Thats all hes done since he entered into that patients secret satanic worship room with the shrine and he touched the Necronomicon he had on the altar in there. lol
hits home here too, i tried to save my gramps with my lung but the doctor refused saying it would only give him a few years, and would be a waste of a lung on someone old, and then tried doing a House by telling me about a patient who desperately needed a lung and that if i agreed to it there and then, they'd test me and have me open for it in no time. Doctors are cunts.
My grandfather had heart valve surgery and got to live another 10 years, died at 86, they said he can't have another surgery at 86 but I am thankful to the doctors because he lived 10 more years. If medicine wasn't as advanced he would've died at 76...
Ramir Duria That’s quite arguable, he was ethically in the wrong, but logically it makes sense that he should get the heart. Assuming that it doesn’t interfere with anything other than the time keeping the wife “alive”.
@@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr I was just making a joke about how everyone feels the need to say “585 likes and no replies? Let’s change that” when they see a very liked comment without replies
Bel Rick wtf does tht have to do w anything? The organ donor list is by no means free market. Not to mention tht all major civilized nations in the world tht run on freemarkets recgnize tht there are some thing u shldnt leave up to the free market, like healthcare
No, sometimes sociopaths take control and thereby remove civil liberties and it sure as shit isn't civilized "please sir, may i have a heart, i've earned one!" "NO! We decide who gets the heart, go die"
House was really good when he was on your side. I loved how he fought for his patient, He said to Cameron the board was right but still his patient for him was first.
he didnt really fight for his patient, he just hates when things are not seen through to the end. the man was happy a dying woman might have her organs rejected after her death
This episode did illustrate a very valid point that many perfectly _serviceable_ organs are simply thrown in the trash because they're not 100% _perfectly_ healthy. Sure, keep the perfect organs for younger, otherwise healthy people who would get the most use out of them, but "second class" organs could still be used for other patients who might only have a few years left, for whatever reason. Hell, if you give a heart from a fat woman to an elderly man who is otherwise in good health and lives a healthy lifestyle, like in this episode, the heart could become more healthy inside him and give him even longer than predicted. (Edit:) so many people only responding to the basic idea without thinking about it. I shouldn't have had to point out that, obviously, a complete medical and legal infrastructure would have to be built around the practice, to protect both patients and doctors. I wasn't advocating for hospitals to just start going about it on spur of the moment inspiration like House did.
Yes, sure but its a logistical problem, even if every single person who died had perfect organs to donate, a lot of them woulb have to be discarded, because their storage is incredibly finnicky ( for lack of a better word ), and if there is a problem in their storage ( wich in this case, with so many organs to handle at once, it is likely ) they would have to be discarded aswell for fear of contamination. Take china for example, they steal organs from political dessenters, so their market is flooded with organs, way more than the US has, and still, they cant manage all of them, there are people who still die waiting for those organs.
@@rushyscoper1651 Not exactly. Organ failure causes a huge amount of pain. There are schools of thought that would argue that a peaceful death would be preferable to living longer in suffering. Medical ethics is fickle because there are nearly 100 schools of thought competing to be the new central dogma for all of medicine. Organ transplant, like everything else in medicine that involves death, is hotly debated over.
@Jakk Frost; Law suit. Putting "second-rate" organ would increase the chance of failure even after successful procedure....so...the hospital could be sued for that. Even if statement could be made before the surgery, some lawyers somewhere could make a plausible cause to sue the hospital.
My mother’s heart was devastated by a massive heart attack and needed a transplant. Basically was running at 20 percent capacity or less. Unsustainable. We were so lucky that we had a perfect match, and the hospital was willing to give her the heart at age 57. She’s doing great now. Should easily live another 25-30 years with her lifestyle.
Guy: your dad can.... have her heart. House: (grunts) thank you. Guy: I’m doing it for her. Not for you. House: no. I meant thank you for helping me forget the pain I have in my leg.
ThePatrickis He broke patient confidentiality (and hacked into confidential patient records) and was unethical in obtaining the heart via emotional manipulation. Of course, he's probably only lose it if a complaint was filed, but that behaviour would never be condoned. However, as I stated, this is a drama and it's dramatized to make the show more entertaining.
He didnt hack into any confidential patient records as things like wether or not the organs were declared as viable or not is information accesible for senior staff like house. What patient confidentiality did he break? literally none. Also just because you deem his way of obtaining the heart unethical does not mean that it is or that anyone would bring charges since he did agree in the end. you could not be more mistaken, you could try, but you would fail.
This shows how much double standards that doctor in the medical committee has. He wouldn’t have said that if it was one of his own people whose days are numbered. Way to expose his hypocrisy, House. This is why I respect you. Your bedside manner may be a bit rusty for a doctor but your methods are effective while saving people’s lives.
@@akshaymundkur except later in the episode House admitted that he actually agrees with the committee and was only arguing for the sake of his patient.
Should be a transplant list and a alternative transplant list. The alternative for people who have 0 chance and who have been refused a perfect heart. They should be able to sign away the right to sue if complications happen other than gross malpractice of course and get the tossed organs that are not ideal but who still have good potential and are better than nothing.
