My Thoughts on Maria Robotnik In Sonic 3...

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 115

  • @clerkwithamouth
    @clerkwithamouth Місяць тому +110

    Shadow doesn't blame specifically Walters for Maria's death. Closer to, he holds him partially responsible. Especially since Walters was the last thing Shadow saw before he went into stasis.

    • @stormbringer717
      @stormbringer717 Місяць тому +24

      I also like how shadow in the past was a lot more free spirited , and enjoyed fun times with maria, showing how shadow was very similar to Sonic and Tails , but tragedy changed shadow forever.

    • @JDog2656
      @JDog2656 Місяць тому +16

      @@stormbringer717 He's still different from them in some ways. He certainly appears more reserved and existential. Considering that he came fully grown in a meteor and doesn't know where he came from, it could indicate his potential Black Arms connection. Being a lab rat certainly didn't help. Point is, he is similar to Sonic in some ways, but always had that dark in him.

    • @stormbringer717
      @stormbringer717 Місяць тому +6

      @JDog2656 i like that too . Basically, he is sonic but more introverted , also the fact he came from a commet was a nice reference to the black commet from the black arms . I do wonder wear do shadow and sonic come from in the movie universe.

    • @geeebuttersnap2433
      @geeebuttersnap2433 Місяць тому +8

      It’s tragic that shadow doesn’t know that Walters was the only Soldier there that was trying to save Maria, it would be a great scene of character development to show Walters explain that he tried to save them, that he tried to save Maria by grabbing the soldiers rifle and angle it away from them, but unfortunately ended up killing Maria in the explosion caused by a negligent discharge, maybe show Walters being a broken man with regret about having failed Maria, and shadow can see that walters was never the enemy.

    • @gearhead743
      @gearhead743 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@geeebuttersnap2433 while true, Walter's dialog at the chao garden scene does make him sound somewhat complacent with the actions of GUN.

  • @JohnWickstairs
    @JohnWickstairs Місяць тому +73

    I was worried that the movie would gloss over Maria and Shadow’s care for each other but I am glad that the writers did a wonderful job. The scenes got me emotional

  • @chozochiefxiii3298
    @chozochiefxiii3298 Місяць тому +28

    Outside of the 3rd act, the Shadow and Maria flashbacks were my favorite part of the movie. I like that they had Sonic be the one to discover Shadows familial relationship with Maria. Since in their first encounter Sonic was still snarky with Shadow. Walters tells sonic that shadow was a lot like sonic but found only pain and loss. Once Sonic found out the truth about Shadows trauma he was more willing to be empathetic and talk to Shadow rather than fight him.
    Shadow in general I just love. His trauma is what wakes him. At first there's no desire for revenge he's just awake, hurting and looking for purpose. I love his encounter with G.U.N. in Tokyo. "Why won't you just leave me alone."
    It's made crystal clear that deep down shadow doesn't actually want to hurt anyone. I liked seeing him actually open up to Sonic about Maria when they were on the moon. It's a dialogue I wish was explored in the game continuity at least once. Just let Sonic and Shadow sit down and talk, let Shadow open up a bit about Maria. Maybe Sonic and Shadow wouldn't be frenimies anymore.
    In Shadow Generations, Maria even makes it clear she sees Sonic and thinks he is one of Shadows' friends.

  • @maciesummers4938
    @maciesummers4938 Місяць тому +71

    I think what the movie got 100% right about Maria is her heart and unconditional love.
    It was never transactional, rather she just saw shadow immediately as a sibiling
    In dark beginnings and In the movie, she knows shadow isn’t a monster like how everyone else views him. But he is a person who deeply loves.
    And that he just wanted someone to love him. That’s where I think the movie relationship lies on is just two kids who wanted love and found it each other in a military base filled with monsters.
    I absolutely love how they spend soo much time together just playing around, getting in trouble, teaching him to dance and building a little fort. A fort just for them! And how it is only her who is treating him with love. Love the flower scene!!
    I absolutely loveeee that she skates and plays the guitar acoustic version. And from the beginning shadow cherishes her playing it to him.
    Buttttt…. I still think we needed more focus on shadow, Maria and Gerald this movie or a spin-off. I’m not the happiest about Maria’s disability write-off, her non-sacrifice or how shadow wasn’t made to for her. I still loved the movie but I think they did a disservice by not slowing it down and having those tough talks of acceptance, death looming and finding ones-self between Maria and shadow. I think if they cut a lot of Ivo and Gerald scenes and actually gave shadow and maria 30-40 minutes of content I think it would have been a absolutely amazing movie.

