Yeah regardless of what you think of this woman in terms of spirituality or illuminati or whatever, whether you care about her music or not, what people said about her child was not acceptable in anyway shape or form
Girl bye! She's always been protected and hidden. They dragged tf out of MJ, the worse kind, yet he was still true to himself and really loved his fans. Yet he was still very shy. Stop the cap. Homegirl is living with guilt so now she's shut off
@@kittensmitten3287Yes MJ was dragged in the media. But you seem to forget that there was no social media. You seem to have forgotten how everything affected MJ, especially after the child molestation trial. After that MJ became a total recluse. I'm sure he wished he had shut off sooner and protected his peace!
@@damilolabashorun8890 and that's why I am saying y'all are trying to create a big deal out of why Beyonce is like this. She's not going through what MJ went through (who was still a genuine person through everything). Beyonce is a manufactured pop star, who is disingenuous, trying to scam her fans out of more money selling products, not music, products, all while not discussing what she's selling because she's mute. It does not work like that. No one would care if she just did music and went away and stayed mute. Stop trying to sell ppl weird out of the blue products, you expect ppl to buy just because of your celebrity and name. This is why she really gets dragged.
Right?! I don't care to meet any of those people. I don't watch reality tv with celebrities,especially if I enjoy their music. I know that I would not like any of them.
I met Beyoncé three years ago & she was super humble , super nice & very authentic. I do believe she is just old school & the world is too much for her now, she seems to just want to do her job & live a relaxed life directly after
She is very robotic now lol. Which makes sense I guess cause she pulled herself so far away from people outside of her family, that she probably doesnt know how to interact with people outside of her family. When she was younger I think her personality was adorable, it wasn't too try hard imo. But In the early 2000s everyone was getting dragged/talked about. Paparazzi and tabloids went crazy. It wasn't just a beyonce thing. She just dealt with it differently.
yet someone like taylor don’t either. she damn tired. i don’t even care for beyonce like but this lady get called uneducated for the way she talked in the past so why should she talk now. hell she talk more educated than taylor but people don’t get that cause beyonce really is nice from what i see.
because she really is a tryhard and robotic. idk why some people wanna try and make stuff into something its not. its probably the worst thing a person can do as a public figure is try and make up a personality. artists have tried it before and have gone completely crazy. shes one of those people who isn't necessarily shy or quiet. shes too bossy to be all that shy. she doesn't say much cuz people will see how truly obnoxious she is -- nitpicky, controlling, calculating, arrogant, and overly critical but always trying to come off like shes a huge supporter of black people and women. she doesn't show who she is because shes simply not relatable. even when she doesn't talk people find her presence annoying because shes truly irritating. and she cant hide it. you see it in little facial expressions she makes, eyerolls, and other rude gestures. people can try and act like youre a hater or whatever but im just telling you what it is.
@@fartunyep4501 the fact the people complained about her not showing her son. “It’s like she’s hiding him”. Like Ok??? Y’all not related to them people
@@zaire-aniyarobinson2928 nah illuminati won't actually have 100 of videos on you tube about them being illuminati, they'd be behind the scene controlling the government
I’ll never understand how ppl idolize celebrities. I once did as a teen but once I woke up… never again. Look up to someone successful that you actually know.
i feel that. i cant stand beyonce so im not here for that. i do like some other celebs. i like doja cat but im not into everything she does or whatever. and im not gonna freak out and write 2000 messages defending her. maybe a few lol
Teenagers dont get a pass its ok to be a fan but idolize thats still to much cause teenagers need to know its ok to be yourself and not take on a persona these celebrities are characters and to idolize an illusion is mentally disturbing. Cant nobody rock you like YOU ❤❤
I think how the public treated her first successful pregnancy with Blue Ivy is what put the nail in the coffin for Bey. She literally hasn’t never been as open or sociable ever since.
@@god563616 ??? Are you being dead serious??? How do you not feel empathy for a child reviving death threats and racist remarks THE MOMENT she was conceived & then born?? Are you dumb or just lack emotional and social awareness???
I was thinking the same thing. She used to do interviews before that. She hasn’t even been on a talk show since then. But I don’t pity her because all they care about is money
she was going through it making sure everyone felt included to avoid getting cancelled🤣 I hate this era we’re living in ngl cause why that many identifications?🤦🏾♀️😭
I honestly was proud of Doja for creating that boundary. She basically said..."if yo ass ain't here for the art..go" because there are weirdos who feel entitled to celebs personality like we're in HS or some shit
My mom got to meet Beyonce when she came to her old beauty supply. (I have pics) She was amazed by my mom's name and said she'd never forget her. My mom said she was very laid back and down to earth and she loves to laugh. Very different in person.
i had the complete opposite experience. Beyonce was rude to me when i met her. disappointing as i was a big fan at the time and immediately stopped that day. they say never meet ur idols. 😔
I think Beyonce not showing her personality actually works in her favor. It keeps her mysterious and has people always wanting more and being excited if she even says 2 words to her fans. When you’re constantly being plastered it leaves more room for negativity and for people to stop caring about you as much
Also, she is keeping her brand at a high value in my opinion. If she starts talking and sharing opinions she will definitely turn ppl off and it can be something positive she says someone will be offended and I believe Beyonce is a very sensitive person might be too sensitive to mingle on the internet but also believe her not being easily accessible like a Cardi B will have ppl running to her when she do pop out for tours. She doesn’t show personality during a lot of concerts neither and becomes robotic with few human moments here and there. I believe it’s a wall of protection too.
Cardi B is a monster. Drugging men and getting away with it because people find her illiteracy endearing. Its the selective outfage for me. Smh She has no place in a conversation about Beyonce. @@SSR-Khaleesi
Beyoncé wants to monetize her talents not her life and I’m not mad at it. I think it’s smart because u get cancelled for your opinions, lifestyle choices,etc. Stay 🤐 Bey lol.
Exactly! Makes me think of that moment when destiny’s child went to the UK and interviewers asked her about foot and mouth disease. Like what? 😂 She just wanted to talk about their music lol.
@@foreverblessed6443 fenty is stugguling right know and savagexfenty is closer to bankrupcy. Celeb brand are not there to be a forever. The only brand of celeb with logevity, is the Row, and only because the twins retired from holiwood.
If I were her, I wouldn't either. After y'all bullied my kid, made fun of my southern accent, and said I'm illiterate, I don't blame her. I love it when celebrities like Beyoncé, Rihanna, J Cole, Kendrick Lamar, Ciara, and Russell don't use social media and just release their music. However, I miss Beyoncé because I miss seeing her in interviews, doing TV performances, and attending events. But I still like Beyoncé.
It's not so much her "southern accent" but rather the fact that she just simply doesn't speak eloquently or even in a feminine manner. Just keep that real. Kelly and Beyoncé have similar cadence but Kelly still sounds lovely. No shade. I love Beyonce but again, keep it 100... She sounds like a uneducated dude when she speaks lol
Some people, like myself, are kind of socially awkward and self conscious. I may come across as "standoffish", or "funny acting " to people, but not at all! Im just awkward 😂🤷🏽♀️
I'm mad this is your first time hearing this lol, it was a BIG DEAL... once he was called out the people he bullied came forward and then his family went in on THEM.. it was a wild time for sure lol
If she overly exposed herself on social media like other celebs she would be criticized. She decides to keep to herself, she’s still criticized. There’s no winning for her with the people who (with no good reason) dislike her.
She's going to get criticized regardless. Beyonce think she is too good and up there for y'all. Nothing wrong with her interacting every now and again. In a real way.
@@heylacy3563 She can't. Whenever someone accuses someone of being Bougie, uppity, or "feeling to good for others", they are jealous and use these baseless terms to justify their own feelings of inadequacy.
@@TROYCETV I think about that every time I hear people talk down on her… we were there for a long time, not like today where it’s “hi & bye”… those girls were really nice & im talking about Beyoncé Kelly & Michelle. So Lange was there too… Barton colosseum Little Rock Arkansascant remember the year. -- love your channel Troyce, thanks for the reply!
