Judge Ratha questions Zandile Khumalo in the Senzo Meyiwa Mirder Trial

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 147

  • @lukasgaseb1995
    @lukasgaseb1995 18 днів тому +20

    It’s the first time that I hear a judge reasoning very poorly and really this is a mockery of the justice system in South Africa. He needs to be called out and called to order.

  • @belindamokoele8734
    @belindamokoele8734 20 днів тому +23

    The leading evidence judge , this judge think we are fools

    • @zimasancoliwe
      @zimasancoliwe  20 днів тому +1

      He is giving “I have made a Judgement ”

    • @Israelmthembu-r8y
      @Israelmthembu-r8y 15 днів тому

      You are talking like you were part of that incident my lord

    • @AndileLuvuno-f5c
      @AndileLuvuno-f5c 15 днів тому

      @@belindamokoele8734 such an incompetent judge

  • @kelebogilemolefhi9781
    @kelebogilemolefhi9781 8 днів тому +3

    What does the judge questioning suggests 🤔

  • @nthabisengmqotho9163
    @nthabisengmqotho9163 18 днів тому +7

    Judge and Baloi team work

  • @AstonMambwe-yi6de
    @AstonMambwe-yi6de 20 днів тому +12

    The judge is asking answer suggesting question he knows what answers he wants

    • @normanzwane1985
      @normanzwane1985 19 днів тому +1

      Any lawyer only asks a question whose answer he already knows - Ratha was once a lawyer, so it is to be expected that he would ask questions to merely have the witness confirm his line of thinking.

  • @vailgomba536
    @vailgomba536 19 днів тому +11

    Ngicela ukukhuluma no ma ka Senzo.Mama ngicela uye e court ucele u Jaji nomzansi afrika wonke aliyeke elityala.ngoba ikudla impilo yakho yonke.kubuhlungu kuthi kodwa wena njengomzali i worse .SA aliyindawo elityala kudlalwa nje ngempilo yakwa Meyiya.mabavalele the Meyiwa family and Me icant stand this play anymore nawe jaji sewuze waguga yile case engayindawo.Meyiwa family God will wipe your teas one day.ratha baloyi nizakuzi bhatala iinyembezi ze SA one day together with the khumalo's

  • @zwelithinidlamini9913
    @zwelithinidlamini9913 19 днів тому +8

    Lie lie lie make us believe the lies but one day as a woman yourself you will learn to understand that what goes around comes around 😢

  • @4manpowerDlamini-ch6wb
    @4manpowerDlamini-ch6wb 19 днів тому +5

    Furthermore, defence never said planed killing, accidentally shot. Later their witness Gininda said it was a contractual killing, not defence who said so

  • @AdelaideKweyama
    @AdelaideKweyama 19 днів тому +14

    This case is a child’s play.RIP Senzo Meyiwa.

  • @musamsibi7284
    @musamsibi7284 18 днів тому +3

    Uzandi Khumalo kumele abashwe?

  • @elsonmavuso9156
    @elsonmavuso9156 19 днів тому +3

    Izingane zakwa Khumalo izigenengu zonke why bengakhulumi iqiniso bacover umuntu bemazi Zandi awunaqiniso xem

  • @chailatte1255
    @chailatte1255 14 днів тому +1

    Kodwa licensing yaz kunomuntu ongagika abulale njr kanti lemgulukudu yavulelwa ngibani 2 babengeke bayeke ulongwe ngoba uyise unemali ukelly naye ubeli celeb .

  • @zakhelendulini3835
    @zakhelendulini3835 12 днів тому +2

    Walimala nini kanti onyaweni umangabe isbhamu wasizwa usebathroom 😢😢😢

    • @bongythwala9840
      @bongythwala9840 7 днів тому +1

      😂😂😂indidane le mina sengilalela nje ama clip amancane

  • @belindamokoele8734
    @belindamokoele8734 20 днів тому +5

    It was the time when maphiri clean up the crime scene, that is where you got time to lie . The police never come immediate.

    • @zimasancoliwe
      @zimasancoliwe  20 днів тому +1

      They never called the police, but called Maphiri instead 🥲eish

  • @bongythwala9840
    @bongythwala9840 7 днів тому

    I confident ekuZandi mayekhuluma kusho khona ukuthi batsheliwe ukuthi sinani nizowina .

