They trained for 2 years. Yes, they have trained under Korean coaches but only for around 3 or 4 months. Everything is all under Filipino labors. P-POP (Philippine POP) is new. P-POP is still searching for international recognition. They still don’t have this high budget productions compare to K-POP which is multiple times bigger already. As BINI becomes bigger they are paving the way for P-POP to be notice. If you check out old K-POP there production value of their M/V is not as good as they have now. As they become bigger BINI M/Vs will become more better too.
@@coffeelover9165 How it becomes 4 years? The Star Hunt began on 2019. They debut on 2021. Their pre debut song came out on 2020.. Only thing is even they debut they still continue to train. Even until now. That is why BINI keep getting better.
they're just getting their recognition now...within the past few months their subscriber base internationally has grown significantly due to Cherry on top which was international target base. They have other music videos such as Salamin Salamin and Lagi, but i would also like to understand the meaning of 'music video video can be better' - like in which areas? Also i think times are changing. Ppop is changing the playing field in which the consumers are now asking "OK, i see that they have a great music video... they have a great fully well produced song. But could they perform it live?' A lot of content released in the west and in kpop didn't really focus on the live singing aspect of things, so their music videos and sound mastering is really big budget. Today, i think the filipinos have interestingly changed perception and taste as the focus over there is all about vocals. It was interesting to see that during the Asian Artist Awards of 2023, that a lot of the performances there mainly focused on the choreography. However, it's opened pandoras box when SB19 did their opener for the show and gave the KPOP idols a performance a "What are we watching?" look on their faces, possibly being intimidated due to the high level/calibre of the performance they've jus witness. Like i definitely would not want to go next 🤣🤣 So when PPOP groups perform - it's live including the vocals. This has probably thrown a wrench into KPOP choreos as it's not something that's normally done. However, now the Filipinos are brought into playingfield performing live such as in Kcon, and Billboard of Asia awards in Korea and previously mentioned the AAA. This is great as it pushes for healthy competition between the idols as it forces them to get out of their comfort zones. If these groups we're just finding out about from the Philippines are showing us the level that they're performing is like this, then why can't we do it too. They totally changed the scene as previously it's all about the music videos...now there's different factors due to the wishbus. This is how it is in the Philippines because of the high standards on vocals vs evertyhing else. This crfitique is no longer just being viewed by the Filipinos but it's now gaining traction around the world as it's. Yes, music videos is how it attracts the people to pay attention to the group and what they got like a resume. but a lot of that comes from budget as well. What i'm seeing now are groups getting recognition due to their performances and not via their music videos. And it's totally the other way around now in which they get funding from their performances that they're finally able to then create high budget music video. Anwyways, that's just my general feedback. If you're new to ppop, i think you'll see what i mean later :)
@@partyeslife8157 i get your point. Honestly i listen to good music not paying that much attention to vocals , as i said in my cherry on top reaction, but at the same time i really do love live performances and i get so much more emotional listening to live performances. And my point about the MV was about BINI being perfect in every aspect possible! And i just think that they deserve to have high quality music videos. Sets,clothes and everything else. And i don't mean there was something wrong in the Music Video. I wish my MV Reaction wasn't blocked so everyone could see how much I actually enjoyed it, but i think it could get even better to match the potential they have. Thank you for the explanation.✨
@@ItsRosieDays no worries :) have you tried looking into starting a patreon? it's another alternative for people when videos get blocked, they publish their content there. not sure if you need to pay patreon or what or if you could offer the free patreon for your subs or what. but yeah good luck on the UA-cam content creator journey!
@@ItsRosieDays idk, I like Karera M/V, I think it fits very well with the song. I wouldn't have changed anything. I would've agreed if it is one of the earlier MVs but Karera I thought is amazingly done. I guess its a matter of preference, wish I could see your MV reaction soon.
@@veerand7038yeah, the Fandom (blooms) loves the Karera MV, it fits the songs message. Maybe because this reactor doesn't understand the meaning of the song that's why she doesn't appreciate it.
@@ItsRosieDays Yes that's true. In this group Position Doesn't matter because as per Jhoanna thier leader every single member can do what other member can do also.
Thanks for the awesome review! It’s fair, especially since you mostly cover K-pop. Comparing it to aespa and other K-pop videos might give lower ratings, but for a company just starting in P-pop and international music, they’ve really done well! looking forward for more reviews like this! :) I also recommend checking out their documentary. They’re a pandemic P-pop group, and their company lost it's franchise, so it was tough for them at the beginning, but they persevered and inspired people with their journey from nothing to winning.
@@LDRXTV09 i actually would love to watch documentary. I will talk about it in the my next videos when i watch it. I am curious. Thank you for the comment❤️
@@ItsRosieDays Please don’t engage with the toxic comments. some are came from other fandom of another P-pop or kpop group that thrives on fan wars and negativity. They aren’t genuinely a Blooms and seem to want to discourage reactors from liking BINI. hopefully you're not discourage to do more content like this
@@LDRXTV09 thank you for saying this, actually i don't care that much,i just do me! It doesn't matter what some people say when most of you are okay with the RV that i posted. It just gets annoying sometimes 🤦🏻♀️
MV, Wish bus and dance practice perfect combo. They are so versatile and try different genre.. Salamin Salamin String Golden Arrow Born to win (Debut) Lagi (local and dance practice) Thank you for reacting😊
it is much easier to produce a top-tier music video (just throw money at it) than to create an 8-member girl group where each member is a great vocalist and dancer, and especially with Bini, has great chemistry with each other (you can see their genuine smiles). Additionally, although there are 4 main rappers, all of them can rap. Among them, the role "visuals" does not mean anything - you cannot join any Philippine girl group (or boy group) if you cannot sing well. But they are all beautiful. Good ingredients are hard to find.
thanks for your reactions - unfortunately the Karera MV seems to have been blocked. Please react to their other hits - Salamin Salamin, Lagi, Strings, Golden Arrow. Where available, please also react to the respective dance practices and Wish107.5 performances.
Yes the mv is blocked but sometimes it happens and after hours it's fixed. So i am hoping this will happen with this one as well. I will keep your suggestions in mind❤️
The PPOP GIRLS IDOLS PHILIPPINES should be loved and promoted and reacted to learn the true and good Bini not only groups in the PPOP and show the talent of singing, dancing locally and internationally. ❤️❤️❤️
Wow keep it up on reacting to Bini 😊 There are so many of their songs that I think you would like Lagi, Salamin Salamin, Pantropiko 😊 and their dance practices too.
Another reaction is much better and we really appreciate this so much sweetie. Same thing we want to say that those girls deserve more because their talent since in the beginning is really giving. They improve endlessly and at the same time their smiles makes us smiles too. Whenever we get stress, just watching their clips can lift us. You already see how they enjoy their dance practice because these song Karera is one of their fave song in their album, how much more we, blooms, everyday listening these to motivate ourselves. Thank you sweetie for this wonderful reaction. We hope to watch more of these, it makes us happy on how you guys appreciate their flaws and talents.
@@rabiyahabdulkhabir2601 you are such a sweat soul. Thank you for understanding my points and being so nice❤️they are absolutely amazing and talented . I am happy to know them.
Have you noticed that they incorporate a sign language in their choreo, pls do watch Pantropiko, Salamin Salamin, Golden Arrow, strings & many more, thank you for a good RV & loving Buni❤❤❤❤❤
Maybe because the company they were under was shutdown, so the progress of them being shown to people was a little slow. But salute to the management on pushing through in supporting Bini because i guess they really believe in the girls talents. I suggest you watch their documentary Chapter 1 "Born to win". There is more in Bini than just talents.😊
@@ItsRosieDaysI suggest finishing their discography first, or at least getting to know them better, before watching the documentary. For sure, u won't understand what's happening without knowing them
1:51 I guess that's ok because it's like a transition from one formation to another. so that's the style of BINI's choreo where moments where they highlight a singer doing a move on her own, and the rest are divided into 2 groups doing 2 different moves but still locked in the musicality and then go back to doing one move altogether again.They use a lot of isolation, levels, asymmetrical formations and dominoes. You will see a lot of these 'chaotic' moments 😆 when you see more of their dance practices. A lot of professional dancers reacted to this already and they didn't notice this part, its just a matter of seconds so that doesn't make this a bad choreo. No need to be nitpicky. You are entitled to your opinion though. BINI is managed by ABS CBN, one of the biggest media companies in the Philippines yet they just started to get into quality MVS for Bini like you see in Cherry on Top using a bit og CGI. They starting to collaborate with International music producers and hopefully they can have more budgets and work with better VFX companies and directors. This is the same situation in our film industry. Sadly, Philippines, although Filipinos are artistic when it comes to music, fashion, art, dance, it is still a poor country compared to Korea, which is more of a developed country, companies like SM entertainment, YG, HYBE they spend big budgets on MVs. I know BINI will somehow improve gradually in every comeback but will not get into high budget CGI MVs drastically. You won't see any of those soon if that is your expectation. You need to look at the business side of things where they need to manage and establish funds for the group and management first before spending a lot on budgets. They barely just got famous exponentially this year around just last March I think. Armaggedon is not even the 'best' MV for me as it is effects-driven. People might even forget it in the future. You can see a lot of music videos from the 80's and 90's will have simple or no effects at all but became iconic and considered as the best MVs of all time because of the storytelling, the art direction, the way it created a cultural impact to different generations over the years. Best MVs for me is something that people will not forget. A timeless, classic masterpiece. I'm not sure about your rating system as I don't know what your basis and criteria is? You didn't explained it much. Theres more to appreciating art and good music videos than having bigger budgets and cgis. Sometimes less is more. I know all of this as I work as an Art Director on tv commercials, film for social, events and worked with different production companies internationally for decades. No way BINI is going to be handled by a 'bigger' international label. ABS-CBN won't let them. Last time the Koreans handled the Ppop group, SB19, it turned ugly, they parted ways, and the Boyband decided to self manage their group under 1Z entertainment which is going well and growing. Their mission is to help Ppop groups be known to the world. Ppop groups here help and support each other doing a lot of collabs. All we know that BINI is on the right track in the right company. If you watch their documentary you will see how they are well taken care of during a long journey of struggles, especially during the pandemic. So, dont get me wrong but before you make any more comments about the group, I suggest you dig deeply and understand where they are coming from, otherwise, you will get a lot of bashing from The Blooms as they are a big global community. Understanding the Ppop culture, style will also help. It is just new and emerging. But its ok to give constructive feedback that make sense to the general blooms (it has to make sense lol) and I promise you this. Just make The Blooms happy and they will love you back with more views, likes, comments and subscriptions. 😄 I recommend 2 videos to start with: Karen Davila interview with BINI and Born to Win documentary, which got released recently. They are a pure Filipino group managed by a pure Filipino company. We Filipinos take pride on this. That's why they are dubbed as, "The Nation's Girl Group!" I hope this helps.
She’s looking for chaotic part as she mentioned, rather than appreciating the musicality. 'Karera' is one of the best choreographies I’ve seen, and I know a choreography is top-tier when professional dancers ask who the choreographer is. For example, I used Steezy's choreography for comparison they choreographed 'Cherry on Top,' but the dancers I know weren’t too impressed by it. They liked it, but not enough to ask who choreographed it, and they analyzed it briefly compared to BINI’s choreography, where the analysis lasted almost 50 minutes or more
Kalmahan lang natin blooms. Respetuhin naman natin siya. Bagong reactor lang siya oh di pa nga niya kilala yung girls at yung kwento ng bawat isa eh. We can educate and teach her naman without bashing. Wag yung ganito na bash tayo ng bash. Please please be kind to her.