It's soo weird and I don't want to be around those that act like that it's ridiculous! Someone literally got mad at me ans called me jealous because I made a statement that in my opinion, Bey looks dead inside and emotionless like Troyce was saying in this video 😂 she just looks off to me like the lights are on but no one is home 🤷🏽♀️
Beyoncé is what celebrities were to us growing up in the early 2000’s . We knew nothing about their personal lives except what they wanted us to know in interviews or unless a scandal came out on TMZ or in magazines.
@@ronewithu Absolutely . The point is , we couldn’t get on social media and see one of the biggest stars at the time crashing out. I miss those days 😂. What about you ?
@@staciegreene2262 But back then there was plenty of artists “crashing out” in the media. People didn’t notice because the word about drama in the entertainment industry didn’t get around as fast as it’s getting around now.
@@ronewithu absolutely . I agree !! I never said the crash outs weren’t occurring , but as you said, it didnt reach us as much as it does now. We can literally see the crash outs in real time. I got online today , the FIRST thing I seen was Cardi and offset going at it 😂. Like wtf 🥴
So true! I’m around the same age as her (I’m 41) and we’re at an awkward timeframe because we either resisted social media all together OR jumped in head first… for generations younger than about 35, it’s all they have ever known so it’s weird to them if their favorite artist doesn’t post ALL the details of their personal lives
Nothing wrong with interacting with your fans/supporters but the way people dragged and made fun of Baby Blue and her hair was evil and disgusting. No wonder she stopped showing her personality. 🤷♀️Stuff just happens for a reason. Sad how things turned out. I remember how full of life she was in the 2000s.
Right. And people still look for anything bad to say about her. Like you not obligated to like anybody, but stop trying to find any negative thing to tie to them. It’s been over 20yrs for her career. MOVE ON.
The white dude told her “only your autograph” … Beyoncé rolled her eyes and slid that book over so fast like don’t you ever disrespect my group members… 😂
Completely agree with being mean as a defense mechanism. I’ve noticed that I do this. I’m on the quiet and shy side and get called stand-offish for it. It’s literally just me protecting my peace and I understand why some celebrities are like that
I went to Welch Middle school with Beyonce and Kelly. I can remember her Dad pulling them out of school for auditions and stuff like that. Her whole life has been about her looks and talent. She probably doesn’t know much of anything else. Yes, she has a personality, but she doesn’t have the real life experiences that her fans do. In short, she simply can’t relate. Imagine if you never had normal school experiences, college, work, friends, etc. of course there would be a void. Not excusing the fact that she only attempts to connect when she wants to make a profit, but just expressing why I feel she can’t really connect authentically.
She said she killed the girl on Cowboy Carter and she likes to “expose/express” her life in her music so that was a confession. People believed lemonade but not this?
No cuz I remember everyone was going in on her pregnant belly, claiming it was fake, and criticizing blue ivys hair. I would’ve disconnect from the internet as well…..
So what exactly happened to her stomach in that video? Since when do pregnancy belly’s fold over?? The question is why was she wearing a prosthetic belly or padding her stomach?
@@AstralWRLDsilence…anyone who has had a well pregnant belly knows it doesn’t fold like that. Knock it off. Y’all so busy glazing people that aren’t thinking about you, you can’t even believe your own eyes. I was pregnant at the same time. My belly damn sure didn’t fold. Go sit down.
@@AnimeLuffyFanthis is what they’re talking about. The woman bothers NOBODY. All we know of her is that she loves her family and works her ass off. But then we have you in here with goofy shit talking about “sHE pRoBaLY IN tHe TaPeS!!!”
Yall judge her pregnancy, her children, her husband, her friends, her parents, her hair, her breath (whether YOU'VE ever smelt it or not), her decisions, her mental health, her character... why would she want to extend herself? 🤷🏾♀️
Ppl who are in touch w reality don’t feel like celebrities owe them anything. I’m perfectly fine w them making music and going on abt their day. I feel we know too much abt complete strangers.
Exactly!!! Exactly! Our job is to do one thing and one thing only, consume and appreciate their art and live them alone. and always remember that they are HUMAN BEINGS! and let's just be honest, we don't know these people; they are strangers!
we need to stop thinking we know these people based on what they post, because we dont. Beyoncé being burned by the media so thats why she retreated into her world and closed the door lol, I dont blame her. I dont know her, nor do I want to. Love her music
Are people forgetting how the entire world was literally bullying, dragging and saying the worst things about Blue Ivy and how she looked as a LITERAL baby?!?! Especially when it came to Blue’s hair and nose. It’s sickening she was a baby and it showed the colorism, featurism, and texturism they have within themselves. It’s saddening that most of the hate came from the black community, it gave a lot of self hate.. I don’t blame Beyoncé and how she carries herself when it comes to the media, the industry and people in it along with the “fans”. She deserves all the privacy she wants. The industry drained the fucking life out of Beyoncé.
@TheeJayMac0214 /part/ of it is just that she tries to keep her face perfectly controlled to try not to show wrinkles. EVERY. SINGLE. IMAGE. SHE. RELEASES. IS. A. BODY. CHECK.
Doja cat had valid points on the 50/50, celebrities are celebrated for outstanding talent. People need to chill and stop worshipping them so much. Its insane at this point
@@CalIrvin-ks3iv “Pick her”. In my experience, a lot of explosive entertainers are quite subdued when they aren’t performing. They’re actually introverts who can turn it on when they hit the stage. When I see a personality like that acting super animated in a post or interview, it gives off thirsty “pick me” energy. Beyoncé’s subdued presentation makes sense to me.
Beyoncé was more present in the media in the early 2000s and when her career had just blossomed and I feel like people were twisting her words trying to get her into drama, so she just stopped talking all together
This! I’ve said Beyonce pushed herself into the corner not just by being quiet but by pushing that Queen like regal- goddess image. Literally in Bow down she’s dressed like a queen & telling people to bow down. Her lemonade era she portrayed herself as an african deity. Her performance in that gold dress while pregnant with the twins and a crown on her head while people dance around her on the table like she’s being worshipped. She pushed that goddess like image & that’s why people don’t treat her as human anymore & will observe her under a microscope waiting to see if the “queen” will slip up.
I’m glad I’m someone who doesn’t put celebrities on a pedestal or gets some strange obsession with them. I did that in my high school days but as an adult, I grew out of that. Outside of their music, movie, or show, I couldn’t honestly care less about them. They’re not paying my bills or supporting me through life. They’re just entertainment. That’s it, that’s all.
She is a Virgo we are private folks for the most part. Its hard when we are self are over critical of ourselves so when others chime it its flustering so its better to play the mysterious roll unless you are close enough to us for us to share ourselves. I can only imagine being at her level of stardom how much she has to hold herself in.
I met Beyoncé years ago at the Houston rodeo. She was nice and professional imo…. Everything she would say got ridiculed back then so I think it was strategic for her to not do as many interviews and only do magazine interviews mostly.❤
People are shocked that a legend doesn’t want to be on social media. They feel entitled to relate to her because her talent isn’t relatable. No one else can emanate that, it makes them furious. All these other celebrities have been on social media basically saying “I’m just like you!” and going on rants on twitter to diminish their reputation SMH. Y’all need to wake up and realize she’s not attainable in any sense of the word and thats ok, she shouldn’t be. Real icons don’t need to act that way.
@@ladynicole9151 That’s ok from her because her “talent” is relatable! She doesn’t sing good live. She doesn’t dance well either, a lot like Taylor Swift. You can build a brand on being just OK in a deeper sense while also being digestible to a general audience.
@ladynicole9151 People who make good art do make the world a better place. Also not every product is for every body. Rihanna sells the cool factor, aesthetic and personality. She has to come off as "down to earth" because that's what she is selling. Beyonce is selling music and performance, her personality comes through the performance those who pay for the tickets and listen to the music experience it then. There is no reason she should give the product out for free when it's meant for a limited audience.
People also forget how she was scrutinized and blamed for dismemberment of Destiny’s Child. She went through a deep depression. I don’t think she owes us anything. She has a personality but she is picky abt who she shows it to.
The same reason why Rihanna won’t release another album lol. They was talking about her performance and singing on one of her tours. She hasn’t dropped an album since
I'm so happy you made this video because I'm tired of ppl NOT managing their expectations and having parasosical relationships with ppl they DO NOT KNOW..like wtf??
They said my girl was country, and uneducated! Mind u Beyoncé is one of the only prima Donna’s of her generation that still hold that celebrity allure/mystique.
