Dr Taimoor Rehman's view on Zakat, and it's wrong again!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- In this video, Qaiser Ahmed Raja analyses Dr Taimoor Rehman's assertion over Zakat. Laal is known for making brash claims in the attempt to advocate for Marxism. His attempt on Zakat is no different!
Qaiser is a writer and a researcher of religion, science and philosophy. He is one of the very few voices who converse with reason. He is known for his ardent criticism of atheism and (Pakistani version of) liberalism.
For contact & queries hit the social media links given below.
Stay Blessed!
..................................................................................................................
Video Playlists
• Muslim Scientist
• Coronavirus
• Video Talks
• Personal Development T...
..................................................................................................................
Social Media Links
UA-cam / qaiserahmedraja
Facebook / qaiserahmedraja
Twitter
Linkedin www.linkedin.com/
Instagram www.instagram....
..................................................................................................................
#qaiserahmedraja
This is one of many issues we have. People suddenly become Mufti and start lecturing about Islamic topics." If you don't know about it, dont talk about it."
Zabardast point uthaye hen Qaisar bhai... Jazakallah kher..
Mind blowing and out standing video💓
Islam is really true love 💕 peace religion.
haahahhahahah.. tlp
Jo ap ne thumbnail me likha hai wo ap pe fit hota hai. Ap ne dr sahab ka lecture smjha hi nhi or un ke respond pe video daag daali. Rural and urban areas ko clear campaire kr ke btaya hai ke ghurbat dehaat me ziyada hai.
Tu? Dehaat ma zakat Di ja rahe ha urban se le k state k level pe? Us ka Sara argument is bat pe based ha k zakat is not effective because Pakistan is poor. But Pakistan doesn’t implement centralised zakat system
Aap parhy likhy nahi lag rahy
zindabad Qasier bai ❤️❤️👍👍🥰😍
asslamualaikum Qaiser bhai islamic economic system ke liye kis ko recommend kren ge ?
Humaraay muashray mai zulam ka aik aur izaafa. Abh Paisa hamaraay liyaa itna eham hogayaa hai keh hum abh Zakat jaisay muqadas fareezay par bhi sawaal uthaaingay😡😡😡
There shows criticism in your lecture about Dr Taimoor Rahman, in your previous lecture regarding islamic economic system, you didn't tell anything what to do, what is islamic economic system? You only made your views disagreed with Dr sahab, if there's any way of applying this system kindly make a video
I have also seen his many anti-pakistani posts on social media.
Anti-Islam too
Maa Shaa ALLAH
Hum india ke muslim se request h ke jakat bilkul na de kayoki hamare desh ka paisa bahar jata hai or hum kau kisi bahri garib ko apana paisa de hamre desh me bahut garib hai
JazakAllah
Sir aap kay subscribers kitnay ho gai hain show he nai hotay 🙂 keep going very informative video
Sir bat ye hai Jo mairi samjh main Aya hai k gheer muslimo ny apna system Bana k Chala rahy Hain logo ko Dekha rahy Hain k humara system behter hai chal Raha hai leken afsus ki bat ye hai... Islam Ka system Deen Ka system hum musleman itni counties Hony k bawajud bhe Chala sky hum kis base pe kehty Hain humara system sub se behter hai??? JB k hum khud is system pe nhe chal skty . ...
Brother, firstly we have to understand and learn the system and then it would possible to implement by having a well-disceplineed organization. My personal view 😊
Access to land to landless people not to become zamindar.
Provide name of any muslim country who is running on Islamic law.
Lv u Sir Qaiser.
Sir ap na koi book likhi ha?
😂zaroori ha kia
@@nirwang4224 Sir k pas ilm kafi lgta ha , ma amja maybe inho na koi liki ho
Mashaallah
It seems you want become famous after criticising Dr. Rahman. As you didn't understand his lecture on zakat.
His point was zakat can not eradicate poverty. Do you have any ayat to substantiate your claim or any sahih hadeeth to prove your point that zakat for eradication of poverty.
Capitalism main zakat effective naa honay pay case studies chahiyee arguments ke depth chahaye lakin Marxism mai effective naa honay Kaylie Qaisar sahb ka kah dainaa he kaafi hai.
