Was Gandhiji bigger Political Scientist than Chanakya? | Thinkers | UPSC

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @StudyIQEducationLtd
    @StudyIQEducationLtd  Рік тому +2

    UPSC IAS (Mains) PSIR Optional Live 2024 (Comprehensive) August Batch : bit.ly/3Km0mOA
    Batch Starting on 16th August, 2023 | Class Timing -1:00 PM
    To know more visit : bit.ly/3Km0mOA

  • @taranjeetsingh9518
    @taranjeetsingh9518 Рік тому +162

    no one can stand in front of acharya chanakya legacy and sharp mind he is the guru of diplomacy

    • @g.o.a.t7734
      @g.o.a.t7734 Рік тому +9

      Pehle video to dekhlo bhai

    • @Thepatriot8356
      @Thepatriot8356 Рік тому

      आचार्य चाणक्य ने roman rule से भारत को बचाया था देश की रियासतों को एकजुट करके चंद्रगुप्त को चक्रवती सम्राट बनाकर।वरना मुस्लिम रूल से पहले हम रोमन बन चुके होते।

    • @Anchal-x2r
      @Anchal-x2r Рік тому +1

      Correct bro

    • @vishalmishra8608
      @vishalmishra8608 Рік тому +1

      Definitely

    • @abd2950
      @abd2950 Рік тому +2

      Bilkul sahi Chanakya Chanakya hai. Imagine TV ka Chandra Gupta Maurya Serial dekh lo jindagi badal jaayegi.

  • @HarshSahu-eu8zw
    @HarshSahu-eu8zw Рік тому +78

    Chanakya is great political philosopher i love him❤❤

  • @prosenjhanjh2362
    @prosenjhanjh2362 Рік тому +69

    One who protected this country nd one who divided this motherland 😊

    • @thepriest8694
      @thepriest8694 Рік тому

      ♥️♥

    • @dinumitragarhawli7534
      @dinumitragarhawli7534 Рік тому

      अधूरा ज्ञान विष के समान होता है|
      आप चन्द्र गुप्त तो हैं नहीं कि आपको चाणक्य रोज थोड़ा थोड़ा जहर दे रहे हों, जहर का असर कम करने के लिए|

    • @ArunSingh-nc7ol
      @ArunSingh-nc7ol Рік тому +1

      Absulately true

  • @ritukiran
    @ritukiran Рік тому +11

    Krishna says in Bhagavad Gita - "take 100% responsibility for your karma - only then you will meet yourself" :)

  • @shivanshpandey9402
    @shivanshpandey9402 Рік тому +11

    "Hide your strength and bide your time" crux of vedio
    One of the best way to explain both the legends of India...
    Thanks a lot Shashank sir for this superb presentation.

  • @ayazbaba1112
    @ayazbaba1112 Рік тому +47

    Reaching Chanakya's reach can only be imagined

    • @Thepatriot8356
      @Thepatriot8356 Рік тому

      आचार्य चाणक्य ने roman rule से भारत को बचाया था देश की रियासतों को एकजुट करके चंद्रगुप्त को चक्रवती सम्राट बनाकर।वरना मुस्लिम रूल से पहले हम रोमन बन चुके होते।

    • @zova3674
      @zova3674 Рік тому +1

      Aur tune chanakya toh Pada bhi nahi hoga🤣🤣🤣

  • @PankajKumar-ui1ed
    @PankajKumar-ui1ed Рік тому +25

    Desh ko akand karne wala aur khand karne Wale me kaisi tulna sir❤😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @FreeTibetFreeBalochistan
    @FreeTibetFreeBalochistan Рік тому +34

    If chanakyake ji was alive we would never have seen the concept of Pakistan, or ww1 and ww2 india would be independent. Ghandi only delayed our independence. His non violence costed us lots of lives and years to gain independence, also his moves seems more advantageous to britishers than indians.