I remember people used to make fun of her Texas accent saying she sounds dumb and uneducated not understanding that's just how she talks I mean Britney Spears always had a very deep Southern accent and nobody said anything about her sounding stupid
@@Model_Roe im from texas. im from Houston. she doesn't represent ANY accent from where she group up! so no she did sound dumb and uneducated and for what? cuz she grew up in a damn affluent neighborhood! also wtf are you talking about. did you even follow britney spears? THEY ALWAYS attacked the absolute fk out that girl. they said britney was trashy and clowned her for constantly being seen eating nothing but junk food all the time, they got onto her about her choice of clothes all the time claiming she gave off trailer park vibes. lol where were you?? they absolutely made her out to be the epitome of uneducated trashy white America.
@@mynameisstacey6217 thats beyonce beyonce was faking the whole time. lol why do people not catch onto basic sht. beyonce STOLE kelly rowlands accent and the people's accent who grew up in the wards like KELLY did, not beyonce. stuff be right in front of peoples faces and its downright weird how they dont get it
She still has a personality. U can see when she’s on stage and in her documentaries, she just stays out the public eye when she doesn’t have to be and I don’t blame her at all. The public is cruel asf. I wouldn’t talk to us either if I had the choice 😂
@@TamiaLeslie-ix5qn dont you hate that? when mfs know damn well they dont study anything other than whats being said in a popular environment. lol its so ridiculous. they parrot it over and over again and some still dont even bother to know what they're saying.
Have you ever had a situation at work were you thought you were VERY cool with your colleagues but then you discovered they were speaking poorly about you and/or the people you care about? There is no point in confronting them and you can't leave your job. Plus, you LIKE the work. So, you adjust. You're never mean, you just talk and emote less. You share less. You dedicate yourself to the work instead. You pour your kindness and hope into the work product. As my dad once told me when giving me advice about working with unkind people: , 'Work is for colleagues, not friends. Learn the difference.' Similarly, millions of people sat here and spoke poorly of this woman while she was a first time mother, after child loss. Said she was never pregnant (not that there's even anything wrong with surrogacy, but still). If that wasn't bad enough, folks disrespected the actual baby. But as she's always told us, she loves to sing. And she needs the audience, just like we need her. So, it looks like she's taken my dad's advice; we're no longer friends, we're just colleagues; she learned the difference. And I her response is most appropriate. I hope she keeps this boundary up indefinitely.
The video of Beyonce interviewing Aaliyah in 2000 makes me so sad yet so happy. Sad she’s not like this anymore in public & happy that she used to be and that we can go back in the time and remember the old her.
@ynstulluhhh9852 Now show me where that's a FACT and not something u heard from somebody nobody knows. That's YOUR narrative because YOU don't like her... NOT a FACT.
The issue is people are obsessed with Celebritiy. They really think they are getting to know a complete stranger that has no clue who they are…….because they are on TV or the internet. It doesn’t matter what personality or lack thereof that Beyoncé shows. The audience she attracts is mostly delusional.
It's because she is so used to people making stuff up to make her upset. So she doesn't know if it's true or not. But when it came out that it was true, she left the relationship.
_I’m old enough to remember that 106&Park had to address the fans/public for attacking Bey/Blue Ivy’s hair. Everyone was saying that Bey didn’t know how to do Blue’s hair, and that she shouldn’t let her walk around with “kinky”, unkempt hair. Truthfully, it was her own community going in on her and her child that was the final straw._
Kelly was very patient! She stood there while they embarrassed her. Where was her bodyguard and team? She looked scared and lost. I wonder why she didn't walk out or was she too frighten to do so?
She’s doing the right thing, though. Cause a lot of these girls get online and I end up not liking them anymore when I coulda just enjoyed the music. Now you lost a fan cause your personality sucks.
Yuppp me with Nicki Minaj. Her personality has gotten horrid and now it turns me off supporting her tours and music when I would’ve originally since I grew up a fan
We lose ourselves if we hide it away for too long. Often, it tries to reignite, but it gets snuffed out in fear again. People can be cruel. This industry is really nasty.
When she showed her personality she was criticized and called stupid (ahem… Wendy 👀) So, I really don’t blame her in wanting to keep her life to herself.
I definitely wouldn’t call her “stupid” but she’s definitely not a “cerebral” woman🥴 I don’t mean any harm, her gift from the Most High is performing, singing, dancing… put it this way, if I never see her attempting to act, I would be perfectly fine with that🤷🏽♀️ The speech impediment is clear but “fans” don’t want to admit it.. and it’s not a Texas country accent because I’m from the south as well and we know how to speak clearly
Well the first one, the guy said no only YOU and Bey was like nah... we're a GROUP so we're all gonna sign😅. I loved that moment and didn't think it was awkward at all 🤷🏾♀️
@@NewbiWays2025her and Jay z have been in therapy for years so I bet she’s gone to therapy herself and also she’s like one with her mother so I bet she does have someone to talk to
@@MiR-bp5vx her parents sold and groomed her for the industry...she don't have a say...if that's the case...why her mother let her married JayZ jus saying 🤨🤔
@@NewbiWays2025 lmao you need to go get your head checked. She was never sold her parents protected her while helping her achieve her dream. And she married Jay z when she was almost 30 so that’s a grown woman and I don’t think her mother can tell her who to marry if it’s not some weird creep
If I was her I wouldn't share my life either. Shes an artist. She consistently puts out music. Thats all she owes to her fans. ****chileee that fur bs with kelly was a hot mess.
This video, wow! took me a couple of years to realise not everyone deserves access to you or your kindness, love how you broke it down because the minute I opened myself up to everyone, everything I worked for crumbled and fell apart
Yea people treat celeb culture like these celebrities are gods. We don't owe them anything and they don't owe us anything besides not harming one another. Beyonce is out of touch but that's what rich famous people will always be like sadly. Even nonfamous people are out of touch so it all clashes.
Right. The fans don't owe these celebrities a lavish lifestyle, money, support of any kind or fame. You (fans), CHOOSE to be part of this bizarre culture by supporting these strangers who don't owe you their kindness, openness, friendship. or blue checks. I 100% agree with Troyce and Doja. I stopped celebrity worshipping years ago. It didn't benefit me, and I realized these celebrities don't give a sh*t about their fans AT ALL! They are using y'all for their own needs.... for fame and wealth. until fans comes to Jesus about this problem and start investing more in enriching their own lives and leave these celebrities alone, then this weird celebrity culture /parasocial relationship will never end.
@@Jsarmy87124 whoever the “we” includes need to go outside and do something productive. None of this stuff matters, and paying a celeb’s “rent” is a choice.
when i was a preteen/ teenager before social media and gossip blogs there were message boards and people used to tear beyonce up calling her fat when she was slim thick talking about her accent.. talking about she her outfits talking about her hair. beyonce wasn't always the beyonce she is now she used to get trolled and bullied real bad. i remember when she did that in the club remix and everybody was like oh no she didnt! now if would be insane to even think beyonce would be on a remix. i came up in the early destinys child days i was about 12 13 in 1999.
I don’t think Tyla was rude asking somebody to hold her award. She asked politely and those awards are actually heavy. Cardi B has done the samething. She prob just wanted to focus on her speech.
I’m less than a minute in but so glad you’re speaking on this because I thought this too when people recently started saying she’s forcing being silly to relate and its cringe when no…she’s BEEN silly this IS part of her personality! She may have turned it off to the public and now showing it again but this is not new! If they saw “7/11” or that “Feeling Myself” video she did with Nicki Minaj she was being silly in those videos too so its not a surprise she can be silly! smh 💯
@@damilolabashorun8890 Exactly 😩 I just figured if they didn’t see all that they ATLEAST saw those 2 videos even if not following her closely or fans fr. You’re right its all kinds of footage especially as far back as her Destiny’s Child days being even more silly with Kelly and them so it’s definitely selective amnesia, too young, or just determined to not like her so finding any reason to hate smh.
For the Doja situation in my opinion, it was the way she handled it. Some may disagree, but while I agree that boundaries do exist, it was the way she handled it that was off putting for me. It's just not what happens to you, but it's also how you deal with tough situations. Two wrongs don't make a right.
