I think A-Train in the TV Show is a vast improvement over the comic version in every way. He's also one of the few times I think a race swap for a character actually worked as an improvement over the original, in my opinion. This show does surprisingly well in that department. But here is the reason I think this was an improvement; Black athletes and celebrities who come from poor backgrounds often get accused of being sell outs, A-Train's character embodies this completely. He only refers to his background or race when it can benefit him, but outside of that he doesn't really give a shit about his roots or his community. (In the beginning at least) Also the young Athlete who's gifted with too much money and power too soon, is another common thing for black athletes. Everything about this works so well and organically together to make his character believable. And of course his redemption arc is amazing
A-Train, Noir, Soldier Boy, and Maeve probably are the characters that (in comparison to everyone else at least), got the biggest upgrades in the show compared to the comics. 🙏❤️
@@starwalker6771 so soilder boy wasnt just one guy it was a name passed down, the original soldier boy was closer to the shows version with the green suit but him and the next soilder boy after him died on missions and the one u see in the shorts is the 3rd soilder boy. I guess hes in shorts just to make him less threatning, hes just a joke character in the comic that only shows up to get taken advantage of then killed. Hes just a scared baby.
Either him or The Deep both have similar arcs of redemption , one showing the capacity for moving on from his debauchery and evil and the other incapable
The TV series greatly improves all the characters to be frank, but ironically enough, it makes Homelander even more evil despite giving him more nuance
Marvelous Videos forgot to censor the 3 of the 7's butts in around the 12:51 and 13:48 minute marks despite censoring the aame panel at the beginning of the video.
This version of A-Train from the TV series seems to influence me a lot more than his garbage counterpart from the comics. He gives me an idea for an ideal anti-hero for my original project. Still, it would be awesome in the final season to see The Deep in the place of comic A-Train having his head kicked up in the air by Hughie in the show and have it dropped down into the water, where a shark eats his head.
So, quick question for anyone with regards to A train in the books: Do you think he's hispanic or a tanned american of european descent?? To me, it might be the latter.
It’s crazy how seeing Black people in a positive or empowering image is now too “Political” 😂😂😂 It ain’t got shit to do with politics just say You Don’t Like Us 🤷🏾♂️
I think the Deep and A train’s characters are completely swapped. The deep is taken more seriously in the comics and A train in the show. Also the race swap the Deep being African American and A train being Hispanic in the comics.
Frankly I wonder what would happen if A Train struck HomeLander going as fast as he possibly could knowing he’d only likely get one shot. He has some as of yet underdetermined strength but couple that with his speed it has to be impressive. In the end it’s his best shot.
@@morg4620 I have seen videos talking about it that's why I think that without reading it. I plan on still reading it but from what I know, the show is way better
Uh… no, the narrative has shown time and time again that A-Train is the fastest Supe, like in the Musical Play episode when A-Train carried Hughie away from Homelander at such speeds that Homelander wasn't even able to react, and at his top speeds, Homelander is Mach 3, A-Train with a heart injury that severely slowed his running speed, was able to clock around Mach 2.
@@TryingForSomethingNew The show and the comics have both shown Homelander to be faster than Atrain. In the show Atrain wasnt even the fastest speedster, he needed V to beat Shockwave.
@@ajax201000 his heart was also failing, not really a fair comparison, he was working at 30% speed and needed an enhancer to make up for it, also, in the comics, there's a scene where A-Train catches Homelander crying, and when Homelander notices him and attempts to give chase, A-Train blitzes past him.
@@TryingForSomethingNew He didnt know that at the time and he thought he needed compound v. Theres also a scene in the comics where Homelander tags Atrain at extreme speeds. Also in the show Homelander saves butcher from a literal explosion (as its exploding) and unless im mistaken we havent seen Atrain travel that fast in the show. Even from a logical standpoint Homelander is physically stronger which means he can technically run faster than Atrain or fly faster than him. Atrain cannot tap in to the speedforce or anything like that whichbis the only reason the Flash could run faster than Superman. Plus the whole point of Homelander is that he is the strongest, most invulnerable and most fastest supe. No one alive can who has any if his powers (flight, speed, strength etc) is more powerful than Homelander.
i have mixed feelings about this: on one hand, I want to say that they made him black because we're living in such a politically correct era. On the other hand tv show a train does have such an amazing character arc, dev, etc. i wonder if it would have been the same if he were portrayed white? I don't think so. But why not leave him white and with the comic version? We have that with the deep. But then again we wouldn't get such an amazing character. idk..
The show got super woke. Homelander is an allegory for Donald Trump and Starlight is an allegory for AOC. The comic didn't do that. They're completely different stories being told with some of the same characters.
adaptations of comics dont always have to be an exact copy of the original. if they were, almost nobody would like the show as everyone dislikes the comics. adaptations allow for creativity to show & tell new stories/perspectives. everyone likes the show over the comics so its good that it's completely different. comic accuracy doesnt always mean good storytelling. also the show has always been woke, if youre just now realising then you havent been paying that much attention from the beginning.
