Channel Update + Graphic Novel Discussion
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 сер 2024
- A video to let you all know I've seen your comments - you want the battle cat content, and that may or may not be happening. That, and my reaction to the graphic novel announcement.
Well at least our girl Ivypool is now the deputy ….finally because this girl DESERVES the roll after all the crap that she had go through
May I correct one of your errors ? I think it would be Role not Roll pardon my rudeness
@@Iaminsideyourwalls208we all thought it but it doesn’t need to be said 😅
I seriously doubt they’re gonna retcon Silverstreams character in these comics. I’m more under the impression that they want to give her more screen time so that her relationship with Graystripe and her following death feels more impactful and tangible to the reader.
When I was a kid I didn’t really have a strong connection to Silverstream. When she died, I was sad because I was upset for Graystripe. I’m hoping that the comics introduce her early on, potentially in border conflicts and gatherings. She probably won’t have a ton of important dialogue but they might begin her rescuing Graystripe earlier than usual. That’s just my thought process, I don’t expect the comics to blow me out of the water but I don’t expect them to be bad by any means, they look really promising and the artist is a Warriors fan so they seem to know what they’re doing. I’ll keep my hopes high until the book actually comes out
I’m hoping that they have the romance build from Into The Wild if that’s the case, instead of love at first sight. Because the latter is overdone in this series.
This review is literally the opposite of Moonkitti's and that's so funny
They are the yin and yang.
Just because the graphic novel has designs doesn't mean it's the definitive design for the whole series, it's just the novel artists takes on how the characters would look like
plus a book having an graphic adaptation doesn't ruin people's imagination on what happens in the original book, people can still imagine the characters the way that they want to, many novel book series that people love have movie, comic book, and game adaptations so what's the problem with Warriors doing the same?
Volume 1 of GN does actually include Fire and Ice! They are doing 3 volumes with 2 books in each one
The graphic novels are a great resource for people with aphantasia, people who can’t form pictures/images in their head. Also I feel like the argument of “taking away the reader’s ability to picture” a scene is a little dumb cause, you can still imagine the scene how you want. No one is saying how this graphic novel presents is how you have to imagine it. It’s the same for when novels get turned into other visual media like tv shows or movies.
Yeah, and i think its quite cool to see the graphic novel versions cause i get to see someone else’s in-visioning of the book.
True, plus the original books are still very available for people who aren't interested in graphic novels ^^
This exactly, I always hated how people said graphic novels inspired less imagination than books because it was always the opposite for me
Anyone gonna tell quiet that the graphic novel has into the wild, AND fire and ice put into one?
REALLY?
Well half of fire and ice
No more like 1/2 of fire and ice.
@@2Navalie Yeah, they didn’t include Sandpaw getting saved by Fireheart, Fireheart seeing Cinderpaw’s broken leg, Cloudkit coming to ThunderClan, etc. I could go on, but I don’t feel like it.
NOw, heres the thing, I really LIKE the slightly cartoonish designs, it makes Brokenstar look like a saterday morning cartoon bad guy, and I lOVE that! Bluestar looks old but regal and I like how each cat is different. BUFF SILVERSTREAM MUST RAISE
11:34
I mean, they introduced Princess the new graphic novel, even though she too, only appeared in Fire and Ice.
i’m pretty sure it’s ITW and FAI mashed together into one book
@@LatteCookies_Spoonindeed it is there’s 3 volumes each with 2 books mixed into it
As someone you started with graphic novels in my young days, i think graphic novels can be useful to people who have a hard time to imaginate. Other than that, graphic novels are a fun way to visualise the characters and settings better only after you have read the books, i dont know, its like completing a completely black and white drawing with colour.
As much as i love visualizing myself, the emotions of seeing what you have or haven't missed, and how close it is to something that someone else imaginates, idk, it connects everyone closer.
this why i love watching fandom maps, art, pmvs and animations.
I hope warrior cats never ends, I love how it never stops regardless of the quality.
I never want a conclusive ending, let this series keep continuing until we die as a species 🙏
Tbh I kinda hope it ends
agreed, i tend to not read the books just for them to begin with. i like seeing the fandom use the books as barebone roots and building something actually creative and genius with then
It's actually an into the wild PLUS fire and ice graphic novel adaptation I think
It is I read it ( I deadass got it early )
@@Rulose like the entire thing? If so how did you do that?
mhm,how?:0
@@Amethyst_the_rain_night I have connections to someone in the printing company!
@@Rulose sooo lucky
The "bad decision" is talking about Silverstream's death not making her a worse character
I interpreted the "bad decision" as her breaking the code
The constantly nice and supportive wife who has no thoughts beyond “I just want you to be happy my love” is a borderline misogynistic trope. A mean girl character can also having misogynistic writing but at least it gives her more depth than the very bare bones character she had in the first series (she was basically fridged too). Let the girl be a spoiled Clan princess and daughter of the leader while still being a sympathetic character.
