We all value and respect your opinion Johnathan. Telling the truth is nothing to apologize for. You tell it as it is. Stay Strong, stand your ground.💯🌟
Mister Pollard, sir, do not be saddened,feeling putdown,for speaking truth,the Holy Scrolls,the Holy land and the Holy people, set apart,the apple of His eye,the light to the nations,your land,your people,HaShem is with you, the nations still have the time to choose wisely,to learn from your words and from Rebbe Dovid,to hold fast the garment of you, children of Yisrael,thank you for speaking out,this world is running out of time.May we all soon see the coming of Mosshiach,in our days,for His beloved,His children,the beautifull people.Thank you sir,thank you Rebbe!
Jonathan is a genius. I wish the Rabbi would let him speak more. I also notice that the Rabbi does not always respond or comment on Jonathan's brilliant observations but instead begins his own as if ignoring Jonathan's insightful contributions to the conversation.
Jonathan you're passion was there but clearly Perry is a professional BS artist. I would recommend two things. first of all go over your interview with him or ambush with a professional debater just to sharpen your skills and how to respond to a slick tongue snake like him, second perhaps Rav Bar Chayim, can invite him on to this program to an equal time debate with the Rav being the "balanced" moderator. The debate should be done in a calm fashion not attacking him personally but more about his ideas and how he's wrong historically and according to Jewish philosophy and law. If he declines the debate publicize that he's a wimp and will only go on programs with moderators friendly to him.
You have zero to apologise for Yonatan, the creep made my blood boil. My comment caused me to be suspended from you tube for 24 hours. i24 has become a disappointment after the first couple of months of this war.
Jewish Nationalism is a matter of survival. If we aren't extreme we cease to exist. Hashem is in control and it definitely boils down to our merits whether we survive or not. But we can't be wishy washy with how we deal with the Land. They certainly weren't in times of our Temple. We fought. We've always fought for our existence and always will.
Jonathan and Rabbi, i am totally on your side, the only thing that has happened to me since Covid and politics as it stands today, is a leaning to the right of Genghis Kahn, and no one is going to change my mind. I just pray Hashem allows us to win this war with not too much more pain and suffering and that Israel remains a Jewish Country, and that we can live in peace, happily ever after. Its enough😭
Perry was very arrogant in that interview. He's a professional debater, whereas you Mr Pollard are not. People like him sense your passion and love for Am Yisrael... honestly, this is the vulnerability of all of us who see the injustice against us. they use this as our weakness...It's not in your nature to be a ruthless debater
I saw the i24 with Dan Perry and he had the most outlandish arguments I've ever heard when compared to Yonatan's. I find i24 to be a bit disingenuous at times. A soon as the mayhem of Oct 7th tones down, they resort back to the echo chamber talking points of the US.
Today Pakistan has expelled 2 million Afghans from the country because of their constant terrorism. Over 6 million people have left the territory of Ukraine as a result of the war. After the World War 2, the Sudeten Germans (numbering more than 3 million) and the Carpathian Germans (about 500 thousand), who had lived in Slovakia and Transcarpathian Ukraine since the 13th century, were deported from the Sudetenland region of the Czech Republic, by the people of the Czech Republic, as the sympathizers of the German fascists. Why does Israel, after the bloody pogroms in her own country, should act to the detriment of the safety of her citizens, differently, than the nations of the world have always acted for centuries in similar situations ?
Mr Jonathan Pollard you must understand there is a fifth group, they are the Erav Rav, this is a group that joined the Jews that left Egypt, and through our long history have become mixed with the Jewish people, and they are the ones that have caused us all our problems all trough history, and will be ruling Israel as we get closer to the redemption, there are great Rabbis like the Ramchal and others that have written about the Erav Rav in the end of days, the terrible problems they will bring upon the Jewish people.
My Dad, al love shalom said to fix peeping doors with some oil. So Jonathan and Rivkah a simple solution just put a bit off oil on the Hinges, any oil will do.
Jonathan, you were very civil, nothing to apologize for. He was the spewing slogans "exreme right", "fascist"... Your points got through, and all he could respond is that your solutions are too simple and will isolate us from the world.. Interesting that he didn't say your idea was immoral, just that it's not practical..
