Yeah! But we can't do anything,he leaves then..... I cried so hard! But I couldn't turn back time, if i only have a power :'( but we need to be strong right now,especially now, our fandom suffers from dramas, rumors etc. we need to proove to the boys that we still love them even though zayn leaves. We need to apreciate what they do, coz we all know, it's hard to them without one of their brother, all the high notes, his part on the song etc. i wish i could turn back time!
***** He didnt diss them. He even clarified that in his tweet. He said #realmusic… I do not think that was shade at the boys. Whether he goes solo or rejoins them on a new label, you have to remember Modest/SYCO controlled every aspect of production. What songs made the album, the arrangements, the marketing, the drops, the recording schedule EVERY THING. So when he says real music, he just means music that feels true to the message he wants to send. And if they boys join him, it will finally be THEIR REAL MUSIC. Their REAL VOICE. He could just be shading 1DHQ not the band.
Yh I know! especially as they had to change it because of zayn leaving: this is one of my favourite songs and I thought it was awesome for a first time
I know that this video makes it seem like the crowd was completely dead but it really wasn't. I had the amazing opportunity to go and see them perform and honestly, the crowd was amazing, people were singing and screaming and even crying. it doesn't seem like it but it really was insane.
I agree.. It wasn't the best performance, but for the first time it was great! As well... The crowd didn't really seem to react to Liam asking them to sing along. Why?
Lizette Legorreta I get that, but if they ask you to sing along.. why not sing along? Well the good thing about it is that we can hear them really clearly singing it for the first time :)
Trish The Dish Ok if that's what you think you noticed I respect that :) But I'm gonna say this in the nicest way possible: am I the only one that enjoyed it and saw nothing wrong? The boys looked fine to me of course they're just gonna look tired this has just become an everyday thing for them and they just have to make it through but they're really doing their best I didn't judge them this was my first time ever seeing them and the least I could've done was be grateful. They're human too, we shouldn't push their limits that much. I do wish they're as wild and interactive as they used to be in their earlier shows but for me they didn't have to do much they already did enough just by showing up and coming here. Sometimes I think we shouldn't just look into stuff so much we just need to appreciate that they actually showed up cause most of us have waited for years to see them in person so they could give us this once in a lifetime experience and that's it. It was the best night of my life and I was really sad when it was over. I hope you enjoyed the show though :)
It's true that Louis messed up his solo part but that does not mean that he sings bad. He also contributes to the harmonies of the other boys. He has sung this song really well in other concerts. Besides that the other boys were perfect. So y can't we support him instead of criticising him continuously?
+Ritaja De BESIDES, it was LOUIS and LIAM who basically wrote this song!! So if not for Louis - we might had never even heard this song! ;)) Good voice is a big deal - but it's not yet everything! - the ability to create such a wonderful music is also a rare talent!
People defending louis voice: understand, when someone critics his voice, its not because its bad. His voice is really great, BUT he often signs out of tone, and thats why people say his voice should get better. Take a look for exemple his solo at the Jimmy Kimmels Love You Goodbye, he ends completly out
1:58 - Oh my God, Louis is so handsome. At all times, especially this minute. His eyes and smile were shining again in this final phase of One D. even with Zayn leaving (which we know made them all sad)...
I love this era of them! Black or white t-shirt and skinny jeans! Harry’s Chelsea boots then Liam and Niall joining the Chelsea boot train!! And Louis with his vans🥺😭😭
It was so special to me that they performed this for the first time and I got to be there to see it. Was truly the best night of my life. Thank you so much for uploading this
Upon rewatcing this performance I realized...I love it. Besides tge dead crowd and a few wrong lyrics, AND not being able to hear ALL of Harry's part of the, first verse--I think they did really well for the 1st time performing Fireproof!
