I'm totally a lamb but to he honest I wouldn't change Celine over Mariah! I grew up appreciating the song and Celine's performance. It really lacks nothing! It's perfect just the way it is! ❤️
So this UA-cam channel decided to work hard and bring together two angelic, legendary voices to make this beautiful snippet, and idiots just decided to jump in and deemed it a competition and started bashing the other singer for nothing? Did I miss something, or is Idiot Apocalypse 2019 approaching? smh
Are you talking about the note at 0:09? Haha that was not flat (it should actually be called "sharp" in this case, per your comment about hitting a higher note) at all! It was a sharp inflection (an E5) that was totally on key!
@@tialylunique7123 what I meant mariah's voice "size" is naturally smaller. She has one of the smallest voices in the industry and I'm not talking about resonance here
@@Jesus-gd3bj Mariah Carey having " one of the smallest voices in the industry " No, you're totally wrong. You may don't know Mariah's music properly Mariah is the vocalist having the biggest and the strongest voice in the industry, she has a much stronger voice than Céline. That's how she built her success , popularity and fame all over the world since her very first released materials without any cover, any duet and any movie soundtrack to boost herself unlike Céline . Céline is the one having the smallest voice in the industry proved by her limited voice that Israël one dimensional voice sounding so nasal, basic, generic, predictable and so annoying.
editing not so good but the whistle at the end was perfect. I always thought that if mariah ever covered this song she would do the flute part herself or maybe harmonize with the flute cause she is able to hit those flute notes perfectly.
where is that "go on" at 00:17 is from ? I know its from mtv unplugged but wich song? (also the vid shows mariah at make it happen but the sound is from somewhere else.. cant figure out from where)
Celine still EATS on this. And I mean the ENTIRE CRUSE SHIP. I literally can not with this. SUSTAIN! ATE all 7 courses. Who chose these Mariah notes? Scandalous 🤣😍
People just can't help comparing. They were actually in different venues and used different microphones? Different sound systems? Comparing resonance. Really?
Excellent work but I own the mtv unplugged and those were not the notes she sang on those clips. Perhaps you used them since it matches the vocal cuts you put together? Either way I enjoyed it like you other works. JiT wished you didn’t pitch the notes
Nahh Mariah’s resonance is definitely better...she has a wider sound and more ring than Celine. That doesn’t take away from Celine power though! They are amazing vocalists in their own ways! Definitely both on top of their game. I would say Celine is a better balladeer than Mariah, though, in a sense that she can sustain notes better! Mariah’s ballads have very RnB vibes to them!
boobooness Gir- well no it said Mariah was on to sing the song but Tommy forced her not to Celine want to do the sing at one point but obviously did🤷🏻♂️
Oof well.. i did this like almost 4 years ago.. time flies lol and I’m not exactly sure sorry.. Maybe the first bit is from make it happen and the second part is my all live from divas live micfeed (could be wrong)
Ok...Mariah is the best about the whistle register...but Celine is Celine. And we don't, we must say nothing! She is the best singer in the world and I know you know this is the truth.
Celine Dion her voice so clear and techniques and emotional. Mariah whistle sound so crazy ! Ariana grande can do it . But Celine’s voice nobody can sing like her 😬🍒
Um Ariana can literally do celine’s voice, it’s the other way hun, multiple people have been able to copy celines and Whitneys sound/voice except Mariah’s 🤷🏻♀️
Acaba sendo um ft injusto porque na hora que Celine está finalizando a nota, a voz da Mariah é colocada, e geralmente uma parte em que a voz dela está no ápice, ou seja no incio da nota, não está por igual.
Should it not be Celion Dion ft Mariah Carey? 😀 In an alternate universe, rumour has it that Mariah started as Ceine's backup singer where they stayed in an apartment with matresses on the floor with many cats 👀
Lol delusional much? Those singing style of mariah that the editor did doesn’t fit the song.. this song doesn’t need vocal show offs. It needs emotions that only céline can do and known for that.