Hindi naman siya binabash ng blooms. Ineducate lang. Ganda kaya ng Karera MV. Kahit ang mga BINI girls, very emotional sila nung nag react sila sa MV nila nato. The MV fits the message of the song.
We have to respect her opinions. She has been watching a lot of korean MV' s and that is why she has high standards. Bini's MV's are getting better and better but they are not yet quite up there with other korean MV productions as they are still growing in popularity.
Yes like me a non dancer at first I taught their dancing is chaotic until real choreographers and dancers explained things in detail how intricate and hard their movement then I start to see the beauty and synchronization.
@@valleysofdreams everything about the choreo and their movement was perfect. The part where i said it seems chaotic is the position of all of them and not the dance itself. Not only them but some choreographers use this technique and it is just not my taste. And it was only for a few brief seconds. That's it
no i dont think so, no way its higher budget than Cherry On Top or Salamin Salamin. And their makeup and wardrobe game is way above currently than the past
6:36 - There were several factors why the group was not well-known and did not reach a wide Filipino audience earlier. First of all, the COVID-19 pandemic hit the company, along with the Philippine Congress not allowing the renewal of their free-to-air franchise. This led to the company being forced to cut 11,000 employees. This was followed by the shutdown of the company's local music radio stations, which prevented the airing of their music. As a result, the group and the company were forced to find alternatives, such as using social media to promote the group.
The MV of 'Karera' for me is perfectly fine. It's not as high quality as K-pop, but the feel of the MV perfectly suits the message of the song. Actually, I prefer that kind of MV over lots of CGI effects and flashy things happening because it doesn’t resonate with the message of the song. And don't worry-as BINI keeps getting bigger, their MVs will have higher production, just like in 'Cherry on Top.' In their past MVs, they had a low budget. I suggest not expecting too much about the MV since P-pop is just getting started, but someday it will get bigger. We'll get there, and BINI is the starting point
@@heavensky8706 yes this type of songs don't match with CGI effects and people don't have to pay to much to get there , i just think that there was still some space for improvement.overall i really enjoyed watching the MV. Now i know the story so i won't be expecting much and just enjoying. But i will have my honest opinion said though.☺️ Thanks for the comment.
@@mikepadz1976 no it is not about being content with just the mv , but having a good MV is also a part of the process so it can be important, especially when the group deserves a better quality in their MV's. When you have it all also having a good MV can be the cherry on top.
@@ItsRosieDays majority of the BINI Fandom loves that Karera MV, especially the BINI girls themselves.. they were emotional reacting to that MV. Me personally loves Karera MV out of all their MVs' because of the meaning/message of the song and also they just look happy on it. Especially the part where they are running towards the sunset, I think that is very beautiful. They didn't used green screens for the music video. Also,maybe because you don't understand the meaning of the song that's why you don't appreciate the music video.
@@barbieborbe6060 i reacted to the MV as well and i loved the lyrics and also the MV was so lovely and light and made me happy All i am saying is that there is still room for progress.
As I read the comments, I honestly wonder if some commenters are Blooms because BINI has so many bashers from other fandoms trying to bring them down. So I hope you understand and don’t get offended. Just continue to dig deeper into BINI and don’t expect too much
@@heavensky8706 i love the girls already and i don't care that much about the comments. It just shows how many people know them and follows them, bloom or not. Don't worry we will have more BINI videos.😉✨
@@ItsRosieDaysThank you so much for continuing your BINI journey you will love the girls don't mind them like he said BINI has a lot of Basher from other fandom I understand about the poor quality of the production of their Music Video but the MV of Karera are supposed to be like that the message of the song and the summery vibe the nature fits it well. Try Salamin Salamin, Pantropiko, Strings, and I Feel Good and try to react with 1 song like Strings MV/ their Dance Practice and Wish bus live performance in all thanks I love your reactions to BINI.
Thank you for your comment ❤️ It is so low to try bring a gg down like that, some people!🤦🏻♀️ I understand your points. I will try to have more three part reaction but i also might do singles.
BINI hasn't stopped training even after their debut; they continue to train daily as part of their routine. They are hardworking girls. When P-pop started, no one supported it. Even after gaining international recognition alongside other groups, Filipinos remained close-minded about P-pop. Our music is dominated by hip-hop, ballads, bands, and Western artists, so it’s hard to introduce a new genre. As a result, all P-pop groups went into **nugudom** for many years, including BINI. They experienced being bashed and compared to K-pop, and they were even asked to their faces, "Who are you?" BINI is a miracle in P-pop; no other group has managed to break into the mainstream except BINI. If you know their story, you will understand how they crawled their way to the top
@@bananajam1356 i will start to know them better slowly. It's okay, always someone has to pave the way. So many similar thing's like this happened to K-pop artists as well. So many big groups were unrecognised back then. But now... I'm sure BINI will be a known great group someday.✨
Hahaha,as what i notice naka lock na si reactor sa KPOP style eh, may sariling style and ibang ASIAN country and di lahat gagayahin ang KPOP Style, kaya naninibago to at parang ang standard nya ay katulad ng KPOP dapat eh kaya ganun di yta nya alam yung mga style ng pag sayaw like domino effect and wave and different formations ng mga sayaw kya ganun. Hayaan nyo na guys, baka iba lang talaga gusto nya, kung ako diko ipagpipilitan yung gusto ko, para gustuhin nya, Hahaha, pero di nako magsasayang para pilitin sya eh^^. dapat natural lang na magustuhan nila yung artist, walang pilitan. TY na lang po^^.
@@L4wD-4U as i said in the video i am not only talking about kpop but every MV that i have seen by now. i completely accept that they have their own style, all i said was that they could have had better MV's and the they have some room for improvement.
@@ItsRosieDayswell I don't know about your preferences of what a GOOD MV is, but personally, I think KARERA is a good MV.. especially if you understand the meaning of the song.. millions of blooms (BINI Fandom) loves that MV that's why I will not be surprised if they will react negatively of what you just said in this reaction video. No hate, just saying...peace🤙
For us Filipinos, we don’t really care much about MVs, well for me anyway. We are used to listening and watching talent on TV or radio, this why the Wish Bus is there so artists can showcase their vocal talent. I think that nowadays, especially, younger generations are into visual satisfaction, aka flashy high budget MVs. This is also prolly why Bini’s 2 latest MVs (Salamin, Salamin & Cherry on Top) are more flashy and contrasty. With all that said, i hope that you don’t get discouraged to reacting to Bini and to PPop, or even OPM(Original Pinoy Music) artists. Philippines have a lot of talent to offer to the world music and performance and I’m glad that the world is starting to take notice.
I am glad to know them. I think MV doesn't come first but it also can be something important. In this industry, it is a part of the process. It is not a must for the song to have high quality MV but since the girls are so great in everything else i just think that maybe it would be better to have a high quality MV too.though right now, i understand the situation of the company. So we should wait a bit more. I understand your point too though.✨thank you for commenting 😉
For me, a high quality MV is nothing when you can't translate it in live and raw performances. And if I watch an MV, its the song itself, the melody and the lyrics is what makes me hook to it, not the visuals of the MV. MV is just an extra for the song, to give more meaning to the music amd the visuals of the singer when the real meaning and essence of the songs is already in the lyrics and melody of the song. I dont know if you get what I mean but that's how I interpret an MV for a song 😅 Anyways thank you for a BINI RV, they always slay 🌸
@@chicharongbulaklak2805 yeees exactly a good MV is a cherry on top for sure and since they are flawless in every aspect i think if they have even better MV's it would be better, cause they have the potential for it. Yes i get your point✨ Thank you for watching and commenting.❤️
MVs are subjective just like beauty. What you find beautiful I might find it so so. But for me the MVs that you've reacted so far are just right. Their production and creative staff are trying to find just the right balance between one's auditory and visual experience imho. And I think they've done a good job!
@@antoniobalentawak2599 the fact that you can't see the mv reaction i posted because it is blocked have made so much misunderstandings. If you could see the video you would see that i enjoyed watching it. It was a good MV but still had some place for improvement to match the groups potential. That's what i think though. Thank you for commenting.
Ok, have watched the whole video. I can tell you right now you wouldn't see BINI mvs as great as Aespa's mvs currently. I mean its not really fair to compare their mv's to someone like aespa who is in one of the top companies of kpop that has been doing this for decades now. BINI's company is new to the scene. Even country wise you cant compare it, just look at Korea's GDP against PH GDP 😆
just wanna say that Filipinos are naturally talented, Philippines won't be called the home of the best singers for nothing, even if they say they don't sing or dance, that's not true, or they say that because they don't do it professionally or something, but ever since they're born they're exposed to music already, (karaoke) Filipinos are musically inclined so forming a group to be recognized internationally is perfect
If you you're interested to know them, please check out BINI Chronicles first and their interview with Karen Davila after. Do not go straight into the documentary or guide videos cause you'll miss some stuff. Thank you for appreciating them. ❤
@@ItsRosieDays Please prepare some tissue. Few reactors were kinda mad that we didn't tell them they're gonna need it. Their interview is like the sequel of the BINI Chronicles. It's their first interview after they become popular. As you may know, they gained popularity just this year after their song 'Pantropiko' went viral on TikTok. They'll talk about their years being invisible to the public, their struggles and hardships especially during pandemic, their company shutting down and more. 😊
it was just a week ago when the bini born to win documentary was released so the struggles of the girls and their company is still so fresh to many fans so i see that you struck a nerve when you rate their MVs like that. with that being said, i totally get your point and i know you don’t mean no harm. it’s the opposite actually, you just wish the best for the girls because they deserve it. too bad the resources of their company is not that big compared to other kpop or western artists but they are doing their best. hopefully bini could really break into the international scene with their talent and for sure the budget will follow and they would afford to have world class MVs that would match their talent and worth.
@@chayE214 thank you for understanding what i meant, i had to explain the same thing over and over again in the past days. I wish them the best✨also thank you so much for the comment❤️❤️
wow your the first reactor i've watch who said those words, I would suggest you do your due diligence first about how BINI's management before you've said those stuff. and comparing the KARERA m/v to another KPOP m/v is a big nonono, do you even know what's the meaning of that song to a lot of people? thanks for the reaction though.
@@K3VZ-j1o i think some of you got the wrong idea about what i said, first of all i am new to p-pop and i'm starting to know BINI, they are great and now i know this is the best the company can do right now. I am pretty sure they will grow to be even better. But my point was that BINI have so much potential and the quality of their music videos could be better to match that. Though it's good to know they are under a good company and management. If you have watched the video you should know that i said i am not comparing the groups. Just the production power in the MV's. And the meaning of the song doesn't have to do anything with that. Thank you for watching and commenting though.
@@ItsRosieDays like i said lets do our due diligence first, if you only knew what that group and management went through. So if your are just riding the waves right now coz this group is making a lot of noise. Do some research first before you offend more people. Every group and management has some flaw and everything has factors. So if you dont know the facts. Lets avoid comparison. As what BINI Aiah said on their concert lets avoid comparison and have a peaceful world for everyone.
@@K3VZ-j1o Tama na po yan. Na sabi mo na gusto mo sabihin kaya tigil na po muna. Hwag ma trigger dahil lang sa opinyon ng iba. Pinapahiya mo lang ang Bini at mga kapwa pinoy. Pakiusap lang.
Kpop songs are heavily processed vocals. If thats what you mean by "high quality" music. I like how bini's songs just truly showcases their actual voices without being heavily process which makes them sound like the studio version while their live singing.
@@franzxiya i said music videos and even if i said music i think BINI is incredible in vocals that no one can doubt their vocals powers and one might doubt the quality of the music itself like lyrics and instrumentals and ...! Wich i think even in that part they don't seem to have any problems. I meant the MV's could have better qualities to match their potential.
