Just like marathi people who don't want up bihar (from own country) people to even come and work in Maharashtra. So how arunachalis and mizos are expected to let refugees come and dictate us in our own land and demand chakmaland. All state people have that mentality. Outsiders are only acceptable to a certain limit. Beyond that limit means definite bloodshed.
Are you comparing Biharis with Chakmas? I'm asking this because Biharis are thieves, unhygienic and they engage in fights wherever they go. Even though there are some good Biharis but most of them are like this.
U just simply skipped logical reasoning classes. Chakma didn't come to work as Bihari and UPwadi , the definition of indigenous tribe is very broad once you truly know the meaning you will realise, but being said that as much as Mizoram is for Mizos , it is also for Chakmas
No one is speaking about why muslim majority countries have no respect for the minorities . Chakma, hajongs were indigenous to the CHITTAGONG HILL TRACTS. Muslims cry for equality where they are minority but treats other communities as thrash where they are in majority.. why non muslim Bangladeshis are forced to leave their land and migrate?? where are those so called human rights organizations when minorities are persecuted in a muslim majority country
Wow Bisbo your research on this topic is so half heartedly done. The reason Chakmas are having problem in gaining citizenship is because of special right of Arunachal Pradesh. Arunachal Pradesh has been a protected state way before Independence. Even during Britishers rule, the indegineous of Arunachal were protected, which was again adopted after Independence. Now let's come to Chakmas issue, the population of Chakmas are already around 1 lakhs in present days. Where as my tribes population is around 15000. If Chakmas are given citizenship, won't we in our own land become a minority? Chakmas can get their citizenship somewhere else where there is no such law as special protected state.
This is one of the most messed issue in India. On one side chakmas are eligible for Indian citizenship. But on otherside concern of Arunachal Pradesh is also genuine. Settling Chakmas in Arunachal Pradesh ie NEFA of that time was a big blunder. I can't see any solution except a costly solution of shifting chakmas outside Northeast mainly in big cities where population is more cosmopolitan.
Outside of NE? are you kidding do you think this is too easy to say outside of NE we belong to Indigenous tribes we can't even servive without our hilly areas and what about the racist people there in mainland if I'm in South of India and I can speak their language too they still called us chinese momo etc. who said we are demanding Chakmaland in Arunachal pradesh we get settlers by GOI everything we do our own Govt of Arunachal didn't provide a single piece of rice till now no rights nothing means nothing as a Indigenous we know servival techniques yes ofcourse in this modern generation many of us Demanding for our rights snatched by so called a student organisation All Arunachal Pradesh student union (AAPSU) AR govt gave rights to those who came after us Chakmas because of Peace kind of word we are on demand and belong from Buddha's clan yes we are demanding but to restoration of rights not begging. Aur agar kisi ka baap me bhi himmat hai to AR se nikal ke dikhaye Peace aur pieces ka matlab ek kar denge. We were innocent because of Peace this AAPSU torture us for rights Identity n more, before we were uneducated and now many of us can handle the pen and if needed gun too. A great leader said RIGHTS IS NOT GIVEN WE HAVE TO TAKE IT Living without rights and identity better die. we were innocent that's why they Snatched all the rights.
Many information are incorrect. Southern parts of Mizoram is predominantly inhibited by Chakmas brcause it was part of Chittagong Hilltracts. It was made a part of Lushai hills, the then Assam in 1890s for administrative convenience. Please research more and give clear picture, otherwise you will end up endangering more chakmas who have been already Indian citizens for hundreds of years. If you check the first list of schedule caste and schedule tribes compiled in 1950 by government of India, you will find Chakmas as STs in 5 states namely West Bengal, Assam, Mizoram, Meghalaya and Tripura. Don't twist history, ask from people who lived their own history and not from any third party. Third parties will always be biased am telling you.
@Princess Kuku Then I suppose you need to read a collection of books written by British writers/ rulers. If not, then you can satisfy your ego by making up your own history. Some people have no idea why there's a place named Demagiri in aged old Indian maps. You can still find it fyi. By changing its name to Tlabung for purpose of ethnic cleansing won't change history. Thanks for the reply though. No hard feelings as I don't harbor hatred for you or anybody.
@Princess Kuku Thanks for the reply again. Which year census are u referring to? I have the archives of 1911 as well as 1951. You can find the pdfs on google if u would like to read one. 😊
@@jorapada323ignore them buddy. It is evident that Chakmas thrive for fish and rivers so they usually settle in Valleys, just see even till date they are also good swimmers. While Lushai/zo/mizo/kuki tribes are hilly tribe ( btw mizo literally mean Hilly Tribe ) they aren't that good swimmers, every single year mizo people drown in river streams being sober or drunk.
India and Bangladesh make billions of dollars in trade, closing the borders will only solve the refugee problem, but it will worsen the economy. Moreover, Bangladesh is not the only one to blame for.
Work is going on. Infact a large percentage of work is done. But India Bangladesh border is one of the longest border in the world. So it will take some more times.
Go to google map. See the border. Overlapping area, households, and population. Also, economy of East India depends on Bangladesh money. Banglsadeshis own about 70% or more long distance transport business in Eastern India. They spend Rs.7000.00 crore legally and more money unofficially in Eastern India that create jobs. They give business to hospitals in South India and Kolkata where sometimes more than 60% high spending patients are from Bangladesh. Closing border means China and other powers would come inside our belly. Need a visionary who knows the area to solve the issues, not an anti-national jumlebaaz PM. Bangladesh separated because of religion in 1947. But in spite of a friendly Govt there for over 12 years now, we could not use that to India's advantages to look for a long term solution.
Sir/Madame, We have seen your video on your UA-cam channel (link: ua-cam.com/video/ukcr7lFInCo/v-deo.html) where you did a case study on the Chakma-Hajong people vis-a-vis CAA and their broad history especially on the migration and resettlement of 2748 families in present-day Arunachal Pradesh. It appears that you have sourced most of your content from the "White paper on Chakma and Hajong Refugee issue by the Govt of Arunachal Pradesh". Unfortunately, this white paper was published by the state Government as a reaction to the Supreme Court verdict of NHRC vs State of AP dated 09 Jan 1996 which had indicted the state government of its complicity and failure to protect the rights and liberty of the Chakmas and Hajongs living in AP. When the state government itself is a party and is hand in gloves with AAPSU in perpetrating violence and oppression on the hapless Chakmas one can imagine the immanent bias reflected in the White Paper. Please read the judgment for details. It is a fact that the Chakmas and Hajongs did not go to NEFA on their own. They were taken there by the government of India traversing a distance of 1200 kilometers from CHT. Hence, they were accepted and rehabilitated by the Government of India in the then North East Frontier Agency (NEFA), which later became Arunachal Pradesh under a centrally sponsored ‘definite plan of rehabilitation’ scheme following a series of discussion(s) between the representatives of the Central government, state administration and local tribal leaders. The statement that the Chakmas had converted to Buddhism from Islam is incorrect. At no point in history were the Chakmas Muslims. It was a practice to adopt the titles of ruling dynasties as a gesture of accepting the token suzerainty of the Mughal Emperor after the Mughal-Chakma wars (Subir Bhaumik -Insurgent Crossfire; Lancer Publishers, New Delhi). Before embracing Theravada Buddhism during the time of Kalindi Rani, the Chakmas practiced another form of Buddhism called Lori (another form of Mahayana Buddhism). The image of the great Chakma Queen Kalindi Rani as a Muslim lady in your video is quite offensive, to say the least. Below we present some more (by no means exhaustive) inaccuracies in your video: *NEFA, now Arunachal Pradesh, over objections from their indigenous people were asked to take in 2598 families.* # The Chakmas and Hajongs were permanently settled in five different settlement areas in 3 divisions of NEFA (now Arunachal Pradesh) by the Government of India under a Centrally sponsored "definite plan of rehabilitation" in 1964-69 with the consent of the local tribal chiefs, then NEFA administration and the Governor of Assam. NEFA was then administratively managed under the Ministry of External Affairs through the Governor of Assam. Citizenship was already given at the time of rehabiliation. It was only later that these rights were derecognized one after another as part of denial and deprivation policy of the state. *Population swelled from 50 odd families in 1966 to 788 families, soon they demanded citizenship of India. The 2600 Chakma families had taken refuge in Arunachal, had grown in to 65000 units by 1991.