Ok well now that it's been pointed it as a theory I don't believe it is her, but cmon olivia give him a second chance I mean U and I both know you can't resist that pretty face ;)
JR is the one helping Emma! Someone who knows several conspiracies theories surely knows lots of secrets too, and we saw that he's a quite a good hacker; It would be easy for him to send messages to everyone, or control printers and screens. Being a conspiracist, he can smoothly hide his partnership with Emma. And the cake? Certainly, he doesn't want to waste a cake he paid for. but why would he help Emma, they don't seem to be close..... because now everybody will take his crazy ideas seriously
I think it's Tess cause she wants the drama and she does like the guilty group sooo she is helping Emma cause she needs drama and something to talk about cause all she do it talk about other people's life and drama OMG ITS TESS
i would almost be offended if i hadn't heard this theory about a bajillion times. no need to speculate, it WASN'T me. simply doing my journalistic duty and reporting the facts!
Yeah that makes a lot of sense Gabriel. Honestly this guy is the one throwing theories the hardest, which does make him look more guilty. If his tea gets spilled, I'm so excited for it!! :)
Gabriel Cavalheiro If he's doing it, he wouldn't accuse everyone but himself because it'd be too obvious. And if he was working with Olivia he wouldn't want to draw attention to himself or Olivia. Personally I think it could've been Tati, maybe Preston, or even Alex.
that video she posted claiming she was sick seemed very fake and suspicious so i might be inclined to believe this although maybe she was actually helping emma with the cake and that was why she was not there. maybe she secretly prefers emma to tatiana which is convoncing since she spoke about her so much but can't even be bothered to show up to tatianas party? pretty convinced olivia is helping emma now.
FINALLY!! SOMEONE UNDERSTANDS MY THOUGHTS!!! IT MAKES SENSE! SHE WAS "SICK" (nice acting) WHEN IT WAS HER BIRTHDAY!! SHE COULD HAVE EASILY SENT THAT CAKE!! SHE IS WORKING WITH EMMA!!
Here's a theory: Everyone had a part in this. Without telling Emma. One person got the diary, one hid it in the school, one kept an eye out for it, one made copies of it, and one put the pages up there.
DestinyMage Nikos I always thought it was a collab effort. How did Person plastered the pages without getting caught? Person had a lookout. And think about it: Every important person in this show had a good reason to hate Emma, so, why not wait until the most important moment in her life to expose who she really is?
Olivia i don't think it was you! I see people commenting how J.R. and you were helping Emma, but if he knew you were doing it with him why would he draw attention to you Olivia? I think it could've been Tati or maybe even Alex..
it was totally her. She wasn't at the party when the cake was delivered, Tati and her are best friends so only Olivia would know that. Olivia would be jealous of how Preston and Tati are the #1 couple so she decided to take their place and exposed Preston so that Tati and Preston wouldn't be #1 and her and JR could be #1 until JR recently exposed her, which makes me predict that JR will be next to be exposed. I have more to my theory but that would take awhile to explain and I don't feel like explaining it all right now
Personally, I believe emma started this whole ordeal. She wanted something to happen, so she spread her diary (fake diary maybe?) around and BOOM. Exactly what she wanted.
OR think about this...what if i just love theories? u know, people say i'm pretty talented at comin up with them. don't keep a man from following his passion!
Or maybe Olivia was talking about Emma a lot because she is into her? Could still be the one that stole the diary, like unrequited love turning to hate? Or they do have a thing now and Olivia is helping Emma? So many possibilities!
I like J.R., but the fact that he keeps making theories, makes me think that maybe he's saying everything to steer everyone away from suspecting him, believe him and his theories, because he did it. These theories are the cover up. He's so insistent that someone else did it. That's why he's saying that he's always right.