Kindly debate karnii hai toh hawa main batain toh naa karain...
With all due respect, it is pretty clear why doctor sahab blocked you on twitter. Your understanding of socialism, capitalism, private ownership, and even the zamindar system is severely lacking to put it nicely. All you did in this video is attack strawman arguments. Also your view of the holodomor famine seems to be totally influenced by western propaganda. I highly recommend reading some texts by Marx and Engels to have a better understanding of what doctor sahab is saying.
Zamindari ko sahi sabit kar raha hai
❤️
🤲🤲🕋❤️❤️❤️
Laal prhaa likha jahil biased insan ha.. bs upr upr se lgta bht achi bat kr rhaaa asal me chwliyan hoti ha
Agar hai effective toh phir logo ke paas food ki kami nhi honi chahiye
G bilkul. Abhi kami ha q k zakat ki jaga oppressive tax le kar ap ki hakumat aur military elite billionaire bante hain aur imf ko sood dete hain karzo pe.
@@Fundamental_Islam. Name it whatever you want.
@@meowkitty3100 no please 🙏 use some common sense. Zakat is given to needy in the society. It’s is not used to enrich rich politicians and bajwas or soodi institutes. Zakat is purely the right of poor. They are given employment with that money, their debts are payed off, those who can’t work get monthly wazifa, zakat money is invested in given services like clean water, education, health care etc. in your country 80% ppl don’t even have clean water to drink. So where’s zakat?
@@Fundamental_Islam. Can you build balance of power with mere Zakat? A person who owns 1 billion dollars can easily manipulate Zakat system by giving it to some poor person he employs, then taking the money back after showing the government. Understand Zakat's purpose. It's to help the poor. When another financial system is built over helping the poor in a deeper way then why do you object?
@@meowkitty3100 oh God 🤦🏻♀️
Do you know zakat is a centralised system in Islam? Government collects it and government distributes it. And yes it helped when it was implemented:
“Zakat was the surplus of people that erased their needs at that time to that extent that a man would pay his Zakat but there was nobody eligible to receive” (As-Sallabi, 1999, p574)
🌹🙂
Waiting for someone to reply this pseudo atheist
محترم آپ کو نہ اسلام کی نالج ہے نہ جدید مغربی فلسفہ و نظاموں کی، آپ مجھے تھرڈ لیئر آف انٹلیکچول سے بھی نیچے کے معلوم ہوئے۔
Isko sub pta h,sabse zyda or sabse accha.topic koi bhi ho. economy,education,religion,science,philosophy all rounder h ye...🤣🤣🤣🤣
Beta q ki unone Padha he kafi saari chize...
Pehle malum kar liya karo chize
@@rizvvan21 or .beta jiska kaam hi padhana h usne kitna padha hoga???
(y)
Soft jihadi.....hahahaha....logo ka vivek islam ki ninv hila dega
Kesar raja aap ek molvi bankr reh gye... Kuchh naee baat kro. Science per bolo
Don't act like idiot
@@hafizosamanizami1377 is ganje ke baal lg waado is ke face per white collar kro do insaan lagye ga kesar.... Sare pakistani mehk malik jese hai
Tu kyo bhuk raha hai kutta tuje kya roti chaheye😂😂😂😂
Ye jo Taimur rehman jesy surkhy hen ye koe nae baat krty hen wo gissy pity farsooda na qabil e itlaaq nariye ko alapty rehty hen qaisar bhai ny to phir ny so-called evolutionists ki bolti band krwadi hy
Zakat fitra sdka sb mulla kha jate hai.. Jin ka haq hai wo bhooke Mr rahe hai
Mulla tere bap hai tu mang le 😂😂😂
@@op-le9lb Sare ulmao ki londiya ki chooot
Tu de de phir jinka Haq hai
To iska mtlb ye kesy ho gya k zakat ka nizam galt h?
Agr mulla kha jata h to ja k pkro usy
Ye Indus Hospital, Edhi, SIUT, JDC, Selani Welfare Trust, shuakat khanun or injesi sekro charitable organization kiya apky walid sahab k pesu se chalti hen??
Qaisar Pakistan ko bchana hai to humein bry level pe islahat krni hon gi aur is trhan k logon ko mulk badr krna chahiye...