Guys wag natin siyang ibash new reactor kasi siya eh sana maintindihan natin yun. Let's be kind to her. Hindi pa niya kilala masyado yung girls tsaka hindi niya pa alam yung kwento ng girls. So please stop bashing her. We can teach and guide her naman without bashing.
it's me again Miss Rosie I like your reactions..you're smiling throughout the video..😊seems you like it..anyways if you have time please have a check "Huwag muna tayong umuwi" wish bus performance..by the way if you keep reacting to BINI i'm very sure your subs will go up fast🙂..
React to bini song by a music video,dance practice and wish bus for each song you see something is bigger on each part from mv to dance practice to wish bus😅 you become blooms in no time😅
Hi Rosie! I just finished watching your 3-part reaction to Karera. I hope you check out my recommendations: CHERRY ON TOP 🍒 - PRESHOW KCON LA BINI (Jhoanna, the leader, not present, but they still slayed the performance) - Dance practice from STEEZY YT channel - Wish USA Bus performance Thanks for this RV 😊🥰
When you’re able to see the docuseries you would understand that the trial and error to get where they are. Ppop is still making noises compared to K-pop. The difference is that with the little resources that they have it really gave them the drive to get where they are now. International scene is the next step for the girls and happy to know you’re one of the many that’s in for the ride
@@Hannibearhugs i can't wait for them to grow bigger than they already are. I will watch the documentary soon. I think as you said with the little resources that they have they are doing a pretty great job at what they do. So proud of them.
@@ItsRosieDaysIt's too early for you to watch the documentary. I suggest getting to know them better first because there are so many facts that aren't in the documentary. You also won't understand their story fully because you don't know the context of what they're talking about. Even though the documentary was made for casuals as an introduction, many things are missing
Hi, I really love your honest reaction and criticism. Constructive criticism from others really helps someone to improve and grow. Please forgive my fellow blooms if somebody is being rude in the comments. On the music video, i would agree that the output could use some improvements. A great MV could really help an artist to he recognized. Honestly, this doesn't come close to KPOP MVs. However I would like to emphasize the improvements on their MVs, from the set design, concept and editing. Despite Bini being under a huge media company, the ABS-CBN, it is still a new company when it comes to promoting a pop idol group. Not to mention the financial crisis the company faced during the shutdown and the pandemic. The concept for me is good enough but i would agree with you that there still could be some improvement. In my opinion at least, their best MV is Salamin, Salamin. If you have time, i suggest you check this out. Additionally, i suggest 2 of their older songs "Born to Win" and "Strings". Thanks again for the reaction, we truly appreciate it. Also, please forgive my imperfect grammar.
@@sanzcamaso hi ✨that is fine, we should understand that we all have our own opinions and expectations towards everything. You have good points and i see where they come from. From a group that is somewhat new they are doing amazing. And the company is surely doing the best they can. And also thank you for the suggestions. I will definitely watch them❤️ thank you so much for your comment✨
NEW subscriber here I hope you will react to their MV stings because its on fire and its my favorite MV of Bini the live wish bus on fire and also the dance practice❤❤ And also react to their other mv Salamin salamin Pantropiko lagi I feel good Na na na Golden arrow Born to win The coconut And more
I understand why there are some stans triggered in comsec about the company not giving them justice. If you watch their docu, you'll know how much their company fought for them. These girl have faced too many struggles and challenges so did their company
@@starbyte984 yeah but i have said it multiple times that i am new to this group and P-pop overall. Like so many nice people in the comments that explained they could do the same, but not like this!
@@ItsRosieDays @ItsRosieDays I'm sorry about that. As a bloom myself, I can assure that they only said those things out of emotion, and they don't mean them personally. This is just a total misunderstanding, and they should have just told you in a nice way
Yeah most of their MVs does not have heavy CGI and SFX as their type of music does not really require those kind of highlights. Born to win has some heavy sfx and cgi
As usual, PPOP groups are being compared to KPOP groups. But who made KPOP the standard for POP music? While there are similarities, PPOP has its own distinct identity. In PPOP, talent and skills come first, followed by looks. In KPOP, it often seems that looks come first, then talent. Regarding music videos, they're made differently, too. You might not fully appreciate the 'Karera' MV if you're unfamiliar with BINI's story. And of course, the budget is a major factor-KPOP productions usually have much larger budgets than PPOP. The Philippines, especially in show business, isn't as financially strong as South Korea. We appreciate the comments and reactions, but if you really want to compare PPOP and KPOP groups, focus on their talent-vocals and dancing. Try to find a KPOP performance where the group sings and dances simultaneously, and live. Then, watch BINI's live vocal and dance practices ("Lagi" for example). The difference will speak for itself.
@@myjseven as i said in the video i never meant to compare. I just said i think they deserve to have better quality for their MV's cause they have so much potential in everything and they are flawless in every aspect. MV doesn't come first but can be a cherry on top of all the talents they have. I hope you understand my point now. Thanks for your comment.
I mean their company is one of the top entertainment company in PH, I think its the best company they could get here. With fairness, they seem pretty alright currently, the girls seems happy with their management. But you know a company is still a company so you cant really trust fully.
I think you should comment after watching the MV of Karera (or their other MVs for that matter). This is a dance practice video and not the official music video. And after watching this video, I don't know how you could suspect that their management does not do them justice. If you know their back story and how they were formed, you will appreciate more their management and the support they were given. By the way, if I were part of their management team, I would be insulted. I don't think that's a fair comment
@@MarcyTrinidad i have watched the Karera MV. Unfortunately it has been blocked . I uploaded the three videos together but the MV reaction isn't visible. If you have seen my cherry on top video reaction you would have known that i am new to p-pop . And my point was that, i think they are incredibly talented and they could have had better music videos that could match their potential. I have seen the MV, who watches a dance practice and comments on the MV? I saw the MV , live and dance practice , and this was just my opinion with all the information that i have by now from them .
@@ItsRosieDays As you say you are still new to PPop, then all the more it's unfair for you to judge their management on a few (maybe just MVs of 2 of their songs). I think their creative team did a very good job on Karera's MV. Also CoT and Pantropiko. Maybe after you watch 5+ MVs then you can decide whether their management isn't doing them justice to their vocals and dance skills. PS: Karera MV is nominated for Best Music Video in the annual Awit Awards, that's the award giving body by the Philippine Association of the Record Industry (PARI). Look it up.
You need to calm down, that's her opinion, most of us appreciates the MV and she just said that the MV could've been much better, that's just it, no insult there, you're too sensitive
@@ItsRosieDays Oh I'm calm... especially when the channel owner hearts a nice comment but if it's not to her liking, no heart there! Oh well... These are also my opinions since I have friends in ABS-CBN/Star Magic
@@ItsRosieDays please forgive these out-of-place comments. Most of them are children or teenagers brainwashed in social media with very little understanding of the world. They haven't been taught proper online manners. Even their idols, Bini, have a difficult time dealing with them.
Wag nyu agad e request yung documentary sa mga reactors na kaka simula plang. D rin nila ma appreciate yan ng todo, saka na ng ma d deep dive na tlga sila.
Blooms, please learn to differentiate the difference between an insulting comment and a constructive criticism. Let's take a negative feedback without being butthurt. The reactor is just simply giving her observations and opinions. There's nothing wrong with that.
her mentioning the management did not give justice to Bini is not a constructive criticism. She can always say something about the MV but calling out the management with that is so off. She didn't know what she's talking about.
@@seansanb5527 kakapanood lang kasi natin ng docu kaya there's the 'fire' to defend BINI now that we know the struggles of the girls and the management on a deeper level to get to this point. Kahit ako na off sa line nya na 'are they under fair company?' at 'Kpop trainees then what happened?' pero I chose to peace and kindness nalang lalo na at kakaumpisa palang nya mag react sa girls. For me for now okay sige pagbigyan pero yung mga susunod pa ng reax dun malalaman if into or not yung reactor 😅
Isn't it true their company doesn't do them justice? Not just BINI, but their artists in general. We all know the company's production is way behind compared to neighboring countries. Their stage, camera works and overall production didn't improve. It's also one of the main reasons why BINI took so long to gain popularity. If it weren't for TikTok and other platforms, we wouldn't have known BINI. Her rating for the production budget is kinda brutal though, but I totally understand why. She's used to K-pop, and is just new to P-pop. So please if you have something to say, tell her in a nice way. Let's respect her opinion and appreciate her honesty, cause it only proves she's being authentic. I understand where you're coming from, but don't let your emotions control you. Let's welcome everyone in our BINI journey, it's more fun than saying mean things. Love y'all ❤️
@@ninabarcelo1874 thank you for understanding my point , i didn't know their stories but now that i know a little bit it's more clear to me. Your opinion was interesting, you are the first who agreed with my point in the video😃. On some level you are right , we are a little used to K-pop quality MV's . Thank you so much for your comment , and being so nice✨❤️
@@ItsRosieDays You go girl. You're welcome, and we're here to guide you through. Don't let others affect what you have to say. A little story why I ended up with that opinion, since you find it interesting. It came to mind recently after BINI performed in China. The stage, camera works etc are something that the local entertainment industry is lacking. My frustrations about it grew after I came across a reactor reacting to a Disney produced thing called "A Night Of Wonder" with Disney+ wherein 3 local artists performed a Disney medley. I didn't have idea about it until out of curiosity, I clicked and watched the whole thing with her. Both of us were left in complete awe after. These artists can really take off if only given proper everything
@@ninabarcelo1874 that is exactly what i meant, they deserve even more. They have so much potential. But everyone says it is out of their companies hands, cause this is the best they can do. I don't know much yet. When i watch more videos and do more research about them i'll know. That's the reason why it was interesting for me what you said. So many people disagreed. Thanks for the comment❤️✨
Sobrang sensetibo naman kayong mga Blooms. Di naman pwede lahat na reactors gusto ang girls natin. Relax lang. Pinapakita ninyo lang gano ka-immature kayo. Pinapahiya ninyo ang Bini at mga kababayang Pinoy. Hwag nalang magkomento at lipat nalang sa ibang channel na puro lang pagpuri sa mga pinoy. Pakiusap lang.
you are quite wrong about their budget. they are supported by one of major tv stations in Philippines albeit they've been gutted by previous president . abs-cbn sold some of their properties to support bini. hence you see the they have paid big bucks to composers of cherry on top.. and you can see the qualitative progression of quality on their mvs. personally i dont like cherry on top.. its too commercially. bini already knows what their signature music is. pantropiko, karera, salamin, huwag na tayong umuwi . those songs have their bini music.. they need to pretty much go that way.. and not the cherry on top way. xg pretty much nailed their signature weird music.
@@MO-nj7tj i personally think that the quality of their music videos could be better. Since the potential that the group has is incredibly higher than this. In k-pop you can see so many groups that don't have half of the talent BINI have and the MV's are so high quality and better than this.
With ABS' tv and radio shutdown, BINi management/group had to work with a very limited but decent budget. its workable and higher than budget of other ppops. Born to Win (debut song) mv had a big budget but the rest was very tight. Big buget for Philippine setting bit nowhere near kpop level budget. It's just that BINi's mv producer and video edit co were creative in choosing locations and getting partners. E.g., Golden Arrow and Lagi. the bridge in GA was newly constructed and they just asked for permission using their connections in the tourism and provincial govt. That way they don't need to block traffic and pay huge fees to help them. Re Lagi, people think they had the sets made for that or paid a lot for cgi. They shot it in a theme park that was closed and just reopened. Even Cherry on Top, people thought Bini shot it in SF to target US market. yes it was for US market but it was actually just a hotel in the province in PH. That's pinoy ingenuity
@@peeenut with the budget they had which you say its somewhat workable they did a great job. I hope they grow along with the company. I will check the other mv's you mentioned, thanks for the explanation.