I always get the sensation that Lou can do better, I think he has gotten the potential and a beautiful voice so I don't get why he doesn't get a nice coach to make him improve :c. At this moment I feel that Louis is weaker than the other boys but not because he "can't sing" but because it seems like he needs a bit more of support from a vocal coach or a bit more of rehearsal :c. I just hope for Louis to get the help he needs to improve :(
Ok Louis kinda messed up his solo, but I am speechless. It was a great performance, their voices blended together perfectly, Liam's voice was amazing and his high notes made him sound like an angel. Harry' voice was perfect too and he made a high note too I think whichI loved. I am so glad we finally get to hear this live.
it is obvious louis’ was messed up, his notes were fine but his mic was going in and out. usually u can here louis clearly in chorus but his voice was absent
I want everybody to know that Louis has a great good voice. He only has that very wonderful angel voice. Please don't say not a good one coz he is really a good good one.
Melissa Chavez ya right Melissa. As a fan it really hurts when they said he can't when we know he can and knew that he only has that good damn angel voice . he's unique and he is perfect for me and for us.
I feel like they kind of forgot the lyrics, but this is the first time! Louis sang Niall's line (oops!) Anyways, we wouldve loved to hear them sing this at #OTRASantaClara
***** yes i agree so much it would have been amazing to hear this and yeah we got spaces but when u think of it its not fair to any one like the out of states concerts they didnt get to hear no control and 18 and us didnt get to hear strong and one thing and now the newer shows didnt get to hear spaces and tbh on what i think they should have one setlist and stop making changes cus its not fair we all want to hear the same songs as everyone else and before anyone say well u should be greatful that u saw then and yes of course i am and we all are and im sure u would feel the exact same way if u went
Angela Dowling IPhone 6... TO be honest it could have been better, I didnt know that if you upload from your Iphone to the UA-cam app it deteriorates the quality. My next 4-5 videos should hopefully be better!
I think they did a great job ! We lost zayn but we still have 4 amazing talented boys and if you think this wasn't a great performance than go see the shows after this one ,they've improved and I'm not just saying this cuz I'm a fan 😊
Sometimes singers have their worst and best performance, it wasn't the best but they did a good job ,and they've improved alot in this song live,they seem more confident in singing it now (ppl shouldn't say one of them can't sing just by looking at one of their performances)
Okay, i get it, you miss Zayn, we all do but dont be too sad over that bc he wasnt happy in the band and he left it bc of that so be happy for him and dont feel sad
I think this performance was amazing. The "missing" quality was probably Zayn, not gonna lie, and I think Louis was singing in a key not great for him. But it was. Amazing. I wish I could've been there
louis had done his best all this time. if u are sensitive, he contribute more ib vocal / high part. he contributes for the high background note.niall too. harry for front and husky voice. liam and zayn for low n soft backgrnd.
@Siti Zubaidah Mohd Zahri, that is what happens when people have favorites, they tend to hype up their favorite and undermine the others, Personally I believe that of the five of them Liam has the best voice however most people will say i is Zayn or Harry which is not he case.
@@karllywalters7998 Best voice is subjective, but technique wise Liam is better than both of them. People are just too biased to Harry and Zayn to realize that.
Louis did a few high notes in Made In The AM, and he took Zayn’s high note in Don’t Forget Where You Belong after he left, but before that he didn’t really do any high notes.
@@lolaa.8161 I will agree with you that best voice is subjective as it depends on who your favorite is, but I was been unbiased this time as Louis is my favorite...dwl😊😊
My band are perfect always, with or without Zayn! Happy birthday my One Direction. ***** Harry Styles Louis Tomlinson Niall Horan Liam Payno #onedirection
Nialls definitely gotten better, idk about Louis tho. It's probably hard for Liam and Harry to have to carry most of the weight. Hopefully Louis will do better in his solo career. If he decides to do so of course
cierrac02 I think it might be the rain and chilly temperatures, but damn, they barely showed any enthusiasm. If I was there and it rained and I was cold I'd still be flipping the fuck out with excitement. Smh, they have NO excuse.
