Same colors, same staging, different results?!

As promised, I tried to recreate my last wildcard flip on a winerack. VERY different response, despite using the same color pallet, and I have two ideas to explain the difference. But after this experiment, one thing remains clear: small differences between pieces as well as "X-factors" can be CRUCIAL to seller engagement, and replicating a viral flip isn't as simple as copying and pasting on a similar piece.
Please comment any ideas you might have that would explain the difference in response for these two!
#furnitureflip #beginnerdiy #thriftflip #furnituremakeover #diyprojects #flippingfurniture #upcycling #thriftingtips #homedecorideas #budgetfriendlydiy #diyfurniture #furnituremakeover #sidehustle #confidencebuilding #tattoofund #meditativecrafting #beginnersdiy #sidehustlesformoms #morethanmoney #upskillyourself #betteryourself #betteryourlife #getuncomfortable #worksmarter #worksmarternotharder