The show has never been woke people are just made because it went from making fun of sjws to conservative far rights it just means no one is safe from the show kinda like South Park
@@koolaidpurple the problem the writing got worse, now everything gets back to status quo, nothing moves forward, that makes the woke part too much more evident and more distracting, there was a structure following along S01 and then some S02, but fell apart on S03... and I think they don't know what to do with the characters as a whole now.., they will just keep stretching the story, without major changes. They already ran out of Comic material, that tale was not that long, only thing left is the shock value, but gets old after a while. Feels more like "pervert of the week' structure now..
Your grammar sucks, but we can’t all have what we want, huh? I think you suck, but in the big picture what I think doesn’t matter, what makes you think you’re opinion is any different.
@@Adeycoola pure evil. seriously what makes a villain more mysterious when you barely know one passed. or hell even have a personality. I honestly getting tired of the boo-hoo background story. people forget what true evil looks like or is.
I think A-Train in the TV Show is a vast improvement over the comic version in every way. He's also one of the few times I think a race swap for a character actually worked as an improvement over the original, in my opinion. This show does surprisingly well in that department. But here is the reason I think this was an improvement;
Black athletes and celebrities who come from poor backgrounds often get accused of being sell outs, A-Train's character embodies this completely. He only refers to his background or race when it can benefit him, but outside of that he doesn't really give a shit about his roots or his community. (In the beginning at least)
Also the young Athlete who's gifted with too much money and power too soon, is another common thing for black athletes. Everything about this works so well and organically together to make his character believable. And of course his redemption arc is amazing
What race swap??
@@ilyjawanni In the original comics A-Train isn't black he's white
@@jairusjackson7799 ngl in the comics he looks like a black dude with a white hairstyle
@jairusjackson7799 A-Train isn't white in the comics. Take a closer look his skin tone is only slightly lighter than the Deep's there.
TV show A Train is 10 times better than his comic book counterpart. So happy to see him redeeming himself
A-Train, Noir, Soldier Boy, and Maeve probably are the characters that (in comparison to everyone else at least), got the biggest upgrades in the show compared to the comics.
🙏❤️
@@darkclaw1462 especially soilder boy😂
@@FrmDa505why was he wearing short pants?
@@starwalker6771 so soilder boy wasnt just one guy it was a name passed down, the original soldier boy was closer to the shows version with the green suit but him and the next soilder boy after him died on missions and the one u see in the shorts is the 3rd soilder boy. I guess hes in shorts just to make him less threatning, hes just a joke character in the comic that only shows up to get taken advantage of then killed. Hes just a scared baby.
I was hoping to see hugie getting his revenge for robin, like in the comic, but hugie and the temp v is also really different in the comic, too bad.
But yes, A-Train in the show is a MUCH better character!
I feel sad that A-Train is going to die this season. The only comfort is that he was able to right a wrong with Hughie.
😮
Either him or The Deep both have similar arcs of redemption , one showing the capacity for moving on from his debauchery and evil and the other incapable
The TV series greatly improves all the characters to be frank, but ironically enough, it makes Homelander even more evil despite giving him more nuance
Major difference: A-Train actually has an arc in the show
A-Trains redemption curve would create an interesting dilemma for Hughie.
Hughie already forgave him after he got him the V for his dad.
@@animator049 What??? I haven't got that far! 😄
@@ExMachina70 this why you dont look at a review channels comments.
@@UncleQuille1 I know! I know! I keep telling myself that, but the lure of the comment section exceeds my will not to look.
Where have you been brother? 😅
Marvelous Videos forgot to censor the 3 of the 7's butts in around the 12:51 and 13:48 minute marks despite censoring the aame panel at the beginning of the video.
This version of A-Train from the TV series seems to influence me a lot more than his garbage counterpart from the comics. He gives me an idea for an ideal anti-hero for my original project. Still, it would be awesome in the final season to see The Deep in the place of comic A-Train having his head kicked up in the air by Hughie in the show and have it dropped down into the water, where a shark eats his head.
I think, the show is better than the comics
Did you read the comics?
@@Joseph_Joestar_da_goat, I did, and I think the show is better than the comics.
A-Train Redemption ✊🏾✊🏾✊🏾
Atrain jokes about running through robin in the show too
i thought a-train in the comics was hispanic
Great break down❤❤❤
So, quick question for anyone with regards to A train in the books:
Do you think he's hispanic or a tanned american of european descent?? To me, it might be the latter.
It’s crazy how seeing Black people in a positive or empowering image is now too “Political” 😂😂😂 It ain’t got shit to do with politics just say You Don’t Like Us 🤷🏾♂️
"without any further delay.." goes on to talk a load of shit
Hey guys I know a difference!
I think the Deep and A train’s characters are completely swapped. The deep is taken more seriously in the comics and A train in the show. Also the race swap the Deep being African American and A train being Hispanic in the comics.
Frankly I wonder what would happen if A Train struck HomeLander going as fast as he possibly could knowing he’d only likely get one shot. He has some as of yet underdetermined strength but couple that with his speed it has to be impressive. In the end it’s his best shot.