+Tammi Laura sorry, but they don't need an excuse, personally i was dancing around, singing along and screaming. Who are you to tell the crowd how to act? If they wan't to save their voices (unlike me, i might as stabbed myself in the throat) and actually hear the boys sing, then that's their decision NOT yours, sorry to break it to you :/ I've been waiting 4 years for this band to come to my city and they finally did, buteveryone on social media telling ME that i don't deserve to be a fan because i was too quite? that hurt a lot, cause i thought this fandom was my family :') I hope you don't take offence to this, but fans who don't want to scream, and actually want to hear their vocals actually do exist. I am not one of those though and i love to jump around and scream, just like a lot of other fans, which is OKAY. being quite and listening is also OKAY. Don't take this reply as an offence, i just hope it opened up your eyes a bit because these comments/tweets/replies actually DO hurt some people, for awhile i let these comments affect my experience, i felt GUILTY, and that shouldn't be the case at all, Please think before you type and put yourself in other's peoples shoes, because anything as simple as this, CAN hurt. Thank you for reading this (if you did lol) and have a nice day :)))
Louis' mic should have been louder..... I love his part
louis smile at 2:00. when he looked as liam. so cute. I'm in love with these boys.
I definitely missed Zayn's voice on this track. The Ziam harmonies on the album are perfect. Was awesome seeing it live though. Liam was fantastic.
Trish The Dish so true and you can so tell when they perform the new songs on tour how much zayn's voice is missing...ugh....he blends their voices
Yeah! But we can't do anything,he leaves then..... I cried so hard! But I couldn't turn back time, if i only have a power :'( but we need to be strong right now,especially now, our fandom suffers from dramas, rumors etc. we need to proove to the boys that we still love them even though zayn leaves. We need to apreciate what they do, coz we all know, it's hard to them without one of their brother, all the high notes, his part on the song etc. i wish i could turn back time!
***** He didnt diss them. He even clarified that in his tweet. He said #realmusic… I do not think that was shade at the boys. Whether he goes solo or rejoins them on a new label, you have to remember Modest/SYCO controlled every aspect of production. What songs made the album, the arrangements, the marketing, the drops, the recording schedule EVERY THING. So when he says real music, he just means music that feels true to the message he wants to send. And if they boys join him, it will finally be THEIR REAL MUSIC. Their REAL VOICE. He could just be shading 1DHQ not the band.
Trish The Dish I agree with you in every word you wrote :)
agreed. ziam voice is soft and blend well with the other boys.
the people saying Louis needs to try and make his voice better are pissing me off his voice is perfect already and it was perfect here
Yh I know!
especially as they had to change it because of zayn leaving: this is one of my favourite songs and I thought it was awesome for a first time
Grace Howis same jesus i can't stand some people
Yes thank you for not being a total bitch like some other people!
Grace Howis you're welcome
SAME.
I know that this video makes it seem like the crowd was completely dead but it really wasn't. I had the amazing opportunity to go and see them perform and honestly, the crowd was amazing, people were singing and screaming and even crying. it doesn't seem like it but it really was insane.
It's so cute how Liam loves this song
It feels so weird seeing Niall with blonde hair after nearly three years of me being used to his brown hair omg
Lol ik it tripped me out
Harry is very charming :)
More than charming, much more . He does so much for the world and never says a bad word about anyone.
I agree.. It wasn't the best performance, but for the first time it was great! As well... The crowd didn't really seem to react to Liam asking them to sing along. Why?
they had a fan project about staying quiet during little things, but for some reason they stayed quiet throughout the whole show
Lizette Legorreta I get that, but if they ask you to sing along.. why not sing along?