* # As per available data with the Govt. of India and Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh 2,598 families comprising 14,138 persons were settled in NEFA (now Arunachal Pradesh). As per the 2011 census, the total Chakma and Hajong population combined is 49,784 which is merely 3.6% of the total state population. The growth rate of the Chakma-Hajong population is significantly LOWER than the overall state population. The compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) for the Chakma-Hajong population stands at 2.60% versus 2.87% for the overall state population. For the 2001-11 decade, the decadal growth rate for Chakma-Hajong population stands at 17.5% versus 26% for the overall state population. As per the statement made by *Hon'ble Chief Minister, Shri Pema Khandu* on the floor of the State Legislative Assembly on 8th January 2020, the total Chakma-Hajong population as per survey done by DCs in 2015-16 stands at 65,875. (The Arunachal Times, dated 08 Jan 2020). *The population of 50 odd families (57 to be precise) is of one village called Joypur only and you seem to have unfortunately mixed up that village population with the total Chakma population. Government of Arunachal asked to 50 families to return to allotted areas and vacate additional areas with reference to Arunachal Pradesh vs Khudiram Chakma, 1993, SCR(3) 401 court case. They are indulging in illegal and criminal activities and constantly troubling the locals.* # It is a case of gross misrepresentation and generalization. In fact, a lot has been written about the issue of land encroachment by Khudiram Chakma who supposedly ‘strayed’ outside the settlement area. It has received wide publicity in the media and the case has been cited by many. But it is sad that no in-depth study has ever been done to understand the case as an example of good relationship and cultural assimilation that was developing between the fellow Buddhist tribes like the Chakma and Singpho tribes. Khudiram Chakma never went to the court on the citizenship question. He went to the court for justice - to quash an ‘arbitrary’ order issued by the Circle Officer to vacate the land donated to him and 56 other families by one local Singpho Raja (Chief) Shri Ningrunong Singpho. The deed of donation that became the subject matter in Apex Courts was about one square mile of personal land donated by the Singpho Raja to Shri Khudiram Chakma. It did not happen by force nor was the decision taken overnight. It was preceded by years of mutual friendship, affection and respect for each other and is an expression of that genuine love and friendship. It was a win-win situation for both the donor Raja and Shri Khudiram Chakma because it acted as a buffer against other encroachers eying for uncultivated vacant land lying in the area. Clearing the forest and converting it into cultivable land meant providing protection against wild elephants making their presence felt and grazing and destroying paddy crops in the human habitat. How someone sitting as a Judge in Delhi would be persuaded to appreciate such rural local nuances. The fact that he lost the case eventually in the Supreme Court is another matter, but no one thought that the case will be used to generalise the verdict of the case and pitted against all the Chakma and Hajong people of Arunachal Pradesh. Every Chakma was branded as a foreigner although the facts and circumstances of the 56 families are not the same and are different from those of the other families rehabilitated in Arunachal Pradesh. But for the impugned notice issued by the Circle Officer of Diyun which created this as an issue, Khudiram Chakma would not have gone to the court. That is what triggered the litigation process in courts and the vulnerable Chakma tribals failed to win the case against the mighty and powerful state government. *Relation between locals and refugees deteriorated so much in 1994, AAPSU issued quit Arunachal Pradesh.* # The relation between the Chakmas and other local tribes deteriorated only for a brief time at the behest of AAPSU who, in their zeal to copy the Assam agitation of AASU of the late 70s on their way to power, wanted their version of the foreigners (the other) and found soft targets in the then Chakmas and Hajongs who were just settling down after their rehabilitation. Backed by the state machinery AAPSU have been subjecting the poor Chakma and Hajong people to systematic denial, deprivation and derecognition of the Chakma and Hajong people of their fundamental rights. Hence the apex court had indicted both AAPSU and the state government in the 1996 judgement. There are mainly 2 issues in Arunachal Pradesh - the China issue and the Chakma -Hajong issue. It’s in the interest of AAPSU to keep this issue alive. Riding on the wave of confusion, fear and xenophobia created in the minds of innocent Arunachalee public, many AAPSU leaders have become successful political leaders in the state. AAPSU were dismissed once as a body comprising (of) ‘pampered’ students (Gupta 1982) and another time as a ‘private entity’ (Limpert 1998). However, being master propagandists, backed by the corridors of power in Arunachal Pradesh, in the mainstream, it is only the AAPSU version of what the Chakma-Hajong issue is that is available and accessible to the people. We are happy that you have tried to empathize with our cause but quite concerned that it ended up doing quite the opposite as such half-truths and inaccuracies have only distorted the reality of our settlement and existence. It may be mentioned here that 90% of Chakmas and Hajongs are citizens of India by birth and the original migrants were also accorded de facto citizenship rights at the time of their rehabilitation. It is only later after 1980 that the rights of Chakmas and Hajongs were derecognized one after another in the name of ‘citizenship’. Please get in touch with us on Facebook or email us at teamcrdo@gmail.com for more details /clarifications, if any. We would also like to share this video (facebook.com/apcrdo/videos/466522594040081/) with you which seeks to dispel some of the commonly held myths about the Chakmas and Hajongs of Arunachal Pradesh. Sincerely, Team CRDO
Sorry, to say but Brus & Reangs are not from Bangladesh. The one coming illegally by crossing borders for last many decades and being able to hold majority population in the state of Tripura are the so called Hindu Bengalis or Bangladeshi Hindus. They're being able to hold majority population here in the state of Tripura because they're coming up in huge number till today in fact they're the one who got hold of the Administration. So which makes easier for their people to come up in huge numbers. You can't deny the fact that a majority always rules or minority. That's why we say Majority wins. And the real sons & daughters of Tripura are known as Tiprasas. It came from two Kokborok (The Mother Tongue of Tiprasas) words:- 1) "Tipra or Hill Tiperrah" means The Tripura the place where the Tiprasas resides. 2) "Bwsa" means child. Thus the words together forms and makes Tiprasa. Many of you aren't aware of the fact that The Tripura Kingdom is the 2nd Longest Dynasty (with the rulings of 183 kings starting from Mahabharata Era) in the world after the Romans. The Tiprasas are having various Tribes & Sub Tribes like Debbarma, Jamatia, Reang, Hrangkhawl, Molsoms, Rupini and many more are there. And among Reangs there are various sub tribes or clans like Meska, Bru etc.
@@crazyman6644 Yes... under CAA out of 100 applicants 98 are bangladeshi bengali .. The Government inorder to avoid protest and hide have added the words like -- Pakistan Afghanistan sikh parsi jews etc .. in fact how will a hindu pakistan cross the v v tight Border like North and south korea .. Bangladesh is open porous and manned by corrupt BSF. Look at all other borders with China Pakistan Myanmmar these border are tight fenced and manned by ARMY.. While for bangladesh the border is opem and BSF. This is the policy of govt to encourage illegal migrantions in NORTH EAST and dessiminate the indegenious population like in Tripura and Assam next Meghalaya amd Sikkim .. dont forget the Indo Nepal treaty where Nepalese are encouraged to come India enmass amd no exemption .. 🙏
Anonymous what you mean by world refugees? They are plenty of places in main land India for the refugees to resettle so why gov is after North East only?.
Thanks bro for sharing information about chakmas . I am from arunachal pradesh and the population of chakma refugees are going to outgrow the indigenous people and Yes, they should be distributed across India.
@@mokshithramesh3938 in arunachal too there are many south Indians living and earning and I didn't say a word about south Indians to be deported . India is for Indians not for refugees or illegal immigrants
Dear KHbang..There is absoloutely no need to worry about Chakmas outgrowing and outnumbering the indigenous tribes. Chakma and Hajongs population constitutes less than 4 percent to AP's population(based on 2011 census data). Chakma-Hajong pop as per census 2011 is approx 49 thousand against 13.8 lakhs total population of AP. As per the official statement made by Hon'ble CM Mr Kandhu, made on the floor of the State LA, the Chakma and Hajong population is 65, 875 as per the survey conducted in 2015.