Lion 🦁 Of Islam. Qaiser Ahmed Raja❤️❤️❤️
Alhamdulillah, I found your channel because few days back I discussed this matter of zakat with my father after getting influenced by Dr. Taimur. Albeit, I was satisfied by my father’s reply but your answers added more clarity. Thank you and keep going, your views are guiding us. JazakAllah khair!
Qaiser bhai hum aapke sath hai please aap apni sari zindagi isi kaam me laga dijiye
mashaAllah ♥️
Londi ko halal krk tum ho gya khush
Aslam o alikm sister..apko pta hay aap hmara fakhr hay..Ap Mery liye dua kry me bhi apki trha deen ka kam kru.❤
Allah ap se bohat razi ho....Ameen
Mahshalllah ❤️ Allah apko Khush rakhe ❤️❤️
Love from Kashmir India.
Plz watch Sheikh Omar baloch.
@@aimgoal2453 who is he?
He is eminent scholar on islamic eschatology.watch on UA-cam.
@@aimgoal2453 Thank you! I have never heard this name before. I will check him out.
@@jaqazraf9728
WE HINDUS WORSHTP WOMEN
Yes, I agreel
But how to worship women according to
dharma ?
Brihadaraaryaka Upanishad 6.4.2
Prajapati said to Himself: "Well,
let Me make a firm basis for it
semen). So He created woman.
Having created her, He placed
her below and worshipped her.
Therefore one should worshipa
Woman, placing her below. He
(Prajapati) extended His organ
that projects and with it
impregnated her.
Ashamed this guy shares my name 🤦♂️
Lol
Jis tarah us daur ke Arab me nation ko yaad rakhne ke liye hifz karna aik majboori thi kiyunki us waqt na press thi aur na hi recording ka koyi system lekin aaj recording ki sahuliyat mojood hai tab yeh kehna ki hifz karna aaj zaruri hai galat dalayil hai. Jaise us daur me log unton par safar karte the tab aaj isko sabit karna ki aaj bhi oontoo par safar karna sahi hai
Thanks for your response
Even I was disturbed by his video
آپ کی بات محض مخالفت برآے مخالفت نظر آتی ہے جس میں دلیل اور علمیت برآے نام بھی نہیں ہے
یوکرائن کے بارے میں جھوٹ نہیں کہنا
Bomgian hi bongian , Islam ka koi economic system hai hi nahi. Islam nay hamesha running system hi adopt kia hai. Agar hai to explain karen
Ask dear Dr sahib to join me in a debate. I'll explain Islamic economic system and he will explain socialism. Pass my message on 🙂
Hmm…
usury haram (Quran 2:275 )
Fiat currency haram (Quran 7:85)
Zakat welfare system (Quran 9:60)
Jizya tax (Quran 9:29)
No price fixing (Sunan Abi Dawud 3451)
Open up books sometimes!!!
زکوۃ لینا اور دینا غیر اخلاقی ہے ۔ کسی کو دینا تو اسکی انا کی انتہائی توہین ہے اور لینا اسلام کی کمزوری ہے
بھائی جان زکوٰۃ حکومت کو دی جاتی ہے جیسے ٹیکس دیا جاتا ہے
اور حکومت اسے ریاست کی فلاح و بہبود کے لئے استعمال کرتی ہے
اب اس میں غیر اخلاقی کیا ہے ؟؟؟
@@hafizmalikabdurrehmanoffic407 وہ بات تو درست ہے لیکن اس حقیر ٹیکس کے انکار پر کسی کی جان لینا کونسا انصاف ہے ؟ ۔ باقی میں اس ادارہ حکومت انسانی آزادی کے خلاف سمجھتا ہوں اس کی ضرورت نہیں
Hum to qaisar bhai ke leye Allah se dua karte hen
I differ many of your ideas but ur view on zakat was correct. Hazart Abu bakar launched a crusade against zakat violators. It can be taken besides income tax. Because in taxation super tax can be imposed
There is possibility of human error no problem . Yet DR is a great asset , not in terms of expertise on islam but political science. If Raja sahib has hold on one subject , then Dr has on an another . Doesnt matter, alteast he is trying and researching , unlike most of the people , eating , working , fucking , sleeping .
