‘CELEBRATE’ but it’s only TZUYU’s lines
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 сер 2024
- thank you for watching ☁️
im bored and they just came back with another bop, so…
i do not own any of the clips or music used in this video. all credits to original owners. the only thing i take credit for is the editing / subtitles overlaid on it.
my videos are created solely for entertainment and (as of now) nonprofit purposes.
🍃 PLEASE DO NOT RE-UPLOAD. 🌺
#celebrate #twice #tzuyu #셀러브레잇 #트와이스 #쯔위 #조우쯔위 #조자유
tzuyu was actually clarified to have one more line in the bridge (with nayeon), which adds about 3 seconds to her total, making it about 19 seconds
edit: why are all of y’all fighting in the comments um- chillax 😃
She also had adlib in minas bridge right after mina was done singing, many people mistaked that as Mina
@@CureWonderfuI last time i checked it was indeed mina, since a lot of people were confused about that when celebrate first dropped, but i’ll check again for you
edit: different sources say different things so i can’t confirm for sure. whoever it is it sounds beautiful tho :)
@@wonyoungest you can check live concerts!
i wish she had more lines she has the best voice -.-
Despite being one of the most followed member on Instagram, she only have like legit 5 seconds on this MV. Like wtf
ikr.. jype mismanaging visuals part 93647
Well that's what she renew her contrac for
Ikr she's the visual of Twice for a reason they should at least give her beautiful outfits and visual-screentime to promote her visuals like how they did In feel special
@@user-oc6pv2pk5g Actually Nayeon is the visual of Twice!
@@sakura-unboxing Tzuyu is the official one
JYPE so scary about Tzuyu appear on the screen time. I 'm proud of Tzuyu even less screen line, she still the most IG follower and famous too. JYPE , your unfairly treats too much.
Haha lol you try managing a 9 member group and getting them all equal share, it’s not an easy task
JYPE didn’t give me enough time to take screenshots because Tzuyu’s screen-time and lines are sooo little. Even she didn’t get enough screen-time, she is very beautiful and shining as she gets but she deserves better and to be shining like brightest star
im gunna be a starr
I think we need to support Tzuyu by showing our anger to JYP about the unfair situation of Tzuyu! No matter it is useful or not! We can unite together on net claim that 「we want Tzuyu more」!
This was the reason we and other tzuyu Stans wanted tzuyu to not renew her contract but even if she did so other she would have been bashed by Ot9 or other Stans who wanted twice to renew
Finally find Tzuyu in the mv. Good job!!!
I thought her only line was her first line since I barely heard her or even saw her at the MV she showed up like 5,6 seconds then disappeared.
子瑜值得更好的對待
她願意續約繼續當邊緣人也只能祝福她了！
畫面真的很少😒
I’m very disappointed after watching it, tzuyu deserves better..U know why TWICE can’t discover in international show or like cover magazine etc. more because JYP can’t promoted them more from the very start they starting in kpop industry..They should allowed them to show their own talents, I’m sure one of them can act they should be in kdrama etc..
there are a lot of things jype has held back on for twice, even though they’re literally one of the most popular groups out there..
now that they’ve renewed their contract and 3rd gen is heading to a close, i hope they’ll get more individual promotions and do more of the things they want to do
Her lines were veryyyyy less in this mv
Her lines are okay, she got 17-19 seconds.
She has lines but not screen time :(
she's almost invisible in the music video lol why is her screentime so low
some of these screen time could only see blur Tzuyu or she's at the corner.... (like the polaroid part)
actual screen time maybe less than 10 sec
so what are we celebrating for...?🤔
子瑜鏡頭一樣少的可憐
they doesn't treat her right, she deserve better
she does.. most of them do
thank god the distribution was actually a lot better this time around so :D
@@wonyoungest this type of fans are dumb af
If they don't treat her well, she will automatically not renew her contract at JYPE. But this, she did her contract extension, it means what you see is not what you think. And that means she's comfortable with how they treat her.
@@kimtesa7534 💯 true! I don't see anything wrong here. The song line distribution is actually fair. Nayeon only have a second or two gap with Jihyo which is better than usual because half of her line in the song is adlibs.
twice has 9 members and each song is around 3 minutes long, if you divide 3 minutes into 9, each member should get around 33seconds each to be fair, however, main vocalists would usually have to sing longer parts thus other member’s parts are shorter, in this case, this line distribution is pretty fair to be honest, quit complaining!!