Problem is people on that alternative list will not be grateful if and when their loved ones die soon after transplant. If you transplant an organ with a risk of hep c infection which then kills the patient, his loved ones will decide, fairly or not, that it was your fault that the patient died, and even if you ban them from suing, they will stir up distrust of the whole organ donation system that will do more harm in the long run than the good produced by trying to save the lives of these marginal cases. In short, it's necessary to deliberately allow people to die of organ failure because mankind is irrational and selfish.
Scoot Matheson Yeah, decent point... One the other hand, some ten thousand possibly preventable deaths every year. If implemented even marginally well, this system would be great, but good luck getting it through the health-insurance and hospital management lobbyist swines.
Alternatively we could do the following. 1. Let people SELL their organs post mortem. This would drastically increase the willing donors. 2. Let private buisness purchase organs rather than attaching it to a state run board. If you do these two things I guarantee you will have dozens of companies buying and storing organs within a year, the price would also likely actually go down due to the massive supply increase and the incentives to inovate In storage. To prevent abuses you would however likely need to mandate 3. That organ companies buy insurance for defective organs. This would actually solve almost all abuses as the insurance companies would keep the organ market mostly in line. I'd imagine you'd have more deaths due to transplant complications, but far fewer deaths due to insufficient organs, which would on balance save many lives.
Jane Hrahan that could work in a society with a good private and public healthcare system, and in which crime rates and migration are low. The private sector distributes, the public sector ensures there’s an alternative in case of monopoly (or objection of conscience) and regulates the practice (usually this isn’t beneficial, but in medicine a minimum standard of quality is necessary for it to make sense), low crime rates prevent organ harvesting and black markets, and low immigration prevent human trafficking and transplant tourism. The latter could be viable if there is a great surplus.
@@janehrahan5116 and presumably if you are selling organs you must buy them... I think I detect an american Person shouldnt be refused healthcare, and as a result organ donations, because they arent born with a silver spoon or dont make as much as someone else
It's so strange to see House literally go out of his way to guilt trip an organ donor committee, get a heart that's been rejected and get punched in the gut just for an elderly patient. His words say one thing,his actions say another
1:49 This actually made me start crying, my grandfather raised me and in my eyes he was a superman and when I got to be bigger than him and he started to get older I started watching him, everywhere he went i was with him always behind him (the family called me his shadow lol). Well he started to have heart problems around 2017, he was 78 and had done hard labor his entire life (he still worked at the family business with us) and the doctors wanted to do surgery, he put off the surgery until my graduation that same year and when i finally graduated he went under the knife. The surgery went smoothly and he was awake and talking a week later so they released him about a month later, but he had some infection issues, and had to go back in for another 2 months to get cleared up but after he got out we learned he was suffering from congestive heart failure and the doctor gave him at most 3-4 years before his heart gave out, it was hard but I accepted it and we were good for about 9 months. Then july 2018 hit, my grandfather had started to slow down had swelling in his legs, always lethargic he would wake me up at different times in the night and ask me to watch tv with him and we had no problems but one night he told me he was scared of dying and that he didnt want to go, I was never good at these kinds of conversation and i just reassured him he wasnt dying anytime soon and everything was gonna be okay, I was wrong, 2 weeks later his doctor came over to visit us for the fourth of july and after looking over my grandfather for a few minutes he took me and my aunts, uncles and grandmother to the back room and he gave my grand father a week at most to live, it killed me I went outside and cried for what seemed like hours before I hardened up and accepted it. The next week was painful the family decided i should stay and take care of him until he passed but in that last week he was out of it he was jumping between time periods, talking to his dead dad about antique chevy's, him mom about tomorrows lunch and near the last couple hours he sat up in his bed and looked at me, the light in his eyes were back and he seemed like he was entirely there for once and asked me what day it was I told him it was saturday , he asked for the time I told him it was 7:54 pm and the last words he said to me were 'Go ahead and get some sleep we have to go grocery shopping tomorrow and you have to mow the lawn" my aunt showed up to takeover for me so i could get some sleep 'ok paw ill see you in the morning, good night I love you" 'I lover you too boy' and then he closed his eyes and laid back down. My aunt took over and she woke me up 3 hours later crying saying he had passed after that I was on autopilot doing the motions, the funeral, the burial, and the return all that time really let it sink in for me that he was gone forever and of course I started crying again all I learned that week is that its a sad day when a superman dies.
I was raised by my Grandparents..this hit major soft spots for me. The elderly deserve care and hope like anyone else. I’m glad House fought for a heart for Amy’s Grandfather.
@@dragon22214 exactly! people should be prioritised by how much they contribute to the GDP! people who make less than 300K a year should never be entitled to organ transplants!
"How old are *you,* Doctor? When do we get to toss you on an ice floe?" Is one of my favorite all-time House lines. It's just so...House. It's manipulative, it's not entirely fair, even, but it cuts right to the heart of the matter (no pun intended) .
You don't need to save lives to be right nor does he even have to tell his team the right answer once he's figured it out. He could just as well let them suffer and die and still be right and have solved the puzzle.
He also thrives on being publicly right. And still needs to cure to know for sure he's right. Plenty of times he thought he had the answer but turned out he didn't. But to be fair he does care about saving lives, just doesn't care about the person itself.
@@warpatato doubtful - the guy was already on with turning off the ventilator. If House wasn't so in the guys face the organ would have been dead before they got to Cuddy's office
Also, it was the woman in the ER who passed from the car accident whose last name was Neuberger. If you watch he types "Laura" as the first name meaning she's female. add the context of him checking to see if the association could use her organs and, well, you can connect the dots from there ^^
If you think about it, House's lack of sensitivity made him a great doctor. But.. if you count his acts of saving lives through emotion (like the bulimia patient who needed the heart transplant), he was even a greater doctor.