Nothing would really happen. His travel speed is only like Mach 1
HE'S BLA-
That’s aw😢😊esome
I haven't read the comics only the show but the show seems so much better. Comic version seems like garbage honestly.
How can you call it garbage when you haven't read it.Read the comics. You will see it's not garbage
@@morg4620 I have seen videos talking about it that's why I think that without reading it. I plan on still reading it but from what I know, the show is way better
A-Train was stupid, is that a difference?
Show >>>>>
the show has already established that homelander is faster than atrain
Uh… no, the narrative has shown time and time again that A-Train is the fastest Supe, like in the Musical Play episode when A-Train carried Hughie away from Homelander at such speeds that Homelander wasn't even able to react, and at his top speeds, Homelander is Mach 3, A-Train with a heart injury that severely slowed his running speed, was able to clock around Mach 2.
@@TryingForSomethingNewhis speed in the race was mach 1.3
@@TryingForSomethingNew The show and the comics have both shown Homelander to be faster than Atrain. In the show Atrain wasnt even the fastest speedster, he needed V to beat Shockwave.
@@ajax201000 his heart was also failing, not really a fair comparison, he was working at 30% speed and needed an enhancer to make up for it, also, in the comics, there's a scene where A-Train catches Homelander crying, and when Homelander notices him and attempts to give chase, A-Train blitzes past him.
@@TryingForSomethingNew He didnt know that at the time and he thought he needed compound v. Theres also a scene in the comics where Homelander tags Atrain at extreme speeds. Also in the show Homelander saves butcher from a literal explosion (as its exploding) and unless im mistaken we havent seen Atrain travel that fast in the show.
Even from a logical standpoint Homelander is physically stronger which means he can technically run faster than Atrain or fly faster than him. Atrain cannot tap in to the speedforce or anything like that whichbis the only reason the Flash could run faster than Superman.
Plus the whole point of Homelander is that he is the strongest, most invulnerable and most fastest supe. No one alive can who has any if his powers (flight, speed, strength etc) is more powerful than Homelander.
Obviously, he's black in the show. 😂
Doesn’t matter
And? The deep is black in the show
@@enon8116 And? That's a main difference.
@@Chinler887 Kinda does. If we're talking about differences in both iterations.
@@enon8116 Black? The Deep is white on the show! Either you never seen the show or you're delusional.
Affrimative train.
i have mixed feelings about this: on one hand, I want to say that they made him black because we're living in such a politically correct era. On the other hand tv show a train does have such an amazing character arc, dev, etc. i wonder if it would have been the same if he were portrayed white? I don't think so. But why not leave him white and with the comic version? We have that with the deep. But then again we wouldn't get such an amazing character. idk..
The deep and Atrain switched roles. In the coming the deep is black and has to deal with racism, and Atrain in the comics is just as bad as the deep
@@alwaysmarlin6657 yeah. Sounds like it all worked out.
do your research first. the deep what black
Y’all white folks seeing black people as a political negative is hilarious 😂😂😂
White people can’t run so honestly it’s a no brainer
Can't wait for A-train to die. Maybe Homelander can fly straight through him.
The show got super woke. Homelander is an allegory for Donald Trump and Starlight is an allegory for AOC. The comic didn't do that. They're completely different stories being told with some of the same characters.
Show was always woke but I’m happy you are finally figuring that out
adaptations of comics dont always have to be an exact copy of the original. if they were, almost nobody would like the show as everyone dislikes the comics. adaptations allow for creativity to show & tell new stories/perspectives. everyone likes the show over the comics so its good that it's completely different. comic accuracy doesnt always mean good storytelling. also the show has always been woke, if youre just now realising then you havent been paying that much attention from the beginning.
The show has never been woke people are just made because it went from making fun of sjws to conservative far rights it just means no one is safe from the show kinda like South Park
@@koolaidpurple the problem the writing got worse, now everything gets back to status quo, nothing moves forward, that makes the woke part too much more evident and more distracting, there was a structure following along S01 and then some S02, but fell apart on S03... and I think they don't know what to do with the characters as a whole now.., they will just keep stretching the story, without major changes. They already ran out of Comic material, that tale was not that long, only thing left is the shock value, but gets old after a while. Feels more like "pervert of the week' structure now..
got woke? You were blind for first 3 seasons :P ARe you one of those who thought Homelander was the good guy in this story? :D :D :D
The show suck. Why cant we have flat out evil villains.
Wait do you mean villains born pure evil or just became irredeemable due to their environment like Homelander?
Your grammar sucks, but we can’t all have what we want, huh? I think you suck, but in the big picture what I think doesn’t matter, what makes you think you’re opinion is any different.
@@Adeycoola pure evil. seriously what makes a villain more mysterious when you barely know one passed. or hell even have a personality. I honestly getting tired of the boo-hoo background story. people forget what true evil looks like or is.
@@NerdXZ-pn4nt so like Frieza or the Green Goblin right?
@@Adeycoola yes