Why TDX and TDS should NOT be comparable!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 вер 2024
- In this video, I stray away from the normal format i'm used to, to discuses the relationship between TDX and TDS and why they SHOULDN'T be compared! Let me know if you enjoyed this time of content so I can make more like it in the future!
Oh yeah and join my discord server!!
/ discord
#roblox #towerdefensex #tdx #robloxtowerdensex #towerdefensexroblox #tdxroblox
i want the sweet succulent juggernaut
دهست أكثر من 10 منازل في كولورادو لاحقًا، وجدت قاعدة للكائنات الفضائية 👽👽😱😱 لقد أعطوني مسدس ليزر قوي جدًا بعد أن جاء الملك جونغ أون وأعطاني سلاحًا نوويًا لألعبه في القطب الجنوبي 🎅🏿 لكنه انتهى في الشرق تايوان بعد ذلك أكلت 35 بطيخة🍉
@@Russia0987me too 😊
my man is speaking fax@@Russia0987
juggernaut is such mid tower shotgunner better
@@MilitaryGuy1v5tBOSNIANARMYyou said Ttd is better than tdx and tds so your opinion doesn’t count
I love how people compare a BETA game to a full game, is crazy.
Tdx ise still in beta to but i think they forgot to remoove it from the thing 😂
Tbh I think it first started with tdx fans debating on what td game is better
it is still in beta, because there is not that much content in tdx right now..@@Display.Offline
more of your opinion tbh@@thatduck4928
and the beta game wins honestly lol in tds if i play with multiple people i get kicked but in tdx I PUT FULL GRAPHICS AND WARSHIP SPAM AND NO KICK WITH MULTIPLE PEOPLE.
this is just so damn true
I've had enough when both communities beef each other
Instead the *REAL ONE* that should be beefed is ttd
YESSSSS!!!!!! that frigging game is straight up p2w and SUPER BORING!!!!.I like the series and the other versions but the game? (ttd in particular) nah
Bros speaking facts🗣️🗣️🗣️
TTD is literally the worse TD game ever. It's worse than every skibidi toilet games on Roblox. It's literally gambling for kids. Nothing more but a thing that fuels the creator's pocket with money.
@@TGWA101 they should rename TTD to Brainrot Tower Defence : Gambling Edition (MORE GAMBLING)
@@TGWA101 atleast skibi defence is good ngl
i agree with this a lot, back when i played tds in area 51 it was so buggy and weird that after getting commando i just… quit. Then, during the overhaul is when o came back, and the game was…. still buggy. Came back again around halfway into the halloween update and that’s when i started REALLY enjoying the game, and from there i kept playing since. TDX definitely has its problems (skin crates, very grindy, not the best replayability) but i also believe it will be just like tds back when i played in area 51. It will DEFINITELY improve over time.
Tdx is just like other games on launch:new and unpolished with rooms for improvement.As a tdx player,im just glad that when tdx came out,it was not buggy,tho still needs major improvements
No, i think it will get much worse from here.
@@filippohl9097 we will see where this goes
@@filippohl9097 bro is sooo wrong now that the endless mode is coming
@@filippohl9097Bro is a not a seer.
As a tower defense game fan that loves tdx and tds equally, it’s kinda funny how fans are fighting which game is better or not, while in reality it’s probably the same but with different air refresher.
Imo, things you said are pretty valid.
the music in the Halloween 2020 lobby still haunt me to this day with the tds community being immature as a say golden mini is overrated.
Ikr.I mean,i played all kinds of td games (from an old garden defence game on your local com shop to btd series to roblox td games) and honestly,why fight? Why bring hate on new games with the same genre as the ones these people are playing rn? If u guys do not like what tdx is rn,no one is forcing u to play,nor no one is talking smack at u for not playing it.Instead of joing on these useless debates,just ignore it if u dont like it.Dont step down to those immature clowns who has nothing to do but start meaningless debates on everything.As the one said on the vid,tdx is new,unpolished,has many room for huge inprovements,but we are fine with it.We knew what we were going to recieve when tdx came out and we cool with it.