    • @maciesummers4938
      @maciesummers4938 Місяць тому +15

      BUT ALSO PEOPLE!! WITHOUT YOU THE FULL VERSION FROM DARK BEGINNINGS IS NOW STREAMING!!!

    • @MárioRubenMartins4
      @MárioRubenMartins4 Місяць тому

      No it didnt only americans think that but in reallity americans ruined a japanese story like they are doing with european stories

    • @MilkyWayMarsBar
      @MilkyWayMarsBar Місяць тому +11

      @@MárioRubenMartins4 How did we ruin it? I personally think that Shadow and Maria as siblings is infinitely better than them as 'lovers', which is downright weird and gross (as people are claiming that Shadow and Maria are in Japan).

    • @MárioRubenMartins4
      @MárioRubenMartins4 Місяць тому

      @MilkyWayMarsBar hmm in the original japanese story the god king of all they arte not lovers but close friends like lil bro and sister, see this is why america ruins everything cause all they see is s.x but dont know what condoms are, i have been playing SA2 for at least 23 years i know the story of them to the tea i even loved what a brazilian fan did he did not make them lovers but as a big sis and funny lil bro i loved that better then this...crap at least the brazilian guy had the kindness to draw the ark in space and not some dumbass crap on the sea or whatever england has this story weas a insult to shadow shadow is a well defined complicated and unique caracter made by a japanese, and some ding dong that said he played the game probably to levbel 5 and didnt finish the game and there is a biolizard and whatever that dumb goofy thing was but oh well ytou people there like goofy stuff so go see it many times and 1 for myself cause i wont see this movie or any movie in theaters ever again

    • @LegionOf3
      @LegionOf3 Місяць тому +2

      I fully agree. Would have been a great way to add in the Bio-Lizard too. But I think the movie would have needed to be PG-13

  • @OrangeToadGamer
    @OrangeToadGamer Місяць тому +62

    I really liked how they portrayed Maria in the movie, she is very charming and her bond with Shadow is really endearing, honestly makes her fate all the more sadder

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +20

      And this is why I love the movie! Love seeing people care for her, instead of just make fun of her tbh

    • @juliabonavita4731
      @juliabonavita4731 Місяць тому

      ​@Idkkprincess it feels like ever since dark beginnings the meme of cheering for Maria to die QUICKLY die down

    • @freelands8355
      @freelands8355 25 днів тому +1

      ​@@Idkkprincess i always hated whenever people cheered at her death scene in Sonic Symphony

  • @J.M.C.Thorne
    @J.M.C.Thorne Місяць тому +46

    One aspect I was wondering about (and ended up liking) was the fact that when you say "50 years ago" in the early 2000s, it would take us to the 1950s, and we see this in Maria's clothing style in the games, HOWEVER, when you say 50 years ago in the 2020s it takes you back to the 1970s and we see how the whole 70s motif is used between Shadow and Maria in the movie from the clothing to the music, and I'm all for it. ❤
    Ps. Can you imagine Shadow saying "Groovy" or using any 70s slang? XD

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +19

      We need Shadow interacting with the new world and love for vinyl 🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @MilkyWayMarsBar
      @MilkyWayMarsBar Місяць тому +4

      @@Idkkprincess Definitely 💯😂

  • @katieee_llyn
    @katieee_llyn Місяць тому +19

    Honestly I adored their relationship so much in the film. It was even better than I imagined. I’ve always wanted to see the characters act properly like kids and siblings. It made her death the more emotional and even brought me to tears. The quote she and shadow quote a few times in this film too made me ball. It reminded me of my father who died passed when I was a kid. Honestly brilliant movie
    Edit: I’m hoping that if they do a solo movie for shadow that they go more in depth and show more moments with shadow and Maria

  • @donaldwright8567
    @donaldwright8567 Місяць тому +31

    I do love the fact that they specifically gave Maria 70's style outfits and interests (skating, record players, ect.). Unlike in the games where we're always told that the ARK incident took place 50 years in the past, but nothing in the games reflected that.
    The thing that always drove me crazy is that for some reason in the games, the G.U.N. soldiers were shown to have just as advanced equipment and technology as they do in the modern day, which makes absolutely no sense!?

