The end bit was the icing on the cake for me and should be for everyone. One side calls upon Allah and the other side calls upon the Messenger of Allah. May Allah guide us all.
The truth is clear, wallahi I don't know how anyone can deny after watching this. Stay away from shirk! May Allah guide us and keep us on the right path
*Why is it a debate to supplicate directly to Allah when Allah has commanded us to SUPPLICATE to Him alone through the Noble Quran and the authentic sunnah?* _rather than directly through the dead._ *Greetings to the Prophet (pbuh) is not a dispute rather SUPPLICATING to him DIRECTLY is a grave disobedience.* May Allah reward Ustadh AbdulRahman.
Allaahu akbar The last two rounds defined the whole debate. Asrar came with all of his shubuhaat in his last round, and Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan absolutely crushed him. Hope he calls him out for a debate around the asmaa and sifaat. May Allaah azza wa djall reward our Ustadh, and may he guide the sufis
shyik Asrare"s evidences are completely destroyed .And say, "Truth has come, and falsehood has departed. Indeed is falsehood, [by nature], ever bound to depart.17;81
The last 2 sentences summed up the whole debate and the aqeedah of the 2 parties... Allahu akbar and ya rasulallah, common sense and logic says the haqq is with allahuakbar. May allah unite us and guide us all to the truth, if we were united then there is no way our lands and ppl wud b in the state they r
Somthing for the viewers to think about why would you risk being in the hell fire for eternity aswell as well as losing all your good deeds for somthing your teacher claims is only recommended. and the worst part is that you all know the best of our ummah the most beloved to Allah from our Ummah the Sahabah never did it. just ponder over these words only a person with no intellect would risk their whole religion by asking help of other then Allah. I ask Allah to guide us all to the truth.
Subhan Allah, one is asking you to ask Allāh سبحانه وتعالى directly because he تعالى said: ادعوني أستجب لكم ان الذين يستكبرون عن عبادتي سيدخلون جهنم داخرين "Call upon me and I will surely respond to you. Verily those who disdane from my worship will enter Hell fire humiliated". While the other is asking you toopposs the words of the Messneger صلى الله عليه وسلم: "When you ask then ask Allāh". And his asking youvto call upon the dead. Which if the two positions fits into the sound mind
allhamduliiah very complicated debate half the words used hard hard for normal people to understand but still the truth was prevailed walahi only ask allah alone for help outstanding.
SubhanAllah I can't believe this debate is taking place when it's so clear cut! The prophet PBUH COMPLETED this deen, even taught us how to eat and drink. IF we were supposed to ask him for help after his death surely he WOULD have taught us this too!!!!! Gosh, when these people pray "iyyakanasta-een" the response from the heavens must be, "no you don't you liar"
ustadh Abdul Rahman Hassan is a gem from ALLAH mashallah the end part of the video when. the people said allahu akbar and they said ya rasoolullah lol. ustadh Abdul Rahman Hassan ripped asrar Rashid apart.
asrar is being too academic at times. he addresses solely ustadh abdurrahman but ustadh abdurrahman is addressing the layman when answering asrars questions
jazaka Allah khair brother ibn mansur for uploading this debate and for all your effort may Allah reward you and your family abundantly , i think it must have taken alot of your time
So far Asrar hasnt brought any textual evidences or daleel from Quran or Sunnah where its permissible to call on tha dead be it 'Awliya' or Rasool rather he resorted to tha usual trickery whereby he wants Abdurahman has to prove the impressibility of it .. Asrar funny enough is busyin himself on scorin points correctin grammar or 'notq' pronunciation n he got schooled on it ... Tha last part 'amazed' me Subhan'Allah in Conclusion tho History for centuries has stayed da same exactly like a fox they do 'Makr' and when caught n faced they do 'Farr'
![DEBATE: Can You Make Du'a To The Prophet ﷺ After His Death? [PART 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oG7ZYk5_RhE/mqdefault.jpg)
![DEBATE: Can You Make Du'a To The Prophet ﷺ After His Death? [PART 1]](/img/tr.png)
![DEBATE CUT OUT PARTS - Can You Make Du'a To The Prophet ﷺ After His Death? [PART 3]](/img/n.gif)
The last statement of Ustadh Abdulrahman Hasan at the end of the video epitomises the whole debate - "We say AllahuAkbar, they say Yaa RasoolAllah"
The end bit was the icing on the cake for me and should be for everyone. One side calls upon Allah and the other side calls upon the Messenger of Allah. May Allah guide us all.
The truth is clear, wallahi I don't know how anyone can deny after watching this. Stay away from shirk! May Allah guide us and keep us on the right path
*Why is it a debate to supplicate directly to Allah when Allah has commanded us to SUPPLICATE to Him alone through the Noble Quran and the authentic sunnah?* _rather than directly through the dead._ *Greetings to the Prophet (pbuh) is not a dispute rather SUPPLICATING to him DIRECTLY is a grave disobedience.* May Allah reward Ustadh AbdulRahman.
SubhanAllah very clear to understand islam by Ustadh Abdul Rehman , barakAllahu feek.
