Just watched this. I severed in the US ARMY and retired. I was assigned along side a Blackwatch unit in southern Iraq. My ancestry is FRASER, who fought along side the Blackwatch. I was given a Blackwatch tartan by the unit I was with, I still wear it proudly today.
I'm an American of multi-UK descent...long story. But, my Grandma H. was of Highland descent. Her 4x great grandpa came here after the last Jacobite uprising! She taught me a great deal (yet, nowhere near enough) about my ancestry. I did, however, understand why these uprisings took place. My mother and my stepfather were both very authoritarian, even trying to control my thoughts and feelings. Nobody can endure forever under such conditions. Although I'm Episcopalian, I can understand the Covenanter viewpoint! My mother was Southern Baptist! I would swan dive into Hell before I would worship in that manner. Dad and his family ran the gamut from Catholic to Methodist. As for the Black Watch... my all time favorite Scottish military force! Pure badass! Thank you for posting this video! I would say the English government has some serious apologies to make!
My uncle Jim Matthew was captured at st valery 10th of June 1940 he was with the black watch royal highlanders with the 51st highland division my nephew was with the 1st Scots regiment the old highland light infantry he also did two tours of Iraq and 3 tours of Afghanistan one of his tours he was assigned to the American green berets special forces
I’m English and so my sympathy may not be entirely appreciated but I am always very emotional hearing about the treatment of the Highlanders. Such a beautiful place, leaving it against their will must have been so painful. Forcibly stamping out a cultural identity of such proud people seems the cruelest punishment imaginable. This video was very well done.
I'm American but descended from Scottish highlanders. While that likely doesn't actually mean anything to anyone, I for one, appreciate your sentiment.
It wasn't you doing bad to Highlanders don't live with guilt. It's 300 years we are a great nation after all. Is good to know the history but don't take it personal
I'm a descendant of Farquhar Shaw and the information that you convey is why I chose to wear the Black Watch tartan over the Shaw tartan. Mad respect for this video Bruce.
I too am related to Farquhar Shaw! And my Granddad, my Dad's Dad, was the Company Sgt Major in the 4th/5th Battalion Black Watch during WWI, and his brother too was with him. Their father too had been in the Black Watch. My Granddad on my Mom's side was a Piper in the Black Watch along with 2 of his 3 brothers all joining up together. (The third joined the Seaforths because I believe he had left home & that was his nearest battalion) & Granddad piped his mates 'over the top' and likely piped my CSM Granddad over the top (not knowing they'd be linked through marriage in the next war!) My Dad was also an apprentice in the Black Watch for awhile... though joined the RAF (& became a Flt/Eng in 148 (Special Duties) Sqd in WWII. I've always been very proud of them all! My brother got my CSM Granddad's army uniform kilt (which has a mended bullet hole in it) and his son now has it. And my son's wedding colours were Black Watch tartan. Their firstborn little girl was Christened in a 130 year old Christening Gown, the ribbon of which I replaced with the Black Watch tartan which was around son's & wife's wedding cake & table ribbons. The Black Watch is a part of our history that we're very proud of. So thank you for the history lesson! I enjoyed it very much (I've just discovered your Channel & I'm slowly making my way through your vids & enjoying EVERY SINGLE ONE! :)
@@ScotlandHistoryTours I just stumbled on to your videos My maiden name is Morrison and I am just learning about my ancestry. I am going to hit the subscribe and start learning could you suggest on your videos where to start ??
I suppose I'd go to the channel page and look at the playlists which have a subject theme. That way you can choose what's of most interest to you first
Scottish descended American. I never considered wearing the Black Watch Tartan for the same reason I don't wear any American Service Uniforms, I never served. I was surprised that some Americans are against wearing the tartan. Honestly, I shouldn't be, a lot of Americans barely understand their own history, much less anybody else's. Honor to anyone who volunteers and serves, as my dad did. Also, it was great seeing the statue and bridge again. I visited back in 2005. Someday I hope to return to Scotland.
Many Americans did not learn their history even if their teachers were good ones. Many of my father's students wrote essays that looked like they had fallen asleep in his class. But his only happened once and when the young lady realized she was surrounded by upper classmen when she finally woke up she never fell asleep in his class or any other again.
@@rvail136 Hello Richard, I've only just seen these history clips on the Black watch, and they are indeed a regiment to be proud of. I would like to wear the Black watch Tartan to honour those who served, so could you tell me how to wear it "Correctly", Thank you. Elizabeth.
I became quite fond of the Black Watch tartan being introduced to it as a napoleonic re-enactor. I've been on many of the Regiment's battlefields - from la Coruna to Waterloo- and always put it on as part of my period uniform . It is just part of the hobby and a great fun. I've learned to wear it properly according to 1813 regulations and I wear it occasionally as a modern garb just because I like it. Always been complimented when walking out in my Black Watch kilt, both in Continental Europe and in Scotland. So, nae problem at all to wear it even if you don't have any real connection with the Regiment, just do it properly and it'll be 100% all right.
I was in the British Army and served with the Black Watch in the early 80s. It was like being part of a large family and even years later I have met people who I have served with. What surprised me was the number of Yorkshire men who had followed their ancestors from the 2nd world war to serve with them. There is nothing better than marching behind their pipes and drums when on parade. Fond memories.
Aye play Black Bear. Hello brother, I hope you're thriving. I began with the Black Watch but went to the paras but to upset some folk there I'd wear my kilt with pride in the mess.
It was government policy in WW2 to man regiments with conscripted personnel from different parts of the UK rather than predominantly from traditional geographic recruiting areas - a harsh lesson learnt from WW1 where communities and families had suffered heavy losses where their local battalions had been in action.
Do you not mean drums and pipes. As a Royal Scot in the 80s the one thing that gave me goosebumps was the return to barracks march home behind the drums and pipes. Only thing I've had a similar reaction is at murrayfield for the rugby when thousands of us sing flower of Scotland. Only part I miss to this day is my muckers. The tab from glencorse to the castle law ranges up that hill back down and through the pipe with water back of Milton Bridge kirk I should have knew what was coming. Wouldn't hange a thing though
My grandfather was in the Black Watch based in Montréal. As a immigrant to Canada, he felt it was his patriotic duty to serve his new country. The pride he felt from his service was beyond words.
Wrong Black Watch, that’s the “plastic” Black Watch! 😂 However, I have served (being a black watch veteran) with Black Watch of Canada in Afghanistan. They were great men and over the moon, as well as surprised to be serving with us the “real” Black Watch! i have so much respect for them and the forebears from Canada. FTFT.
david fellow pert resident am 54 great great great grandfather was black watch grew up with a wollen black watch tartan as my bedspread very proud of the black watch too
My Uncle served during WWII as the regimental piper for the Calgary Highlanders of Canada. The Black watch was the tartan they wore. He was born in Scotland.
My father, an Edinburgh graduate, was Regimental Medical Officer to The Black Watch when they were in Berlin in 1951. It sounded like a place of complete devastation even 6 years after the end of WW2. The Black Watch was engaged in 'public order' duties, which meant riot control. The CO at the time was Bernard Fergusson (must be worth a video) who ordered that the Black Watch paint their helmets black and have a red hackle welded to the same. A hardened Tam O'Shanter.
Yep my grandfather was in the Black Watch. He was at Dunkirk, he spent years fighting the Japanese in Burma. He had the Burma star. I don't live in Scotland, I wasn't born there and I find it sad how some people hijack the memory of these people for their political causes.
When a soldier dies in his duty no matter what country he serves he becomes part of a fraternity of honor having given all in this life had to offer for duty and country God bless them all!
First time I ever heard someone say what I have said since my own military service! I am British, living the last 20 years in Germany, married to a German and with kids. When I attend my village war-memorial each year, for that I do at 11am on the 11th of November, I read all of the names on the stone and remember my own family and my wife's, that have fallen; civilian or military, winner or loser. My drinking-kilt is in the Black Watch tartan BTW.
@Mr. Shlock "The Shlock" took two attempts yet still managed to convey absolutely no message to his audience or intended victim......... Sir, you are a clown 🤡
I'm a Campbell, and my father was in the Black Watch , Canadian Regiment, in WW II. I wear the Black Watch tartan today with pride along with the Ancient Campbell tartan. Our family are proud of the Black Watch. Being Canadian, I never heard negative things about the Black Watch. When I was of legal drinking age, my father took me to the Black Watch Armory in Montreal for my fist drink. (smile) Thank you for the story of this illustrious regiment.