Well the good thing about it is that we can hear them really clearly singing it for the first time :)
trishdishes.tumblr.com/post/124730781829/what-really-happened-in-edmonton
Check out my blog on the "quiet" Edmonton show
Trish The Dish thank you :)
Trish The Dish Ok if that's what you think you noticed I respect that :) But I'm gonna say this in the nicest way possible: am I the only one that enjoyed it and saw nothing wrong? The boys looked fine to me of course they're just gonna look tired this has just become an everyday thing for them and they just have to make it through but they're really doing their best I didn't judge them this was my first time ever seeing them and the least I could've done was be grateful. They're human too, we shouldn't push their limits that much. I do wish they're as wild and interactive as they used to be in their earlier shows but for me they didn't have to do much they already did enough just by showing up and coming here. Sometimes I think we shouldn't just look into stuff so much we just need to appreciate that they actually showed up cause most of us have waited for years to see them in person so they could give us this once in a lifetime experience and that's it. It was the best night of my life and I was really sad when it was over. I hope you enjoyed the show though :)
It's true that Louis messed up his solo part but that does not mean that he sings bad. He also contributes to the harmonies of the other boys. He has sung this song really well in other concerts. Besides that the other boys were perfect. So y can't we support him instead of criticising him continuously?
There r many people who r continuously criticising him
+Ritaja De BESIDES, it was LOUIS and LIAM who basically wrote this song!! So if not for Louis - we might had never even heard this song! ;)) Good voice is a big deal - but it's not yet everything! - the ability to create such a wonderful music is also a rare talent!
Yes, Louis is a very talented writer!
Nataliya Portna it is everything if you're a singer!
I really missed Zayn's voice
I’ve never seen Harry look more beautiful.
This broke my heart...zayn we miss you...
Wow liams voice in this is just extraordinary 😍
People defending louis voice: understand, when someone critics his voice, its not because its bad. His voice is really great, BUT he often signs out of tone, and thats why people say his voice should get better. Take a look for exemple his solo at the Jimmy Kimmels Love You Goodbye, he ends completly out
Liam's voice wow
niall has gotten so much better
1:58 - Oh my God, Louis is so handsome. At all times, especially this minute. His eyes and smile were shining again in this final phase of One D. even with Zayn leaving (which we know made them all sad)...
Wow thanks I've been searching for their Fireproof live performance and this is the only one I've found.
Remember harry when he was 18😁😆
I love this era of them! Black or white t-shirt and skinny jeans! Harry’s Chelsea boots then Liam and Niall joining the Chelsea boot train!! And Louis with his vans🥺😭😭
It was so special to me that they performed this for the first time and I got to be there to see it. Was truly the best night of my life. Thank you so much for uploading this
They're leaving me speechless and I don't know whyyyyy
Upon rewatcing this performance I realized...I love it. Besides tge dead crowd and a few wrong lyrics, AND not being able to hear ALL of Harry's part of the, first verse--I think they did really well for the 1st time performing Fireproof!
*the
Thank you for sharing, the color was beautiful! I agree Zayn's voice is missed on some of the songs. But I think the boys are doing great!
When you went to this concert 😍😍😍
Harry and liam basically carried this song.
so true
Refined Gold yass😁
Agree
Like they carried the band for the rest of the year after Zayn quit
@@vincentprakash4891 no ❤️
TBH, Why am i crying?
I think they did pretty well!
so much in this song idk where to start
I always get the sensation that Lou can do better, I think he has gotten the potential and a beautiful voice so I don't get why he doesn't get a nice coach to make him improve :c. At this moment I feel that Louis is weaker than the other boys but not because he "can't sing" but because it seems like he needs a bit more of support from a vocal coach or a bit more of rehearsal :c.
I just hope for Louis to get the help he needs to improve :(
I love when the high notes come Louis always pulls his mic away from his mouth it's adorable
Ugh I wish I could go back to this night
Louis tongue at 1:30 omg
Ok Louis kinda messed up his solo, but I am speechless. It was a great performance, their voices blended together perfectly, Liam's voice was amazing and his high notes made him sound like an angel. Harry' voice was perfect too and he made a high note too I think whichI loved. I am so glad we finally get to hear this live.