    • @Shaktisingh84599
      @Shaktisingh84599 Рік тому +1

      Bhai ky baat kar raha hai, amar thodi the chanakyake😅

    • @civictheories9670
      @civictheories9670 Рік тому +1

      Did before British whole of India was one unit as per say in 1500 ? Gandhiji brought political unification among princely states ,British Indian territories ,he enlightened Indians that they are not free so stop criticising Gandhiji if you are unable to understand gandhism

    • @faug5299
      @faug5299 Рік тому +3

      @@civictheories9670 wo itna mahaan to partrion kyu nhi rok paya

    • @civictheories9670
      @civictheories9670 Рік тому

      @@faug5299 Pehle partition k spelling Sikh lo ,r ha Pehle ancient history se start karo thora ,ir se start karna partition hardcore tmhare jaisa hard liner jo religion dikhta hai uske Karan hua hai

    • @faug5299
      @faug5299 Рік тому

      Partion two nation theory ki hi upar bna tha

  • @Manish_kumar4297
    @Manish_kumar4297 Рік тому +1

    🙏आपके विचार रखने के तरीके के कायल हैं हम
    ❤ बिहार से हम🙏
    जय हिंद गुरुजी 🙏

  • @shivanisompura5
    @shivanisompura5 Рік тому +18

    I am incredibly grateful for the opportunity to learn from you, sir. Your teaching style is engaging, and you effortlessly break down complex concepts into understandable parts. This session was truly enlightening!!!

  • @weall2031
    @weall2031 Рік тому +9

    Gandhiji and Chanakya are two distinct personalities. They are assets for Bharat. Jai Bharat, Jai Maa Kali

  • @sanoj5601
    @sanoj5601 Рік тому +1

    Maza aa gaya awesome , sochne ka naya tarika pta chala ek dum mastt 🔥

  • @tanmoyroy3340
    @tanmoyroy3340 Рік тому +42

    Gandhi is nothing beside CHANAKYA

  • @GOURAVKUMAR-kx2lw
    @GOURAVKUMAR-kx2lw Рік тому +2

    Madhyam Marg sir jee behtareen hai, situation dekhte huye dono ne apne vichar diye the and Hume bhi situation ke anusar Kam karna chahiye I think both are great. Sbse achhi bat yahi lagi ki dusro par dosharopan nahi karni chahiye apni aatmashakti par karya karni chahiye

  • @astronplato
    @astronplato Рік тому +21

    Chanakya is and always be the best philosopher of politics ---- Gandh unke per ki dhoowan bi nai h

    • @premdaheriya8455
      @premdaheriya8455 Рік тому +2

      आपने फिर गांधी को नहीं पड़ा है

    • @PULKITKATARA
      @PULKITKATARA 9 місяців тому +1

      Nhi 😂😂​@AkashSharma-gb3pv

  • @enjoywithabhi8171
    @enjoywithabhi8171 Рік тому +42

    No british agent can stand in front of our pride chanakya

    • @powerfull8338
      @powerfull8338 Рік тому +4

      😂😂😂 fully brainwashed 😂😂

    • @enjoywithabhi8171
      @enjoywithabhi8171 Рік тому +7

      @@powerfull8338 wanna debate over this statement of mine!

  • @shivanshpandey9402
    @shivanshpandey9402 Рік тому +9

    "या" का concept नहीं होना चाहिए, "और" का concept होना चाहिए। अर्थात् गांधी या चाणक्य में से किसी एक को नहीं बल्कि गांधी और चाणक्य दोनों के जीवन से हमें सीख कर आगे बढ़ना चाहिए।।

  • @Shekhar-d7e
    @Shekhar-d7e Рік тому +8

    Deep knowledge & analysis is needed to connect two personalities...
    Great video Sir.

    • @Thepatriot8356
      @Thepatriot8356 Рік тому

      आचार्य चाणक्य ने roman rule से भारत को बचाया था देश की रियासतों को एकजुट करके चंद्रगुप्त को चक्रवती सम्राट बनाकर।वरना मुस्लिम रूल से पहले हम रोमन बन चुके होते।

  • @ritukiran
    @ritukiran Рік тому +2

    EXCELLENT lecture sir! Mazaa agaya sunkar!! Appka tarq excellent hota hai and you are well read!

  • @dr.tusharsonar5964
    @dr.tusharsonar5964 7 місяців тому

    Great explaination and analysis by Shashank Tyagi ji !

