How effective are COVID vaccines?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 гру 2021
- How effective are COVID vaccines? In this video I look at a recently peer-reviewed study on COVID vaccines in all of New York State. The study looked at the COVID vaccine effectiveness against infection as well as the COVID vaccine effectiveness against hospitalization.
New England Journal study: www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056...
COVID Vaccine | Myocarditis Risk • COVID Vaccine | Myocar...
COVID Transmission | Do vaccinated transmit as much as unvaccinated? • COVID Transmission | D...
How to Optimize Your Immunity! Beat COVID and Other Health Conditions. • How to Optimize Your I...
Covid Treatments Your Doctor Can Prescribe! • COVID Treatments at Ho...
DISCLAIMER : Thank you for watching my UA-cam video. The content of my video is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. No doctor-patient relationship is formed by viewing this video. For further details, please click the following link below for my full disclaimer.
drive.google.com/file/d/1tQku...
Dr. Keith Moran MD, RCPSC, DABIM, RCS, NBE Biography:
I am a consultant in Internal Medicine with special medical interests in gastroenterology, cardiology, and echocardiography. I am a a full-time practising physician in these areas. I was an undergraduate at the University of Toronto, Trinity College where I received a number of scholarships including one for top student at Trinity College. I attended medical school at the University of Toronto graduating with a gold medal. My internship was completed at McMaster University in Hamilton followed by a residency in Internal Medicine at the University of Western Ontario in London. I then completed a fellowship in General Internal Medicine at the University of Western Ontario. I am an active echocardiographer who has been certified and recertified by the National Board of Echocardiography. I am certified in cardiac sonography and have trained and completely educated a number of cardiac sonographers. I am the medical director of my cardiology laboratory which was established in 2001. My laboratory performs echocardiography and stress echocardiography amongst other tests. I maintain my certification in the American Board of Internal Medicine. I have over 27 years of experience as a hospital-based consultant in internal medicine and intensive care unit attending physician.
#MedicinewithDrMoran
Here's some more of my videos!
Blood Clots after COVID Vaccine / New Information! ua-cam.com/video/It7VNzhAqOs/v-deo.html
How to Optimize Your Immunity! Beat COVID and Other Health Conditions. ua-cam.com/video/6EpUsC1elNU/v-deo.html
COVID Vaccine | Myocarditis Risk ua-cam.com/video/aJETb9EKaI8/v-deo.html
COVID Transmission | Do vaccinated transmit as much as unvaccinated? ua-cam.com/video/PU1JMwCmZR4/v-deo.html
Acid reflux - Heartburn - Prevent and treat gastroesophageal reflux! ua-cam.com/video/HOyOseWji0A/v-deo.html
COVID Masks | Do Masks Help? ua-cam.com/video/fFCYv0X4kf4/v-deo.html
How to Tell if You are Healthy ua-cam.com/video/klwwN6KDBDc/v-deo.html
Wonderful video. Might you please also do a video on UK Health Security Agencies latest study on vaccine effectiveness, please? It shows after 15 weeks there is "negative efficacy." I'd love for you to share your views on what this means.
I would like to know about natural infection. I had mine may of 21. As I'm watching vaccinated people around me all getting covid and I'm sitting in the same guard shack they've been in all day long and I don't get it. How long does natural immunity last
@@Mystorm2021 he spoke about that several times... you can click on his channel name then on videos ... you can also find the search box on the upper right of the menu next to Videos ...
TV advertisements for "get vaccinated" showed dozens of people being vaccinated. Not one case showed the needle being aspirated.
That's the wrong question. How dangerous is the virus to justify a vaccine? If the virus is not a threat than even water infected into one's body is 100% effective against the virus!..
I like to see a study of
hospitalisation of unhealthy non vaccinated as supposed to healthy non vaccinated that would be interesting.
I did my own study: Months ago at three different dates within a six month period I meet with three different individuals two of who were on quarantine from CoVid19. I hung out with two of them the entire day with no mask. The third person was not confirmed to have it, however she was confirmed to have CoVid19 after she left my house. I picked her up from the airport and she stayed at my house for about four hours. She was coughing and I could tell it was deep in her lungs. I still have yet to feel sick. I am a 55 year old male with no health issues and have O+ blood. I am 5’-6” tall and weigh 195 lbs. Not been vaccinated, but I will get the shot in about 10 years when the experiment is done. I wear a fake see through gator mask and travel quite a bit between Livingston, TX. and Houston, TX. I never was my hands unless the toilet paper tears 😳, no really I don’t even wash my hands before eating unless my hands are visible dirty.
@@ramohino hehehe. Well you are very lucky so far. 800,000 people were not so lucky.
