instead of just stating that he used the same chords, lets appreciate the fact he mananged to create 2 completely different legendary melodys/lyrics/songs over the same chords
yeah and i definitely think thats due to hit limited knowledge of musical theory. Anyone who understands proper chords and keys would never think of switching to e after starting the song with em7....because on paper it doesn't work....thats what made noel so good at songwriting...his ability to be able to feel the chords and melodys regardless of what they were
He’s a working class lad from Manchester, music theory lessons weren’t freely available. He’s mostly self taught and what’s he’s managed to do is nothing short of incredible
Incredible. The same chords and same rythm for 2 very different songs and the two are fantastic! Step of the train is gonna be the day that they re gonna all alone at dark. Because maybe... Youre gona be the met my maker...
Great version...a lot of the reason Be Here Now is slammed is unfair, just impossible expectations/Oasis burnout...but the other big reason is that there were some legitimately great tunes on it that were all but RUINED by overproduction, constant smothering in random unnecessary guitar riffs, soloing in the verses, overdubs, etc...so when you can hear the raw song like this exposed, it reveals the great song(s) that was there the whole time
Additional thoughts: Yeah, the acoustic version exposes how much the song does, and always did, use same chord structure as Wonderwall, but so what? Noel 'borrows' tons of riffs from other people, why not steal one from himself? Both songs can exist with similar riffs and still be good. But I also skip Wonderwall when I listen to "...Morning Glory" since it's so overplayed, so I'm biased. Also, I wish there were more like this, not necessarily acoustic, but somehow like "alternate" versions of Be Here Now songs without all the ridiculous guitar overdubs etc, stripped down, so we could here the album as it "should" have been...they should do a special edition where Noel goes back into the studio with the master tracks, guts out all the bullshit and puts it out..."Be Here Now...Naked" lol. Gotta write him a letter
I"m a musician and i adore Oasis, but this is embarassing! I couldn"t play this song anymore, because it"s literaly the same as "Wonderwall!" I mean it"s not against the law to copy your own song...D"YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN? 😆
instead of just stating that he used the same chords, lets appreciate the fact he mananged to create 2 completely different legendary melodys/lyrics/songs over the same chords
Cocaine Rain I appreciate the Pre-Chorus. He uses E7 and then goes to E.. that is hard to do, really.
yeah and i definitely think thats due to hit limited knowledge of musical theory. Anyone who understands proper chords and keys would never think of switching to e after starting the song with em7....because on paper it doesn't work....thats what made noel so good at songwriting...his ability to be able to feel the chords and melodys regardless of what they were
iemandmusic it's actually Esus4 but they both sound equally good
@@iemandmusica he goes from B7 to E actually
He’s a working class lad from Manchester, music theory lessons weren’t freely available. He’s mostly self taught and what’s he’s managed to do is nothing short of incredible
I want a T-Shirt with the Oasis dog on it!!!!!😍😍😍I love it......
A guitar, one man, we don't need nothing more.
Thank you for this!
Once you know the origin of the words, you cannot unhear.
d'you know wonderwall?
haha!
Wonder wall and dyou know what I mean have somewhat of the same chords
Noel gênio
Today is gonna be the day that all my people right here right now would like to say to you
But I don't know hoooooow, yeah yeaaaah!
I walk a lonely road the only one that I have ever known
Incredible. The same chords and same rythm for 2 very different songs and the two are fantastic!
Step of the train is gonna be the day that they re gonna all alone at dark.
Because maybe... Youre gona be the met my maker...
Alternate Title: Wonderwall 2
Perfeição
makes me wonder if they ever did a medley with this song and Wonderwall at a concert
Great version...a lot of the reason Be Here Now is slammed is unfair, just impossible expectations/Oasis burnout...but the other big reason is that there were some legitimately great tunes on it that were all but RUINED by overproduction, constant smothering in random unnecessary guitar riffs, soloing in the verses, overdubs, etc...so when you can hear the raw song like this exposed, it reveals the great song(s) that was there the whole time
banger!
He uses the same chords in all his songs, but in different order.
HopeNeverGone eheh kinda true
Best comment 😉😎
HopeNeverGone nope.
It's a stupid cliché.
HopeNeverGone I mean, so do most artists
@@badgasaurus4211 Basically the 90% of mainstream music
Anyone know the story about the Mad Dog Logo?
why so less views for you ?!
biblical
All together whom are we and what do we want... Freedom of speech.. tourette's us lot from Macclesfield'Cheshire..
Additional thoughts: Yeah, the acoustic version exposes how much the song does, and always did, use same chord structure as Wonderwall, but so what? Noel 'borrows' tons of riffs from other people, why not steal one from himself? Both songs can exist with similar riffs and still be good. But I also skip Wonderwall when I listen to "...Morning Glory" since it's so overplayed, so I'm biased.
Also, I wish there were more like this, not necessarily acoustic, but somehow like "alternate" versions of Be Here Now songs without all the ridiculous guitar overdubs etc, stripped down, so we could here the album as it "should" have been...they should do a special edition where Noel goes back into the studio with the master tracks, guts out all the bullshit and puts it out..."Be Here Now...Naked" lol. Gotta write him a letter
When wonderwall knows what they mean...
MCFC
MUFC
PJFC🐯
is it just me or does this version of the song sound way too much like wonderwall?
Em G dsus2 asus4 (capo on second) @sheskat
I"m a musician and i adore Oasis, but this is embarassing! I couldn"t play this song anymore, because it"s literaly the same as "Wonderwall!" I mean it"s not against the law to copy your own song...D"YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN? 😆
yeah and even the way he's strumming, it's the same. I don't like this version.