Not really. Abs did not sell properties for BINI. ABS decided to sell its real property and physical/traditional (non tv or internet related) businesses to the other shareholder faction in June this year I think. I guess BINI was a factor to the move to focus on internet-related business but the selling of properties was just recently and definitely not to fund BINI's mvs. Like any other group/show within the ABS organization, BINI only had a working budget which their management had to allocate for allowances of the girls and mv, shows etc. Now, ofc, it is different. BINI has real money now from endorsers, streams and content. Also, ABS will fully fund mv and concerts now bini being its crown jewel
I believe there is even talks now with Mattel (barbie). Warner also said to reached out Bini management. I don't know if its ost for Barbie 2 or its both barbie toy and movie
Thank you for your reaction. Just an opinion regarding Bini MV's not as high quality as others from Kpop. As with all MV's is impacted a lot by the budget. Bini's label is not as deep pocket and as the larger more established Kpop backed labels. Also, they cannot give an equal high budget to BINI as they are not comparatively as well known as the top established Kpop groups.
@@crxdelsolsir that is understandable i really hope they will take over and become even more internationally recognised.their company will definitely grow over time. They have chosen the right people. I didn't know about the situation of the company. Thank you for your comment✨
When you dig deeper, you understand more. But if you're looking for high-quality videos like K-pop, I think BINI is not for you. They are formed by pure talent, and their company sacrifices too. Maybe they are lacking in some aspects, but they fight for the girls, believe in them, and dream with them. I don’t know what kind of quality MV you’re looking for, and I don’t understand why you focus on the quality of the MV and not the song or the talent. Do you have an explanation for that?
@@MusicallyRex in my other videos of Karera i already said that they are extremely talented but in this video i meant, they are perfect in every way and even the MV was good but there is still room for improvement. Since they have everything and the potential a good MV could've been a cherry on top of everything else.
every choreographer and other reactor about this Karera dance practice they praise the blocking and synchronization how good it is, and you just said chaotic 😅😅 anyways no hate, just learn more about them.
@@coffeelover9165 yes the chaotic part was just about one second of it , how did you miss the part where i said i liked the choreo and the way they performed it, their foot work is strong and they are so synchronised? Thanks for the comment though😊
Yeah, Choreographers and dancers who reacted to the Karera dance practice love it, they even want to know who choreographed it. In a trained eyes that is not chaos, just a part of their blockings. No hate. Just saying..🤙
@@barbieborbe6060 i seriously wish you would understand that the part where i said chaos i meant the positions, and it was only for a second. That is something that i have seen in K-pop dances as well ,it just doesn't feel good to me . And i specifically showed you guys which part. Did you not hear the rest of what i said? I like the choreography and the way the girls performed it. It was so flawless. Their footwork was strong and their movements were firm. I was shocked when i found out they were trained for only two years cause they look professional.
it's a fair comparison, don't worry, just throw a constructive and informative comment sa kanya . so she can understand na wala pa sa standard ng kpop ang bini pero darating din tayo dun.
@@chicharongbulaklak2805 yes, definitely, haha sorry I should be more specific na sa MV and productions not in a raw talent. pero yung mga gantong reactors let's be mindful sa mga comments naten din, i mean nothing is wrong with your comment naman pero let's be more welcoming sa mga gantong reactors and call out yung ibang blooms not to bash but inform, educate and give a constructive comments sa mga reactors na katulad niya :) . in this way, we build a good community and support positively both reactors and bini :).
@@starbyte984 yes, and i actually really like the lyrics, i turned the sub on this time because you guys had told me to. The song is so meaningful and light. I loved it.
what do we know?! maybe he has already watched the MV and knows the meaning of the song, it's a dance practice so it's probably the dance that he should pay attention to and react to. hey stupid blooms I'm a pinoy too! don't show that bini's fans talk and behave like that, it's embarrassing.
LOL, comparing MVs in a dance practice video is so off. Next time react only how simple/complicated the choreo is. The fact you start comparing MVs from different groups, different genre and different management is very wrong. This is just your 2nd or 3rd reaction from Bini and you start comparing already. You don't know what you are talking. Karera is one of the best song of Bini and you doing this, good luck to you. Too early for you to say this. You saying if the management give them justice without even knowing the what they went through, what are the sacrifices that company did just for this group to survive. It is okay to provide feedback for improvements but start comparing with other groups when you only watch a few MVs is very wrong. If you will insist with your opinion then this is my opinion as well.
First of all my reaction video is a three part video including MV,Wish bus live, and the dance practice but since the MV reaction is blocked for now you can't see it. My dance practice video was the last part and i talked about all of the three videos at the end. So i didn't just watch the dance practice and react. Who does that?! And also i said it in the video and caption. What i say is based on what i have seen from them by now! And i asked you to suggest me the best MV that they have had so far so i can react to it later on. I said it multiple times. And about the comparing! I said it in the video i am not comparing the groups. It's better that you calm down a little bit and try to get my point. I said they are an amazing group. I am new to p-pop and BINI so still my informations are flawed. I shouldn't take classes and sit here and react. I wanna learn little by little. And like so many other people in the comments you could've just corrected me. I didn't know about the company . But so many nice blooms told me about. I like having conversations with people here. And it's not a big deal. Let's not take everything thattttt serious when someone clearly doesn't mean anything by it. I believe in BINI. They are an amazing group with so much more potential. And all said was that the MV could've been better to match their potential.
@@ItsRosieDays we are talking about the management here when you mentioned are they giving justice? Really? and it is not a big deal? You just don't know what you are talking. I'm not questioning the talent of Bini because I know how talented they are. As I mentioned if you will insist with your reaction be it and I will do mine as well.
@@ItsRosieDays girl read all the comments in this reaction, reflect on what the people are saying. eat your words once you know the story of what the management sacrificed just to continue this project.
I know what you mean by them being supertalented but the company they're with is not enough. It's because that company has been known for catering only to the Philippine market for decades and they are only starting to go international with very limited budget. I do believe that in the hands of a big Korean Kpop company, they can truly achieve international stardom faster. Anyway, check our "Strings", which I prefer as it shows their fierceness. It's also more Kpop.
@@Steven_speaks Remember they don't have a TV network anymore, so I'm sure they're being wise about spending. Also, top K-pop budget for managing and promoting their talents are in $100 M to $400 M range. Still, if they only spent $20M per group, this is still money that ABS may not want to gamble since they don't have a TV station anymore.
@@kalag7447 yes but it is something that can be like cherry on top above all the effort they put into their work. They are perfect at every aspect why not get even better, you know.
I'm confused, I don't know if I'm here for our 8 Young Women BINI or just for you @Rosie Days 🫀🌸🫠🥹☺️ Always remember, you are beautiful inside and out. 🫶🏻
![Professional Dancer Reacts To BINI "Karera" [Practice + Performance]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Bkj_J20oAoA/mqdefault.jpg)
![FIRST TIME REACTING TO BINI 'Karera' Dance Practice [WAIT A MINUTE!!!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/y1xqCZuHfn4/mqdefault.jpg)
They trained for 2 years.
Yes, they have trained under Korean coaches but only for around 3 or 4 months. Everything is all under Filipino labors.
P-POP (Philippine POP) is new. P-POP is still searching for international recognition. They still don’t have this high budget productions compare to K-POP which is multiple times bigger already.
As BINI becomes bigger they are paving the way for P-POP to be notice. If you check out old K-POP there production value of their M/V is not as good as they have now.
As they become bigger BINI M/Vs will become more better too.
@@jojobiketech1674 i can't wait for that day✨and for two years of training they are amazingly well trained
* 4 years
I think Bini Sheena said they train like 4 years.
@@coffeelover9165
How it becomes 4 years? The Star Hunt began on 2019. They debut on 2021. Their pre debut song came out on 2020..
Only thing is even they debut they still continue to train. Even until now. That is why BINI keep getting better.
@@jojobiketech1674 dont know, I just watched the one Sarah Geronimo and Bini Sheena met.
they're just getting their recognition now...within the past few months their subscriber base internationally has grown significantly due to Cherry on top which was international target base. They have other music videos such as Salamin Salamin and Lagi, but i would also like to understand the meaning of 'music video video can be better' - like in which areas?
Also i think times are changing. Ppop is changing the playing field in which the consumers are now asking "OK, i see that they have a great music video... they have a great fully well produced song. But could they perform it live?'
A lot of content released in the west and in kpop didn't really focus on the live singing aspect of things, so their music videos and sound mastering is really big budget. Today, i think the filipinos have interestingly changed perception and taste as the focus over there is all about vocals. It was interesting to see that during the Asian Artist Awards of 2023, that a lot of the performances there mainly focused on the choreography. However, it's opened pandoras box when SB19 did their opener for the show and gave the KPOP idols a performance a "What are we watching?" look on their faces, possibly being intimidated due to the high level/calibre of the performance they've jus witness. Like i definitely would not want to go next 🤣🤣
So when PPOP groups perform - it's live including the vocals. This has probably thrown a wrench into KPOP choreos as it's not something that's normally done. However, now the Filipinos are brought into playingfield performing live such as in Kcon, and Billboard of Asia awards in Korea and previously mentioned the AAA. This is great as it pushes for healthy competition between the idols as it forces them to get out of their comfort zones.
If these groups we're just finding out about from the Philippines are showing us the level that they're performing is like this, then why can't we do it too. They totally changed the scene as previously it's all about the music videos...now there's different factors due to the wishbus. This is how it is in the Philippines because of the high standards on vocals vs evertyhing else. This crfitique is no longer just being viewed by the Filipinos but it's now gaining traction around the world as it's.
Yes, music videos is how it attracts the people to pay attention to the group and what they got like a resume. but a lot of that comes from budget as well. What i'm seeing now are groups getting recognition due to their performances and not via their music videos. And it's totally the other way around now in which they get funding from their performances that they're finally able to then create high budget music video.
Anwyways, that's just my general feedback. If you're new to ppop, i think you'll see what i mean later :)
@@partyeslife8157 i get your point. Honestly i listen to good music not paying that much attention to vocals , as i said in my cherry on top reaction, but at the same time i really do love live performances and i get so much more emotional listening to live performances. And my point about the MV was about BINI being perfect in every aspect possible! And i just think that they deserve to have high quality music videos. Sets,clothes and everything else. And i don't mean there was something wrong in the Music Video. I wish my MV Reaction wasn't blocked so everyone could see how much I actually enjoyed it, but i think it could get even better to match the potential they have.
Thank you for the explanation.✨
@@ItsRosieDays no worries :) have you tried looking into starting a patreon? it's another alternative for people when videos get blocked, they publish their content there. not sure if you need to pay patreon or what or if you could offer the free patreon for your subs or what. but yeah good luck on the UA-cam content creator journey!
@@partyeslife8157 thank you so much. I might join patreon later. I have it in mind. ✨
@@ItsRosieDays idk, I like Karera M/V, I think it fits very well with the song. I wouldn't have changed anything. I would've agreed if it is one of the earlier MVs but Karera I thought is amazingly done. I guess its a matter of preference, wish I could see your MV reaction soon.
@@veerand7038yeah, the Fandom (blooms) loves the Karera MV, it fits the songs message. Maybe because this reactor doesn't understand the meaning of the song that's why she doesn't appreciate it.