That music would always be in my head forever (I always use that one DJ skin that plays that specific music.)
Finally, people are standing up to the right path.
@@AnimanDude-hk8kt im just tired seeing endless yapping when i scroll up on shorts and random vids
@@bhinglaberinto7450 True, especially in tdx-related videos on the comments. What really ruined tdx's reputation is its community, hell even the tds discord community are dunking on tdx due to its players. It's all just an endless, and most definitely pointless to compare between the two. I'm just about to start playing tdx again after leaving that game to rot during the Christmas event, but the massive amounts of hate.. Dang.. I feel terrible for tdx to have such immature players, thinking it can compete with tds when it's literally a different game with the same genre. I'm glad this video is posted, I just hate comparison in general, especially that one watermelon youtuber who also thought of tdx's win, turning to a different side than they have expected.
TDX is starting to cook! John has listened to the community in his recent live stream (Speed boost will become a free feature and people who paid will get something special, future skin crates won't give out duplicates)
in the end you even got like a multiplayer x1,5 speed right?
@@vegitobluekkx2069 ye
This is really concise, gets straight to the point, no video filler, and hits the mark. Congrats man, you got a subscriber. I really like this stuff. Nice.
To be fair with your point, Tdx’s developer (John Roblox) was very well known in the tds community for making game trailers. He even got the bloxy award for best game trailer. But he eventually left the team and announced tdx which nearly the entire tds community knew about so it was pretty big. So it doesn’t really matter which one came out first, because almost the entire tds community knew about and tried tdx. I think the reason it has a low player count is that it’s a little outdated from tds. Tdx was announced before tds fixed their easy mode, made tutorial, matchmaking finished, and the other permanent modes like pizza party and badlands.
Yeah, I tried it and I regret
L profile picture
@@SCSlime99 ?
@@SCSlime99 your pfp is literally 🧊🤓
@@KyloBarley At least mine isn’t a plagiarized game
Finally someone speaking facts.
Like seriously this annoying bash about comparing is so dumb I already rant about this on Eggcrypted video (if it didn't got taken out)
and I have to say. You. You did good explanation.
Rookie mistake 🤓🤓🤓 It's Eggrypted
We can't compare because we are comparing a game that collabs with towerbattles and a game that Copies evrything from Towerbattles
just to add, when you said it goes from 13k dollar juggernaut, and 225 level warship, it has been nerfred to lvl 100, and many new in between towers were added (one of which you used in your footage)
probably my biggest issue with TDX right now is how it's managed
TDX just feels like it was rushed to meet a deadline and to satisfy an increasing mob of impatient people
a lot of towers are released unbalanced then reigned in after a day or two
UNBALANCED?
RANGER ACTUALLY HAS A USE FOR NEWER PLAYERS PLAYING WITH EXPERIENCED PLAYERS, IT HAS AOE ATTACKS, ARMOR PIERCING, DOES ACTUAL GOOD DAMAGE, WHILE TDS' BEGINNER TOWERS ARE ABSOLUTELY USELESS, CRYO RANGER: USED ON SMALL MAPS, SHOTGUNNER: USED TO CLEAR ENEMIES QUICKLY: CRYO BLASTER: USED TO FREEZE BOSSES, OPERATOR: HUMVEE SPAM. TELL ME WHEN HAVE YOU EVER USED MILITANT, DEMOMAN, FREEZER, SCOUT, SOLDIER, PAINTBALLER, AND SHOTGUNNER AFTER GETTING MINIGUNNNER? NEVER EXACTLY.
@@enchanted3820, dude, don't take this too seriously, please, I respect that you love the TDX, but I can see that you use that to complain about a different game, yes, you do have good points, I really see that you have good points, but the tone that you use, I just can't ignore that, if you're willing to defend a game, do it more respectfully, you'll have a better chance of not being replied to be pointed out about the way you say your points. But in the end you have good points, but say it respectfully to others.
