Have Russians 'surrendered to the fate' of Putinism? | Conflict Zone
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 тра 2024
- "The question of prestige is no longer that relevant for Putin," says Nina Khrushcheva.
Speaking to DW's Conflict Zone on the day of Moscow's "subdued" Victory Day parade, the professor of international affairs - and great-granddaughter of Soviet premier Nikita Khrushchev - says Russia's approach is now matter of fact: "'Russia is at war. And you take it or leave it,'" she says. But "those who are not agreeing with this kind of approach are going to be eliminated."
What hope does she have that Russia can move beyond Putin and Putinism?
Watch the interview and let us know what you think below, or join us on Twitter: / dw_conflictzone
Conflict Zone is Deutsche Welle's top political interview. Every week, our hosts Tim Sebastian and Sarah Kelly are face to face with global decision-makers, seeking straight answers to straight questions, putting the spotlight on controversial issues and calling the powerful to account.
#Russia #Putin #victoryday
Subscribe: ua-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
Give Ukraine F-16s, let it finally win.
You got shares in Raytheon?
Give Ukraine a deathstar, let it finally win.
Give Russia time, let it implode (again)
You made my day dude, nice joke!
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
What better endorsement for the western world than the grandchild of Khrushchev deciding that she would rather live and teach in US than Russia? Great interview!
Great comment, and tbf there are plenty of other endorsements in plain sight... Russians appear to have their heads in the sand though.. Doubling down on their tendency towards masochistic resignation.
@@ivanivanov-qi1el Maybe don't create gigantic empires that cover half the planet and then think your 'glorious empire' that was too broke to continue existing can just "make donations" like that
stalin's daughter went back after 2 divorces! She said usa not so great!!!
@@ivanivanov-qi1el It is totally irrelevant who donated Crimea to Ukraine, because Russia recognized Crimea as part of Ukraine in 1991 and 1994.
BTW, in the 1991 referendum a majority of the people of Crimea voted for Ukraine. Russia recognized that and accepted Ukraine's final borders.
If you look how many people try to get American citizenship, it’s HUGE! The Ussr has no one applying for citizenship! In fact , 3 million Russian’s have moved to the US in last 30 year’s! That’s just the legal ones ...
What an incredible interview. She is so well spoken and knowledgeable on the topic. Well done
Of course she's well-spoken she's a professor in NYC.
@@tdtm82right lol? I know it was intended as praise, but it betrays some pathetically low initial expectations of an established expert if merely speaking well merits mentioning.
Lived there for 11 years, and I will say this - the question for them is staying or leaving. It isn't about changing Russia, self determination, Putin or any of that. The whole 'Russia is what it is' complex is just too ingrained from a very young age.
Russians have always had an ingrained victim complex. I guess it’s the result of always being serfs. Little wonder Russians are so paranoid and turn to alcohol.
@Save the OLIGARCHS that is not really true. There are countries were things can be changed and were you aren't used like a serf.
Currently RUSSIA has that North Korean vibe.
Resentful ignorant mentality.
I’ve listened to way too many interviews of Russians and they seem so apathetic, apolitical, and atheistic. They are fearful of what may happen if they say anything negative about Putin, his Orcs, or his War
@Save the OLIGARCHS no, in a democracy you can vote someone out of office, take to street and demonstrate and speak freely.
The silent russians will have to pay for their silence.
In roubles? 🤔
*and you will pay for NATO HYENAS*
@@elbibwen3019 RuSSṉazi 🤮
but not as much as the non-silent russians
There is no amount of suffering the Russians WON"T tolerate. Their national identity is that they are purified by suffering and they can suffer more than any other people on earth. They can tolerate unlimited amounts of corruption and even corruption of the Russian Orthodox Church. Russian identity expects all of that. They are never going to decide they have reached a level of poverty or tyranny that causes them to overthrow the tyrant of the moment. I support Ukraine, but I don't pretend Russian nature is exactly like Germany, England, or US. It is not. The Russian people SHOULD revolt and save Russia from their current regime, but they won't.