@jocriss No, it's not. Enya was originally picked by James Cameron to do the Score of the Titanic but she turned it down then, James Horner came then, Cameron asked Enya to do the voices in the Score that Horner made. James Horner secretly made "My Heart Will Go On" and asked Celine to sing it. At first, when Horner was playing it to celine and singing that song, she's making a sign at the back to her husband, Rene that she didn't like the song (and because horner isn't a great singer so that adds why celine don't want to sing that song) but Rene said to Horner that Celine will make a demo. And she did and she did it in ONE TAKE only. And the rest is history :)
@@JohnDeLeon28 I hear about that story, during the recording studio, Celine Dion had her period, so she was not in a good mood, but look, one take only
Hihi that you took a very young mariah to sing Céline song because today it would certainly sound différent now that she doesn t have the voice that she add way back then 😉
Len Stgelais ofc it’s going to sound different since nobody’s voice sounds the same but still sounds beautiful . But for the record i used vocals from acapellas so they can blend easier.
Alex L.A. Im not saying that you Didn t do a bad job on the contrary you did an excellent job you did your best my point is that now mariah is not the same singer that she was way back then 🥰
MMilotic hihi good one because these days shes singing live all over différent média and still is the same Céline has she was younger contrary to mariah who still add some proplem lately with singing live ho well thats mariah 🤷♂️🤷♂️
Check out my cover of Save Your Tears by The Weeknd
ua-cam.com/video/qPL-wtSWZjo/v-deo.html
0:17 That Mariah high note with Celine singing the melody like that, was absolutely gorgeous. I almost cried.
Absolutely. It's angelic. So emotional.
Yasss absolutely
OMG A BLINK 😭HII! I THOUGHT ID NEVER FIND A BLINK SHARE THE SAME LOVE FOR OLD NOSTALGIC MUSIC😭
ua-cam.com/video/w7fszz8ff9o/v-deo.html
Ikrrr
All the ladies, Celine, Mariah and Whit sound so amazing together. VH1 Divas should have had all 3 of them as headliners.
Agreed!
Imagine them 3... and Imagine if they'd actually gotten along with eachother. What a gift we would've gotten.
@@danielbenitez6985 None of them had a problem with the other and respected each other as entertainers.
@@akeemj7676 Mariah has been a bit bitchy to Celine over the years.
@@TTUploads it's not bitchy. She said she didn't think Celine had enough respect for Aretha. That's it
SLAYline and LEGENDriah
Celegend and Lipriah
@@goldranger5182 don’t even try to come for the queen mariah
@@jamarijamari3478 queen of payola
Lets just say they are both the best in their ways!
@@GamingWithEric2508 period!
if mariah did my heart will go on, she'd harmonize her whistle with the flute. omg imagineee 😍😍
0:20 i loved
I tought the flute in the beginning was Mariah whistling hahaha
The Whistle Is So Angelic 🦋🦋🦋🕊🕊🕊
I NEED THE FULL VERSION, OMG
That's amazing lamby, a dream come true! Legends 💖👑
absolutely! hope you liked the hamonies too!
@@AlexGray19 Yeah nice edit! 💖 I honestly don't know why they never recorded a song together, they blend like Pb&J 😅
I wasnt sure what was happening here but I must say that Ending with Mariah was Epic nicely done.😁
I'm totally a lamb but to he honest I wouldn't change Celine over Mariah! I grew up appreciating the song and Celine's performance. It really lacks nothing! It's perfect just the way it is! ❤️
You like boring and nasal? 😂😂😂💩💩💩
The blend at 0:18 HAD ME IN TEARS
Celine's resonance is unmatched.
Fact.
Her nasality is unmatched 💩💩💩
It's classic Mariah too! Ahhhh, I'm crying from the beauty of it all.
Why whats wrong of hip hop Mariah?
If mariah would've recorded this in the daydream era, imagine the crystal clear belts!!
Look at how classy céline is..
I Saw This Last Year and i want to take a look at it again so i searched this up! ❤️
glad you are still enjoying it
That whistle note saved this shit.