I've read the graphic novel. While it does have it's flaws, that doesn't make it bad. I can say this. I. LOVE. The graphic novel. Sure it ain't perfect, but it doesn't need to be. It's amazing the way it is! It's beautiful! Anyone who hasn't read it really should. Also, i kinda like the Silverstream design. Whether or not you agree with me, Silverstream's design is still good even if it isn't accurate. We can still enjoy it. Y'all can insult the design of Silver all you want, but it's not gonna lead the artists to remake the entire novel because of one simple flaw. Just enjoy it :)
I like the cartoony style of the graphic novel. Silverstream in Graystripe’s graphic novel is supposed to just be a dream of his, right? Not her actual spirit from StarClan? Graystripe was never able to commune with StarClan in the series.
Do you have anything positive to say about... anything QR?
The graphic novel is just another take on the series, it’s by no means a way to force people to stop being imaginative with designs and locations. As someone with aphantasia I’ve always struggled to picture the events in the books, and I think this is a great way to broaden the audience of the series. There’s nothing stopping people who dislike the adaptations from just reading the original books.
As for the whole Silverstream “villain” thing… I think it’s pretty far fetched to say the series is getting a graphic novel to retcon the original books because one of the authors is divorced? The “bad decisions” line is pretty clearly alluding to her death - while in the long run the relationship DID lead to good, it’s undeniable that at the time of the books releasing her relationship with Greystripe was a bad decision. It was against the warrior code, which was a much larger part of the series at the time (leading to cats being shunned/punished). The first edition of the graphic novel also covers part of Fire and Ice, not to mention Silverstreams popularity - hence why they released a promo image of her.
It's going to be an adaptation of the first two books, actually.
specifically the first one and half of the second one
@@2Navalie where'd you hear that?
@@twist_ending7545 from another warrior cats channel, it might not be correct, idk
@@2Navalie pretty sure it's wrong. It's the full first two books
@@twist_ending7545 okay
Nothing makes you happy lol
fym
Missed you! Don't force yourself to post stuff you don't want to. I honestly love just rewatching your videos, it's always just as fun
It's interesting how averse editors can be to letting graphic novels be actually graphic.
Buff woman ‼️‼️‼️
Have you ever thought about reading the Guardians of Ga'hoole books?
I love those books! They are so underrated. The movie was great too
@calliethecat7408 i only started reading them a few months ago, I love just how dark they are! Out of Warriors and Wings of Fire, it's probably the most violent and darkest of the two
They’re adapting both Into the Wild and Fire and Ice in the graphic novel
I don’t really like Brokenstar’s design, he looks more cute than scary. I just wanna pick him up and love on him, he’s way too fluffy and adorable!
Honestly I've really enjoyed the non-warriors stuff. I still enjoy your warriors content, but I just feel like there's a lot nicer vibe from the gaming clips. Yeah, it's fun to get your hate on, but it's also fun to just share things that make you happy. I know I have some extra bias, Jojo's Bizarre Adventure and Fallout are my favorite anime/manga and gaming series, of course I love New Vegas clips and Jojo memes. Do what brings you joy, there might not be as many people watching, but you'll still have an audience.
As for the graphic novels, I'm really excited! I know part of this is that I read a lot of manga (admittedly, mostly Seinen) and I'm a huge Watership Down fan and it had 2 very good adaptations that I could see Warriors potentially following. I even have a tattoo of the animated film's version of the Black Rabbit of Inle, I'd love to see Warriors follow its or a lot of other visual medium xenofiction adaptations in their quality. Plus this isn't the first time Warriors is being adapted as a graphic novel of some sort either, of course there's the mangas and the current fan webcomic boom, but other translations have had comic/manga/etc adaptations of direct book scenes before. I can see it going well.
Also for context, from everything I've read, the graphic novel is going to cover the first 2 books/each graphic novel is going to adapt 2 books. This is a good thing as the first arc is the only one that really works as 6 books. I think it's probably less cynical, "bad decisions" just meaning her dying. I'd imagine Silverstream might be bitchier like her recent arc appearances, but a lot of people really love bitchier Silverstream. It gives her a more in your face personality to have her be remembered for instead of just the fridging, which is why I imagine this is happening in the first place. Warriors has always had a misogyny problem and it still has a very blatant one, but a hopeful part of me thinks this is an attempted step to start to remedy some of it in the past.
I don’t know if you’ll see this but I used to watch you when I was younger (11 - 13 ish). I loved and probably will always love listening to people complain and get angry because it means they have the spark of passion. I know there talking about the thing they love or once loved. So I will thank you to forever and back for sparking my passion for the things I love.
if youre moving onto other interests that's fine! talk about the stuff you enjoy, I love jojo's so im sure some people with similar interests will watch it
I read the Pride of Baghdad graphic novel because of your little comment about it, and I would have been so disappointed if the Warriors graphic novel was as needlessly edgy as that was.
