A random little kid: Takes a video gameplay of Reforge, grabs 2 or more videos of old Minecraft videos, slaps some text on there that say "Minecraft then VS now."
I really like the idea that you start out with blocks and then can kind of like, sculpt them to the shape you want. Whether diagonal, round, or with chunks inside taken out. It will allow people to do a lot more detail.
I always imagined that in early stages of development Mojang/Notch thought the game would be not cubical but it ended up being classic that way so they didn’t change it
I mean, if we peer back to older MC forums, Notch had mentioned how he really wanted to "eventually make a 'realistic mode'". Thankfully we never saw the abomination that style would be, as he a month later decided to fully dedicate to the blocky style (presumably because it looked, well, bad to say the least - we never saw it, but that's what I assume happened or he just forgot about it)
they should really update the art of the game if you look at their poster/ cosept art that looks amazing but then the in-game textures look like Roblox assets
every single texture is work in progress they said it in every trailer every video how can anyone still ask even the hand is placeholder you will get a multitool you will get custom generation with portals and stuff to throw in to change the terrain behind it and stuff they reasendly changed the ui for the sculpt mode!!😅
Yeah, this game will most likely die on launch honestly. You cannot compete with Minecraft mainly due to brand recognition alone. P.S this game just looks lower quality (i know it`s in pre-alpha, but the game just looks pure ugly imo) I`d be surprised to see it even launch.
Hytale and Reforj focus on different aspects of Minecraft. Hytale is more focus on community created content as that's what Hypixel is. 4J is focusing more on the average player experience. I follow Hytale news, and they heavily focus on creator tools, which is why it has taken them so long. They realized half way through that Java isn't the best language for a game and recoded everything in C++. Right now I wouldn't be surprised if they released the game in the next 4 years. Both games are trying to compete with different aspects of Minecraft, and I'm excited for both.
@@BobouxhasrobuxOfficialYT Hytale not being released yet is more relevant to this than something like GTA 6. Which is something completely different, not being released yet. Besides the joke is getting overused and i’m not even interested in GTA (aside from big smoke memes).
All that I can say is that I think this can turn out to be an amazing popular game, but as well as, nothing will change that Minecraft will still always have a special place in my heart, after all the years I've played it, making worlds and making nostalgic memories....
This actually looks pretty neat! Sure, the shaders and lighting could use some attention, but I've always wanted some of those sculpting features in Minecraft (especially the diagonals!). I look forward to seeing this game's development.
ngl, they should have the ability to make airships like Lego Fortnite but also the ability to go to space and set up astroid miners. Or also make a underwater base/vehicles. A true limitless sandbox game would be fun.
I think their main thing to do is give it a gimmick, there needs to be a reason to play this game rather than other games. They probably have one not shown yet though, but also the art style could use some work, otherwise it seems amazing
Lighting stuff like Ray tracing and graphics optimization are like end stage development stuff usually. First you build core systems, then flesh it out, then make it look pretty
I agree, the first thing I though was the lighting, it's what holds back the footage and I think it's a good place to start especially since it's still not even in Alpha yet.
I think there are 2 mayor problem with visual. 1. textures, surelly because it is pre-alpha but a big parts of textures is one color, Minecraft looking good because pixels little changing shades and that is why it looks more natural than most of games of this type. 2. I think world could be much more blocky than trying to be not, this will by much more problematic since it looks like they done that on purpose. Minecraft feels so creative (especially if you have good spatial imagination) because you can look at landscape or tree or whatever and see it can be destroyed and imidiatelly rebuilded 1:1. Having random polygons that filling empty space between blocks feel little bit random and hard to replicate especially for new players. For 2. also many irregular edges can have another interesting effect, and that it looks worse, even with more details, just because Minecraft have maybe blocks with little of details, but that is consistent little of details, this looks like random mess.
It's already looking great with all the variety of things that can be done, only thing Minecraft has on them is just being out longer and haveing time of influence, and being what it is compared to goes to show itself considering it's new and when Minecraft was about as new didn't have nearly as much and is still being updated.