@@davidcurle7381 Your comment is truly stupid, no one would ever think any of this is real because everyone knows House M.D is a tv show. Still, just because it's not real doesn't mean people can't talk about it.
7:40 And that is the moment he knew that he had been played. Because this guy - who'd only had a few scenes - was a good decent person. And what good decent person could possibly respond to that in any other way? I know its only a show. But most people are good decent people, even if they forget it sometimes.
Bilbo_Gamers An organ donor card means that the hospital can decide to use your organs- they didn't. House is suggesting an "experimental" type of organ donation (giving second rate hearts to people with second rate life expectancies) that she didn't technically agree to while alive. It's up to her husband.
But the husband had the right to decide for his wife to be on or off life support - if she was off life support, her organs would have stopped functioning, rendering them useless. Skipped that step in the logical scheme ;)
in Australia at least it comes down to family's consent regardless of card or not. The card is really only there to tell the family its what they wanted, can't really have a legally binding contract with a dead person anyway.
I will never get over the fact that this show had the best musical score ever. Every damn time, that piano plays some heart-breaking combination of chords and I feel like I'm gonna cry my eyes out.
I didn't know that an emergency room has clear doors and family members can just stand there and watch ? I am from Europe so maybe it is normal in the US ?
Well i can't speak for usa but in Canadian hospitals i believe its not clear doors i think its just a plot device tho to show how much the man is suffering and the seriousness and urgency of the situation
@@NorzkenolZn He's talking about when his wife was dying in the ER and he was standing there watching through the glass walls. My ER does have glass walls, but only on the side facing the nurses station. There are, however, curtains that can be drawn. They try to explain away all the glass in this hospital as being there because it is a teaching hospital. It's really there because it is a set for a TV show.
that was the house i liked, he solved the case and wants to make sure the patient is fully healed and goes through most of the episode doing so. slowly went south when he just wanted the answer.. even if it meant they already died midway
I like how well the dialogue at the beginning summarises the arguments for and against ageism in healthcare. It's a heavily debated topic and it was well utilised here
House: Hey, listen. You take your wife off life support and I'll have forgot about this in two weeks. Gale here on the other hand... Amy: Amy. House:Whatever... Haha, good old House, never to bother about learning his patients' names
really hope more and more people do the organ donation , my dad had to donate his kidney for my brother.. He is now discouraged after the operation and afraid that he is on only 1 kidney.. this act of kindness will help many lives...
this makes almost no sense. The hospital just spent what, hundreds of thousands of dollars keeping this patient and treating them only to decide all of that was worthless. I get that they want to give limited hearts to the most likely to survive patients, but the only disqualifier was his age. He would have made it with a healthy heart, and its really presumptive to suggest that because he doesnt get the most possible years out of a heart that he doesnt deserve one. BTW, most heart transplants give you ten extra years. Just ten years of having to wake up and make sure the blood starts flowing, ten years of constant doctoral visits, ten years of immunosuppresants to prevent rejection, just ten years. Alot of patients dont even get that long. 5 years of less then optimal life quality is still better then the week without a heart this man was given. Lots of organs are deemed unusable because of patient health not being pristine. Many more organs are lost because of hospitals not being able to procur them in timely fashions. But its really dumb to say that maybe someone down the line might deserve's that heart more because they will get more time out of it, purely because the man is 60. BTW the average age of a heart transplantee is 70. This man just turned down a 60 year old because he was old, but he's much younger then the average and that tells me that this man values young people more then old people.=
That what scares me about getting old, no one wants to take care of you and they think it’s a waste to save you Because you “lived a full life already”
Your kids would take care of you. Of course, elderly lives matter but if you had to choose -who would you save, a young or an elderly person? Honestly? I mean, elderly themselves would say go save young
lol, 'pinching their ass' isn't exactly something that can be done painfully and as a surprise unless that person is already naked from the waste down and not facing you. in other words he didn't ahve that option. However thank you for providing the image of someone pinching houses ass...its quite humerus
Almost everything House does is medically illegal but still morally right. And this show had several actual doctors as consultants. The medical field could be a lot better if several rules are changed.....
I like how Cameron is just running around looking for dead patients to scavenge from 😂
That moment when ... you think you signed on to be a capital d Dr and you are in actual fact a gofer ... just chasing round body parts
Thats all hes done since he entered into that patients secret satanic worship room with the shrine and he touched the Necronomicon he had on the altar in there. lol
I love that they aren’t even sure she’s brain dead before Cameron spotted her. She’s like “well she’s been down a min” lmao
That’s why they call them vultures
You Like that? I hope you meant it sarcastically.
My dad had a heart transplant about 6 years ago . He's 70 now . This one kinda hit home for me
House MD is one of the greatest series ever and congrats about your dad.
Happy for your dad :) may he live long
aurora dreamer remeber they said 5-10 and 20 if there lucky.
hits home here too, i tried to save my gramps with my lung but the doctor refused saying it would only give him a few years, and would be a waste of a lung on someone old, and then tried doing a House by telling me about a patient who desperately needed a lung and that if i agreed to it there and then, they'd test me and have me open for it in no time. Doctors are cunts.