Lenin , Stalin, Putin... the USSR likes the cruel dictator type .... centuries of serfdom
Better to have an escapee from the asylum like Joe Biden 😂
@@ramdev9578 agreed
yes, putin is the new peter the great (in his eyes).
According to the US media.
When the Soviet Union went bankrupt the wealth of Russia should have been inherited by the soldiers and people that fought for the country not handfools of oligarchs living in other countries
Love Conflict Zone - they have the best interviews. Thank you for posting.
Nina Khrushcheva is, without question, a woman of high esteem. She loves her native country, as every person should, but she is also rational and reasonable. Wishing her and her people all the best, and hoping for peace in Ukraine. Greetings from Israel.
Props to Nina Khruscheva. She doesn't get hung up about one point and just moves on to the next when a question is asked which is very rare to see. She doesn't try to go to in depth if she's out of her own depth either. She also seems well informed on all fronts having taken in information from multiple sources on those specific fronts.
That title of professor is definitely one that was earned rather than just given.
never asweared queastion
Great interview and interviewer. Nice discussion without interruptions. 🙂
Finding it hard to be empathetic to the struggling Russians
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
@@javierfrancia1938 bots from russia are trying to link their opositioners to Ukraine? You are not trying hard, bot, your dogs is your problem After defeating you, we will fight with other russins, dont expect that you will be able to change a skin and escape retribution
@@javierfrancia1938 🌻🌻🌻
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
@@unoimright5153 indeed, JUA, JUA, JUA, JUA, JUA, JUA
@@elwray3506 reality bites, let me give you something for that pink skin rash
Excellent journalism!
Yes, the interviewer had staying power and stuck to her last, continuing to ask pertinent questions. DW chooses the right people for the job.
Great interview. She's right about so many nknown unknowns. When you start a war this big you are starting up an out of control rollercoaster
putin's handpicked cabinet supply him w/ 'correct' answers eg. russian 'liberators' be welcomed by ukr women throwing flowers at them, ukr army fall in days / wks. pointless to contradict him (out of job), so create 'acceptable' intel rpts n pocket money funding make believe informants (win-win).
😂 what does that 80% consist of massed trebuchet?
@Save the OLIGARCHS Um, no.
@@Waaaaaah13 😂 so what, was that parade the other day with the one WW2 tank the other 80%?! 🤡
The American military industrial complex wants this war to continue...we are at the edge of the abyss and no one cares whatsoever. Ukraine and Zelensky are simply pawns in a much bigger game. The actions being implemented now are from plans made right after the Soviet Union fell.
Why does NATO still exist? NATO was created to counter soviet Russia and the Warsaw Pact...why did NATO not disband?
Because the US wanted to destroy Russia. There was no genuine plan to democratize it. There was no plan to bring Russia into the fold of wealthy or dominant nations/democracies. No, the US ALWAYS wanted Russia as an enemy, even if they wanted peace.
NATO continued to expand and violate every agreement posited / codified after the Soviet Union fell. NATO continued to push up and inch towards Russia's doorstep.
The US tried to intervene in a 2014 coup during the Color Revolutions and instill a "democracy" there; a puppet of the US right on Russia's doorstep.
I am NOT a Putin sympathizer. These are FACTS. And now the world will eventually pay for these bold and careless mistakes. Mark my words. We are THIS close to nuclear confrontation. Meanwhile, while we expend treasure on Ukraine to fight a pointless war, China is now coming up very quickly to surpass us in the global and arms markets. The stage is being set for another world war, and we are plunging FULL STEAM ahead.
The progression will be: Denial, anger (where Russia is now), bargaining, depression and then acceptance that Ukraine does not belong to Moscow.
All this is academic. Russia's greatest sin is about making this about Russia. Practically talking about the war as if Ukraine does not exist - I'm tired about hearing how Russia feels. How they're reacting. How they will react to this and that. Russia needs to be beaten back so that Ukraine can heal. What happens with Russia is up to them. They can be as crazy as they want to be. In Russia.