Samuel L jackson put his award on the ground during his speech cause he said the award is HEAVY! And olivia rodrigo also passed her award to someone cause she said it's HEAVY! I think people just want a reason to hate Tyla cause i never truly see the girl do anything worth disliking her.
I agree with everything you said. Doja is a good example too. I don’t always agree with her responses but she’s still human first she’s one of the only ppl in our generation that has no problem standing up for what she believes in I’m just mainly concerned about Bey cus it’s like you can tell she’s disassociating 80% of the time it’s all in her tone and face it’s crazy
She doesn't do interviews because their is so much controversy around her and she cannot handle those questions. She's not equipped IMO. From the drummer calling her a witch, stepping on bandmates spotlight get where she is, taking Amerie's whole image, elevator fights,, stealing songs, not paying writers enough, Jay Z controversy...Beyonce can't handle that, and honestly, if she does not have to, it is *smart* to just avoid it altogether.
@TheArtofBeingReacts your probably right. It goes back to this her parents main focus was making her a star. And everything else was put on the back burner . Ie education socializing with her own age and her really getting to know herself. honestly I think she is undeveloped in certain Areas. Whenever you see her doing an interview you can tell something is abit off or Awkward. I don't think she is stupid at all. Just undeveloped.
Once y’all made fun of baby blue hair she ain’t never give us nothing again
Exactly 💯
Right a lot of her black fans are anti black …talking about her baby hair her voice like what’s going on ..
@@AlteriaMcCullersI remember that petition. A mess and just embarrassing.
And they made fun of her facial features as well! Saying she looks too much like jay (meaning it in a negative way)
Yeah regardless of what you think of this woman in terms of spirituality or illuminati or whatever, whether you care about her music or not, what people said about her child was not acceptable in anyway shape or form
Hell, I'm a regular nobody & as I've grown older, I understand sometimes the best thing you can give ppl is your silence.
Best.Comment.Ever!
FACTS.
Facts!
Agreed sis.
Girl FACTS!! 🫶🏼realest comment! ♥️
When she showed her personality, people didn’t appreciate her. The industry drained her. I’ll never judge her for being private.
💯
She doesn’t really have a personality….
Girl bye! She's always been protected and hidden. They dragged tf out of MJ, the worse kind, yet he was still true to himself and really loved his fans. Yet he was still very shy. Stop the cap. Homegirl is living with guilt so now she's shut off
@@kittensmitten3287Yes MJ was dragged in the media. But you seem to forget that there was no social media. You seem to have forgotten how everything affected MJ, especially after the child molestation trial. After that MJ became a total recluse. I'm sure he wished he had shut off sooner and protected his peace!
@@damilolabashorun8890 and that's why I am saying y'all are trying to create a big deal out of why Beyonce is like this. She's not going through what MJ went through (who was still a genuine person through everything). Beyonce is a manufactured pop star, who is disingenuous, trying to scam her fans out of more money selling products, not music, products, all while not discussing what she's selling because she's mute. It does not work like that. No one would care if she just did music and went away and stayed mute. Stop trying to sell ppl weird out of the blue products, you expect ppl to buy just because of your celebrity and name. This is why she really gets dragged.
Y’all are deep in delulu land talking about authentic connections. Y’all are her customers not friends 😂😂
Right?! I don't care to meet any of those people. I don't watch reality tv with celebrities,especially if I enjoy their music. I know that I would not like any of them.
Finally some sense
I agree
Exactly!! They think these celebs actually care about them and defend them as if they were their best friends.
💯
I met Beyoncé three years ago & she was super humble , super nice & very authentic. I do believe she is just old school & the world is too much for her now, she seems to just want to do her job & live a relaxed life directly after
Every time she attempts to show her personality she is accused of “trying too hard”. But when she doesn’t she’s “too robotic”.
She is very robotic now lol. Which makes sense I guess cause she pulled herself so far away from people outside of her family, that she probably doesnt know how to interact with people outside of her family. When she was younger I think her personality was adorable, it wasn't too try hard imo. But In the early 2000s everyone was getting dragged/talked about. Paparazzi and tabloids went crazy. It wasn't just a beyonce thing. She just dealt with it differently.
It comes off as bad acting. She's so scripted
yet someone like taylor don’t either. she damn tired. i don’t even care for beyonce like but this lady get called uneducated for the way she talked in the past so why should she talk now. hell she talk more educated than taylor but people don’t get that cause beyonce really is nice from what i see.
because she really is a tryhard and robotic. idk why some people wanna try and make stuff into something its not. its probably the worst thing a person can do as a public figure is try and make up a personality. artists have tried it before and have gone completely crazy.
shes one of those people who isn't necessarily shy or quiet. shes too bossy to be all that shy. she doesn't say much cuz people will see how truly obnoxious she is -- nitpicky, controlling, calculating, arrogant, and overly critical but always trying to come off like shes a huge supporter of black people and women.
she doesn't show who she is because shes simply not relatable. even when she doesn't talk people find her presence annoying because shes truly irritating. and she cant hide it. you see it in little facial expressions she makes, eyerolls, and other rude gestures.
people can try and act like youre a hater or whatever but im just telling you what it is.
@@Supported32320 seek help... you don't know these people🤣🤣 this is exactly the parasocial shit they're talking about in the video
Beyonce should continue being mysterious. I dislike knowing too much about celebs. Also its healthy for her tht people dont know 2 much about her.
Agree. I appreciate celebs who keep some mystery 💯
I second it ...😊
Yesss knowing them is horrifying . Nobody wants to know the real ugly truth
@@fartunyep4501 the fact the people complained about her not showing her son. “It’s like she’s hiding him”. Like Ok??? Y’all not related to them people
That’s what people love about Rihanna.. she can sell anything
I mean… if 90% of the internet thought I was the Illuminati’s accomplice I would barely come on social media too..
Good point 🤣
I believe that she is im ngl😭😭😭
@@zaire-aniyarobinson2928 nah illuminati won't actually have 100 of videos on you tube about them being illuminati, they'd be behind the scene controlling the government
@@zaire-aniyarobinson2928Illuminati doesn’t exist boo stop being delusional
@@oonalunahNo you are just uneducated on the matter. Best to concentrate on your next horrible looking unit. 😊
I’ll never understand how ppl idolize celebrities. I once did as a teen but once I woke up… never again. Look up to someone successful that you actually know.
Facts!!
i feel that. i cant stand beyonce so im not here for that. i do like some other celebs. i like doja cat but im not into everything she does or whatever. and im not gonna freak out and write 2000 messages defending her. maybe a few lol
Right I just don’t understand how the brains of those people work. Doesn’t one outgrow that at like 14 😂
Anyone who isn't a teenager idolizing celebrities in adulthood simply needs to grow up
Teenagers dont get a pass its ok to be a fan but idolize thats still to much cause teenagers need to know its ok to be yourself and not take on a persona these celebrities are characters and to idolize an illusion is mentally disturbing. Cant nobody rock you like YOU ❤❤
I think how the public treated her first successful pregnancy with Blue Ivy is what put the nail in the coffin for Bey. She literally hasn’t never been as open or sociable ever since.
what is there to feel sorry for?
Parasociable I would say, but yeah you got it in one basically
@@god563616 ??? Are you being dead serious??? How do you not feel empathy for a child reviving death threats and racist remarks THE MOMENT she was conceived & then born?? Are you dumb or just lack emotional and social awareness???
@@xoxpctxox I KNEW what I meant to say that’s why I wrote it the way that I did. There’s nothing to read through, correct, or misinterpret.
I was thinking the same thing. She used to do interviews before that. She hasn’t even been on a talk show since then. But I don’t pity her because all they care about is money
Hearing Rihanna say ‘all the gender appropriations’ makes me laugh every single time.
Like what does it even mean 😂🤦🏾♂️ 🤣
It means whatever it does to not be canceled 😂
…and the pronouns 😢😅
she was going through it making sure everyone felt included to avoid getting cancelled🤣 I hate this era we’re living in ngl cause why that many identifications?🤦🏾♀️😭
She is from the Carribean we don’t know about that shit 😂
I honestly was proud of Doja for creating that boundary. She basically said..."if yo ass ain't here for the art..go" because there are weirdos who feel entitled to celebs personality like we're in HS or some shit
Boom 💥. This really needs to be said. These are human beings who are entitled to autonomy.