My grandfather fought with the Black Watch and was wounded shortly before the assault on Verrieres Ridge. He lived the rest of his life with shrapnel in his back, but he lived, and I'm here as a result. It has been a very long time since I've been the armoury, though a few years back I was able to visit the Citadel in Quebec City.
Indeed, there are many fine examples. Trust me, Black Watch tartan still sells in the US. I know for a fact that people like to use it here in the US for a Scottish wedding too. Thank you Bruce for helping to set the record straight on the American created Black Watch tartan issue (Or at least it seems that it was American created.)
@Cernunnos 2024 I think you missed everything I was trying to say. Sorry you missed that. And quit waving the liberal cultural appropriation flag. I descend from Scots. The Allisons, Donaldsons, the Stewarts and Duncan I, King of Scots. Scottish dna is in my veins. Cultural appropriation my rear end.
This presentation is so touching, so personal. All I knew of the Black Watch was that band practice as held every week in the Black Watch Armoury on Bleury Street in Montreal and it was there that I cut my teeth as the only girl (so young) in a brass band, with many men who had served in the forces. Black Watch were represented in the annual parade along Sherbrooke Street. Black Watch was, for me associated with the mythical-romantic history of Scotland as a nation of warriors. This video opens up the personal tragic side of all these stories that live in history books and I thank you once again for giving them life.
British English, served with many Scots. Thanks for this, regiment is family, family is regiment. The links to our forebears are what sustains us now and in the future. You are justifiably proud of your grandfather, his tartan and your local regiment with its impressive history.
I'm English by birth but British by the grace of God. Served shoulder to shoulder with Scottish soldiers for many years in several places. Toiled with them in a veterans organisation too. The were and still are my proud brothers. Stronger together! One people, one crown and one flag.
As an American, a historian by trade, and a descendent of American soldiers who fought in the Revolution, let me say here that the 42nd is a Regiment I hold in highest esteem. I can think of no regiment I would wish to hold my flank than the Black Watch!
I love this channel. I'm not of Scottish descent myself, but I live in the Canadian province of Nova Scotia, and we're bursting with people of Scottish descent. There is a strong pride in that descent, and in fact the island of Cape Breton, where almost everyone is descended from Scots stock, looks for all intents and purposes like some displaced Scottish province, rent from the very soil of that place, and dropped from the sky to abbreviate the Northumberland Strait. Your content deserves the largest possible audience. Thanks for the great stories, and the lessons of history.
@@marksadventures3889 Yes, a little. I think is about 5%. Based on 23 and Me, I'm mostly Irish and Northeastern French, with some Dutch, and German. I have 1/1024th of Mi'Kmaq as well.
"He wanted to be with his comrades and do his duty" The essence of every good soldier. Thanks for taking the time to make this, very informative. All the best from Dundee
Very emotional. From a True Scotsman. Two generations of my Family served with the Gordon Highlanders. Both of my Brothers with The Black Watch. Thank You.
Thank them all for their service, then and now. Beannaich Dia na h-Albannaich anns a ’Ghàidhlig! ~~ Seas gu cinnteach May the Lord God of the Scots Bless you! ~~Stand Sure [Anderson family motto] Mstrdiver - US Army - 1973 to 1995
My dad was in the Black Watch between WW1 and WW2 before he came to Canada and then to the US and so proud of his service. I can remember wearing his Kilt when I was a kid in the 50s.
Many wear the Blackwatch tartan, But only a few have truly Earned it... and I thank Them for their Service.... and I thank You Bruce for sharing this with us....
As an American serviceman (retired now) I have always had great admiration for the Black Watch, thinking of them as the best fighters. My wife is a Shaw descendant so when we visited Scotland two years ago she got herself a kilt. I just asked her and she told me that her grandmother gave her her Black Watch kilt which is hanging in the closet. I am humbled, honored and proud to think that through marriage I might be related. I have 3 kilts of my own from the 3 pipes & drum bands that I am in and would be honored to wear a Black Watch kilt with my military uniform. Thank you for history lesson.
I just discovered your channel. Well done! I don't have any association with the Black Watch but I've served in America's military for 25+ years. I am pleased to see you name the names of the fallen soldiers. Their lives deserve to be remembered. Thank you.
Thanks from Canada. My grandfather fought with The Black Watch, Royal Highlanders of Canada (RHC) and survived WW1. His son, whom I'm named after was also Black Watch and fought in WW2, but was killed in the massacre on Verrieres Ridge when his regiment was near annihilated by SS troops. I play the pipes today in their memory and have for near 25 years.
As an American of Cherokee Scott-Irish descent and having had the Honor and Privilege to have witnessed the courage and outstanding professionalism of the Black Watch Regiment bear no ill will towards them. Knowledgeable Americans have the upmost respect as well. Thank you Bruce for your many wonderful videos and for sharing your knowledge.
Wow ! I had no idea about the true History of the Black Watch. How proud you must be of that grandfather in his Black Watch kilt. Another fascinating video Bruce so brilliantly presented.
A lance corporal serving with the regiment was shot by a sniper in East Belfast in November 1971 and a young private serving with the regiment was killed while on foot patrol on Dungannon, County Tyrone by a remote control device in July 1978... 😔 I spent quite a while tonight trying to find their names, to my failure.. So many here in Ulster owe these young men and their comrades our lives. A debt we can never repay to some...
There is no debt. All soldiers serve and do so following orders be they what they may. I am pleased to know Ireland is peaceful today and if that was possible by our service that's good. I am proud to know people of Ireland North and South and glad there is peace. Slainte
@@marksadventures3889Unfortunately there is no peace here my friend.. your service and the sacrifice of others all done in vain. The traitor Tony Blair surrendered to the murderous scum of the ira and released those responsible for the deaths of my own family members from jail.. an act that has signed his own death warrant should he ever be in the same room as myself.. He then left your fellow servicemen to face trial at the hands of the terrorists they were here to defend us from.. Again, there is no peace here my friend, merely a lul in the fighting..but the EU is trying its best to bring trouble back on the streets here nevermind anything else.. As for Ireland, it has been peaceful since the 1920s.. You never served in Ireland my friend..
Gotcha, yeah the IRA shouldn't have started the violent campaign, they should have used diplomacy and politics to get a better deal for the Catholics but I read a Wiki page on that horrific conflict and the British Army ended up killing LOADS of unarmed civilians during the pacification campaign. And yet the IRA was funded by the Soviet Union. A no-win situation! 😓 Hopefully the Accords will hold and the youth of Northern Ireland won't end up in the arms of say, George Soros or ANTIFA.....
My history is Scots/Irish and from the Appalachian mountains. I served in the United States Marines and if an American bad mouthed the Blackwatch then they are ignorant of our country's history. They should read about King's Mountain during the American Revolution.
Beautiful Doc!!!! Long live the Black Watch!!! I wear my BlackWatch kilt with pride here in the United States of America to honor my fighting ancestors who’ve bled and died for that name and that simple yet so important tartan!!!! Thank you for such amazing words you were able to convey in such a short time. I know you’ve touched many lives and informed many people. You have a wonderful gift.
Thank you for this. Two years ago I made a Black Watch themed guitar and donated it to raise money for charity. I could not do justice to the guitar without learning something of the history of the Black Watch. It was fascinating to learn, not just about the Regiment but also of other aspects of the history of Scotland. Originally from Derby I was always aware that the town was the southern-most reach of the Young Pretender's march on London. There is now a statue to commemorate this event in Derby. I digress but that is what history makes you do. I have followed many tangents and still do. Thank you for helping me to a better understanding of the mutiny. Personally I think that Farquhar Shaw was correct in his actions. The Black Watch is still a great regiment with proud traditions despite its recent homogenization. Thank you again. I have subscribed.
It breaks my heart, as a proud American, to hear some of the things that my countrymen heap scorn upon and about which they try to create narratives of shame and disgrace. Too many people want to leap to knee jerk conclusions without digging any deeper to seek the story behind the story and discover the truth. Thank you for a great story well told.
We Americans are often very lacking in our understanding of our own history, let alone that of another country, even one many of us are privileged to claim as an ancestral home. I remember as a young lad - a long time ago - reading Prebble's great histories of Scotland, including the Highland mutinies. A shameful period but the men of the 42nd and their families served with honor and dedication as do their modern day successors. I'm proud to have a Black Watch tartan along with my family tartan.