People should look into Eco Survival. It's a voxel based world with more in-depth physics. Also, it's a literal planet. You can go around it, and you also see earth curving down into the horizon. It's a bit of a pain with its progression but it can be tweaked
Make sure it has alot of villages with and without village people dont make the mountain to big its take time knocking them down and fulling the holes up just to add more land for ur villlage ..make sure u have tnt in ur blocks ..
i grew up by playing a minecraft ripoff but that doesnt mean it was bad it was called portals and this game reminds me so much of it bcs it was a childhood game😅
This is pretty exciting. Hopefully in the future there is something like this coming up and don't die midway. Hope they succeed in delivering the best they can. 🔥
In my opinion, I actually cannot wait for this to come out. because this has a lot more features than minecraft does. I mean, yeah, you could basically do the same thing with mods. But this has a lot of features built in. Looking forward to seeing some updates.
I don't think it would replace Minecraft but it would be cool for the game to have elements of scrap mechanic in terms of building machines rather than how Minecraft uses redstone
Definitely should change up the world generation consistency. Other than that it doesn't look half bad for beta. Minecraft will always be the goat though
4J cared so much about minecraft on consoles (100 times more than microsoft cares about bedrock on console.) so, i think 4J will do a great job with this game.
Ansolutely love how it looks so far, I'd honestly immediately switch over to Reforj for survival experience and keep Minecraft just for the extra stuff if ii continues to be what we can see rn.
I don't think it'll surpass Minecraft, but it seems like a possible competitor. It really has to jump leaps and bounds to surpass Minecraft, because there is so much that it got right, that I think Reforj might struggle to compete, and I worry that people will see it as a rip-off. But who knows? Maybe Reforj is the next 15-year mainstay!
well, did you watch the video? I think it's simple to understand that 1: it isn't only blocks and textures of pixels, 2: it already has many things in its PRE-ALPHA
@ I understand that, and I know it’s in its pre-alpha, but what’s the main mechanic of the game? What sets it apart from Minecraft? It feels like the fundamental idea of the game is unfinished, not just the game itself
Im having serious deja vou right now, because this exact thing happened with the minecraft movie, less than 60 seconds of footage came out, and everyone hated it which it didt deserve, sure, judge the movie once you watch it, or at least a *full* trailer. But now that the trailer came out, everyone is feeling pretty good about it. I feel like this same thing is happening, this game is getting a lot of hate it doesnt deserve and should be compared to minecrafts pre alpha.
bro might be ahead of us
I’m 1st for a reason
This is the pinned comment. How does it only have 1 reply?
@@The_UnknownKing-BlimpBosses not even i know
People hating on pre-alpha gameplay really just want their newborn to already work a 9-5 job and make six figures
I mean to be fair human babies are really stupid
@Nameuser3000we will yearn for the mines when this game comes out
who wouldnt want that?
@@insane7718 I mean to be fair human babies are stupid like a baby bear can do better of a job for their parents
@@Dansnazzyok republican. You got your president, now show us what you got, shake that thang
A random little kid: Takes a video gameplay of Reforge, grabs 2 or more videos of old Minecraft videos, slaps some text on there that say "Minecraft then VS now."
Fr
with skilled editing
@@EliteCameraBuddy who cares the editing and if reforge or hytales comes out people would say "minecraft is better cuz nostalgia" Bro both are good
not even a little kid lol just some randomass dude
@@kezottle You mean AI
being able to get diagonal shapes and rounded edges maybe even spherical shapes is absolutely amazing.
Reforj is basically the spiritual successor to Minecraft, just as Minecraft was the spiritual successor to Infiniminer.
and infiniminer was the spiritual successor to. FRACTAL BLOCK WORLD. (jk)
I don't know, it feels the same as any other knock-off Minecraft game to me.
what else are they supposed to do they are known to make MINECRAFT CONSOLE EDITION!!!
@@thegreypilgrim2849 by that logic, Minecraft is a knock off of infiniminer.
@@Jesus_Student What logic? I just told you what I think.
I really like the idea that you start out with blocks and then can kind of like, sculpt them to the shape you want. Whether diagonal, round, or with chunks inside taken out. It will allow people to do a lot more detail.