@@mokshithramesh3938, First, arunachali are not refugees to South India. Stop comparing refugee to indian and what made you think to question our nationality. Second, what is the ratio of arunachal with to the population of south India or any south state. At last, they are not there to settle permanently and who will settled in there with complete different regions with different languages, food habit, manner, values.
Bruh Entrepreneur koi conductor nahi hai uskiliye education air qualification jahiye Tu banja Entrepreneur agar tere me financial capibalities hai yaha fir struggle kar sakta hai
Think again....its not even BJP now, the lies are getting blown. The students of Jamia Milia University in New Delhi were fighting for secularism and what not when they themselves reserve 30% seats for muslims, 10% for muslim women, 10% for muslim OBC/SC ST (lol what??) The St. Stephens college which protested few days ago for secularism has 50% seats reserved for christians and is 95% funded by government. The JNU is getting so much fee benefits , such cheap accomodation and tuition fee for a college in New Delhi? And now what they are fighting for? To grant citizenship to those non muslims whose homes were burnt and asked to leave or die just cause the muslims of undivided India wanted islamic nation, did anyone ask those hindus or sikhs living in punjab about creating pakistan or not? Now if we wont give citizenhship to them then who will but you guys want those muslims also to get the indian citizenship, are you fucking crazy or out of your mind, the muslims who participated in 1946 Direct action day of killing hindus for not creating pakistan. Seriously?? These guys have their lies literally blown up now and they are just changing their issues almost daily!
@@arjunbatra2072 Rohingyas are one of the most oppressed societies in the world......Bangladesh accepts so many refugees and they are running out of space and redirecting them to India...Shia Muslims in Pakistan too are being oppressed in Pakistan....perhaps CAA could at least count these special Muslims alone into its list......I know that Muslims form a majority but please do look into the plight of Rohingyas in Myanmar......In addition Srilankan Tamils too are not granted citizenship irrespective of whether they are Hindu or Muslim or christian or whatever.....Have you read about the Srilankan Tamil Genocide conducted by the Sinhalese government? SImply calling Tamizhans are terrorists by pointing out LTTE is ignorant.....when someone kills ur people in hundreds and no one gives a fuck, then such people are bound to take up arms...I am not justifying LTTE completely....but they had their reasons...
@@KishoreKumar-uz8ir shia muslims make up about 20%, of Pakistan population....that's 40 million of their 200 million people...are we insane to being in 40 million people Shias have the option to go to Iran which is a Shia majority country and in 1947 it was these shia Muslims also who demanded for Pakistan..now just because things haven't gone well for them doesn't mean they can use India as a prostitute
still, majority of the world's Chakma population is in Bangladesh.. Bangladesh has more chakma population than India.. And, I am a bengali hindu from Dighinala, Khagrachari District, Bangladesh. Most people in our area are Buddhist chakmas.
Relocation across India is a joke. That is akin to breaking their culture and community. I as an Indian am ashamed that so many ancient communities of ours now belong to no where.
I agree every state should take the burden...we cant push them out and keeping them as refugees will only increase local disputes....BUT WILL HAJONGS BE READY TO COME OUT OF NE????? Government should work out an amicable plan which can be a win-win situation for all....Only BJP can do this as all other parties only promise but shy away from such contagious issues, we can only grow when such internal issues are resolved....
Hey there Bisbo. Big fan of yours. You might be very busy in other things but please upload more often. Wish I could work with you and your team. One of my dreams 😄
This is almost my full time work and we are looking to expand our team so as to upload more often. email me at gobisbo@gmail.com and tell me what role you want with us.
@@BisboWorld Greetings Bisbo. Thank you for your response. This is to inform you that I have sent an email regarding the type of work I can help you with. 😊
Its very sad for the Chakmas that Arunachalis dont allowed them to get citizenship and Mizoram are likely not to give a piece of land for the Chakmas coz they are fighting for greater Mizoram to include Mizos in Bangladesh, Myanmar ,Manipur and Tripura and assam. By the way war will happen in the near future i guess so
Give them in ur state, not in our state. We r already facing many problems like unemployment, no proper facilities of education, health, road, electricity etc. So if u favouring giving them citizenship then call them in ur state or just keep queit.
@@JaMesBonD12346 sir we will force are state governments to take in more refugees We in Karnataka already have 20,000 bengali hindu refugees in Raichur district Don't worry...but please help our hindu refugees with protection
@@JaMesBonD12346 The Chakmas and Hajongs of AR have been deprived of their basic rights, which a human being is entitled to. For the last 50 years, the Chakmas didn't eat into any share of employment as needless to say, Chakmas are denied any employment rights and other host of rights, facilities or benefits. Chakmas are grateful to the people of AP and will remain grateful nothwithstanding.
@@sansakma4014 go back to ur place or state which entitle u all dos basic right. U dont ve to feel grateful to AP Coz no APST will accpt u at any cost.
@@mr.random369 exactly...but before you accept something as a truth, you should first study, get the facts right. Chakmas came from South China , really common!
@@mr.random369 that's a known fact, Chakmas have been living in Myanmar since ages. Then about the Chakmas who are born in India. Are they from CHT??This is the point. In the same logic as yours, the Nyishis who had migrated from the north, crossing the mighty river named Supung(Tsangpo) in China can be called as foreigners also??
@@asingurung8044 😁😁all indian know history very that all Bengali don't came from Bengladesh ,west Bengal and some portion of Tripura and Assam are Bengali majority..but u all Nepal people came from Nepali..u should go back
Thanks Bisbo, your informal style lets us understand complex issues easier. Could you make a video on the Tibetan refugees. We see a large number of them in Uttarakhand and Himachal. What is their legal status? Have they been granted citizenship?
Many don’t know: Chakma king along with Mong king and influential tribal MLA had been in the compensation committee and rehabilitation scheme. But they failed in that.
I'm also a Chakma from Bangladesh yeah it's very painful for our community that we lost our mother land because of " MUSLIMS '' we were all Buddhist at that time but now many of us have been converted into different religions like Christianity and even Muslim we have our own alphabets and we had our own land but it was taken by MUSULMAN , the government of Bangladesh doesn't give us any kinds of succour and it's really hard for Chakmas' to get a job in here we are demanding our own country from the government of Bangladesh Sheikh Hasina who had said to give us back our country before we committing our military to them, the three districts Rangamati, Kagrasuri and Bandarban are supposed to be ours but why she still has been making highways and putting armies camps in those areas and lastly i would like to say that we are not same with Reangs,Brus, Hajongs and Debbarmas they belong from indo mongoloid community except Hajongs and we belong from Buddha's sakya and they are not from Bangladesh but Tripura
@@Rafi-ox1vl hmm bro eder myanmar pathano uchit okhan thekei era asche.eder k khediye Rohingya der pahade thakbe.muslim der upore otachar korsilo Myanmar.tai amader o bhuddist der okhane pathano uchit
Thanks for the information how is your condition now as hasina is removed and crisis is going on Bangladesh? Are the chakma and jumma people of cht safe ?
Bangladesh govt should expose how many tribal ppl got gov jobs and their jobs in the capital city 5 star hotel to garments sectors. They live in dhaka and all around 64 districts getting benefitted by it and when it's about their district they become so self centered even though they are just migrants from other part of the world from 16th century.
And now chakma claim mizoram as their ancestral land.......we the pople of Mizoram will not accept this we will even join china if the govt don't do anything about this.........we don't understand just how a chakma women bare 3 children in one year.......PM modi, mizoram is splitting up because of chakma do something
@Naukri chahiye Modi ji muje I'm so sorry to hear that...... Yes they have autonomous district counsel in mizoram unfortunately..... Problem like this in mizoram is our everyday bread and butter.... Hope we could come up to find solution for this
We Tripuri also feel like the same 👍👍👍👍. Illegal immigrants always be remain Illegal. Their behaviour totally opposite to Northeast Indian Peoples. Their heart also like Bangladeshis and always supporting Bangladesh.
@@thwikungbara8677when do chakma people support Bangladesh ? . Stop spreading hatred dude. You know it very well chakmas and Tripuris are very closely related in Tripura as well as in Bangladesh.Even Before partition chakmas and Tripuris are living near to each other and have close relation with the Tripuri N chakma kings for generations. Agartala Buddhist temple was made by Tripuri king only.Much love from France .