Thks dear Jonathan I agree with you and when I tried to point out this situation I am considered old fashioned an enemy of the civilization but what civilization pls??? Despite Israeli society is affectd by this anti jewish culture. We need a jewish state according to the HaShem s convenant no respected. Again thks Jonathan. AM ISRAEL HAI with the hope that Mashiah will come soon. un
That fourth group are Erev Rav, some yes, some not anti-Jewish. And of course there are Erev Rav among the other three groups. I read somewhere that there will only be 600,000 survivors! after the Geulah. That would correlate with Har Sinai. Yes Yehonatan is correct about our indigenous roots.
Geulah was Israel’s national rebirth in 1948 and there was indeed 600,000 when that happened. And when it grew to 600,000 of young fighting age Israel expanded to take Jerusalem. These numbers correlate to the number at mt Sinai and the numbers led by Yehoshua Ben Nun. Israel is now fighting the wars in the tanakh with correlations to the period of Judges and the transition from Shaul to David in Sefer Shmuel.
unfortunately, in US for example, being brought up without religious education or many Jewish traditions is a stumbling block to being true to oneself and being a Jew. Without wanting to be “Western” at all we feel unmoored from any world. We know who we are but how to join the Jewish people fully? It can be done but it is not easy.
Which of the 4 types of Jews described by rabbi would be the belief way of the Jews that were living on the border with Gaza in the kabutz on that horrible day of 10/7?
that's an embarrassing question as i bet you know. theanswer is, mostly number 4, i.e.,totally secular, post-Jewish and movingt owards post-zionist as well.
@@phillipbaram9563 I apologize if it’s insulting but I’m onGod’s side and we need to see it His way and be on His side - I pray that ALL Jews in the land return to the abrahamic covenant
Right now, today, over a million refugees and growing of christians and moslems fleeing isis is north mozambique. Just say jews instead of isis and then the world will care.
When Pollard speaks about "Our Enemies" The Prophet Isaiah, the Jews sawed in half , he said that God YHVH is the enemy of the Jews. , . God said "So I turned against them, I became their enemy, and I YHVH GOD fought against them ( against the Jews in Jerusalem) So the Jews invented Judaism to murder God.
Time to change the definition of Jew. There is no Torah basis for Jewish by the mother. In Torah, you are a Jew if you are in a covenant with God. Osnat, Ruth, etc... Anything else makes a mockery of Torah. Just because Hitler says you are a Jew does not make you a Jew. Unfortunately, the Hitler definition is basically what causes us our problems.
That person thinks the truth is an opinion you can agree or disagree upon, two persons three opinions., you know (?) Life and Death is not an opinion, HaShem's word is not in that league at all ! I want to sent you something on Korea spiel, which I am a victim of also ( tell Bibi)
Hashem loves every Jew. Even those who are very far from yiddeshkeit. In fact, Hashem has the greatest pleasure when someone who is far makes even the tiniest move in the direction of teshuva. Traitors are found in all the groups you mentioned. It is a well known fact that the time preceding the redemption, the Rabbis are the ones preventing it from happening.
You dont know if Hashem has the greatest pleasure from the tiniest move to teshuva from those who are far. That's your assumption. In any case, traitors don't do any teshuva.
Yep, the same love he had for those who made the avoda zara of the golden calf; then He destroyed them. That's true up to a certain point. If a Jew becomes an enmity against Hashem, all bets are off.
It would appear that you fail to realize if you are Jewish, yet don’t keep HaShems covenant then you are by every definition cut off. Sorry you can’t have your cake and eat it too.
Speaking of types of Jews, you failed to mention the Herods among you. Through the vehicle of the false doctrine of matrilineal descent, you yourself created this infusion of Esau among you, and they have become a knife in your side. Yes?
