The Day After in Gaza: What is the Path Forward? David Friedman, Caroline Glick, Mordechai Kedar
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
- Join One Jewish State at www.1Jstate.com
Click here to buy "One Jewish State" by Ambassador David Freidman - amzn.to/47b4qvj
Thank you for bringing these wonderful and knowledgeable people together. I hope in the future we can have more of these three in discussion together in a longer format so they are able to delve deeper and question each other so we can all have a better understanding and more importantly that the people and leaders in israel will see and realise what needs to be done and how a shift in mindsets is much needed to move forward together. God bless you all. Amen
Fabulous discussion with a star-studded panel of true experts!
As a Christian, in full agree. G-d bless you all. שלום
Todah Rabah! ❤ Great panel, great discussion!
This is truly wonderful thank you for putting this together. So grateful.
Todah Rabah ! Interesting and informative ! 🇮🇱💙
Bravo .... good Ideas Exactly for Israel nation ....❤❤❤❤
i hope the Israeli leadership is listening to M. Kedar 🤔
Amazing panel! You gathered my favorite speakers in one episode. Thank you! TOTAL VICTORY! 💙🇮🇱
Kushner's new book talks of kushner crushing the sovereignty idea via Trump when Netanyahu brought it up.
Heard that within the last week here on UA-cam. I'm just beginning to listen and agree that sovereignty is the only option, Natasha hausdorf a barrister has proven that the land of Israel is indeed Israel's and no one else's and should not be divided. Furthermore Sinai shouldn't have been given away. Finished watching and glad that it is being discussed, what wasn't discussed was disavowing Oslo. The plo abrogated it upon signing. Hopium and shh have resulted in continuous bloodshed.
May ambassador Friedman achieve a second term as ambassador!
begin's decision to return sinai to egypt was a torah true correct decision. the lubavitcher rebbe's decision to continue to oppose begin's peace pact with sadat, was torah incorrect. the only reason that israel is still alive today and not 100% surrounded by terrorist enemies is because of the peace agreement with egypt.
The children in Israel need a Jewish Education ! Israel did not begin in 1948 !
This is the most serious problem and the root of all other problems - the neglect of Jewish education.
There is a common, internationally recognized solution that has been implemented over and over throughout the world, by every major world power. In fact there are far more peoples in the world living under this form of governance than those who possess independent sovereignty. It is autonomy under the sovereignty of a host sovereign power. Autonomy with devolution provides a mechanism by which the level of independence of the autonomous people can be varied from the extreme of occupation to the opposite extreme of full independence in proportion to the level of cooperation and trust between the living autonomously and the host nation. The two most obvious example among hundreds are Scotland (under UK sovereignty) and Puerto Rico (under US sovereignty). The only reason this solution is ignored is because it would end the perpetual conflict against the Jewish State.
we are of the same mindset. i am from toronto canada. the quebec to canada relationship is the perfect example of how sovereignty and autonomy can work in perfect harmony. yes, to loyalty: no, to terror!
Good video ❤❤❤
Kedar, Glick and Friedman are a gift to the Jewish people.
Successful vs failure states. Where are Egypt and Jordan? Did I miss it?
Prayer please, for Newsreal, Dr Anthony Harper. Shalom
The bad thing about this 10/7 issue is that the military and leaders should have been taking this digging tunnels and keeping a better eye on their country
Wouldn’t the one state solution demographic change, destroy Israel as it happened in Lebanon?
The PLO flag is the flag of Hejaz, that ought to be discussed often and publicly
Yes we're big. We owned this whole land for thousands of years. We share the colors of our flags 🇦🇪🇪🇭🇪🇬🇩🇿🇯🇴🇰🇼🇵🇸🇸🇩🇾🇪
Why does that piss you off?
Is it against your delusional self destructive ideology?
Do you long to live 2000-5000 years ago?
Have you stagnated there because of a delusional story?
OMG 😮
The website button doesn’t work.
Ambassador, at some point can you address return to sacrifices ?
Youre going to need Rabbis to agree on the staus of the Temple mount before getting to politicians.
So if you listen ambassador Friedman, he is implying that many many Arabs integrated into Israel 🇮🇱 already right? Then what is the problem with 2 states solving? I do not understand. Is Israel a Jewish state? Or Israel 🇮🇱 like United States or Western European? Meaning everyone state, the global state? What Jews want?
They've forgotten God's commandments. Thou shalt not kill. Thou shalt not steal. Love one another. Most have forgotten about God. pray for peace 🙏
Solution: Israel should insist ( and act upon)on removal of all refugee camps with all their 1.6 million official refugees out of Gaza. Refugees are not to decide where the refugee camps to be located. Move them to Syria, Sudan, South Africa, Iraq, Lybia, etc. Only this will bring safety to south of Israel.