@@dathyr1 800,000 fat people or have a comobility‘s that never took care of their bodies if you call that luck whatever✊🏿😎🤦♂️
@@dathyr1 taking into account the amount of morbidly obese and unhealthy lifestyle underline health issues, I'm surprised it's not even more. Let's talk about the proportion of healthy people dying from covid-19 compared to the unhealthy.
@@ramohino Understand. Thing is they dont give us all the stats of the 800,000 people that died. You continue to stay safe and happy holidays to you
Thank you Doctor but I am 70 years old and I am very healthy. I have not been sick in over 20 years. I simply don’t trust my government nor do I trust big pharmaceutical companies. My best friend is a great doctor who recommended not getting any jabs until the real truth and longer studies are competed
I agree with your doctor friend. Too much unknown.
I was compelled to get jabs . No jabs no work no survival. I still survive … and fight. Stronger now .
In Quebec, over 18 months in a population of 8.5 million people (all ages), without comorbidities over 70 only 130 people died. In the same age group, with comorbidities, 9850. If you're in good health, your risks are very low.
I'm 73 and been sick but didn't die. I like you don't trust the medical system. I haven't been to a doctor since I was 13. That 60 years ago.
@@ritab-c492 I personally know 5 people, 3 of them under 22 years old who died within 24 hours of being vaccinated. These were healthy people, all of them. I personally know 2 people who died from Covid , one was already suffering from cancer and in her 80's, the other a 50 year old woman who was healthy until the hospital gave her the wrong drugs, they killed her.
Good to see that the unvaccinated aren't posing any risk to the vaccinated as it regards hospitalization.
If your vaccine prevents hospitalization at such a high rate, it should be irrelevant to you that any one refuse the vaccine.
From the study there were still some vaccinated people who ended up in hospital. I assume you're okay with them taking precedence over the unvaccinated ones if they have to make a choice over who gets a bed from catching covid? Then there's all the patients with non-covid conditions who might need healthcare. Be a shame if they couldn't get a bed because they were all taken up by people who refused a vaccine for that could have prevented them ending up there. Then there's all the doctors and nurses putting themselves at risk while working non-stop to deal with all the patients, vaccinated or not. Maybe the vaccinated just care more about all the people around them 🤔
@@dorkangel1076 I assume you're okay then if in the future it comes out there are long term negative effects, with the vaxed being denied medical care in preference of the unvaxed because the vaxed made a choice that harmed them? If not then sit down.
@@dorkangel1076 by your logic; overweight people (one of the biggest factors in those with severe Covid, heart disease, among others) should be blamed for their condition or denied care. Nice
he does not say that and it is not logical either. You seem blind to the fact that the virus is infectious. The 2378 individuals in this study who were vaccinated and hospitalised would particularly not agree with you, since with the greater prevalence of illness among the unvaccinated they quite likely caught it from one of them. I don't like the way you say 'your vaccine' either. Wake up: this is not a time to indulge in us vs them. This is time to behave, for everyone.
@@dorkangel1076 are you ok with smokers and obese people let the non smokers and lean people taking precedence in medical care? What about drug addicts and drunks? People don’t practice safe sex?
Hi Dr Moran, while I appreciate the fact that this study was intended to investigate the efficacy of vaccination for preventing serious illness and death that was not the foundation claim for the roll-out of these vaccines, that was that mass vaccination would eliminate the disease from the population, not only has this not happened there is no clear evidence that any reduction in spread and infections has been effected at all!.
I am also very concerned that this study was using PCR testing as a basis for identifying illness when the best they can do is identify exposure to some virus. Further confusion is likely if the presence of neutralising antibodies is the basis for identifying immunity.
Unless these issues are clearly addressed and evaluated then no sensible conclusions can be inferred from this study!.
Cheers, Richard.
creative caculating conclusively proves they work... real world countries 90+% v axed.. covid still killin somebody?? it does not add up.. japan?? they have almost none??
@@daveriddlelin9327 Japan - high vitamin D from all those fish they eat. Also, they tend not to be obese. Also they started seriously using IVM with their last wave, which then crashed.
@@davewalter1216 fishies... good point... I started to eat more lately anyway ... now I will be even more enthusiastic! Thanks.
The doctor is a shill. He's just pushing buyer confidence for those who made the mistake of getting vaccinated.
@@roundpeg3239 I bet you have impecable credentials, which makes you a troll.
The reason you don't hear more cases in the vaccinated group because covid testing is only voluntary for them unlike the unvaccinated group they need to be tested weekly when working with their employer and going to places that requires negative test. It is only logical to say that you will hear more cases in the unvaccinated group because they are frequently being tested . Unfortunately, data reporting is no longer accurate.
