Will Israel be held accountable for its actions in Gaza? | Inside Story
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 тра 2024
- More bodies have been found in mass graves in Gaza after Israeli forces withdrew from the Nasser and Al Shifa medical compounds they had besieged for weeks.
The Palestinian Civil Defence says there is clear evidence the Israeli army committed crimes against humanity by carrying out summary executions.
The UN and EU are calling for urgent and investigations.
And The US says it wants answers, too.
But will Israel answer?
And how will it be held to account?
Presenter: Mohammed Jamjoom
Guests:
Mansour Shouman - Gaza Citizen Journalist who took refuge at Nasser Hospital for months during the conflict.
Andreas Kleiser - Director for Policy and Cooperation at the International Commission on Missing Persons.
Kenneth Roth - Visiting Professor at Princeton School for Public and International Affairs and the former Executive Director of Human Rights Watch.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#PalestinianCivilDefence #Palestine #Gaza #SouthernGaza #GazaMassGraves #KhanYounis #NasserMedicalComplex #GazaNasserHospital #GazaHospitals #GazaUnderAttack #GazaHumanitarianCrisis #Israel #IsraelHamasWar #GazaWar #IsraelWar #IsraelPalestineWar #IsraelGazaWar #IsraelWarCrimesInGaza #GazaBombardment #GazaRefugeeCamps #GazaGenocide
If Israel refused independent investigations this would equal an acknowledgement of guilt.
Even if independent investigation confirmed Israel atrocities, the west Will veto any penalty against them for sure!!!
Israel WILL do that. When have they ever allowed independent investigations. They don't allow international journos for Christs sake. And USA, UK, Germany, Canada will accept Israel doesn't need independent investigations.
They always refuse UN and private investigations.
U S and U K helped then since Balfour Declaration 2nd November 1917.
They're still helping them with arms, money and special troops.
U K spy drones are in the sky of Gaza, since 8th October. U S and France are providing special troops to Gaza, since 8th October. Infamous arms supplies from Germany.
Exactly. I find refusing investigation to be an even more conclusive marker of guilt than a conclusion of guilt from an investigation.
You are ignorant. It was reported many times at the time that the Hospital Staff buried those bodies there. You people are the reason that Palestinian is now synonymous with Liars, Scammers , Rapists and Baby killers. You are so stupid.
USA, and those who provide power to Israel should be accountable for this...
@@fairuzmaileen5691 yet you guys aren't advocating for the downfall of Iran. you know the who convinced the palestines they could take down Israel. I guess you should pick your friends more wisely.
@user-ft5vq1ki9y Iran leaders aren't trying to monopolize world's economy and resources. Extremist response is a consequence of this system, a system that creates monsters and then punishes innocent civilians👎
My responses are being deleted... wish you all well🌠truth will always prevail
What about Iran and Russia?? 😮
@@narharidas2528 shh. you can't mention who the real criminals are.
"U.S says it needs answers too" REALLY: ISN'T U.S THE ANSWER TO ALL THAT'S HAPPENING?????
They've always been the problem. Murderous white America!!
My government is the hypocrisy champs.
Absolutely YES.
Man are y'all conspiracy minded. If only there were some other thing you weren't considering, like... your own security.
Yes
Empire State of Liars and criminals
Pithy slogans is all you have. You know none of the history. You probably think Israel started the war of 1948.
@@benb6527 they didnt started in 1948 correct but continue untill now
Shameful world to let this atrocity continue
🦍🦍🦍🦍🐐🐐🐐
shame on hamas and radicals Muslim...shame on you commenting without thinking..😅😅😅
@@doglover5195my vocabulary is not as strong to comment what I feel. It's not just shame anymore.. We allowed this to not just 'happen' but 'continue'.
And then there are people who still talking about justifications and haters.
@@doglover5195 you must be a dog yourself...
@@doglover5195 - delusional, barking at the wrong trees!!
add oil....
Satan has truly showed who HIS SEEDS are in this world!
@@manikumar3996c o w worshipper is a satan
True, Revelation 3:9
You would marched with Hitler and his murderers!