My grandfather had heart valve surgery and got to live another 10 years, died at 86, they said he can't have another surgery at 86 but I am thankful to the doctors because he lived 10 more years. If medicine wasn't as advanced he would've died at 76...
"Gail here, on the other hand..."
"Amy?"
"Whatever."
I am not sure if that was by accident. By him forgetting her name, it actually proves his point that he will forget about this in two weeks
@@kolos4650 more like 2 days
lPlanetarizado more like 2 seconds
@@rafaela.flores4084 more like never remember in the first place
That was literally my grandmas name
“Take it out on me, not her”
Ten seconds later
“UGH”
Kicks you in the balls you fall to the ground in pain
Ramir Duria That’s quite arguable, he was ethically in the wrong, but logically it makes sense that he should get the heart. Assuming that it doesn’t interfere with anything other than the time keeping the wife “alive”.
House expected to get physically assaulted and knew it was well worth it to save the girl's father. A simple calculation/move, yet heroic in a way.
@@JustSomeGuyLV i doubt he expected his balls to take the hit
@@JustSomeGuyLV He should've wear teeth and crotch protections though ;)
he was rude, he was sarcastic, he was insulting, none of that stopped him making very valid points
I think I’m supposed to comment on the amount of likes you have then say something like “let’s change that” but I don’t really know
@@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr I was just making a joke about how everyone feels the need to say “585 likes and no replies? Let’s change that” when they see a very liked comment without replies
@@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr that sounds like a lot of compartmentalized racism and misogyny there bud
@@nsahandler Misogyny, misandry, and worst of all... homie-phobia.
He manipulated a grieving husband and called his wifes body meat. House doesn't care and his argument isnt valid
You know when House puts on his lab coat he’s about to put on a serious act!
William Chan extremely manipulative and unethical. i don’t think it’s illegal though.
Bro not gonna lie, I choked up when I saw him wearing his coat.
This is why free markets exist so those who have succeeded in life can just buy their rewards and remain living.
Bel Rick wtf does tht have to do w anything? The organ donor list is by no means free market. Not to mention tht all major civilized nations in the world tht run on freemarkets recgnize tht there are some thing u shldnt leave up to the free market, like healthcare
No, sometimes sociopaths take control and thereby remove civil liberties and it sure as shit isn't civilized "please sir, may i have a heart, i've earned one!" "NO! We decide who gets the heart, go die"
House was really good when he was on your side. I loved how he fought for his patient, He said to Cameron the board was right but still his patient for him was first.
when did he tell cameron that the board was right?
In the episode, these are just clips
AND the puzzle was already solved.
he didnt really fight for his patient, he just hates when things are not seen through to the end.
the man was happy a dying woman might have her organs rejected after her death
This episode did illustrate a very valid point that many perfectly _serviceable_ organs are simply thrown in the trash because they're not 100% _perfectly_ healthy. Sure, keep the perfect organs for younger, otherwise healthy people who would get the most use out of them, but "second class" organs could still be used for other patients who might only have a few years left, for whatever reason. Hell, if you give a heart from a fat woman to an elderly man who is otherwise in good health and lives a healthy lifestyle, like in this episode, the heart could become more healthy inside him and give him even longer than predicted.
(Edit:) so many people only responding to the basic idea without thinking about it. I shouldn't have had to point out that, obviously, a complete medical and legal infrastructure would have to be built around the practice, to protect both patients and doctors. I wasn't advocating for hospitals to just start going about it on spur of the moment inspiration like House did.
Yes, sure but its a logistical problem, even if every single person who died had perfect organs to donate, a lot of them woulb have to be discarded, because their storage is incredibly finnicky ( for lack of a better word ), and if there is a problem in their storage ( wich in this case, with so many organs to handle at once, it is likely ) they would have to be discarded aswell for fear of contamination.
Take china for example, they steal organs from political dessenters, so their market is flooded with organs, way more than the US has, and still, they cant manage all of them, there are people who still die waiting for those organs.
@@theterribleanimator1793 just make a second class organ separated from the normal one.
Bad organ better then no organ.
@@rushyscoper1651 Not exactly. Organ failure causes a huge amount of pain. There are schools of thought that would argue that a peaceful death would be preferable to living longer in suffering.
Medical ethics is fickle because there are nearly 100 schools of thought competing to be the new central dogma for all of medicine. Organ transplant, like everything else in medicine that involves death, is hotly debated over.
@Jakk Frost; Law suit. Putting "second-rate" organ would increase the chance of failure even after successful procedure....so...the hospital could be sued for that. Even if statement could be made before the surgery, some lawyers somewhere could make a plausible cause to sue the hospital.
> they steal organs from political dessenters, so their market is flooded with organs
Except that they don't and it isn't.
My mother’s heart was devastated by a massive heart attack and needed a transplant. Basically was running at 20 percent capacity or less. Unsustainable. We were so lucky that we had a perfect match, and the hospital was willing to give her the heart at age 57. She’s doing great now. Should easily live another 25-30 years with her lifestyle.
I'm so happy for you and I hope your mother is doing well 💙💜
@srush Nobody needed your clarification.
@srush ???????
Hope your momma is still alive and thriving, five years later, brother.
Now I want to know what srush said, but his channel got deleted for not abiding by community guidelines.