@@enchanted3820I’ve actually used shotgunner and freezer on my alt after getting mini. Shotgunner is great for early game and freezer works very well as a support tower once you get about 3 of them
@@darkery-benedictanimations268 he is in no way obliged to say it respectuflly, honestly tdx is a great game that takes the boring repetitiveness away like a fresh start
@@agonyproreal I do agree, TDX is a great game, I just don't seem to like see people defend the game in a manner that is like what Enchanted said.
"Nah I'd compare."
-Both fandoms 💀
Hey sun flower why is your name sun flower if you’re not as hot as the sun
tbh toilet tower defense is the best and most OG td game even better than cringe overrated btd
@@MilitaryGuy1v5tBOSNIANARMY agreed
@@MilitaryGuy1v5tBOSNIANARMY”⚠️You have alerted the *horde* “
@@MilitaryGuy1v5tBOSNIANARMYfr man
The endless mode trailer is out, it's not nightmare mode as from what they advertise, it's more of bringing an endless gameplay experience... The more waves you survive, the more rewards you get. Endless mode seemed to bring brand new enemies and bosses too, and is the Endless Mode considered the "Nightmare Mode"???
Alright, that's all I can say for now regarding what TDX has been cooking recently
Even as somebody who doesn't like TDX, i have said actively that i see potential in TDX, just at the moment it's ruined. I play new TD games all the time, despite being level 560 in TDS. I've gone through countless games i love and this was one of the few where i lost interest within a week. I do hope that TDX gets their crap together and can give a really enjoyable experience. Great vid btw
tds is doodootrash p2w game
@@theonewhocaredandasked9126 i hate people who say tds is bad because it's pay to win, there are games with way more intrusive microtransactions and roblox also forces games to make good money to be relevant on the platform so it's not even their fault
TDX had the opposite effect.I was excited to start fresh and experience something new.Even tho tds and tdx are similar I had no idea which would be most effective tower to get.Which help spark my curiosity and explore most of the towers and its better cross-path.
tdx is a good game its just too new, but I think its already better then tower blitz cuz it ACTUALLY UPDATES
tower blitz is goated tho-
Tbz is amazing
@@petrocksquad The most grindy TD game ever.
@@enchanted3820tdx is just as grindy while being less fun
@@clashroyale-yl4ecfr
2:40
surprisingly, the made up scenario... perfectly describes what I experienced for TDX
it just, felt like an experience I would try for a while, and then forget about eventually
honestly, this whole video was really good, solid explanations and everything
When I started to play tdx I at first liked it but when I got juggernaut I felt drain of the game because it felt like tdx grinding felt more boring to me than tds
As i said,tdx is new and has that cliche geeling when u reach a certain point.Me as of now is on break after i grinded to get everything on tdx,for theres no need to stay if u do not enjoy the gameplay anymore.I mean,i can just go back if i feel like it or if tdx is finally good.
I don’t play it anymore
I love the game idea and design but the grinding is just a pain in my ass after I got jug I just stopped
@@stromsaurus9335I Grinded my ass to warship and I still like the game, you just have low attention span.
Which is what I would’ve said if I didn’t have a low attention span
True but another reason why I don’t play it anymore I am just to much of pussy to the other modes
What you say is true, I have seen many videos addressing the problems of the game, and among the most mentioned are the poor replayability of the game and the grinding. Both of these problems are understandable as it is a game that came out months ago and can be solved with updates that fix aspects that can be improved. I think the game is not on a bad path, it has great potential but I do think that there are people who should think that Tdx is a recent game compared to tds which has been years since its release. just give the devs time to polish the game.