@@manikumar3996 lindus are. Lindus like yourself. No wonder brits treated lindus like dogs
@@manikumar3996 That's lindus such as yourself.
HOW pathetic and wrong it is to ask the PERPETRATOR IF an investigation can be done!WTF!
Isreal is expected to investigate itself. Accountability is antisemitic
Lol
Serial killer doing an investigation.
Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity!
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Son of God are 2 titles one referring to the Word of God = God himself and one referring to creation (humans, angels, demons)
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*
Very Sick and inhuman to even think that the one who committed such crimes is asked to investigate themselves ... which world is this we are really living in???????
Israel and USA need to be held accountable... but we all have learnt that wont happen
Also UK and germay
The world knows how evil these two countries are. I’m American and ashamed of my country.
By who? Grow up.
@@mohammedmuktarbutt5419and France
@@LadieKadie all empires fall eventually.
the golden age of IMPUNITY is over...
Ha ha ha
See for yourself who are the human animals.
The fact that you need to ask Israel for permission to enter the strip to do testing is all you need to hear..Israel would never allow this...If you truly want answers you need to force the issue..US will always keep arming and protecting Israel..
Dictating Terms & Holding Humanity Hostage it's F@king outrageous 💔
@Vader - apt to summon Russia and China to interdict!!
@@ngkeam9491I agree if you’re saying let the Chinese and the Russians investigate.
The fact they refuse the investigation makes them guilty of torture and buriying people alive. Its beyond words.
Refusing investigation makes them guilty.
The US should be charged as a co conspirator to this.
Blame Biden.
I have no words! Money, greediness,power have taken human heart. How can human beings come this?
+ 23 years of anti-musli propaganda since 9/11. Europe is full of it.
Have you ever took history class?? You might learn thing or two
You forgot the children and the elderly that Hamas kidnapped and maybe the Israelis are looking for them and rightly so.
When I see any child or an innocent person being killed it is heartbreaking but what choices did Israel have after that terrible massacre.
Every country in the world would have reacted the same way.
I blame Hamas for what's going on in Gaza. When rockets are fired at Israel, they have the Iron dome.
The Billions that Hamas have they could have protected their people but instead they allowed them to become human shields and that is unforgivable.
@@Petal4822si don't get your rationale that killing hospital patients and fill them. In ground, how were they human shields? The Hamas was hiding under their bed?
What makes you think that Hamas is responsible?
Please save Palestinian please save Gaza.
Israelis are saving the world...
@@manikumar3996How exactly? By killing everyone in sight?
@@manikumar3996by murdering children? lol 😆
Amen!
@@manikumar3996
Israelies have been brainwashed into thinking like the racist Zionist nazis . The last time I checked that didn't go well for everyone.
This is horrible! I cannot believe these atrocities are being justified
They always were, since Balfour Declaration 2nd November 1917.
They will never be justified
Free Palestinians… open the border into Egypt. What choices did Israel have after that terrible massacre.
Every country in the world would have responded the same way.
I blame Hamas for what's going on in Gaza.
The Billions that Hamas have they could have protected their people but instead they allowed them to become human shields and that is unforgivable.
@@Petal4822trying justifying this everywhere? Doesn‘t work.
I have my own history of slavery in America..my father was a share cropper, we were extremely poor. However i have never witness such evil in my life!! Actually witnessing it in real time is much different than reading about it!!
These people are the same you've read about.
These people were Slave owners and owners of slave ships too.
@@FRESHKIDD23BRO@ what people are you talking about
Free Palestinians… open the border into Egypt. What choices did Israel have after that terrible massacre.
Every country in the world would have responded the same way.
I blame Hamas for what's going on in Gaza.
The Billions that Hamas have they could have protected their people but instead they allowed them to become human shields and that is unforgivable.
@@Petal4822 @ you have to be kidding the worlds population with a excuse like this to justify Genocide but don't worry keep watching because those very occupiers are Finished. GOD is not MOCKED 🤔
Mansour's clearcut message: TIME IS RUNNING OUT.
Israel MUST be brought to JUSTICE!!
After she finishes bringing Hamas and its partners to justice.
