Well, this is a completely different kind of ghost story. Rather than the usual haunting, it gives us all a warning of what may come. I saw it coming the moment Mr. Kindley said that Clive was trying to warn Toby. That, and the rain. You forgot for Toby to ring his bell before the cave-in, by the way.
Thanks I'm glad you liked it:) I noticed that too about the bell but unfortunately I cannot change it as I've already deleted all the video files to free up space. On another topic I have sent you a new script
That was a grand story - some overtones of Dickens' 'The Signalman' by any chance, with the three warnings? You must be quite well researched to have included Elsie, the Wisbech & Upwell baggage van, who certainly didn't appear in the original Awdry stories about Toby and his line - indeed, the real van had long become a garden shed, or worse, when Awdry and Teddy Boston knew the W&U. Lovely.
I’ve seen your ghost stories since the beginning: they have all been very good, and it’s nice to see how far these have come: better audio and better models with better lighting. You don’t do too many stories about protagonistic ghosts. The last I can remember is The Banker in NRS Sudrian Railway Ghosts two. Maybe you can do the fourth story on a ghost train. Maybe one about a Ffarquar ghost that was one of the coffee pots that was scrapped in the engine shed where Thomas sleeps. Of course, the decision is yours, but I think my brief idea could be an interesting one. Keep up the good work! And of course, I must credit theburiedtruck for his great narration and voice acting.
Very lovely story! It felt better when Clive spoke as it didn't feel menacing as other ghost in the series. I hope u will incorporate this in a few future projects ;)
I love how this ghost was kind just like the first one with Percy and the letters, it was nice how Percy,,Daisy,& Toby each got a story to themselves, it’s nice how thomas didn’t get the spotlight like he usually does, if your going to continue this I would recommend about having Bertie as the main character
You know its nice to see a ghost story with a happy ending, normally we see the area taken down or avoided so its nice to have an ending such as this, good job my friend. Some scenes were abit laggy but didnt spoil the video. I must ask mate and I hope you can find a few moments in your time to reply but where and who made that awesome haunted Henry theme?
Hey ShunterProductions I have a idea for your next haunted tale and its called "the sinking phantom engine" and its about Rosie sees a ghost engine by the coastline near the lighthouse
Mid way it was scary, then after the Mr Kindly story, it became somehow sad :( Like with NWR1991narrated A figure in the Tunnel, I became sad too :( IDK why, but I gets sad rather than chilled :(
I know that the NRS is going to be rebooted soon and done in PDF but are there any plans for one last story for this book? I think it would be nice way to end off on as your ghost stories were definitely the most popular and I think it would be a good way to inform everyone that the series is getting rebooted.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
This story went from, creepy to sad, to heart touching. Not many stories can do that in such a small timeframe. Three cheers for Clive!
I think Clive has joined "The Banker"'s Conrad as one of my favorite ghosts you've introduced. I love it when there are friendly ghosts.
And "Figure in the Tunnel with Mary Smith who only freaked the engines, but never harmed them
Ah, yes, poor remorseful Mary. :(
I really love T&F ghost story's like this they are always mysterious and interesting.
Same here! 😀
This certainly was quite a spooky story. It was making me get the shivers at times. You made this tale something for us to think about :).
I love these stories so much.
Another amazing story
I like the realistic approaches to the engines. Almost like the Hornby thomas models.
Awesome story. Never thought a ghost like Clive...was trying to tell Toby something.
great job, the sudrian ghost stories have always been my favorite episodes from you
Well, this is a completely different kind of ghost story. Rather than the usual haunting, it gives us all a warning of what may come. I saw it coming the moment Mr. Kindley said that Clive was trying to warn Toby. That, and the rain.
You forgot for Toby to ring his bell before the cave-in, by the way.
Thanks I'm glad you liked it:) I noticed that too about the bell but unfortunately I cannot change it as I've already deleted all the video files to free up space. On another topic I have sent you a new script
Thank you!
ShunterProductions have you ever heard of Glynn the coffee pot engine
I love this video so much. It's so beautiful thanks for making it.
That was a grand story - some overtones of Dickens' 'The Signalman' by any chance, with the three warnings? You must be quite well researched to have included Elsie, the Wisbech & Upwell baggage van, who certainly didn't appear in the original Awdry stories about Toby and his line - indeed, the real van had long become a garden shed, or worse, when Awdry and Teddy Boston knew the W&U. Lovely.
I’ve seen your ghost stories since the beginning: they have all been very good, and it’s nice to see how far these have come: better audio and better models with better lighting. You don’t do too many stories about protagonistic ghosts. The last I can remember is The Banker in NRS Sudrian Railway Ghosts two. Maybe you can do the fourth story on a ghost train. Maybe one about a Ffarquar ghost that was one of the coffee pots that was scrapped in the engine shed where Thomas sleeps. Of course, the decision is yours, but I think my brief idea could be an interesting one. Keep up the good work! And of course, I must credit theburiedtruck for his great narration and voice acting.
Nice episode. Excellent work
I really love this style and detail
That was wonderful. Well done.