I am an American who is a history buff. Material from the Ancient World through WW1 and WW2. What you are saying about Americans is true but not universal. I think they don't teach real history in school today. Just current events and politically correct BS. You don't know who you are unless you know where you came from. You can't understand American history unless you know European History - particularly British History. You can't understand British History unless you know Medieval European and Ancient History. It's all connected. I know a Scots American woman and a German American woman and I was surprised at what little they were taught about their own history in Scotland and Germany. I think it's kind of a universal problem today with younger people.
My English father began his military service during the Second World War with the Black Watch. He did his training at Queen’s Barracks, Perth and was ultimately sent to North Africa. In January 1944 he and a number other Black Watch men were transferred to the Sherwood Foresters for the Anzio landings. His closest friend was a man named John Gavin. They’d done their training together in Perth and been transferred to the Foresters together. As far as I’m aware, they never met again after the war. However, when I came along in the late 1950s, I was given his surname as my middle name. The bonds of comradeship run deep.
I think this is one of your absolute best videos, precisely because it's about very real, very specific people, and clearly so personal to you. I take my hat off to you, sir.
My grandfather was in the black watch and I’m as proud as hell of him . And I’m ENGLISH . Great military force with a noble history of serving the British empire.
I grew up in the Black Watch family, my Father was a soldier for 22 years. I was born in Germany and also lived in Scotland, England, Northern Ireland and Hong Kong throughout the 80s and 90s. I made a video talking a little about my timeline growing up as a kid in the Black Watch a while back, it's on my channel. I live with my own family in Ontario, Canada these days. This was a great video and enjoy your channel very much. All the best!
I am a very distant shaw, a great grandmother. I wear a shaw tartan kilt, im a us soldier of twenty years. Well now ill own a black watch kilt. Thank you for this and all of your amazing, and educational videos. I simply love them.
This was so heartfelt and informative. so many lives lost. My great-great grandfather on my mam's side was a blackwatch and I wore the Black Watch kilts to every St Patricks Day Parade in NYC and then for three Burns Night Celebrations. I wore it for my mam and I wore it for the BlackWatch who were lied to and then executed for their honor and pride of place. this video you made had me crying because no one would understand the pride here in the US. Thank you, thank you for making these people live again by telling their story and saying their names. thanks.
Why do you wear a black watch kilt to a St Patrick's day parade?, that's an insult to irish people. Do you not know what the black watch regiment did to irish people during the North of Ireland conflict.
Bruce you are a true Seanchaí. My grand mother told stories that we had a uncle of my great grand mother family was Black Watch. My great grand mother Jenny Baxter was born Lanark, Scotland 1873, died London, Kentucky 1970, her family immigrated to USA in the 1884. Great Grand dad Renus Brown (born Edinburgh 1866 died Pittsburg, Kentucky 1957, his side moved to the USA in 1877). Both met and fell in love in Pittsburgh Kentucky. Did my DNA and clocks in at 87% Scottish of which I am immensely proud, thanks to both Grand parents. And for you that get upset when you hear an American say "I'm Scottish", we know we are not "Scottish" in the born there sense. Settle down. That's American shorthand that really means "I'm of Scottish descent".
I portray a Lieutenant of the Black Watch during WW1 at the National WWI Museum and Memorial in Kansas City, MO; as part of the Living History Volunteer Corps. Felt compelled to do so after visiting the Military Museum at Edinburgh. Mad respect to all that serve!
@Mr. Shlock Not sure what you're trying to say, but like I said it's a trash Amerikwan ghetto phrase. Stop using it. Also, "Mr Shlock" is probably an apt name for you.
Scotland has wonderful warriors. I had a good fight in Ayr one Friday night in a nightclub, even the police were nice to tell me to go back to the B&B. I had to fight 2 guys and the music stopped and a big circle surrounded me until the bouncers asked me to leave when I met the police at the door. The fire in the Scots was trilling, unlike the time when I had to confront an English platoon in Cyprus, where I annoyed them so much that they accepted me into the gang for the day on the remainder of the boat trip around Cyprus. I had the misfortune to wear the Irish flag bathing shorts for swimming and the English soldiers were just back from Belfast the day before and didn't expect to see the Irish flag, and 3 of the soldiers picked me up and threw me off the ship, they did that twice before I said something to make it stop. I love my neighbors.. love from Ireland... i stand beside you all.
I come from south west Perthshire and my Grandad and two brothers volunteered for the 8th battalion of the Blackwatch (Highland Cyclists) in WW1.My grandfather was the only one of the brothers to survive the war.My mothers uncle served in the 5th battalion Blackwatch in WW2 and died after his platoon was straffed by RAF Hurricanes in a rest up area shortly after the Normandy landings.I am immensely proud of my family’s involvement with the Blackwatch and was extremely proud to wear the Blackwatch tartan at my wedding.
Could I ask, were your grandad and great uncles members of the 8th (Service) Battalion The Black Watch (Royal Highlanders)? Or were they members of the 1/1st Highland Cyclist Battalion (formerly - until the reforms of 1909 - 8th (Cyclist) Battalion, The Black Watch (Royal Highlanders))? The reason I'm asking is that my great uncle served with the 8th (Service) Battalion, The Black Watch in WW1 and I am researching the battalion and the men who served in it. If your family members were 8th (Service) Bn. The Black Watch I would be grateful for any background information on who they were and what they did both prior to (and in your grandad's case after) the war. In turn, I will give you the details I have related to their war service and location of their graves / memorials - if you are interested.
A good story very well told. You have an excellent turn of phrase sir, and an obvious deep love of your subject which is very engaging. As a Yorkshireman I can recognise and empathise with the pride of place felt by Scots, we come from places where the landscape nourishes the soul. We may not see eye to eye on every subject, but every strength to you and your ventures on UA-cam.
My cousin was in the Black Watch. Fife is part of its recruitment area. I believe they’re talking of getting rid of it now. Had tears in my eyes watching this. Was at the Black Watch museum a couple of years ago. One of the saddest things I saw was the kilt with the mud of the Somme still on it. History is about people, not dates and battle recitals. History is to be learned from, not repeated.
Yes, more recently they recruited in Fife and Dundee. I suppose it depends what you mean by recent eh? They reorganised forces to save cash a while back and amalgamated regiments into The Royal Regiment of Scotland in 2006
@@ScotlandHistoryTours aye, but I heard something more recently about cutbacks and amalgamating it with another regiment and that the tartan wouldn’t be worn again. I was so angry, I switched off the report and didn’t get the details.
@@jacquelinebain57 Since 2006, all battalions of the Royal Regiment of Scotland, including the 3rd Black Watch Battalion, have worn a slightly lighter version of the Government tartan No 1, first worn by the 42nd (Known as 1a, this version was the tartan sett worn by the Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders). I very much doubt that it will change. So that should rate as glass at least half full.
@@jacquelinebain57 Scots battalions are safe. A battalion of the Mercian Regiment is being disbanded. Other reductions in manning will be through natural wastage over time. Someone else has commented on the tartan.
My Dad fought in the second battle of the hook in Korea couldn’t be more proud. I remember him wearing his black watch tartan to my passing out parade when I joined the Argyll’s.
What a thrilling tale you tell! Growing up in the 1950s in central New York State, my dad would take me to performances by Black Watch pipe & drum bands, once a year if they came by, never missing a chance. Thank you for this video.
I'm an American, and although my clan is Donnachaidh, I also have a family connection to the Black Watch. I proudly wear the issued kilt that belonged to a Co.Sgt. Murty. When I wear it, if someone makes a negative comment (usually a person of Irish descent) I make it a point to try to educate them about the regiment. This was a great video. Thank you for making it.
I wear my Black Watch tartan kilt and kit as often as occasion permits. My maternal grandfather (Campbell) served with the 10th. battalion from 1915-1918. Two of his brothers also served with the 8th and 10th battalions. Proud second generation Canadian of Scottish heritage and prouder still of my family’s service.
US Army veteran here……I don’t know any Americans that have disdain for the Black Watch but the US Army holds the Black Watch in high regard. Much respect for them and your grandfather
A large portion of Scottish immigrants came to Canada , keeping there homeland close to there hearts, they stood up and served in many highland regiments, most notable, the Royal Highland Regiment of Canada, the Black watch. they kept their traditions alive where ever they were, and shared them with new friends and family alike.