  • @sandyglobalshipping1982
    @sandyglobalshipping1982 19 днів тому +6

    So when saying the State version is the true version so how could Kelly rushed to the hospital to save life of someone she ordered a hit on...

    • @celumusasimelane1110
      @celumusasimelane1110 19 днів тому

      good question

    • @Ntuli-w8v
      @Ntuli-w8v 19 днів тому +1

      He was already dead when she took him too hospital it was too cover themselves Tumelo made a call to Senzos brother in-law telling him what acxactly happened wait for it Wil come out

    • @michaelmbetse340
      @michaelmbetse340 18 днів тому +1

      The judges line of questioning is questionable. 😮

  • @YOURCRUSH-ng6xl
    @YOURCRUSH-ng6xl 19 днів тому +6

    Because he was shot by mistake thats y they rushing him to the hospital. Judge Ratha u evil

  • @chailatte1255
    @chailatte1255 14 днів тому +1

    Advocate msholo ilihlo lakhe kalimvumeli ukt athule tu!!!

    • @bongythwala9840
      @bongythwala9840 7 днів тому

      😂she is burning kuthi akafe nje ,mayezwe uBizo wakhe ashaya amanga😂

  • @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc
    @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc 18 днів тому +2

    VERY GUD MR RATHA LETS FORGET ABOUT HEARSAYS

  • @makasandra
    @makasandra 19 днів тому +4

    Thank you

  • @pindiwesweetnessndemka7068
    @pindiwesweetnessndemka7068 7 днів тому

    Thanks!

    • @zimasancoliwe
      @zimasancoliwe  6 днів тому

      Yho🥹🙏🏾Thank you so much for this. This is the first ever.
      I appreciate it from the bottom of my heart. May you be Blessed❤️🙏🏾

  • @bongythwala9840
    @bongythwala9840 7 днів тому

    Yona indoda ka Zandi ithini nje ukushada neSigebengu esinamanga njengoZandi ,😮

  • @ThembalihleMariaMkhize-yd7zq
    @ThembalihleMariaMkhize-yd7zq 18 днів тому +2

    That was the first nd last question judge Ratha asked after that he was shutup by brown envelope

  • @Zeelovezee
    @Zeelovezee 17 днів тому

    Mayeeee kwasuka loko RIP Senzo😢😢😢😢😢

  • @shirleychetty8375
    @shirleychetty8375 18 днів тому +1

    Rata did it not baffle you that an ambulance wasnt called. Kelly had a great bravado to be an excellent driver when her man was just shot. 7 people you count Rata. Im assuming all 7 were blind.

  • @NosiphoMenu
    @NosiphoMenu 17 днів тому +2

    Liyadika lizwi lika Zandile😮😮

  • @mandisapali7992
    @mandisapali7992 19 днів тому +1

    Ngubani owabulala uSenzo Meyiwa😭😭

  • @celestesamuels7623
    @celestesamuels7623 18 днів тому

    Maphiri was just standing by or hanging washing. She was called or was already in the house before shooting

  • @StheGumede-n7x
    @StheGumede-n7x 9 днів тому

    Angythola kanjan senawavulela imilenze

  • @musamsibi7284
    @musamsibi7284 18 днів тому +1

    Babenza ngathi babemsiza this is noses at all.😂😊

  • @sibusisomhlambi6257
    @sibusisomhlambi6257 14 днів тому +1

    This judge though, 😢

  • @KarabeloMosala-w6n
    @KarabeloMosala-w6n 11 днів тому

    Dis judge it seems like he knows, ,,,,he defend...everything

  • @NicolitiaMehlo
    @NicolitiaMehlo 19 днів тому +1

    Ngowumbuzi why u Mapiri wa cleaner after kungene izigebengu

  • @shirleychetty8375
    @shirleychetty8375 18 днів тому +2

    Longwe killed Senzo because you were busy with Senzo dear Thandi. He had a motive....and senzo died because of you dearest.

  • @lundiminenzima1162
    @lundiminenzima1162 19 днів тому +2

    Zandi told the court, but she was in bathroom and and up hit by sparks

  • @masiluisaacrakgolela2404
    @masiluisaacrakgolela2404 14 днів тому

    Thembi from moja love 99 can solve this case and senzo's mom can get a closer,i don't think there's an intruder.