This fan made video already gave me goosebumps. How much more if they truly do this legendary collaboration? 😍❤️
Glad you liked it! Check out my covers! ❤️
The way Céline moves... so classy. Btw, you did an amazing job. Especially the harmonies of “on” with Céline. It really fits 👍🏼
0:18-0:23 sounds so Wow🎶😍🎶
I love the ending!❤️
Mariah's whistle note would've appeared when the ship hits the iceberg.
At 0:44 Mariah saw the iceberg and screamed... 🤔
That whistle wouldve been enough to shatter the iceberg.
Who knows! Maybe they will do something together in the futur! :D
I can't imagine , if mariah can singing celine songs with her high notes like that, Oh godness its was amazing
do the whole song with mariah's voice, we are begging you
So this UA-cam channel decided to work hard and bring together two angelic, legendary voices to make this beautiful snippet, and idiots just decided to jump in and deemed it a competition and started bashing the other singer for nothing? Did I miss something, or is Idiot Apocalypse 2019 approaching? smh
💖
Idiots apocalypse still goes on in 2021! 🙄🤦
THIS IS SOOO GOOD IF THEY COLLAB NOW I WILL DIE
Oh wow mariah carey shes the queen what angelic voice and the whistle GOOSEBUMPS 👍👏👑❤️
amazing work wow
Yes!!! I love the ending with the whistle. That's how Mariah would sing the song.
Nicely done. I would love to hear MC sings the entire song tho!
mariah flat..she hit higher note infront of the climax (which is not the right key)
the whistle captivate me
Are you talking about the note at 0:09? Haha that was not flat (it should actually be called "sharp" in this case, per your comment about hitting a higher note) at all! It was a sharp inflection (an E5) that was totally on key!
the WHISTLE NOTE !!!! MY QUEENS
Pretty Mariah.
That was so good 😂 👌🏻
thank you!
Whoever said celine has smaller resonance than mariah should listen to this. Celine’s ring is so much bigger.
You do realize that it could have been the audio levels were not the same. 🙄
@@LalaMontenegro1 not only that, but mariah's voice is smaller by default lol
@@Jesus-gd3bj Mariah's voice is much bigger and much more powerful than Céline's
@@tialylunique7123 what I meant mariah's voice "size" is naturally smaller. She has one of the smallest voices in the industry and I'm not talking about resonance here
@@Jesus-gd3bj Mariah Carey having " one of the smallest voices in the industry " No, you're totally wrong. You may don't know Mariah's music properly Mariah is the vocalist having the biggest and the strongest voice in the industry, she has a much stronger voice than Céline. That's how she built her success , popularity and fame all over the world since her very first released materials without any cover, any duet and any movie soundtrack to boost herself unlike Céline .
Céline is the one having the smallest voice in the industry proved by her limited voice that Israël one dimensional voice sounding so nasal, basic, generic, predictable and so annoying.
editing not so good but the whistle at the end was perfect. I always thought that if mariah ever covered this song she would do the flute part herself or maybe harmonize with the flute cause she is able to hit those flute notes perfectly.
That flute doesn't even go that high. Most sopranos can sing those notes.
@@Ignasimp it goes to g6 or a6. That's pretty high
@@takemyhand1988Mariah probably would’ve taken it to 7th octave
where is that "go on" at 00:17 is from ? I know its from mtv unplugged but wich song? (also the vid shows mariah at make it happen but the sound is from somewhere else.. cant figure out from where)
The first part is from make it happen unplugged. Idk about the "on" part
On sounds like butterfly tone
Celine still EATS on this. And I mean the ENTIRE CRUSE SHIP. I literally can not with this. SUSTAIN! ATE all 7 courses. Who chose these Mariah notes? Scandalous 🤣😍
I wish I can watch them singing together . . .
Last whistle 🥺🤘🤘
Lol 😆 that was good especially at the end
I love this type of videos! but Goodness! The toxicity of the comment section is unbearable lol 🤧
Gieux Croix true 🤷🏼♂️
Honestly there's no reason for people to start a fight by trying to prove nothing but they do so eventually! 🤦
A song to remember 😊
Wow🦋👏
Wow that's good
People just can't help comparing. They were actually in different venues and used different microphones? Different sound systems? Comparing resonance. Really?