Bro had a big vision 💀
I always imagined that in early stages of development Mojang/Notch thought the game would be not cubical but it ended up being classic that way so they didn’t change it
I mean, if we peer back to older MC forums, Notch had mentioned how he really wanted to "eventually make a 'realistic mode'". Thankfully we never saw the abomination that style would be, as he a month later decided to fully dedicate to the blocky style (presumably because it looked, well, bad to say the least - we never saw it, but that's what I assume happened or he just forgot about it)
would have been like the Minecraft movie💀
they should really update the art of the game
if you look at their poster/ cosept art
that looks amazing
but then the in-game textures look like Roblox assets
I know, it looks like a mobile game
yeh, things like this need to look clean and basic, looks like an old texture pack or a rip off.
it looks like one of those block craft 3d ripoffs
@@racknether yeah tue
every single texture is work in progress they said it in every trailer every video how can anyone still ask even the hand is placeholder you will get a multitool you will get custom generation with portals and stuff to throw in to change the terrain behind it and stuff they reasendly changed the ui for the sculpt mode!!😅
I can more call it 3D Terraria, it just has more stuff that looks more similar to Terraria, than Minecraft (terrain, and building)
It's successor of Minecraft not terraria 😅😅😅😅
@@ElizabethFolivi It is not a successor. It's an inspiration. It's PLANNED to be a successor, but now it isn't
@@LAyersFur okay but it is not based of off terraria
@@ElizabethFolivi who knows? I don't, neither do you... unless you're with 4J
This game's peak ngl. I would like to see players building mechs just like how they build houses in this game
VERTICAL SLABS PEAK
pillars are awsome yes there are pillars you can see them in the creative showcase
Mechs would be so awesome
Edit: would be nice to build them block by block to really customize how they look and function.
@@tdwwolf6107 Mix Besiege with Minecraft, it would be great!
this game is voxels, just a different kind of voxel, using marching cubes
There is 2 outcomes when this game releases
A: Hyped up for 2 weeks then gets forgotten and dies out
B: gets popular and doesnt die out for a while
i have a feeling itll be A, you cant really beat minecraft
Or gets received badly by people, is called a rip off, and they hate it
I think it’s gonna be A but just be hyped up for like 5 months
Yeah, this game will most likely die on launch honestly. You cannot compete with Minecraft mainly due to brand recognition alone.
P.S this game just looks lower quality (i know it`s in pre-alpha, but the game just looks pure ugly imo) I`d be surprised to see it even launch.
A
Who’s here after notch announced Minecraft 2
Just found out 😂
Hytale and Reforj focus on different aspects of Minecraft.
Hytale is more focus on community created content as that's what Hypixel is. 4J is focusing more on the average player experience.
I follow Hytale news, and they heavily focus on creator tools, which is why it has taken them so long. They realized half way through that Java isn't the best language for a game and recoded everything in C++. Right now I wouldn't be surprised if they released the game in the next 4 years.
Both games are trying to compete with different aspects of Minecraft, and I'm excited for both.
Bro had a vision…
We getting Minecraft 2 before Hytale.
First person to not say before gta vi
@@BobouxhasrobuxOfficialYT Hytale not being released yet is more relevant to this than something like GTA 6. Which is something completely different, not being released yet. Besides the joke is getting overused and i’m not even interested in GTA (aside from big smoke memes).
I got Lego Minecraft ad lol
0:52 there’s a caption error where it should be voxel instead of auxo
that looks more optimised since its not cubes and just triangles but then again big simple shapes are optimised better in minecraft so idk
That has very little to do with optimisation
All that I can say is that I think this can turn out to be an amazing popular game, but as well as, nothing will change that Minecraft will still always have a special place in my heart, after all the years I've played it, making worlds and making nostalgic memories....
Diagonal shapes and rounded edges is so GOOOOOOOD. Like Dayum this looks cool 4:16
Imagine the triangle redstone
dear god it's terrifying
It looks so cool lmao, I like how it’s doing its own thing in terms of design
This actually looks pretty neat! Sure, the shaders and lighting could use some attention, but I've always wanted some of those sculpting features in Minecraft (especially the diagonals!). I look forward to seeing this game's development.
Yay now the Minecraft movie has a accurate game to base itself on
BROS A TIME TRAVELAR 😶
2:17 As long as they don't make raytracing MANDATORY. Also, it really reminds me of Scrap Mechanic.
That player model feels really uncanny...
