Why didn't Ruben Ghosh sing a song from Noor Jhan Exclusive interview with Shabnam

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
  • #RubenGhosh #NoorJhan #Shabnam

КОМЕНТАРІ • 64

  • @javaidiqbalbutt7216
    @javaidiqbalbutt7216 3 роки тому +12

    She was No.1 heroine of Lollywood for a long time, May she live long

  • @javaidiqbalbutt7216
    @javaidiqbalbutt7216 3 роки тому +9

    She was Great actress, Madam Shabnam ko dekh K bari khushi hui

  • @faizanwaqar3103
    @faizanwaqar3103 3 роки тому +9

    Shabnam and Nadeem Baig was the No.1 pair in pakistan film industry.

    • @shehlamushtaq6219
      @shehlamushtaq6219 Рік тому

      Shabnum my soulmate

    • @shehlamushtaq6219
      @shehlamushtaq6219 Рік тому

      Shabnum je app bate bhttt rapeat krti hein Ali bhai ka qisa salu bhai robin ghos ka zikr zhr lagta hai shabnum tanha hein beta paas hota tu aj tanha na hoti dukh hua son kr ke tanha hein shazi malik payri lagtein hein

  • @faizanwaqar3103
    @faizanwaqar3103 3 роки тому +5

    She was No.1 heroine of superstar Waheed Murad and Nadeem Baig

  • @faizanwaqar3103
    @faizanwaqar3103 3 роки тому +5

    Madam Shabnam is the Great actress of the sub continental,

  • @faizanwaqar3103
    @faizanwaqar3103 3 роки тому +5

    Mir Talkies is the leading channel of youtube which covers the Art, culture and true artists minutely.

  • @sirajkhan7840
    @sirajkhan7840 Рік тому +3

    What a way to sit in front of ladies! Straight from the village.

  • @Internationaltourismlalazaar
    @Internationaltourismlalazaar 3 роки тому +6

    حسن نثار اتنا بڑا نام مگر تمیز بلکل نہیں اتنا غرور کہ اتنی بڑی سٹار لیجنڈ کے سامنے پاوں ٹیبل کے اوپر شیم آن یور ایتھیکس

  • @EPIPHANY544
    @EPIPHANY544 3 роки тому +3

    Amazing SHABNAM

  • @chtariqswl
    @chtariqswl 3 роки тому +5

    Meer sahib ap video boht chhoti bnatay hain...video Lambi bnaya krain...mukammal interview hona chaheay

  • @faizanwaqar3103
    @faizanwaqar3103 3 роки тому +3

    Madam Shabnam ne be shumar khushyan pakistan ki awam ko entertainment ki shakal man din hain Allah inhen khush rakhy

  • @sohailanjum2887
    @sohailanjum2887 2 роки тому +1

    Yes my queen...shabnam mam...always no 1 ...

  • @sohailanjum2887
    @sohailanjum2887 2 роки тому +1

    Always no 1 shabnam ji .love you mam

  • @abdullahrajpoot9048
    @abdullahrajpoot9048 3 роки тому +5

    But malika e taranum madam noor jahan jaisa koi nihi hu sakta wo legend ha or sab actresses or singers sa senior ha do respect

    • @sultankhan5945
      @sultankhan5945 3 роки тому +4

      Madam ji ne Pori Pakistan film industry ko apni awaz Ka Sahara de k qaaym rakha

    • @shehlamushtaq6219
      @shehlamushtaq6219 Рік тому +1

      Shabnum tanha hein un ki bate son kr dukh huaa

  • @NasirShahidAbeer
    @NasirShahidAbeer 2 роки тому +1

    Madam Shabnam played a romantic heroine for 4 decades, probably a world record.

  • @tariqmahmood6418
    @tariqmahmood6418 2 роки тому +1

    A few years back, Shabnam was invited to Lahore Gymkhana. There I asked her about Robin never working with Madam. At that time, she did not mention this rehearsal incident with Madam, and simply said that she did not interfere in Robin's work. She even denied that Robin composed music for Sawan Aaaya Tum Nahi Aaaye but left the film because producer wanted Madam to sing his tunes. His tunes were later recorded by his assistant.
    I wish somebody could tell which song Robin rehearsed with Madam,, and in whose voice was that recorded later on.