Great observation, and they are hitting different note, I guess that this video is a bit of one sided
And this is Mariah in her prime. Celine well after her prime.
@@danielbenitez6985 well celine lipped already at the start of her career with less demanding songs than Mariah…your point?🤷🏻♀️
@@catattacks1522 TOXICCCCCC
@@danielbenitez6985 well celine was lipsyncing to an old recording
Just love it.. 😊.
Hope to meet you Alex L. A.. 😊.
BTW why do I never ever see them in one frame or at the same event, like greeting each other or something??
This song doesn't require extra notes and very hard belts. All u need is a properly tuned instrument and Celine has it right.
Can You Make My Heart Will Go On and Hero Mashup Song Please.
Cyllene Celine Albornoz thanks for the suggestion! 😊
Could you make one of Mariah singing alone? Please.
No
#TheMCWhistle 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
Hope to meet you Alex L. A.. 😊.
I wish Mariah covered the song during her prime 💔
U couldve used the forever word from mariahs forever song
the volume need more blended, love the ending
UAUUUU Mariah ♥
*My dub will go on*
Quando a Celine morrer, quero que a Mariah cante essa música em algum tributo
0:29 😭
Excellent work but I own the mtv unplugged and those were not the notes she sang on those clips. Perhaps you used them since it matches the vocal cuts you put together? Either way I enjoyed it like you other works. JiT wished you didn’t pitch the notes
Hmm, Celine sounds better, she has Godlike resonance!!!
Mariah overall has a better and greater resonance than Céline
@@tialylunique7123 I disagree.
@@tialylunique7123 I object
@@glennbaran1645 prove me wrong if you can
Nahh Mariah’s resonance is definitely better...she has a wider sound and more ring than Celine. That doesn’t take away from Celine power though! They are amazing vocalists in their own ways! Definitely both on top of their game. I would say Celine is a better balladeer than Mariah, though, in a sense that she can sustain notes better! Mariah’s ballads have very RnB vibes to them!
What songs are the snippets from because Mariah sounds amazing?
They are all from the MTV Unplugged EP, the only ones I can actually pinpoint are Can't Let Go and If It's Over
@@lichyyyyy the videos are but the vocals aren't
00:00 Is this Mariah whistle???
Thousands of people are capable to whistle. Even higher.
but not everyone can control them while sound pleasing at the same time.
Not you discrediting Mariah 😭 she’s one of the only ones to do so like that. You ain’t find one of those unlike someone like Ariana 😭🤣
Millions of people are capable of belting. Even higher
What song did Mariah sing on the whistle part?
i'm not sure i fully remember.. i think it was can't let go
@@AlexGray19 Yeah I think its Can't Let Go. Thank You! :)
Cara, ficou incrivél
Celine angels voices wala na makatapos kay celine legendary
I just caught wind that Mariah was actually supposed to sing this sing but Tommy forced her not to.
Lol polluted wind
She wasn't wtf.
boobooness Gir- well no it said Mariah was on to sing the song but Tommy forced her not to Celine want to do the sing at one point but obviously did🤷🏻♂️
Didn’t want to do the song at one point but obviously did*
It was historically intended for celine by James Horner and no one else.
grabe ung whistle ni Mariah❤
0:18 where is this vocal from?? Plsss
Oof well.. i did this like almost 4 years ago.. time flies lol and I’m not exactly sure sorry.. Maybe the first bit is from make it happen and the second part is my all live from divas live micfeed (could be wrong)
@@AlexGray19 😭😭😭😭 but thx
Esa canción es sólo para ser cantada por celine dion, nadie más
Si celine maliit lang bukas ng big pero grabe at very simple lang sha
Ok...Mariah is the best about the whistle register...but Celine is Celine. And we don't, we must say nothing! She is the best singer in the world and I know you know this is the truth.