  • @SiyabongaMtshali-nj1hy
    @SiyabongaMtshali-nj1hy 19 днів тому

    Uyaziyin uzandile ukuthi usisi wakhe owathenga labobantu abangena🤔

  • @syviennentombentshamotsau2130
    @syviennentombentshamotsau2130 17 днів тому

    There were intruders
    , this is obvious, the big question is who sent them to kill Senzo!

  • @zanoxolontshangase8525
    @zanoxolontshangase8525 17 днів тому

    Walimala kanjan onyawen uGirl ngoba ethi wese bathroom or bedroom ngeskhath kuqhuma isbhamu?

    • @ayandaginger
      @ayandaginger 17 днів тому

      Ja neh🤣🤣🤣Wazibophisa

  • @EMMlanjeniMlanjeni
    @EMMlanjeniMlanjeni 8 днів тому

    Eletyala bayalixoxa umnikazi akakhweli emaplangeni usenzo uthandana no Kelly but yena ungaphandle

  • @pamaskus3066
    @pamaskus3066 19 днів тому

    The calls to chicco changed the whole story protecting his son longwe...

  • @TsakaniMaluleke-z9k
    @TsakaniMaluleke-z9k 16 днів тому

    I miss judge ramaromo on the rosemary case

  • @nonkululekonkulei7450
    @nonkululekonkulei7450 19 днів тому

    Uxakwa yini ngoba uyalazi iqiniso ninomdeni wakho wonke ninesono nina noba umzali kasenzo ekhala inyembezi phambi kwenu yhoooo

  • @markvusi7797
    @markvusi7797 19 днів тому +1

    Can she demonstrate how they were seated in the house before until the intruders arrived. Who was sitting next to who?

  • @ZukiswaDukuza
    @ZukiswaDukuza 19 днів тому +1

    Longwe said everybody was already asleep in the neighborhood that s why he couldn't call them😂

  • @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc
    @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc 18 днів тому

    VERY GUD ZANDI SPORT ON YOU WERE ABLE TO IDENTIFY THIS TWO NKABIS BONGANI NTANZI AND GADLA MNCUBE

  • @bongythwala9840
    @bongythwala9840 7 днів тому

    Judge : "these stop nonsense 😂😂😂"
    zandi: "😂😂😂 my lord bbe"

  • @SmangaNgcobo-r5r
    @SmangaNgcobo-r5r 9 днів тому

    Lelijaji umqondo walo sukhathele.ligugile.lihlulwa kubona.kuthi labantu ababoshiwe bakhelwa itulo ababulali ilaba babesrndlini

  • @DesmondNkosi-tz9mz
    @DesmondNkosi-tz9mz 11 днів тому

    The is something wrong she sad she was seating on the couch and she peeped throu the passage now she was in the bath room when Senzo was shot zandi tell the truth ratha wake up don't take sides

  • @RoySingh-x7y
    @RoySingh-x7y 20 днів тому +9

    This lady know who is the killer😂😂

  • @LungileMtshali-jm4en
    @LungileMtshali-jm4en 18 днів тому

    Abaloyeke lelicala laba ijaji seliqedile ngalo

  • @nhlanhladlamini198
    @nhlanhladlamini198 12 днів тому

    Why did you interfere with the crime scene 😢😢😢

  • @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc
    @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc 18 днів тому +2

    THUMPS UP ZANDI VERY CLEVER GOD BLESS YOU THIS 5 ACCUSED ARE INVOLVED IN THE KILLING OF SENZO MEYIWA

    • @mhlonishwaskhumbuzo8099
      @mhlonishwaskhumbuzo8099 17 днів тому

      Awazi lutho khehlah,usukulele uma kuqhubeka ama proceeding 😂😂usangena uyisicabucabu nje esingawazi umthetho uyabhibhidla nje

    • @Boi4bennet
      @Boi4bennet 17 днів тому

      You smoked weed laced with covid 19

    • @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc
      @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc 17 днів тому +1

      @mhlonishwaskhumbuzo8099 shothi unenkinga emadlebeni or ulibele cdom ndina

    • @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc
      @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc 11 днів тому

      @mhlonishwaskhumbuzo8099 suke kulele naku lochama ngako

    • @bongythwala9840
      @bongythwala9840 7 днів тому

      ​@@NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lcisidomu wuwe wena Msunu kanyoko .