I have just discovered your brilliant channel. Your delivery and research are second to none. I didn’t realise how ignorant I was about Scottish history until I listened to you.
Very well done Bruce. As a 'Sweeney' I have been interested in Scottish history as Our History seems to have started in the Western Isles. It would seem to me as an ancestor of a Gallowglass that the Black Watch were the English/ Scottish form of constabulary / Gallowglass for the Highlands. For a centralized gov't or was it for the Lords of the varying estates throughout the countryside.
I'd already been blown away by your content, but this video is top shelf. A thousand kudos, sir. From an american Scot who has no roots, thank you for this, you are a gentleman and a scholar.
This is the second video I've seen from you bruce and I have to say, your passion for Scots history is infectious. Now it's time to sit back, sink a few (more) Guinesses and watch your back catalog. Slàinte mhath from Fife.
A brilliant video and very well told story, thank you so much! Thank you especially for highlighting both the very personal story of Farquhar Shaw and the wider political issues. For such a small country, Scottish history is incredibly complex, but one of its main dynamics is the tension between personal independence and solidarity with the clan and the nation. A central element is personal loyalty to the clan/group leader, and through that leader, to the crown. What happens when the leaders behave in ways that fail their followers, or are so concerned with their personal status that they ignore the needs of their people? That's the question that lies behind so much Scottish history, even today. Liked and subscribed!
There is a photo here, similar to the one you described, of my grandfather who served in the Black Watch in WWI. He emigrated to New Zealand after returning from war. His kilt hangs in my brothers wardrobe.
My Uncle Davy was in the Black Watch, and he was a great bloke. He was very proud to have served with such a fine regiment. He always got emotional at the sound of the pipes.
I Just found your channel. You Sir, can tell a story!! My Glasgow born Grandpa and Great Grandpa, were both Black Watch!! Here in the states, we their Children, Grand children and Great Grand children are proud of them!! We wear the colors proudly on occasion.
I am an American veteran and can trace my ancestry back to Scotland. The only kilt I have ever worn was in Black Watch pattern. The politics of this were unknown to me. All I knew was that they were soldiers, and good ones at that. And that is all I need to know to honor them.
@@bachatacam4016 why can't people wear it to show respect and to teach about it? there's a difference. Plus some could be wearing the pattern not knowing what it is. Seriously y'all need to lighten TF up.
@@libertylovingbeckles6797 lighten the fuck up about cultural appropriation, tell you what I'll walk around in a USMC uniform with medals on and claim I'm honouring them? He never served in the British army, he has no right or claim to government tartan.
I just love your clips on Scottish history. This one was very poignant, as that thread connecting the Black Watch from its ancestral lands to the present remains unbreakable. 👍
I'm a Kiwi, but my Grandfather, Father and Uncle all served in the Black Watch and my Father always wore his Blackwatch kilt at special occasions as us boys wore the McNab tartan. Thanks for the video, the story of which was already familiar to me after reading the history of the Black Watch
@@ScotlandHistoryTours makes me think on the Gordon Highlanders. I mind a lovely man that lived in the care home in my village where I used to work as an activities coordinator. He was a Gordon highlander, loved his black watch tartan 🥰
@@RileyWolfeable Gordon Highlanders wore Gordon tartan (similar to Black Watch but with thin yellow stripes). Used to have an army surplus Gordon's kilt myself - until it was nicked from my house by some eejit who probably didn't even know what it was.
As an Englishman , I have always linked the Black Watch with valour and service to Britain, Bruce as usual fills in the blanks masterfully, Excellent video.
I could listen to you talk for hours. Thank you for getting into such detail. I've proudly worn the kilt of the Black Watch, and would do it all over again if I could.
I just subscribed to this channel. I'm an American veteran who served three years only. I served just one tour because I knew that once in, the powers that be own you and your destiny. Much respect for the men described in this true tale of heroes! Having done some genealogical research I am a descendent of one Mary Bruce who as a young lady, lived in the Fordyce area of Aberdeenshire who for whatever reason, migrated to Virginia in America in the year 1703.
A great regiment with a great military history, as a piper, I had not trained in piobaireachd when my dad, a civil engineer moved overseas for a contract, I later met piping tutor, Allan Watters, former Pipe Major of the Black Watch and the senior Pipe Major at El Alamein who rounded off my training and became a close friend, both of us sharing our stories of active duty, his being far more interesting and historic than mine!
Great documentary Bruce well presented, I served for 9 years in the Black Watch and never knew the half of this history,Cheers Bruce, All the Best 🥃 Tam Purvey
Love Scotland! Once whilst in the Isle of Skye I heard a lone Piper and thought that a paranormal event was taking place, then found it was a guy practicing, great well narrated video
Just watched this. I severed in the US ARMY and retired. I was assigned along side a Blackwatch unit in southern Iraq. My ancestry is FRASER, who fought along side the Blackwatch. I was given a Blackwatch tartan by the unit I was with, I still wear it proudly today.
I'm an American of multi-UK descent...long story. But, my Grandma H. was of Highland descent. Her 4x great grandpa came here after the last Jacobite uprising! She taught me a great deal (yet, nowhere near enough) about my ancestry. I did, however, understand why these uprisings took place. My mother and my stepfather were both very authoritarian, even trying to control my thoughts and feelings. Nobody can endure forever under such conditions. Although I'm Episcopalian, I can understand the Covenanter viewpoint! My mother was Southern Baptist! I would swan dive into Hell before I would worship in that manner. Dad and his family ran the gamut from Catholic to Methodist. As for the Black Watch... my all time favorite Scottish military force! Pure badass! Thank you for posting this video! I would say the English government has some serious apologies to make!
@@aldenhaverfield655Ahh you do what ever's right for you!
Well seeing as you’re a Fraser and a soldier that fought alongside the Black Watch, I’d say you’d be mad not to!
And you are still a YANK too . 😂
My uncle Jim Matthew was captured at st valery 10th of June 1940 he was with the black watch royal highlanders with the 51st highland division my nephew was with the 1st Scots regiment the old highland light infantry he also did two tours of Iraq and 3 tours of Afghanistan one of his tours he was assigned to the American green berets special forces
I’m English and so my sympathy may not be entirely appreciated but I am always very emotional hearing about the treatment of the Highlanders. Such a beautiful place, leaving it against their will must have been so painful. Forcibly stamping out a cultural identity of such proud people seems the cruelest punishment imaginable. This video was very well done.
Thanks, hon. Love you guys loads xxxxxxxx J
I'm American but descended from Scottish highlanders.
While that likely doesn't actually mean anything to anyone, I for one, appreciate your sentiment.
I also descend from highlanders. I may have pict blood in my veins. I'm proud to be a scot ! (Albeit a tad removed ) .
It wasn't you doing bad to Highlanders don't live with guilt. It's 300 years we are a great nation after all. Is good to know the history but don't take it personal
I'm also English, well Yorkshire 😁 and have massive sympathy, love n respect for the Highlanders 👍
I'm a descendant of Farquhar Shaw and the information that you convey is why I chose to wear the Black Watch tartan over the Shaw tartan. Mad respect for this video Bruce.
Wow!
I too am related to Farquhar Shaw! And my Granddad, my Dad's Dad, was the Company Sgt Major in the 4th/5th Battalion Black Watch during WWI, and his brother too was with him. Their father too had been in the Black Watch. My Granddad on my Mom's side was a Piper in the Black Watch along with 2 of his 3 brothers all joining up together. (The third joined the Seaforths because I believe he had left home & that was his nearest battalion) & Granddad piped his mates 'over the top' and likely piped my CSM Granddad over the top (not knowing they'd be linked through marriage in the next war!) My Dad was also an apprentice in the Black Watch for awhile... though joined the RAF (& became a Flt/Eng in 148 (Special Duties) Sqd in WWII.