Russians' most disastrous mistake is to allow their country to be taken over by a cabal of ex-Soviet KGB, psychologically incapable of anything but bouncing endlessly back and forth between Denial and Anger.
You are mistaken) Ukraine will be destroyed. It is only a question of price. It may happen that the price will be the destruction of Russia and the planet as a whole. But this matter has been decided.
In their mind there is no war in Ukraine, since Ukraine in not a county.
@@perkunast9680 As said. I don't care. They can be as crazy as they want to be. In Russia. Not in entire other sovereign countries.
They just tried to protect the people in the East which were in a civil war with the Kiev regime since 2014.
I have relatives suffering enormous pain in Ukraine as I write this. My hope is that some of them will live long enough to witness Putin facing a firing machine gun one day that can not come soon enough.😠💔
.. dangling upside down might be nice
What i heard is Putins great fear above all is that a population mob will lynch him like what happend to Mussolini
Would been a long line❤
I stand with Ukraine 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
Not going to happen keep dreaming
@@lovyriturajanything’s possible
Its obvious Putrin is now afraid for his own safety
Few people care about what Russians do in Russia. The “anti Russian sentiment” is simply against Putins Russia meddling outside its borders. Equating this Russian foreign policy with their identity is a hallucinatic Russian idea.
NOPE . its against RUSSIA and the RUSSIANS and their ''dreams'' founded ON NOTHING ! or should i say ...founded on LAZZYNESS at their workplaces and agressive diplomacy on the international scene
They are basically ROBBING US
what you are saying is a hallucinatic idea. Russia's foreign policy and war is the extension of what russians always wanted from their czar.
Agree! Really an example of infantilism for an entire nation. Russia is largely defined by chronic and crippling inferiority complex that would be comical but not for the resulting suffering.
Enjoy Cheap American GAS. Freedom Gas bebe - freedom Gas- Future of German economy is bright.
@@iiitiberiusiii3441 I think MKG is saying that the Russian people have projected for themselves a hallucinatory image of some imagined generic hostility toward Russians by people outside Russia. (A hallucination contrasted against the reality that people outside Russia in fact object *only to the continuing Russian behaviour* of sending Russian troops and spies on missions into the territory of Ukrainian to attempt to sabotage Ukraine's democratic development trajectory.)
Excellent interview
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
Based on this interview, western partners should increase support to ukraine asap
It's a purpose-full drip feed to prolong the war, they know what they are doing.
That lone T-34 sure scream might!
Excellent interview. Fascinating insight from Professor Nina Khrushcheva.
She is an insightful academic. Fantastic interview from all sides.
During certain Romanov times, up to 93% of the Russian population were serfs. Serfs were essentially slaves who could be bought, sold, and traded by the Russian nobility. Russia has never truly known democracy. The serf mentality still exists -- "servility to those above, tyranny to those below." Id., page 48.
Right-on
Exactly. Very good point. The other process is called embourgeoisement (loosely: "to became citisens", no wonder bourgeois was a cuss word for Marxism-Leninism.
Serfs were tied to their land, right? So a serf couldn’t be sold, but if the land was sold, the serf family would come with it.. am I wrong?
@@Curt_Johnston that's how I've understood it
@@Curt_Johnston Yes, serfs are not the same as slaves. One could not force a serf to move from the land he was born. I mean on paper but how many knew their rights back then is another question.
Thank you for this interview! What an insightful articulate, esteemed commentator Khrushcheva is.
Well Done. !! Thanks. !!
Nina has great insight into the old USSR and into Putins crazy personality and the Kremlins workings.
SHE'S a crook that never stepped in a FACTORY , russian or western one !
Therefore i can EASILY say she's a LUNATIC
i CAN BET MY money for a week she'll try to convince me that the russians are working HARD :D
Maybe she does, but I do not find her answers sufficiently crisp and precise.
@@Dylandog24neither do I. I have a feeling that she was not saying everything she actually thinks
@@Dylandog24 Maybe you know better how Putin and his regime will end , and the future of Russia will be , Please Enlighten me.