Successful states? I think that's a stretch. I think some of those countries have so much oil and such small populations that with the help of western financial system and productivity to be able to buy their hydrocarbons that it is able to cover up the total failure of Islam. Before Islam arrived in the region it was relatively much more successful.
I have always been a "fan" of David Melech Friedman: Because of his gut-understanding of the concept of AMELEK, and the numerous forms he can take. And also because, in his own way he's a 'frontovik'. Who's various careers are based on confronting reality, of the most unsavory kind. Despite his acquired "diplomatic" delivery: He knows full-well that the nature of islam, itself, & the moral zombies it creates, is the real "primal materiel of the negative" that must be solved. It's not really about "Da' Jooze" {united nations goon-show dialect} or Eretz Israel, or PM. Netanyahu, or "da' zionist conspiracy' & on & on a la nausee. Mme. Glick has often unleashed the same bottled-up lightening at more than a few more cultivated 'liberal-minded' & self-styled "sympathizers" from Europe's diplomatic & political communiti. es. I myself enjoyed one such event with a certain Danish ? gentleman. Who threw in the towel, with "All, right, all right, you've made your point". BUT in the end, "making her point", reminded of somebody who paid with his life in an American prison, for being right about the only ones who choose the borders of Medinath Yisroel. Any body remember Rabbi Meir Kahane ? Or the cutting edge concept about who the "permited blood" really is ? Jabotinsky, Orde Wingate & Menahem Begin. Were THEY ever wrong about anything ? The present shape of Amelek will not escape the "Night of the Long Knives" {From the Indian Mutiny, 1857}. No matter what THEY look like, no matter where THEY squat, no matter what language they do Taquiya in or what head-gear THEY wear. Yours truly lives in Toronto Canada. Where we've got about 3/4 of a million of 'em .Norman L. Roth
I like the "indian reservations" idea. "Clan Emirates" 😅
Making it look like a MiddleEastern concept 😂😂, you can't be more european than that.
We miss President Trump too. Trump was good to the whole world.
Why didn't you guys also invite Dr. Martin Sherman? His perspectives and ideas would definitely enrich the discussion.
The Reshef Plan: The Day After the Current Conflict in Gaza and Lebanon
There has never been a state called Palestine and the Arab leadership in the territory of the former Mandate of Palestine has never been interested in a two-state solution. By stating that, I am not denying Arab Muslim descendants of the Mandate the right to a national identity -- just not a "Palestinian" one. Allow me to explain, starting with the “day after” this conflict.
The proposed idea of having the UAE and Saudi Arabia involved as partners with Israel and Egypt in the development of an Emirates-like enclave in Gaza is a good one. Together, this consortium should manage a protectorate where a Gazan government can be developed that is not Islamist and independent of the PA. Apart from local policing responsibilities, Israel should maintain security control. Part of this deal would require that a strip of Gazan territory (1.5-5km wide) be annexed by Israel (including the Philadelphia corridor) for use as a security buffer. Additionally, Egypt would be required to hand over ca. 250-300km2 of land including Rafah and its surrounding area to the protectorate. Such an arrangement would leave it to the Israelis and Arabs to manage Gaza’s reconstruction and development without direct interference by outsiders, e.g., the UN. Under this plan, five emirates/governorates would be established: North Gaza, Gaza City, Deir Al-Balah, Khan Younis, and Rafah. A state called the United Gazan Emirates would be declared once the consortium unanimously agrees that Gaza is able to self-determine as a demilitarized state in peaceful coexistence with Israel.
However, that plan does not fix the wider problem of what to do with the West Bank, Jerusalem, and southern Lebanon. That is why similarly fitting solutions should also be applied for those areas, and -- the game-changer -- extended to all of Israel. The current conflict can be used in much the same way as the American Civil War was used to reintegrate the states that had seceded from the Union and determine the legal status of African Americans - the Reconstructionist Era.
It is time for a solution that is not misguidedly focused on “splitting-the-baby” - the two-state solution - but tackles the core issue of Israel's acceptance as a Jewish state in a Muslim region of the world. Such a solution should acknowledge that the Mandate’s territory, including the West Bank and East Jerusalem, was originally intended by the San Remo Conference (1920) and League of Nations (1923) for the establishment of a national home for the Jewish people west of the Jordan River. In doing so, the League recognized the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine and the grounds for “reconstituting” their national home in that country. Such a solution should also recognize that only people in the former Mandate who match the characteristics for indigeneity listed in the UN's Factsheet “Who are Indigenous Peoples?”, are the Jews. And, it should acknowledge that in 1948, Israel was the only state to declare independence in the territory, meaning that under the universally applied legal principle of international law, uti possidetis juris, it inherited the pre-existing borders of the Mandate as its internationally recognized sovereign borders.