Allah aapko Jaza e Khair ata kre...inshaAllah ham tamam Musalmano aur Ummate e Mustafa ka yahi Maqsad hona chahiye ki wo Islamic Kawaneen lagoo kre jisme har insaan k jaan sir maal ki hifazat ho aur zulm ko hukmraan ka darr.
Focus on other things than Taimur Rahman sb and the Engineer.
sir how you can vanish interest rate in Pakistan? than what is the alternate?
Yeh muslim zamindari sarmayedaroo ka bachao kar raha hai
Yeh shaksh Dr taimur rehman ki baat ko samajh hi nahi paya
Used multi type logical fallacy not fact
Dear muslims..I have 3 simple questions. Can you as a muslim answer my 3 basic questions about islam from the quran alone?
Here are those 3 questions as follows:
* who is the writer of quran?
* Where does Allah say in quran that quran was revealed to mohammed?
* Where does Allah say in quran that Mohammed is/ was a prophet?
Please answer word for word from the quran alone.
To whom the quran was revealed
Prophet muhammad saw taught the verses of the quran to the qatib e wahi
So , who else was the quran revealed to?
“As for those who believe, do good, and have faith in what has been revealed to Muḥammad-which is the truth from their Lord-He will absolve them of their sins and improve their condition.” (Quran 47:2)
“Muḥammad is not the father of [any] one of your men, but [he is] the Messenger of Allāh and seal [i.e., last] of the prophets. And ever is Allāh, of all things, Knowing.” (Quran 33:40)
Apka response is not very much logical there are so many this and thats included... aap ukrain ki example tu da rahy hain but china ki example nehi da rahy k unho na kis tharh grow kar lia... SOE kis tarah zayda competitve hoti hain apko learn karna chahy...
He didn’t say socialism is completely flawed watch again
Kak nahi patha aap ko
Why not more than 2.5 % . 2.5% is not mention in Quran but later adopted by Caliphs, it should be more than this according to basic needs of poors
Al-Bukhari (1454) narrated from Anas (may Allah be pleased with him) that Abu Bakr (may Allah be pleased with him) wrote to him this document when he sent him to Bahrain: “This is the obligatory charity that the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) enjoined upon the Muslims and that Allah enjoined upon His Messenger:… for silver, one quarter of one tenth.”
Abu Dawud (1572) narrated from ‘Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “If you have two hundred dirhams and one full year has passed, then five dirhams are due on them. You do not have to pay anything - i.e. on gold -- unless you have twenty dinars; if you have twenty dinars and one full year has passed, then half a dinar is due on them, and if the number increases then work it out on this basis.” (Classed as sahih by al-Albani in Sahih Abi Dawud)
Ibn Majah (1791) narrated from Ibn ‘Umar and `Aishah (may Allah be pleased with them both) that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) used to take from every twenty dinars or more, half a dinar, and from forty dinars, one dinar. (Classed as sahih by al-Albani in Sahih Ibn Majah)
Achi bongian mari hain. Zakaat 2.5% say aajtak koi problem solve hoi hai
“Mene tu bhht research ki ha bht history parli ha 🤡” jahil awam!!😂
“Zakat was the surplus of people that erased their needs at that time to that extent that a man would pay his Zakat but there was nobody eligible to receive” (Omer bin Abdul aziz by As-Sallabi, 1999, p574)
Very knowledgeable clip
یار زمین پر ہر انسان کا برابر کا حق حتی کہ عورت کا بھی اتنا ہی حق ہے جتنا حق مرد کا ہے ۔ مجھے یہ بتائیں کہ اک شخص یعنی زرداری کے پاس اتنی زمین ہے کہ اسکو پوری نہر سیراب کرتی ہے تو کسی کے اک مرلہ بھی نہیں ہے تو یہ تقسیم عادلانا ہونا چاہیے باقی ہر انسان کو پرائیویٹ ملکیت ملنی چاہیے تاکہ وہ اس پر محنت کرے اور اس سے اپنا اناج اور ضروریات زندگی حاصل کرے
باقی کیپٹل ازم بھی اتنا برا تصور نہیں ۔ بھوک سے بچاؤ کا حل اس میں حکومت کی ذمہ داری ہے
خیر میں ذاتی طور پر حکومت کے ادارے کو غیر ضروری سمجھتا ہوں معاشرہ اس کے بغیر بھی سروائیو کر سکتا ہے
Ar Rational insan ko pata hai wo kon kon sy influential Philosophers te Jino ne Scientifically prove kr diya k SOCIALISM wahid Solution hai jis me insaan k hatho insan ka istehsaal khatm ho sakta hai.