@Aurelio-Rey milaor cabal it will end in fire and blood..
fantastic interview! much appreciated.
Great interview, as always.
nah , she isnt Tim Sebastian ...she's .... TOTALLY out of the business . She isnt CAPABLE to feel it
Excellent interview! Thank you.
She is describing russia as a country occupied by a single fascist dictator, not the country that brought this fascist dictator to power and when he went too far they ran or scared.
The American military industrial complex wants this war to continue...we are at the edge of the abyss and no one cares whatsoever. Ukraine and Zelensky are simply pawns in a much bigger game. The actions being implemented now are from plans made right after the Soviet Union fell.
Why does NATO still exist? NATO was created to counter soviet Russia and the Warsaw Pact...why did NATO not disband?
Because the US wanted to destroy Russia. There was no genuine plan to democratize it. There was no plan to bring Russia into the fold of wealthy or dominant nations/democracies. No, the US ALWAYS wanted Russia as an enemy, even if they wanted peace.
NATO continued to expand and violate every agreement posited / codified after the Soviet Union fell. NATO continued to push up and inch towards Russia's doorstep.
The US tried to intervene in a 2014 coup during the Color Revolutions and instill a "democracy" there; a puppet of the US right on Russia's doorstep.
I am NOT a Putin sympathizer. These are FACTS. And now the world will eventually pay for these bold and careless mistakes. Mark my words. We are THIS close to nuclear confrontation. Meanwhile, while we expend treasure on Ukraine to fight a pointless war, China is now coming up very quickly to surpass us in the global and arms markets. The stage is being set for another world war, and we are plunging FULL STEAM ahead.
brilliant interview given the moment. thank you.
I thought _that_ had happened years ago. Cultivating resignation (resignation to the regime), depoliticization, and passive obedience among the population (and among any potential opposition that actually stays inside the territory) is typical of authoritarian regimes. At some point people just accept the reality that they are powerless to change.
@Save the OLIGARCHS Are you a human, or a bot containing very few lines of sourcecode?
So correct Oligarch!!! The western world banished Putin.. the US isn't a democracy, it's an authoritarian hegemon pathetically using the guise of freedom.
@Save the OLIGARCHS Oh, there are absolutely people in the US who want this. Quite a few are supporters of Putin’s favorite orange-hued US President, whom I suspect also pays your bills.
@Save the OLIGARCHS are you a complete nutcase?
@Save the OLIGARCHS nothing to argue. You have made no points, put up zero arguments and given no examples. You are like a magat who has dirtied his diaper and is now smiling proudly as if they've written a great thesis.
Excellent interview. Thank you.
The Russian people must distance themselves from Putin ! If there is any hope for Russia to be part of a progressive world !
The "progressive world" BANISHED Putin...what are you talking about?!
The progressive world will never allow Russia to become prosperous and part of a world that promises prosperity. Because the West's goal is to destroy Russia and hatred of the Russian people is part of the policy of NATO and the EU
The “parade” was more like a funeral 🪦 🇷🇺
Ex KGB Putler's Russia is a PRISON.
So sad......not!
@@paulhargreaves14971 tank parade!
American army parade would have been awesome. LGBTs cavorting down the main street, dressed in frocks, marines marching in high heels, f-35s going up and down like helicopters. And a loony liberal opening fire on school kids 😂😅😂
@@dartfather TBH, a no tank parade would have been less ridiculous than this shitshow!
Great sense from this speaker. More please 🙂
Thanks for posting.
Professor Kruszchev is a very smart honest guest to have on
RS. Canada
fantastic interview. Nikita would be proud of her, even if he disagreed with her.
Absolutely great interviews, the lady is amazing. Interesting and intelligent.
As we would say in my country, that was a glass of clear wine. Very good interview.
That was polluted, non-journalism. Every question was a leading one. Are you serious?
I really like Nina Khrushcheva. She is so Intelligent and well spoken.