    • @77stack
      @77stack Рік тому +1

      Shabnam never acknowledged the success she earned due to songs sung by Noor Jehan.
      Few examples are Andaleeb, Dosti, Dil lagi, and many more.
      And now she openly criticizes Noor Jehan’s style of singing, what a thankless person.

    • @tariqmahmood6418
      @tariqmahmood6418 Рік тому

      @@77stack In hat function in Gymkhana, I got her to praise Madam's songs half-heartedly. Irritated as she already was by my non-stop mention of Madam, I sked her how she felt picturizing Madam's songs. And she finally said,' That felt good, that's the reason those songs by Madam were such huge hits."
      Her narrative on Robin's not working with Madam was quite different in that session that what she said in this interview. Perhaps, all this 's got to do with well-known Punjabi-Bengali animosity.
      And this Hassan Nisar...Some time back in a TV show, he bluntly accused Shabnam of arranging gambling parties at her Lahore home while trying to prove that dacoity at her house was her fault. And now he is licking her feet to sell his UA-cam channel. Such hypocrite!!!! In that TV show, they were discussing one of the dacoits getting PYT ticket for elections.

  • @nochannal6113
    @nochannal6113 3 роки тому +9

    یہ درست ہے کہ روبن گھوش نے نورجہاں سے نہیں گوایا لیکن اسکے باوجود وہ عظیم گلوکارہ ہیں

    • @sultankhan5945
      @sultankhan5945 3 роки тому +3

      Yes madam ji ki sabko zroorat thi keun k madam ji Noor jahan ji pe Alla.h Pak Ka khas karam tha

    • @sadafsonia6549
      @sadafsonia6549 3 роки тому +4

      بلاشک شبہ اور یہ دونوں میاں بیوی پاکستان سے پیار نہیں کرتے تھے

    • @sultankhan5945
      @sultankhan5945 3 роки тому +3

      @@sadafsonia6549
      I think

    • @sultankhan5945
      @sultankhan5945 3 роки тому +2

      @Iam Pro kon roban ghosht

    • @SultanKhan-yn1mn
      @SultanKhan-yn1mn Рік тому +1

      نہیں گوایا تو نہ سہی میڈم روبن گھوش جیسے موسیقاروں کی محتاج نہیں تھیں ملکہ تھی سروں کی آواز کی

  • @naeemdin3606
    @naeemdin3606 2 роки тому

    Beautiful interview but Very short ,I felt like I was sitting in the room with everyone, very relaxing interview but I didn't recognize the young lady with madam shabnam sahiba,please update me.thank you for uploading

  • @juilebutt5984
    @juilebutt5984 2 роки тому

    Aise legends ka interview lete rahna chahyeie

  • @m.majidaslam7209
    @m.majidaslam7209 3 роки тому +9

    Madam Noor Jahan nei six Decades
    (1940s - 1990s) inn Mouseqaroun kei saath kaam ker kei lazawal geet aur Ghazalein takhleeq keen :
    GHULAM HAIDER
    FEROZE NIZAMI
    NAUSHAD
    KHAWAJA KHURSHID ANWAR
    RASHID ATREIY
    MASTER INAYAT HUSSAIN
    G A CHISHTI
    TASADAQ HUSSAIN
    HASAN LATIF
    KHALIL AHMED
    SALIM IQBAL
    TUFAIL FARUQUIE
    NASHAD
    NISAR BAZMI
    KAMAL AHMED
    WAJAHAT ATREIY
    NAZIR ALI
    MASTER ABDULLAH
    NIAZ AHMAD
    USTAD RAEES KHAN
    MOHSIN ALI
    Sohail Raha
    etc
    Yeh Robin Ghosh kee bud-qismati hee keh sakteiy hain keh voh Madam Noor Jahan jaisee Azeem fankar kei saath kaam kerneiy sei mahroom reheiy

    • @abdullahrajpoot9048
      @abdullahrajpoot9048 3 роки тому +1

      Sorry (1934) to (1995)
      Madam na apna career 7 Sal k age ma shura kiya tha or 9 Sal ki age ma flim ka song gaya tha madam 1926 ma peda hoyi thi

    • @sultankhan5945
      @sultankhan5945 3 роки тому +2

      Waah waah Bhai zabadast

    • @m.majidaslam7209
      @m.majidaslam7209 3 роки тому +1

      @@sultankhan5945 Bohut Shukriya

    • @sirajkhan7840
      @sirajkhan7840 Рік тому

      My favorite Top 20 NJ Urdu songs with different music directors
      The titles on the second line are runners up/second choice.