  • @ElizabethMokgadiMathobel-ss1ts
    @ElizabethMokgadiMathobel-ss1ts 19 днів тому +2

    Is Ratha a judge 'cause he is everything and everywhere alledgely an investigator, a witness, a state advocate above all an advocate for the witnesses. His behaviour is disgusting. Why can't he stop all these and pass his pre-determined vedict of finding the 5 accuseid guilty of murder. Who is he protecting at the course of the wrongfully 5 accused men? Ratha, why are you doing these? You are abusing your powers but God above is the only judge for the good and the bad.

  • @SoshaMthimkhulu
    @SoshaMthimkhulu 17 днів тому

    Lisaqhubekelan lelicala ngoba ususikhiphile isnqumo lobabah lo

  • @jeslinahmncube
    @jeslinahmncube 14 днів тому

    Why judge asking ?

  • @bonganichauke8367
    @bonganichauke8367 16 днів тому

    The Judge??????💔💔💔

  • @BrightonNdlera-v2l
    @BrightonNdlera-v2l 17 днів тому

    This is not cross examination.

  • @modiredipelekekae6034
    @modiredipelekekae6034 12 днів тому

    They took a dead body to the hospital for the doctor to confirm his death

  • @EgnesiaHermanus
    @EgnesiaHermanus 14 днів тому

    Abanye bayokhala Heeeiii Ratha looks defeated as we speak by Gininda's lies

  • @khumbulaningcobo3210
    @khumbulaningcobo3210 17 днів тому

    Hawu lelijaji

  • @beebee2409
    @beebee2409 19 днів тому

    You planned before you got to the Spaza House

  • @vumilemjoli9979
    @vumilemjoli9979 15 днів тому

    Aibo what is ths judge saying. Why us he leading the witness.

  • @SiphiweSiphiwe-oi9gh
    @SiphiweSiphiwe-oi9gh 19 днів тому

    Ratha lana ubuza into engekho bekumele bamuyeke senzo afe kuyangaye bangamuyisi esbhedlela ngoba abulawe yibo. Lekhehla liyabheda

    • @normanzwane1985
      @normanzwane1985 19 днів тому

      Well he is an officer of this court, he has the opportunity to pose questions - you & I are mere onlookers.

  • @chazilemanana2454
    @chazilemanana2454 18 днів тому

    Hhaybo uzandi uye esbhedlela after abuya kwa kwa mapuri jiki jiki wahamva nabo hhayi ayikho lento

  • @SiyavuyaNgxabazi
    @SiyavuyaNgxabazi 18 днів тому

    My lord they didn't plan the killing it was by mistake that's why he was rushed to hospital

  • @Naniki876
    @Naniki876 20 днів тому

    Not knowledgeable about law,but is it right that the judge cross examines the witness on behalf of the state when he is the one that is going to mete the judgement?

    • @zimasancoliwe
      @zimasancoliwe  20 днів тому

      Let me correct my thumbnail from cross-examining to questioning/seeking clarity . It is unethical to cross-examine, he can rather ask questions for clarity. In this case he is seeking clarity, even though I don’t see it ethical.

    • @Naniki876
      @Naniki876 19 днів тому

      Thank you ​@@zimasancoliwe

  • @lundiminenzima1162
    @lundiminenzima1162 19 днів тому

    How come the so called inkabi/intruders came in the house and demaded cellphones and money. After all none of them were robbed.

  • @MamikieMokhele-tp3wk
    @MamikieMokhele-tp3wk 19 днів тому

    Was this today

  • @BonginkosiChristianNgema
    @BonginkosiChristianNgema 16 днів тому

    This was a hoodie or Muslim hats

  • @NickSetlai
    @NickSetlai 8 днів тому

    My lord it was n accident

  • @ZukiswaDukuza
    @ZukiswaDukuza 19 днів тому

    Yho akaxakwanga lo mntwana,iintlantsi zamfumana ese bathroom😂😂😂

  • @mulaloshandukani1733
    @mulaloshandukani1733 17 днів тому

    😢Judge can't even get the deceased's name right

  • @MasilakheLeleki
    @MasilakheLeleki 13 днів тому

    Zandile you was inside the toilet,wabona kanjani ukuthi ningenelwe?