My bias Tzuyu :-)
JYP always doesn't want Tzuyu to get more attention from fans than other members, because Tzuyu is too popular will destroy the members that JYP wants to promote, but JYP is also worried that if Tzuyu leaves Twice, Twice will lose many fans
they’re afraid another ‘suzy and miss a’ thing is going to happen
Tzuyu clearly loves being in TWICE and the group is very successful. Leaving TWICE for whatever reason would be extremely hard for her as she would essentially have to leave behind her second family in the other members. I think if TWICE were to ever disband, it would be a group decision or extreme health circumstances. I have no doubt they’re all in it for the long run.
子瑜仙女聲音超好聽超療癒
Maybe Tzuyu have only few lines in this MV...but she killed her part with her sweet voice...💙💕
So important for them to add everything else rather than Tzuyu on the screen for HER line.
ikr...i need to play it at 0.5 speed to take a screenshot of her lol
This is what I notice in recent comebacks. But either way, Tzuyu shines with her vocals and beauty.
EXACTLY!!!!
You do realize in this mv they did that to every member😭 its not just tzuyu.
@@saracooper3435 Right, but this becomes a problem when they don’t compensate the mbr with other shots. This time unlike rest of the team each has in avg 15-25+secs of screen time, Tzuyu has less than 10, and many are fragmented shots. She wasn’t given screen time for some of her lines, also she doesn’t even get to stand near the centre during her first part. And Tzuyu is the visual of the group, not officially but acknowledged by Twice and the public. We’re just hoping for fair treatment to keep the fandom at peace, not asking for more.
I like Twice but if JYP acts unfairly on Twice some member or deliberately suppresses some member, it will bring shame to Twice
真的一定要以這樣的模式對待子瑜嗎？子瑜越來越瘦她的心裡狀態ok嗎？我真的不明白子瑜的父母為什麼要續約，真心覺得應該讓子瑜好好休息思考人生其他可能。
她願意續約繼續當邊緣人也只能祝福她了！
@@bradtao1 不是不瞭解你的這種心情，我偶爾也有，但子瑜的善良正是我入坑的原因之一，我目前還是會繼續支持她，接下來就看續約後的狀況，如果公司還是這樣我也心累了(希望續約的時候有談好條件)，應該會漸漸遠離kpop圈。
@@Tibbyrock 她被邊緣化還是跟其他人賺一樣的錢，那就祝福她快樂待在T團囉！
Her lines were ok, but wtf happened with her screentime? She was singing and the camera was showing ANYTHING but Tzuyu.
they doesn't treat her righ
Let's stream this film to show our support to Tzuyu! She deserve better!
i mean i felt the same way, the first time i seen the M/V I instantly noticed Tzuyu wasn't shown as much as everyone else i get it was a Japanese track giving most of the light to the members who are Japanese and I was glad to see more of momo, sana, and mina. i just hope it wasn't anything intentional
she did well in BDZ 😭 i thought they will give her chance again but sigh
YES bdz tzuyu era 100%
missing those days lol
Kura-kura era is her best era for me.
@@Kyyanos OH YES kura kura was good too
@@Kyyanos the iconic prechorus 😫✨
0:03, it's her part but Sana in center??? Why???
You do realize that happened to every member in that whole mv.
thats a part of choreo, sana had her pre chorus and since at that time tzuyu was in corner they couldnt let her jump and come to the center
So sad
Even she singing in some cuts no scene.😢
All OT9 Once should see the problem here, if you don’t then it’s too bad. I will always support Twice with all my heart regardless, but I really hope JYPE can just simply even out the screen time for all 9, not to say divide them evenly, just a little and enough to stop all the fan war within the fandom.
the leader of twice should try to distribute or make sure all the members get attest 10 sec singing time, while few members get all the lines others gets less or ignored
Jihyo isn't the one who always contribute the lines but when she do, she does that.
that’s not exactly how it works in kpop, it’s usually the producing team..
if jihyo had a say in it, though, im sure the songs would be more fair
First Jihyo (leader) is not the one who distribute the lines. Second, distributing lines is not as easy as u think, they always make sure if one member would fit the part or not, they don’t do it randomly. Third, this song’s line distribution is kinda fair cause every member has 10s+ unlike "Truth" line distribution 💀.