Gloria Petroni yeah really
Louis was sick
it is obvious louis’ was messed up, his notes were fine but his mic was going in and out. usually u can here louis clearly in chorus but his voice was absent
chelsea leary yeah, it wasn't his falt that they didn't turned up his mic loud enough, ugh louis deserves sm better 🥺
He is unfornatly insecure about his voice and i think that unfortnatly he was sick😢😢😞😞
Ive ben a fan 4 years and havent ben in one concert at all😭😭😭😢
0:56 Aww Louis
such a beautiful and perfect song
I wish they had a more responsive crowd
louis looks so good omg
I miss zayn 's voice 😭😭😭😭
I like how he screamed sing it over Niall's voice
IM CRYINGGGGG
lol did anybody notice louis made a mistake on his part of the song???!!!!! i love him;)
I want everybody to know that Louis has a great good voice. He only has that very wonderful angel voice. Please don't say not a good one coz he is really a good good one.
He is amazing. How can people think he's not great at singing. He has become confident with his voice. He should just ignore the haters that say that
Melissa Chavez ya right Melissa. As a fan it really hurts when they said he can't when we know he can and knew that he only has that good damn angel voice . he's unique and he is perfect for me and for us.
Abegail Cabanting yass
damn...it hurts knowing that he'll never be able to sing the song with the boys ever again...
rip Liam💔
we miss you😭
niceeeee!!! I loved your page
I feel like they kind of forgot the lyrics, but this is the first time! Louis sang Niall's line (oops!)
Anyways, we wouldve loved to hear them sing this at #OTRASantaClara
***** ... We could have been louder at Santa Clara , if only they sang this. But at least we got to sing SPACES with the boys at Santa Clara :)
***** yes i agree so much it would have been amazing to hear this and yeah we got spaces but when u think of it its not fair to any one like the out of states concerts they didnt get to hear no control and 18 and us didnt get to hear strong and one thing and now the newer shows didnt get to hear spaces and tbh on what i think they should have one setlist and stop making changes cus its not fair we all want to hear the same songs as everyone else and before anyone say well u should be greatful that u saw then and yes of course i am and we all are and im sure u would feel the exact same way if u went
Louis didn't sing nialls part
What camera did u us this footage it incredible.Thanks for sharing.
Angela Dowling IPhone 6... TO be honest it could have been better, I didnt know that if you upload from your Iphone to the UA-cam app it deteriorates the quality. My next 4-5 videos should hopefully be better!
really the quality amazing. Ive filmed from my phone and looks nothing as good as this footage.
I think they did a great job ! We lost zayn but we still have 4 amazing talented boys and if you think this wasn't a great performance than go see the shows after this one ,they've improved and I'm not just saying this cuz I'm a fan 😊
원디렉션 사랑해요ㅠㅠ♡
this crowd tho dead af..
Felo Ciraptor Thank you!
This was just the beginning, we all got louder as the night went on
Louis looks so happy❤
Finally I thought they wouldn't sing fireproof 🔥 😘
Was I the only one who smiled when Louis had that big smile on at the end
I smiled too
I MISS THEM SO FUCKINF MUCH🥺🥺
Like damnnn! I miss my boys😭😭😭
i went to this concert
lmao louis was singing niall's line XD i love this song very much but it sounds wonderful with zayn actually...
liam messed up too at 2:00. that was why louie looked at him. he said "nobody love you" twice when it was supposed to be "nobody knows you"
It's just spelled Louis. Pronounced Louie. Just so you know
❤❤❤
I like it
Could Harry be more perfect ❤️💖?
my concert, im tearing up
0:46 not subtle harry :P
Sometimes singers have their worst and best performance, it wasn't the best but they did a good job ,and they've improved alot in this song live,they seem more confident in singing it now (ppl shouldn't say one of them can't sing just by looking at one of their performances)
1D i miss u so muchhhhhhhhhhhh
@zayn I miss you
guys,there was plenty of people singing,just not alot,i was singing my lungs out.
i was just reading that 1d performed fireproof on the up all night tour in duluth before anyone knew it
Okay, i get it, you miss Zayn, we all do but dont be too sad over that bc he wasnt happy in the band and he left it bc of that so be happy for him and dont feel sad
my heart hurts
i miss zayn
niall I'm definitely feeling something deep inside:)
I think this performance was amazing. The "missing" quality was probably Zayn, not gonna lie, and I think Louis was singing in a key not great for him. But it was. Amazing. I wish I could've been there
why is the crowd so dead 😔😔
Louis was so emotional.. kiss to you Louie..