My takeaway on this interview: Putinism is just one face of authoritarianism/dictatorship. Suppression of press freedom and civil liberties may be perceived as a sign of strength. But in reality it is a sign of weakness. Strong governments would never be scared of press freedom and civil liberties. Strong government relies on strong institutional stability rather than on one or a few personalities. Strong governments are strong enough to allow transfer of leadership and would not allow a person to serve more than 8 or 10 years in power to prevent incubating a cultist personality. Let's take a look at the "Russia and friends" camp:
Putin - 23 years in power
Lukashenko - 29 years
Kim Jong-un - 11 years (but his dynasty has ruled for 75 years)
Assad - 23 years
...and counting with no certain end in sight.
In those years, at least four American presidents have already held office.
Biden, Trumph...they are presidents? I always seen them as a puppets of corporative interests. Never like smart, normal people. Politicians voted by nation. People who work in interests of their own people...no, never acted that way. American presidents are clowns and nobody ask nation anything. That is how things look like.
Russia-USA same thing in different ways.
I hope normal Americans don't support USA invasions, breaking of international law, disrespecting UN, borders of independent countries, killing civilians, usage of nuclear weapons... USA do all this and much more. I hope people don't support it but I can't see that anywhere. Like there is no freedom, just brainwashing.
From Europe, I see you two like two sides of same coin. Something is raw, something shinny, sofisticated but what you see behind the scene is just the same.
And Putin did his best to export Russia’s “model” to the US, in the form of our own orange would-be Mussolini and his spineless enablers in the Republican Party. That’s reason enough to give Ukraine everything it needs to crush the Russian military and kick it back across the (1991!) border to Mordor.
Putism is exactly what Trump is aiming to achieve in the USA with the help of the republicans and his MAGA army.
"Strong" or not, some dictatorships are long-lived. The Kim dynasty that, along the military, rules North Korea with an iron fist and does not rely on wars of expansion to pacify its population, has lasted for much longer than most experts had guessed. However, the Kim dynasty owes much of durability to China (and, in the past, to the Soviet Union), which has an interest in maintaining it as a buffer state, basic human rights be damned.
If u found good leader,, u keep him at long u can.This is stability, what people wish after that misery decade in 90s.And if u check many in EE still live in this 90s, Ukraine/Moldova and so on.Russian wish Biden for president...No, they not! :)
Fascinating analysis! Thank you Nina Khruscheva and DW News for an enlightening and sobering report!!
Sarah Kelly is a great moderator for Conflict Zone ~ very interesting and incisive questions
This is an excellent interview - both in terms of the questions asked and the depth and insightfulness of the responses given.
fascinating, incredible comprehensive, outstanding questioning.
Imagine that with Tim Sebastian:
He would still battle around the third question and just spew tension instead of thoughts.
Absolutely superb interview!
A great interview and an incredibly insightful and pragmatic lady, family connection adds another dimension ...however the merit is all hers . more Nina!
Muskovy will be stuck until the fearful leader leaves the Duchy
Did she just say the parade was carefully choreographed to display "military might"? Laughable. I'd say It showed the opposite.
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?v
@@javierfrancia1938I've seen you comment this like 3 times now wtf do you actually mean when you say this? And what "Tribe" are you?
@@EuanWhitehead oh, its more than 3 times, ...and you know exactly what it means, but then again you might feel directly implicated with the tribe, or maybe you have no clue of the subtle language, who knows?
@@javierfrancia1938 not really man you're just a rando online idk what you're on about you sound like you're just spamming as a troll
@@EuanWhitehead looks like you are just an unemployed kid trying to sound tough and getting entangled into geopolitics without any knowledge or experience
Well done again Professor Kruscheva. It's grim and the only way is to tell it like it is.
Nina Kruscheva says it like it is. Eastern European countries knew this about Russian behavior and thinking and it's taken democratic western countries a long long time to get a glimmer of understanding where Putin and Russian society is coming from.
So much for providing Putin with an 'off ramp' theory. They thought the early days of the war that Putin would realize he made a grave miscalculation and needed some 'cover' to get out of the special operation, i.e. 'off ramp'. Well the only thing Putin understands is brute force, and he really doesn't care how many Russians die in this war. Hard concept for 'The West' to understand. Yes it's 13th century with modern technology.