Maybe I sounded rude but I was just trying to explain to u since many don’t understand this 😅.
@@kpopythings614 why don't you say twice doesn't write their own song too, i mean you said all bullshit
@@drdisrespect.8174 Idk what this has to do with what I just said and no need to be rude mate
So why do the other members renew their contracts for 5 years, and only Tzuyu renews their contracts for 3 years? Because JYP hopes that Tzuyu will contribute her fans to other members in these three years, and the Tzuyu's parts will be very small in these three years. JYP hopes that Tzuyu's fans will be transferred to Other members or Twice as a whole, these are my inferences, but I hope I'm wrong, if my inferences are right, that possible the most Tzuyu's fans will leave Twice disappointed
If her treatmenet wont get better, i do not think Mama chou will advise Tzuyu to continue with the contract. Unless theyre being blackmailed to do so. I read other theory that it will be bad for Tzuyu to leave jyp because she might get hate for it, because everyone expects Twice to be 9. :( and she will be blamed by ruining the group. You know very well that once do not care about Tzuyu's welfare, they only care about their bias and Twice being complete and with no scandal. Speaking for Tzuyu's mistreatment ruins their blindsided belief that everything in twiceland and jype is all good.
我希望能讓子瑜也出一支她自己喜歡的創作單曲，讓她那如當初時勇敢的展現自己，她現在讓我覺得當初的勇氣被打壓後都施展不出手腳，但我知道她覺得不竟如此！希望子瑜放開來！我相信一定很棒！畢竟她的進步有目共睹！
Thx for the editing
no problem :)
I'm glad we're still friends .👍🌻
Beautiful !
I wonder how you capture these
Tzuyu doesn’t deserve better this time, she once had choice to not renew her contract, but she did, so no more #treattzuyubetter campaign.
She had no choice though. If she left, solo stans and ot9 fans would have bashed her saying that she is a "black sheep". And now that she renew people are still complaining. Poor girl has no place to go.
She line is just too short
Her lines are okay, it's the screentime that makes her lines look short
😍😍😍😍😍😍
I think you forget the line in the bridge, after Mina
the one who sings after mina is sana, and if you mean the line she supposedly sang underneath nayeon’s high note, i wasn’t sure if it was actually her so i didn’t include it (it was technically just a harmony since the high note was way more prominent anyway)
@@wonyoungest It's between Mina and Sana. If I'm not mistaken it says "You made It"
@@eumesmo5533 ahhh i see
my bad, i thought that was just mina 🧖♀️🤞
@@wonyoungest No problem
@@wonyoungest Hey, do you know if they will do any performance with this song?
Imo she get enough lines but she get less screentime
One more in bridge part you make it also tzuyu part so is 20 seconds
im still salty bout celebrate era... its is one of my fav twice song but fans at that time ruined it all by continuously saying mistreat and idk but eventually mina and sana ended up getting lota of hate and everyone in between the fights forgot the main point of this song
It’s a shame that she never gets any good lines or screen time and momo too,
If you add all the times and screen time for all the videos off tzuyu and they have a lot off m/v you could make one m/v off tzuyu that’s how much screen time she gets
😄😊😀
She deserves better, please leave the group girl
....