Why you also don't go to your places from where you came you are also a part of Mongoloid and use Tibeto Burman language you also had come from Myanmar we have our own district council in Mizoram if you don't leave your state then why should we? ? And actually we don't claim that Mizoram is our ancestral land and we are only 3 brothers and sisters since I born how could you say that all Chakmas are giving birth 3 childrens within a month it's because you don't want to be a part of an Indian and you want to destroy our own autonomous district council if you split your state from India we' ll split our land from Mizoram 😂😂 Love from Bangladesh ❤❤
We can't say...refugee who are responsible...why boundary committee...didn't take it India as before, they are also fought against British to make free India...The leader who cut it from mainland, make them minority, insecurity...N at present own brother said them as refugee...those who hav three brothers and make house in a plot of land if this land divided in 3 different countries...think now...
Okay every North East states has chakma hajong problem, and they are so demanding asking permanent residence certificate in Arunachal Pradesh but didn't get, they are good people but migration to other land and asking rights is not the way especially state like Arunachal Pradesh where main land india people also can't buy lands.
Correct 💯 you can adopt muslim from Assam in Arunachal pradesh by st or status you are not tribal, but can't to tribal Chakmas cultures and tradition living many things have similarities to your cultures because you people are Miya lovers
What happened when Rohingya muslims were forced out of Myanmar and Indian govt put those people back into Myanmar when they migrated to India. Why is India not bothered for uighar Muslims from China who are kept in detention camps. Aren't these 2 countries lying in our neighborhood. Haha if Ravish start questioning PM modi will run out out of answer for the very first simple question. Creating chaos while there is a debate across the country on economy and jobs is what BJP style like a Boss.
We have about 40000 rohingya refugees in India.. for a country with a population like ours that has not been able to give citizenship to most of her refugees since 1950 ..do you really think its a wise decision to keep accepting more and more ? Can you just keep religion aside for once !
Like i always say... Refugees should be distributed in the whole country, not just be given citizenship in a border land which will betray the trust of locals...
@@BisboWorld It seems more complicated than that condition can be applied to first generation which migrates not off springs. It will be fun to see how three nations try to solve mess created 70 years ago(partition). This can not be solved by just one nation source nation of migration needs to be onboard. Although nice video thank you !
@@saurabhdsawant yeah but north east has special rights and even you and i can go and settle there willy-nilly... Once they they get resettled they can go any where in the big states no one would stop them...🤷 Having a gradual shift in demographics of mostly urban areas is not the same as lakhs of refugees in rural areas suddenly getting citizenship...
@@satyasubhash8869 There might be restrictions now. Do you think with 370 gone it special treatment to 7 sisters will hold in near future ? Also the special rights to NE can be used to kick immigrants off those areas after citizenship grant. All depends on how it will be implemented . More issues to surface ...
@@BisboWorld please let me know how to reach out to you. We would be happy to share our insight. Nonetheless, appreciate your attempt to tell our story.
@@BisboWorld Chakma of mizoram were never a refugee they have their own administration body called CADC given by GOI in 1972 southern part of present mizoram was part of Chakma kingdom which went under Indian territory(boundary) in 1947
Obviously refugees must be distributed. They are Indians & they should be given a proper settlement. Btw people who are speaking that why anti CAA supporters are against calling back people to India...C'mon u knw man..its not abt that ...just the govt who says verbally that citizens need not to worry...just once give in writting. I challenge there will be no protest...but u knw their intention thats why they are afraid ...
We can distribute chakmas in metropolitan cities. The population there is cosmopolitan and diverse .. And they will also be more prosperous in metro cities
Brus or Riangs(they are the same) are not from CHT, they are genuine citizens of India, Don't entitle them as Refugees like the Chakmas, Chakmas and Brus are incomparable, yet you can compare Brus with Kashmiri pandit, they are internally displaced people, due to ethnic violence in Mizoram, so do some fact checks.
@Princess Kuku Yea, that's also one of the several reasons, further studies shows us, they(Brus) moved to Mizoram in last centuries for jhum cultivation and when areas were demarcated by the British they(Brus) also settled in Lushai Hills(Present day Mizoram). Another fact check.
Thank you for explaining our pain, I'm also a Chakma
Ohh. Your surname is confusing though.
Nice
@@abhilashpatel3036 Why bro?
Mongal Mohan Chakma hissu bussus oni thank you hotte
Bekkani bane bane hotte chakma guno bepare
@@Ailleng_Chakz Bekka ni dow ama sanne gori hobor noh pebo dow...hintu Jeni hoi de seni 80% oi dow
Just like marathi people who don't want up bihar (from own country) people to even come and work in Maharashtra. So how arunachalis and mizos are expected to let refugees come and dictate us in our own land and demand chakmaland. All state people have that mentality. Outsiders are only acceptable to a certain limit. Beyond that limit means definite bloodshed.
Are you comparing Biharis with Chakmas? I'm asking this because Biharis are thieves, unhygienic and they engage in fights wherever they go. Even though there are some good Biharis but most of them are like this.
U just simply skipped logical reasoning classes. Chakma didn't come to work as Bihari and UPwadi , the definition of indigenous tribe is very broad once you truly know the meaning you will realise, but being said that as much as Mizoram is for Mizos , it is also for Chakmas
No one is speaking about why muslim majority countries have no respect for the minorities . Chakma, hajongs were indigenous to the CHITTAGONG HILL TRACTS. Muslims cry for equality where they are minority but treats other communities as thrash where they are in majority.. why non muslim Bangladeshis are forced to leave their land and migrate?? where are those so called human rights organizations when minorities are persecuted in a muslim majority country
I love Chakma People coz they r pure hearted
We need to snatch 5000 square km land from Bangladesh and settle refugees there.
that is never gonna happen
Or force Bangladesh to accept them
@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 it's easier to capture land than to force a country to accept millions of people
Wow Bisbo your research on this topic is so half heartedly done. The reason Chakmas are having problem in gaining citizenship is because of special right of Arunachal Pradesh. Arunachal Pradesh has been a protected state way before Independence. Even during Britishers rule, the indegineous of Arunachal were protected, which was again adopted after Independence. Now let's come to Chakmas issue, the population of Chakmas are already around 1 lakhs in present days. Where as my tribes population is around 15000. If Chakmas are given citizenship, won't we in our own land become a minority? Chakmas can get their citizenship somewhere else where there is no such law as special protected state.
How can 60 thousand chakmas become majority in ur state when the population of arunachal is 11lakhs🤨
Chakmas Tribes people very friendly to all,, I love❤ Chakmas tribes
After seeing your videos on different topics my doubt got cleared,keep it up good work
Thanks Kishan
We are (Chakma and Hajong)facing this due to m.d..fkr Redcliff and Jinah in 1947 east Pakistan was created on the basis of religion.
Now fighting d indigenous people over the land
Same here in Bangladesh. Chakma create so many problems in Bangladesh.
This is one of the most messed issue in India. On one side chakmas are eligible for Indian citizenship. But on otherside concern of Arunachal Pradesh is also genuine. Settling Chakmas in Arunachal Pradesh ie NEFA of that time was a big blunder. I can't see any solution except a costly solution of shifting chakmas outside Northeast mainly in big cities where population is more cosmopolitan.
Outside of NE? are you kidding do you think this is too easy to say outside of NE we belong to Indigenous tribes we can't even servive without our hilly areas and what about the racist people there in mainland if I'm in South of India and I can speak their language too they still called us chinese momo etc. who said we are demanding Chakmaland in Arunachal pradesh we get settlers by GOI everything we do our own Govt of Arunachal didn't provide a single piece of rice till now no rights nothing means nothing as a Indigenous we know servival techniques yes ofcourse in this modern generation many of us Demanding for our rights snatched by so called a student organisation All Arunachal Pradesh student union (AAPSU) AR govt gave rights to those who came after us Chakmas because of Peace kind of word we are on demand and belong from Buddha's clan yes we are demanding but to restoration of rights not begging. Aur agar kisi ka baap me bhi himmat hai to AR se nikal ke dikhaye Peace aur pieces ka matlab ek kar denge. We were innocent because of Peace this AAPSU torture us for rights Identity n more, before we were uneducated and now many of us can handle the pen and if needed gun too. A great leader said RIGHTS IS NOT GIVEN WE HAVE TO TAKE IT Living without rights and identity better die. we were innocent that's why they Snatched all the rights.