Nice episode cant wait for more love your ghost stories i wouldent mind just ghost episodes but i know that would get boring to make after awhile
this is one of my favourites.
May I recommend you make the last story about a ghost engine? One of the former engines of the branch, trying to cause trouble?
Amazing ghost story! I love it! Spooky but enjoyable.
This is such a different ghost story it's so good
Very lovely story! It felt better when Clive spoke as it didn't feel menacing as other ghost in the series. I hope u will incorporate this in a few future projects ;)
Wh-what’s in my eye?
Is this liquid?
*oh, it’s tears*
Another amazing ghost story.
9:20 YOUNG Thomas? Isn't he only a year younger than Toby? Otherwise, this story was great. Can't wait for the next one!
Thank u Clive! For saving his crew!
I love how this ghost was kind just like the first one with Percy and the letters, it was nice how Percy,,Daisy,& Toby each got a story to themselves, it’s nice how thomas didn’t get the spotlight like he usually does, if your going to continue this I would recommend about having Bertie as the main character
Very well done, absolutely wonderful. If I ask what's the music at 4:52. I want to use it in my videos
Fantastic story man! :)
5:55 Once an engine attached to the train, and was afraid of the few drops of rain. He squeaked into the tunnel, and would not come out again
*Henry wished at you*
Amazing work
Its a realy good story!
Clive did his job in preventing a death similar to his and he is the best kind of ghost to encounter.
awesome video
You Mean To Tell Me You Were Afraid Of Dear Old Mrs Kyndley
Nice, can’t wait to see more new content! :D
5:55 Toby The Tram Engine is acting like he is refusing to get out of the tunnel because of the heavy rain
I already listened to this on soundcloud.
All sodor ghosts should be friendly like Clive
You know its nice to see a ghost story with a happy ending, normally we see the area taken down or avoided so its nice to have an ending such as this, good job my friend.
Some scenes were abit laggy but didnt spoil the video. I must ask mate and I hope you can find a few moments in your time to reply but where and who made that awesome haunted Henry theme?
Robtheredengine it was aceoftrains who made the theme
Are you sure, because its not on his soundcloud or youtube account. I am looking for that theme for when Henry enters not the runaway theme.
Robtheredengine I think the theme is called Henry enters the forest
I found one by a user called theturntable2002, is that the one? sorry for all the questions mate I appreciate you getting back to me btw ^^
So the flashback is set in 1952? Toby still has his grey cowcatcher and BR number 68221
Nice one!
Could you make another Ghost train story or maybe remaking Sir Handell get's scared like Odd the Purple Engine suggested?
Hey ShunterProductions I have a idea for your next haunted tale and its called "the sinking phantom engine" and its about Rosie sees a ghost engine by the coastline near the lighthouse
Sebastian Heenan that’s sounds great! Although it could be shortened to ‘The Phantom Engine’. Liked comment
@@terrier_productions i agree on that mate that would be a good name
Love it
When is the 4th video coming?
Omg this was amazing has to be the best and the hole ghost tunnel thing MIGHT have happened in real life. It did.
Mid way it was scary, then after the Mr Kindly story, it became somehow sad :( Like with NWR1991narrated A figure in the Tunnel, I became sad too :( IDK why, but I gets sad rather than chilled :(
Maybe the next story should involve a ghost train
good job :D
DO you have 2006 Henry link
Nice.
5:55 Looks like the episode A Sad Story About Henry (Come Out Henry!) Thomas and Friends season 1
I hope Mavis and the quarry is your next story
I really like this story good job
And do u by chance have Discord
I know that the NRS is going to be rebooted soon and done in PDF but are there any plans for one last story for this book? I think it would be nice way to end off on as your ghost stories were definitely the most popular and I think it would be a good way to inform everyone that the series is getting rebooted.
There will be a fourth story to this it just needs to be written
@@ShunterProductions Sweet. I will admit it would feel off if there were just 3 stories instead of the usual 4.
A little spooky, but a good story nevertheless
That's two ghosts named Clive.
And it's because your voice sounds very familiar.
When is the next story for Ffarquhar Haunts going to be on UA-cam?
Oh be patient, you can't rush a good story like this
Landslide
Where did you get james?
I will do Paxton's lines by September
By now you're nearly to 8,444 subscribers. #up8444
Congrats on getting 8,444 subscribers. #up8444
Is this your last video your gonna make
There will be more ghost stories right
If I feel like it
15:26 Rest in peace Clive
What models are these that you use?
5:45 I don’t see the man
Why do you have another channel called dcg12b?
John Blum two completely different people dcg12b narrates some of my stories. That's does not mean we are two of the same people lol
Where do you get the James model from?
Matthew Boucher it's a private model given to me
Oh well
Hi, not trying to be a jerk I just found this video randomly. What is this?
Edward and Toby are not that old
Tablet Aussendienst well how old are they wise guy
You need something in the background oh your channel
WERE GONNA UNSUB IF THERES NOT A NEW EPASOED (lol Jk)