@@user-ul9cf7so6jYou got a like too. Shame on both of you.
Hello aljazera it’s stop spreading lies hospital staff buried those died because under blockade
Israel AND the American government - my government - MUST be brought to JUSTICE!!
@@user-ul9cf7so6j
Criminals will always side with other criminals. From their words you shall know them.
Alright that’s it , humanity is finished .
It NEVER WAS.
IT WAS & STILL IS LIP SERVICE.
CANNOT TRUST HUMAN BEINGS EVER AGAIN.
Will Syria?Yemen?
Not just humanity, this world is finished.
For those who are religious or spiritual, it's clear after this that we have been abandoned by the Heavens. The Heavens saw the descent of humanity into evil, and we have been forsaken.
US and UK administration has to be held accountable for this genocide due to their support and weaponary supply periodly
Yes
Agreed 😢😢😢
Well, all thier history are built on colonization, what to expect?
Agree
Biden must be made accountable, prison for life.
The first entity that should be held accountable is US GOVERNMENT
Agreed 💯
When I see any child or an innocent person being killed it is heartbreaking but what choices did Israel have after that terrible massacre.
Every country in the world would have reacted the same way.
I blame Hamas for what's going on in Gaza. When rockets are fired at Israel, they have the Iron dome.
The Billions that Hamas have they could have protected their people but instead they allowed them to become human shields and that is unforgivable.
@@Petal4822sure, one day justifies burying alive, torture. 7 months. Trying to act non biased?
@@Petal4822 Look at your own SICK reasonings!!! GENOCIDAL ENABLER!! EACH CHILD BEING KILLED WITH YOUR APPROVAL TOO!!! SICK!
@@Petal4822give proof? only got proof of palestinians tied to idf tanks.
Independent investigators MUST be in Gaza. I CANT BELIEVE Journalists are not ALLOWED IN GAZA.
If you‘re guilty you don‘t want investigations….
that is bc Hamas are famous for their propoganda ,palestines lies would be exposed..
How can any country stand by and support what is going on in Gaza and also the West Bank. Shameful. 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
As long as Israel exist this will not end.
Agree they should not exist. Tremendous mistake by British letting them reside in israel
As long as you exist it will not end.
The Balfour dekl. , dumb idea.
@@user-ul9cf7so6jresorting to personal insults now? Getting hard to justify.
Israel has NO right to exist, PERIOD !
If we cannot investigate anything now, imagine when there are hundreds of thousands murdered in Rafah?
Condemnation will only be in the hearts of all of us who are morally hurt by the Israeli crimes against Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank/Jerusalem.
Look at the Srebrenica cemetery in the background! So many innocents...
Bravo, so we'll said! Thankyou❤
Shame on world
I can't still believe this is actually happening somewhere in Gaza. When I see the bodies, I think it's from a movie 😢
alot of what we see on the news is altered and staged,,,those people are well know for that.
Thank you Al Jaseera. Mansour-your heart is speaking clearly and loudly 🙏we all see the truth ... the ones who "don't" are simply LYING 🤬
The question is who is going to hold Israel accountable for Gaza genocide and mass graves under the hospital. The Arab world? No. Are Arab ready to take in Palestinian, No. World has abandoned people of Phalistine as rodents. Shame on every country that is watching as bystanders.
Rodents? Ok. That works.
Les palestiniens ne veulent pas être accueillis, ils veulent rester chez eux
Shame on you, sorry excuse for a Zionist! Rodents? Full-Blown psychopaths refer to people as rodents, btw!
Don't you understand what you are saying is exactly what Israel wants. If the palistinians leave Gaza. They will never be able to go back home. Millions of palistinians live in surrounding counties. They are not a allowed to return to there motherland. Zionism is a plague that is destroying humanity.
Rodents?
Well let me break some old news for you, Arab leaders are literally under the thumb of the U S. Ever since Egypt's Peace treaty was signed in 1978.
DO NOT dehumanise the honourable Palestinian People of Palestine.
They already suffered enough since Balfour Declaration 2nd November 1917.
The further you and your peers dehumanise the resilient brave Palestinian People, the more you prove your monstrous mindset.