What are you guys talking about Louis sounds just like he is on the album in my opinion.
When they sang Zayn 's part 😔
I am crying
DONT JUDGE LOUIS. ITS A LOT GOING AROUND HIM NOWADAYS JUST BE HAPPY HE CAME AND SANG
0:48 😍💚💙
it's so silent...
why?
Harry is forever bae
Oh Louis....those aren't the lyrics my love
where was the crowd @?
what is this 1:04 ?
Humanity!
louis had done his best all this time. if u are sensitive, he contribute more ib vocal / high part. he contributes for the high background note.niall too. harry for front and husky voice. liam and zayn for low n soft backgrnd.
@Siti Zubaidah Mohd Zahri, that is what happens when people have favorites, they tend to hype up their favorite and undermine the others, Personally I believe that of the five of them Liam has the best voice however most people will say i is Zayn or Harry which is not he case.
@@karllywalters7998 Best voice is subjective, but technique wise Liam is better than both of them. People are just too biased to Harry and Zayn to realize that.
Louis did a few high notes in Made In The AM, and he took Zayn’s high note in Don’t Forget Where You Belong after he left, but before that he didn’t really do any high notes.
@@lolaa.8161 I will agree with you that best voice is subjective as it depends on who your favorite is, but I was been unbiased this time as Louis is my favorite...dwl😊😊
@@lolaa.8161 That is the sad part, over the years he was told he couldn't sing, he therefore did not have much faith in his own voice🤔🤔
Why was Niall only in 10 seconds of the entire video???? I'm having a Niall withdrawal
My band are perfect always, with or without Zayn!
Happy birthday my One Direction.
***** Harry Styles Louis Tomlinson Niall Horan Liam Payno
#onedirection
Wow
1d fans in edmonton, lets be friendsss
if you not from edmonton thats cool too lol
Zayn's part . I can't 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Wow it sounds so nice live! They could do a little better but even though it was their first time they did good!
nice lyric change louis 😗😁😘😚
It will get better with time :-)
Nialls definitely gotten better, idk about Louis tho. It's probably hard for Liam and Harry to have to carry most of the weight. Hopefully Louis will do better in his solo career. If he decides to do so of course
so nice and beautiful live! but i think they can do it better next time..and why do i feel like i was hearing Zayn?
im kinda sad. theres something empty in the performance.
That was my birthday 😓😅😌😄😍
But why is the crowd so damn quiet???
There are probably quiet because they want to hear their voices instead of the people around them, but guess we won't know for sure. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
cierrac02 I think it might be the rain and chilly temperatures, but damn, they barely showed any enthusiasm. If I was there and it rained and I was cold I'd still be flipping the fuck out with excitement. Smh, they have NO excuse.
+Tammi Laura sorry, but they don't need an excuse, personally i was dancing around, singing along and screaming. Who are you to tell the crowd how to act? If they wan't to save their voices (unlike me, i might as stabbed myself in the throat) and actually hear the boys sing, then that's their decision NOT yours, sorry to break it to you :/ I've been waiting 4 years for this band to come to my city and they finally did, buteveryone on social media telling ME that i don't deserve to be a fan because i was too quite? that hurt a lot, cause i thought this fandom was my family :') I hope you don't take offence to this, but fans who don't want to scream, and actually want to hear their vocals actually do exist. I am not one of those though and i love to jump around and scream, just like a lot of other fans, which is OKAY. being quite and listening is also OKAY. Don't take this reply as an offence, i just hope it opened up your eyes a bit because these comments/tweets/replies actually DO hurt some people, for awhile i let these comments affect my experience, i felt GUILTY, and that shouldn't be the case at all, Please think before you type and put yourself in other's peoples shoes, because anything as simple as this, CAN hurt. Thank you for reading this (if you did lol) and have a nice day :)))