Lekin Mashallah ek to "Clerics " aur an to yhe modern CLERICS Khud Europe me ja kr Zindagi ka Maza lo aur Pakistan ha kr Jazbati Hujoom ko Superficial Batain btaho aur Science aur reason say dor dor in bato ka Wasta nai.
Fallacies ke illawa kuch aata hai weswy?
Kuch influencial philosophers ne allegedly prove krdiya k socialism answer h to Tum ne maan Liya or chahtey ho k hm bhi maaney?
Issey circular definition kehtey hn ' kyunki mere favorite log kehtey hn ye Sahi h to Sahi h '
What a brain dead thing to say lol!
Kon si science aur reason? K a random blast throwing particles here and there randomly, blindly created our eyes, kidneys, digestive systems, circulatory systems? Stop pretending to be scientific you know nothing about science.
And what solution does any of your socialist has for fiat currency frauds and usury based loans? Agr socialism itna acha ha tu why is China giving private farming and business?
Respected QAR Sahib, i think you made a wrong statement.
Hazrat Abu Bakkar RA had to fight who refused to pay Zakat to the center. They simply said that we will manage it locally instead of paying it to Baitul Maal.
So it is a centralised thing.
Hopefully i am wrong as i won't be happy to point out your mistake.
Please make separate video on islamic economic system
MA Sha Allah. Allah tala aap k Eman. Amal. Ilm or zindgi ma brkaat ata fermain. Ameen
I Love Sufism
From Lucknow
I love Islam
From Pakistan
Munafiq bhi apne ko islami kahlata hai
@@AslamKhan-qs6hc Allah Pak faisla kar lengey k kon Muslim hay aur kon munafiq.
Achi video..
thumbnail per kaam kiya jaey.
Very Superficial Counter
Scientific arguments Should be Countered with Scientific Arguments...
Hum mein Sub say bra Masla yahi hai k apne Chand saal ki Tujurbe k Circle me reh kr Poore Science ko Challenge krte hai.
Chai wo social Science ho ya Phir basic Science
What superficial arguments did you see Br Qaiser Ahmed give here?
Do you even understand superficial arguments?
Provide a logical ground to base your accusations otherwise what you said is not even superficial let alone scientific!
Qaiser bhai assalamu alaikum
Qaiser Raja why u r arrogant
Aman why are you acting like a kind
Lal ka na jaiz beta aa gya h
Hahahaha
Lal ko bhjo debate krny k liy
Qaiser raja ny open challenge kia tha lal ko
Lekin vo bhag gya
Qaise bhai is your mirror, now who is arrogant??
Where qaiser raja show arrogance??ik line likh ka comment kr dia bs.typical dull minded peoples
Qaiser sir rayasat ki zimedari ha zakat lena.. agr asa na hota to hz abu bakr sadique R.A munkar e zakat k khilaf larty ni..
This is for islamic State rather than anywhere.
@@qasmibook8710 zahir c bat ha.. jb b islam ki bat ki jati ha us mtlb islam ki rayast hi hti ha
@@decentali3399 ye kisne kahdiya k jan bhi islam ki baat hogi to riyasat hi murad hoga
bharat islami riyasat nhi to kya yahan ham islam ki baat na karen ?
Ye konsa logic hai.
this man do not know anything abour dr taimoor and his ideology. he constantly talked about academic standard but he himself did not follow that. like the way he is representing (rather strawmaning) dr taimoors argument on access to land i am sure he did now read any credible research on that. And he is ver comfortable to talk about Ukraine under Stalin but he will not speak the capitalist Adventures in Bengal by the east india company which killed 10 million after they won bengal and 3 million in WW2. please educate yourself first then try to refute a scholar like Dr taimoor.
Where did he support Capitalism?
Don't put words in others' mouth.
BTW, I've been listening to Dr. Taimur a lot and I respect him.
👍👍👍