Missing organs are we talking about a Mass body harvesting event?
Obviously!!!
Israel has the largest skin bank in the world .
They have the biggest skin grafts bank in the world. There was a 12 year old boy who was taken by Idee Effe and he said he was injected with something that made him sleep for 2 days . When he was awakened he had a surgical staples where his liver should be .
@@supernova7848
Yes you’re right. I saw the photos.
Witchcraft 🧙♀️
Israel has deeply disturbed me throughout my life from my youth in the 1950s , I am astounded how generations have been turning a blind eye to their never ending brutality against Palestinian’s .
Just look at the level of fakeness their organizations that are allowed to operate in US have.
The international community might want to reconsider Israels membership status.
In your dreams
Humanity should reconsider their membership.
That's not how it works. You understand that North Korea is a member of the UN? You understand that China is actively engaged in genocide against the Uyghur and they are a PERMANENT member of the UN security council. You understand that Russia is currently engaged in real genocide against the Ukrainians and they are also a PERMANENT member of the UN security council. ARAB-MUSLIM SUDANESE are currently genociding Black African Durfuris, no one cares. Everyone is doing it, but you only care about the single Jewish state. Don't you rind that a tad bit sus? No, because you will rationalize your hatred, as all racists do.
@@kezianartey6372
Israeli Hasbara?
It has to be an independent investigation.
If this isn’t followed by trial and prison then there is no justice. The courts are useless. Barb
🦍🦍🦍🦍🐐🐐🐐🐐
The Nuremburg trial should be used as a guideline
Excellent, knowledgeable guests.
Mansour Shouman 🙏❤
Hero in humanity!
Thank you.
Shame on USA
USA THE COUNTRY THAT IN 2ND WARTIME WERE SO RESPECTED. IS THIS THE SAME USA. THE GUYS WITH THE GUM FOR THE KIDDIES
Nothing is covered up that will not be revealed, or hidden that will not be known.
[Luke 12:2]
The most moral army im the world showing their morals yet again😮😮😮
Organs missing? What the h4ll?!
The world NEEDS an INDEPENDENT investigation defend human rights and prevent atrocities on a global scale. If Israel has nothing to hide, they shouldn’t protest independent investigation into this. 💔🇵🇸
Independent??? Israel will not allow anyone or group into Gaza.
Refusing is confessing.
Thank you south africa ❤❤❤❤❤
This is not vengeance, it is madness.
In the book 'OVER THEIR DEAD BODIES', MEIRA WEISS an Israeli doctor, claimed that organs were taken from dead Palestinians between 1996 and 2002 and used in medical research in Israeli hospitals and also TRANSPLANTED INTO ISRAELI PATIENTS.
This is against Geneva codes and it's pretty recent. Other countries are doing fine without illegal organ removal & illegal land robbing. Shame on Isreal. Are their people aware of this? Or is it a norm for them to dehumanise ppl to that extent?...
@abacus ThankYou for this information. This is so EVIL, these devils need to be stopped!
It is enough of "more of the same". Immediate ceasefire, humanitarian backup in Rafah....and urgent independent investigation on the scale of these war crimes.
This is beyond ridiculous how humans can be so cruel!
Yes look at October the 7th it's absolutely unbelievable
Free Palestinians… open the border into Egypt. What choices did Israel have after that terrible massacre.
Every country in the world would have responded the same way.
I blame Hamas for what's going on in Gaza.
The Billions that Hamas have they could have protected their people but instead they allowed them to become human shields and that is unforgivable.
@@andy9102 you're saying its ok to slaughter civilians and children. "what about october 7?" What about the lies about the baby beheadings? People are seeing how untrustworthy israel is. Thay lie and constantly deflect and project. The party is over for israel. The world see who the real aggressors and its israel. Ive seen vidoes where jewish settlers are stealing Palestinian familys homes. Also Rachel Corrie incident RIP, and the idf cowards couldnt take responsibility for running her ovr with a bulldozer while...........stealing Palestinian lands by demolishing their homes with said bulldozers....
oh then theres the USS Liberty incident where your precious Israel attacked American military and many servicemen died.....I could go on and on about that corrupt state (israel). The constant foot on the neck of the Pa;estinians is sick .. I could go on and on with facts about how your beloved israel acts
@@Petal4822 Spot on!