'Strings', Golden Arrow and 'Born to Win'. These are some of their hidden gems. ❤
Bini is an Elite group. Every single member can be Main Vocalist , Main Dancee , Rapper and Visual
@@Stanbiniph-8 wow✨
@@ItsRosieDays Yes that's true. In this group Position Doesn't matter because as per Jhoanna thier leader every single member can do what other member can do also.
@@Stanbiniph-8 i have literally seen that in the few videos I've seen from them.multi talented!
@@ItsRosieDays We (blooms) are excited to watch more Bini Reaction Video here on you channel 😊
@@Stanbiniph-8 thank u babe☺️✨
Thanks for the awesome review! It’s fair, especially since you mostly cover K-pop. Comparing it to aespa and other K-pop videos might give lower ratings, but for a company just starting in P-pop and international music, they’ve really done well! looking forward for more reviews like this! :) I also recommend checking out their documentary. They’re a pandemic P-pop group, and their company lost it's franchise, so it was tough for them at the beginning, but they persevered and inspired people with their journey from nothing to winning.
@@LDRXTV09 i actually would love to watch documentary. I will talk about it in the my next videos when i watch it. I am curious. Thank you for the comment❤️
@@ItsRosieDays Please don’t engage with the toxic comments. some are came from other fandom of another P-pop or kpop group that thrives on fan wars and negativity. They aren’t genuinely a Blooms and seem to want to discourage reactors from liking BINI. hopefully you're not discourage to do more content like this
@@LDRXTV09 thank you for saying this, actually i don't care that much,i just do me! It doesn't matter what some people say when most of you are okay with the RV that i posted.
It just gets annoying sometimes 🤦🏻♀️
BINI 🔛🔝
MV, Wish bus and dance practice perfect combo.
They are so versatile and try different genre..
Salamin Salamin
String
Golden Arrow
Born to win (Debut)
Lagi (local and dance practice)
Thank you for reacting😊
it is much easier to produce a top-tier music video (just throw money at it) than to create an 8-member girl group where each member is a great vocalist and dancer, and especially with Bini, has great chemistry with each other (you can see their genuine smiles). Additionally, although there are 4 main rappers, all of them can rap. Among them, the role "visuals" does not mean anything - you cannot join any Philippine girl group (or boy group) if you cannot sing well. But they are all beautiful. Good ingredients are hard to find.
@@bobbyv7042 i completely agree with you.a better mv could be the cherry on top though. ☺️🤔✨
thanks for your reactions - unfortunately the Karera MV seems to have been blocked. Please react to their other hits - Salamin Salamin, Lagi, Strings, Golden Arrow. Where available, please also react to the respective dance practices and Wish107.5 performances.
Yes the mv is blocked but sometimes it happens and after hours it's fixed. So i am hoping this will happen with this one as well.
I will keep your suggestions in mind❤️
@@ItsRosieDaysI’ve noticed other people either watermark or change the opacity of the mv so that it can pass the UA-cam restriction
@@Gfilam great, thank you so much
up
Up
The PPOP GIRLS IDOLS PHILIPPINES should be loved and promoted and reacted to learn the true and good Bini not only groups in the PPOP and show the talent of singing, dancing locally and internationally. ❤️❤️❤️
@@rsllpn9193 they are literally amazing. I really want to know them better😍
Blooms attendance
Wow keep it up on reacting to Bini 😊
There are so many of their songs that I think you would like Lagi, Salamin Salamin, Pantropiko 😊 and their dance practices too.
@@jochval thanks for the suggestion 😍
And the wish bus performances🫶🌸
we always love your reaction videos with BINI, you gotta dive more deeper, they are so chaotic and fun with their each personalities. 🥰🔥
@@SEVN_1795 i think watching their documentary will help me know them alot better✨thanks for watching btw❤️
oh Yes Brilliant, Yes Please it's a Must ❤️
Another reaction is much better and we really appreciate this so much sweetie. Same thing we want to say that those girls deserve more because their talent since in the beginning is really giving. They improve endlessly and at the same time their smiles makes us smiles too. Whenever we get stress, just watching their clips can lift us. You already see how they enjoy their dance practice because these song Karera is one of their fave song in their album, how much more we, blooms, everyday listening these to motivate ourselves. Thank you sweetie for this wonderful reaction. We hope to watch more of these, it makes us happy on how you guys appreciate their flaws and talents.
@@rabiyahabdulkhabir2601 you are such a sweat soul. Thank you for understanding my points and being so nice❤️they are absolutely amazing and talented . I am happy to know them.
Thank you for your honest review... for sure they will improve and excel more in the global crowd 👍👍
@@maryjanebaldo6462 and thank YOU for watching and commenting babe✨
Thanks for this RV 🥰🌸
Thank you for watching✨
❤❤❤❤bini🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭
Have you noticed that they incorporate a sign language in their choreo, pls do watch Pantropiko, Salamin Salamin, Golden Arrow, strings & many more, thank you for a good RV & loving Buni❤❤❤❤❤
@@alegrianatividad8669 yes someone told me in the comments😍that is amazing.
I will have more BINI reaction videos.😉
Welcome to the Biniverse!!
Thank you😍
Welcome to BINIverse
@@straferboii thanks😍✨
Maybe because the company they were under was shutdown, so the progress of them being shown to people was a little slow. But salute to the management on pushing through in supporting Bini because i guess they really believe in the girls talents. I suggest you watch their documentary Chapter 1 "Born to win". There is more in Bini than just talents.😊
@@kalitabujara2291 oh so they have a documentary too. I'm curious now
Hey, stop. It's too early for her to watch that documentary. She needs to know the girls more before watching the documentary
@@ItsRosieDaysI suggest finishing their discography first, or at least getting to know them better, before watching the documentary. For sure, u won't understand what's happening without knowing them
@@heavensky8706 oh thanks for the tip. I will watch it later then✨
@@peeenut 🥲🥲
BTW great reaction. New subscriber here. Looking forward for your next BINI reactions. 🤙🤙🤙
@@kdm374 thanks for subscribing ✨
thank you for your reactions, thers a lot of videos or guide if you want to know them 1by1, they have good ❤
they have motivational characters ma'am, all bini members are good people ang i know you will love them if you know them better
@@jayceeyabut-m9w thank you for your comment. Sure i actually wanted to do that cause i do wanna know them better
1:51 I guess that's ok because it's like a transition from one formation to another. so that's the style of BINI's choreo where moments where they highlight a singer doing a move on her own, and the rest are divided into 2 groups doing 2 different moves but still locked in the musicality and then go back to doing one move altogether again.They use a lot of isolation, levels, asymmetrical formations and dominoes. You will see a lot of these 'chaotic' moments 😆 when you see more of their dance practices. A lot of professional dancers reacted to this already and they didn't notice this part, its just a matter of seconds so that doesn't make this a bad choreo. No need to be nitpicky. You are entitled to your opinion though.
BINI is managed by ABS CBN, one of the biggest media companies in the Philippines yet they just started to get into quality MVS for Bini like you see in Cherry on Top using a bit og CGI. They starting to collaborate with International music producers and hopefully they can have more budgets and work with better VFX companies and directors. This is the same situation in our film industry. Sadly, Philippines, although Filipinos are artistic when it comes to music, fashion, art, dance, it is still a poor country compared to Korea, which is more of a developed country, companies like SM entertainment, YG, HYBE they spend big budgets on MVs. I know BINI will somehow improve gradually in every comeback but will not get into high budget CGI MVs drastically. You won't see any of those soon if that is your expectation.
You need to look at the business side of things where they need to manage and establish funds for the group and management first before spending a lot on budgets. They barely just got famous exponentially this year around just last March I think.
Armaggedon is not even the 'best' MV for me as it is effects-driven. People might even forget it in the future. You can see a lot of music videos from the 80's and 90's will have simple or no effects at all but became iconic and considered as the best MVs of all time because of the storytelling, the art direction, the way it created a cultural impact to different generations over the years. Best MVs for me is something that people will not forget. A timeless, classic masterpiece.
I'm not sure about your rating system as I don't know what your basis and criteria is? You didn't explained it much. Theres more to appreciating art and good music videos than having bigger budgets and cgis. Sometimes less is more. I know all of this as I work as an Art Director on tv commercials, film for social, events and worked with different production companies internationally for decades.
No way BINI is going to be handled by a 'bigger' international label. ABS-CBN won't let them. Last time the Koreans handled the Ppop group, SB19, it turned ugly, they parted ways, and the Boyband decided to self manage their group under 1Z entertainment which is going well and growing. Their mission is to help Ppop groups be known to the world. Ppop groups here help and support each other doing a lot of collabs.
All we know that BINI is on the right track in the right company. If you watch their documentary you will see how they are well taken care of during a long journey of struggles, especially during the pandemic.
So, dont get me wrong but before you make any more comments about the group, I suggest you dig deeply and understand where they are coming from, otherwise, you will get a lot of bashing from The Blooms as they are a big global community. Understanding the Ppop culture, style will also help. It is just new and emerging. But its ok to give constructive feedback that make sense to the general blooms (it has to make sense lol) and I promise you this. Just make The Blooms happy and they will love you back with more views, likes, comments and subscriptions. 😄
I recommend 2 videos to start with: Karen Davila interview with BINI and Born to Win documentary, which got released recently.
They are a pure Filipino group managed by a pure Filipino company. We Filipinos take pride on this. That's why they are dubbed as, "The Nation's Girl Group!"
I hope this helps.
She’s looking for chaotic part as she mentioned, rather than appreciating the musicality. 'Karera' is one of the best choreographies I’ve seen, and I know a choreography is top-tier when professional dancers ask who the choreographer is. For example, I used Steezy's choreography for comparison they choreographed 'Cherry on Top,' but the dancers I know weren’t too impressed by it. They liked it, but not enough to ask who choreographed it, and they analyzed it briefly compared to BINI’s choreography, where the analysis lasted almost 50 minutes or more
@@faithfuldays3886 thank you so much for the explanation. I get your point.we all have our own opinions.
What you said is well explained✨
Eeeyyy 🤙🤙🤙
Kalmahan lang natin blooms. Respetuhin naman natin siya. Bagong reactor lang siya oh di pa nga niya kilala yung girls at yung kwento ng bawat isa eh. We can educate and teach her naman without bashing. Wag yung ganito na bash tayo ng bash. Please please be kind to her.
Hindi naman siya binabash ng blooms. Ineducate lang. Ganda kaya ng Karera MV. Kahit ang mga BINI girls, very emotional sila nung nag react sila sa MV nila nato. The MV fits the message of the song.
We have to respect her opinions. She has been watching a lot of korean MV' s and that is why she has high standards. Bini's MV's are getting better and better but they are not yet quite up there with other korean MV productions as they are still growing in popularity.
bini + rosie?? stunning! 😌
@@pendragon27 thanks honey✨❤️
Yes like me a non dancer at first I taught their dancing is chaotic until real choreographers and dancers explained things in detail how intricate and hard their movement then I start to see the beauty and synchronization.
@@valleysofdreams everything about the choreo and their movement was perfect. The part where i said it seems chaotic is the position of all of them and not the dance itself. Not only them but some choreographers use this technique and it is just not my taste. And it was only for a few brief seconds. That's it
@@ItsRosieDaysdidn’t mean to offend you but I like you replying to each one of us. Your review is valuable 😊
@@valleysofdreams none taken☺️✨i like connecting with you guys
Check out 'Born to Win'. I believe it's their highest-budgeted MV
I will watch it then😍
@@ItsRosieDays maybe in your next reaction? 😊
no i dont think so, no way its higher budget than Cherry On Top or Salamin Salamin. And their makeup and wardrobe game is way above currently than the past
@@starbyte984 it's a good choice, though i have so many options on my plate. But i will definitely react to it😉
6:36 - There were several factors why the group was not well-known and did not reach a wide Filipino audience earlier. First of all, the COVID-19 pandemic hit the company, along with the Philippine Congress not allowing the renewal of their free-to-air franchise. This led to the company being forced to cut 11,000 employees. This was followed by the shutdown of the company's local music radio stations, which prevented the airing of their music. As a result, the group and the company were forced to find alternatives, such as using social media to promote the group.