Abu Taymiyyah can't stop smiling mashallah
did they try to overshadow praise of Allah with the praise of the Prophet peace be upon him in the end? what is this madness
the end clarified it all masha allah.. may allah guide us and take away narrow mindedness and make understanding the haqq easy for us
Allaahu akbar
The last two rounds defined the whole debate. Asrar came with all of his shubuhaat in his last round, and Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan absolutely crushed him. Hope he calls him out for a debate around the asmaa and sifaat. May Allaah azza wa djall reward our Ustadh, and may he guide the sufis
shyik Asrare"s evidences are completely destroyed .And say, "Truth has come, and falsehood has departed. Indeed is falsehood, [by nature], ever bound to depart.17;81
May Allah reward our brother abdulrahman
The last 2 sentences summed up the whole debate and the aqeedah of the 2 parties... Allahu akbar and ya rasulallah, common sense and logic says the haqq is with allahuakbar. May allah unite us and guide us all to the truth, if we were united then there is no way our lands and ppl wud b in the state they r
Somthing for the viewers to think about why would you risk being in the hell fire for eternity aswell as well as losing all your good deeds for somthing your teacher claims is only recommended.
and the worst part is that you all know the best of our ummah the most beloved to Allah from our Ummah the Sahabah never did it.
just ponder over these words only a person with no intellect would risk their whole religion by asking help of other then Allah.
I ask Allah to guide us all to the truth.
Subhan Allah, one is asking you to ask Allāh سبحانه وتعالى directly because he تعالى said:
ادعوني أستجب لكم ان الذين يستكبرون عن عبادتي سيدخلون جهنم داخرين
"Call upon me and I will surely respond to you. Verily those who disdane from my worship will enter Hell fire humiliated".
While the other is asking you toopposs the words of the Messneger صلى الله عليه وسلم:
"When you ask then ask Allāh". And his asking youvto call upon the dead.
Which if the two positions fits into the sound mind
allhamduliiah very complicated debate half the words used hard hard for normal people to understand but still the truth was prevailed walahi only ask allah alone for help outstanding.
SubhanAllah I can't believe this debate is taking place when it's so clear cut! The prophet PBUH COMPLETED this deen, even taught us how to eat and drink. IF we were supposed to ask him for help after his death surely he WOULD have taught us this too!!!!! Gosh, when these people pray "iyyakanasta-een" the response from the heavens must be, "no you don't you liar"
Ended the debate on the right note Ma'sha'Allah
1:20:25, ENDED THE DEBATE. Asrars rashids whole concept of Tawheed got broken to pieces just by one reference.
Brother, by the will of allah you killed it out there💯 allahuakbar
ustadh Abdul Rahman Hassan is a gem from ALLAH mashallah the end part of the video when. the people said allahu akbar and they said ya rasoolullah lol. ustadh Abdul Rahman Hassan ripped asrar Rashid apart.
May Allah SWT reward you naseeha sessions and ppl who gave clarifications Allahumbarik
Iyya kana'budu wa iyya kanasta'een-' You alone we worship and You alone we ask for help'- end of discussion. Basic.
We all know who won alhamdlilallah
2:04:17 When the Ash'aris start having a bid'ah attack.
The end bit 😂 sub han Allah
1:58:17 debate OVER
Maa shaa Allah!!! 💯
asrar is being too academic at times. he addresses solely ustadh abdurrahman but ustadh abdurrahman is addressing the layman when answering asrars questions
jazaka Allah khair brother ibn mansur for uploading this debate and for all your effort may Allah reward you and your family abundantly , i think it must have taken alot of your time
where is stick? he argument needed something to stand on.
54:22 did Ustadh just speak Somali? Lol May Allah bless him and grant him highest place in jannatul Firdaus a'laa
+Ameera Ahmed yh lol i thought so too. hadhaw baan ka hadlaynaa lol
Yeah something like this
+Lol lel yeah he did and if you were wondering what he said, he said we will be talking about it later
lool i noticed it too
ma sha allah ustadh ARH is a very good speaker.
Asrar needs to get to the point he goese round in circles
Maa Shaa Allah
Brother Abdul Rahman you nailed it Man
SubanAllah
asrar got ripped apart
So far Asrar hasnt brought any textual evidences or daleel from Quran or Sunnah where its permissible to call on tha dead be it 'Awliya' or Rasool rather he resorted to tha usual trickery whereby he wants Abdurahman has to prove the impressibility of it .. Asrar funny enough is busyin himself on scorin points correctin grammar or 'notq' pronunciation n he got schooled on it ... Tha last part 'amazed' me Subhan'Allah in Conclusion tho History for centuries has stayed da same exactly like a fox they do 'Makr' and when caught n faced they do 'Farr'
Alhamdulillah
1:57:20 Asrar biting his fingers in confusion, he knows he messed up big time.
ALLAHU AKBAR!!!! 😄😄😄😄😄
at 1.49.38 can someone please tell me where to find that statment of Abdullah ibn mubarak? it's gold and I really want to know where to find it please
54:22 Did the Sheikh just speak in somali for a sec?
Allah hu Akbar
جزاكم الله خيرا
just finished this part, bring on the next
yes yes yes
:)
1st as usual.
lool
first