Mariah and Celine has their own weakness and strength
Celine Dion her voice so clear and techniques and emotional. Mariah whistle sound so crazy ! Ariana grande can do it . But Celine’s voice nobody can sing like her 😬🍒
Um Ariana can literally do celine’s voice, it’s the other way hun, multiple people have been able to copy celines and Whitneys sound/voice except Mariah’s 🤷🏻♀️
@@catattacks1522 give me ur Fb name my love ! I can sing open arm by Mariah 95% I can copy her techniques
Techniques Mariah is easy for me
@@monyreach6570 can you hit all the notes from the lowest note to the highest belt?
@@monyreach6570 also there are multiple people who impersonate Celine exactly in singing. There's not even one for Mariah
@@takemyhand1988 hardest song for me is without u and emotion !
I can sing only open arm and hero by Mariah Carey I sing like her 98%
Mariah carey is the best thing God has ever done
Tho I like Mariah but except the whistle it didn't click for me ....the climax was awesome tho....and this is a classic by Celine
well duh the editing is off and it makes mariah sound false which is not possible with mariah.
Acaba sendo um ft injusto porque na hora que Celine está finalizando a nota, a voz da Mariah é colocada, e geralmente uma parte em que a voz dela está no ápice, ou seja no incio da nota, não está por igual.
Whistles thing is what holding back Mariah's legendary vocalist status
Sadly she's VOCALLY inferior outside this registry
Mariah is the original....
... what?
Girl this is not your original video
0:18 0:42
Should it not be Celion Dion ft Mariah Carey? 😀 In an alternate universe, rumour has it that Mariah started as Ceine's backup singer where they stayed in an apartment with matresses on the floor with many cats 👀
Thanks for the comment! This performance is already in an alternative universe. Merry Christmas! 🎅🎄🎁
0:16
No!!!
No
😱🤭😵😂🤣😂🤣
mariah is the win
Lol delusional much? Those singing style of mariah that the editor did doesn’t fit the song.. this song doesn’t need vocal show offs. It needs emotions that only céline can do and known for that.
Then you know the reason why "my heart will go on" indeed goes to Celine. The melody did not fit to mariah that time.
Mariah best voice !!!
mariah messes up the song !! 😤
Did you guys know this song was firt wrote to Mariah and than they gave it to Celine??
No its not
LOL that's fake news.. I'm sure there's no proof to show hahaha
@jocriss No, it's not. Enya was originally picked by James Cameron to do the Score of the Titanic but she turned it down then, James Horner came then, Cameron asked Enya to do the voices in the Score that Horner made.
James Horner secretly made "My Heart Will Go On" and asked Celine to sing it. At first, when Horner was playing it to celine and singing that song, she's making a sign at the back to her husband, Rene that she didn't like the song (and because horner isn't a great singer so that adds why celine don't want to sing that song) but Rene said to Horner that Celine will make a demo. And she did and she did it in ONE TAKE only.
And the rest is history :)
@@JohnDeLeon28 I hear about that story, during the recording studio, Celine Dion had her period, so she was not in a good mood, but look, one take only
Mariah would never sing this song. She's hip hop. From what I can recollect, it was Celine's song. Lamb here.
lol
Hihi that you took a very young mariah to sing Céline song because today it would certainly sound différent now that she doesn t have the voice that she add way back then 😉
Len Stgelais ofc it’s going to sound different since nobody’s voice sounds the same but still sounds beautiful . But for the record i used vocals from acapellas so they can blend easier.
Alex L.A. Im not saying that you Didn t do a bad job on the contrary you did an excellent job you did your best my point is that now mariah is not the same singer that she was way back then 🥰
@@lenstgelais7652 Neither has Céline xx
MMilotic hihi good one because these days shes singing live all over différent média and still is the same Céline has she was younger contrary to mariah who still add some proplem lately with singing live ho well thats mariah 🤷♂️🤷♂️
@Len Stgelais You are idiot. Bitch
Horrible la Maria .
This is awful, mariah's voice doesnt fit with the song