Israel will never be held accountable as long as nations are treating Israel as a holy cow. Sadly, I think Mansour is right.
💯
This is such an utter disgrace
The only one that is more than capable to ensure justice without doubt for Palestinians is Allah alone, just put your trust on HIM
Allah is a demon
Yes Absolutely
In your dreams
This is Allan´s justice..... ??
@@thomashelbo1432 of course, he is punishing hamas supporters aka palestinians
Mansour is absolutely RIGHT ❤ 🇵🇸
GOD sees and knows who are wrong and who are right and KARMA is REAL
I NEVER thought I would see this sort of atrocities after Hitler. And what makes it worse is that Israel is the culprit. Shame on the world that is allowing Israel to get away with such atrocities.
This is just the beginning. i could only imagine what more will be uncovered when this is all over.
Exactly 😢this is horrific we are being so emotionally and mentally affected by this evil I mean the whole world.
@@julibrown6984No, we're not, it's just you.
@@JackFieldBandcongratulations your a sociopath 😁👍🏻
@@JackFieldBandher and Millions of others. Like me!
Free Palestinians… open the border into Egypt. What choices did Israel have after that terrible massacre.
Every country in the world would have responded the same way.
I blame Hamas for what's going on in Gaza. The terrible suffering going on in Gaza while Egypt keeps its doors shut.
The Billions that Hamas have they could have protected their people but instead they allowed them to become human shields and that is unforgivable.
YOU CAN'T have what's NOT yours STEP DOWN and GET OUT NOW Thank you 🌹
body parts total criminal idf war crimes need to be accountable
El karma existe y espero que actue pronto sobre el llamado " pueblo de Dios "
If these acts are not categorized as war crimes, then we wouldn't know what justice is.
I'm hoping Al J will look into Israel's big Skin and Organ Market. This has been happening since 1986.
Any objection for Int'l investigations must be considered acknowledgement
Today, Israel is sitting on top of the world-untouchable. This is very sad, as this is the 21st century, not the dark ages of the past! Remember that in the end, there is an unbiased, final judgment in God's decisions.
For the sins of all of humanity's collective inaction and failure to stop this, the entire world is punished for our indifference. The Zionists' actions and the ensuing indifference of the world has doomed us all. I am sure the natural disasters that have been increasing in frequency the past few years, those will only get worse before things get better. These natural disasters are the hand of God, a manifestation of God's discontent with the blindness of humanity to the truth and our race blindly following the sinful path of indifference and egoism.
The entire Israeli nation must take full responsibility for this atrocity...
people who believe they are chosen by God will never be held responsible. Admitting any wrongdoing implies God is wrong which is impossible.
Israel don’t accept Jesus Christ us their savior so they never have a peace
All religion needs to be cancelled
The fact that you need to ask Israel for permission to enter the strip to do testing is all you need to hear
اللهم احفظ أهل فلسطين والمسجد الأقصى من كيد الظالمين وأيدهم بنصرك وقوتك.
Free Palestinians… open the Rafah border into Egypt. What choices did Israel have after that terrible massacre.
Every country in the world would have responded the same way.
I blame Hamas for what's going on in Gaza. The terrible suffering in Gaza while Egypt turns its back and keeps its doors shut.
The Billions that Hamas have they could have protected their people but instead they allowed them to become human shields and that is unforgivable.
This is a disgrace Palestine must be free of this occupation
Free Palestine from HAMAS. Enough of this war.
The testimony of the Gaza Citizen journalist Mansour Shouman needs to be seen and heard everywhere.
If you can only watch one news broadcast at the moment, choose this one.
We need a new UN with new laws. The current body has lost its credibility.
Again they are literally having Freddy Krueger and Jason investigating their crimes . Are you kidding me
Silence worse than committing crime...
Silence is complicity.
What kind of explanations is us government expecting exactly?
ICC useless..