A reconstructionist solution would involve Israel reconstituting itself as a Constitutional Federal Republic (The Federal Republic of Israel), comprised of 27 governorates in Israel’s current borders including the Golan Heights and greater Jerusalem, and seven governorates in Judea and Samaria (Jenin/Tubas, Nablus, Tulkarm/Qalilya/Salfit, Ramallah/Al Bireh, Jericho, Bethlehem, and Hebron). The republic would be guided by a federal constitution granting equal political and civil rights to all its citizens. Southern Lebanon would become a protectorate of a consortium of several states including Israel, until such time as the consortium unanimously agrees that Lebanon is able to govern it as a demilitarized region in peaceful coexistence with Israel. As with Gaza, a strip of territory adjacent to the border with Israel would be annexed by Israel as a security buffer.
Each of the republic’s 34 governorates would have a locally elected government with the ability to raise local taxes and manage general administrative affairs. They would also hold specific powers defined in the constitution that would determine which powers belong to the nation (federal), which are shared (concurrent), and which belong only to the governorates, e.g., local police would manage day-to-day policing while national security matters and crimes crossing governorate lines would be handled by a federal authority.
The elected Governors - excluding the Governors from Gaza and southern Lebanon -- would sit in a new deliberative chamber of government. They could be joined by four representatives of the major faith communities in Israel constituting over 1% of the total population (Jewish, Muslim, Christian and Druze). While the chamber would not have legislative authority, it would have the mandate to scrutinize legislation, hold the government to account, and consider and report upon public policy. It could also seek to introduce legislation for the Knesset to consider and propose amendments to bills before their final passage into law. It would be able to delay bills though it could not indefinitely block their passage, with the possible exception of bills involving constitutional amendments, when a supermajority of 60% would be required. This would allow for the voices of all residents of the republic to be heard and considered.
The Knesset would have legislative power and be much like it is today, though Israel's laws should be revised so that coalition governments cannot be as easily captured by extremist elements, e.g., the election threshold could be raised from 3.5% to 4%, and a coalition government could only be formed with 55% of Knesset members, not the current 50%. If a coalition of 55% cannot be formed, then a second round of elections would be conducted with minority parties that obtained less than 4% of first-round votes dropped from the roll. Once established, a coalition government could be dissolved with a 50% vote in the Knesset. If the Knesset votes to dissolve a government but a new coalition government cannot be formed, then, like now, an election would be held.
This solution would allow Arabs to have local autonomy where they predominate and secure their property in a national register. It would not allow for Palestinian statehood. Originally proposed in 1937 by the Peel Commission, the idea of a two-state-solution was adopted by the UN in 1947, and after that, repeatedly tried by Israel with the support of the U.S., including as recently as 2000 and 2008. Every time it was rejected by the local Arab leadership, which only ever sought annihilation of the Jewish state. The opportunities for a two-state solution have been squandered, and as the current conflict lays bare, it would not resolve the real issue, which is Muslim acceptance of a Jewish state in the region.
Regarding citizenship, Arabs would be offered citizenship conditional on 1) completing two (women) to three (men) years of national service (not necessarily military); and 2) renouncing foreign citizenship of states adjacent and/or hostile to Israel. Both of these conditions would also be required for Jews to hold citizenship. Those who do not accept these conditions or are beyond the age of national service, would receive full residency with full civil rights, and political rights in the governorates where they are registered. They would be able to vote in local government elections and for their representatives in the new chamber but not in national elections for the Knesset. They would be able to travel, work and live anywhere inside the republic but would not be able to change their residential governorate except by marriage, when they could change their residency to that of their spouse. They would get a special passport for international travel. Children would obtain citizenship status, but would lose it at 18 if they fail to fulfill the requirements of national service. The right of return would continue to apply for all Jewish immigrants and could be extended to include Arabs who can prove their residency in the Mandate prior to 15 May 1948, and who have not held citizenship of a country that is currently hostile to Israel within the past 10 years. Under penalty of law, organized insurgent activity (defined by law) would be grounds for imprisonment and/or to strip offenders of their citizenship/residency and expel them. Acts of terrorism (defined by law) would invoke a death penalty.
A Constitutional Federal Republic of Israel should be supported by all civilized nations. Not only would it offer resolution to the Arab-Jewish conflict in the territory of the former Mandate, but it would also deal a heavy blow to the pernicious dawa of the Muslim Brotherhood that has captured Arab and Muslim political thinking around the world.
😂 Israel is being finished and you plan for other states ?! Keep dreaming.
🚫🤡
3 neo Nazis great panel
Funny to hear it from inheritor of Al Husseini (Hitler's friend) ideology and people who have "Hitler" store in Gaza and fly swastika flag. But nice try 😉