At the end of Isaiah 19, The Lord Almighty gave the blessing, "Blessed is Egypt my People, Assyria the Work of my Hands, Israel my Inheritance ". So the one giving the blessing, as Lord must be Son of the Father, since he says "ISRAEL IS MY INHERITANCE". God as Creator does not inherit anything, the Messiah must inherit seing a Father and Son complexity of relationship is required to say there is an INHERITANCE. So there is nothing in that for the Jew, they have not eaten the Passover for 1950 years, under Moses Law in Exodus Chapter 12, the Jews are Foreigners and Occupiers in the land promised to Israel, they are not Israel, and they will have another Holocaust and Exile out of Jerusalem, because YHVH is their enemy, who has kept them from the Korban Services of Temple Israel, because the only place God is sending them is down to SHEOL.
I saw the i24 with Dan Perry and he had the most outlandish arguments I've ever heard when compared to Yonatan's. I find i24 to be a bit disingenuous at times. A soon as the mayhem of Oct 7th tones down, they resort back to the echo chamber talking point of the US.
![How to Get a Developer Job - Even in This Economy [Full Course]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6nz8GXjxiHg/mqdefault.jpg)
We all value and respect your opinion
Johnathan. Telling the truth is nothing to apologize for. You tell it as it is.
Stay Strong, stand your ground.💯🌟
thks.
Jonathan you argued very well without preparation nothing to be sorry for. It's not possible to give clarity to people like Perry.
Mister Pollard, sir, do not be saddened,feeling putdown,for speaking truth,the Holy Scrolls,the Holy land and the Holy people, set apart,the apple of His eye,the light to the nations,your land,your people,HaShem is with you, the nations still have the time to choose wisely,to learn from your words and from Rebbe Dovid,to hold fast the garment of you, children of Yisrael,thank you for speaking out,this world is running out of time.May we all soon see the coming of Mosshiach,in our days,for His beloved,His children,the beautifull people.Thank you sir,thank you Rebbe!
Jonathan is a genius. I wish the Rabbi would let him speak more.
I also notice that the Rabbi does not always respond or comment on Jonathan's brilliant observations but instead begins his own as if ignoring Jonathan's insightful contributions to the conversation.
It’s his channel
To be fair, I think the Rabbi likes Pollard very much and I am grateful for these videos.
@@mhasson33 I only watch the channel because of Jonathan Pollard.
Jonathan you're passion was there but clearly Perry is a professional BS artist. I would recommend two things. first of all go over your interview with him or ambush with a professional debater just to sharpen your skills and how to respond to a slick tongue snake like him, second perhaps Rav Bar Chayim, can invite him on to this program to an equal time debate with the Rav being the "balanced" moderator. The debate should be done in a calm fashion not attacking him personally but more about his ideas and how he's wrong historically and according to Jewish philosophy and law.
If he declines the debate publicize that he's a wimp and will only go on programs with moderators friendly to him.
I support Israel. I have 5 branches of my family living in Israel. HaShem Bless Israel.
You have zero to apologise for Yonatan, the creep made my blood boil. My comment caused me to be suspended from you tube for 24 hours. i24 has become a disappointment after the first couple of months of this war.
Great minds…right on!
thank you for the truthful and deep content.
הרבה ברכות.
Jewish Nationalism is a matter of survival. If we aren't extreme we cease to exist. Hashem is in control and it definitely boils down to our merits whether we survive or not. But we can't be wishy washy with how we deal with the Land. They certainly weren't in times of our Temple. We fought. We've always fought for our existence and always will.
You have the biggest gay parade in the world in tel Aviv. But you think God is on you're side.
😂😂😂
Jonathan and Rabbi, i am totally on your side, the only thing that has happened to me since Covid and politics as it stands today, is a leaning to the right of Genghis Kahn, and no one is going to change my mind. I just pray Hashem allows us to win this war with not too much more pain and suffering and that Israel remains a Jewish Country, and that we can live in peace, happily ever after. Its enough😭
❤. I watched and I think talking over each other kept Mr. Pollard’s very salient points from being heard.
Perry was very arrogant in that interview. He's a professional debater, whereas you Mr Pollard are not. People like him sense your passion and love for Am Yisrael... honestly, this is the vulnerability of all of us who see the injustice against us. they use this as our weakness...It's not in your nature to be a ruthless debater
This is where Rabbi Tovia Singer comes in...