  • @sonukumar-ic8hc
    @sonukumar-ic8hc Рік тому +5

    Sir I wait for your lacturer specially on geopolitics

  • @rakshitmehrotra
    @rakshitmehrotra Рік тому +1

    Just ended up watching your full video and I am impressed with your teaching style as you have lucidly explained everything. Although I am not a civil services aspirant, I am sure all your students are very lucky to have you as your mentor. Good job 👍

  • @bhavik12342003
    @bhavik12342003 Рік тому +3

    Shsshank Sir, will you make a video on "Chanakya Neeti" and its possible uses in today's context?

  • @VijaySharma-rj3iy
    @VijaySharma-rj3iy Рік тому +6

    What a fine joke ? No comparison between Raja Bhoj & Gangoo Bai Telin

  • @shengdane
    @shengdane Рік тому +1

    Hope both of these ideas lead india towards an ideal path...❤

  • @nextbigthing2001
    @nextbigthing2001 Рік тому +20

    Basically Gandhiji was more like Lord Ram and and Acharya Chanakya was like Lord Krishna. An Individual person should follow Gandhiji but for a leader of a nation , or specifically a nation should follow Chankya. If Gandhiji was an ideological saint then Chankya was one of the greatest philosophers and politicians of all time.
    In conclusion, Chanakya was by far a greater mind than Gandhiji.

    • @Thepatriot8356
      @Thepatriot8356 Рік тому

      आचार्य चाणक्य ने roman rule से भारत को बचाया था देश की रियासतों को एकजुट करके चंद्रगुप्त को चक्रवती सम्राट बनाकर।वरना मुस्लिम रूल से पहले हम रोमन बन चुके होते।

    • @surajshradharasmitabehera6587
      @surajshradharasmitabehera6587 Рік тому

      Ram ji to ravan ko mara he. Ravan age ahinsa kya hota kya hota . Agar ko dusman apaka kisi lady ristedar rape karne karega to kya karoge aap.Gandhiji ka baat sunoge kya

    • @nextbigthing2001
      @nextbigthing2001 Рік тому

      Jsb

  • @abhishek_arra
    @abhishek_arra Рік тому +1

    Thanks for sharing this video 🙂🙏

  • @Rahul.0076
    @Rahul.0076 Рік тому +2

    Great Teacher ❤ On UA-cam

  • @KingsterEntertainmentVlog
    @KingsterEntertainmentVlog 10 місяців тому

    Your teaching methods so fantastic ❤ jai hind sir or theory ka lecture ligiyea

  • @forgers287
    @forgers287 Рік тому +1

    Very good lecture .
    I learn a lot from this topic

  • @gaurishshukla1
    @gaurishshukla1 8 місяців тому

    So nice explanation ❤

  • @kartikeshsaurkar4353
    @kartikeshsaurkar4353 Рік тому

    Excellent teaching.
    I wish I could have learnt history & philosophy from you in my school days.

  • @Bishnoi-ly1qj
    @Bishnoi-ly1qj Рік тому +1

    Sir you are wonderful teacher...one day you will be known for PSIR just like shubhra ranjan mam

  • @samirbhuyan6830
    @samirbhuyan6830 Рік тому

    Great sir🙏

  • @PiyushRaj-em3sp
    @PiyushRaj-em3sp Місяць тому

    "History is witness that idealists have always failed to implement their ideology and bring real change to the world, whereas realists have managed to do so."

  • @saimajahan719
    @saimajahan719 Рік тому

    Thanks sir bhot achi lgi class

  • @worldview5433
    @worldview5433 Рік тому +12

    Mohan Das stands nowhere near Acharya Chanakya

  • @crazyforcooking764
    @crazyforcooking764 Рік тому +1

    Thank you
    Your videos are important
    Please make. a video on Modi ji
    Is he doing good or bad

  • @Gyan_with_me0
    @Gyan_with_me0 Місяць тому

    जय हिंद sir ❤❤❤❤❤🎉❤❤❤❤❤

  • @sidhartkumar621
    @sidhartkumar621 Рік тому +1

    Mind-blowing ❤

  • @HarshSahu-eu8zw
    @HarshSahu-eu8zw Рік тому +17

    Meanwhile Subhash Chandra Bose ,hitler and krantikari is laughing at corner😂😂😂😂😂

  • @pavanchoudhary60
    @pavanchoudhary60 Рік тому

    Gud sir ❤ salute

  • @HarshSahu-eu8zw
    @HarshSahu-eu8zw Рік тому +7

    dharm ki jit hoti hai to terrorist meanwhile islamic terrorist and Britisher laughing at corner 😂😂😂😂

