How One Piece Depicts Masculinity
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 лип 2024
- Analysis Anthology ig.
Scattered thoughts on One Piece's ongoing Narrative and character themes strung together by a cringe buzzword. And sorry, I'm not touching Sanji and his Adventures on Newkama with a 20ft pole.
Time Stamps
0:00 Romance Dawn
5:01 ONIWABARU!!!
7:23 YOLO
9:33 The Deadliest Sin
11:35 Toxic Stoicism
Music Used in order of appearence
Gravity Rush 2OST -Cosmola Marketplace / Boss Theme
Okami ost - Sussano's Training / Sakura Blossoms]
KH3 fanmade ost
• Kingdom Hearts 3 Imagi...
One Piece - Binks Sake
PABLO BOBADILLA RIDERr
• SOGEKING 狙撃の王様そげキング - ...
cr1ticalfailure
• This Life is Mine | In...
• RWBY- Path to Isolatio...
This video was posted on Anime Amino.
aminoapps.com/c/anime/join/
#ONEPIECE #Manga #AnimeAnalysis
Twitter
/ namedpuff - Фільми й анімація
Bon-chan is the most masculine character in the series
Amen Brother.
Amen
Amen.
Friendship is a amazing thing
Never thought less of him not counting when he was a opp
Katakuri is the embodiment of "Sticks and stones may not break my bones, but words... I've said enough."
It says a lot that one of the manliest men in One Piece walks around dressed like a Baby.
Also, for some reason the music fits Katakuri unreasonably well.
And another is a cyborg in a speedo
lol what? so being a man means lying to your woman going around killing ppl and ignoring the needs of the wife and the child lol ? i was sad for his wife, not for him.
@@potatorisa ...Admitting to his mistakes and trying to make up for them, doing what he thinks is best for his family, going his own path with a smile on his face, no matter how much ridicule it incures, etc. etc.
It's mainly about his progression though, take him from the start of his story, sure I'll agree with you, but it's everything after the his wife's accident that makes him manly.
Or it's just me and I got Mulan flashbacks, you never know...
@@MarcelJ. mmmm yeah after doing the damage admitting it is the least he could do. but atonement hasn't come
that's why One Piece is my favorite anime of all time!!
I just love that it features total badasses regularly ugly-crying for all kinds of different reasons. In most media, men aren't allowed to cry outside of the most extreme circumstances, like losing a child, and even then it can only be one single tear dripping down their otherwise stoic and determined face. In one piece, a good man will cry when his loved ones die, but he'll also cry because he's moved by a sad story, or something his friends did for him, or because he's reuniting with those friends. And then he'll turn around and knock the stuffing out of some bad guys. Wearing your heart on your sleeve and being vulnerable with those you care about is seen as a good thing which not only doesn't make you any less badass, but it helps you to accomplish your goals and be even MORE badass than if you'd hidden everything away. The series can get repetitive with its formula, but godDAMN does it do masculinity so well.
Sanji is kinda a problem though lol
Didn't sanji cried like twice during whole cake
whaat how's Sanji a problem🤨
@@jakesjacket because no matter how often and vehemently the women reject him, he won't stop bugging the absolute shit out of them? Like, I get that sometimes no can mean yes, but 40 no's in a row probably means no lol
@@jakesjacket Because he's a creepy weirdo
@@foop145 Has he ever actually accosted the same woman twice when she clearly rejects him? Nami and Robin never outright tell him no, they seem to lead him on just because they're amused by it. Everyone else, he makes a move, they tell him no or beat the shit out of him, and then he moves on. If I forgot about something, though, let me know.
One thing I've noticed is that despite Big Mom's big dream of making her people into one big family, she's only really turned it into a business.
In a family, you would never be ashamed to show your face, even if you got laughed at. Because those are your younger siblings, you love them, even if they're being goofs or assholes. In a family, you would never have to become the pillar for your peers, or act like everything is business. In a family, you don't have to be ashamed of losing when there are sisters and brothers to wipe your wounds and lift you up.
One Piece drestoys the myth of masculinity being something that is inherently toxic and broken in the first issue. True masculinity. Where Shanks shrugs off some Bro who wants to fight because he is so bad ass. Yes Shanks is the true masculin hero here. And he does everything that is counter to so called masculinity and shows what real confidence and self esteem is. It’s what’s great about this show.
Masculinity was never something that is inherently toxic it’s always an admirable thing it’s only called toxic in today’s woke media in the west not even in the whole world
I'd like to think a large part of katakuri's insecurities were a result of big mom's parenting. She claims to love all races of their world yet was disgusted when she noticed pudding's third eye. Also When her youngest children would chase each other with weapons she cheered them on. The pressure from that type of environment as well as the incident with his sister likely became what could've given early rise to his dysphoria, causing him to not be able to develop bonds with his family. Choosing to become a black sheep instead.