    • @J.M.C.Thorne
      @J.M.C.Thorne Місяць тому +5

      Ikr? The 70's aesthetic was one I hoped they would not forget, seeing the movies came out in the 2020s, and they looked good! BTW, something that took me off guard was the idea that Maria was the one who roller skated, and Shadow possibly took that from her! Mind-blown.
      When it comes to the og design of Maria, I always saw her dress very 50's ish, do I don't have much quarrel with the og game on that matter.
      Edit: I agree with the G.U.N. soldiers issue. They look the same always 😂😂😂😂 a big oversight to be sure.

  • @liamphibia
    @liamphibia 16 днів тому +1

    I cannot wait for another overanalysis from you when Sonic Movie 3 comes to DVD/streaming. This is just *great.*

  • @FSAPOJake
    @FSAPOJake 24 дні тому +2

    I like that they gave her kind of the same silly personality that Gerald and Ivo have. Her heart was never twisted like theirs, so we get some insight not only into what Shadow may have ended up like if he just had close friends during his time on Earth, but also what Ivo might have been like if he was raised by a family that properly loved him.

  • @DrCocofruit
    @DrCocofruit Місяць тому +15

    It's not that his quills can stop time, but instead that the chaos energy innate for Shadow and his quills has a rejuvinating effect, so Gerald licking the quills is like taking a sip from the fountain of youth to keep him alive longer
    I wonder if Ivo knows this
    Edit: Explained by Jeff Fowler himself. They were gonna make a scene to show this but instead it was cut for time cus it's just a minor thing in the grand scheme of the movie's plot

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +2

      I highly doubt Ivo knows… but he did take a lot of licks throughout this movie…maybe he’s still alive. Who would’ve thought the stinking hedgehog would be his salvation 🤣🤣🤣

  • @TheNitr01
    @TheNitr01 24 дні тому +2

    The moments we did have of Maria made me so positively elated that I definitely became blind to the way they changed her character from the games, which you did a good job of pointing out.

  • @BigCheesyPro
    @BigCheesyPro Місяць тому +12

    One thing I think many of us are grateful for this year, is that, no matter what, people know who Maria is now. Between Dark Beginnings, Shadow Generations, and the Sonic 3, more people know her now, and know who she is and what she meant to Shadow. And even if the many iterations of her differ, and their circumstances may change, no matter what, her and Shadow were everything to each other, and everyone knows that now, and I think that’s my biggest takeaway!

  • @mylesmwalkerjr
    @mylesmwalkerjr Місяць тому +8

    I've been waiting on your take on Sonic 3, this is like a Christmas Gift to me

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +3

      HAHAHAHA thanks for waiting! Spoiler review/free character breakdown tomorrow. Hopefully…

    • @mylesmwalkerjr
      @mylesmwalkerjr Місяць тому +1

      I'll look forward to it

  • @honeybeebo
    @honeybeebo 23 дні тому +1

    great discussion that you’ve opened up! I see Maria as the Ultimate Deathform, and the writing for various depictions takes that title in various directions: as an angelic doomed plot device, or an ever looming illness that Shadow is frustrated he can’t cure, or a haunting repeating memory of her last moments, or a connection to humanity that she never actually got to live as, or in the movie’s case simply an accident that took us (and her family) by surprise. no sacrifice, no illness, just an unfortunate attempt at prevention. and that works because they showed her being an actual character beforehand. in every iteration, as soon as you see her you know she’s gonna die, you can’t work around that doom even if you don’t want to directly shoot her. but at least this time she’s shown living for awhile to juxtapose the abrupt doom. but i think they could’ve (and should’ve) worked her illness in the movie somehow, even as just a simple line of dialogue to explain why she’s at the lab, because she can be just as upbeat and lively with a disability

  • @waqasomar8272
    @waqasomar8272 26 днів тому +3

    Your thoughts on Maria and shadows relationship are things I've always thought about but never verbalised and I love that I hope you can keep making videos about anything

  • @knux333jw
    @knux333jw 29 днів тому +4

    I love how Maria was portrayed in the movie... (don't even mind her toned down death scene all too much) but yeah. They cut a bit t o o many things from her game backstory to make her simpler, and there definitely needed to be a few more scenes to clear up things around Shadow's part in her story as well. Maybe it's stuff that'll be touched on in a future project.
    Especially think it wouldn't be too pricey either. Since just one scene showing how much she meant to Gerald, or how Commander Walters factored into things would've helped.