The building system looks pretty fun
Oh cool, another Minecraft inspired game teaser! I sure am excited for the release! *Hytale flashbacks*
Bro had a vision
I thought we stopped doing minecraft killers/clones in 2011. All jokes aside. This game looks decent.
ngl, they should have the ability to make airships like Lego Fortnite but also the ability to go to space and set up astroid miners. Or also make a underwater base/vehicles. A true limitless sandbox game would be fun.
That would be amazing
I think their main thing to do is give it a gimmick, there needs to be a reason to play this game rather than other games. They probably have one not shown yet though, but also the art style could use some work, otherwise it seems amazing
Lighting stuff like Ray tracing and graphics optimization are like end stage development stuff usually. First you build core systems, then flesh it out, then make it look pretty
I agree, the first thing I though was the lighting, it's what holds back the footage and I think it's a good place to start especially since it's still not even in Alpha yet.
make sure it's easy to mod!! having the ability for the community to make mods and use them to fully customize the game experience is SO GOOD
Microsoft depises 4j because they are just built differently and too good
One feature I would like to see in this game, and in Minecraft, s the ability to select a shape and fill it in with blocks automatically.
Heres the problem Minecraft most likely could be modded into this game.
minecraft can be modded into ANY game
Looks kinda fun. Curious to what it will become eventually. But to be honest, I think that at this point, no game will truelly replace minecraft
I think there are 2 mayor problem with visual.
1. textures, surelly because it is pre-alpha but a big parts of textures is one color, Minecraft looking good because pixels little changing shades and that is why it looks more natural than most of games of this type.
2. I think world could be much more blocky than trying to be not, this will by much more problematic since it looks like they done that on purpose. Minecraft feels so creative (especially if you have good spatial imagination) because you can look at landscape or tree or whatever and see it can be destroyed and imidiatelly rebuilded 1:1.
Having random polygons that filling empty space between blocks feel little bit random and hard to replicate especially for new players.
For 2. also many irregular edges can have another interesting effect, and that it looks worse, even with more details, just because Minecraft have maybe blocks with little of details, but that is consistent little of details, this looks like random mess.
It's already looking great with all the variety of things that can be done, only thing Minecraft has on them is just being out longer and haveing time of influence, and being what it is compared to goes to show itself considering it's new and when Minecraft was about as new didn't have nearly as much and is still being updated.
People should look into Eco Survival. It's a voxel based world with more in-depth physics. Also, it's a literal planet. You can go around it, and you also see earth curving down into the horizon. It's a bit of a pain with its progression but it can be tweaked
Make sure it has alot of villages with and without village people dont make the mountain to big its take time knocking them down and fulling the holes up just to add more land for ur villlage ..make sure u have tnt in ur blocks ..
yep this is minecraft 2
i wont call it that😅
i think it's pretty cool and I kinda agree with you that some textures and furthness effects need to be fixed
its all placeholder
@@nataliehergerdt6571 yes, i know that.
I highly doubt it would ever beat minecraft. The charm of minecraft is what makes it successful.
everything is a placeholder everything they said that is a placeholder is textures, lightning, hand, ui, mechanics, world gen
things that will be added are mobs, survival mode, beacons, portals, aura, enemys, systems, structures, minigames, multitool, utility blocks/items
Leave a link in the description to the channel
Just imagine 100 players civilisation videos in this game it's gonna be lit, i can't wait to try it
Honestly minecraft has to much nostalgia
i grew up by playing a minecraft ripoff but that doesnt mean it was bad it was called portals and this game reminds me so much of it bcs it was a childhood game😅
This is pretty exciting. Hopefully in the future there is something like this coming up and don't die midway. Hope they succeed in delivering the best they can. 🔥
I think the graphics are cute and I feel this has a lot of potential down the road.
it reminds me a lot of an xbox 360 game, Which is a good thing, it means they're sticking to their roots and listening to fans
Fortnight
I know it won't be as popular and successful as minecraft, but i still feel like it'll work tbh
In my opinion, I actually cannot wait for this to come out. because this has a lot more features than minecraft does. I mean, yeah, you could basically do the same thing with mods. But this has a lot of features built in. Looking forward to seeing some updates.