I've always been very proud of them all! My brother got my CSM Granddad's army uniform kilt (which has a mended bullet hole in it) and his son now has it. And my son's wedding colours were Black Watch tartan. Their firstborn little girl was Christened in a 130 year old Christening Gown, the ribbon of which I replaced with the Black Watch tartan which was around son's & wife's wedding cake & table ribbons. The Black Watch is a part of our history that we're very proud of. So thank you for the history lesson! I enjoyed it very much (I've just discovered your Channel & I'm slowly making my way through your vids & enjoying EVERY SINGLE ONE! :)
@@ScotlandHistoryTours I just stumbled on to your videos My maiden name is Morrison and I am just learning about my ancestry. I am going to hit the subscribe and start learning could you suggest on your videos where to start ??
I suppose I'd go to the channel page and look at the playlists which have a subject theme. That way you can choose what's of most interest to you first
Shaw clan blood here , hello from Australia Cuz ....LOL
Scottish descended American. I never considered wearing the Black Watch Tartan for the same reason I don't wear any American Service Uniforms, I never served. I was surprised that some Americans are against wearing the tartan. Honestly, I shouldn't be, a lot of Americans barely understand their own history, much less anybody else's. Honor to anyone who volunteers and serves, as my dad did.
Also, it was great seeing the statue and bridge again. I visited back in 2005. Someday I hope to return to Scotland.
You don't need to have served. Wear the uniform or tartan to honor those who did. Just wear them "correctly" is all this vet could ask.
Many Americans did not learn their history even if their teachers were good ones. Many of my father's students wrote essays that looked like they had fallen asleep in his class. But his only happened once and when the young lady realized she was surrounded by upper classmen when she finally woke up she never fell asleep in his class or any other again.
@@rvail136 Hello Richard, I've only just seen these history clips on the Black watch, and they are indeed a regiment to be proud of. I would like to wear the Black watch Tartan to honour those who served, so could you tell me how to wear it "Correctly", Thank you. Elizabeth.
@@e.w.1179 there are dozens of videos here on the tube of you....just search "how to wear a kilt"...
I became quite fond of the Black Watch tartan being introduced to it as a napoleonic re-enactor.
I've been on many of the Regiment's battlefields - from la Coruna to Waterloo- and always put it on as part of my period uniform .
It is just part of the hobby and a great fun.
I've learned to wear it properly according to 1813 regulations and I wear it occasionally as a modern garb just because I like it. Always been complimented when walking out in my Black Watch kilt, both in Continental Europe and in Scotland.
So, nae problem at all to wear it even if you don't have any real connection with the Regiment, just do it properly and it'll be 100% all right.
Thank you Bruce, I'm a 68 year old Aussie Veteran with Black Watch ancestors, your presentation put tears in my eyes.
Ah Kim, you just brought a bubble to me
My LaMont clan Scottish tartan.
“Dogmatic politics ignores people.” Then and now. Good word, Bruce! Such a tragic story. Thanks for sharing.
I should put it on a T-shirt
@ScotlandHistoryTours Sounds like a plan to me Bruce!
I was in the British Army and served with the Black Watch in the early 80s. It was like being part of a large family and even years later I have met people who I have served with. What surprised me was the number of Yorkshire men who had followed their ancestors from the 2nd world war to serve with them. There is nothing better than marching behind their pipes and drums when on parade. Fond memories.
Aye play Black Bear. Hello brother, I hope you're thriving. I began with the Black Watch but went to the paras but to upset some folk there I'd wear my kilt with pride in the mess.
It was government policy in WW2 to man regiments with conscripted personnel from different parts of the UK rather than predominantly from traditional geographic recruiting areas - a harsh lesson learnt from WW1 where communities and families had suffered heavy losses where their local battalions had been in action.
Do you not mean drums and pipes. As a Royal Scot in the 80s the one thing that gave me goosebumps was the return to barracks march home behind the drums and pipes. Only thing I've had a similar reaction is at murrayfield for the rugby when thousands of us sing flower of Scotland. Only part I miss to this day is my muckers.
The tab from glencorse to the castle law ranges up that hill back down and through the pipe with water back of Milton Bridge kirk I should have knew what was coming.
Wouldn't hange a thing though
My grandfather was in the Black Watch based in Montréal. As a immigrant to Canada, he felt it was his patriotic duty to serve his new country. The pride he felt from his service was beyond words.
Hi Adam, that would be the Canadian Black Watch
Wrong Black Watch, that’s the “plastic” Black Watch! 😂 However, I have served (being a black watch veteran) with Black Watch of Canada in Afghanistan. They were great men and over the moon, as well as surprised to be serving with us the “real” Black Watch! i have so much respect for them and the forebears from Canada. FTFT.
@@cwftft4273 when did you serve with the Scottish Black Watch?
My Dad was Black Watch for 22 yrs as was my Grandad -I was born in the Queens Barracks in Perth -proud of my Black Watch legacy
david fellow pert resident am 54 great great great grandfather was black watch grew up with a wollen black watch tartan as my bedspread very proud of the black watch too
My Uncle served during WWII as the regimental piper for the Calgary Highlanders of Canada. The Black watch was the tartan they wore. He was born in Scotland.
My father, an Edinburgh graduate, was Regimental Medical Officer to The Black Watch when they were in Berlin in 1951. It sounded like a place of complete devastation even 6 years after the end of WW2. The Black Watch was engaged in 'public order' duties, which meant riot control. The CO at the time was Bernard Fergusson (must be worth a video) who ordered that the Black Watch paint their helmets black and have a red hackle welded to the same. A hardened Tam O'Shanter.
Yep my grandfather was in the Black Watch. He was at Dunkirk, he spent years fighting the Japanese in Burma. He had the Burma star. I don't live in Scotland, I wasn't born there and I find it sad how some people hijack the memory of these people for their political causes.
People be people be people
It's enough to make an SNP Marxist weep with joy.
@@rpm1796 Rshole
Hard fighting, lest we forget
My granddad was in the Black Watch too captured at St Valerie. June 4th 1940. Mighty fighting Black Watch!
When a soldier dies in his duty no matter what country he serves he becomes part of a fraternity of honor having given all in this life had to offer for duty and country God bless them all!
First time I ever heard someone say what I have said since my own military service! I am British, living the last 20 years in Germany, married to a German and with kids. When I attend my village war-memorial each year, for that I do at 11am on the 11th of November, I read all of the names on the stone and remember my own family and my wife's, that have fallen; civilian or military, winner or loser. My drinking-kilt is in the Black Watch tartan BTW.
@Mr. Shlock I know nothing about you and won't make assumptions. Would you like to tell me why you feel this way?
@Mr. Shlock "The Shlock" took two attempts yet still managed to convey absolutely no message to his audience or intended victim......... Sir, you are a clown 🤡
@Mr. Shlock shlock, all soildiers are indeed "cannon fodder"........... Think about it
@Mr. Shlock yawn
I'm a Campbell, and my father was in the Black Watch , Canadian Regiment, in WW II. I wear the Black Watch tartan today with pride along with the Ancient Campbell tartan. Our family are proud of the Black Watch. Being Canadian, I never heard negative things about the Black Watch. When I was of legal drinking age, my father took me to the Black Watch Armory in Montreal for my fist drink. (smile) Thank you for the story of this illustrious regiment.
Fu*King campbells
My grandfather fought with the Black Watch and was wounded shortly before the assault on Verrieres Ridge. He lived the rest of his life with shrapnel in his back, but he lived, and I'm here as a result.
It has been a very long time since I've been the armoury, though a few years back I was able to visit the Citadel in Quebec City.
I've always associated the Black Watch with courage and I shall continue to do so.
Indeed, there are many fine examples. Trust me, Black Watch tartan still sells in the US. I know for a fact that people like to use it here in the US for a Scottish wedding too.
Thank you Bruce for helping to set the record straight on the American created Black Watch tartan issue (Or at least it seems that it was American created.)
@Cernunnos 2024 I think you missed everything I was trying to say. Sorry you missed that. And quit waving the liberal cultural appropriation flag. I descend from Scots. The Allisons, Donaldsons, the Stewarts and Duncan I, King of Scots. Scottish dna is in my veins. Cultural appropriation my rear end.
aye, and my great great granny was george washingtons chief carpet scrubber
@@LordRaiden86 I'm sorry who exactly were you trying to communicate to?
@@yogimarkmac Don't know why you feel the need to come on and comment negatively. Nobody cares what tartan you wear
This presentation is so touching, so personal. All I knew of the Black Watch was that band practice as held every week in the Black Watch Armoury on Bleury Street in Montreal and it was there that I cut my teeth as the only girl (so young) in a brass band, with many men who had served in the forces. Black Watch were represented in the annual parade along Sherbrooke Street. Black Watch was, for me associated with the mythical-romantic history of Scotland as a nation of warriors. This video opens up the personal tragic side of all these stories that live in history books and I thank you once again for giving them life.