  • @MilkyWayMarsBar
    @MilkyWayMarsBar Місяць тому +11

    🚨 *_(WARNING!! TEENAGE FAN GIRL INFO DUMPING BEYOND THIS POINT!! WILL CONTAIN SPOILERS!!)_* 🚨
    As a 17 year old lifelong Sonic fan, I gotta say: Sonic 3 was so phenomenal, that I watched it 3 times (2 days ago was my third time, the 20th was my second, and the 19th {the Fan Event} was my first). Also, Alyla really captured Maria's energy and kindness accurately; she did amazing as Maria.
    The movie got Maria's compassion and empathy right; Maria was as sweet, sympathetic, understanding, and nice as she was in the games. They really captured Shadow and Maria's sibling bond/friendship (whatever you view it as), correctly. It was very wholesome and heart warming to see....And the quote, "the light that shines even when the star is gone"....
    That just broke my heart. Paramount, Fowler, + SEGA COOKED with this movie.
    Actually, the movie got EVERYTHING about SA2 right---Just a few changes, like how Maria doesn't have N.I.D.S in the movie, as well as Shadow wasn't created by Gerald (with the help of Black Doom); Shadow was found in a meteorite that landed in Oklahoma 50 years ago (I forgot where the meteorite was found, despite watching Sonic 3, three times lmao. Please correct me if I'm wrong). Shadow even tells Maria he doesn't know where he's from. Two other changes is that of Gerald being executed by firing squad, and being dead long before the events of SA2 + Shadow '05. In the movie, he was actually still alive, and Fowler revealed him taking hits off of Shadow's quill (like how Eggman does with Sonic's) helped him get slightly younger each time he did it, because of the Chaos Energy inside the quill. Finally, the last change is how Maria died: She died from a gun shot to a tank full of Chaos Energy, which led to an explosion. I (personally) don't mind these changes, and the movie still exceeded my expectations!
    Anyways, Alyla did _amazing_ as Maria, Keanu did _amazing_ as Shadow, and all the other actors; Ben as Sonic, Colleen (the OG) as Tails, Idris as Knuckles, Jim Carrey as Gerald & Eggman; plus other actors/actresses that played supporting characters: Tom, Maddie, Rachel, Randall, Rockwell, Agent Stone, and Commander Walters....They all did amazing. This movie was phenomenal. Sonic 3 is #1 in America and Ireland right now. Let's go!! 🖤❤

  • @juliabonavita4731
    @juliabonavita4731 Місяць тому +7

    I would say Maria and shadows relationship in
    SA2, Shadow the Hedgehog, Dark Beginnings, Sonic X Shadow Generations is more sentimental. Obviously I am not saying their relationship in the movie was not sentimental I mean there was that scene with the Stars. But their relationship in other media you can tell is more sentimental.
    But what I like about the movie version is that it's more entertaining. I like that we get to see Maria be an actual kid and I like that we get to see what they do in their free time

  • @Naruto-kq7gh
    @Naruto-kq7gh Місяць тому +12

    8:29 I could be wrong but I think in the movie the reason shadow doesn’t like Walter’s is because he was somewhat responsible for Maria’s death in a way and also he was the one who put shadow away for 50 years.

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +3

      Yeah but how does he know that’s Walter’s tho…bro hasn’t seen him in 50 years…
      And also Walter’s seems to have not known what to do with Shadow. He acted out after Maria’s death and even though he knew shadow was still a child. It was still a complicated situation. He also seemed to be okay with Team Sonic, even keeping their picture and giving them the key. There’s something bought Walter’s that I would love to continue seeing. And his actor. His actor was nice to look at 🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @Naruto-kq7gh
      @Naruto-kq7gh Місяць тому

      Yeah the pic in his jacket was weird. Loved the video❤

    • @JohnWilliams-wl9px
      @JohnWilliams-wl9px Місяць тому +3

      @@Idkkprincess probably just recognizing certain facial features, and the fact he worked for GUN. Kind of like how in real life you can recognize a younger version of your grandparent by looking at their photos.
      If Sonic 3 wasn’t live action, then younger and present day Walter would likely have design not show they are the same person just different ages.
      But of course live action they are simply different actors

  • @ACinemafanatic
    @ACinemafanatic Місяць тому +21

    If shadow gets his own spin off movie I wanna see more of Maria and shadow and it would be interesting he encounters jojo who is Maddie’s niece that gave sonic his shoes

  • @gamerx759
    @gamerx759 Місяць тому +5

    They did a good job with the scene between Shadow and Maria.