Bro listened to the whispers 💀
Never expected to see my thumbnails being used in other peoples videos, cool 😂
Love your vids man 😁
I am quite excited for its release! 😀
Yea me too yayy
Mojang getting ready to sue them if it was Nintendo
This game would look great for some fun, simple machinery.
the building already looks cool
I don't think it would replace Minecraft but it would be cool for the game to have elements of scrap mechanic in terms of building machines rather than how Minecraft uses redstone
Definitely should change up the world generation consistency. Other than that it doesn't look half bad for beta. Minecraft will always be the goat though
4J cared so much about minecraft on consoles (100 times more than microsoft cares about bedrock on console.) so, i think 4J will do a great job with this game.
That's looking good, keep it up! Reminds me of "no cubes mod".
If you guys want to play something better: Lay of the Land or Vintage Story
Ansolutely love how it looks so far, I'd honestly immediately switch over to Reforj for survival experience and keep Minecraft just for the extra stuff if ii continues to be what we can see rn.
Me playing Minecraft and I didn’t see this 😂
Are you kidding me
You mean I could FINALLY have diamond shaped buildings and round pillars
Sign me up this looks awesome!!!
This game would look a lot better if it wasn’t so bright and had shaders
It was bad at the start but now there is better tech than the old days so it would be faster and new
I don't think it'll surpass Minecraft, but it seems like a possible competitor. It really has to jump leaps and bounds to surpass Minecraft, because there is so much that it got right, that I think Reforj might struggle to compete, and I worry that people will see it as a rip-off. But who knows? Maybe Reforj is the next 15-year mainstay!
0:03 they better change that logo
why (make chain)
@@OctoSystem cus it looks similar to the n*zi flag thingy
why
This is looking pretty cool. I still have a feeling Minecraft will be better, but this game will probably be pretty good
the building looks insane
And this game will still be released earlier than Hytale
I feel like it's Minecraft -1 !!!
Hopefully, they’ll be able to put it on iOS and Xbox
it doesn't feel the same............
Of course it doesn’t…it’s a different game💀
@BenIThink it should still feel minecrafty
@@B3HRAMQ4DIR Well, it’s not made by Mojang, it isn’t an official Minecraft 2. If it was too similar, it would be copyrighted.
@BenIThink ohh I didn't watch a lot of reasons he vid thanks ig
It doesn't need to
That looks awesome ngl
Reforj is future of yt gaming
But do we know the key difference between Minecraft and reforge? Why would someone buy this over Minecraft.
1:49 pre office stage 🔥🔥🔥
DUDE NO WAY I WAS JUST THINKING ABOUT THE MEME AND THEN I GOT RECOMMENDED THIS 😭
terrain generation and voxel tech, they got way more than enough funding to make a game engine more optimized than java edition, absolutely
I like the original better. The fact that it isn’t realistic leaves a lot to the imagination.
what do you call the original?
if you are speaking of minecraft does it have really realistic leaves????
no
@ 🤣🤣🤣
BRUH MINECRAFT 2 ACTAULLY BEEN AOUNED
This will never replace Minecraft, sorry. There is so many memories with Minecraft ❤
This looks very promising
Got me at vertical blocks
i want to see reforj's version of herobrine
What makes it different from Minecraft though?
well, did you watch the video? I think it's simple to understand that 1: it isn't only blocks and textures of pixels, 2: it already has many things in its PRE-ALPHA
@
I understand that, and I know it’s in its pre-alpha, but what’s the main mechanic of the game? What sets it apart from Minecraft? It feels like the fundamental idea of the game is unfinished, not just the game itself
@@MrSkeleton14 oh so i think you mean "what the task is", right? unfortunately, i'm not sure about that
Naaaaah nothing will ever beat the classic Minecraft graphics.
Im having serious deja vou right now, because this exact thing happened with the minecraft movie, less than 60 seconds of footage came out, and everyone hated it which it didt deserve, sure, judge the movie once you watch it, or at least a *full* trailer. But now that the trailer came out, everyone is feeling pretty good about it. I feel like this same thing is happening, this game is getting a lot of hate it doesnt deserve and should be compared to minecrafts pre alpha.
It might sound like a stupid question, but how can someone join the pre-alpha?
will it support mods like Minecraft do?
Reminds me of Planet Explorers and thats now free abandonware...