I think you need yo watch the born to win documentary. You will appreciate them more and the support the company given to them.
@@edzh i will😍
The MV of 'Karera' for me is perfectly fine. It's not as high quality as K-pop, but the feel of the MV perfectly suits the message of the song. Actually, I prefer that kind of MV over lots of CGI effects and flashy things happening because it doesn’t resonate with the message of the song. And don't worry-as BINI keeps getting bigger, their MVs will have higher production, just like in 'Cherry on Top.' In their past MVs, they had a low budget. I suggest not expecting too much about the MV since P-pop is just getting started, but someday it will get bigger. We'll get there, and BINI is the starting point
@@heavensky8706 yes this type of songs don't match with CGI effects and people don't have to pay to much to get there , i just think that there was still some space for improvement.overall i really enjoyed watching the MV.
Now i know the story so i won't be expecting much and just enjoying. But i will have my honest opinion said though.☺️
Thanks for the comment.
Since u already watched their cherry on top MV. I guess you should react next their wish bus and dance practice :)
@@shailazaro8259 good idea
@@ItsRosieDays thanks, ma'am! Waiting for it!
New subscriber here from Philippines. 🤗
Thank you for subscribing 😉✨
Kpop fans are contented to only watched MV but Ppop fans always look forward to LIVE Performances.
@@mikepadz1976 no it is not about being content with just the mv , but having a good MV is also a part of the process so it can be important, especially when the group deserves a better quality in their MV's. When you have it all also having a good MV can be the cherry on top.
@@ItsRosieDays majority of the BINI Fandom loves that Karera MV, especially the BINI girls themselves.. they were emotional reacting to that MV. Me personally loves Karera MV out of all their MVs' because of the meaning/message of the song and also they just look happy on it. Especially the part where they are running towards the sunset, I think that is very beautiful. They didn't used green screens for the music video. Also,maybe because you don't understand the meaning of the song that's why you don't appreciate the music video.
@@ItsRosieDays I think KARERA is a good MV , I don't know about your preferences but I want to tell you that Millions of blooms love that MV,
@@barbieborbe6060 i reacted to the MV as well and i loved the lyrics and also the MV was so lovely and light and made me happy
All i am saying is that there is still room for progress.
As I read the comments, I honestly wonder if some commenters are Blooms because BINI has so many bashers from other fandoms trying to bring them down. So I hope you understand and don’t get offended. Just continue to dig deeper into BINI and don’t expect too much
@@heavensky8706 i love the girls already and i don't care that much about the comments. It just shows how many people know them and follows them, bloom or not. Don't worry we will have more BINI videos.😉✨
@@ItsRosieDaysThank you so much for continuing your BINI journey you will love the girls don't mind them like he said BINI has a lot of Basher from other fandom I understand about the poor quality of the production of their Music Video but the MV of Karera are supposed to be like that the message of the song and the summery vibe the nature fits it well. Try Salamin Salamin, Pantropiko, Strings, and I Feel Good and try to react with 1 song like Strings MV/ their Dance Practice and Wish bus live performance in all thanks I love your reactions to BINI.
Thank you for your comment ❤️
It is so low to try bring a gg down like that, some people!🤦🏻♀️
I understand your points.
I will try to have more three part reaction but i also might do singles.
Their company is still in baby phase when it comes to making music videos since BINI is their first ever girl group
Thanks so much .... Mikha is our top 1 but we do love the 8
@@SHKUNIONshkunion she is so gorgeous 🥺✨
Thanks
BINI hasn't stopped training even after their debut; they continue to train daily as part of their routine. They are hardworking girls. When P-pop started, no one supported it. Even after gaining international recognition alongside other groups, Filipinos remained close-minded about P-pop. Our music is dominated by hip-hop, ballads, bands, and Western artists, so it’s hard to introduce a new genre. As a result, all P-pop groups went into **nugudom** for many years, including BINI. They experienced being bashed and compared to K-pop, and they were even asked to their faces, "Who are you?" BINI is a miracle in P-pop; no other group has managed to break into the mainstream except BINI. If you know their story, you will understand how they crawled their way to the top
@@bananajam1356 i will start to know them better slowly. It's okay, always someone has to pave the way. So many similar thing's like this happened to K-pop artists as well. So many big groups were unrecognised back then. But now...
I'm sure BINI will be a known great group someday.✨
More bini reaction
Sure😉✨
Hahaha,as what i notice naka lock na si reactor sa KPOP style eh, may sariling style and ibang ASIAN country and di lahat gagayahin ang KPOP Style, kaya naninibago to at parang ang standard nya ay katulad ng KPOP dapat eh kaya ganun di yta nya alam yung mga style ng pag sayaw like domino effect and wave and different formations ng mga sayaw kya ganun. Hayaan nyo na guys, baka iba lang talaga gusto nya, kung ako diko ipagpipilitan yung gusto ko, para gustuhin nya, Hahaha, pero di nako magsasayang para pilitin sya eh^^. dapat natural lang na magustuhan nila yung artist, walang pilitan. TY na lang po^^.
gusto nya talaga un maganda MV kahit nakakaumay tunog
@@L4wD-4U as i said in the video i am not only talking about kpop but every MV that i have seen by now. i completely accept that they have their own style, all i said was that they could have had better MV's and the they have some room for improvement.
@@ItsRosieDayswell I don't know about your preferences of what a GOOD MV is, but personally, I think KARERA is a good MV.. especially if you understand the meaning of the song.. millions of blooms (BINI Fandom) loves that MV that's why I will not be surprised if they will react negatively of what you just said in this reaction video. No hate, just saying...peace🤙
For us Filipinos, we don’t really care much about MVs, well for me anyway. We are used to listening and watching talent on TV or radio, this why the Wish Bus is there so artists can showcase their vocal talent. I think that nowadays, especially, younger generations are into visual satisfaction, aka flashy high budget MVs. This is also prolly why Bini’s 2 latest MVs (Salamin, Salamin & Cherry on Top) are more flashy and contrasty. With all that said, i hope that you don’t get discouraged to reacting to Bini and to PPop, or even OPM(Original Pinoy Music) artists. Philippines have a lot of talent to offer to the world music and performance and I’m glad that the world is starting to take notice.
I am glad to know them. I think MV doesn't come first but it also can be something important. In this industry, it is a part of the process. It is not a must for the song to have high quality MV but since the girls are so great in everything else i just think that maybe it would be better to have a high quality MV too.though right now, i understand the situation of the company. So we should wait a bit more.
I understand your point too though.✨thank you for commenting 😉
Maybe they wanted to make it simple so people will focus more on song and its beautiful meaning. Try checking out Salamin Salamin. ❤
@@paramoret8277 maybe✨thanks for the suggestion.
Bini hip hop dancer❤
For me, a high quality MV is nothing when you can't translate it in live and raw performances. And if I watch an MV, its the song itself, the melody and the lyrics is what makes me hook to it, not the visuals of the MV. MV is just an extra for the song, to give more meaning to the music amd the visuals of the singer when the real meaning and essence of the songs is already in the lyrics and melody of the song. I dont know if you get what I mean but that's how I interpret an MV for a song 😅 Anyways thank you for a BINI RV, they always slay 🌸
@@chicharongbulaklak2805 yeees exactly a good MV is a cherry on top for sure and since they are flawless in every aspect i think if they have even better MV's it would be better, cause they have the potential for it. Yes i get your point✨
Thank you for watching and commenting.❤️
You're so amazing and Beutifull 🤭✨✌️❤❤
Omg thank you❤you are so sweet
MVs are subjective just like beauty. What you find beautiful I might find it so so. But for me the MVs that you've reacted so far are just right. Their production and creative staff are trying to find just the right balance between one's auditory and visual experience imho. And I think they've done a good job!
@@antoniobalentawak2599 the fact that you can't see the mv reaction i posted because it is blocked have made so much misunderstandings. If you could see the video you would see that i enjoyed watching it. It was a good MV but still had some place for improvement to match the groups potential. That's what i think though. Thank you for commenting.
I see BINI reaction video, I like and subscribe 🤙🤙🤙
Try Lagi dance and vocal practice
@@mcky0130 so many of you are suggesting Lagi! I'm interested now🤔✨
Ok, have watched the whole video. I can tell you right now you wouldn't see BINI mvs as great as Aespa's mvs currently. I mean its not really fair to compare their mv's to someone like aespa who is in one of the top companies of kpop that has been doing this for decades now. BINI's company is new to the scene. Even country wise you cant compare it, just look at Korea's GDP against PH GDP 😆
just wanna say that Filipinos are naturally talented, Philippines won't be called the home of the best singers for nothing, even if they say they don't sing or dance, that's not true, or they say that because they don't do it professionally or something, but ever since they're born they're exposed to music already, (karaoke) Filipinos are musically inclined so forming a group to be recognized internationally is perfect
If you you're interested to know them, please check out BINI Chronicles first and their interview with Karen Davila after. Do not go straight into the documentary or guide videos cause you'll miss some stuff. Thank you for appreciating them. ❤
@@paramoret8277 i saw the Chronicles in their youtube channel and i was curious, i will watch them soon😍✨
@@ItsRosieDays Please prepare some tissue. Few reactors were kinda mad that we didn't tell them they're gonna need it. Their interview is like the sequel of the BINI Chronicles. It's their first interview after they become popular. As you may know, they gained popularity just this year after their song 'Pantropiko' went viral on TikTok. They'll talk about their years being invisible to the public, their struggles and hardships especially during pandemic, their company shutting down and more. 😊
@@paramoret8277 🥺i'm happy they are in a better place now.thanks for the tips
Pls react to ultimate guide to BINI 2024❤
ya ma'am i think if you watch this you will love them❤❤
it was just a week ago when the bini born to win documentary was released so the struggles of the girls and their company is still so fresh to many fans so i see that you struck a nerve when you rate their MVs like that. with that being said, i totally get your point and i know you don’t mean no harm. it’s the opposite actually, you just wish the best for the girls because they deserve it. too bad the resources of their company is not that big compared to other kpop or western artists but they are doing their best. hopefully bini could really break into the international scene with their talent and for sure the budget will follow and they would afford to have world class MVs that would match their talent and worth.
@@chayE214 thank you for understanding what i meant, i had to explain the same thing over and over again in the past days.
I wish them the best✨also thank you so much for the comment❤️❤️
wow your the first reactor i've watch who said those words, I would suggest you do your due diligence first about how BINI's management before you've said those stuff. and comparing the KARERA m/v to another KPOP m/v is a big nonono, do you even know what's the meaning of that song to a lot of people? thanks for the reaction though.
@@K3VZ-j1o i think some of you got the wrong idea about what i said, first of all i am new to p-pop and i'm starting to know BINI, they are great and now i know this is the best the company can do right now. I am pretty sure they will grow to be even better. But my point was that BINI have so much potential and the quality of their music videos could be better to match that. Though it's good to know they are under a good company and management. If you have watched the video you should know that i said i am not comparing the groups. Just the production power in the MV's. And the meaning of the song doesn't have to do anything with that.
Thank you for watching and commenting though.