Allah rahmatiNya dan diridhoiNya aku rahmatNya yang dirahmatiNya dan diridhoiNya kebaikan yang dirahmatiNya beserta diridhoiNya rahmatNya dengan kebaikan yang dirahmatiNya juga dirahmatiNya rahmatNya yang dirahmatiNya hati damai tentram serta ridhoi dan meridhoi kebaikan yang dirahmatiNya kemudahan dan kelancaran untuk tercapainya apa yang dituju dengan sukses dan bahagia lahir batin yang dirahmatiNya rahmatNya
Allah rahmatiNya dan diridhoiNya aku dan istriku rahmatNya yang dirahmatiNya dan diridhoiNya kebaikan yang dirahmatiNya juga diridhoiNya rahmatNya dengan kebaikan yang dirahmatiNya beserta dirahmatiNya rahmatNya yang dirahmatiNya hati damai tentram serta ridhoi dan meridhoi kebaikan yang dirahmatiNya dan dimudahkannya kelancaran untuk tercapainya apa yang dituju dengan sukses dan bahagia lahir batin dengan rahmatNya yang dirahmatiNya
Where is her high note
Oi milida mamirada miha
to whoever that is saying tzuyu has barely any lines:
twice has 9 members and each song is around 3 minutes long, if you divide 3 minutes into 9, each member should get around 33seconds each to be fair, however, main vocalists would usually have to sing longer parts thus other member’s parts are shorter, in this case, this line distribution is pretty fair to be honest, quit complaining!!
Surely youve noticed how short her screentime right ?
and to add on, the lyrics of this song were by all 9 members of twice and jyp, so i’m pretty sure tzuyu would’ve stated out if she wanted more parts, in this case, she seems comfortable with the length of her parts and as tzuyu fans, shouldn’t y’all be more mature and respect her decision?
Exactly
She had 17-19 second lines. The problem is the screentime. And i doubt Tzuyu asked to not be seen in the mv.
@@tzuyukiwichou2892 but chaeyoung didn't have any screentime either and barely any lines. But who's saying she's mistreated? Most of the members had someone else on screen when it was their line. But why is it only talked about when it's tzuyu?
@@saracooper3435 i saw a chart indicating Tzuyu being last in screentime, which is very far from the others. Chaeyoung was one of the last in lines but she got enough screentime, she made an impression because her moments are all long shots. Meanwhile you cant see Tzuyu's frame for more than a second. And supposedly you think Chaeyoung is being mistreated and deserve better, then I encourage you to speak up for her too. Why should we, as fans, not advocate for the members when we know very well they are being treated unfairly? Im speaking for Tzuyu, Chaeyoung, Dahyun and Jeongyeon.
@@tzuyukiwichou2892 oh ok, next time I will speak up for chaeyoung. I didn't know tzuyu was last in screentime either 😪 Oh also when I said something about it only being a problem when it's tzuyu I didn't know you were a person who advocates for all mistreated members instead of one. Sorry for the misunderstanding.
What is wrong with those who say few? Really, let's be honest, she got even more lines than the main voice of Jeongyeon, and she was the most LINE member with Mina and Sana
It's the screentime thats bad not the lines. The others are confuse, thought it was the lines, because when it was her turn to sing, she was nowhere in the screen.
i don't think you guys understand that it is her job as visual to have less line . main vocalists got most of it then vocalists, rappers and then the rest dancers/visuals . im pretty sure the members are all ok with their own roles and if it wasnt the case for anyone she would of quit . like for example since its a japanese song fans can expect Mina, Sana and Momo to maybe have more lines which in this case Mina and Sana seems to have but not Momo because she doesn't usually sing much because shes the main dancer thats her job ... it's not a mistreatment it's a job and everyone has their own tasks ! all of you should just enjoy the whole song instead of crying about x member didn't do much etc they are a group not solo artists .
They just want to have her sing the whole song🥴
@@davidmarclouiseencabo8072 which is impossible but hey they started the solo debut with Nayeon so maybe in 10 years we'll get a Tzuyu solo song lol
@@Micstl lol
@@Micstl but if we follow JYPE or twice schedule she may have her Solo in 3-4 years from now. They like recording songs and keep it until they can release it with other songs.😂
@@davidmarclouiseencabo8072 yeah you're right they are not like Blackpink Twice actually do some music ... 😅
the fact is she is ok with how she is treated. her fans should just let her be and stop with the #. she aint worth it.
Whatttt ? U have the audiocity to say she ain't worth it ?!. Like really ???...!!,!..
F U!
@@jahnavitzueevee5864 shes ok with it so she deserves how she is treated. you aint no body to her nor do you know how she feels.
@@gingerginger1163 so how do U know how she feels and how do U know that she is ok with it
Did she tell u ?
U too ain't nobody to her
@@jahnavitzueevee5864 she decided to renew her contract with JYPE meaning she's happy with how JYPE mistreated her. Fact.