Um I probably wouldn't have put it exactly like that but honestly I agree. The convenient fact that Olivia wasn't there at Tatiana's B-day is a bit too much for me
You're so savage, J.R. Go take your theories to someone who cares.
thanks, Tati. knew u would have my back like i always have urs 💕 and J.R. r u kidding me?? ur def NOT getting another date now...
olivias fake gags were ridiculously fake, its her lol
Ok well now that it's been pointed it as a theory I don't believe it is her, but cmon olivia give him a second chance I mean U and I both know you can't resist that pretty face ;)
HELLO HI WE CARE
Noor Kahwash ikr.
JR is the one helping Emma! Someone who knows several conspiracies theories surely knows lots of secrets too, and we saw that he's a quite a good hacker; It would be easy for him to send messages to everyone, or control printers and screens. Being a conspiracist, he can smoothly hide his partnership with Emma. And the cake? Certainly, he doesn't want to waste a cake he paid for. but why would he help Emma, they don't seem to be close..... because now everybody will take his crazy ideas seriously
i always see your comments and theories on each video,and they are actually accurate! great job on them!
WHAT IF ITS YOU!!!!!
The cake one is really something to think about..
Gabriel Cavalheiro
Unless he didn't want watse a good cake, so, do a five second rule.
This actually makes a lot of sense....a lot more than J.R.'s newest "truth". Thanks for your comments Gabriel! :)
I thought it was Olivia, but now that you made a theory I'm not so sure
I NEED A CLEAN UP ON AISLE ONE! SOME HOT TEA WAS SPILT EVERYWHERE!!!
how many mops does it take to clean up all this tea? EENGH 🚨answer: 2️⃣1️⃣2️⃣
I think it very well could be Olivia, but not for these reasons. I think she wanted to show Tatiana how 'cool' she was by humiliating Emma.
I think it's Tess cause she wants the drama and she does like the guilty group sooo she is helping Emma cause she needs drama and something to talk about cause all she do it talk about other people's life and drama OMG ITS TESS
CC& EJ I have been saying tess since episode 1 THANK YOU FOR ASLO THINKING SO!
I doubt it
Tess isn't that stupid
and also i think tess has/had a crush on emma which is what she told alex not to tell anyone about
i would almost be offended if i hadn't heard this theory about a bajillion times. no need to speculate, it WASN'T me. simply doing my journalistic duty and reporting the facts!
CC& EJ YES
okay J.R i see you digging for gold 0:09
what can i say, u gotta be prepared to look anywhere to get to the truth
J.R.
But sometimes, the truth can hurt.
My god-
"Usually girls talk about my beautiful face." 😂 that line killed me
J.R. you’re my spirit animal
I accept. and you're welcome.
NOOOO She's helping Emma, why do you think she was talking about her so much? Don't try and confuse us!
I always look forward to this guy
you and me both CreepyRainbowLover 47
every time you come up with a different theory.... a bit suspicious?? 🤔 trying to hide something??
Yeah that makes a lot of sense Gabriel. Honestly this guy is the one throwing theories the hardest, which does make him look more guilty. If his tea gets spilled, I'm so excited for it!! :)
Gabriel Cavalheiro ur always here 🙄😂
Gabriel Cavalheiro If he's doing it, he wouldn't accuse everyone but himself because it'd be too obvious. And if he was working with Olivia he wouldn't want to draw attention to himself or Olivia. Personally I think it could've been Tati, maybe Preston, or even Alex.
Gabriel Cavalheiro DUDE I SEE YOU SO MUCH I'm starting to wonder if I'm stalking you or something 🙈
I think it's either Olivia or Tess... or both
it could've been olivia i mean we don't know much about her
all u need to know is that i'm innocent... J.R. look what u have done ughh 🙄
Alright so now we know it's not Olivia
that video she posted claiming she was sick seemed very fake and suspicious so i might be inclined to believe this although maybe she was actually helping emma with the cake and that was why she was not there. maybe she secretly prefers emma to tatiana which is convoncing since she spoke about her so much but can't even be bothered to show up to tatianas party? pretty convinced olivia is helping emma now.
plus she's been acting all friendly with Tatiana lately, probably to appear innocent in her eyes
at this point it seems like everyone could be helping Emma..I'm so confused. This is a thick plot
Damn JR comes up with the greatest theories. I’m all for it in this show
I mean it would makes sense, considering that her BFF Tati was best friends with Emma, jealousy does wonders don't you think
kolomadica this deserves more likes
I'm fine with any theory as long as nobody's picking on Alex.