I saw the i24 with Dan Perry and he had the most outlandish arguments I've ever heard when compared to Yonatan's. I find i24 to be a bit disingenuous at times. A soon as the mayhem of Oct 7th tones down, they resort back to the echo chamber talking points of the US.
Today Pakistan has expelled 2 million Afghans from the country because of their constant terrorism. Over 6 million people have left the territory of Ukraine as a result of the war. After the World War 2, the Sudeten Germans (numbering more than 3 million) and the Carpathian Germans (about 500 thousand), who had lived in Slovakia and Transcarpathian Ukraine since the 13th century, were deported from the Sudetenland region of the Czech Republic, by the people of the Czech Republic, as the sympathizers of the German fascists. Why does Israel, after the bloody pogroms in her own country, should act to the detriment of the safety of her citizens, differently, than the nations of the world have always acted for centuries in similar situations ?
Mr Jonathan Pollard you must understand there is a fifth group, they are the Erav Rav, this is a group that joined the Jews that left Egypt, and through our long history have become mixed with the Jewish people, and they are the ones that have caused us all our problems all trough history, and will be ruling Israel as we get closer to the redemption, there are great Rabbis like the Ramchal and others that have written about the Erav Rav in the end of days, the terrible problems they will bring upon the Jewish people.
We need more Pollards and fewer perries.
He prepared himself and you didn't, you were just prepared to talk honestly
Exactly.
My Dad, al love shalom said to fix peeping doors with some oil. So Jonathan and Rivkah a simple solution just put a bit off oil on the Hinges, any oil will do.
Thank you Jonathan and Rabbi David Bar- Hayim I agree with you both ... I AM PROUD TO BE JEWISH ... JULY 10 ,2024
Jonathan, you were very civil, nothing to apologize for. He was the spewing slogans "exreme right", "fascist"... Your points got through, and all he could respond is that your solutions are too simple and will isolate us from the world.. Interesting that he didn't say your idea was immoral, just that it's not practical..
Europe seems like the sound made when one throws up.
Dear Rabbi please allow Jonathan to finish his train of thought.
😂
Proverbs 23:9 speak not in the ears of a fool, for he will despise the wisdom of thy words. Don't waste your breath on fools like perry.
Thks dear Jonathan I agree with you and when I tried to point out this situation I am considered old fashioned an enemy of the civilization but what civilization pls??? Despite Israeli society is affectd by this anti jewish culture. We need a jewish state according to the HaShem s convenant no respected. Again thks Jonathan. AM ISRAEL HAI with the hope that Mashiah will come soon. un
B"H
The Jewish people are on the way back to the Creator.
Keep the faith brother
❤
That fourth group are Erev Rav, some yes, some not anti-Jewish. And of course there are Erev Rav among the other three groups. I read somewhere that there will only be 600,000 survivors! after the Geulah. That would correlate with Har Sinai. Yes Yehonatan is correct about our indigenous roots.
Geulah was Israel’s national rebirth in 1948 and there was indeed 600,000 when that happened. And when it grew to 600,000 of young fighting age Israel expanded to take Jerusalem. These numbers correlate to the number at mt Sinai and the numbers led by Yehoshua Ben Nun. Israel is now fighting the wars in the tanakh with correlations to the period of Judges and the transition from Shaul to David in Sefer Shmuel.
Very interesting.
unfortunately, in US for example, being brought up without religious education or many Jewish traditions is a stumbling block to being true to oneself and being a Jew. Without wanting to be “Western” at all we feel unmoored from any world. We know who we are but how to join the Jewish people fully? It can be done but it is not easy.
Which of the 4 types of Jews described by rabbi would be the belief way of the Jews that were living on the border with Gaza in the kabutz on that horrible day of 10/7?
that's an embarrassing question as i bet you know. theanswer is, mostly number 4, i.e.,totally secular, post-Jewish and movingt owards post-zionist as well.
@@phillipbaram9563 I apologize if it’s insulting but I’m onGod’s side and we need to see it His way and be on His side - I pray that ALL Jews in the land return to the abrahamic covenant
I watched it and it seemed like they wanted to ambush mr pollard. It was very bad.
I don’t understand the Taliban and for sure I can’t for the life of me understand this tossed up !