      No Song title Music Director

      1 Sagar roye lehrein shor machayen Khwaja Khurshid Anwar
      Raahon pe thaari mein nazrein jamaye
      2 Kahan tak suno ge kahan tak sunaoon Master Inayat Hussain
      Kuch bhi na kaha aur keh bhi gaye
      3 Dil ke afsane nigahon ki zuban tak Saleem-Iqbal
      Chal hat ri hawa ghunghat na utha
      4 Chalo achha huwa tum bhool gaye Nisar Bazmi
      Ho tamanna aur kia jaane tamanna
      5 Mujhe chand se darr sa lagta hai Deboo Bhattacharya
      Na jane kaisa safar hai mera
      6 Galiyan galiyan dhoond chuki mein Sohail Rana
      Chand se keh do chala jaye
      7 Chanda ki nagri se aaja ri nindya G A Chishti
      Woh khwab sohana toot gaya
      8 Zindagi hai ya kisi ka intezar Rasheed Attre
      Jiyara tarse dekhan ko
      9 Chandni raatein taron se karein batein Feroz Nizami
      Tum zindagi ko gham ka fasana
      10 Ye wadian ye parbaton ki shahzadian A. Hameed
      Chun liya meine tujhe sara jahan
      11 Zindagi ke safar mein akele thay hum M. Ashraf
      Khat parrh ke ab dil behelta nahi sajna
      12 Abhi dhoond hi rahi thi ye nazar tumhe Khalil Ahmad
      Qadmon mein tere jeena marna
      13 Wo mera ho na saka to mein bura kion Nashad
      Mein ne ik ashiyan banaya tha
      14 Ghanghore ghata dil ka alam M. Ilyas
      Zindagi dhoondti hai phir wohi piar ko
      15 Mujhe apni dunia mein wapas bula le Moslehuddin
      Chupke chupke sab se chhup ke
      16 Log dekhen na tamasha meri tanhai ka Hasan Latif
      Ja apni hasraton pe aansoo baha ke
      17 Saathi mere bin tere sooni laagi re Kamal Ahmed
      Mere mehboob mere pyar ke qabil
      18 Jaane wali cheez ka gham kia karen Master Abdullah
      Jawab de bewafa zamane jawab de
      19 Tere bina yun gharrian beeteen jaise Nazir Ali
      Tere qadmon mein bikhar jaane ko
      20 Lo chal diye wo humko tasalli diye Ghulam Haider
      Bachpan ki yaadgaaro

    • @YasirAli-rp6nn
      @YasirAli-rp6nn 2 місяці тому

      Bilkul durust frmayaa aap ny

  • @manimalik6505
    @manimalik6505 3 роки тому

    Shabnum was number 1 actresses in Urdu films in the 1970s, 80’s and early 1990s.
    She made nice clean family entertainers which resulted in other actresses not able to compete with her.

  • @sohailanjum2887
    @sohailanjum2887 2 роки тому

    I love you soooooooo mutch shabnam ji .

  • @sajidsiddiqui8652
    @sajidsiddiqui8652 3 роки тому +4

    No doubt Noor Jehan was a above average singer, ghosh was an average MD

  • @m.majidaslam7209
    @m.majidaslam7209 3 роки тому

    Kindly note the names of the following Music directors in the list shared earlier as well :
    A Hameed
    Wazir Afzal
    Bakhsi Wazir
    Ghulam Shabbir etc

  • @ahmadabdurehman2087
    @ahmadabdurehman2087 Рік тому

    نورجہاں اور بشیراحمد کا گانا تم جو ملے دل کو قرار آگیا۔ روبن کی دھن تھی

    • @Lucky-el6jo
      @Lucky-el6jo Рік тому

      Usli music Khan At ur Rehman ni di thi

  • @nochannal6113
    @nochannal6113 3 роки тому +1

    It is a great showbiz Event

  • @azzanullah9317
    @azzanullah9317 Рік тому

    Kindly just see the last 1 minute of video if you want an answer to caption's statement. .. thank me later :)