'she was talking alot about emma and usually girls talk about my beautiful face so it didn't make sense' LMAO
My favorite part of this series
olivia and jr? an iconic ship
FINALLY!! SOMEONE UNDERSTANDS MY THOUGHTS!!! IT MAKES SENSE! SHE WAS "SICK" (nice acting) WHEN IT WAS HER BIRTHDAY!! SHE COULD HAVE EASILY SENT THAT CAKE!! SHE IS WORKING WITH EMMA!!
Personality on point 😂👌🏼
Here's a theory: Everyone had a part in this. Without telling Emma. One person got the diary, one hid it in the school, one kept an eye out for it, one made copies of it, and one put the pages up there.
Nice idea Magician. Actually seems really plausible. Good job with this theory!! :)
DestinyMage Nikos
I always thought it was a collab effort. How did Person plastered the pages without getting caught?
Person had a lookout. And think about it: Every important person in this show had a good reason to hate Emma, so, why not wait until the most important moment in her life to expose who she really is?
You are just the best JR
his eyelashes are goals
hey, Miles sent me from his channel and I'm in love with this show!! when's the next episode coming out?!!
*plot twist* I think Emma exposed it herself just so she could slowly ruin their lives!
J.R.: "So I've been thinking… again."
Me: Uh oh
conspiracy theory:it was J.R.
I love J.R.'s theories 😂
His videos give me life 😂
The fact you keep calling out my theories makes me think I’m wrong about them :(
It was Olivia
it was soooo not. omg J.R. now i'm being dragged into this whole mess because of u
Olivia i don't think it was you! I see people commenting how J.R. and you were helping Emma, but if he knew you were doing it with him why would he draw attention to you Olivia? I think it could've been Tati or maybe even Alex..
Caitlyn Bailey I have the same feeling.
it was totally her. She wasn't at the party when the cake was delivered, Tati and her are best friends so only Olivia would know that. Olivia would be jealous of how Preston and Tati are the #1 couple so she decided to take their place and exposed Preston so that Tati and Preston wouldn't be #1 and her and JR could be #1 until JR recently exposed her, which makes me predict that JR will be next to be exposed. I have more to my theory but that would take awhile to explain and I don't feel like explaining it all right now
Olivia
Well, it's a better idea than say it to you in person.
Personally, I believe emma started this whole ordeal. She wanted something to happen, so she spread her diary (fake diary maybe?) around and BOOM. Exactly what she wanted.
J.R. IS SO FUNNY I CANNOT HAHAHAHAHA
Back at it again with the white vans
Blue Dreams please give back ur moms phone
Lexi Williams 😂😂
I love J.R. sooo much 😂😂
Finally someone said it 😂
THE PEOPLE NEEDED THE TRUTH 💯
Belle M. *I said right after she vlogged!* 😞 I don't put it past her!😞
J.R. right! 😌
I love how J.R basically is everyone in the comments😂😂
You can point a finger
But there's three pointing back 💀🎶
I love your character 😂😂
Plot twist : it was JR.
I really think it was Emma herself just wanting drama and being the center of attention. But low key love j.r. 😂 he is my favorite
Kenny (J R) literally is my favorite I stg
finally baby we're (somewhat) on the same page!!!!!!!
“Buttt... it’s facts” 😂
Guys guess what? tomorrow is Tuesday so guilty party time
Yassss I've been waiting for somebody else that thinks that I've been saying that since the 2nd episode
hottest man around warren academy... yeah sure but have you seen jake and alex???
have you SEEN me on the dance floor?!