Many information are incorrect. Southern parts of Mizoram is predominantly inhibited by Chakmas brcause it was part of Chittagong Hilltracts. It was made a part of Lushai hills, the then Assam in 1890s for administrative convenience. Please research more and give clear picture, otherwise you will end up endangering more chakmas who have been already Indian citizens for hundreds of years.
If you check the first list of schedule caste and schedule tribes compiled in 1950 by government of India, you will find Chakmas as STs in 5 states namely West Bengal, Assam, Mizoram, Meghalaya and Tripura.
Don't twist history, ask from people who lived their own history and not from any third party. Third parties will always be biased am telling you.
@Princess Kuku Then I suppose you need to read a collection of books written by British writers/ rulers. If not, then you can satisfy your ego by making up your own history.
Some people have no idea why there's a place named Demagiri in aged old Indian maps. You can still find it fyi.
By changing its name to Tlabung for purpose of ethnic cleansing won't change history.
Thanks for the reply though. No hard feelings as I don't harbor hatred for you or anybody.
@Princess Kuku Thanks for the reply again.
Which year census are u referring to?
I have the archives of 1911 as well as 1951. You can find the pdfs on google if u would like to read one. 😊
@@jorapada323ignore them buddy. It is evident that Chakmas thrive for fish and rivers so they usually settle in Valleys, just see even till date they are also good swimmers. While Lushai/zo/mizo/kuki tribes are hilly tribe ( btw mizo literally mean Hilly Tribe ) they aren't that good swimmers, every single year mizo people drown in river streams being sober or drunk.
why don't we close the border from bangladesh?
India and Bangladesh make billions of dollars in trade, closing the borders will only solve the refugee problem, but it will worsen the economy. Moreover, Bangladesh is not the only one to blame for.
Work is going on. Infact a large percentage of work is done. But India Bangladesh border is one of the longest border in the world. So it will take some more times.
@@shahirmostafa what border fencing has to do with trade unless the traders have valid documents.
Go to google map. See the border. Overlapping area, households, and population. Also, economy of East India depends on Bangladesh money. Banglsadeshis own about 70% or more long distance transport business in Eastern India. They spend Rs.7000.00 crore legally and more money unofficially in Eastern India that create jobs. They give business to hospitals in South India and Kolkata where sometimes more than 60% high spending patients are from Bangladesh. Closing border means China and other powers would come inside our belly. Need a visionary who knows the area to solve the issues, not an anti-national jumlebaaz PM. Bangladesh separated because of religion in 1947. But in spite of a friendly Govt there for over 12 years now, we could not use that to India's advantages to look for a long term solution.
Mamata won't allow
Sir/Madame,
We have seen your video on your UA-cam channel (link:
ua-cam.com/video/ukcr7lFInCo/v-deo.html) where you did a case study on the Chakma-Hajong people vis-a-vis CAA and their broad history especially on the migration and resettlement of 2748 families in present-day Arunachal Pradesh.
It appears that you have sourced most of your content from the "White paper on Chakma and Hajong Refugee issue by the Govt of Arunachal Pradesh". Unfortunately, this white paper was published by the state Government as a reaction to the Supreme Court verdict of NHRC vs State of AP dated 09 Jan 1996 which had indicted the state government of its complicity and failure to protect the rights and liberty of the Chakmas and Hajongs living in AP. When the state government itself is a party and is hand in gloves with AAPSU in perpetrating violence and oppression on the hapless Chakmas one can imagine the immanent bias reflected in the White Paper. Please read the judgment for details.
It is a fact that the Chakmas and Hajongs did not go to NEFA on their own. They were taken there by the government of India traversing a distance of 1200 kilometers from CHT. Hence, they were accepted and rehabilitated by the Government of India in the then North East Frontier Agency (NEFA), which later became Arunachal Pradesh under a centrally sponsored ‘definite plan of rehabilitation’ scheme following a series of discussion(s) between the representatives of the Central government, state administration and local tribal leaders.
The statement that the Chakmas had converted to Buddhism from Islam is incorrect. At no point in history were the Chakmas Muslims. It was a practice to adopt the titles of ruling dynasties as a gesture of accepting the token suzerainty of the Mughal Emperor after the Mughal-Chakma wars (Subir Bhaumik -Insurgent Crossfire; Lancer Publishers, New Delhi). Before embracing Theravada Buddhism during the time of Kalindi Rani, the Chakmas practiced another form of Buddhism called Lori (another form of Mahayana Buddhism). The image of the great Chakma Queen Kalindi Rani as a Muslim lady in your video is quite offensive, to say the least.
Below we present some more (by no means exhaustive) inaccuracies in your video:
*NEFA, now Arunachal Pradesh, over objections from their indigenous people were asked to take in 2598 families.*
# The Chakmas and Hajongs were permanently settled in five different settlement areas in 3 divisions of NEFA (now Arunachal Pradesh) by the Government of India under a Centrally sponsored "definite plan of rehabilitation" in 1964-69 with the consent of the local tribal chiefs, then NEFA administration and the Governor of Assam. NEFA was then administratively managed under the Ministry of External Affairs through the Governor of Assam. Citizenship was already given at the time of rehabiliation. It was only later that these rights were derecognized one after another as part of denial and deprivation policy of the state.
*Population swelled from 50 odd families in 1966 to 788 families, soon they demanded citizenship of India. The 2600 Chakma families had taken refuge in Arunachal, had grown in to 65000 units by 1991.*
# As per available data with the Govt. of India and Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh 2,598 families comprising 14,138 persons were settled in NEFA (now Arunachal Pradesh). As per the 2011 census, the total Chakma and Hajong population combined is 49,784 which is merely 3.6% of the total state population. The growth rate of the Chakma-Hajong population is significantly LOWER than the overall state population. The compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) for the Chakma-Hajong population stands at 2.60% versus 2.87% for the overall state population. For the 2001-11 decade, the decadal growth rate for Chakma-Hajong population stands at 17.5% versus 26% for the overall state population. As per the statement made by *Hon'ble Chief Minister, Shri Pema Khandu* on the floor of the State Legislative Assembly on 8th January 2020, the total Chakma-Hajong population as per survey done by DCs in 2015-16 stands at 65,875. (The Arunachal Times, dated 08 Jan 2020).
*The population of 50 odd families (57 to be precise) is of one village called Joypur only and you seem to have unfortunately mixed up that village population with the total Chakma population. Government of Arunachal asked to 50 families to return to allotted areas and vacate additional areas with reference to Arunachal Pradesh vs Khudiram Chakma, 1993, SCR(3) 401 court case. They are indulging in illegal and criminal activities and constantly troubling the locals.*
# It is a case of gross misrepresentation and generalization. In fact, a lot has been written about the issue of land encroachment by Khudiram Chakma who supposedly ‘strayed’ outside the settlement area. It has received wide publicity in the media and the case has been cited by many. But it is sad that no in-depth study has ever been done to understand the case as an example of good relationship and cultural assimilation that was developing between the fellow Buddhist tribes like the Chakma and Singpho tribes.
Khudiram Chakma never went to the court on the citizenship question. He went to the court for justice - to quash an ‘arbitrary’ order issued by the Circle Officer to vacate the land donated to him and 56 other families by one local Singpho Raja (Chief) Shri Ningrunong Singpho. The deed of donation that became the subject matter in Apex Courts was about one square mile of personal land donated by the Singpho Raja to Shri Khudiram Chakma. It did not happen by force nor was the decision taken overnight. It was preceded by years of mutual friendship, affection and respect for each other and is an expression of that genuine love and friendship. It was a win-win situation for both the donor Raja and Shri Khudiram Chakma because it acted as a buffer against other encroachers eying for uncultivated vacant land lying in the area. Clearing the forest and converting it into cultivable land meant providing protection against wild elephants making their presence felt and grazing and destroying paddy crops in the human habitat. How someone sitting as a Judge in Delhi would be persuaded to appreciate such rural local nuances. The fact that he lost the case eventually in the Supreme Court is another matter, but no one thought that the case will be used to generalise the verdict of the case and pitted against all the Chakma and Hajong people of Arunachal Pradesh. Every Chakma was branded as a foreigner although the facts and circumstances of the 56 families are not the same and are different from those of the other families rehabilitated in Arunachal Pradesh. But for the impugned notice issued by the Circle Officer of Diyun which created this as an issue, Khudiram Chakma would not have gone to the court. That is what triggered the litigation process in courts and the vulnerable Chakma tribals failed to win the case against the mighty and powerful state government.