"She's my wife" - "not anymore"
_Till death do us apart_
500 likes no comments guess I’ll be the first
Hi
'Til death do us PART. Not apart. Smh...
Technically still not medically dead. Probably hasn't even left her body to face her Maker.
@@james_ford86 "Til' death do us part" means "until death separates us"
Guy: your dad can.... have her heart.
House: (grunts) thank you.
Guy: I’m doing it for her. Not for you.
House: no. I meant thank you for helping me forget the pain I have in my leg.
hahhhahahaaahaaa
Season, episode? :)
It''s an alternative hypothetical conversation that would follow after he kicked him in the groin.
No, I'm asking about the video.
Goran Tomin description bruh
I wonder how many medical licenses have been revoked from Dr. House
FlippyTuna
He would've lost it in this episode, and pretty much every episode I have watched. It's just suppose to be fun.
FlippyTuna so easy to lose the license its disgusting
I'd love to hear your obviously crazy expectation of why he would have lost it in this episode.
ThePatrickis
He broke patient confidentiality (and hacked into confidential patient records) and was unethical in obtaining the heart via emotional manipulation. Of course, he's probably only lose it if a complaint was filed, but that behaviour would never be condoned. However, as I stated, this is a drama and it's dramatized to make the show more entertaining.
He didnt hack into any confidential patient records as things like wether or not the organs were declared as viable or not is information accesible for senior staff like house. What patient confidentiality did he break? literally none. Also just because you deem his way of obtaining the heart unethical does not mean that it is or that anyone would bring charges since he did agree in the end. you could not be more mistaken, you could try, but you would fail.
That guy, the husband of the dead woman.. he is one of the best actors that has appeared on this show
He was one of the main characters in the series Heroes.
Matt Parkman
Also in the Rockstar game LA Noire!
Greg Grunberg
That's Matt Parkman!
"Gale here on the other hand."
"Amy."
"Whatever."
Ha ha, I love it when they do scenes like this. Really breaks the tension.
"It's a marriage made in heaven!" Wow, that's really poorly worded on multiple levels.
Hahahahaha, Hugo Mueller did kill his wife
omg I didn't see that ahahahah
Sam Sizer
It was expertly worded on multiple levels
All House phrases in this whole episode were really poorly worded
@@williambrady9578it’s moller. Not the guy who investigated trump.
"How old are u Dr. ? When do we get to toss u in an ice flow??" Burst a laugh !!
floe
It’s different when it’s not you
This shows how much double standards that doctor in the medical committee has. He wouldn’t have said that if it was one of his own people whose days are numbered. Way to expose his hypocrisy, House. This is why I respect you. Your bedside manner may be a bit rusty for a doctor but your methods are effective while saving people’s lives.
*_floe_* ;)
@@akshaymundkur except later in the episode House admitted that he actually agrees with the committee and was only arguing for the sake of his patient.
"She's my wife"
"Not anymore"
Ouch😂
Ari Ochoa Silver tough devil, I call it.
Ari Ochoa I almost died laughing
Oof
Ari love House...brutal honesty
that's an awful reply by House. How about
"she's my wife."
"she was your wife, now she's the saviour of a family man. Is that so bad?"
Should be a transplant list and a alternative transplant list. The alternative for people who have 0 chance and who have been refused a perfect heart. They should be able to sign away the right to sue if complications happen other than gross malpractice of course and get the tossed organs that are not ideal but who still have good potential and are better than nothing.
Problem is people on that alternative list will not be grateful if and when their loved ones die soon after transplant. If you transplant an organ with a risk of hep c infection which then kills the patient, his loved ones will decide, fairly or not, that it was your fault that the patient died, and even if you ban them from suing, they will stir up distrust of the whole organ donation system that will do more harm in the long run than the good produced by trying to save the lives of these marginal cases. In short, it's necessary to deliberately allow people to die of organ failure because mankind is irrational and selfish.
Scoot Matheson Yeah, decent point... One the other hand, some ten thousand possibly preventable deaths every year. If implemented even marginally well, this system would be great, but good luck getting it through the health-insurance and hospital management lobbyist swines.
Alternatively we could do the following.
1. Let people SELL their organs post mortem. This would drastically increase the willing donors.
2. Let private buisness purchase organs rather than attaching it to a state run board.
If you do these two things I guarantee you will have dozens of companies buying and storing organs within a year, the price would also likely actually go down due to the massive supply increase and the incentives to inovate In storage.
To prevent abuses you would however likely need to mandate
3. That organ companies buy insurance for defective organs. This would actually solve almost all abuses as the insurance companies would keep the organ market mostly in line. I'd imagine you'd have more deaths due to transplant complications, but far fewer deaths due to insufficient organs, which would on balance save many lives.
Jane Hrahan that could work in a society with a good private and public healthcare system, and in which crime rates and migration are low. The private sector distributes, the public sector ensures there’s an alternative in case of monopoly (or objection of conscience) and regulates the practice (usually this isn’t beneficial, but in medicine a minimum standard of quality is necessary for it to make sense), low crime rates prevent organ harvesting and black markets, and low immigration prevent human trafficking and transplant tourism. The latter could be viable if there is a great surplus.
@@janehrahan5116 and presumably if you are selling organs you must buy them...