AlexDisney lol😅… true
J.R. Oooh😕 😂
TRUE
J.R.
I have seen you in your freshest outfit ever! (Your uniform.)
You look rad and mad, and you're not bad in it, too.
its either Olivia, Tess orrr JR
I'm with you on this! I think Olivia is helping Emma or she's just doing it.
"It's facts" me when I'm a conspiracy theorist.
rip J.R's love life
It was Jr or Olivia.
I can't believe you did this whole theory and didn't mention that Olivia wasn't at Tati's birthday party!
J.R. BACK TO DROP SOME KNOWLEDGE
love this guy
what if J.R is doing these conspiracy theories so people think it’s not him 🤷🏻♂️🤓
OR think about this...what if i just love theories? u know, people say i'm pretty talented at comin up with them. don't keep a man from following his passion!
Or maybe Olivia was talking about Emma a lot because she is into her?
Could still be the one that stole the diary, like unrequited love turning to hate?
Or they do have a thing now and Olivia is helping Emma?
So many possibilities!
I been thinking... Again...
JR knows something 🕵️🕵️🕵️🕵️
I like J.R., but the fact that he keeps making theories, makes me think that maybe he's saying everything to steer everyone away from suspecting him, believe him and his theories, because he did it. These theories are the cover up. He's so insistent that someone else did it. That's why he's saying that he's always right.
I love this kid😂💀
I think it was Olivia too😂😂
Iconic.
Agreed
At the end it'll be someone we didnt even think about. But like who? Probably someone out of their friend group
Episode 6 today!! 😄
i was pretty sure it was olivia but then this came out so now i'm not sure 😖
Um I probably wouldn't have put it exactly like that but honestly I agree. The convenient fact that Olivia wasn't there at Tatiana's B-day is a bit too much for me
Well now that he covered this it can’t be
J.R. Honestly only one of ur theories i agree with
Actually I think she’s helping Emma. She was home sick (which btw looked totally fake), and had every chance and reason to help her.
ummm Brady, i'm seriously offended. do i even know u? that's a huge accusation. why would i fake sick or have any desire to help Emma?!? ugh.
Olivia Or maybe you weren’t getting enough spotlight as Tatiana. That makes some more sense then you just being petty for an unknown reason.
It's obviously Olivia, I've been calling it since the beginning
Dangit I thought it was Olivia but now he said it was Olivia so I guess it isn't Olivia?
HAPPY BIRTHDAY KENNY
j.r most definitely had a vine account
I'm crying 😂😂😂
Maybe J.R. posted emma's dream journal...
why does he say “olivia” so weird lmao, he’s like “oh-livia”
JR is iconic
It was J.R.!
YES SO EARLY
He’s my favorite😋
You know what? Olivia is been getting closer and closer to Tatiana without any apparent reason, so there may be something hidden there
Well ok but why though.Why would she do it?To start drama?idk
I love Charlie but I really think it was her. I'm also really excited to know what Charlie did.
Bobbie Vlogs I totally agree!
God JR just the fandom isn't he-
I actually agree with someone and I’m surprised that’s you
no need to be surprised Riley, the facts DON'T. LIE.
J.R. Your right! I would think that you would continue on the theory on Principle Lee. I’m going to hopefully continue on with the Olivia theory
Is Charlie next¿
Kenny Knox!!!
It was J.R.
Every one of these theory vlogs in crease my own theory that it was JR
ME?! J.R. Jackson?! i'm just the messenger of wisdom here, no need to be coming after me now, c'mon
Let it be whoever you want but not charlie plz.
EXCUSSSEEEEEE MEEEEEEEE?!?!
its jr hes trying to get no one to pay attention to his involvement by blaming everyone else
DAMN J.R. THIS IS WHAT IVE BEEN SAYING FOR SO LONG DAMN