SUBSCRIBE IF THEY BOTH GOOD
ttd better than both of those tdx is just boring and too easy same with tds void reaver is just skill issue
@@MilitaryGuy1v5tBOSNIANARMYkey why ees
Blud whate the f-@@MilitaryGuy1v5tBOSNIANARMY
@@MilitaryGuy1v5tBOSNIANARMYI can’t tell if your actually joking or not
@@Randoperson392 rage bait, his channel has phuck your heart lyrics as ddescription
I can agree with what you said and as a guy who’s level 197 and been hooked to tds since a month before hardcore (I did play during the heights event I just never cared) and like level 75 or something in TDX I agree I like to see tds as my casual TD experience just a simple match with simple gimmicks it’s basically use a ability or two… place a tower and medic so the stun isn’t hell when warden hits sometimes make sure the teammate uses COA
But then TDX.. I have to calculate where the prices are to the tower, which path is more efficient, what towers my teammates have to the mode, what ability do my teammates have to be as efficient to kill eradicator MK2, how much HP my towers are on, where is the bait most effective in relation to not be wasting space, is it worth doing a rewind or just restarting, what support is placed and it’s range to be as effective to reaching towers and how competent are they because I swear they sound smart till the match starts and they go for warship that they bought robux on ANGEL ISLANDS
(And before you say half of those apply to tds… your right but like you get so much cash and you can have a teammate that can solo fallen in a squad match it allows for huge risks meanwhile TDX whenever I’m playing we all have to focus and helping newbies beat elite mode is a fight on its one and then with the sudden uprising on nightmare- look you get my point before I double this messages length I see tds for more casual matches and I see TDX for my strategic and focused matches… WHICH IS WHY I PLAY TOILET TOWER DEFENCE YEAHHH- that is a joke I never even entered the game)
if im gonna be honest when i played TDX i didnt experience any bug but in TDS we still have the stupid matchmaking bug where you spawn in and your entire team or half of your team doesnt spawn in (idk if its fixed or not but i doubt its fixed) and then theres hardcore which still gives me the chills to this day cuz i grinded for i think about 2-3 months straight to get accel
It’s not a bug, they just leave before they get in because they think the team is bad
@@xmanthegreat370 makes me hate tds community more
For me, For a Betta State Of TDX, I am impressed How Even if TDX is still In beta Phase, They Did alot of Things in there game! Especially the Endless mode in april 20, I really enjoyed this game, for me, I din't got annoyed grinding This game, I really Enjoyed Grinding the Armored factory New tower! For sure if the Plane towers came out, Oh Boy, TDX would be Wild! 🔥🔥🔥
I agree with every word you said and mainly because i have just started grinding TDX
i think why all the TDS fans starting comparing and just hating on TDX is because theyre most likely afraid that TDS will get more unpopular to a literal game in beta for some reason, and so tried to compare the bad things of TDX to the qualities of TDS without reminding themselves of the MANY "oopsies" that TDS had that they still forgave, even if they were 10 times worse
Finally, a video that is not completely bashing TDX...
Remi saying how games take long to make massive updates weekly
Toilet Tower Defense: what am I to you, a misfit?
TDX is only in their beta’s. True it’s not as good as TDS has to offer but both games get boring an hour or 2 after playing. Of course the grinding in both of these games are gonna be a lot more different but who wants to spend majority of robux that was dug out of your wallet just to get towers with special ability skins?
TDS may not offer a lot of towers that are NOT pay to win but they can be very easy to grind.
But in TDX, they have a lot to offer. It’s just what kills the mood of their game is the Grinding itself. (The only things that cost robux is the skins)
We want to easily grind for the towers that are available to us but we also want more towers to play around with.
In my opinion tdx is just more enjoyable for me tds is good but tdx vibe is better in my opinion
i do think in a years time we can really start to compare the games as features in tdx will be developed and more populatity which gives them a reason to make more content
bro single-handedly gave me motivation to play rn. subscribing
the only reason i no longer ply tdx is because pl join u when u say solo but they added the solo button to the survival statue
I see a lot of comparison in the "graphics" like dawg, 1 is cartoony and 1 is supposed to be high quality its like comparing a cartoon with a live action movie.
I'm more of a graphics guy, but i agree it's corny. Like just because the graphics of a game might not be "realistic" enough doesnt mean its shit.