  • @jakeystarsuper
    @jakeystarsuper 22 дні тому +1

    They portrayed Maria being goofy and mischievous child. Not as bad, but they were missing an important thing. Maria was also sick and was suffering from an illness and Rebbot. It was trying to cure a shame that they didn’t put that.

  • @ironprincedom2611
    @ironprincedom2611 Місяць тому +5

    It goes without 'needing' to say... I absolutely 💯 LOVED the characterisation of 'MARIA' within this adaption/version!
    But holy hell, what a twist of a spin... OVERALL > :j

  • @Pokemonka150
    @Pokemonka150 29 днів тому +1

    Oh my gosh!!! You spotted this "out of egg" reference. You are the first person talking about it. I immediately noticed it and geeked out 😂😂😂

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  29 днів тому +1

      I'm going to be honest with you...i don't remember what I was talking about...

    • @Pokemonka150
      @Pokemonka150 29 днів тому

      @@Idkkprincess, I meant that as Shadow is put into the lab tank, we see him open his eyes through the crack. I recognized the same moment in the announcement animation of The Year of Shadow-Fearless. It was him breaking from a "stone-egg". You are the first person talking about it. I thought I tagged the time (a few seconds after it 😅 Guess not - It was in the first 5 minutes or so.)

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  29 днів тому +1

      @ OHHH YEAH! I’m surprised no one else caught that

    • @Pokemonka150
      @Pokemonka150 29 днів тому

      @@Idkkprincess Me too :-D That's why I was so happy to hear you noticed to 😀

  • @fightingmedialounge519
    @fightingmedialounge519 Місяць тому +4

    8:23 his hatred is less about thinking he's the reason she's dead, so much as supporting the group that did kill her before and personally saw to him getting locked away.

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +4

      Yeah but Walter’s seem to want to defend them. And i don’t know if Shadow knew that. And how did Shadow know Walter’s looked like that…and Walter’s says that Shadow’s power was too much and blamed the incident on Gerald. He never talks about what actually happened. He never mentions Maria and Sonic and co. I understand they wanted to keep that part of the story under wraps until the reveal but he just says a cliff notes version of it that I wish they expanded a little bit more on

    • @fightingmedialounge519
      @fightingmedialounge519 Місяць тому +1

      @Idkkprincess true, but that's a hollow sentiment for someone who spent 50 years stuck re-living the same moment. As for how shadow knows it was him, Walters just staring him down as he's sealed without trying to apologize gives off the impression. Considering Gerald seemingly killed Walters, it's not much of a leap to assume he told shadow what he did and even showed footage. I think the idea is we're supposed to know something bad happened and just assume what Walters said is the truth. Only to get more and more information that brings that into doubt(Gerald wanting revenge, shadow constantly blaming GUN, then keeping Gerald alive for death weapons). Culminating in us learning the actual truth of the situation.

  • @imperfectmyst
    @imperfectmyst Місяць тому +4

    Like i know theres some people gonna be disappointed that she isnt sick or not shot but even the chances felt more impactful

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +5

      You gotta love that Robotnik charm 🤣🤣🤣

    • @imperfectmyst
      @imperfectmyst Місяць тому

      ​@@Idkkprincess yup

  • @phantomnio3918
    @phantomnio3918 Місяць тому +1

    Gotta say, I saw the thumbnail and I took that exact Shadow squishmellow to my first viewing of the movie 😂 that movie was so good!

  • @BigCheesyPro
    @BigCheesyPro Місяць тому +4

    I have all of the exact same opinions. I do think them not included her sickness or wish does remove a very important level of Shadow and Maria’s relationship and I’m so curious why they decided to remove those. I feel like we are definitely missing some deleted scenes and could have used more about Gerald in the past. I really love the stuff we got with their relationship, like the depiction really emphasizing that they are both kids. And I do like how they changed her death to make it PG friendly while keeping GUN’s involvement essentially the same. Their intention was to shoot. They were going to shoot. They did not care that they were kids. I really like how they used Walters in the past to intervene, but the end result ultimately be the same, without showing anything explicitly. But I do really wish we got a longer scene of that or her last words or something. But gosh their relationship is so sweet in the movie.