British English, served with many Scots. Thanks for this, regiment is family, family is regiment. The links to our forebears are what sustains us now and in the future. You are justifiably proud of your grandfather, his tartan and your local regiment with its impressive history.
I'm English by birth but British by the grace of God. Served shoulder to shoulder with Scottish soldiers for many years in several places. Toiled with them in a veterans organisation too. The were and still are my proud brothers. Stronger together! One people, one crown and one flag.
@@gusgone4527 R sole
@@adyseven1 An archist.
I salute you brother. Stay safe, stay strong and stand united. Together we conquered the world.
@@gusgone4527 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
As an American, a historian by trade, and a descendent of American soldiers who fought in the Revolution, let me say here that the 42nd is a Regiment I hold in highest esteem. I can think of no regiment I would wish to hold my flank than the Black Watch!
The French sorted them out at Ticonderoga.
Heh heh... "revolution"
@@merrybutcher2978 and the Scots sorted them at the battle of Waterloo
@@Andy-ScotsIrish-TheGAEL. Wouldn't have done it before the Russian invasion.
I love this channel. I'm not of Scottish descent myself, but I live in the Canadian province of Nova Scotia, and we're bursting with people of Scottish descent. There is a strong pride in that descent, and in fact the island of Cape Breton, where almost everyone is descended from Scots stock, looks for all intents and purposes like some displaced Scottish province, rent from the very soil of that place, and dropped from the sky to abbreviate the Northumberland Strait.
Your content deserves the largest possible audience. Thanks for the great stories, and the lessons of history.
Nova Scotia - New Scotland. You will have some Scots in you.
@@marksadventures3889 Yes, a little. I think is about 5%. Based on 23 and Me, I'm mostly Irish and Northeastern French, with some Dutch, and German. I have 1/1024th of Mi'Kmaq as well.
"He wanted to be with his comrades and do his duty" The essence of every good soldier. Thanks for taking the time to make this, very informative. All the best from Dundee
Very emotional. From a True Scotsman. Two generations of my Family served with the Gordon Highlanders. Both of my Brothers with The Black Watch. Thank You.
Thank them all for their service, then and now.
Beannaich Dia na h-Albannaich anns a ’Ghàidhlig! ~~ Seas gu cinnteach
May the Lord God of the Scots Bless you! ~~Stand Sure [Anderson family motto]
Mstrdiver - US Army - 1973 to 1995
My dad was in the Black Watch between WW1 and WW2 before he came to Canada and then to the US and so proud of his service. I can remember wearing his Kilt when I was a kid in the 50s.
Many wear the Blackwatch tartan, But only a few have truly Earned it... and I thank Them for their Service.... and I thank You Bruce for sharing this with us....
As an American serviceman (retired now) I have always had great admiration for the Black Watch, thinking of them as the best fighters. My wife is a Shaw descendant so when we visited Scotland two years ago she got herself a kilt. I just asked her and she told me that her grandmother gave her her Black Watch kilt which is hanging in the closet. I am humbled, honored and proud to think that through marriage I might be related. I have 3 kilts of my own from the 3 pipes & drum bands that I am in and would be honored to wear a Black Watch kilt with my military uniform. Thank you for history lesson.
Your wife might like this ua-cam.com/video/vzcsVXn7_zs/v-deo.html
I just discovered your channel. Well done! I don't have any association with the Black Watch but I've served in America's military for 25+ years. I am pleased to see you name the names of the fallen soldiers. Their lives deserve to be remembered. Thank you.
Thanks from Canada. My grandfather fought with The Black Watch, Royal Highlanders of Canada (RHC) and survived WW1. His son, whom I'm named after was also Black Watch and fought in WW2, but was killed in the massacre on Verrieres Ridge when his regiment was near annihilated by SS troops. I play the pipes today in their memory and have for near 25 years.
My granddad was Canadian Black Watch WW1 13th Bn. Piper
My dad and my uncle were both Englishmen in the Black Watch in the 60s both Manchester lads, they've both passed now and I still have my dads kilt
Great video, I served with Baz Stephen We will remember him and all others. Thank you for this
Much love from a Campbell clan in mississippi. Black watch is always in my heart, and I still wear my great great grandfather Archibald's colours.
Campbell's always had a massive presence in the Argyll@ Sutherland highlanders
showed this to my father who was an officer in The Black Watch during the 80s and 90s; We both found it very interesting, thank you.
As an American of Cherokee Scott-Irish descent and having had the Honor and Privilege to have witnessed the courage and outstanding professionalism of the Black Watch Regiment bear no ill will towards them. Knowledgeable Americans have the upmost respect as well.
Thank you Bruce for your many wonderful videos and for sharing your knowledge.
Oh boy
This was a moving, and sad story. Thanks for sharing such a story close to your heart, and to your family.
My grandparents were from Scotland and I was raised with a reverence and respect if you like for the Black Watch.
Wow ! I had no idea about the true History of the Black Watch. How proud you must be of that grandfather in his Black Watch kilt.
Another fascinating video Bruce so brilliantly presented.
A lance corporal serving with the regiment was shot by a sniper in East Belfast in November 1971 and a young private serving with the regiment was killed while on foot patrol on Dungannon, County Tyrone by a remote control device in July 1978... 😔 I spent quite a while tonight trying to find their names, to my failure..
So many here in Ulster owe these young men and their comrades our lives. A debt we can never repay to some...
Good!
@@ianclark6485..Good?
OK chum..whatever..
There is no debt. All soldiers serve and do so following orders be they what they may. I am pleased to know Ireland is peaceful today and if that was possible by our service that's good. I am proud to know people of Ireland North and South and glad there is peace. Slainte
@@marksadventures3889Unfortunately there is no peace here my friend.. your service and the sacrifice of others all done in vain. The traitor Tony Blair surrendered to the murderous scum of the ira and released those responsible for the deaths of my own family members from jail.. an act that has signed his own death warrant should he ever be in the same room as myself.. He then left your fellow servicemen to face trial at the hands of the terrorists they were here to defend us from..
Again, there is no peace here my friend, merely a lul in the fighting..but the EU is trying its best to bring trouble back on the streets here nevermind anything else.. As for Ireland, it has been peaceful since the 1920s.. You never served in Ireland my friend..
Gotcha, yeah the IRA shouldn't have started the violent campaign, they should have used diplomacy and politics to get a better deal for the Catholics but I read a Wiki page on that horrific conflict and the British Army ended up killing LOADS of unarmed civilians during the pacification campaign. And yet the IRA was funded by the Soviet Union. A no-win situation! 😓 Hopefully the Accords will hold and the youth of Northern Ireland won't end up in the arms of say, George Soros or ANTIFA.....
My history is Scots/Irish and from the Appalachian mountains. I served in the United States Marines and if an American bad mouthed the Blackwatch then they are ignorant of our country's history. They should read about King's Mountain during the American Revolution.
Thank you. My grandfather served for decades. Born on the Isle of Skye. My father served our country for 32 years
Brilliant. My great uncle from Belfast served with Black Watch in the Boer war.
Beautiful Doc!!!! Long live the Black Watch!!!
I wear my BlackWatch kilt with pride here in the United States of America to honor my fighting ancestors who’ve bled and died for that name and that simple yet so important tartan!!!! Thank you for such amazing words you were able to convey in such a short time. I know you’ve touched many lives and informed many people. You have a wonderful gift.
Thank you for this. Two years ago I made a Black Watch themed guitar and donated it to raise money for charity. I could not do justice to the guitar without learning something of the history of the Black Watch. It was fascinating to learn, not just about the Regiment but also of other aspects of the history of Scotland. Originally from Derby I was always aware that the town was the southern-most reach of the Young Pretender's march on London. There is now a statue to commemorate this event in Derby. I digress but that is what history makes you do. I have followed many tangents and still do. Thank you for helping me to a better understanding of the mutiny. Personally I think that Farquhar Shaw was correct in his actions. The Black Watch is still a great regiment with proud traditions despite its recent homogenization. Thank you again. I have subscribed.