I think I detect an american
Person shouldnt be refused healthcare, and as a result organ donations, because they arent born with a silver spoon or dont make as much as someone else
It's so strange to see House literally go out of his way to guilt trip an organ donor committee, get a heart that's been rejected and get punched in the gut just for an elderly patient. His words say one thing,his actions say another
I thought he got kneed in the groin.
1:49
This actually made me start crying, my grandfather raised me and in my eyes he was a superman and when I got to be bigger than him and he started to get older I started watching him, everywhere he went i was with him always behind him (the family called me his shadow lol). Well he started to have heart problems around 2017, he was 78 and had done hard labor his entire life (he still worked at the family business with us) and the doctors wanted to do surgery, he put off the surgery until my graduation that same year and when i finally graduated he went under the knife. The surgery went smoothly and he was awake and talking a week later so they released him about a month later, but he had some infection issues, and had to go back in for another 2 months to get cleared up but after he got out we learned he was suffering from congestive heart failure and the doctor gave him at most 3-4 years before his heart gave out, it was hard but I accepted it and we were good for about 9 months. Then july 2018 hit, my grandfather had started to slow down had swelling in his legs, always lethargic he would wake me up at different times in the night and ask me to watch tv with him and we had no problems but one night he told me he was scared of dying and that he didnt want to go, I was never good at these kinds of conversation and i just reassured him he wasnt dying anytime soon and everything was gonna be okay, I was wrong, 2 weeks later his doctor came over to visit us for the fourth of july and after looking over my grandfather for a few minutes he took me and my aunts, uncles and grandmother to the back room and he gave my grand father a week at most to live, it killed me I went outside and cried for what seemed like hours before I hardened up and accepted it. The next week was painful the family decided i should stay and take care of him until he passed but in that last week he was out of it he was jumping between time periods, talking to his dead dad about antique chevy's, him mom about tomorrows lunch and near the last couple hours he sat up in his bed and looked at me, the light in his eyes were back and he seemed like he was entirely there for once and asked me what day it was I told him it was saturday , he asked for the time I told him it was 7:54 pm and the last words he said to me were 'Go ahead and get some sleep we have to go grocery shopping tomorrow and you have to mow the lawn" my aunt showed up to takeover for me so i could get some sleep 'ok paw ill see you in the morning, good night I love you" 'I lover you too boy' and then he closed his eyes and laid back down. My aunt took over and she woke me up 3 hours later crying saying he had passed after that I was on autopilot doing the motions, the funeral, the burial, and the return all that time really let it sink in for me that he was gone forever and of course I started crying again all I learned that week is that its a sad day when a superman dies.
Superman never really die. They live on in the hearts of the ones they loved.. so glad u had that time with him..
He had an amazing grandchild. You were blessed to have him, he was blessed to have you.
I was raised by my Grandparents..this hit major soft spots for me. The elderly deserve care and hope like anyone else. I’m glad House fought for a heart for Amy’s Grandfather.
Cuddy was right there hearts are a rare and they have to go to those that can use it the best
Wasn't her name Gale?
@@TrisSpy Whatever
They deserve care and hope within reason just like everyone else
@@dragon22214 exactly! people should be prioritised by how much they contribute to the GDP!
people who make less than 300K a year should never be entitled to organ transplants!
"He's 66."
"He told me he was 65, liar."
"This is his first hospitalisation since he broke his leg when he was 23 or 22 I'm not sure anymore" :P
idk
She literally looks 12 and was probably around 30 during this
WCGwkf Perfect for my taste.
She's 39 now.
Who dat
Jr TuMacho Keri Lynn Pratt
And the character was about 20
What i love about this episode is house had already solved his puzzle, yet he still fought to save the man’s life
"How old are *you,* Doctor? When do we get to toss you on an ice floe?"
Is one of my favorite all-time House lines. It's just so...House. It's manipulative, it's not entirely fair, even, but it cuts right to the heart of the matter (no pun intended) .
It is a great line. But is it really unfair? He is pointing something out.
How can a man care so much about saving peoples lives and still be so indifferent towards everyone?
Utilitarianism.
You don't need to save lives to be right nor does he even have to tell his team the right answer once he's figured it out. He could just as well let them suffer and die and still be right and have solved the puzzle.
He also thrives on being publicly right. And still needs to cure to know for sure he's right. Plenty of times he thought he had the answer but turned out he didn't. But to be fair he does care about saving lives, just doesn't care about the person itself.
Because feelings are overrated. Life is important, not opinions
Ah.. the frigid wind of teen rebellion
House is da real mvp for taking that hit.
To be fair he would have gotten the heart without getting hit if he have show some tack and didn't piss off the husband so much xd
Would have been funny if he said something like "Why did he go for the nuts?"
Now no one can say house hasn't done anything for his patients
@@warpatato doubtful - the guy was already on with turning off the ventilator.
If House wasn't so in the guys face the organ would have been dead before they got to Cuddy's office
Aleksandar Mitic he’s always the MVP
The fat guy's name is Newburger? The writers being a bit direct there.
I wonder if he will get a new burger for a wife after all House did point out to him his wife is just meat at this point :P
it's a German surname, literally it would translate into something like "NewMountain-er"
Also, it was the woman in the ER who passed from the car accident whose last name was Neuberger. If you watch he types "Laura" as the first name meaning she's female. add the context of him checking to see if the association could use her organs and, well, you can connect the dots from there ^^
It clearly wasn't her maiden name though, it was the husband's surname.