He is one of the only ones to genuinely care for his family, how has he not developed bonds with them?
I find it so sad that masculinity, and just being a man and manly is often condemned as a whole in large parts of the modern world. Toxic masculinity is a thing, but masculinity in itself is not bad(same with femininity, and toxic femininity). There is a reason we add an extra word when we refer negatively towards masculinity.
I have seen with my own eyes young boys taking to Andrew Tate and people like him, and learning and living by his views because he is one of the few that does not talk down on masculinity, and the concept of manly men.
It's quite sad, and quite uncomfortable for me as a female when young guys I care about suddenly started expressing those degrading views toward my gender(I live in a country where men and woman is nothing but equal. We have our differences, but not because one is looked at or treated as less. Of course, it's not perfect, but I might be pessimistic when I doubt perfection is possible. So talk like that is quite uncommon).
I know they do not have cruel intentions, but a lot of bullshit has been spunged into their brains, and I have had to have a talk with some of them because of this.
I remember being taken aback when Luffy expressed not wanting frills on his clothes because it was girly and that he didn't want the others to laugh at him. I took him as someone that simply would not care if something was "girly" or not. But then it makes sense because a lot of men in One Piece are all about the "honor of a man", and the responsibilities and codes they live by because of this. Luffy is no exception. And I had to wonder if it was a bad thing that Luffy did not want to wear "girly" things.
Some would call it toxicity. But it's really not.
It's not like he looks down on those girly things or anyone that likes that. Luffy is the furthest thing from toxic. He just doesn't want to wear them himself.
Because I was taken aback that Luffy was not okay with wearing girly things, I had to consider why. And realized masculinity is treated quite badly when it should not. Instead, we should embrace that masculinity and femininity exist. Neither is inherently bad.
Girls being shamed for being "too feminine", and boys being told they are inherently toxic for being masculine or even just a man is bad and unhealthy.
One Piece masculinity is something that should be more normal to see in media I think. Big, cool, manly men expressing their emotions, living their lives to the fullest with all their hardships and joys, and following their honor codes is badass as hell.
At least that is my perspective as a female.
I think Luffy is perfectly fine to not want to wear frills, I think people have the right to have preferences, likes, and dislikes. People don't have the right to be unnecessarily rude, but I don't think people making themselves uncomfortable in order to be seen as politically correct is the right way.
@@wesleywallace4426 Completely agree with you. This is why I found it strange that I was taken aback when Luffy was unhappy with the frills.
I was more or less unconsciously thinking that gender clothes/preferences are not ideal. But I honestly think as long as people are comfortable and happy with what they are wearing it really doesn't matter. There is nothing wrong with Luffy not wanting to wear more feminine clothes.
I love how he proceeds to forget Higuma's name.
I am pretty sure Luffy/Shanks would also do same thing
Great points about how WCI is a land of deception and everyone there lies in some way or another. Also this makes me appreciate Katakuri much more, makes me want to reread WCI again
You might've made some very good points but have you ever considered that masculinity is too manly to even be toxic
That’s a pretty toxic thing to say mister! Have you not been taking your testosterone suppression pills!!?
100%
@Puff The Pirate there is no such thing as toxic masculinity, this is a concept invented by the far-left. There are well educated men, and poorly educated men only. And their behavior be it proper or lacking, does not involve their masculinity but their manners and morality
@@puffthepirate1528 testosterone is my natural juice. I want more of it never less. I want kaido levels of testosterone
I eat other men to steal their testosterone.
This was basically a Luffy vs katakuri analysis. But I wanted to make longer videos so I ended up forcing an anthology. It’s hardly about masculinity I just couldn’t think of a better word to string these common themes together. In hindsight I should have framed it as Luffy vs Katakuri and sprinkle in how these themes were used elsewhere.
No I think you were right. I actually would have liked if you made a conclusion that would tie things neatly into a final commentary about masculinity.
I don't know if you planned on it but you actually made a good dissection of what toxic masculinity is through your analysis of Katakuri. Katakuri and big mom's family is the embodiment of just how harmful the burden put on boys to perform can be. In any cases, I'm happy that somebody finally made a video about that topic because it's something that I always saw in one piece and really appreciated. The way oda, through goofiness and absurd, manages to deconstruct steretipical masculinity and create male characters that are badass and endearing at the same time.
So thank you for this
This turned up great tho, keep up the great work
"will" might be another good example of word
To be fair to Oden he probably could have stopped Kaido when he got back but the civilians were basically being held hostage.