No matter which game you think is better, I think we can all agree that both of them are leagues above Toilet Tower Defense.
Yes def
Toilet tower defense can’t even be compared to all of this gold.
Its comparing the worst copy to ever exist, copying not only other tower defense games , but also copied a copyrighted show made for people invested in “sentient toilets vs technology come to life” trend.
Versus a well polished game made with years of work put into it(tds), and the amount of quality and fresh air tdx brings in.
Both tds and tdx should not be compared to a trash, cash-grab game for kids known as “toilet tower defense”
Any tower defence that works and isn't a gambling machine is far above toilet tower defense
Btw, im played tdx for 1 day and im not stop playing until today
And tds im played for 2 hours and never played another time 😢
ya'll forgetting that almost every td game EXCEPT tdx has an AUTO SKIP FUNCTION. WHERE THE FUCK IS THE AUTO SKIP?! THIS GAME WAS IN DEVELOPMENT FOR A COUPLE OF YEARS AND NO ONE THOUGHT TO IMPLEMENT AN AUTO SKIP?!???!!
They adding it soon dawg its a new game
@@strikerblx1585Bro said it was in development for years and they still didn't think of doing that
@@takebacktheholyland9306 Tds took like 3 years to add it you know
I was just gonna go away quickly, but once I heard the music I KNOW this youtuber will be different
My problem with tdx is that it was WAY too overhyped. "YO TDX WILL BEAT TDS ITS SO MUCH COOLER ITS BY JOHNROBLOX" and when I played the game on release it was simply boring. I didn't stick around because it was boring as hell. Mind you, I don't have a full acc in tds neither, its just more fun, and has higher quality. However, tdx did save tds by making them actually try with the updates
TDX has been in development for ages, I think it’s fair to compare it to TDS.
I prefer tower blitz to both of those tho
love this commentary typa content!!
the problem is, although so many people are saying ''don't compare tdx and tds, tdx new and needs time'' that is correct. But nobody is going to wait tdx to update and make their game better. Including tds.
True
Honestly tho once nightmare mode drops tdx gonna be so fun😊
Holy shit, its the jack in the box guy! (Best commercials and food ever)
It's true i've played quite a bit of tdx but I always come running back to tds, it's just so much more polished and it's mode roster while similar to tdx has more variety, tdx literally repeats the same two bosses twice for their modes it can get kinda stale
TDX in Beta is already amazing
If the marketing is done right, it could be on par with TDS. Just hope the same could be said with Tower Blitz, Tower Heroes, Vector Fission, and more. Not enough people are talking about it.
The marketing was done right, the reason it didn't beat tds is because most players who like the type of game tdx is are already playing tds and they are not gonna switch because they already have lots of progress on tds. Currently, tdx is doing pretty well though averaging 7k per day after the endless update. It's only going up from here
That's what I've been saying bruh 💀💀💀
This is a good watch
same bruh
omg its remi
im a huge fan!!
TDX is a unique experience for sure, bosses killing ur towers, really puts ur brain on speed modes to prepare and the strats require brain cells (Which most ppl dont have)
Very good video. how lucky to get a recommandation to somebody who puts efofrt and does not follow same format as others
Anyway! I dont mind tds as im lvl 200+ and played game for years during my school time and I dont mind tdx either! feels very fresh to me for a new game to enjoy!
In my opinion I prefer tdx because to me. Tds is more for younger audience. I completed the Game (played since 2019) and tdx suits my interest and style but Idc what I think about either games. there both great!
Eitherway what I only dislike is the Content Creators who make videos on the Game atleast in my opinion. Is the always same formatting editing, editing and some even dont get straight in to the point which results in either skipping through parts of the video or the videos itself is pretty boring. that my only problem which isnt linked to the Game at all!
in my opinion its just I prefer playing tds myself then watching people who make videos on the Game or even just people who do non commentary videos
But the point is. both games are completely fine and im willing to keep playing them regardless. I feel myself completed with tds as I stopped playing in 2022 and I feel like I done enought with the Game. so I want to start a new journey in tdx because it is alot more violent and it suits my interest of the genre and military theme!