  • @HideandSeek11
    @HideandSeek11 Рік тому

    Excellent presentation 👏

  • @Dr.AryamanAbhisekBiswal
    @Dr.AryamanAbhisekBiswal Рік тому +5

    Gandhi is highly overrated. He was an average politician. I give him credit for trying to unite the country but that's it. We didn't get independence because of Gandhi. It's not very difficult to understand

    • @durga1983
      @durga1983 5 місяців тому

      He made a plan

  • @manasbagar183
    @manasbagar183 Рік тому +2

    Vry deep ❤

  • @karsanrathva7275
    @karsanrathva7275 Рік тому +1

    My perspective is that we want to both stretegy are important bcz of every country can collaboration so we can growth as well economic factors such as all others are responsible their so that way my own views 🙏

  • @ClearHearth
    @ClearHearth Рік тому +7

    कहा राजा भोज कहा गंगू तेली|

  • @pradeeppanda2073
    @pradeeppanda2073 Рік тому

    Very good sir

  • @zeolitasherigara611
    @zeolitasherigara611 Рік тому +1

    Nice topic sir thank you ❤❤

  • @akhimlachang7677
    @akhimlachang7677 Рік тому

    The two great real human whose teachings still influence the minds of millions.

  • @sandipsahu1419
    @sandipsahu1419 Рік тому +3

    चाणक्य के समय में जिन क्षेत्रों को एक किया गया था,
    महात्मा गांधी ने उसे देश से अलग कर दिया ।
    चाणक्य एकीकरण
    गांधी विभाजन
    तुलना नही हो सकता

  • @pure_heart_words5567
    @pure_heart_words5567 9 місяців тому

    The promises that were made in the past were the compulsions of the past, those that were broken today are the necessity of today.

  • @RahulJagtap14
    @RahulJagtap14 Рік тому +5

    I like Chanakya only.

  • @krishnagupta4643
    @krishnagupta4643 Рік тому +10

    Gandhiji was the greatest personality ever india has..
    None could match his stature..
    A deadly combination of statesman, patriot, saint

    • @Robin-il4ev
      @Robin-il4ev Рік тому +7

      Hmm Apni Poti ke saath Nanga sone wla Saint( Autobiography) . Aisa patriot ki Ambedkar ne bahot achhi baatein likhi Hain Usske baate mein

    • @chandrakant1837
      @chandrakant1837 Рік тому

      ​@@Robin-il4evso what?What was poona pact? Wasn't for Hindus.

    • @singhabhi.16e
      @singhabhi.16e Рік тому +1

      Lol...😂😂🤣🤣

  • @bhagyashree8719
    @bhagyashree8719 Рік тому +1

    Gandhi's सर्वोदय is a idealistic thought and it can be realistic by people's and State's efforts❤

  • @Rocket_T2
    @Rocket_T2 Рік тому +1

    Has someone read "those" chapters from The Story of My Experiments with Truth

  • @nareshkumarbansal5985
    @nareshkumarbansal5985 Рік тому

    Marvelous

  • @sangharshcivilservice2661
    @sangharshcivilservice2661 11 місяців тому

    मजा आ गया sir ji

  • @devasinghpannu545
    @devasinghpannu545 Рік тому +1

    सर गाँधी जी के बह्मचर्य प्रयोगो का विश्लेषण कीजिए हर टीचर इस टॉपिक से बचता रहता है

  • @crimsonlyyours
    @crimsonlyyours Рік тому

    Great comparative perspective for psir

  • @bittutamang4390
    @bittutamang4390 Рік тому +3

    Gandhi ji is a great scholar but can't compare with chanakya,if he is so great why he permits to create Pakistan ???