Hey, it's a 'u' not a 'w'!
If you think about it, House's lack of sensitivity made him a great doctor. But.. if you count his acts of saving lives through emotion (like the bulimia patient who needed the heart transplant), he was even a greater doctor.
Hey this is not real!
@@davidcurle7381 Thank you, Captain Obvious.
@@Primus54 the point was for some, it seems not obvious- comments passionately made if it was real!
@@davidcurle7381 Your comment is truly stupid, no one would ever think any of this is real because everyone knows House M.D is a tv show. Still, just because it's not real doesn't mean people can't talk about it.
@@shydreameress264 No it's real. Hahahah
"Take it out on me, not on her"
Knees house right in the balls
"You can have the heart"
Some times that little catharsis goes a long way
Don't worry, he'll just use the power of the dark side and regain his health.
Kenny first thing I thought, this guy looks JUST like Emperor Palpatine 😂
"How old are you doctor? When do we get to toss you on an Ice flow"
Best line!
Well, to be fair he did offer
It's amazing how you can have such a touching moment that still includes a groin shot.
This shows how much house cares about his patients even though he does not want to show it he will do anything to help them so much respect to him
The way Hugh raises his eyebrows brings back so many memories of Blackadder
7:40
And that is the moment he knew that he had been played. Because this guy - who'd only had a few scenes - was a good decent person. And what good decent person could possibly respond to that in any other way?
I know its only a show. But most people are good decent people, even if they forget it sometimes.
A member of a medical review panel should review this show to talk about how many times House should have lost his medical license
I can tell you exactly how that would go.
You: How many times should House have lost his license?
Medical Review Board: Yes.
The scene in the ER is one of the very rare times they’re actually doing chest compressions on someone who’s in cardiac arrest.
Poor CPR. WWWAAAYYY too fast compressions
That's Ellen from Drake and Josh
House: Why didn't you notify him of his wife's death?
Ellen: That is Not mah job
It's Helen
It is indeed Helen, just Ellen here. Kind of funny.
@@Pheer777 Underrated
And Shirley!!!
You know u have a good Doctor when he takes a hit in the crouch so that your dad can have a heart
8:16 is the best moment of the House series, with Chase's punch coming in a close second.
That girl is gorgeous.
I guess but I prefer them living
Keri Lynn Pratt
She was on a Smallville right around this time.
Yeah and cute.
Name?
Wtf she had an organ donor card? What happens to her organs is not her husband's decision.
Bilbo_Gamers
An organ donor card means that the hospital can decide to use your organs- they didn't. House is suggesting an "experimental" type of organ donation (giving second rate hearts to people with second rate life expectancies) that she didn't technically agree to while alive. It's up to her husband.
Bilbo_Gamers her choice. she consented to the technology. house's argument is flawed, lack of heat heart is not the cause. only way!😲
But the husband had the right to decide for his wife to be on or off life support - if she was off life support, her organs would have stopped functioning, rendering them useless. Skipped that step in the logical scheme ;)
The point is, once the organ transplant team decided to decline to use her organs, it became the husband's decision again.
in Australia at least it comes down to family's consent regardless of card or not. The card is really only there to tell the family its what they wanted, can't really have a legally binding contract with a dead person anyway.
“Gail here...” “Amy” “Whatever.” 😂😂😂
I like the husband of the dead wife, he was a cool character albeit being brief, and was greatly acted. House kinda deserved that
This channel is making me want to actually watch this series
come on !!!! watch it , best serie ever !!!!!
I'm so glad Mr. Neuburger accepted the deal House offered him
Whatever it takes to save the patient. House is actually a great doctor
"This is my wife"
"Not anymore"
*drops mic*
*picks up scalpel*
man that girl is so cute
grrmonkey do we have a name?
Seigi Tenshi well I was talking about the fat girl on the table...
Seigi Tenshi jk, Keri Lynn Pratt
grrmonkey I won't judge either way >P
Bruh she like 12
What's Shirley doing there ? I swear i recognize someone everytime i watch House.
What's... ehm... the cop from Heroes doing there? ;-)
Shirley Temple?
Nate Jones Bennett from Community
"Take it out on me not her. "
Procceds to kick house in the nuts.
"Fine , You can have her heart . "
I will never get over the fact that this show had the best musical score ever. Every damn time, that piano plays some heart-breaking combination of chords and I feel like I'm gonna cry my eyes out.
I can’t with House sarcastic self 😂😂 love him
8:11 lmao those puppydog eyes.
This is honestly heart breaking and freaking hilarious at the same time. The feels for the guy who lost a loved one.
House: Gail here on the other hand
Daughter: Amy
House: Whatever
House is a savage lol 🤣🤣🤣
Mr. Neuberger: "Your dad can have her heart"
House: "and I think I'm gonna need her spleen"
it's heartbreaking watching this part of episodes without the full episodes :D
Ty for uploading. Love this episode
Jose Krimzon what episode was this one?
Mehrab Daemi Season 2 Episode 14
Which episode is it?
Oh sorry nvm lol
@@blakehouston2044 darude - sandstorm
I didn't know that an emergency room has clear doors and family members can just stand there and watch ? I am from Europe so maybe it is normal in the US ?