*Relation between locals and refugees deteriorated so much in 1994, AAPSU issued quit Arunachal Pradesh.*
# The relation between the Chakmas and other local tribes deteriorated only for a brief time at the behest of AAPSU who, in their zeal to copy the Assam agitation of AASU of the late 70s on their way to power, wanted their version of the foreigners (the other) and found soft targets in the then Chakmas and Hajongs who were just settling down after their rehabilitation. Backed by the state machinery AAPSU have been subjecting the poor Chakma and Hajong people to systematic denial, deprivation and derecognition of the Chakma and Hajong people of their fundamental rights. Hence the apex court had indicted both AAPSU and the state government in the 1996 judgement.
There are mainly 2 issues in Arunachal Pradesh - the China issue and the Chakma -Hajong issue. It’s in the interest of AAPSU to keep this issue alive. Riding on the wave of confusion, fear and xenophobia created in the minds of innocent Arunachalee public, many AAPSU leaders have become successful political leaders in the state.
AAPSU were dismissed once as a body comprising (of) ‘pampered’ students (Gupta 1982) and another time as a ‘private entity’ (Limpert 1998). However, being master propagandists, backed by the corridors of power in Arunachal Pradesh, in the mainstream, it is only the AAPSU version of what the Chakma-Hajong issue is that is available and accessible to the people.
We are happy that you have tried to empathize with our cause but quite concerned that it ended up doing quite the opposite as such half-truths and inaccuracies have only distorted the reality of our settlement and existence. It may be mentioned here that 90% of Chakmas and Hajongs are citizens of India by birth and the original migrants were also accorded de facto citizenship rights at the time of their rehabilitation. It is only later after 1980 that the rights of Chakmas and Hajongs were derecognized one after another in the name of ‘citizenship’. Please get in touch with us on Facebook or email us at teamcrdo@gmail.com for more details /clarifications, if any.
We would also like to share this video
(facebook.com/apcrdo/videos/466522594040081/) with you which seeks to dispel some of the commonly held myths about the Chakmas and Hajongs of Arunachal Pradesh.
Sincerely,
Team CRDO
Chakmas deserve their stand as equals in society. #fightforyourrights
Refugee go back to Bangladesh 😂
We must take back our Chittagong and must resettle chakmas there. It's their home.
but question is how?
@@shafuimcoming5151 that is never gonna happen just be happy that your not persecuted as bad as other groups
@@departmentofchemistryunive8926 How dare you have the audacity to say this?
@@asmitnandi3432
You want a war with Bangladesh lol?
Love from Chittagong hill tracts... I am also a chakma
Sorry, to say but Brus & Reangs are not from Bangladesh. The one coming illegally by crossing borders for last many decades and being able to hold majority population in the state of Tripura are the so called Hindu Bengalis or Bangladeshi Hindus. They're being able to hold majority population here in the state of Tripura because they're coming up in huge number till today in fact they're the one who got hold of the Administration. So which makes easier for their people to come up in huge numbers. You can't deny the fact that a majority always rules or minority. That's why we say Majority wins. And the real sons & daughters of Tripura are known as Tiprasas. It came from two Kokborok (The Mother Tongue of Tiprasas) words:- 1) "Tipra or Hill Tiperrah" means The Tripura the place where the Tiprasas resides. 2) "Bwsa" means child. Thus the words together forms and makes Tiprasa. Many of you aren't aware of the fact that The Tripura Kingdom is the 2nd Longest Dynasty (with the rulings of 183 kings starting from Mahabharata Era) in the world after the Romans. The Tiprasas are having various Tribes & Sub Tribes like Debbarma, Jamatia, Reang, Hrangkhawl, Molsoms, Rupini and many more are there. And among Reangs there are various sub tribes or clans like Meska, Bru etc.
🛑☎️SAVE TRIPURA from bengali bangladeshi
more will come after caa announcement 😥
@@crazyman6644 Yes... under CAA out of 100 applicants 98 are bangladeshi bengali .. The Government inorder to avoid protest and hide have added the words like -- Pakistan Afghanistan sikh parsi jews etc .. in fact how will a hindu pakistan cross the v v tight Border like North and south korea .. Bangladesh is open porous and manned by corrupt BSF. Look at all other borders with China Pakistan Myanmmar these border are tight fenced and manned by ARMY.. While for bangladesh the border is opem and BSF. This is the policy of govt to encourage illegal migrantions in NORTH EAST and dessiminate the indegenious population like in Tripura and Assam next Meghalaya amd Sikkim .. dont forget the Indo Nepal treaty where Nepalese are encouraged to come India enmass amd no exemption .. 🙏
@Mahfuja Akter historically it was never part of Bangladesh Or bengal
@@jhgftu4736 No CAA for NE India. Told by GoI
Only solution is the immigrants should be destributed among all Indian states and not just on North east.
Then North East want India too share the burden of world refugee too
Anonymous what you mean by world refugees?
They are plenty of places in main land India for the refugees to resettle so why gov is after North East only?.
Yes very right
Good sharing🙏🙏🙏❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
Thanks bro for sharing information about chakmas . I am from arunachal pradesh and the population of chakma refugees are going to outgrow the indigenous people and Yes, they should be distributed across India.
Bad idea
Bad idea, let them grow in Arunachal, so people will be walking, we can have control on china too..
@@mokshithramesh3938 in arunachal too there are many south Indians living and earning and I didn't say a word about south Indians to be deported . India is for Indians not for refugees or illegal immigrants
Dear KHbang..There is absoloutely no need to worry about Chakmas outgrowing and outnumbering the indigenous tribes. Chakma and Hajongs population constitutes less than 4 percent to AP's population(based on 2011 census data). Chakma-Hajong pop as per census 2011 is approx 49 thousand against 13.8 lakhs total population of AP. As per the official statement made by Hon'ble CM Mr Kandhu, made on the floor of the State LA, the Chakma and Hajong population is 65, 875 as per the survey conducted in 2015.
@@mokshithramesh3938,
First, arunachali are not refugees to South India. Stop comparing refugee to indian and what made you think to question our nationality.
Second, what is the ratio of arunachal with to the population of south India or any south state.
At last, they are not there to settle permanently and who will settled in there with complete different regions with different languages, food habit, manner, values.
We Indian natives need jobs and increased quality of life.Let them become entrepreneurs
Bruh Entrepreneur koi conductor nahi hai uskiliye education air qualification jahiye
Tu banja Entrepreneur agar tere me financial capibalities hai yaha fir struggle kar sakta hai
It would have been ended up peacefully if BJP wasn't playing religious game on CAA.
Think again....its not even BJP now, the lies are getting blown. The students of Jamia Milia University in New Delhi were fighting for secularism and what not when they themselves reserve 30% seats for muslims, 10% for muslim women, 10% for muslim OBC/SC ST (lol what??)
The St. Stephens college which
protested few days ago for secularism has 50% seats reserved for christians and is 95% funded by government.
The JNU is getting so much fee benefits , such cheap accomodation and tuition fee for a college in New Delhi?
And now what they are fighting for?
To grant citizenship to those non muslims whose homes were burnt and asked to leave or die just cause the muslims of undivided India wanted islamic nation, did anyone ask those hindus or sikhs living in punjab about creating pakistan or not? Now if we wont give citizenhship to them then who will but you guys want those muslims also to get the indian citizenship, are you fucking crazy or out of your mind, the muslims who participated in 1946 Direct action day of killing hindus for not creating pakistan. Seriously??
These guys have their lies literally blown up now and they are just changing their issues almost daily!