Bro toxic stoicism hits different thanks for explaining this to me bro keep up the good work
Loved the point you made about Katakuri getting up, just to fall down again in imitation of Luffy. I never thought of it like that and it makes so much sense
Whitebeard is the most chadlike character in all of manga
After guts and thors
ESCANOOOOR
When its not nightime
I always love some well done one piece analysis. Really has to much depth.
I love the manga animation you're doing! Please keep it up!
One piece doesn’t arguably depict masculinity but instead focuses on each person individually and how they act and are based on their upbringings.
It 100% depicts masculinity and its virtues. Luffy's real journey is that of a boy becoming a man.
i don’t agree, i think his real journey is not as simple as that. Luffy’s journey is about him becoming pirate king and then to fullfill his final secrets dream. Themes of him becoming a man from a boy aren’t overly present. @@Sebster85
Damn once brink's sake started playing i teared up a bit
great vid, and I loved the Gravity Rush OST in the background :D
Glad to see someone talk about this aspect of One Piece
Very needed video for the young men of today! Masterful work
This was an excellent analysis!
Loved the segment on all the false exteriors of WCI
There's definitely more examples like Carmel but I thought it'd drag on too much if I mentioned more than 3. Also that Brook section is my favorite part of the whole video.
Glad I found this channel 👍🏽
Great video! Thank you for reminding me how great One Piece is !!
This video deserves more likes that it has.
This is the kind of man Shanks is yet ppl were going around saying he is a "holy" Knight lololololol
I've been meaning to watch this video for a while. I was a little bummed that I couldn't understand your squeeky rant, but these points make me love WCI even more than before. In a lot of ways, One Piece isn't as good as it used to be, but it's still amazing.
Looks like we’ve found a new Morj
Oh your too kind.
amazing video, glad i found your channel
i had to slow the speed down to 0.5 to listen to the 'ridiculous tangent' and i fully agree with what you said
susanoo's theme playing over you talking about wano fits so well
Love this video so much. Nice manga format.
Awesome video!!! Love this so much!
Great video, great points, ended up getting thoroughly distracted by the Rwby music playing in the background multiple times, 10/10 will watch again
I enjoyed your video. A little to the theme of what you were talking about in the video...I wish I could have understood your rant, lol. I was genuinely interested in your opinion, that's why I'm here. Hope to hear the next rant more clearly. You could have still had the rant, just...stand in your words. They're as important as the other ones here. 😅 I'm get off my soap box now. Good video. I love whole cake for similar themes.
You won points from me using Weiss' songs for Katakuri. Absolutel vibes
Shocked me how well it went together
These videos are slapping
Also, I'll be waiting on that Pudding video.
Maybe I wanted to hear your tangent at the end
You can always slow it down to listen if your interested.
@@puffthepirate1528 it's kinda hard to understand such an high pitch - at least to a not-so-good-at-english-listener. maybe you can make a whole normal speed video out of this tangent
Man, I wish you more views. Great video.
Okay I agree with your point regarding Oden. The thing is, he would’ve killed Kaido in their battle if he was not tricked. Kaido even knew it. It’s why he became suicidal. He yearns for the death that he deserved. Kaido hoped the Akayaza samurai would kill him, to gain the satisfaction of death at the hands of the Kozuki inheriting Oden’s will. This is a great video, I wish I had confidence to talk about motifs in this wonderful story on UA-cam.
“Rubber always bounces back” one of the coldest lines ever said
6:48 thats the most Trebol ass laugh Ive ever heard 😂
Sick video
incredible visdeo, this is a thing i miss in modern days.
Great video keep making more video
This is such a good vid
great video on the topic of masculinity, I feel the term "toxic masculinity" has been thrown around too haphazardly and without any real understanding of what is means, to the point any display of a typically masculine trait/act is seen as "toxic masculinity". masculinity has never been the problem, the real problem is when you take something to an extreme, any trait taken to it's extreme (or the extreme of the total lack of said quality) can become toxic/detrimental to a person. your video did a great job at displaying how One piece shows these traits in there most noble forms and there dangerous forms in a very smart and thought out way.
additionally, your section on katakuri was specifically really amazing. in my life I have often felt like katakuri/had to act in a similar vain and as a result made some of the same mistakes/flaws that came as a result. so the way you analyzed that section was not only more in depth than other katakuri analysis but also really thought provoking to me and I find that commendable
I actually feel that toxic masculinity is what happens when there is not enough masculinity. Having pride and trying to conquer solely through strength is to avoid the other parts of masculinity like leadership and gentleness
@@philspaghet i agree
Thank you for this video. I will stop running.