Fans are more entitled than ever
I called BS, so she’s using the word weirdos to hide behind the fact that she is pushing demonic spirits! Into the universe!!
Exactly ❤ i love doja's art and her boundaries 😊
lol she ain't just about the art her damn self
I’m mad awkward socially like Beyoncé. So I get it! Not everyone is a people person.
Me too😂
Same and even I get misjudged and people think that I'm "less than smart" as Wendy Williams would say. lol
Me too
@@TheJavaciaright?
@@TheJavacia well maybe you are smart but im not gonna sit up here and act like that woman dont sound out of touch more than half the time.
My mom got to meet Beyonce when she came to her old beauty supply. (I have pics) She was amazed by my mom's name and said she'd never forget her. My mom said she was very laid back and down to earth and she loves to laugh. Very different in person.
i had the complete opposite experience. Beyonce was rude to me when i met her. disappointing as i was a big fan at the time and immediately stopped that day. they say never meet ur idols. 😔
@@trailertrishThey also say not to idolize humans so it’s a little on you. She could have been having a bad day or you could have been annoying. 😅
@@trailertrishshe’s human. Could’ve had a bad day like any other person
Im just saying if yall pay attention to the negative comments from this past week or so youll notice theres a trend on what they look like
Whats the similarities@@bee3467
I think Beyonce not showing her personality actually works in her favor. It keeps her mysterious and has people always wanting more and being excited if she even says 2 words to her fans. When you’re constantly being plastered it leaves more room for negativity and for people to stop caring about you as much
Example; Cardi B
That's what she wants. She's persevering the super stars secret life. But it doesn't work in this climate
Also, she is keeping her brand at a high value in my opinion. If she starts talking and sharing opinions she will definitely turn ppl off and it can be something positive she says someone will be offended and I believe Beyonce is a very sensitive person might be too sensitive to mingle on the internet but also believe her not being easily accessible like a Cardi B will have ppl running to her when she do pop out for tours. She doesn’t show personality during a lot of concerts neither and becomes robotic with few human moments here and there. I believe it’s a wall of protection too.
Cardi B is a monster. Drugging men and getting away with it because people find her illiteracy endearing. Its the selective outfage for me. Smh She has no place in a conversation about Beyonce. @@SSR-Khaleesi
i agree with you! i do think though, it can make it harder to sell her products. which is why she’s doing those Cecred wash day videos…
Beyoncé wants to monetize her talents not her life and I’m not mad at it. I think it’s smart because u get cancelled for your opinions, lifestyle choices,etc. Stay 🤐 Bey lol.
This! Not sure why everybody wants to have a friendship with celebrities
Exactly! Makes me think of that moment when destiny’s child went to the UK and interviewers asked her about foot and mouth disease. Like what? 😂 She just wanted to talk about their music lol.
@@Shiann444It's so weird! 🤯
It also causes her businesses to fail cause she's not relatable like a rihanna, etc. I do respect it, though
@@foreverblessed6443 fenty is stugguling right know and savagexfenty is closer to bankrupcy. Celeb brand are not there to be a forever. The only brand of celeb with logevity, is the Row, and only because the twins retired from holiwood.
If I were her, I wouldn't either. After y'all bullied my kid, made fun of my southern accent, and said I'm illiterate, I don't blame her. I love it when celebrities like Beyoncé, Rihanna, J Cole, Kendrick Lamar, Ciara, and Russell don't use social media and just release their music. However, I miss Beyoncé because I miss seeing her in interviews, doing TV performances, and attending events. But I still like Beyoncé.
Ciara don't use social media??? Ummm ok😂😂😂😂
the message is cool but the examples are off lol
It's not so much her "southern accent" but rather the fact that she just simply doesn't speak eloquently or even in a feminine manner. Just keep that real. Kelly and Beyoncé have similar cadence but Kelly still sounds lovely. No shade. I love Beyonce but again, keep it 100... She sounds like a uneducated dude when she speaks lol
@@arantxapellmeRihanna and Ciara on sm heavy
@@NeFF0865exactly 😂😂😂🤦🏽♀️
Some people, like myself, are kind of socially awkward and self conscious. I may come across as "standoffish", or "funny acting " to people, but not at all! Im just awkward 😂🤷🏽♀️
Why are you awkward?
@wselenag45 it's a trait of highly intelligent people.
@theelizardqueen Oh wow! Never heard that. That's awesome
literally!!
Not me starting to get teary eyed for that little boy only for you to say that he was getting bullied for being racist?!? Say what sir?!??😂😂😂😂😂
I'm mad this is your first time hearing this lol, it was a BIG DEAL... once he was called out the people he bullied came forward and then his family went in on THEM.. it was a wild time for sure lol
Me too lol😮😂
“But I’m getting a little sidetracked” like excuse me ima need the rest of that story lmaooo
If she overly exposed herself on social media like other celebs she would be criticized. She decides to keep to herself, she’s still criticized. There’s no winning for her with the people who (with no good reason) dislike her.
@@Handlehandling so true
girl beyonce is a full demon. she’s nothing to like. she needs to repent to jesus christ
She's going to get criticized regardless. Beyonce think she is too good and up there for y'all. Nothing wrong with her interacting every now and again. In a real way.
@@mizkaponi4853 can you explain how she behaves like she’s too good and up there?
@@heylacy3563 She can't. Whenever someone accuses someone of being Bougie, uppity, or "feeling to good for others", they are jealous and use these baseless terms to justify their own feelings of inadequacy.
I met destiny’s child & she was sooooo funny at the meet n greet. I’ll never forget that
You were lucky enough to see the real her .
@@TROYCETV I think about that every time I hear people talk down on her… we were there for a long time, not like today where it’s “hi & bye”… those girls were really nice & im talking about Beyoncé Kelly & Michelle. So Lange was there too… Barton colosseum Little Rock Arkansascant remember the year. -- love your channel Troyce, thanks for the reply!
I think for people to go so hard for someone youll never meet is insane😂
yeah its weird especially when the celeb doesnt even deserve it. not every celeb deserves to be defended
I think that’s why they’re not friendly! It’s giving weirdo.
The same thing could be said for all the hate… how u hate somebody u don’t know ???
It's soo weird and I don't want to be around those that act like that it's ridiculous! Someone literally got mad at me ans called me jealous because I made a statement that in my opinion, Bey looks dead inside and emotionless like Troyce was saying in this video 😂 she just looks off to me like the lights are on but no one is home 🤷🏽♀️
@@Shiann444 yeah how about people saying oh i just dont like that person w/out ever having interacted w/ them? its weird
That kelly rowland ambush was crazyyyy
And the fact she basically had to ask for help 😳 they just let those people take over.
RIGHT! This my first time seeing this
Damn she looks lost
Im confused why NOBODY stopped the protesters the first 5 minutes 😂
That part! Kelly is such a sweetheart… if that would have been one of these new age gen z artists, it would’ve been a different situation😂
Now that I think about it. Thats why BET died. They talked about Blue Ivy hair. She shut down 106. Then it became the Tyler Perry Graveyard.
😊😊😊😊😊
Not Tyler Perry graveyard 😅💀
LMFAOOO AND DID
I bet Tyler is making them a lot of money tho. Speaking of 106 Wendy Williams said that Free had Shawn Carters baby back in the days
@@priestessraefalla1730INDEED!!😂
Beyoncé is what celebrities were to us growing up in the early 2000’s . We knew nothing about their personal lives except what they wanted us to know in interviews or unless a scandal came out on TMZ or in magazines.
They also had messy radio stations and websites surrounding celebrities personal lives it just wasn’t this personal people actually lived their lives
@@ronewithu Absolutely . The point is , we couldn’t get on social media and see one of the biggest stars at the time crashing out. I miss those days 😂. What about you ?
@@staciegreene2262 But back then there was plenty of artists “crashing out” in the media. People didn’t notice because the word about drama in the entertainment industry didn’t get around as fast as it’s getting around now.