@@arjunbatra2072 Rohingyas are one of the most oppressed societies in the world......Bangladesh accepts so many refugees and they are running out of space and redirecting them to India...Shia Muslims in Pakistan too are being oppressed in Pakistan....perhaps CAA could at least count these special Muslims alone into its list......I know that Muslims form a majority but please do look into the plight of Rohingyas in Myanmar......In addition Srilankan Tamils too are not granted citizenship irrespective of whether they are Hindu or Muslim or christian or whatever.....Have you read about the Srilankan Tamil Genocide conducted by the Sinhalese government? SImply calling Tamizhans are terrorists by pointing out LTTE is ignorant.....when someone kills ur people in hundreds and no one gives a fuck, then such people are bound to take up arms...I am not justifying LTTE completely....but they had their reasons...
@@KishoreKumar-uz8ir shia muslims make up about 20%, of Pakistan population....that's 40 million of their 200 million people...are we insane to being in 40 million people
Shias have the option to go to Iran which is a Shia majority country and in 1947 it was these shia Muslims also who demanded for Pakistan..now just because things haven't gone well for them doesn't mean they can use India as a prostitute
@@elennet4116 you are just shouting... nothing else.... one sided biased
@@sambs3609 he is talking about facts...
In Tripura we try to send them back their own land Bangladesh..
U should
We should make a detention camp for chakma n hajong
Why that was not made for tibetians. Very easy to say these words.
@@HimanshuShekhar7 after that detention center shld be made for tibetians
@@HimanshuShekhar7Tibetan are still in fight for their motherland Tibet
They never claimed right over land where they are temporarily settled I guess
still, majority of the world's Chakma population is in Bangladesh.. Bangladesh has more chakma population than India.. And, I am a bengali hindu from Dighinala, Khagrachari District, Bangladesh. Most people in our area are Buddhist chakmas.
You are right..
Relocation across India is a joke. That is akin to breaking their culture and community. I as an Indian am ashamed that so many ancient communities of ours now belong to no where.
one think i learned today .Until ppl hav pride over my land/my language/my race/my religion.. There will b a problem
Agreed. But people will always have.
That what make nationalism
I agree every state should take the burden...we cant push them out and keeping them as refugees will only increase local disputes....BUT WILL HAJONGS BE READY TO COME OUT OF NE????? Government should work out an amicable plan which can be a win-win situation for all....Only BJP can do this as all other parties only promise but shy away from such contagious issues, we can only grow when such internal issues are resolved....
i love chakma
Reangs are not from Chittagong but from Tripura who got displaced due to creation of dams
Awesome
Please make a video on the Maradu Flats Demolition in Kerala....
Thank you I am chakma also
Hey there Bisbo.
Big fan of yours. You might be very busy in other things but please upload more often. Wish I could work with you and your team.
One of my dreams 😄
This is almost my full time work and we are looking to expand our team so as to upload more often. email me at gobisbo@gmail.com and tell me what role you want with us.
@@BisboWorld Greetings Bisbo. Thank you for your response. This is to inform you that I have sent an email regarding the type of work I can help you with. 😊
😢 thanks alot
*Thank you for sharing*
Its very sad for the Chakmas that Arunachalis dont allowed them to get citizenship and Mizoram are likely not to give a piece of land for the Chakmas coz they are fighting for greater Mizoram to include Mizos in Bangladesh, Myanmar ,Manipur and Tripura and assam. By the way war will happen in the near future i guess so
Grant them citizenship...
During the 1971 war India should annex chittagong hill tract...
Great opportunity missed.
Give them in ur state, not in our state. We r already facing many problems like unemployment, no proper facilities of education, health, road, electricity etc.
So if u favouring giving them citizenship then call them in ur state or just keep queit.
@@JaMesBonD12346 sir we will force are state governments to take in more refugees
We in Karnataka already have 20,000 bengali hindu refugees in Raichur district
Don't worry...but please help our hindu refugees with protection
@@JaMesBonD12346 The Chakmas and Hajongs of AR have been deprived of their basic rights, which a human being is entitled to. For the last 50 years, the Chakmas didn't eat into any share of employment as needless to say, Chakmas are denied any employment rights and other host of rights, facilities or benefits. Chakmas are grateful to the people of AP and will remain grateful nothwithstanding.
@@sansakma4014 go back to ur place or state which entitle u all dos basic right. U dont ve to feel grateful to AP Coz no APST will accpt u at any cost.
Yes they should be distributed across the states not just across border states.
A refugee is a refugee..
Chakmas came from South china, than burma, than Chitagong.
Would appreciate if you brush up history lessons brother.
@@sansakma4014 truth is truth..
@@mr.random369 exactly...but before you accept something as a truth, you should first study, get the facts right. Chakmas came from South China , really common!
@@sansakma4014 1st go & find in which which district of Mayanmar Chakma living.
@@mr.random369 that's a known fact, Chakmas have been living in Myanmar since ages. Then about the Chakmas who are born in India. Are they from CHT??This is the point. In the same logic as yours, the Nyishis who had migrated from the north, crossing the mighty river named Supung(Tsangpo) in China can be called as foreigners also??
Most of the chakmas live in tripura
Thanks for that 🙂
Gorkhas n Darjeeling hills in pre-independence India.
Please make a video on that .... Please 🙏
Yes but later
@@BisboWorld Thanks
U people came from Nepal
@@pankajchatterjee5075 So you from Bangladesh .
@@asingurung8044 😁😁all indian know history very that all Bengali don't came from Bengladesh ,west Bengal and some portion of Tripura and Assam are Bengali majority..but u all Nepal people came from Nepali..u should go back
Good video
Really a history
Awesome video. Keep it up bro.
Nice topic bisbo and 👌
Thanks Shashi
If CCa implement only we North eastern people will suffer not main land so we must abolished this plan
Hey Bimbo.. make a video about Ousting of Kashmiri Pandits .. Do you have the guts? Open challenge
Whole Indian godi media discuss on Kashmiri pandit issue. Let him do this on chakma and hajong
He gets good money from congress so he wont do that video👍
Thanks for explained
Good research work done. Amazing
How do you create such animations..?? Which software or website..??
Adobe Photoshop and Animate
@@BisboWorld Ok. Thanks for reply
Nice explanation Brother keep motivat us
Thanks Bisbo, your informal style lets us understand complex issues easier. Could you make a video on the Tibetan refugees. We see a large number of them in Uttarakhand and Himachal. What is their legal status? Have they been granted citizenship?
So only in my state, i.e. in Tripura Chakma's living peacefully. Although economically they're not very strong
Becoz these tribals that too converted ones are ignorants and insecure.
Long life Hajong brother
I’m from Andhrapradesh searching the Jagan’s name signing out with a doubt is Jagan really an educate 😂😂😂
Yes I am chakma but we are also 1872 trvl
Bast of Chakma
There was a girl from chakma community in our class
Many don’t know: Chakma king along with Mong king and influential tribal MLA had been in the compensation committee and rehabilitation scheme. But they failed in that.
Nyc work keep going guys....
Thanks
Ur videos are very informative and gives proper knowledge on the subject.
Indians should get dual citizenship
Logic wow
I'm also a Chakma from Bangladesh yeah it's very painful for our community that we lost our mother land because of " MUSLIMS '' we were all Buddhist at that time but now many of us have been converted into different religions like Christianity and even Muslim we have our own alphabets and we had our own land but it was taken by MUSULMAN , the government of Bangladesh doesn't give us any kinds of succour and it's really hard for Chakmas' to get a job in here we are demanding our own country from the government of Bangladesh Sheikh Hasina who had said to give us back our country before we committing our military to them, the three districts Rangamati, Kagrasuri and Bandarban are supposed to be ours but why she still has been making highways and putting armies camps in those areas and lastly i would like to say that we are not same with Reangs,Brus, Hajongs and Debbarmas they belong from indo mongoloid community except Hajongs and we belong from Buddha's sakya and they are not from Bangladesh but Tripura
Go to india for live and leave Bangladesh 😂
@@ZihadZihad-bu6pp অবস্থা দেখছো ব্রো? শুধু শুধু এদের কোটা সুবিধা দেয়।
@@Rafi-ox1vl hmm bro eder myanmar pathano uchit okhan thekei era asche.eder k khediye Rohingya der pahade thakbe.muslim der upore otachar korsilo Myanmar.tai amader o bhuddist der okhane pathano uchit
Thanks for the information how is your condition now as hasina is removed and crisis is going on Bangladesh? Are the chakma and jumma people of cht safe ?