  • @GodzillaKing25
    @GodzillaKing25 3 роки тому

    Wah Sir

  • @pranabbiswas7760
    @pranabbiswas7760 Рік тому

    Not Ruben Ghosh it is Robin Ghosh or Rabin Ghosh

  • @mdnishatadv3275
    @mdnishatadv3275 7 місяців тому

    What was the shabnam,s father name

  • @ejazmirza9108
    @ejazmirza9108 3 роки тому +2

    Wo.kehty.thy.k.in.k.aawaz.m.melody.nahe.hy.

  • @imjawads
    @imjawads 3 роки тому

    She is out pride

  • @9thgem
    @9thgem Рік тому +2

    Salute to Robin jee. Noor jahan was a badmash aurat,her voice was a shot after 65,never a playback singer.
    Mala begum.naseem begum , runa laila and zubeda khanam were far far far better than so called malika taranum.she ruined careers of many artists,singers and music directors

  • @Marinology
    @Marinology 3 роки тому +3

    Kya ? madam k kitne gane low pitch pe hue hain ? example : Tera ishq vi eh pagal, is me antra bohot soft aur thin voice hai, yeh bat kuch aur hai !

  • @yasirnawazkhan9174
    @yasirnawazkhan9174 2 роки тому +1

    Mazrat Kay saath aik baat me kahun!
    Agr Gano (Songs) ki kismen (kinds) aik laakh theen to Madam Noor jahan ne aik laakh andazon me gaya our jis perfection Kay sath gaya us ka mukabila koi doosri singer na kar Pai..
    Is matter me story thori different lag rahi h

  • @NasirShahidAbeer
    @NasirShahidAbeer 2 роки тому

    Yaar! industry ke one of the biggest composer Robin Ghosh, unka naam sahin se spelling karo.

  • @HamidKhan-ik5jt
    @HamidKhan-ik5jt 2 роки тому

    I guess we will never the real reason why Robin Ghosh never gave Madam Noor Jehan nor Madam Nahid Akhtar a chance. Both were outstanding singers and gave so much to Pakistan Film Industry. Both had a great variety of singing talent so it just surprises me why Robin Ghosh never have them a chance.

    • @erumashfaq6107
      @erumashfaq6107 7 місяців тому

      Pl try to understand,both naheed n noorjahan had heavy n paindu touch voices.infact naheed ruined image of heroine with her voice.ghosh was bengali influenced musician where sweetness of vocals is prime thing.this sweetness was in mehnaz n nayyera voices,decent n sophisticated.thx god we have some good music coz of them.
      Naheed n madam were goid in sur,but never suited to heroine.

  • @MohammadAhmad-dj6jb
    @MohammadAhmad-dj6jb 3 роки тому

    Shabnam! 🌹

  • @abdullahrajpoot9048
    @abdullahrajpoot9048 3 роки тому +7

    Ya tu dada ki badkismti ha k malika e taranum madam noor jahan k sath un ko gaana ka muka nihi mila

    • @sultankhan5945
      @sultankhan5945 3 роки тому +2

      Yes you are right

    • @erumashfaq6107
      @erumashfaq6107 7 місяців тому

      Hamari khushkismati thi k noor jahan ,naheed akhter se gany burbad nhi krai.dono ka lehja aur awaz intihai paindu thi.

  • @waheedkhattak729
    @waheedkhattak729 2 роки тому

    🤬🤬🤬 Noor jahan k baray ma aesa kah rahay jaisay vo Meri ja rahi the

  • @erumashfaq6107
    @erumashfaq6107 7 місяців тому

    Madam ki paindu awaz thi......ghosh was sophisticated artist.

  • @deepakjana2767
    @deepakjana2767 2 роки тому +1

    Tum to hindu se paida huye ho.....shabnam ja kya huaaaa

  • @mking7325
    @mking7325 Рік тому

    Yeh kumbakt Muslim film in Pakistan itnna bada teeka laga ker film mein kaam kiya how did she getaway with that Pakistanis neend mein the