@@ronewithu absolutely . I agree !! I never said the crash outs weren’t occurring , but as you said, it didnt reach us as much as it does now. We can literally see the crash outs in real time. I got online today , the FIRST thing I seen was Cardi and offset going at it 😂. Like wtf 🥴
So true! I’m around the same age as her (I’m 41) and we’re at an awkward timeframe because we either resisted social media all together OR jumped in head first… for generations younger than about 35, it’s all they have ever known so it’s weird to them if their favorite artist doesn’t post ALL the details of their personal lives
Nothing wrong with interacting with your fans/supporters but the way people dragged and made fun of Baby Blue and her hair was evil and disgusting. No wonder she stopped showing her personality. 🤷♀️Stuff just happens for a reason. Sad how things turned out. I remember how full of life she was in the 2000s.
I haven't seen this comment, but that's what did it!!!!! And don't blame her! That was evil!!!!!
Right. And people still look for anything bad to say about her. Like you not obligated to like anybody, but stop trying to find any negative thing to tie to them. It’s been over 20yrs for her career. MOVE ON.
@@rihannastan5405 this!! 👏👏
Who?
That’s true but her husband also drained her
The white dude told her “only your autograph” … Beyoncé rolled her eyes and slid that book over so fast like don’t you ever disrespect my group members… 😂
Completely agree with being mean as a defense mechanism. I’ve noticed that I do this. I’m on the quiet and shy side and get called stand-offish for it. It’s literally just me protecting my peace and I understand why some celebrities are like that
I went to Welch Middle school with Beyonce and Kelly. I can remember her Dad pulling them out of school for auditions and stuff like that. Her whole life has been about her looks and talent. She probably doesn’t know much of anything else. Yes, she has a personality, but she doesn’t have the real life experiences that her fans do. In short, she simply can’t relate. Imagine if you never had normal school experiences, college, work, friends, etc. of course there would be a void. Not excusing the fact that she only attempts to connect when she wants to make a profit, but just expressing why I feel she can’t really connect authentically.
That’s a great point. It makes sense too why she performed for Coachella. She never got to experience that. So it makes sense.
A lot of black women have to hide who we are . But we show our personalities in art and music.
She said she killed the girl on Cowboy Carter and she likes to “expose/express” her life in her music so that was a confession. People believed lemonade but not this?
True 💯
Yup!
Yes
Which song?? @@khenderson6689
No cuz I remember everyone was going in on her pregnant belly, claiming it was fake, and criticizing blue ivys hair. I would’ve disconnect from the internet as well…..
9:59 oh shit he mentioned it! 😭
So what exactly happened to her stomach in that video? Since when do pregnancy belly’s fold over?? The question is why was she wearing a prosthetic belly or padding her stomach?
Girl I don’t know nor care….. How you know it’s fake? And why you do you CARE so much? That’s the question! 🤨
It was fake , she used a surrogate
@@AstralWRLDsilence…anyone who has had a well pregnant belly knows it doesn’t fold like that. Knock it off. Y’all so busy glazing people that aren’t thinking about you, you can’t even believe your own eyes. I was pregnant at the same time. My belly damn sure didn’t fold. Go sit down.
Every little thing Beyoncé did was a problem now that she doesn’t do anything it’s a problem like……
Literally. I would’ve did the same thing as her tbh
It would not surprise me if Beyonce by any means was involved in one of tapes 💀
@@AnimeLuffyFan She’s definitely involved in something. Let’s not forget she’s on the Epstein list.
@@ahmarindungu9010 she can’t win
@@AnimeLuffyFanthis is what they’re talking about. The woman bothers NOBODY. All we know of her is that she loves her family and works her ass off. But then we have you in here with goofy shit talking about “sHE pRoBaLY IN tHe TaPeS!!!”
Yall judge her pregnancy, her children, her husband, her friends, her parents, her hair, her breath (whether YOU'VE ever smelt it or not), her decisions, her mental health, her character... why would she want to extend herself? 🤷🏾♀️
Ppl who are in touch w reality don’t feel like celebrities owe them anything. I’m perfectly fine w them making music and going on abt their day. I feel we know too much abt complete strangers.
Exactly!!! Exactly! Our job is to do one thing and one thing only, consume and appreciate their art and live them alone.
and always remember that they are HUMAN BEINGS! and let's just be honest, we don't know these people; they are strangers!
we need to stop thinking we know these people based on what they post, because we dont. Beyoncé being burned by the media so thats why she retreated into her world and closed the door lol, I dont blame her. I dont know her, nor do I want to. Love her music
Exactly, I don’t need my favorite artists to be my friend
Especially after the group split and changed out the members.
Love your video’s
Are people forgetting how the entire world was literally bullying, dragging and saying the worst things about Blue Ivy and how she looked as a LITERAL baby?!?! Especially when it came to Blue’s hair and nose. It’s sickening she was a baby and it showed the colorism, featurism, and texturism they have within themselves. It’s saddening that most of the hate came from the black community, it gave a lot of self hate.. I don’t blame Beyoncé and how she carries herself when it comes to the media, the industry and people in it along with the “fans”. She deserves all the privacy she wants. The industry drained the fucking life out of Beyoncé.
Beyonce had personality before jay-z now she doesn't smile much anymore in pictures
Her soul def seems empty.. she’s always looking zoned out. The cowboy carter album you can see how empty her eyes look
@TheeJayMac0214 /part/ of it is just that she tries to keep her face perfectly controlled to try not to show wrinkles. EVERY. SINGLE. IMAGE. SHE. RELEASES. IS. A. BODY. CHECK.
Doja cat had valid points on the 50/50, celebrities are celebrated for outstanding talent. People need to chill and stop worshipping them so much. Its insane at this point
She doesn’t seem empty. She’s calm. She doesn’t need anyone to pick her.
Pick her? Or pick on her?
@@CalIrvin-ks3iv “Pick her”. In my experience, a lot of explosive entertainers are quite subdued when they aren’t performing. They’re actually introverts who can turn it on when they hit the stage. When I see a personality like that acting super animated in a post or interview, it gives off thirsty “pick me” energy. Beyoncé’s subdued presentation makes sense to me.
@@taotaostrong Oh, I thought you meant pick on her, my fault.
@@CalIrvin-ks3iv All good. I love it when people engage in civil conversations in the comments section. It’s all entertainment. 😉
@@taotaostrong I love it when people are kind and civil in the comment section. 😊
Beyoncé was more present in the media in the early 2000s and when her career had just blossomed and I feel like people were twisting her words trying to get her into drama, so she just stopped talking all together
People worship her like a goddess,that’s too much
Honestly, I think that's what put me off Beyonce for a long time. I realised I didn't dislike her, I disliked the celebrity worship.
Idolatry is real 🤦🏽♀️
This! I’ve said Beyonce pushed herself into the corner not just by being quiet but by pushing that Queen like regal- goddess image. Literally in Bow down she’s dressed like a queen & telling people to bow down. Her lemonade era she portrayed herself as an african deity. Her performance in that gold dress while pregnant with the twins and a crown on her head while people dance around her on the table like she’s being worshipped. She pushed that goddess like image & that’s why people don’t treat her as human anymore & will observe her under a microscope waiting to see if the “queen” will slip up.
I could be wrong, but I think there is a church of Beyonce lol
@@potatochip4202It is
I’m glad I’m someone who doesn’t put celebrities on a pedestal or gets some strange obsession with them. I did that in my high school days but as an adult, I grew out of that.
Outside of their music, movie, or show, I couldn’t honestly care less about them. They’re not paying my bills or supporting me through life. They’re just entertainment. That’s it, that’s all.
She is a Virgo we are private folks for the most part. Its hard when we are self are over critical of ourselves so when others chime it its flustering so its better to play the mysterious roll unless you are close enough to us for us to share ourselves. I can only imagine being at her level of stardom how much she has to hold herself in.
her security and staff wasn’t moving fast enough in that one kelly clip like that went on FAR too long
??
Jill Biden moved faster when people were attacking Biden at one of his rallies, and she's not even professional security.
Exactlyyyyy
What could they do? They didn’t touch kelly and seemed to be protesting, which isn’t illegal
@vegannn7178 removed them lmao duh. They took too long to jump to action.
She shows her personality on stage
As someone else aka Sasha Fierce...
@@AGirlCalledNicolethat’s still a part of her.
Virgos are naturally private and at times quiet around strangers…. I wish ppl would just leave her alone
@@iambloopyits a demonic entity apart of her😭
Are we missing that we still had to PAY to see it…? 😩🤷🏾♀️
Being famous is not a blessing. It’s best to love our lives we’re in and make the most of it and enjoy giving our opinions without anyone caring.