Bangladesh govt should expose how many tribal ppl got gov jobs and their jobs in the capital city 5 star hotel to garments sectors. They live in dhaka and all around 64 districts getting benefitted by it and when it's about their district they become so self centered even though they are just migrants from other part of the world from 16th century.
Jay Bhim
And now chakma claim mizoram as their ancestral land.......we the pople of Mizoram will not accept this we will even join china if the govt don't do anything about this.........we don't understand just how a chakma women bare 3 children in one year.......PM modi, mizoram is splitting up because of chakma do something
@Naukri chahiye Modi ji muje I'm so sorry to hear that......
Yes they have autonomous district counsel in mizoram unfortunately.....
Problem like this in mizoram is our everyday bread and butter....
Hope we could come up to find solution for this
We Tripuri also feel like the same 👍👍👍👍. Illegal immigrants always be remain Illegal. Their behaviour totally opposite to Northeast Indian Peoples. Their heart also like Bangladeshis and always supporting Bangladesh.
@@hriata5384 👍👍👍👍
@@thwikungbara8677when do chakma people support Bangladesh ? . Stop spreading hatred dude. You know it very well chakmas and Tripuris are very closely related in Tripura as well as in Bangladesh.Even Before partition chakmas and Tripuris are living near to each other and have close relation with the Tripuri N chakma kings for generations. Agartala Buddhist temple was made by Tripuri king only.Much love from France .
Why you also don't go to your places from where you came you are also a part of Mongoloid and use Tibeto Burman language you also had come from Myanmar we have our own district council in Mizoram if you don't leave your state then why should we? ? And actually we don't claim that Mizoram is our ancestral land and we are only 3 brothers and sisters since I born how could you say that all Chakmas are giving birth 3 childrens within a month it's because you don't want to be a part of an Indian and you want to destroy our own autonomous district council if you split your state from India we' ll split our land from Mizoram 😂😂 Love from Bangladesh ❤❤
First of all chakmas are not from Bangladesh they came from Myanmar
People living in Pakistan also once lived in india providing citizenship is really reliable???
We can't say...refugee who are responsible...why boundary committee...didn't take it India as before, they are also fought against British to make free India...The leader who cut it from mainland, make them minority, insecurity...N at present own brother said them as refugee...those who hav three brothers and make house in a plot of land if this land divided in 3 different countries...think now...
Make a video on Australia forests& animals burning ...
We made on Amazon forest fires. See BSBO channel on UA-cam. It’s our international news channel
Plz upload video on how to do research on any topic
💕💕💕💕
Chakma why cant u protest like this in your own country Bangladesh, why doing too much drama here in northeast??
Okay every North East states has chakma hajong problem, and they are so demanding asking permanent residence certificate in Arunachal Pradesh but didn't get, they are good people but migration to other land and asking rights is not the way especially state like Arunachal Pradesh where main land india people also can't buy lands.
Correct 💯 you can adopt muslim from Assam in Arunachal pradesh by st or status you are not tribal, but can't to tribal Chakmas cultures and tradition living many things have similarities to your cultures because you people are Miya lovers
Who are these Chakma . they are not indians based on their skills they can be given permanent residence thats it
❤️❤️❤️
Free khalisthan,free manipur free nagaland😂
Make a video on Sulemani murder &US Iran atomic issue
Making. Iran atomic issue already made. See channel
What happened when Rohingya muslims were forced out of Myanmar and Indian govt put those people back into Myanmar when they migrated to India. Why is India not bothered for uighar Muslims from China who are kept in detention camps. Aren't these 2 countries lying in our neighborhood. Haha if Ravish start questioning PM modi will run out out of answer for the very first simple question. Creating chaos while there is a debate across the country on economy and jobs is what BJP style like a Boss.
We have about 40000 rohingya refugees in India.. for a country with a population like ours that has not been able to give citizenship to most of her refugees since 1950 ..do you really think its a wise decision to keep accepting more and more ? Can you just keep religion aside for once !
In 2024 chakma tribes r still migrating in tripura
Like i always say... Refugees should be distributed in the whole country, not just be given citizenship in a border land which will betray the trust of locals...
Agree but once given citizenship every indian has right to stay anywhere they want. It makes regional diversity skewed
Both have a point but there can be conditional citizenship options of thought through.
@@BisboWorld It seems more complicated than that condition can be applied to first generation which migrates not off springs.
It will be fun to see how three nations try to solve mess created 70 years ago(partition). This can not be solved by just one nation source nation of migration needs to be onboard. Although nice video thank you !
@@saurabhdsawant yeah but north east has special rights and even you and i can go and settle there willy-nilly... Once they they get resettled they can go any where in the big states no one would stop them...🤷 Having a gradual shift in demographics of mostly urban areas is not the same as lakhs of refugees in rural areas suddenly getting citizenship...
@@satyasubhash8869 There might be restrictions now. Do you think with 370 gone it special treatment to 7 sisters will hold in near future ? Also the special rights to NE can be used to kick immigrants off those areas after citizenship grant. All depends on how it will be implemented . More issues to surface ...
This would not be the same if they were muslim immigrants
Yeah this Arunachalis are all muslim minded they adopt muslims even muslim living in Arunachal pradesh given ST
Poorly researched, prejudiced laden findings. Shallow and narrowly presented video.
Then write some important points not in the video
@@BisboWorld please let me know how to reach out to you. We would be happy to share our insight. Nonetheless, appreciate your attempt to tell our story.
@@BisboWorld Chakma of mizoram were never a refugee they have their own administration body called CADC given by GOI in 1972 southern part of present mizoram was part of Chakma kingdom which went under Indian territory(boundary) in 1947
www.firstpost.com/india/citizenship-status-in-limbo-fate-of-chakma-tribe-in-arunachal-underscores-question-of-who-belongs-who-doesnt-7936461.html?fbclid=IwAR2QDHEm7NWlhgNdqb2GiIHs3nVmkbpT-VkWXGTbbxZYfHkAQj1oIQcZeP0
Ilif its happen chakma n hajong will die please help us 😓😓
Chakma king didn’t oppose the site of the dam. The dam could have been built at Borkol, 18 miles upstream.
Chittagong hill should be in India 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Well sorry then. They are part of Bangladesh.
Tripua and assam should be a part of Bangladesh 😅
Obviously refugees must be distributed. They are Indians & they should be given a proper settlement. Btw people who are speaking that why anti CAA supporters are against calling back people to India...C'mon u knw man..its not abt that ...just the govt who says verbally that citizens need not to worry...just once give in writting. I challenge there will be no protest...but u knw their intention thats why they are afraid ...
24 March 1971after east Pakistan not bangladesh
Chakma r the highest population in mizoram...research again
That's means the highest Chakma illegal migration took place in Mizoram
@@zet-azahau3520 chakma’s wil dominate the mizos in future better b careful lol they r malicious af
Ok
Lol the Bangladesh government has free the Chittagong hill tracts .they can go back there.
Illegal immigrants always be remain migrants.
Next parts
C k m or ek videos
You need to research more
We can distribute chakmas in metropolitan cities. The population there is cosmopolitan and diverse .. And they will also be more prosperous in metro cities
Ohh my God painful history of our chakma
Chittagong hill tracts needed to be a part of india instead of east Pakistan in 1947
Assam,meghalaya,West bengal should be a part of Bangladesh 😢😮
Age Bangla Hoda dii elw ..ebar English baneyun
Brus or Riangs(they are the same) are not from CHT, they are genuine citizens of India, Don't entitle them as Refugees like the Chakmas, Chakmas and Brus are incomparable, yet you can compare Brus with Kashmiri pandit, they are internally displaced people, due to ethnic violence in Mizoram, so do some fact checks.
@Princess Kuku Yea, that's also one of the several reasons, further studies shows us, they(Brus) moved to Mizoram in last centuries for jhum cultivation and when areas were demarcated by the British they(Brus) also settled in Lushai Hills(Present day Mizoram). Another fact check.