  • @novanova78_34
    @novanova78_34 23 дні тому

    I just noticed that Movie Maria is what Game Maria always wished to be

  • @AdrianGuerreroMontes
    @AdrianGuerreroMontes Місяць тому

    I just woke up because yesterday i watched the movie, and yeah i liked when Shadow remembers Maria for the first time. And i mean the montage up until they watched the stars. That part made me feel like theres some heart in the movie.

  • @theelk1453
    @theelk1453 Місяць тому

    My headcanon is that Shadow and Maria had multiple nights where they gazed at the stars, and at some point or another Maria told Shadow that she dreams of exploring the stars someday. And when Shadow ends up on the moon and flying through space, he’s carrying out her wish, in a way.

  • @MiguelHernandez-tj2tc
    @MiguelHernandez-tj2tc Місяць тому +3

    Movie maria robotnik looks so good and beautiful 😊 super sonic super shadow and the post credit scenes are awesome I'm very happy about the sonic characters and it's the best movie of the year marry christmas IDK princess 💙🎄⭐🌟🎁⛄❄🐎🦌🐻‍❄️🐧

  • @PikaLink91
    @PikaLink91 22 дні тому +1

    Alyla was the perfect choice for Maria, and unlike Sherry from Welcome to Raccoon City I am so f***ing glad they got her hair color right. Welcome to Raccoon City got A LOT of shit wrong so being an hour through the movie and seeing this supposedly blonde girl being played by a brunette was the straw that broke my sanity.
    When I saw the trailer thumbnail of Maria putting her hand on Shadow's tube in half darkness I was afraid for a moment that they would do that here as well, so I was glad to see that wasn't the case, false alarm.
    Again, Alyla is perfect for the role and she puts just the right amount of innocent charm, heart, and mischievousness into the character. Like when she sees Shadow react negatively to the Godzilla movie, and then steals an access card to go stargazing with Shadow because she could feel he needed that.

  • @thedarkhorse1990
    @thedarkhorse1990 Місяць тому +1

    If we get a Shadow spinoff show (which Keanu wants to do) im 100% sure we will see more Maria flashbacks.

  • @Ukaran
    @Ukaran Місяць тому +1

    The actress won't stop growing, so they will probably cast a new one.

  • @Pan-cackes
    @Pan-cackes Місяць тому +14

    Movie Maria is actually a real person and not only a subplot for Shadow

    • @jakeystarsuper
      @jakeystarsuper 22 дні тому

      I’m pretty sure there was media where they showed Maria as a person and not just a plot device. They portrayed her as a goofy mischievous child

  • @mrcwillis6970
    @mrcwillis6970 Місяць тому

    Both Shadow and Maria are amazing and are my favourite parts of the movie. Not just because they’re both some of my most favourite characters in the series, but just how lovely their friendship is shown and how much she cares for him. Feel like we could have had at least one more flash back in the movie. Even with the changes I feel they did, still great characters. I feel her love for the earth is shown by all the different things she carries with her, roller skates, music, movies. Plus they’re still making movies not to mention the possibility of a spin off series or movie that many many would want to go deeper into the character and backstory especially if they bring in Doom where shadow comes from (the meteor he comes from is literally like black arms) ❤️🖤

  • @shadamyandsonamylover
    @shadamyandsonamylover Місяць тому +2

    I love your deep dives. Maybe this is coming in your Maria video, but would you do an analysis of shadow/maria from the 50s vs them from the 70s?
    Ever since I saw the movie I just thought it was hilarious that he is now from the 70s. And I just want a comparison analysis between them.

  • @rickyronny4019
    @rickyronny4019 Місяць тому +1

    There’s something about the movies portrayal of Maria that I like more than the games (not to say the games are bad) but I can’t put my finger on it

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +2

      Ya’ll didn’t know she was fun. That’s pretty much it 🤣🤣🤣 but she’s a robotnik for a reason

    • @rickyronny4019
      @rickyronny4019 Місяць тому

      @ yeah I guess so

  • @valentinchappa6702
    @valentinchappa6702 Місяць тому +2

    Well in sa2 he didn't have amnesia, but Gerald manipulated his memories to so that shadow mostly remembered Maria's death. The official English translation did not portray this story beat AT ALL.

  • @171QA
    @171QA Місяць тому +1

    Great video.