It breaks my heart, as a proud American, to hear some of the things that my countrymen heap scorn upon and about which they try to create narratives of shame and disgrace. Too many people want to leap to knee jerk conclusions without digging any deeper to seek the story behind the story and discover the truth. Thank you for a great story well told.
Only the leftists tend to do that
probably because they watch too many Mel Gibson movies and take what they see at face value as fact without doing any real researh on British history
Southern by Grace of God.
We Americans are often very lacking in our understanding of our own history, let alone that of another country, even one many of us are privileged to claim as an ancestral home. I remember as a young lad - a long time ago - reading Prebble's great histories of Scotland, including the Highland mutinies. A shameful period but the men of the 42nd and their families served with honor and dedication as do their modern day successors. I'm proud to have a Black Watch tartan along with my family tartan.
I am an American who is a history buff.
Material from the Ancient World through WW1 and WW2. What you are saying about Americans is true but not universal. I think they don't teach real history in school today. Just current events and politically correct BS. You don't know who you are unless you know where you came from. You can't understand American history unless you know European History - particularly British History. You can't understand British History unless you know Medieval European and Ancient History. It's all connected. I know a Scots American woman and a German American woman and I was surprised at what little they were taught about their own history in Scotland and Germany. I think it's kind of a universal problem today with younger people.
It's very similar to Gordon tartan as well
@@thomaszaccone3960 absolutely Right it's a shame
@@thomaszaccone3960 Can you clarify were they Scottish and German or were they American?
@@pengy4792 Born over there. Cane here later in life. Well past school age. I think they are both US citizens now
Great video. Powerful storytelling Bruce!
Much appreciated!
My English father began his military service during the Second World War with the Black Watch. He did his training at Queen’s Barracks, Perth and was ultimately sent to North Africa. In January 1944 he and a number other Black Watch men were transferred to the Sherwood Foresters for the Anzio landings. His closest friend was a man named John Gavin. They’d done their training together in Perth and been transferred to the Foresters together. As far as I’m aware, they never met again after the war. However, when I came along in the late 1950s, I was given his surname as my middle name. The bonds of comradeship run deep.
My grandfather was, too. Xxxxx 💖🦊🦊
Great story, infact many Englishmen have served in highland regiments over the years,
I think this is one of your absolute best videos, precisely because it's about very real, very specific people, and clearly so personal to you. I take my hat off to you, sir.
Thank you so much for this video...my cousin served with the Black Watch....and our family have always been proud of him....and the Watch 👍👍👍👍
My grandfather was in the black watch and I’m as proud as hell of him . And I’m ENGLISH . Great military force with a noble history of serving the British empire.
Brilliant tale as always. I’m an American Veteran (Clan MacDonald) and I proudly wear the Black Watch!
I grew up in the Black Watch family, my Father was a soldier for 22 years. I was born in Germany and also lived in Scotland, England, Northern Ireland and Hong Kong throughout the 80s and 90s.
I made a video talking a little about my timeline growing up as a kid in the Black Watch a while back, it's on my channel.
I live with my own family in Ontario, Canada these days. This was a great video and enjoy your channel very much. All the best!
A shower of Scottish traitors
Are you Charlie Stotts relative?
I am a very distant shaw, a great grandmother. I wear a shaw tartan kilt, im a us soldier of twenty years. Well now ill own a black watch kilt. Thank you for this and all of your amazing, and educational videos. I simply love them.
This was so heartfelt and informative. so many lives lost. My great-great grandfather on my mam's side was a blackwatch and I wore the Black Watch kilts to every St Patricks Day Parade in NYC and then for three Burns Night Celebrations. I wore it for my mam and I wore it for the BlackWatch who were lied to and then executed for their honor and pride of place. this video you made had me crying because no one would understand the pride here in the US. Thank you, thank you for making these people live again by telling their story and saying their names. thanks.
Why do you wear a black watch kilt to a St Patrick's day parade?, that's an insult to irish people. Do you not know what the black watch regiment did to irish people during the North of Ireland conflict.
Bruce you are a true Seanchaí. My grand mother told stories that we had a uncle of my great grand mother family was Black Watch. My great grand mother Jenny Baxter was born Lanark, Scotland 1873, died London, Kentucky 1970, her family immigrated to USA in the 1884. Great Grand dad Renus Brown (born Edinburgh 1866 died Pittsburg, Kentucky 1957, his side moved to the USA in 1877). Both met and fell in love in Pittsburgh Kentucky. Did my DNA and clocks in at 87% Scottish of which I am immensely proud, thanks to both Grand parents. And for you that get upset when you hear an American say "I'm Scottish", we know we are not "Scottish" in the born there sense. Settle down. That's American shorthand that really means "I'm of Scottish descent".
I portray a Lieutenant of the Black Watch during WW1 at the National WWI Museum and Memorial in Kansas City, MO; as part of the Living History Volunteer Corps. Felt compelled to do so after visiting the Military Museum at Edinburgh. Mad respect to all that serve!
"Mad respect" - LOL....
@@Page-Hendryx what’s funny?
@@fod1855 It's a trash American phrase.
@@Page-Hendryx We yanks think some of your phrases are trash too. But whatever.
@Mr. Shlock Not sure what you're trying to say, but like I said it's a trash Amerikwan ghetto phrase. Stop using it. Also, "Mr Shlock" is probably an apt name for you.
I’m American and I have no problem wearing mine. And now watching this video even more so.
Scotland has wonderful warriors. I had a good fight in Ayr one Friday night in a nightclub, even the police were nice to tell me to go back to the B&B. I had to fight 2 guys and the music stopped and a big circle surrounded me until the bouncers asked me to leave when I met the police at the door. The fire in the Scots was trilling, unlike the time when I had to confront an English platoon in Cyprus, where I annoyed them so much that they accepted me into the gang for the day on the remainder of the boat trip around Cyprus. I had the misfortune to wear the Irish flag bathing shorts for swimming and the English soldiers were just back from Belfast the day before and didn't expect to see the Irish flag, and 3 of the soldiers picked me up and threw me off the ship, they did that twice before I said something to make it stop. I love my neighbors..
love from Ireland... i stand beside you all.
My great grandfather, born 1861, wore the Black Watch tartan. His picture is on my wall. Thank you.
I come from south west Perthshire and my Grandad and two brothers volunteered for the 8th battalion of the Blackwatch (Highland Cyclists) in WW1.My grandfather was the only one of the brothers to survive the war.My mothers uncle served in the 5th battalion Blackwatch in WW2 and died after his platoon was straffed by RAF Hurricanes in a rest up area shortly after the Normandy landings.I am immensely proud of my family’s involvement with the Blackwatch and was extremely proud to wear the Blackwatch tartan at my wedding.
Could I ask, were your grandad and great uncles members of the 8th (Service) Battalion The Black Watch (Royal Highlanders)? Or were they members of the 1/1st Highland Cyclist Battalion (formerly - until the reforms of 1909 - 8th (Cyclist) Battalion, The Black Watch (Royal Highlanders))?
The reason I'm asking is that my great uncle served with the 8th (Service) Battalion, The Black Watch in WW1 and I am researching the battalion and the men who served in it. If your family members were 8th (Service) Bn. The Black Watch I would be grateful for any background information on who they were and what they did both prior to (and in your grandad's case after) the war. In turn, I will give you the details I have related to their war service and location of their graves / memorials - if you are interested.
A good story very well told. You have an excellent turn of phrase sir, and an obvious deep love of your subject which is very engaging. As a Yorkshireman I can recognise and empathise with the pride of place felt by Scots, we come from places where the landscape nourishes the soul. We may not see eye to eye on every subject, but every strength to you and your ventures on UA-cam.
My cousin was in the Black Watch. Fife is part of its recruitment area. I believe they’re talking of getting rid of it now. Had tears in my eyes watching this. Was at the Black Watch museum a couple of years ago. One of the saddest things I saw was the kilt with the mud of the Somme still on it. History is about people, not dates and battle recitals. History is to be learned from, not repeated.
Yes, more recently they recruited in Fife and Dundee. I suppose it depends what you mean by recent eh? They reorganised forces to save cash a while back and amalgamated regiments into The Royal Regiment of Scotland in 2006
@@ScotlandHistoryTours aye, but I heard something more recently about cutbacks and amalgamating it with another regiment and that the tartan wouldn’t be worn again. I was so angry, I switched off the report and didn’t get the details.