Her eyes have always been empty to me. I feel kinda bad for her, it seems like she was robbed of her childhood and young adult hood.
I met Beyoncé years ago at the Houston rodeo. She was nice and professional imo…. Everything she would say got ridiculed back then so I think it was strategic for her to not do as many interviews and only do magazine interviews mostly.❤
People are shocked that a legend doesn’t want to be on social media. They feel entitled to relate to her because her talent isn’t relatable. No one else can emanate that, it makes them furious. All these other celebrities have been on social media basically saying “I’m just like you!” and going on rants on twitter to diminish their reputation SMH. Y’all need to wake up and realize she’s not attainable in any sense of the word and thats ok, she shouldn’t be. Real icons don’t need to act that way.
@@ladynicole9151 So you think...she's not your friend either.
@@ladynicole9151 That’s ok from her because her “talent” is relatable! She doesn’t sing good live. She doesn’t dance well either, a lot like Taylor Swift. You can build a brand on being just OK in a deeper sense while also being digestible to a general audience.
@@ladynicole9151 Understood...I agree.
@@aaliyahmattel536💯🤣🤣
@ladynicole9151 People who make good art do make the world a better place.
Also not every product is for every body. Rihanna sells the cool factor, aesthetic and personality. She has to come off as "down to earth" because that's what she is selling. Beyonce is selling music and performance, her personality comes through the performance those who pay for the tickets and listen to the music experience it then. There is no reason she should give the product out for free when it's meant for a limited audience.
I love when you come up with a new video. It brings temporary joy.
Aw thank you 💕
❤
People also forget how she was scrutinized and blamed for dismemberment of Destiny’s Child. She went through a deep depression. I don’t think she owes us anything. She has a personality but she is picky abt who she shows it to.
She did it though. She's a very traitorous person.
@@truthtorpedo4068I'm sorry she revealed it to you. Hope you heal from that trauma you shared with Beyonce
@@truthtorpedo4068go and eat a D, hater
Although I wasn’t around that era, the blame should be on her dad, Matthew Knowles.
@@truthtorpedo4068wtf? What’s wrong with you?
The same reason why Rihanna won’t release another album lol. They was talking about her performance and singing on one of her tours. She hasn’t dropped an album since
I'm so happy you made this video because I'm tired of ppl NOT managing their expectations and having parasosical relationships with ppl they DO NOT KNOW..like wtf??
They said my girl was country, and uneducated! Mind u Beyoncé is one of the only prima Donna’s of her generation that still hold that celebrity allure/mystique.
@Mangoos393 they used her being country as an excuse to call her ignorant/uneducated. Is that what you’re asking?
I remember people used to make fun of her Texas accent saying she sounds dumb and uneducated not understanding that's just how she talks I mean Britney Spears always had a very deep Southern accent and nobody said anything about her sounding stupid
@@Model_Roe but Solange grew up in the same household and you would never know it by the way she speaks. It’s not the accent.
@@Model_Roe im from texas. im from Houston. she doesn't represent ANY accent from where she group up!
so no she did sound dumb and uneducated and for what? cuz she grew up in a damn affluent neighborhood!
also wtf are you talking about. did you even follow britney spears? THEY ALWAYS attacked the absolute fk out that girl. they said britney was trashy and clowned her for constantly being seen eating nothing but junk food all the time, they got onto her about her choice of clothes all the time claiming she gave off trailer park vibes. lol where were you?? they absolutely made her out to be the epitome of uneducated trashy white America.
@@mynameisstacey6217 thats beyonce beyonce was faking the whole time. lol why do people not catch onto basic sht.
beyonce STOLE kelly rowlands accent and the people's accent who grew up in the wards like KELLY did, not beyonce. stuff be right in front of peoples faces and its downright weird how they dont get it
She still has a personality. U can see when she’s on stage and in her documentaries, she just stays out the public eye when she doesn’t have to be and I don’t blame her at all. The public is cruel asf. I wouldn’t talk to us either if I had the choice 😂
She definitely still has a personality 💯
I love how you’re trying to psychoanalyze a stranger, these parasocial attachments is also why she stays away
@@vegannn7178 where did I psycho analyze? I made an observation from what I’ve seen then put my own opinion on what I would do if I was in her shoes…
Y’all are turning that word into a buzz word 🤦🏽♀️
@@TamiaLeslie-ix5qn dont you hate that? when mfs know damn well they dont study anything other than whats being said in a popular environment. lol its so ridiculous. they parrot it over and over again and some still dont even bother to know what they're saying.
Broke my finger pressing this video, currently watching from the hospital
Broke my vocal chords reading this comment 🤣
At least you're in the right place to have your finger looked at 💀 I hope you'll be out soon!
Get better soon❤️🩹 hope the food good
🤣🤣🤣🤣
I actually am in the hospital watching this😂😂
People thinking they’re entitled to a celebrity they don’t even know from a can of paint will forever be intriguing but slightly disturbing to me
Have you ever had a situation at work were you thought you were VERY cool with your colleagues but then you discovered they were speaking poorly about you and/or the people you care about? There is no point in confronting them and you can't leave your job. Plus, you LIKE the work. So, you adjust. You're never mean, you just talk and emote less. You share less. You dedicate yourself to the work instead. You pour your kindness and hope into the work product. As my dad once told me when giving me advice about working with unkind people: , 'Work is for colleagues, not friends. Learn the difference.'
Similarly, millions of people sat here and spoke poorly of this woman while she was a first time mother, after child loss. Said she was never pregnant (not that there's even anything wrong with surrogacy, but still). If that wasn't bad enough, folks disrespected the actual baby. But as she's always told us, she loves to sing. And she needs the audience, just like we need her. So, it looks like she's taken my dad's advice; we're no longer friends, we're just colleagues; she learned the difference.
And I her response is most appropriate. I hope she keeps this boundary up indefinitely.
“Kelly Rowland has blood on her hands!!!!” So unnecessary
Like where tf was security?!
@@brioliviaexactly everyone would be fired ..
And so rude wth
The video of Beyonce interviewing Aaliyah in 2000 makes me so sad yet so happy. Sad she’s not like this anymore in public & happy that she used to be and that we can go back in the time and remember the old her.
She was envious of Aaliyah, the two don’t go together as any good example, sorry.
@@ynstulluhhh9852 you sound as stupid as your profile name
@@ynstulluhhh9852 beyonce was bigger than Aaliyah when she was 1/3 of a group. Please. Love them both but it’s true. My comment still stands.
@@ynstulluhhh9852this is why she’s private cause yall are so weird.
@ynstulluhhh9852 Now show me where that's a FACT and not something u heard from somebody nobody knows.
That's YOUR narrative because YOU don't like her...
NOT a FACT.
I'm glad Beyoncé is very reserved now and conserving her energy.
The issue is people are obsessed with Celebritiy. They really think they are getting to know a complete stranger that has no clue who they are…….because they are on TV or the internet. It doesn’t matter what personality or lack thereof that Beyoncé shows. The audience she attracts is mostly delusional.
Doja also dated an abuser and blocked the woman who was abused and tried to warn her! That’s also why a lot of ppl don’t like her anymore :/
It's because she is so used to people making stuff up to make her upset. So she doesn't know if it's true or not. But when it came out that it was true, she left the relationship.
TROYCE SERVIN WHEN I CANT SLEEP!!
Got my Boom chicka pop popcorn ready 🍿 😌
Bro save me a plate 😫
I can’t either girl ❤😂
_I’m old enough to remember that 106&Park had to address the fans/public for attacking Bey/Blue Ivy’s hair. Everyone was saying that Bey didn’t know how to do Blue’s hair, and that she shouldn’t let her walk around with “kinky”, unkempt hair. Truthfully, it was her own community going in on her and her child that was the final straw._
I Kelly’s defense, Troy, those weren’t fan. Those were likely PETA fanatics. NOT FANS.
Kelly was very patient! She stood there while they embarrassed her. Where was her bodyguard and team? She looked scared and lost. I wonder why she didn't walk out or was she too frighten to do so?
She was there working and there were other people waiting for a pic with her, that would have been unprofessional.