  • @PZ14WolfGamer
    @PZ14WolfGamer Місяць тому +1

    Yeah I know they kinda changed the backstory of shadow and Maria in sonic 3. But it was a surprise. Shadow coming from a meteor

  • @nikkihedged
    @nikkihedged Місяць тому

    Despite the script removing Maria’s illness, I watched the whole movie and didn’t even notice. Seriously I didn’t realize until hours later that Maria no longer had her disability. 😅😂 I think the disease angle always felt really shallow to me anyway. Like a cheap way to garner sympathy from the audience in her brief appearances in the games. To me, the core of Maria’s character was her pure heart, and optimism about life. Since that was maintained in the film, I didn’t feel like anything was missing at all.

  • @Dailvin
    @Dailvin Місяць тому

    I like your Maria inspired outfit

  • @DanielGarrett9503
    @DanielGarrett9503 Місяць тому +7

    Shadow and Maria are totally meant for each other. ❤️🖤 I seen Sonic Movie 3 last Saturday, and I had a blast. The movie is a 95 for me.

  • @GreenTornadoX
    @GreenTornadoX Місяць тому

    Nice video!

  • @baltimore4life34akallswerv3
    @baltimore4life34akallswerv3 Місяць тому +4

    Movie Maria is in real life in the movie

  • @imperfectmyst
    @imperfectmyst Місяць тому +1

    My Critic with the Whole Maria thing is that they could've had 3 or 4 Perspectives One from Gerald one from Shadow Like Gerald has his Own Version POV On what Maria would "Want" as dose shadow and later have that scene with her Dying with Shadow and Maria and then Maria telling Shadow "Give them a chance for them to be happy" that way like it just shows you and that's it

  • @ArtyAxolotl
    @ArtyAxolotl Місяць тому

    One of my biggist complants about the movie was the fact they took away marias nids and im aware of the fact im very nitpicky with show/movie aductations of games but even tho in the origial stuff not every kid could be a maria those of us thhat were at least i apretated it the growing up with an invisable disablity the growing up in and out of the hospital the not being able to do as much as other kids the knowing you could die way too young was a huge reality for me and still is but maria was the first Character i could relate too cause when i was a kid there wasnt really anything with that kinda rep anf if ghere was it was people whp were wheelchair bound people with prostectics people with visable disablitys and i could never relate to them the way i could with maria maria was a first for me and one of the reasons im such a huge fan of sonic and why shadow and maria are my favente Characters because even tho i was introdused to sonic though sonic underground sa2 was what got me into it and why im a sonic fan to this day i feel like they kinda did shadows backstory and maria a little dirty ues i love and adore their freindship and that we see more of it but theres so much more they could have done to give the arc siblings justice and they didnt like i said im bery nitpicky and i have a lot of stuff i dont like about the movie (more of annoyises but still) along with the good do a like this movie better then the other 2 yes i may be baised with that tho is it a good movie do i like it yes is it peak like everyone is saying no idk if i just feel cheated out with shadow and marias story but i didnt absalutly love the movie it isnt one of my favretes not like too far but like i hope they do better with the show fingers crossed they add marias nids as at least a mention
    (Lile with the first movie i loved amd adored how they took the very niche and not very well known Character of longclaw and made her so much more the secend movie gave me a lot of qrestions about stuff they never answerd and i doupt they will thats a little annoying but what can ya do lol)

  • @BurningFlamesofDivineDragon
    @BurningFlamesofDivineDragon Місяць тому +1

    I went and saw Sonic Movie 3 today. I would give it an excellent rating. I'm glad to see Maria Robotnik wasn't just a plot device for Shadow. Sonic saw that Shadow had a sister that he had lost when he picked up the photo. The question I have is how did Sonic know Maria's name Shadow never once said her name to Sonic at any point maybe I missed something?

  • @LegionOf3
    @LegionOf3 Місяць тому

    I really wish they had done the entire Space Colony Ark thing… 😢

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +1

      I mean the ARK is there…the colony is not. 🤣🤣🤣 but they are still space sibs. They look at the stars. It’s funny how the save my earth thing is inspired by a romance anime yet that is the only thing that got removed…huh

  • @OkamiPrincess15
    @OkamiPrincess15 Місяць тому +1

    I dunno if I’m just huffing copium, but I’m hoping there’s still a chance that it’s revealed in the Shadow spin off that Maria has a different kind of invisible disability. I mean, Maria having an invisible disability that isn’t the result of a terminal illness can be a positive, since that way her being a victim isn’t partly BECAUSE of her disability.