@@jacquelinebain57 Since 2006, all battalions of the Royal Regiment of Scotland, including the 3rd Black Watch Battalion, have worn a slightly lighter version of the Government tartan No 1, first worn by the 42nd (Known as 1a, this version was the tartan sett worn by the Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders). I very much doubt that it will change. So that should rate as glass at least half full.
@@jacquelinebain57 Scots battalions are safe. A battalion of the Mercian Regiment is being disbanded. Other reductions in manning will be through natural wastage over time. Someone else has commented on the tartan.
Bruce, you brought me to tears with your moving story and your family connection with the Black Watch. Great work, keep it up.
Ahhhh... the glorious sunny skies of Scotland! I hope to return in 2022!
I never knew of the Black Watch, but now that I do, I'll never forget them here in The United States, God bless you my Scottish friends.
My Dad fought in the second battle of the hook in Korea couldn’t be more proud. I remember him wearing his black watch tartan to my passing out parade when I joined the Argyll’s.
So did my dad Graham!
What a thrilling tale you tell! Growing up in the 1950s in central New York State, my dad would take me to performances by Black Watch pipe & drum bands, once a year if they came by, never missing a chance. Thank you for this video.
Great video. Love your presentation style and your passionate delivery. Have now subscribed.
I'm an American, and although my clan is Donnachaidh, I also have a family connection to the Black Watch. I proudly wear the issued kilt that belonged to a Co.Sgt. Murty. When I wear it, if someone makes a negative comment (usually a person of Irish descent) I make it a point to try to educate them about the regiment. This was a great video. Thank you for making it.
I wear my Black Watch tartan kilt and kit as often as occasion permits. My maternal grandfather (Campbell) served with the 10th. battalion from 1915-1918. Two of his brothers also served with the 8th and 10th battalions. Proud second generation Canadian of Scottish heritage and prouder still of my family’s service.
US Army veteran here……I don’t know any Americans that have disdain for the Black Watch but the US Army holds the Black Watch in high regard. Much respect for them and your grandfather
A large portion of Scottish immigrants came to Canada , keeping there homeland close to there hearts, they stood up and served in many highland regiments, most notable, the Royal Highland Regiment of Canada, the Black watch. they kept their traditions alive where ever they were, and shared them with new friends and family alike.
I have just discovered your brilliant channel. Your delivery and research are second to none. I didn’t realise how ignorant I was about Scottish history until I listened to you.
Very well done Bruce. As a 'Sweeney' I have been interested in Scottish history as Our History seems to have started in the Western Isles. It would seem to me as an ancestor of a Gallowglass that the Black Watch were the English/ Scottish form of constabulary / Gallowglass for the Highlands. For a centralized gov't or was it for the Lords of the varying estates throughout the countryside.
I'd already been blown away by your content, but this video is top shelf. A thousand kudos, sir. From an american Scot who has no roots, thank you for this, you are a gentleman and a scholar.
This is the second video I've seen from you bruce and I have to say, your passion for Scots history is infectious. Now it's time to sit back, sink a few (more) Guinesses and watch your back catalog. Slàinte mhath from Fife.
Only the second? Aye, get your hamework done laddie😀
WELL DONE SIR !! IT BROUGHT TEARS TO MY EYES . WELL DONE 👏.
Thanks
Aw, Bruce. I have tears in my eyes. Great video, thank you x.
Thanks Dee, glad you enjoyed it
I'm an American and my Dad taught me to respect that Tartan for the same reasons you point out so well in this video. Thank you.
A brilliant video and very well told story, thank you so much! Thank you especially for highlighting both the very personal story of Farquhar Shaw and the wider political issues. For such a small country, Scottish history is incredibly complex, but one of its main dynamics is the tension between personal independence and solidarity with the clan and the nation. A central element is personal loyalty to the clan/group leader, and through that leader, to the crown. What happens when the leaders behave in ways that fail their followers, or are so concerned with their personal status that they ignore the needs of their people? That's the question that lies behind so much Scottish history, even today. Liked and subscribed!
There is a photo here, similar to the one you described, of my grandfather who served in the Black Watch in WWI. He emigrated to New Zealand after returning from war. His kilt hangs in my brothers wardrobe.
I grew up with this monument and have long known the story but have never been so moved by it. An outstanding piece of videography.
My Uncle Davy was in the Black Watch, and he was a great bloke. He was very proud to have served with such a fine regiment. He always got emotional at the sound of the pipes.
I Just found your channel. You Sir, can tell a story!! My Glasgow born Grandpa and Great Grandpa, were both Black Watch!! Here in the states, we their Children, Grand children and Great Grand children are proud of them!! We wear the colors proudly on occasion.
My great grandfather was in the black watch his name was Arthur foy, my respect and regards to all from Australia.
I am an American veteran and can trace my ancestry back to Scotland. The only kilt I have ever worn was in Black Watch pattern.
The politics of this were unknown to me. All I knew was that they were soldiers, and good ones at that.
And that is all I need to know to honor them.
Stolen valor and cultural appropriation.
You need to earn the right to wear that
@@bachatacam4016 why can't people wear it to show respect and to teach about it? there's a difference. Plus some could be wearing the pattern not knowing what it is. Seriously y'all need to lighten TF up.
@@libertylovingbeckles6797 lighten the fuck up about cultural appropriation, tell you what I'll walk around in a USMC uniform with medals on and claim I'm honouring them? He never served in the British army, he has no right or claim to government tartan.
@@bachatacam4016 bollocks
I just love your clips on Scottish history. This one was very poignant, as that thread connecting the Black Watch from its ancestral lands to the present remains unbreakable. 👍
Thank you, Bruce. A very striking monument. There is so much to learn here.
I'm a Kiwi, but my Grandfather, Father and Uncle all served in the Black Watch and my Father always wore his Blackwatch kilt at special occasions as us boys wore the McNab tartan. Thanks for the video, the story of which was already familiar to me after reading the history of the Black Watch
this video deserves a "love" button, the like button just isn't enough.
Thanks for that Bob. Genuinely makes me warm
Another great video and movinging story of of The Black Watch, and Private Farquar Shaw.
This is what I was talking about, I knew there was a story like this around the black watch. Thank you for this 😊
Pleasure
@@ScotlandHistoryTours makes me think on the Gordon Highlanders. I mind a lovely man that lived in the care home in my village where I used to work as an activities coordinator. He was a Gordon highlander, loved his black watch tartan 🥰
@@RileyWolfeable Gordon Highlanders wore Gordon tartan (similar to Black Watch but with thin yellow stripes).
Used to have an army surplus Gordon's kilt myself - until it was nicked from my house by some eejit who probably didn't even know what it was.
I served alongside the Black Watch in Basra, and I would do so again. They were fantastic soldiers and the Iraqis came to respect them.
My uncle was part of the Black Watch. When he came to the states, he gave me the Black Watch pipes that he once played.
As an Englishman , I have always linked the Black Watch with valour and service to Britain, Bruce as usual fills in the blanks masterfully, Excellent video.
Thanks for a really good presentation, brings history to life.
Thanks. And I want to say that this American has no quarrel with the Black Watch or their tartan.
I could listen to you talk for hours. Thank you for getting into such detail. I've proudly worn the kilt of the Black Watch, and would do it all over again if I could.
I just subscribed to this channel. I'm an American veteran who served three years only. I served just one tour because I knew that once in, the powers that be own you and your destiny. Much respect for the men described in this true tale of heroes!
Having done some genealogical research I am a descendent of one Mary Bruce who as a young lady, lived in the Fordyce area of Aberdeenshire who for whatever reason, migrated to Virginia in America in the year 1703.
A great regiment with a great military history, as a piper, I had not trained in piobaireachd when my dad, a civil engineer moved overseas for a contract, I later met piping tutor, Allan Watters, former Pipe Major of the Black Watch and the senior Pipe Major at El Alamein who rounded off my training and became a close friend, both of us sharing our stories of active duty, his being far more interesting and historic than mine!
Great documentary Bruce well presented, I served for 9 years in the Black Watch and never knew the half of this history,Cheers Bruce, All the Best 🥃 Tam Purvey
Thanks Tam
Love Scotland! Once whilst in the Isle of Skye I heard a lone Piper and thought that a paranormal event was taking place, then found it was a guy practicing, great well narrated video
From North Carolina, USA. My grandmother was also a Sharpe.