@@ItsRosieDays like i said lets do our due diligence first, if you only knew what that group and management went through. So if your are just riding the waves right now coz this group is making a lot of noise. Do some research first before you offend more people. Every group and management has some flaw and everything has factors. So if you dont know the facts. Lets avoid comparison. As what BINI Aiah said on their concert lets avoid comparison and have a peaceful world for everyone.
@@K3VZ-j1o Tama na po yan. Na sabi mo na gusto mo sabihin kaya tigil na po muna. Hwag ma trigger dahil lang sa opinyon ng iba. Pinapahiya mo lang ang Bini at mga kapwa pinoy. Pakiusap lang.
@@K3VZ-j1o Narcissist kaba? New blooms are always OA af. You might be a kid also.
Kpop songs are heavily processed vocals. If thats what you mean by "high quality" music. I like how bini's songs just truly showcases their actual voices without being heavily process which makes them sound like the studio version while their live singing.
@@franzxiya i said music videos and even if i said music i think BINI is incredible in vocals that no one can doubt their vocals powers and one might doubt the quality of the music itself like lyrics and instrumentals and ...! Wich i think even in that part they don't seem to have any problems. I meant the MV's could have better qualities to match their potential.
Guys wag natin siyang ibash new reactor kasi siya eh sana maintindihan natin yun. Let's be kind to her. Hindi pa niya kilala masyado yung girls tsaka hindi niya pa alam yung kwento ng girls. So please stop bashing her. We can teach and guide her naman without bashing.
it's me again Miss Rosie I like your reactions..you're smiling throughout the video..😊seems you like it..anyways if you have time please have a check "Huwag muna tayong umuwi" wish bus performance..by the way if you keep reacting to BINI i'm very sure your subs will go up fast🙂..
Thank you, you are so sweet ✨I will check it out
React to bini song by a music video,dance practice and wish bus for each song you see something is bigger on each part from mv to dance practice to wish bus😅 you become blooms in no time😅
@@KilluaZoldyk-in3gs i am planning to have more reactions to their songs😍
Try STRING IN WISH BUS AND DANCE PRACTICE❤❤❤
Hi Rosie! I just finished watching your 3-part reaction to Karera. I hope you check out my recommendations:
CHERRY ON TOP 🍒
- PRESHOW KCON LA BINI (Jhoanna, the leader, not present, but they still slayed the performance)
- Dance practice from STEEZY YT channel
- Wish USA Bus performance
Thanks for this RV 😊🥰
Thank you for watching. Sure i'll check them out😉✨
When you’re able to see the docuseries you would understand that the trial and error to get where they are. Ppop is still making noises compared to K-pop. The difference is that with the little resources that they have it really gave them the drive to get where they are now. International scene is the next step for the girls and happy to know you’re one of the many that’s in for the ride
@@Hannibearhugs i can't wait for them to grow bigger than they already are. I will watch the documentary soon. I think as you said with the little resources that they have they are doing a pretty great job at what they do. So proud of them.
Can you please tell me where i can witch the documentary?
@@ItsRosieDaysIt's too early for you to watch the documentary. I suggest getting to know them better first because there are so many facts that aren't in the documentary. You also won't understand their story fully because you don't know the context of what they're talking about. Even though the documentary was made for casuals as an introduction, many things are missing
2:56--2:58 dance step is a sign language; Bini uses sign language in their dance steps
Oh wow , i didn't know that? Do you know what it means?
@@ItsRosieDays "Buhay ay 'di Karera" is Tagalog for "Life is not a race", which was being signed here
@@ItsRosieDays buhay ay di karera = life is not a race
that's the line where they incorporated sign language with their choreo.
@@apaulmarq thats so cool. Thanks for the info
@@bobbyv7042 thanks✨
Sa susunod na reaction nto positive na lahat 😂😂 di na kami naniniwala. 😎🤙
Hi, I really love your honest reaction and criticism. Constructive criticism from others really helps someone to improve and grow. Please forgive my fellow blooms if somebody is being rude in the comments.
On the music video, i would agree that the output could use some improvements. A great MV could really help an artist to he recognized. Honestly, this doesn't come close to KPOP MVs. However I would like to emphasize the improvements on their MVs, from the set design, concept and editing. Despite Bini being under a huge media company, the ABS-CBN, it is still a new company when it comes to promoting a pop idol group. Not to mention the financial crisis the company faced during the shutdown and the pandemic. The concept for me is good enough but i would agree with you that there still could be some improvement.
In my opinion at least, their best MV is Salamin, Salamin. If you have time, i suggest you check this out.
Additionally, i suggest 2 of their older songs "Born to Win" and "Strings".
Thanks again for the reaction, we truly appreciate it. Also, please forgive my imperfect grammar.
@@sanzcamaso hi ✨that is fine, we should understand that we all have our own opinions and expectations towards everything.
You have good points and i see where they come from. From a group that is somewhat new they are doing amazing. And the company is surely doing the best they can. And also thank you for the suggestions. I will definitely watch them❤️ thank you so much for your comment✨
NEW subscriber here I hope you will react to their MV stings because its on fire and its my favorite MV of Bini the live wish bus on fire and also the dance practice❤❤
And also react to their other mv
Salamin salamin
Pantropiko
lagi
I feel good
Na na na
Golden arrow
Born to win
The coconut
And more
@@jamesnicolescabarte729 sure✨😉
I understand why there are some stans triggered in comsec about the company not giving them justice. If you watch their docu, you'll know how much their company fought for them. These girl have faced too many struggles and challenges so did their company
@@starbyte984 yeah but i have said it multiple times that i am new to this group and P-pop overall. Like so many nice people in the comments that explained they could do the same, but not like this!
@@ItsRosieDays @ItsRosieDays I'm sorry about that. As a bloom myself, I can assure that they only said those things out of emotion, and they don't mean them personally. This is just a total misunderstanding, and they should have just told you in a nice way
@@starbyte984 it's ok, thank you for your comment😊
Please react to Golden Arrow my favorite BINI song
Yeah most of their MVs does not have heavy CGI and SFX as their type of music does not really require those kind of highlights. Born to win has some heavy sfx and cgi
@@thebeardedgamer7829 i will check it out✨
As usual, PPOP groups are being compared to KPOP groups. But who made KPOP the standard for POP music? While there are similarities, PPOP has its own distinct identity. In PPOP, talent and skills come first, followed by looks. In KPOP, it often seems that looks come first, then talent. Regarding music videos, they're made differently, too. You might not fully appreciate the 'Karera' MV if you're unfamiliar with BINI's story. And of course, the budget is a major factor-KPOP productions usually have much larger budgets than PPOP. The Philippines, especially in show business, isn't as financially strong as South Korea.
We appreciate the comments and reactions, but if you really want to compare PPOP and KPOP groups, focus on their talent-vocals and dancing. Try to find a KPOP performance where the group sings and dances simultaneously, and live. Then, watch BINI's live vocal and dance practices ("Lagi" for example). The difference will speak for itself.
@@myjseven as i said in the video i never meant to compare. I just said i think they deserve to have better quality for their MV's cause they have so much potential in everything and they are flawless in every aspect. MV doesn't come first but can be a cherry on top of all the talents they have.
I hope you understand my point now.
Thanks for your comment.
I mean their company is one of the top entertainment company in PH, I think its the best company they could get here. With fairness, they seem pretty alright currently, the girls seems happy with their management. But you know a company is still a company so you cant really trust fully.
@@veerand7038 yes i agree , even when i said they could do better i meant that they are doing pretty good but the quality of the MV could be better
I think you should comment after watching the MV of Karera (or their other MVs for that matter). This is a dance practice video and not the official music video. And after watching this video, I don't know how you could suspect that their management does not do them justice. If you know their back story and how they were formed, you will appreciate more their management and the support they were given. By the way, if I were part of their management team, I would be insulted. I don't think that's a fair comment
@@MarcyTrinidad i have watched the Karera MV. Unfortunately it has been blocked . I uploaded the three videos together but the MV reaction isn't visible. If you have seen my cherry on top video reaction you would have known that i am new to p-pop .
And my point was that, i think they are incredibly talented and they could have had better music videos that could match their potential.
I have seen the MV, who watches a dance practice and comments on the MV?
I saw the MV , live and dance practice , and this was just my opinion with all the information that i have by now from them .
@@ItsRosieDays As you say you are still new to PPop, then all the more it's unfair for you to judge their management on a few (maybe just MVs of 2 of their songs). I think their creative team did a very good job on Karera's MV. Also CoT and Pantropiko. Maybe after you watch 5+ MVs then you can decide whether their management isn't doing them justice to their vocals and dance skills.
PS: Karera MV is nominated for Best Music Video in the annual Awit Awards, that's the award giving body by the Philippine Association of the Record Industry (PARI). Look it up.
You need to calm down, that's her opinion, most of us appreciates the MV and she just said that the MV could've been much better, that's just it, no insult there, you're too sensitive
I don’t think management would take it as an insult; they’re very open to critiques. They always welcome feedback to improve BINI's music.
@@ItsRosieDays Oh I'm calm... especially when the channel owner hearts a nice comment but if it's not to her liking, no heart there! Oh well... These are also my opinions since I have friends in ABS-CBN/Star Magic
Plss react no fear from bini in myx
@@OneARTs-YT noted✨
Eeeyyyyyyy ....
Wag kana mag check sa ibang video gigil ako sau 😂😂😂
Wagch conutnut for the best video you are looking
No need to compare!!!!
@@rayhernandez3141 and I didn't as i said in the video!
@@ItsRosieDays please forgive these out-of-place comments. Most of them are children or teenagers brainwashed in social media with very little understanding of the world. They haven't been taught proper online manners. Even their idols, Bini, have a difficult time dealing with them.
@@seansanb5527 thank you for your comment ✨ i understand .
@@ItsRosieDays Really!!!
I understand youre only new to Bini 😅, maybe when you go down to the Bini rabbit hole
@@B3n-f3m i am pretty new🥺
Wag nyu agad e request yung documentary sa mga reactors na kaka simula plang. D rin nila ma appreciate yan ng todo, saka na ng ma d deep dive na tlga sila.
I agree.
Blooms, please learn to differentiate the difference between an insulting comment and a constructive criticism. Let's take a negative feedback without being butthurt.
The reactor is just simply giving her observations and opinions. There's nothing wrong with that.
her mentioning the management did not give justice to Bini is not a constructive criticism. She can always say something about the MV but calling out the management with that is so off. She didn't know what she's talking about.
@@8TillDend mali naman talaga sabi nya re: ABS pero hwag na po ma-trigger dahil lang sa sinabi nya. Sabi ni Sheena "Choose peace"
@@seansanb5527 kakapanood lang kasi natin ng docu kaya there's the 'fire' to defend BINI now that we know the struggles of the girls and the management on a deeper level to get to this point. Kahit ako na off sa line nya na 'are they under fair company?' at 'Kpop trainees then what happened?' pero I chose to peace and kindness nalang lalo na at kakaumpisa palang nya mag react sa girls. For me for now okay sige pagbigyan pero yung mga susunod pa ng reax dun malalaman if into or not yung reactor 😅
Isn't it true their company doesn't do them justice? Not just BINI, but their artists in general. We all know the company's production is way behind compared to neighboring countries. Their stage, camera works and overall production didn't improve. It's also one of the main reasons why BINI took so long to gain popularity. If it weren't for TikTok and other platforms, we wouldn't have known BINI. Her rating for the production budget is kinda brutal though, but I totally understand why. She's used to K-pop, and is just new to P-pop. So please if you have something to say, tell her in a nice way. Let's respect her opinion and appreciate her honesty, cause it only proves she's being authentic. I understand where you're coming from, but don't let your emotions control you. Let's welcome everyone in our BINI journey, it's more fun than saying mean things. Love y'all ❤️
@@ninabarcelo1874 thank you for understanding my point , i didn't know their stories but now that i know a little bit it's more clear to me.