Anyway overall great video!
For me I don't mind leaving old games, I've played a few tower defense games before (btd 4> btd 5> tower battles> btd 6 > tower defense sim > tdx >) I really enjoy all these games because they are all similar while being different in many ways. Even though I put many years in to many of these games I still like to change between them lol
i love how people compare a game in its beta stage not even 10 months alive to a full ass game with 5 years being around
Moral of the story: just fucking play the game you like.
exactly
awesome video yet again remi 😎👍
can i just say the only fanbase i have seen be outright toxic towards the other game is tds's, I've never heard a peep out of a a tdx player about how the game is significantly better than tds (isn't to say toxic tdx players don't exist, just seem far less frequent from my experience)
What's funny is that i always see tdx players metion tdx, even on a tds video. Like damn shut up about tdx
@@leonardotrujillo8661 I think there's a lot to compare about the 2 games, they are somewhat similar. But when some certain TDS players compare the 2, they refuse to accept the strengths of tdx, either through not being experienced enough (a lot of tds players don't realise you are meant to micro heavily on tdx bosses) or they refuse to accept that the game is good because they hate the thought that its even marginally better than tds in any way. Again I believe this is a minority, a large portion of tds players just don't care about tdx or have never tried it and I can get why tdx players constantly bringing it up can be irritating.
@@reconsider3735 yeah it's annoying when in my post on reddit about freezer rework someone says "blud thinks he ranger from tdx", i have nothing against the game i tried it a bit and it's fun but like I don't want to see it on completely unrelated things.
fr tho what i have to say about this is flip tds they way to dry to keep me going i play like one game and get bored with tdx everything looks so much cooler and works much better but i hope tdx gets less robux hungry it would help their community and the people who waited 2 years would appreciate it too
Even when I lost my account, I still stuck with TDS cause of how good it is now (except for VIP+ which should not be talk about)
As someone who didnt play tds I had the opposite experience. I thought tdx was more approachable since the grind would be more gradual with updates. Less daunting. Tds has years worth of content I would need to catch up on. And with how many updates tdx gets? For me it was a clear decision. I mean look at how far the games come from just November.
Tdx has been cooking up two new modes multiple patch’s yea I agree giving time is key me personally I’m more of a tdx person my self I will admit there is random stuff that happens that need to be fixed (Speed of sound Revived Abominations) but it’s makes up for that with being active with updates and trying to polish them out before releasing them every games going to have flaws every game no matter what is going to have flaws after every update I mean hell scarlet and violet are glitchy as any game that not polished and more glitch’s are fixed more appear not giving something time like what we did for TDS is just unfair to TDX
TDX cares about balanced, where the devs see that getting to lvl 100 and obtaining the best tower because of an op strat that just makes progress shorter is not really fair, it's very new and that could explain the player drop but also that TDX gets seen as "the same" thing as TDS.
While TDS has a larger dev team (90% of them working for a leaked update form 3 years ago that now they remember to add it) and they can do "faster" and better work, also that it has more players because it has participated in some Roblox made events, most recently the hunt and is just overall more well known among the Roblox players for its almost 5 years of it being on the platform.
People are mad about TDX's grind being too long and the game having too much monetization and useless gamepasses while on TDS they are mad for the game being too easy and requiring a 1 tower only spamm to win, both games are the SAME GENRE (a TDG) but not completely same game.
What am I even trying to say? that both games are better than the other in specific things, TDX has better balancing and a team constantly trying to make the game itself balanced and not just towers and gameplay, and TDS has overall better...... Skins??????????? And... playercount?????????????????
Just remember, these are MY THOUGHTS about both games and what people fight about, I obviously won't try to stop something like both communities fighting because, well, it's wasted time, what would be the point of trying to stop something that could just start again right after it being solved?
