wirkung: Sie spüren unmittelbar, um was es geht und können es kaum oder gar nicht artikulieren. Filme von z.B. Steven Spielberg sollten auch nicht auf Kinder losgelassen werden!
Balthus stellt Kinder in erotisch-lasziven Posen dar. Solche jungen Mädchen als Modelle her zu nehmen, ist schon mehr als obszön..
Muito bom ❤❤❤❤
Intresting work
Muito Bom!
Muito obrigado! Fico feliz que você tenha gostado!
Yes😊
Much of this man’s art makes me deeply, deeply uncomfortable. But I suppose that’s the idea.
Art that evokes a strong emotional reaction, whether it’s discomfort, curiosity, or awe, often serves to challenge our perspectives and provoke thought. It’s perfectly valid to feel uneasy about certain pieces; sometimes discomfort can be a powerful tool for reflection and growth. If the artist’s intention is to make you think or feel deeply, then they’ve certainly achieved their goal. Thank you for sharing your honest reaction!
That is normal back then.. maybe 😂
@@HarmonyArtNature Except it isn't a perception that needs to be challenged. We're talking about children.
Excellent.
Thank you so much! I’m glad you think so! 😊
Every single painting in this video was beyond ugly. This includes his landscapes. Colours were all wrong and many faces were distorted. I don’t understand why anyone would have anything positive to say about his work.
FYI: Balthus always painted the children with their mothers attending the session besides him. He didn’t have any relationship with his models other than painting them. The child models came always accompanied by their mothers that attended the whole painting session sitting beside the painter. At the end of it, the mothers got ( very well ) paid by Balthus for the modeling work of the children. This may be disappointing for many of you but it is the truth.
great
Thank you so much! 😊
Seems quite obvious .. he was a good painter (and also a kiddy fiddler)
... klasika , perverzita a chazari-alebo naopak .
Here's some advice ! DANGER ! DANGER ! STAY AWAY !!!! DO NOT LOOK ! I've been to many galleries and art shows across the world ! NOT ONCE did ANYONE HANDCUFF ME and FORCE me to go to ANY OF them.Some I liked ,Some I grew to like and Some I'm STILL thinking about ! IF YOU don't like some ARTWORK you will know rite away or maybe if ur really courageous before u look at it ! !
Thank you for sharing your perspective! It’s great to hear that you’ve had such diverse experiences with art. I totally agree that everyone’s reaction to artwork is personal and unique. It’s all about exploring and discovering what resonates with you. Art is meant to be experienced in our own way, and sometimes it takes a bit of bravery to step out of our comfort zones. Thanks for the reminder that it’s okay to have different reactions to art!
I'm not against the existence of this video, but the thumbnail is too extreme to be public-facing. This wouldn't be the case for an adult depiction.
I know these things are subjective, but you don't want to be in mixed company and have that thumbnail pop up on your algorithm just because you like adult oil paintings. ❤
Ugh! Just bad art. Life's too short to waste a moment of it on this awkward trash. Give real art a chance by consigning Balthus's entire collection to the nearest land-fill!
It's not really art, it's just a glimpse of what's on their mind
Art, by definition, is something made. Whether it accords with your sympathies or opinions is irrelevant to its description.
How does that differ from the work of any artist of any time?
By today's standards Balthus is a CHESTER
A French artist. Artists stand apart, and the French artist most of all.
Balthus makes me think, therefore he is successful.
I don't particularly like all his works, but what does that matter?
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! It's true that Balthus, like many French artists, has a unique ability to provoke thought and emotion. Art isn't always about liking every piece; it's about the impact and the reflection it inspires. Balthus's success lies in making us think and feel.
@@HarmonyArtNature Thank you for keeping art alive and in the minds of people.
That's as important as the artist who puts their mind and soul into their work.
Salamat po
Walang anuman! Enjoy sa video!
I never heard of this painter
The freedom to express parts of the spectrum of existence that exist out of what conservatives deem acceptable or normal is what makes art exciting. Nabokov, Bukowski, Goya, Chapman Brothers etc… even Ellis with American Psycho.
Why is Balthus mispronounced throughout?