Werent the Armenian displaced?
Putin made a movie in East Germany in 1985
Right now, today, over a million refugees and growing of christians and moslems fleeing isis is north mozambique. Just say jews instead of isis and then the world will care.
When Pollard speaks about "Our Enemies" The Prophet Isaiah, the Jews sawed in half , he said that God YHVH is the enemy of the Jews. , . God said "So I turned against them, I became their enemy, and I YHVH GOD fought against them ( against the Jews in Jerusalem) So the Jews invented Judaism to murder God.
No demographic problem? No? Why 1 000 000 Russian non Jewish imports.
JP … I wish you would Run for POTUS
No king can save you
Time to change the definition of Jew. There is no Torah basis for Jewish by the mother. In Torah, you are a Jew if you are in a covenant with God. Osnat, Ruth, etc... Anything else makes a mockery of Torah. Just because Hitler says you are a Jew does not make you a Jew. Unfortunately, the Hitler definition is basically what causes us our problems.
i think there were practical issues before 23 & me
Hitler didn't care if your mother was jewish or not. Hitler killed everyone who at least had one jewish great parent.
Hulk is Chinese
את הנקבוצה הרביעית ניתן להגדיר כ 'חילוניות נוצרית' ....
Shalom Rabbi, would you consider Messianic Jews to be another group?
They are not Jews
Messianics are just christians. Same as jews for jesus. Using the name Jew fraudently doesn't change anything.
Plishtem means invaders, There is no P in Arabic.
That person thinks the truth is an opinion you can agree or disagree upon, two persons three opinions., you know (?) Life and Death is not an opinion, HaShem's word is not in that league at all !
I want to sent you something on Korea spiel, which I am a victim of also ( tell Bibi)
Hashem loves every Jew. Even those who are very far from yiddeshkeit. In fact, Hashem has the greatest pleasure when someone who is far makes even the tiniest move in the direction of teshuva.
Traitors are found in all the groups you mentioned.
It is a well known fact that the time preceding the redemption, the Rabbis are the ones preventing it from happening.
You dont know if Hashem has the greatest pleasure from the tiniest move to teshuva from those who are far. That's your assumption. In any case, traitors don't do any teshuva.
Yep, the same love he had for those who made the avoda zara of the golden calf; then He destroyed them. That's true up to a certain point. If a Jew becomes an enmity against Hashem, all bets are off.
It would appear that you fail to realize if you are Jewish, yet don’t keep HaShems covenant then you are by every definition cut off. Sorry you can’t have your cake and eat it too.
Hashem is not concerned
Every human will be punished
Hashem is a subarchetype of UTsang
Speaking of types of Jews, you failed to mention the Herods among you. Through the vehicle of the false doctrine of matrilineal descent, you yourself created this infusion of Esau among you, and they have become a knife in your side. Yes?
The New God favours the Yue Yue people.
NO MESSIAH MOSHIACH CAN SAVE YOU
Hashem has already betrayed you
Please take your medications
At the end of Isaiah 19, The Lord Almighty gave the blessing, "Blessed is Egypt my People, Assyria the Work of my Hands, Israel my Inheritance ". So the one giving the blessing, as Lord must be Son of the Father, since he says "ISRAEL IS MY INHERITANCE". God as Creator does not inherit anything, the Messiah must inherit seing a Father and Son complexity of relationship is required to say there is an INHERITANCE. So there is nothing in that for the Jew, they have not eaten the Passover for 1950 years, under Moses Law in Exodus Chapter 12, the Jews are Foreigners and Occupiers in the land promised to Israel, they are not Israel, and they will have another Holocaust and Exile out of Jerusalem, because YHVH is their enemy, who has kept them from the Korban Services of Temple Israel, because the only place God is sending them is down to SHEOL.
No god can save you
I saw the i24 with Dan Perry and he had the most outlandish arguments I've ever heard when compared to Yonatan's. I find i24 to be a bit disingenuous at times. A soon as the mayhem of Oct 7th tones down, they resort back to the echo chamber talking point of the US.
yes they seemed just a bunch of leftists when i watched. i didn’t tune in again (English).