Shattering Beauty to Pieces: Overthinking "The Substance"

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 23

  • @darillus1
    @darillus1 20 днів тому +3

    brooks' drive to produces high quality video essays is so over-whelming that he can not stop doing it.

  • @JeremiahShaferSimulacra
    @JeremiahShaferSimulacra 21 день тому +2

    I am looking forward to watching this movie once all my final assignments are done for the quarter.
    This video was really well done. The additional media, film clips, etc. really made this more of an experience.

  • @paulfletcher3454
    @paulfletcher3454 21 день тому +4

    I did stop the video and watched the film immediately. Thank you.

  • @RedBrite
    @RedBrite 9 днів тому

    7:20 lets goo music history 10-A vocab words!

  • @GayestWinston
    @GayestWinston 21 день тому +6

    god damnit I didn't know there was gonna be assignments for this >:(
    Alright, gotta watch the substance

  • @OK2BeFat
    @OK2BeFat 21 день тому +1

    This is really great! Thank you. 😄

  • @Marcus-143
    @Marcus-143 21 день тому +1

    Had to stop after the intro, haven't seen the movie yet and I shan't have it spoiled. Look forward to finishing the video after.

  • @TheProblem2025
    @TheProblem2025 22 дні тому +4

    Just got outa the theatre and I'm still shellshocked.

  • @darillus1
    @darillus1 21 день тому

    Love how you have sprinkled in deleuzian/ baudrillardian concepts into your breakdown of the movie

  • @emmasnow7478
    @emmasnow7478 18 днів тому

    Late boost but still boosting! Haven't watched the Substance, but I shall now.

    • @emmasnow7478
      @emmasnow7478 17 днів тому

      Wow. That was. I was not ready for that movie. Fuck. Thanks for the recommendation. And good video too. I think you hit all the right marks.

  • @romanticplacebo3693
    @romanticplacebo3693 7 днів тому

    I picked up on the repetition and how it was allowing us to consider them as one being rather than two consciousness, but I also interpreted Demi Moore's degeneration less about age and more about her reverting to the stuff underneath all our attempts at beauty, the cancer that is just the elementary nature of our cells. This is what elevated the film from self-hatred in my eyes but you made an excellent case for her being a "Picasso of images" summoned by our gaze. I love how people were surprised by the film and my only worry is the Content being made convincing people that it's credibility of feminism is whether we find it sympathetic to Elizabeth or our own experiences. I suppose the test will be how well it can be reified into our culture as a success or failure, or if traces of it are retained in viewers...

    • @DGQC
      @DGQC  6 днів тому +1

      In five year it’ll be interesting to see what the ‘concensus’ tells us looking back

  • @lurtz8656
    @lurtz8656 21 день тому +2

    Can't finish the video yet, planning on watching this this week (planned to last week but, got distracted for... reasons)

  • @onedova2298
    @onedova2298 День тому

    Finally watched it! The movie is rentable in amazon👍

  • @MocknozzieRiver
    @MocknozzieRiver 9 днів тому

    I did it. I stopped and watched the movie then watched this. Do you have any videos you'd recommend of cute puppies and kittens? 😅
    Great video the movie just took me a bit by surprise.

  • @defmeta
    @defmeta 21 день тому +1

    For the algorians! and have you seen From Beyond?

  • @grizzleknowsbest
    @grizzleknowsbest 21 день тому

    For the wrinkles!

  • @grizzleknowsbest
    @grizzleknowsbest 21 день тому

    And what an anxiety inducing thumbnail you have there, my pretty...not just for the women, let me tell you.

  • @TheCinemaDetective
    @TheCinemaDetective 19 днів тому

    Thanks, I very much enjoyed your take. Yours is easily one of the better videos analysing the movie and I shared your desire to go beyond the surface level message in my own video analysis.
    In my view, this horrific drive that you speak of is the deep, universal impulse for meaning and significance-chasing beauty is one way it manifests but ultimately it's the drive for a meaningful existence. Not just a drive to survive but a relentless drive to matter and to "have substance," to be valued and seen.
    Your take on Monsto being a sort of mash-up of compartmentalised and commodified beauty is interesting. I think Fargeat has said that Monstro was like a Picasso of beauty-fragmented and distorted, yet assembled from familiar elements. For me she's also a mash-up of all the identities that spring from the matrix over a lifetime in the drive to find meaning and significance in her life. In a sense she is a representation of this existential horror, for me Monsto wasn't what she became but what she always was behind the mask and that's what terrifies society. As Monstro she sees all aspects of herself, she see's this fragmentation that you speak of, she also see's all the layers of her identity, and she accepts them. In my reading, she's not pure compulsion until after she breaks a leg and loses her bodily form.
    Thanks again for a great video!

    • @DGQC
      @DGQC  19 днів тому

      The moment of leg loss is an interesting pivot point for that. I’ll have to consider. For me, her pure drive continued but did so through what she could do - slowly inch her way to her star.