I like how she doesn't add conjecture to everything like so many of these interviews
I share Nina Khruscheva's feelings about the future of Russia. It is an incredible mash of interests and powers sub-located in so many spheres of leadership and a little in each division of governance. The defeat of the Russian forces in Ukraine is a bet that may trigger so much division it may lead to another civil war and the separation of more Russian territory into fragmented and independent states. It may also consolidate Russian power and turn it into an autocratic state, excluded from the global economy.
Just like North Korea, even their military parades are the samr
Sorry, but the russian forces are winning on every level. And Putin never wanted to invade all of Ukraine or even Europe. He wanted to have Ukraine stay neutral and free of NATO nuclear missiles and ABMs.
Nina Khrushcheva is a breath of fresh air, will be adding to my resource list..
Essentially its now in Puttin's interest both personal and political to prolong the war until he wins or looses, the west also needs to grasp the fact that this is potentially a forever war.
The interviewer I'm not impressed with at all, as soon as Nina answered in a way that poured water on her assertions, she quickly cut Nina response and moves on, or so it seemed, not impressed at all, this happened several times.
You wrote: "The interviewer I'm not impressed with at all, as soon as Nina answered in a way that poured water on her assertions, she quickly cut Nina response and moves on, or so it seemed, not impressed at all, this happened several times."
I noticed that too. I think the journalist has a producer who wanted some answers they could promote, and it seemed that Nina got a bit perturbed near the end, after several moments of the journalist asking the same question (trying to get the answer she hoped to get).
Props to Nina Kruscheva. She doesn’t get hung up on any one issue, she just moves on to the next question.
Terrific interview!!!
That's not a Mexican stand-off. A Mexican stand-off is like a cold war. Everyone has guns pointed, but no one is shooting. What you have now is the shoot-out that follows the stand-off. You're in a shoot-out, and the last man standing wins.
When at war freedom of liberty and information is always curtailed. PERIOD.
Very interesting, thanks
I really like Nina Khrushcheva. I wish she was on her own show.
agreed. but I assume being a professor at a university she doesn't have enough time unless she was gracious enough to just upload her lectures
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
@Arlan Filank ok. then we can talk about building roller coasters or seismic activity in sea beds, since you're just picking random topics to talk about
@@javierfrancia1938 what "tribe" are you?
I'm not a fan, she's adherent to the russkiye mir and the idea their culture dominates others. It's very colonial of her to think moldolvans want to be part of the russian world. Especially since those who aren't russkiye in the russkiye mir are second class citizens.
As others have said, please offer Khruscheva her own show!
Great interview
Very good interview delivery
haha you're joking right? Every question is a leading question! do you know what true journalism is??
This is a great interview. More Khruscheva, please. I really get the feeling I would like to meet her. I wonder if this Russia gives her pain in that sense that it is her county of birth and she would like to see it peaceful and prosperous. Thanks!
You wonder? --really?
I had the honor of sitting in on one of her courses. She's a fascinating lecturer. Students were rarely absent.
FUN FACT: "One of those who cooked for Rasputin during the Great War was a chef at Petrograd's luxurious Astoria Hotel who went on, after the Revolution, to cook for Lenin and Stalin. He was Spiridon Putin, grandfather of President Vladimir Putin." Source: Montefiore, Simon, "The Romanovs", Vintage Books, 2016, page 600.
_"Do you wanna hear a joke? About russia's Victory Day parade?"_
*_"No tanks!"_*
Brilliant. Such balanced view, knocking down any wishfull thinking or western narratives of the interviewer.
What happened to Tim? I thought Tim was the best conflict zone host. He really asked the uncomfortable questions and dug and dug and dug until he got some answer and not just politispeak!
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦 💪💪💪💪
she is very pragmatic and tells a lot of common sense very authoritive and well researched
Prof. Khrushcheva what an amazing wisdom and intellect always a pleasure to learn from, thank you for your analysis.