This a superficial overview of an important if controversial artist. There are some ludicrous statements - such as Balthus not being influenced by Modern art movements when he moved to Paris despite his close association with many artists such as Picasso and the Surrealist nd Futurist movements. This is just bad Art History - for instance no mention ofnthe blatantly obvious influence of Cezanne. The AI VoiceOver is obnoxiously bad - please choose one (preferably the correct one) pronunciation of his name.
3 colors. Green, white, red... Alchemy.... it's simple
Heavy Epstein vibes here. Pass.
I'd never heard of him. His painting's colors, seem to me, like photographs shot thru filters. A faded, washed appearance. His subjects seem to reflect his time period when indoor plumbing was not common. A repetitiveness of poses,and an admiration of young feminine beauty don't seem, to me, to reflect eroticism. Sweating indoors in summer shows girls attitudes about their too-hot clothing's inappropriate for summer heat.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts! Balthus's unique style does evoke a distinctive mood, often characterized by a faded, almost nostalgic palette. His portrayal of subjects, including their poses and attire, indeed reflects a specific historical and cultural context. It's fascinating how his work invites such varied interpretations. Your perspective on the connection between his art and the era's social conditions is insightful. If you have more questions or want to explore other artists, let us know!
Наводит на мысль о педофилии.
Это важный комментарий. Работы Бальтюса действительно вызывают много споров и дискуссий. Интересно, как искусство может отражать сложные и иногда тревожные темы.
当時のアダルト絵画日本は絵画展で裸は18歳未満高校生18歳です学生証見せてダメダメ高校卒業して4月２日大学生サラリーマンになっからそう大学生晴れて大学入学してから３日４月５日入学式４月9日アダルトレンタル土日我慢我慢じっと我慢の子であったやったーアダルト解禁だー
Мёртвых маленьких зверушек он с собою приносил.
Excellent video. The work is extraordinary but (obviously) the subject matter is a bit suss. You have to make your mind if you accept or reject.
Interesting, only women ,children, female body is beautiful but male interesting muscular. Wish poses were were more structured. What do you suppose he was trying to say? Understand why he is not popular. Not close to being a favorite of mine. But educational.
Tell me again how uncle dolf was evil for calling this crap exactly what it is
There is a very interesting film about him, his models and Japanese wife. Very eccentric man with very subtle view about erotica - to modern porn-drowned or puritan world totally incomprehensible.
0:36 thumbnail
Would be nice if the speaker knew how to pronounce French names.
I don't think he was ever known as Ballus as you pronounce it!!!
Hi there! Thanks for your comment. We always strive to pronounce names correctly, and we based our pronunciation on Wikipedia. However, it's possible there might be an error. We appreciate your feedback and would be glad to know the correct pronunciation.
Hi there, as far as I'm aware, the artist was commonly referred to as 'Balthus' pronounced with a hard 'th' as it is pronounced in his full name, Balthazar. So it could sound like Ball-thus if you pronounce the 'a' one way, or Bal-thus if you pronounce the 'a' as in balloon. Hope that's helpful.
@@jonfield2964 Thank you so much for your clarification. I really appreciate your insight into the pronunciation of ‘Balthus.’ It’s always great to get accurate information, and your explanation was very helpful. Thanks again!
It just occurred to me, that I should have mentioned that my pronunciation is that of a native English speaker. A French speaker would possibly make it sound like 'Baltoos' with no hard 'th' and the 'a' pronounced as in 'balloon'.
Body, body.....body..... and what???
Art（芸術）？ ２０世紀末まで、所有しているだけで犯罪者認定される、禁断の幼女ポルノばかりです。
Hentai（変態）の大先輩達でした。
The art is great but disrespectful to lady's
мда..что ж ему бедолаге по ночам снилось..
It's pronounced Baltoose
Got it, thanks for letting me know! I’ll make sure to pronounce it as "Baltoose" from now on.
Мизулиной на вас нет! 😂
Rich people bought his paintings.
Oh just like Hunter Biden’s paintings
художники это особенная группа людей с оригинальным взглядом на мир всегда интересно смотреть как они его видят и отражают свое видение в картинах попросил мурзика написать картину с его взглядом на мир он лапой покрутил у своего виска и я догадался что он имел ввиду
но если говорить без юмора весь мир искусства науки литературы хореографии и религии построены на воображении и воплотили его продукты в жизнь человечества жизнь которого очень далека от идеала
this is ai generated isn't it?