TDX more grindy ? TDS golden case tower and accelerator more grind that it
@@gamerbeginner5019 TDS accel is extremely fast to grind for, I literally had it in just 6 lvls and 8 hc wins, and Golden crate might be a bit longer, but you can speedrun pizza party 40 times and get it, both of those "big grinds' are possible in just a small amount of time, in days. Compared to TDX, it's 1/20 of the time to get warship and grind those 50k, if you're doing the hard maps for 13k exp and 1950 coins, that makes it faster.
Thanks for the reply.
@@UJUOKGYYU7 well actually, both of it are fair, tds grind may be "faster" , but for tdx, your grinding for an insanely op tower
imo tdx is the better game, yeah it's lower quality and missing some qol, but it's way less grindy (in my opinion), and from my experience has way more replayability. it might just be that i've basically done everything in tds, and that i'm relatively new to tdx, but personally, tdx is way more fun
Endless mode will be soon that will help the game because tds dozent have that feature so its kinda new for a td game pretty cool i am exited for it!
Amazing video bro 👌
We compare cuz we wanna know which game is better for nolife grinding🙃
jack in the box is not quality food💀💀💀
Edit: In-n-out better, Fight me?, Fight me.
Yeah you’re reported buddy 🥱
@@rrounderrYea, your banned
HOW DARE YOU
"yup, your banned" -caseoh
Heresey blasphemy lies!
I like how ur example of getting jugg and then going back to tds is me
1:56 - 2:40
Pretty much me after getting the farm/missile trooper tower
(I dont want to suffer like a newbie again, but now i just focused to continue again)
tbh, my only argument is that you cant blame tdx for scummy gambling with crates, when tds has like, alot more that are alot more pricey than just 200 gold, and some are even roblox only
i still find tds and tdx enjoyable bc i got many things to do in both games like farm for the warship in tdx bc im lvl 88 or in tds i need to get the all golden skins i have half of them
brooo spoken like a true legend
During the end of November and the start of December last year, tdx fans were making fun of tds and flexing their higher play count
But now the tables are turned and now tdx fans are saying "Tdx is in beta!! Tds is a five year game!! You can't compare them!!" Terrible fanbase
The loud minority shouldn’t represent the quiet majority
arent tds fans shitting on tdx all the time because its different? its gotten to the point where it got annoying and i just wanted it to stop. tds rn feels like they lost quality.
If TDS never removed the HIDDEN WAVE it would've been one of the top games of roblox.
As someone who played tds since its release, I loved it so much until 2023 when it started to fall off , and then giving up permanently after their horrible attempt of ugc hunt in 2023, so i moved to tdx and at first i hated it just because for who john was, but after some games, i loved the gameplay and the fact that modes are actually difficult between them and not like in tds with old easy mode being harder than molten, i gave up on tds just because imo it's becoming a dissapointment and egg's video crying about tdx having a worse monetization than tds is completely false when tds itself sells crap ton of towers, event "limited" towers for robux and auto skip behind a paywall aswell with community maps being behind vip servers and vip gamepass, TDX hopefully wont dissapoint with their nightmare mode like tds made with hardcore and overhaul
Oh they won't disappoint. they won't. just beware the difficulty curve. they said it's going way up.
People think both john and the tds devs are at each others throtes when its only a friendly compatition. They are both rivals but not ones that legit want the other dead. Its a mix of rivaly and cooperation, tdx has some referances of tds in it and tds and some ref of tdx.
John already did show how he dislike tds 4 years go, and in the curent the hunt event, john usually chat with planetearth, if you watch his video about tb vs tds 4 years ago you will know why
What really drove me away from TDX was the fact that any video about TDX or TDS made within a week or two of TDX's launch was just filled with random TDX fans saying things along the lines of "Take notes TDS" "Better than TDS" and overall just a whole lot of unjustified hate towards TDS. TB fans had a good reason to hate on TDS, TDX fans don't.
man I had a similar idea to this but in a really original way, one question though what font do you use?
Rubik font!