Your opinion was interesting, you are the first who agreed with my point in the video😃.
On some level you are right , we are a little used to K-pop quality MV's .
Thank you so much for your comment , and being so nice✨❤️
@@ItsRosieDays You go girl. You're welcome, and we're here to guide you through. Don't let others affect what you have to say. A little story why I ended up with that opinion, since you find it interesting. It came to mind recently after BINI performed in China. The stage, camera works etc are something that the local entertainment industry is lacking. My frustrations about it grew after I came across a reactor reacting to a Disney produced thing called "A Night Of Wonder" with Disney+ wherein 3 local artists performed a Disney medley. I didn't have idea about it until out of curiosity, I clicked and watched the whole thing with her. Both of us were left in complete awe after. These artists can really take off if only given proper everything
@@ninabarcelo1874 that is exactly what i meant, they deserve even more. They have so much potential. But everyone says it is out of their companies hands, cause this is the best they can do. I don't know much yet. When i watch more videos and do more research about them i'll know.
That's the reason why it was interesting for me what you said. So many people disagreed.
Thanks for the comment❤️✨
react to their MVs…dance practice videos cant be compared to music videos.
Sobrang sensetibo naman kayong mga Blooms. Di naman pwede lahat na reactors gusto ang girls natin. Relax lang. Pinapakita ninyo lang gano ka-immature kayo. Pinapahiya ninyo ang Bini at mga kababayang Pinoy. Hwag nalang magkomento at lipat nalang sa ibang channel na puro lang pagpuri sa mga pinoy. Pakiusap lang.
Strings
you are quite wrong about their budget. they are supported by one of major tv stations in Philippines albeit they've been gutted by previous president . abs-cbn sold some of their properties to support bini. hence you see the they have paid big bucks to composers of cherry on top.. and you can see the qualitative progression of quality on their mvs. personally i dont like cherry on top.. its too commercially. bini already knows what their signature music is. pantropiko, karera, salamin, huwag na tayong umuwi . those songs have their bini music.. they need to pretty much go that way.. and not the cherry on top way. xg pretty much nailed their signature weird music.
@@MO-nj7tj i personally think that the quality of their music videos could be better. Since the potential that the group has is incredibly higher than this. In k-pop you can see so many groups that don't have half of the talent BINI have and the MV's are so high quality and better than this.
With ABS' tv and radio shutdown, BINi management/group had to work with a very limited but decent budget. its workable and higher than budget of other ppops. Born to Win (debut song) mv had a big budget but the rest was very tight. Big buget for Philippine setting bit nowhere near kpop level budget. It's just that BINi's mv producer and video edit co were creative in choosing locations and getting partners. E.g., Golden Arrow and Lagi. the bridge in GA was newly constructed and they just asked for permission using their connections in the tourism and provincial govt. That way they don't need to block traffic and pay huge fees to help them. Re Lagi, people think they had the sets made for that or paid a lot for cgi. They shot it in a theme park that was closed and just reopened. Even Cherry on Top, people thought Bini shot it in SF to target US market. yes it was for US market but it was actually just a hotel in the province in PH. That's pinoy ingenuity
@@peeenut with the budget they had which you say its somewhat workable they did a great job. I hope they grow along with the company. I will check the other mv's you mentioned, thanks for the explanation.
Not really. Abs did not sell properties for BINI. ABS decided to sell its real property and physical/traditional (non tv or internet related) businesses to the other shareholder faction in June this year I think. I guess BINI was a factor to the move to focus on internet-related business but the selling of properties was just recently and definitely not to fund BINI's mvs. Like any other group/show within the ABS organization, BINI only had a working budget which their management had to allocate for allowances of the girls and mv, shows etc. Now, ofc, it is different. BINI has real money now from endorsers, streams and content. Also, ABS will fully fund mv and concerts now bini being its crown jewel
I believe there is even talks now with Mattel (barbie). Warner also said to reached out Bini management. I don't know if its ost for Barbie 2 or its both barbie toy and movie
Thank you for your reaction.
Just an opinion regarding Bini MV's not as high quality as others from Kpop.
As with all MV's is impacted a lot by the budget.
Bini's label is not as deep pocket and as the larger more established Kpop backed labels.
Also, they cannot give an equal high budget to BINI as they are not comparatively as well known as the top established Kpop groups.
@@crxdelsolsir that is understandable i really hope they will take over and become even more internationally recognised.their company will definitely grow over time. They have chosen the right people. I didn't know about the situation of the company.
Thank you for your comment✨
When you dig deeper, you understand more. But if you're looking for high-quality videos like K-pop, I think BINI is not for you. They are formed by pure talent, and their company sacrifices too. Maybe they are lacking in some aspects, but they fight for the girls, believe in them, and dream with them. I don’t know what kind of quality MV you’re looking for, and I don’t understand why you focus on the quality of the MV and not the song or the talent. Do you have an explanation for that?
@@MusicallyRex in my other videos of Karera i already said that they are extremely talented but in this video i meant, they are perfect in every way and even the MV was good but there is still room for improvement. Since they have everything and the potential a good MV could've been a cherry on top of everything else.
May i know your qualifications for you to do/make those points that you are stating,,because you dont know what did the company did for this group,,
@@benniedaluyon9287 are you hiring people? Qualifications?dude it's a video reaction and we are all allowed to have our own opinions!
hwag na po maki away....sabi ni Sheena "Choose peace"
korean train only for their training system and for only 3 months because ph does not have idol training system here
every choreographer and other reactor about this Karera dance practice they praise the blocking and synchronization how good it is, and you just said chaotic 😅😅
anyways no hate, just learn more about them.
@@coffeelover9165 yes the chaotic part was just about one second of it , how did you miss the part where i said i liked the choreo and the way they performed it, their foot work is strong and they are so synchronised?
Thanks for the comment though😊
@@ItsRosieDays ♥️♥️
@@coffeelover9165 ❤️❤️
Yeah, Choreographers and dancers who reacted to the Karera dance practice love it, they even want to know who choreographed it. In a trained eyes that is not chaos, just a part of their blockings.
No hate. Just saying..🤙
@@barbieborbe6060 i seriously wish you would understand that the part where i said chaos i meant the positions, and it was only for a second. That is something that i have seen in K-pop dances as well ,it just doesn't feel good to me . And i specifically showed you guys which part.
Did you not hear the rest of what i said? I like the choreography and the way the girls performed it. It was so flawless. Their footwork was strong and their movements were firm. I was shocked when i found out they were trained for only two years cause they look professional.
Next time.Please avoid comparison...
it's a fair comparison, don't worry, just throw a constructive and informative comment sa kanya . so she can understand na wala pa sa standard ng kpop ang bini pero darating din tayo dun.
@@LDRXTV09im hope what you mean sa standard ng kpop e yung MV standard lang not the raw talent 😅
@@chicharongbulaklak2805 yes, definitely, haha sorry I should be more specific na sa MV and productions not in a raw talent. pero yung mga gantong reactors let's be mindful sa mga comments naten din, i mean nothing is wrong with your comment naman pero let's be more welcoming sa mga gantong reactors and call out yung ibang blooms not to bash but inform, educate and give a constructive comments sa mga reactors na katulad niya :) . in this way, we build a good community and support positively both reactors and bini :).
this person clearly learned nothing from the lyrics of this song. disappointing😢
It's a 3-part, but sadly the first part, which is the MV is currently blocked
@@starbyte984 yes, and i actually really like the lyrics, i turned the sub on this time because you guys had told me to. The song is so meaningful and light. I loved it.
what do we know?! maybe he has already watched the MV and knows the meaning of the song, it's a dance practice so it's probably the dance that he should pay attention to and react to. hey stupid blooms I'm a pinoy too! don't show that bini's fans talk and behave like that, it's embarrassing.
LOL, comparing MVs in a dance practice video is so off. Next time react only how simple/complicated the choreo is. The fact you start comparing MVs from different groups, different genre and different management is very wrong. This is just your 2nd or 3rd reaction from Bini and you start comparing already. You don't know what you are talking. Karera is one of the best song of Bini and you doing this, good luck to you. Too early for you to say this. You saying if the management give them justice without even knowing the what they went through, what are the sacrifices that company did just for this group to survive. It is okay to provide feedback for improvements but start comparing with other groups when you only watch a few MVs is very wrong. If you will insist with your opinion then this is my opinion as well.
First of all my reaction video is a three part video including MV,Wish bus live, and the dance practice but since the MV reaction is blocked for now you can't see it.
My dance practice video was the last part and i talked about all of the three videos at the end. So i didn't just watch the dance practice and react. Who does that?! And also i said it in the video and caption. What i say is based on what i have seen from them by now! And i asked you to suggest me the best MV that they have had so far so i can react to it later on. I said it multiple times. And about the comparing! I said it in the video i am not comparing the groups. It's better that you calm down a little bit and try to get my point. I said they are an amazing group. I am new to p-pop and BINI so still my informations are flawed. I shouldn't take classes and sit here and react. I wanna learn little by little. And like so many other people in the comments you could've just corrected me. I didn't know about the company . But so many nice blooms told me about. I like having conversations with people here. And it's not a big deal. Let's not take everything thattttt serious when someone clearly doesn't mean anything by it.
I believe in BINI.
They are an amazing group with so much more potential. And all said was that the MV could've been better to match their potential.
@@ItsRosieDays we are talking about the management here when you mentioned are they giving justice? Really? and it is not a big deal? You just don't know what you are talking. I'm not questioning the talent of Bini because I know how talented they are. As I mentioned if you will insist with your reaction be it and I will do mine as well.
@@8TillDend and if you blindly have your guard up, i do insist on mine.
@@ItsRosieDays girl read all the comments in this reaction, reflect on what the people are saying. eat your words once you know the story of what the management sacrificed just to continue this project.
@@8TillDend i would suggest you to do the same thing, read the comments. Most of the people are ok, though only some are like you!
I know what you mean by them being supertalented but the company they're with is not enough. It's because that company has been known for catering only to the Philippine market for decades and they are only starting to go international with very limited budget. I do believe that in the hands of a big Korean Kpop company, they can truly achieve international stardom faster. Anyway, check our "Strings", which I prefer as it shows their fierceness. It's also more Kpop.
@@denniszenanywhere yeah i get that. Thanks i will❤️
I don't think Star Magic has limited budget. It's ABS-CBN after all, just sayin.. ✌️
Limited budget because they were shutdown, I'm pretty sure they could've put everything for BNII if they are still operating
@@Steven_speaks Remember they don't have a TV network anymore, so I'm sure they're being wise about spending. Also, top K-pop budget for managing and promoting their talents are in $100 M to $400 M range. Still, if they only spent $20M per group, this is still money that ABS may not want to gamble since they don't have a TV station anymore.
Nah your standard is just way too high For a group who are just starting to go international
Who gives an f about music videos if the song is a bop. MVs are superficial anyways.
@@kalag7447 yes but it is something that can be like cherry on top above all the effort they put into their work. They are perfect at every aspect why not get even better, you know.
@@ItsRosieDays do you know what came first though?
@@kalag7447 what comes first in what?
what a waste...
I'm confused, I don't know if I'm here for our 8 Young Women BINI or just for you @Rosie Days 🫀🌸🫠🥹☺️
Always remember, you are beautiful inside and out. 🫶🏻
Delulu? Eyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy😄
The Rizzler.. 😁😂✌️