That's true, because if they hold israel responsible they will have to hold hamas responsible too
@@kezianartey6372 Fine with me. Hamas committed some crimes, civs should be off limits, and Izzy has committed many, many more - 75 year crime spree.
@@tethergobrrr Hamas put out a statement months ago inviting an investigation of 10/7.
@@tethergobrrrIt may be fine with you, but it isn't fine for many in the UN.
@@tethergobrrryou spelt self defense wrong
Free Palestine
From Hamas? SURE! There own EVIL SEED, YES...indeed.
@@alp3781kinda lame
Free Palestinians… open the border into Egypt. What choices did Israel have after that terrible massacre.
Every country in the world would have responded the same way.
I blame Hamas for what's going on in Gaza.
The Billions that Hamas have they could have protected their people but instead they allowed them to become human shields and that is unforgivable.
@@Petal4822 Go and tell that to all these losers on the streets, these days. What a joke. People are losing it, I swear. S. media can be cancer!!!
America and UK should also be held responsible for aiding and abeding
Agree but biden has turned into netanyahus puppet. He would clean the blood off his hands
They created the monster..
When is The Hague going to act? Nothing but bureaucracy !!
hypocrites mad about the college campus protests against mass graves than against the mass graves themselves.
Well, Netanyahu has already declared himself as the 47 president of United States of America by calling for crackdown on students in the campus across us. Really 😊
Now for what ICJ is waiting for?
They are confused. The evidences say it was Hamas' fault😂
They're corrupt. Expect nothing.
They seem to be buying time for their Azrahell, U S and U K masters, until they finish Gaza.
UN, Security Council, ICC and ICJ belongs to Western imperialism.
The system was made to serve those who created it; not the rest of the world.
Permission?
Their just talking no action
All mouth, no action!!!!
Agreed 💯
What do you expect in Gaza after a people who calls others human animals? The global majority is not surprised of these mass graves
It’s time to BDS by every country.
Make it illegal to trade with is real.
🦍🦍🦍🦍🐐🐐🐐🐐
ولا تحسبن الله غافلا عما يعمل الظالمون
You mean hamas?
@@kezianartey6372since 8th October another genocide taking place in West Bank and East Jerusalem (where Kkkkhamas doesn't rule).
Go, find yourself another semi valid lie.
X I O N I S T HASBARA.
@@kezianartey6372mean Isreal
Al Jazeera English, Subscribed because your videos always make me smile!
Israel Court of Justice (ICJ), where are you?
@saee- not ICJ, its UNSC's actions to enforce the rulings!!
@@ngkeam9491 they are all Israel controlled 🎮. Doesn't matterm
These reports do not come up to CNN and MSNBC. We know why, do we?
Arabic-language CNN broadcasts protests in universities, while English-language CNN does not broadcast protests in universities. You can verify and compare to learn the extent of the hypocrisy of American media channels.
La Hawla Wa la quwwata illa bi Allah
Well what you expected when you give Israel weapons.
Believe plan for no of countries for oil
These LOVING FAMILIES killed for FOOD and PEACE it's WRONG STOP this NOW Thank you 🌹
Oh this will be ignored, and swept under the carpet, really sad indeec😢😢😢😢
Arabs only constitute 14% of the population of Israel but they donate 25.1% of all organs. ""FAMILIES OF ORGAN DONORS BETWEEN JEWS AND ARABS IN ISRAEL DURING A MILITARY OPERATION" ( Pdf. Taylor and Francis online)
Living through this sad moment in human history.
ICJ rulings been violated but they stood wait & see.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Truth always PREVAIL 💯...
The same masse grave wee found in Sinai after the war even long time after the war of 73. Mass grave for Egyptian soldiers. Same masse grave you can find in Tantura village ( Tantura massacre 1947-48). It is in their blood they knew how to cover up their crimes and the international community, international law is not working to prevent such Genocide it is even helping it to be done
If not, then its clear the law is just there to control the sheep
Freedom for humanity we humans stand with palastine ❤❤❤❤❤❤
No, never. When justice emerges from the turret of a tank, accountability
becomes a far cry.
UNITED NATIONS STAND UP STOP NATHANYAHU NOW Thank you 🌹
How cruel are these Zionists?