Russian trolls in the comments are very afraid of Ukraine getting F-16s.
Time to make Russian trolls really depressed.
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
Russian troll here. Give Ukraine everything they ask. Total demilitarisation and denazification of NATO is needed.
I wouldn’t use Russia and prestige……in the same sentence particularly in reference to leadership and or military.🇺🇦🇦🇺🕊
It should not be forgotten that historically power in Russia was always very concentrated from the Czarist times through the Soviet era and up until this day and every attempt at loosening the grip always led to massive turmoil and traumatic experiences for the population. Thus, many Russians see authoritarian rule as a maybe not very pleasant but nonetheless necessary instrument to keep even worse things away.
Yes Putin, NATO is getting closer to your borders. YOU made it happen.
shows what a brilliant genius he is
“Look in a mirror. You caused this.”- Sauli Niinisto
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
Lol nope better do war now then defending on russia land when nato will attack
@@aaronclarke1434Did he say that?
The only 'truth' we can rely on here is that Putin is fighting against an entire country, every man woman and child, and in his OWN country very few people want to fight or really believe there is anything worth fighting for. So anyone basing their understanding of Russias chances based on the populations of the two countries, their GDP's or the size of their armies are entriely underestimating what having a real cause means. Look at Afghanistan, an even poorer country, with a smaller population and NO army, managed to defeat the Soviet Union (a MUCH bigger and better bankrolled army than Russia has) and the USA. Look ate Vietnam and Korea, both of which eventually wore down both China and the USA. Putin is going to loose this BIG TIME, and quite soon.
Refreshing to hear a true Russian perspective whilst also being careful with choosing her words and extreme honesty about what will happen. It's going to be another interesting episode in history soon.
As a Russian elite, she naturally has cognitive dissonance. Can't conceive of a Russian defeat. Ukraine can absolutely knock this administration out by collapsing Russia's defensive line. Like the way this interviewer probes.
Kruschev's granddaughter is pretty cool.
"I'm not a fan of collective punishment, so I'm going to cry too." Beautiful.
Take your meds. Cry, it will help you till the white coats arrive. Don't shoot any school kids, calm down.
I wonder if Putin has read 1984...
Nina Khrushcheva is brilliant. The journalist is also very good. Thank you both.
Dear Nina Khrushcheva, adopting a purely academic perspective on this war yields limited insights. This war will reach its conclusion very soon. The evident decline of Putin and Russia suggests that the aftermath will devastate the Russian people.
Release the F-16's already!
И что твой 16 сделает? 😂😂😂
Соснет у су-27 я думаю!
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
For some reason, watching this interview makes me remembering that song, sung by War "Why can't we be friends" 🤨🙂
And it is true....at least for me, that in the age of internet and its interconnectivity, a world full of "physical" boundaries, makes no sense at all.
I think people should fight to find ways of living better together than apart.
What is stoping us?
Why can't we be friends?
What is stopping us is the dictatorship in Russia deciding they have the right to control the lives of Ukrainians.
It’s not easy to be friends with someone when they are denying your existence, stealing part of your country and bombing your civilians
"What is stopping us?"
-a handful of neurotic septuagenarians trapped in past trauma and futile effort to recapture their youthful "glory days", sadly.
Putin.
The thing is, you live in XXI century and russians have stuck in XIX. They think in terms of growing the empire and enslavement of other peoples, not cooperation and enlightenment. Very simple.
Great interview, and Sarah Kelly is a lot more welcoming as an interviewer than her male counterpart.
Of course russia can move pass putin. The real question is: can putin make it pass Ukraine? History will remember putin as a failed tyrant who caused countless lives to end.
🥱🥱🥱
But hopefully the West has learned to never deal with russia again. They have been given chance after chance to act like a civilized country and they show their true colours every time. They are barbarians and we should keep them ostracized forever.
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
@@javierfrancia1938 Go away Putin troll.