  • @Meshawroo
    @Meshawroo Місяць тому

    they might explore more on Shadows meaning to be in future films ... there is a chance the Blk Arms are going to try to invade ... considering they are suppose to be biblical horrors they could show flash backs on Gerald's deal and why he was the first person to find Shadow ... even in the back story Walters gave it was sus ... and as biblical beings ... there is a chance a vision on Maria guarding Shadow may ask him to protect earth ... this is all speculation/hopes for future projects ... OOOOOH if they do the whole time mechanic of sonic CD there is also a chance to see Maria again ... and she would have to sacrifice to keep the timeline stable ...

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +3

      You know I don’t think they’re gonna go down the biblical horrors route…I think aliens are gonna be a stretch but I would put them around like OG Avengers kinda threat…personally Black Doom’s design in live action would give me the hibbie jibbies

  • @pokemaster374
    @pokemaster374 Місяць тому +2

    I wanted more interaction between Gerald and Maria to solidify why he cared so much for her to do what he did in the movie.
    Yes, that's his grandchild, but since the movie didn't give us a reason as to why she was at a military base like in the games, that part was definitely lost on me and when she eventually dies, I don't feel sad because her death is essential to move the plot not move my heart

  • @EngineerRailMan
    @EngineerRailMan Місяць тому

    The one thing I am disappointed about in the film is there isn’t an epic race battle between Sonic and Shadow. No I am not counting the one where Shadow was on his bike. Shadow has to be on foot while racing Sonic with some fighting.
    Btw IDK, have you seen the Project Shadow fan films?

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +2

      Yes, I have seen the project shadow fan film and people have been asking for me to review it. So I probably will…because it also tackles my personal hobby of vintage electronics…I actually have some of the stuff shown in the film ;p
      Also no chaos control from Shadow too….so I’m excited to see the future!

  • @Organoth-wi4mx
    @Organoth-wi4mx 29 днів тому

    Hi

  • @randomshadow888
    @randomshadow888 Місяць тому +1

    The movie is great, no doubt. Still, I am honestly disappointed about the story changes, especially the "ark" on the earth and Shadow coming from a meteorite....Did Jeff fowler forget that, or ignore that?

    • @Idkkprincess
      @Idkkprincess  Місяць тому +4

      I mean…we don’t actually know where Shadow came from in the games. Like we know Gerald created him but Shadow’s root (aka the Egg scene we get in the Japanese Fearless intro) is unknown…
      I was fine with the bunker and understood why that was changed. And I like that it didn’t change their relationship!

    • @randomshadow888
      @randomshadow888 Місяць тому

      @Idkkprincess Can you please send the link of that egg video, it sounds interesting

    • @Chri5o0o
      @Chri5o0o Місяць тому +2

      You do know that Jeff F doesn't make all the decisions. Yes, he's the director but it's overall a paramount film. They have more control than the director. I feel like Jeff does the best he can but cmon, this is Hollywood.

    • @GuyWithNoNickName
      @GuyWithNoNickName Місяць тому +4

      Shadow’s origin being “unknown” opens up the doors for more possibilities.
      Yes, he came from a Meteor, but where was the meteor from? Was he sent there on purpose? Was it an accident? All questions that could be answered by future projects.
      Just because it’s not exactly the same as the games doesn’t automatically make it bad.

    • @JohnWilliams-wl9px
      @JohnWilliams-wl9px Місяць тому +2

      @@GuyWithNoNickNamealso it’s a movie they don’t have enough time to include everything. When it was confirmed the next movie was going to feature Shadow, I called the Bio-Lizard wasn’t going used as nothing more than a cameo.

  • @MárioRubenMartins4
    @MárioRubenMartins4 Місяць тому +1

    I didnt like the movie or this Maria
    A brazilian fan made a better job at it then sega like i say americans ruining the world since the day they the country was made.

    • @AntolaRes
      @AntolaRes Місяць тому +9

      who are you 😭😭

    • @MárioRubenMartins4
      @MárioRubenMartins4 Місяць тому

      @@AntolaRes just a european guy who is tired of americans ruining stories, from japanese stories to european, either changing them and make them goofy like this silly movie did or putting blacks in european story which arte NO BLACKS IN EUROPEAN STORY but i am glad you americans loverd this....thing at least go watch it a gajilion times to surpass a billion then to see what mess sonic movie 4 will be.

    • @snowdude8583
      @snowdude8583 Місяць тому +2

      huh?

    • @MárioRubenMartins4
      @MárioRubenMartins4 Місяць тому

      @snowdude8583 @snowdude8583 huh? what? where? when? what planet am i on?