Nihal 542765 were not EMR cuddys office is not in that part of hospital
Depends on the hospital
Well i can't speak for usa but in Canadian hospitals i believe its not clear doors i think its just a plot device tho to show how much the man is suffering and the seriousness and urgency of the situation
@@NorzkenolZn He's talking about when his wife was dying in the ER and he was standing there watching through the glass walls. My ER does have glass walls, but only on the side facing the nurses station. There are, however, curtains that can be drawn. They try to explain away all the glass in this hospital as being there because it is a teaching hospital. It's really there because it is a set for a TV show.
US ERs, at least the ones I have seen, don't have clear doors. I just assumed it was for theatrical reasons.
House balls = woman heart
"How old are you, doctor?" That's a fatal shot.
I lost it when House said “gale here” and she replied “Amy”. 💀💀
whenever Grunberg turns his head to the side, like gives them a side look during conversation, I always think he's trying to read their mind
That’s such a difficult situation. Shout out to house for going about it in the worse/most entertaining way possible.
7:36 that expression... he was trying to read her mind
Keri Lynn Pratt is the most adorable thing I've ever seen in my life.
The title should be renamed "House Asks For Testicle Transplant".
“If you really cared about me, you’d find me a better corpse” 😅
that was the house i liked, he solved the case and wants to make sure the patient is fully healed and goes through most of the episode doing so. slowly went south when he just wanted the answer.. even if it meant they already died midway
8:18 This is what a doctor gets from trying to save a life. 🙁🙁🙁
I like how well the dialogue at the beginning summarises the arguments for and against ageism in healthcare. It's a heavily debated topic and it was well utilised here
0:13 moments like these are why i love house such a smartass lol
4:10 onwards is "people you will know from other things" city.
House: Hey, listen. You take your wife off life support and I'll have forgot about this in two weeks. Gale here on the other hand...
Amy: Amy.
House:Whatever...
Haha, good old House, never to bother about learning his patients' names
No matter how obnoxious house is, he does it to save lives. He is such a sweetie
really hope more and more people do the organ donation , my dad had to donate his kidney for my brother.. He is now discouraged after the operation and afraid that he is on only 1 kidney.. this act of kindness will help many lives...
'take it out on me, not her' dude: 'say less'
SHIRLEY?!
All those years at Greendale and caring for her father pair off.
Surely, and don't call me Shirley again.
A little Nake Gun allusion, eh?
His daughter is precious.
I mean to be honest at 8:05 he did say take it out on me, not her
this makes almost no sense. The hospital just spent what, hundreds of thousands of dollars keeping this patient and treating them only to decide all of that was worthless. I get that they want to give limited hearts to the most likely to survive patients, but the only disqualifier was his age. He would have made it with a healthy heart, and its really presumptive to suggest that because he doesnt get the most possible years out of a heart that he doesnt deserve one.
BTW, most heart transplants give you ten extra years. Just ten years of having to wake up and make sure the blood starts flowing, ten years of constant doctoral visits, ten years of immunosuppresants to prevent rejection, just ten years. Alot of patients dont even get that long. 5 years of less then optimal life quality is still better then the week without a heart this man was given.
Lots of organs are deemed unusable because of patient health not being pristine. Many more organs are lost because of hospitals not being able to procur them in timely fashions. But its really dumb to say that maybe someone down the line might deserve's that heart more because they will get more time out of it, purely because the man is 60.
BTW the average age of a heart transplantee is 70. This man just turned down a 60 year old because he was old, but he's much younger then the average and that tells me that this man values young people more then old people.=
I had a heart transplant in Sept 2022 so these episodes hit hard for me. I’m only 20 I was 18 at the time
"Take it out on me, not her."
"OK, here it comes ..."
"You think you can win me over by calling me a racist?" what is this, current year?
Yeah...
That what scares me about getting old, no one wants to take care of you and they think it’s a waste to save you Because you “lived a full life already”
Your kids would take care of you. Of course, elderly lives matter but if you had to choose -who would you save, a young or an elderly person? Honestly? I mean, elderly themselves would say go save young
If that's what scares you about getting old you haven't learn yet how much it sucks to age physically, mentally even before you start to die. Not fun.
I really like how this show explores Soo Manny gray areas.
I miss House so much. House was wonderful. It really brought some cheer into a paraplegics day.
Why is it always the crotch?
If you wanted to 'take it out' on somebody, would you knee them:
a, in a place where it hurts far more than anywhere else?
b, anywhere else?
lol, 'pinching their ass' isn't exactly something that can be done painfully and as a surprise unless that person is already naked from the waste down and not facing you. in other words he didn't ahve that option. However thank you for providing the image of someone pinching houses ass...its quite humerus
Liver or kidneys are good. You get a solid blow there you hit the dirt no matter how tough you are.
Humerus? No, I'd say quite radius.
A good knee strike in a relaxed quadriceps can hurt a lot
4:12 Shirley from Community 😂😂
8:30
House: Your welcome, Gale
House:I have respect for the living
Only few seconds later
House: calls her galle
The girl: its Amy
House: I don't care
Honestly, if I was House, I would have done the same thing. A jerk saving as many lives as he can 👍
Yay! Yvette Nicole Brown is always a delight.
So is House in a white coat...
Almost everything House does is medically illegal but still morally right.
And this show had several actual doctors as consultants.
The medical field could be a lot better if several rules are changed.....
The law is crazy, in many ways
House always wins
Well that was a rollercoaster of a video right there
can probably see the entire series by just watching all the short yt clips by now.