Celebrities are not your friends and you don't who they are.
She’s doing the right thing, though. Cause a lot of these girls get online and I end up not liking them anymore when I coulda just enjoyed the music. Now you lost a fan cause your personality sucks.
Yuppp me with Nicki Minaj. Her personality has gotten horrid and now it turns me off supporting her tours and music when I would’ve originally since I grew up a fan
I think ppl are overbearing and invasive and it can be very uncomfortable
Beyoncé used to make these little fun video collages, show her personality 24/7, etc but people would start doing the most.
Beyoncé just said in her GQ interview how fame is like a prison to her & that’s why she doesn’t attend events. Good video! I love Doja😅
There’s nothing wrong with being private … not everyone’s the same 🙏🏾✨
They were literally calling her dumb when she used to talk to us. I would've stopped talking too 🫠
Real
I mean… no shade but she did sound uneducated.
Same. She never sounded dumb to me. Neurodivergent maybe but that doesn’t mean low intelligence.
We lose ourselves if we hide it away for too long. Often, it tries to reignite, but it gets snuffed out in fear again. People can be cruel. This industry is really nasty.
I love Beyoncè as a person - I don’t know her personally, but I’m glad she stays quiet. Ppl do too much.
HOLD ON. The fact that security didn’t stop those people at Kelly’s meet and greet pissed me off
When she showed her personality she was criticized and called stupid (ahem… Wendy 👀) So, I really don’t blame her in wanting to keep her life to herself.
I definitely wouldn’t call her “stupid” but she’s definitely not a “cerebral” woman🥴
I don’t mean any harm, her gift from the Most High is performing, singing, dancing… put it this way, if I never see her attempting to act, I would be perfectly fine with that🤷🏽♀️
The speech impediment is clear but “fans” don’t want to admit it.. and it’s not a Texas country accent because I’m from the south as well and we know how to speak clearly
I wouldn't be surprised if Beyonce is just tired of everyone's crazy crap.
Well the first one, the guy said no only YOU and Bey was like nah... we're a GROUP so we're all gonna sign😅. I loved that moment and didn't think it was awkward at all 🤷🏾♀️
I wonder if she has severe anxiety too?
She been controlled her whole life...never been able to speak up or speak to someone about it 😕
@@NewbiWays2025her and Jay z have been in therapy for years so I bet she’s gone to therapy herself and also she’s like one with her mother so I bet she does have someone to talk to
@@MiR-bp5vx her parents sold and groomed her for the industry...she don't have a say...if that's the case...why her mother let her married JayZ jus saying 🤨🤔
@@NewbiWays2025 lmao you need to go get your head checked. She was never sold her parents protected her while helping her achieve her dream. And she married Jay z when she was almost 30 so that’s a grown woman and I don’t think her mother can tell her who to marry if it’s not some weird creep
You're mentally ill@@NewbiWays2025
If I was her I wouldn't share my life either. Shes an artist. She consistently puts out music. Thats all she owes to her fans.
****chileee that fur bs with kelly was a hot mess.
Technically she doesn’t owe y’all that. She finds her fan’s strange because of their attachment to her
Public figures she should use Instagram then
@@vegannn7178 please she is a fan too ! Stop playing
People always find a problem when a black girl/woman is introverted
Doja was out here poppin bubbles 😂 "I'm not your friend!"
Her stomach did fold like a fake one though. We all saw. Moms especially noticed.
This video, wow! took me a couple of years to realise not everyone deserves access to you or your kindness, love how you broke it down because the minute I opened myself up to everyone, everything I worked for crumbled and fell apart
Yea people treat celeb culture like these celebrities are gods. We don't owe them anything and they don't owe us anything besides not harming one another. Beyonce is out of touch but that's what rich famous people will always be like sadly. Even nonfamous people are out of touch so it all clashes.
They owe us we paid their rent the same way we owe our boss ...
Right. The fans don't owe these celebrities a lavish lifestyle, money, support of any kind or fame. You (fans), CHOOSE to be part of this bizarre culture by supporting these strangers who don't owe you their kindness, openness, friendship. or blue checks. I 100% agree with Troyce and Doja. I stopped celebrity worshipping years ago. It didn't benefit me, and I realized these celebrities don't give a sh*t about their fans AT ALL! They are using y'all for their own needs.... for fame and wealth. until fans comes to Jesus about this problem and start investing more in enriching their own lives and leave these celebrities alone, then this weird celebrity culture /parasocial relationship will never end.
@@Jsarmy87124 whoever the “we” includes need to go outside and do something productive. None of this stuff matters, and paying a celeb’s “rent” is a choice.
when i was a preteen/ teenager before social media and gossip blogs there were message boards and people used to tear beyonce up calling her fat when she was slim thick talking about her accent.. talking about she her outfits talking about her hair. beyonce wasn't always the beyonce she is now she used to get trolled and bullied real bad. i remember when she did that in the club remix and everybody was like oh no she didnt! now if would be insane to even think beyonce would be on a remix. i came up in the early destinys child days i was about 12 13 in 1999.
tina only taught her how to be a perfect doll, not an expressive being. dolls only “talk” when played with. she only talks when working.
I don’t think Tyla was rude asking somebody to hold her award. She asked politely and those awards are actually heavy. Cardi B has done the samething. She prob just wanted to focus on her speech.
Plus she's been dealing with a back injury that she had to cancel her tour for.
Yes! Being Quite is the best power, I love it !
I’m less than a minute in but so glad you’re speaking on this because I thought this too when people recently started saying she’s forcing being silly to relate and its cringe when no…she’s BEEN silly this IS part of her personality! She may have turned it off to the public and now showing it again but this is not new! If they saw “7/11” or that “Feeling Myself” video she did with Nicki Minaj she was being silly in those videos too so its not a surprise she can be silly! smh 💯
It's selective amnesia. I mean the're tons of old videos of Beyonce on the internet, interviews, backstage and behind the scenes.
@@damilolabashorun8890 Exactly 😩 I just figured if they didn’t see all that they ATLEAST saw those 2 videos even if not following her closely or fans fr. You’re right its all kinds of footage especially as far back as her Destiny’s Child days being even more silly with Kelly and them so it’s definitely selective amnesia, too young, or just determined to not like her so finding any reason to hate smh.
It just doesn’t look natural.
For the Doja situation in my opinion, it was the way she handled it. Some may disagree, but while I agree that boundaries do exist, it was the way she handled it that was off putting for me. It's just not what happens to you, but it's also how you deal with tough situations. Two wrongs don't make a right.
True
Samuel L jackson put his award on the ground during his speech cause he said the award is HEAVY! And olivia rodrigo also passed her award to someone cause she said it's HEAVY! I think people just want a reason to hate Tyla cause i never truly see the girl do anything worth disliking her.
Didn’t she get bit by a fan… I’m not mad at her for keeping her distance with her fans. Y’all are deranged
She was allegedly bit by another celebrity
it was sanaa lathan allegedly
she actually was caught eating on one of her back up singers and doing witchcraft on her. the lady sued her.
GIRL WHEN??? It literally was another celebrity
@@vegannn7178 that must be something new what i’m talking bout happened like last year.
Beyoncé seems like fun and sweet of you actually get to know the real her.
I don’t blame her for being private because people annoying asf and never happy , very miserable.
I agree with everything you said. Doja is a good example too. I don’t always agree with her responses but she’s still human first she’s one of the only ppl in our generation that has no problem standing up for what she believes in
I’m just mainly concerned about Bey cus it’s like you can tell she’s disassociating 80% of the time it’s all in her tone and face it’s crazy
She doesn't do interviews because their is so much controversy around her and she cannot handle those questions. She's not equipped IMO. From the drummer calling her a witch, stepping on bandmates spotlight get where she is, taking Amerie's whole image, elevator fights,, stealing songs, not paying writers enough, Jay Z controversy...Beyonce can't handle that, and honestly, if she does not have to, it is *smart* to just avoid it altogether.
@TheArtofBeingReacts your probably right. It goes back to this her parents main focus was making her a star. And everything else was put on the back burner . Ie education socializing with her own age and her really getting to know herself. honestly I think she is undeveloped in certain Areas. Whenever you see her doing an interview you can tell something is abit off or Awkward. I don't think she is stupid at all. Just undeveloped.