  • @Payal-gg3xm
    @Payal-gg3xm Рік тому +2

    Best one

  • @madhusudanmuley7545
    @madhusudanmuley7545 Рік тому +3

    Kuch bhi 😂😂 Acharya Chanakya se kisi ka bhi comparison kr doge 🤣

  • @arnabgoswami522
    @arnabgoswami522 Рік тому

    Jai Hind

  • @maniksharma1403
    @maniksharma1403 Рік тому +2

    Got Goosebumps sir
    Hats off

  • @thepriest8694
    @thepriest8694 Рік тому +1

    एक करने के लिए चाहे समाज हो या राष्ट्र अथक प्रयत्न आवश्यक हैं - चाहे वह चाणक्य के हों चाहे मोदी के ! वहीं तोडने, टुकडे करने या टुकडों में बांट कर आटा-साटा करने के लिए चाहे वह समाज हो या राष्ट्र हो गांधी होना ही काफी है

  • @himansusabar5206
    @himansusabar5206 Рік тому +2

    Mk Gandhi is just a appeaser..
    There is no comparison between chanakya and mk Gandhi

  • @kalingaRanjan1889
    @kalingaRanjan1889 Рік тому +1

    Chanakya greatest of all time

  • @tanzinmanurigzin3258
    @tanzinmanurigzin3258 10 місяців тому

    Both ware great Indian .

  • @youtubejs-kl3xo
    @youtubejs-kl3xo Рік тому +1

    One was responsible for the creation of greatest empire of that time & another presided over partition of motherland.

  • @Amitt2009
    @Amitt2009 7 місяців тому +1

    Sir Acharya Chanakya ka koi barabari nhi kr sakhta....with due respect Gandhiji ko bass bhukh hartaal karna aata tha jaise aajkal biwiya karti hai manwane k liye

  • @sachisagane4071
    @sachisagane4071 Рік тому +1

    Dono desh ke Masiha hai 🎉🎉🎉

  • @vishalmishra8608
    @vishalmishra8608 Рік тому +3

    Chanakya ki tulna puri vishwa me ek hi vyakti se ho sakti hai vo hai Macedonia ka Aristotle bass aur kisi ki aukaat nahi hai aacharya chanakya se tulna karne ki

  • @Zerotoleader
    @Zerotoleader Рік тому +1

    Gandi had more love humanity , socialism and spiritualism. Jad se system me problem solve . Like aurvedic but Chanakya had only agressive, allopathic medicine, it's need temporary pain. Because we are human meterialstic. We have indriya family emotions not sadhu Mahatma.

  • @avikdey6818
    @avikdey6818 Рік тому +3

    After hearing i am still alive mtfckr 😮

  • @aks5697
    @aks5697 Рік тому +3

    Gandhiji is best❤

  • @plvalue4970
    @plvalue4970 Рік тому +2

    Gandi aur chankya , kya baat krte ho bhai , is baat pe to tmhare sochne k capability pr sawaal uthne lagega , us samay k log ek bhed k group jaise the aur gandi sabse aage chalne wala bhed , agar wo kua me koodne ka nirnay kr liye to sab koodne ko taiyaar ho jaate the bina soche samjhe bina knowledge media aur Information transformation k abhaav ki wajah se gandi unke liye bhagwaan bn gya tha Jo kah de sab sahi h , agar koi aadmi jis ghar me rah raha h us Ghar me do bete h , aur ghar ka batwara hota h to gandi pahle bete ko aadhe ghar ki poori jameen uske naam kr deta h aur dusra beta jo bahut seedha ho gandi bol de uspe bhedo ki tarah believe krta h use kuchh nhi milta use bol Diya jata h ki tm to seedhe ho tm kya karoge apna kuchh bna kr , pahla beta aadhe ghar ki jameen lene k baad bhi bolta h baaki ke aadhe ghar me bhi Mera hissa h , gandi ne apne dusre bete se is baar kuchh poocha hi nhi kyuki wo to bhedo ki tarah gandi ji pr yakeen krta tha unhone pahle bete se bina argument kiye use bol dete h ki theek h tm dusre Wale ki jameen me bhi aake rah sakte ho to pahle bhi to sath me hi dono poore Ghar me rahte the to batwaare ki jaroorat kya thi ye baat gandi k palle nhi padi kya wo itna Kam dimag tha ya phir uska pahla beta apne baap pe gya tha do hi chheze nikal k aa sakti h aur 😅funny baat ye h ki usi dusre bete ki generation aaj use rastrapita bulaati h usi dusre bete ki generation uske asmark banwa k har saal sraddhanjali dene se lekar note me photo chhapwane se lekar coaching me teachers dwara bina kisi analysis k Bharat k mahaan koot nitigya aur apne tej dimag se bade bade samrajya ko dhool me milaane se lekar phir se ek mahaan samrajya banane Wale se us dhoort gandi ko jisne apne hi parivaar(bhed) k haq k liye ladne ki bajaaye unhi peeth peeche chhora Marne Wale ko compare kr raha h , isse aapki mansikta aur tark karne ki chhamta pr uthta h ki ye mansikta padhe likhe logo me kyu aa jati h , aap logo ko kyu lagta h ki har wo cheez aap bachho ko samjha sakte h jo aapne apni mehnat se kitabo se padhi h aur wo paragraph kisi k stamp lagaane aur kisi teacher k believe krne se sahi ho jata h