"In the world of one piece there is no place for people without a dream"
where's the manliest man among men who sacrificed his freedom twice for Luffy, the one and only Bon-Clay
Great video, but I felt like the music was a little too loud. Keep up the good work fellow nakama!
This was the manliest video to ever manly
Zoro and Katakuri are my favourite characters, but i didn't notice what Katakuri was hiding and the weight he was carrying for the longest time, until i saw this video, thank you for informing me
“Your life should be the last thing you give, but what good is a long life if you don’t protect the things you care about. “
Fire quote
um actually 🤓stoicism refers to not allowing your emotions to control your actions, and not to the fact you hide your feelings... BAKA SHINJI!!!
In an age where people are negatively reactionary to anything, we could use more stoicism
@@ReiseLukas i agree ngl
toxic stoicism *is* about hiding your feelings though, it refers to a wrong and unhealthy adherence of the philosophy of stoicism causing you to just shut off from struggle to feel in control, which katakuri does.
@@propanesquid5234 yeah but in this video he was implying that stoicism itelf is toxic. its a diffeent thing if he would clarify he was specifically talking about suppressing emotions, but he deliberately mixed up the definition of stoicism to make a (false) point (btw sorry for my poor english skills)
your emotions always control your actions
nice video
12:30 Brook is priceless
Brook was the most important part of that arc.
Luffy won, Katakuri didn't lose on purpose. Yes, I did slow down rant at the end to 0.25x and my ears are BTFO now
Great video, but does any else feel like the music is too loud? I feel like it's a little distracting.
Gotta love the Okami ost!
I mean its a romance so its a story full of passion, and all great men have unwavering passions and wills
This whole thing where Katakuri is afraid people will make fun of him for his mouth, makes no sense given the context of One Piece. There are so many weird looking characters and they are considered normal by their surrounding characters. Fat, skinny, tall, short, monstrous, ugly etc. So the concept of Katakuri being considered weird for having that mouth just doesn't add up. It's like a talking animal being considered strange in Bugs Bunny where there are so many other talking animals.
Partiality making others insecure just to feel better
Its cause of this
People make fun of him
He fights them(as a kid)
Same guys attack his sister for revenge
good video, i think the music is a bit too loud but otherwise, enjoyed the content
Shanks is the pinnacle of true masculinity
Hey, your point in the video were great, but try to decrease the volume of the background music next time. It's a bit distracting, at least to me.
That’s a pretty wild theory, that Sniper king and Usopp are the same person I am it’s downright ridiculous 😅.
Gotta give respect to the Gravity Rush 2 OST in the video!
Good and interesting video but could you make the music louder next time I could almost hear you
17:07 *cries*
Yes, I cried during that page of Luffy complaining about how hungry he was. What of it?
Why am I findin this channel late?
I love the video, but the music is too loud
Whitebeard and Zoro shaped my idea of masculinity when I was younger
luffy realy be saying "i always come back"
Gigachad senior pink is the epitome of manliness
haha no he sucks.
music too loud but good vid!!
I thought exactly the same, when he used the Pirates of the caribbean theme you couldn't hear him that well
🔥🔥🔥
One Piece gay asl and I love it
And there still homophobic one piece fans🫣 like… did we read/watch the same thing cuz like…
@@lulu_TheWitchBoyFOR REAL. Fishman Island Is all about racism yet there are racist one piece fans too
@Idiot Archives bros be like "I hate woke politics in everything!!!! Now I'm gonna consume anime and manga because that stuff DEFINITELY doesn't have ANY politics in it!!!" AND THEN WATCH/READ ONE PIECE
It's a good thing most of the real world hates the flamers
Great vid but the music is off. Deeper music would have fit the tone
WHY DID U SPEED UP THE RIDICULOUS TANGENT 😭
The background music is from gravity rush 2
random gravity rush cameo
Objection, his crew mates have already ridiculed Luffy for every of his shortcomings.
You are TRULY OP to put a talking chipmunk donut out on the Internet! 😁 /gen
You can never beat a crackhead like Luffy
WCI was so goood!
Ikr!? I Love it.
Bro there was a video in your music
What about whitebeard is he a man since he never had injuries on his back cause he never ran from a fight or whitebeard is like ace he never ran to protect his family
Wearing a Swan costume and helping your friends. Thats manly.
Healthy but badass No nonsense masculinity? ... Whitebeard!
Huh? This is just what Masculinity always was.
14:55 oh no, that's me
You shouldn't have added the super pinch voice, i genuinely didn't understood a thing
I wonder if Roger's illness was due to similar self sacrificing techniques
No it was haki
music sometimes is as high as your voice on speaker
Guess I'm like Katakuri when it comes to talking to Girls (I don't)
I wonder if thats why GOLD ROGER died so young????🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