The longer series run they tend to decline, I stopped reading the series at Dawn cuz it was so slow. The New Prophecy will be more bearable as a graphic novel. It is hard to write great book after great book there are always bound to be some subpar ones in any long series.
11:32 I’m pretty sure it’s an adaptation of Into the Wild and Fire and Ice, if I’m correct
Entirety of broken code is a banger though
One, your style of rants seriously appeals too me. It's fun, and I would be happy if you wanted too talk about Mass Effect, Jojo, Baldur's gate, or even the adventure zone. (Or whatever else you feel like.) So long as it's you talking about it!
Two, those graphic novels eh? I feel more or less the same way. I don't think it will. But it's not exactly out of the question.
Either way, missed your stuff brah
a fallout fan too huh? well this gives me another reason to subscribe. also i watch your channel because you are entertaining and you make me laugh. you also aren't just some puppet that follows path that alot of people try to follow. you call out bs when you see it. you don't pretend its not there when it fits your ideas and ideals. you are someone that i know it sounds weird but you are someone that i feel i can trust even if we don't always agree. you have proofin yourself quiet rage. also my problem with the graphic novel is that most of the characters look the same, they do not try to make any of the characters look different or tell a story with their design. like tigerclaw doesn't even look scary to me. he looks like a brown fireheart. like when i think tigerclaw i see a massive brownish orange like tabby who is a scaryA$$ brute willing to do what it takes to get what he wants, even if he has to murder for it. fireheart i see as your basic good guy underdog or undercat heh, who can see pass borders and always has a opened mind to other's opinions even if those opinions are not from his own clan. to me he has your basic hero body type. and the last comparison is bluestar. bluestar is your respectable wise leader type who does what's right but also tries to keep a fine line between her clan and the others so they don't get in the way of her own clan's problems. she has the leader body type. she is not tigerclaw massive but she does have a strong body to her but she's kinda got a similar body to fireheart's in my opinion. okay one more i guess. graystripe to me is your goofy best friend type that is there for you even at your worse of times type. he is a descent warrior in combat but he's to me has a fluffy but more friendly and chubby appearance to him. and i know i just couldn't forget Silverstream. while i find buff silverstream interesting and maybe i'll try to make a design that mixes both designs of her some how but as i see her, she is a slim or sleek cat with silver fur with fur that is probably always shimmering like an otter's. she is probably very respected in her clan do to her father being leader which would probably give her this feeling of she could do whatever she wanted even if that meant possibly betraying her clan to date graystripe. crookedstar probably would never kick his daughter out lets be honest. also she probably kinda has a opened mind like fireheart does and she can see pass clan borders as well. now that being said that doesn't mean she would betray her clan. her family and friends are there afterall.
i personally think you can do what you want including not doing warriors content, you may just find new fans with it
They butchered the second book in the graphic novel 😢
What your top ten favorite warrior cat leaders
Tell me you didn’t watch the video without telling me you didn’t watch the video
11:32 it's actually an adaptation of both books.
specifically its into the wild and half of fire and ice
its been a while since been into warriors, my interpretation of blue star change, for me, now have tons of grey legs, many grey legs with a blue star in the middle. Wait... think mess up my notes cuz thats another blue star
Personally going off of certain stereotypes I think they're going in the opposite direction after all the typical mean girl personality is it really shown through with with big buff bodies where is the character design they're giving her if they do change your personality I think it's more going to go towards the direction of nerds girlfriend in the nerd and jock webtoon
Well... I came to you for your take on warrior cats. I stayed in hopes of getting more of that or sth else that could be great because it has you in it. Then I found out you love jojos. Our tastes can't be that different. whatever you end up doing, I'll probably like it. That's why I'm staying (pretty much forever).
When i saw the teaser for the 9th cycle I was royally pissed first the protagonist is forgettable and second why another quest we have enough with ivypool’s heart but no
Im just kind of reading wings of fire now, and reading all kinds of other books
Not flexing, but as bizarre as these changes are to Warriors, my AU oddly feels more bizarre, though that could largely be due to the fact that I merged FOUR FREAKING FANDOMS INTO ONE
You should play Dead by daylight
It was a bad decision!!
as someone who actually thinks series 7 and 8 are better than series 6 and 4 (yes, really), there’s no excusing series 9. i say that, and it hasn’t even come out yet- why?
well. moonpaw. the one new protagonist of the upcoming series… we know her design and we know her parentage. the latter? THEY MADE THEM FIRST COUSINS FROM THUNDERCLAN. sunbeam and nightheart? pfft, why would we choose such a fitting couple for her name? any other clan? hell no, protagonistclan never dies. i will not stop being salty about this.
yeah real the only thing im happy about her is moonpaw having a unique design, excited for the graphic novel however.
Quiet rage, maybe keep your rage quiet? For once?