Remi i dare youn to use support only like edj sniper laser gunner john and granadier the 0-5 sniper for unstea
Th and also lg and john dmg buff and granadier slow down you can also still use their other paths
I think tdx devs learned from the mistakes of tds, to make a great game in just 2 years.
If we didn't have tds tdx would probably be nonexistent
ngl, i kinda stopped playing tdx because the game had a really dumb way of balancing progression. for example, in tdx the gameplay is great. It’s enjoyable and has some good effort put into it. However, knowing that you have to do it 100+ more times… it literally destroys the purpose of quality gameplay. you kinda get bored and forget on how much effort was put into the game. probably many other people have come across this problem from grinding in tdx
The same with golden skins and accelerator, stop being hypocrite
I agree. Warship sells for 50k as the most expensive tower in the game. Is TDS there are 6 golden skins each costing 50k as well. Not to mention you earn money quicker in TDX but since the rounds are longer and the attention spans of children nowadays are terrible, people say TDX is more grindy.
@@bendysama1728he didnt even mention tds
Thing is, John brought tdx in as direct competition to tds, he made everyone think its gonna kill tds, so ofc everyone is gonna compare the two
Here’s what I do: I play other games > I play TDX after seeing its awesome gameplay > slowly start getting bored > back to step 1.
These are just two room of different furniture
I switch to one another when i gets bored
Crazy how people always compare tdx (still in beta) to a full game
TL;DR:
TDX is like 5 months old, and TDS has polished itself for over 5 years. Give it time.
3:28 I haven't really followed much of TDS but apparently their largest bug the rate of fire bug was only really fixed late into last year, and im pretty sure the gambling mechanics are here for some time before the game is fully released
Ive tried both tds and tdx. Tdx is a higher quality game with better graphics and maps. Tds has more options and game mechanics. Tbh though, i find tdx more interesting as its harder to play compared to tds. More strategy needs to be used. I often find that in my friend group, we usually just lounge around and talk while playing tds but when it comes to tdx we actually have to coordinate and work together. So in the end it just depends on what kind of player you are. If you're just a casual player then tds isnt so bad, but if you prefer strategy and graphics then tdx would be the way to go. Given some time I believe tdx will quickly surpass tds due to its higher quality and mechanics
but when you max out your account on TDS your left with doing nothing until next update so you can play TDX until new TDS update drops and just continue maxing out TDS account and trying to max TDX account too
Honestly remi is speaking facts like I agree with everything he says remi is soooooooooo underrated keep going buddy amke more amazing videos
Pretty good vid👍👍
Guys I hope tdx won’t make me gamble or pay for better towers
Also there a lot of others tower defense games with stuff like perks,tower skill trading and clans waiting for you
My brain died while grinding in both games.....
TDS is like classic BTD while TDX is like modern BTD, there are similarities, but aren't really comparable.
Both games are great i wouldnt say tdx is bad right now as it is but i have a problem with the "only in tdx" slogan since tdx doesnt bring anything new to the table
Despite being a good game, it has a boastful slogan that sounds like TDX is promising us very very "original" concepts and ideas present in the game itself such as towers, enemies and gameplay yet it feels archetypal
@@satriaprotoThats onw thing with both TDS and TDX, they lack Originality and are kinda just well a generic TD with nothing special about em
All I want is the s3x update in tdx
Soon my friend.. soon..
Of course it’s soon. Why do you think John is adding the war machine soon?
The concepts are similar but are different
Comparing tds, a 5 year old game, to tdx, a game which hasnt even been out for a year, how fair, right?
I like em both, but I generally prefer TDX. It seems like it has more cool stuff then TDS IMO. I love TDS but man the events recently have left something to be desired. TDX gets pretty frequent updates and has a lot of neato stuff to play with.
I totally agree with this guy like no doubt
Remember when shotgunner was named Enforcer and could summon Swat Vans?
Tbh i think the reason of it its because its fairly new but peapole tend to keep sticking around with the orginal game instead of a fangame or seaquel