  • @shyamalkumarsowmondal7704
    @shyamalkumarsowmondal7704 Рік тому

    Jay Siya ram

  • @pankajpuri9833
    @pankajpuri9833 Рік тому +3

    Gurudev chankya ki tulna is gaddar se....y Kya mazak hai 🤬🤬

  • @MrStudd007
    @MrStudd007 Рік тому +5

    Yes absolutely Gandhi ji great than Chanakya but Chanakya was also great

  • @manojkr.basumatary182
    @manojkr.basumatary182 Рік тому

    Lage raho Munnabhai

  • @Kkkushwah7905
    @Kkkushwah7905 Рік тому +1

    Chanakya is a fictional character I think there is no chanakya exists in our history

    • @googlesharma4477
      @googlesharma4477 Рік тому +2

      Toh aap apna perspective rakho na

    • @googlesharma4477
      @googlesharma4477 Рік тому +2

      Jitna chanakya ne baat btayi h arthshastra mein utna aap akele apne poore jivan mein nhi soch sakte . Unki book padhiye kaafi gyaan milega aapko jo aapke aage aane wali life mein kaafi kaam dega

    • @AnuragThakur1
      @AnuragThakur1 Місяць тому

      ​@@googlesharma4477Abe ye kushwaha hai dimag nhi hai isme jatiwad bhara hai!!

  • @atanusardar700
    @atanusardar700 Рік тому +1

    Kothai kashmiri wool r kothai bogoler chul

  • @swapanghosh9867
    @swapanghosh9867 Рік тому

    Evil? Was that word unnecessary...no people would allow it for the simple reason images are like the fears one has example...shadow boxing...ha ha h!

  • @studywith_np85
    @studywith_np85 Рік тому

  • @124_vishaltaware8
    @124_vishaltaware8 7 місяців тому

    Kya israel ne arthsatstra padhi hai

  • @akkhan4176
    @akkhan4176 Рік тому +1

    Gandi was great and constructivist ❤❤❤

  • @PRASHANTKADARAKOPPA
    @PRASHANTKADARAKOPPA 8 місяців тому

    No

  • @starksuman
    @starksuman Рік тому

    BRUhhhhhhhhhh.................................

  • @shashibala7034
    @shashibala7034 Рік тому +1

    Gandhi was equal to zero at front of chankya

    • @premdaheriya8455
      @premdaheriya8455 Рік тому

      गांधी ने चाणक्य को मात दे चुके हैं वो उनसे भी ज्यादा दूर दर्शी है भाई

  • @kashtaraiya
    @kashtaraiya Рік тому

    Chanakya is myth created by brahman

  • @saibalsahoo8597
    @saibalsahoo8597 Рік тому

    😅😅😅

  • @abhaysingh3328
    @abhaysingh3328 Рік тому

    Kuch bhi kuch bhi

  • @mhaya1
    @mhaya1 Рік тому

    Curse for bharat.

  • @joker_op_CR7
    @joker_op_CR7 Рік тому

    😂😂😂😂😂😂 nice joke

  • @ashwan_yadav
    @ashwan_yadav 11 місяців тому +1

    Chanakya is great