@Arlan Filank UNPROFOR was in kosovo. Over 40 nations including russia took part. russian forces are responsible for the lybia civil war. They have troops there guarding oil pumps they get the profits from. Afghanistan attacked the US. The terrorists responsible gained power due to russias war in Afghanistan 🤷♂️
If you really want a long list of wars look at how many russia has touched.
Yeah Putin is always standing on top of buildings yelling here I am, get me with a fire cracker😅
An intellectual brave enough to say "I don't know" , knows more than most:)
She mentions Donbass, What/who is Putin looking for there?
He's looking for nothing more than a hiding place from acceptance of his own cognitive limitations. Putin's dysfunctional response to discrepancy between his pet theories and reality is to angrily smash at reality with a succession of increasingly large hammers.
No official Chinese Victory Day attendance this year. I find that significant.
Chinese FM is standing at Berlin in this Victory Day , if you read the news,it's pretty much meaningful to the world since 1945😉😉
It is normal year, not 5, 10 commemorative year.
humm why would a nation founded in 1949 celebrate victory in WWII that ended in 1945? it doesn't make any sense.
@@No_Man_Is_An_Island
Because if China wanted to show solidarity with beleaguered Putin Russia, attending Victory Day would be a perfect way to do that.
Perhaps they were scared of drones
This is an amazing channel.
Wrong, this is one of the most warmongering hawkish channels at the moment. You need to get out more! Theres a big wide world out there, noyt just US and Europe
Yes !!
Well they'd best not get too used to him. He's probably still a fit guy, but already well over the average male life expectancy for a Russian. What a shame he's only been a superficial nationalist, spending the last 20yrs cementing his personal power instead of fostering strong and enlightened replacements to take his place and transform Russia into somewhere people will want to live and other countries to ally cooperatively with.
Truly. This is probably the only comment on this video with any substance
Yea he's a dictator isn't he, has serious personality problems and in his mind he is the most important person on the planet so he will do anything to protect it. All dictators are the same.
putin's handpicked cabinet supply him w/ 'correct' answers eg. russian 'liberators' be welcomed by ukr women throwing flowers at them, ukr army fall in days / wks. pointless to contradict him (out of job), so create 'acceptable' intel rpts n pocket money funding make believe informants (win-win).
So true The disappointment of the century, I would say. But this does not mean that we should not exterminate the Ukrainians.
Glad to see the Russia became stronger and richer because of the war, as shown in the parade of the most advance tank
We mostly have to thanks sanctions. We were 11 world economy before them and now we are 8 th! More sanctions needed of course.
@@user-qp8js5ps5c you're watching too much russ tv
@@user-qp8js5ps5c Why does Putin drives decadent western Mercedes? Because you clowns are not able to manufacture decent automobile in 21st century.
"The Russia"?
Okay.
@@user-qp8js5ps5c cool, let the sanctions continue forever 😊
The only one thing that is frightening to me is that they can put into power someone who will be as narcissistic and hateful as Putin who would like to rematch
"So many unknown unknowns" .... It would seem that Nina Khrushcheva, as a Russian born and bred, cannot bear to imagine a defeat for for her country. If you are Russian, 'Russky Mir' will always have appeal.
She's American now. Her grandfather denounced Stalin. Things improved until POS Putin started invasons of its "brothers". Russia almost became a normal country. Now it will be a pariah state for generations.
Her comparison of Putin to Trump is very accurate
So Nina is of the same tribe as Ziolensky?
@@javierfrancia1938 what’s your problem?
When did trump assassinate political rivals and friends getting to popular?
@@noquochoke He forgot to take his meds.
@@First-Last_name Jan 6th was close ....
all of us should understand that
Ruskyi mir is simply Lebensraum idea and ambition of the Asian hordes to become part of the rich (both in history and wealth) European continent. Nina presents the facts and is capable of accurate analysis of the situation, yet she cannot separate herself from the idea of Ruskyi mir and relativizes the horrible depths to which the nation descended. She also does not believe that the country can democratize the way Ukraine did, which makes her a proponent of the past. It is not about wishful thinking, but about an ideal of revival which should always be pursued.
very good comment.