  • @johnphakathi3463
    @johnphakathi3463 18 днів тому

    First and fore most cleaning the crime scene one of the biggest mistake WHY???? WHAT were you hiding some one must be charged for deafiting the ends of justice

  • @PULEMAKGALE-n4i
    @PULEMAKGALE-n4i 18 днів тому

    What is equally perplexing, or baffling, Mr. Judge, is that one or two witnesses who were in the house testified that Longwe pushed the gunman as he ran outside. Longwe never got shot, and the gunman never chased after him. This is confusing as well. Will the judge seek clarity on this matter?

  • @ThomasMtsweni
    @ThomasMtsweni 16 днів тому

    Zandi uqabanga ukuthi kwafa ìnja

  • @ThandiMatale
    @ThandiMatale 19 днів тому

    O araba masepa zandi it shows its cooked

  • @dollydollence4144
    @dollydollence4144 13 днів тому

    Judge well done . Good questions

  • @mfundohashe9705
    @mfundohashe9705 19 днів тому

    Hawu this judge maara ?

  • @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc
    @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc 18 днів тому

    MSHOLOLO KNOWS THAT MJIYAKO WAS BONGANI NTANZI S LAWYER BUT SHE LOOKS LIKE SOME ONE WHO DOESNT KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THAT

  • @AndileLuvuno-f5c
    @AndileLuvuno-f5c 15 днів тому

    Is this judge really competent? How can the judge do advocacy for the defendent? He is also presiding over Sizwe homicide not Senzo

  • @zakithidlamini
    @zakithidlamini 17 днів тому

    This Judge is jjuseless
    Senzo was killed accidentally so that is why they had to rush him yo hospital. It was Chicos son who was Zandis boyfriend and Senzo womanizer was showing interest to Zandi.

  • @Itisfijished
    @Itisfijished 16 днів тому

    Nxa

  • @twmashabamashaba4072
    @twmashabamashaba4072 20 днів тому +1

    Tjooooo this madala is bias Jesus

  • @MfanafuthiMdunge
    @MfanafuthiMdunge 20 днів тому +1

    Nxxx umsuzo lo

  • @MfanafuthiMdunge
    @MfanafuthiMdunge 20 днів тому +1

    This judge

  • @layithakubhayi6592
    @layithakubhayi6592 8 днів тому

    This judge think he is a south african law ... he will be arrested for his narrative

  • @beebee2409
    @beebee2409 19 днів тому

    Biggest fiber🤑🤑🤑

  • @clementphillips4571
    @clementphillips4571 10 днів тому

    This Judge is not the right person for this case is even mix names.. the is something wrong about him

  • @kwaitonduku7019
    @kwaitonduku7019 18 днів тому

    What type of Judge is this, wadutyulwa ngemistake whn you shot someone by mistake yamsiza mos

  • @kelebogilelegobye1729
    @kelebogilelegobye1729 19 днів тому

    This Zandile had no sense

  • @kwaitonduku7019
    @kwaitonduku7019 18 днів тому

    Lo Judge andimva ebuza kuthi Longwe dlula njani kwisgebengu esiphethe isibham sephumile ke baleke waphelelaphi, buza lena tht suit narrative ayifunayo

  • @augustnobela7984
    @augustnobela7984 17 днів тому

    This judge is disgusting and listening to this lady anxious me the most, dont wanna lie

  • @bernardmpundu2462
    @bernardmpundu2462 19 днів тому +1

    South Africa is a zoo

  • @beebee2409
    @beebee2409 19 днів тому

    Leave the proof Zandie you are not the judge, dont try to act smart yeŕr

  • @ZwelakheShazi
    @ZwelakheShazi 6 днів тому

    OMG 🛑stop nonsense 😅😅

  • @shirleymunyai786
    @shirleymunyai786 19 днів тому +1

    Rubbish zandile nonsense
    So who kill Senzo then?

  • @LungileMtshali-jm4en
    @LungileMtshali-jm4en 18 днів тому

    Liyekeni lelicala nina zinja

  • @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc
    @NkosinathiShongwe-yu3lc 18 днів тому

    MNCUBE DID REMOVE DREADLOCKS BUT FAILED TO REMOVE THE BIG EYES