Now, can you explain the difference in hospitalizations between the unvaccinated and vaccinated for me? I'd love to hear your theory on how this relates to the effectiveness of the vaccines.
@@ShlonBetts It seems that you are assuming that I disagree the use of vaccines. Vaccines does give you temporary protection but doesn't give you immunity. Of course, hospitalization on unvaccinated without previous infection will be higher because this is a novel virus. The research study should be compared between the vaccinated vs natural immunity. That will be a game changer. I work in the hospital and I haven't heard natural immunity being hospitalized, unlike vaccinated group you see them often.
@@stephenguy3901However, the note will not tell you if the unvaccinated has natural immunity or had previously infected. You either have to ask the person history or read their past medical history. Trust me, most of the unvaccinated who gets hospitalized had only initial infection. I work with a lot of Covid patients. I felt bad for this patients because most of them didn't get any sort of Early Treatments for Covid, their conditions were already critical when they come in.
@@stephenguy3901 You missed the point. What I stated was I'm not seeing cases for natural immunity being hospitalized compared with fully vaccinated and unvaccinated with no previous infection. I'm not trying to confuse you.
@@stephenguy3901Just so you know, I've been doing lots of research in my own hospital. So far, I haven't seen or heard a person with previous infection being readmitted in my hospital. This is very amazing. I know for sure that Natural immunity is very strong and long lasting. In addition, I don't think we will ever find out publicly here in the US that natural immunity is superior than the Covid vaccines. Our government, CDC, and NIH are not interested and against this topic because there's hardly any profiteering on Natural Immunity. Also, please understand that I totally believe the video that being presented here that the unvaccinated without previous infection will have more hospitalization than the vaccinated group because Covid vaccine is already giving us some protection, sadly it will not give us a "real" Immunity. Unfortunately, fully vaccinated individual will still have many breakthrough infections and they will still get hospitalized. The real question we needed to ask ourselves, is our current Covid vaccines, a real "vaccines" or is this just some sort of "treatments" that we need to take it over and over again? Just a thought.
I don't trust anything anymore.
53 got covid, no symptoms or very little so why the big push for this for those who don't need it
Not sure about New York State, but Ohio numbers have been skewed.
1. Vaccinated patients have been documented as “Vaccine Status: Unknown”.
2. Positive test results are recorded as “Covid Hospitalization”, even if no symptoms were present. (E.g., admitted after a car accident, but tests positive.)
I appreciate your detailed reviews of the data available, unfortunately, the data available is not a true picture of reality.
Assuming that's true; that doesn't explain the high hospitalisation and mortality rates in the unvaccinated in each and every study.
@@willguggn2, What I typed above is not assumed.
What is assumed is how those with "Vaccine Status: Unknown" are counted. I was told they are counted as "Unvaccinated", but I have not confirmed.
The fact that fully vaccinated individuals are being counted as "unknown", is at minimum, lowering the counts of fully vaccinated individuals who are covid positive, hospitalized, in the ICU, or have died... and as assumed, are increasing these numbers in the unvaccinated category.
The numbers here in my part of Canada are different. Three quarters of our cases are fully vaxed, the number of vaxed in hospital is creeping up while the number of unvaxed is unchanged. 🤷
Canada is better vaccinated than the US. And how is your area compared to New York? Don't look only at the percentage. If you had full coverage, hospitalizations would account for 100% vaccinated. So "vaccines don't work" they say. Except they have 100 patients hospitalized with 10 in the ICU with 100% coverage, instead of 1000 patients hospitalized with 100 in the ICU with 80% coverage. Imagine what it would be like without vaccination - hint; India. And yeah, those are made up numbers to illustrate a point. Creeping may be due to waning over time for 2 dose regime, and/or the percentage of old and fragile. Here the ratio is 1:10 for vaccinated in hospital, but we kicked off later (than the US) with long period between doses that may have benefited us.
source of information? I call bullshit on your comment.
Mathematically speaking, if a province or country has 10 million people and 90% are fully vaccinated and a 10% isn't, it means 9 mil vs 1 mil.
With complete made up and theoritical numbers: if 0.5% of fully vaccinated people end up to the hospital and 4% of the non-vaccinated ends up to the hospital, we'll end up with figures like that: 45k vaccinated in hospital vs 40k unvaccinated in hospital.
9 000 000 x 0.005 = 45000
1 000 000 x 0.04 = 40000
Ratio = 52% of the vaccinated people are at the hospital vs 48% non-vaccinated people at the hospital.
Non-vaccinated are still a disproportionate demographic.
@@AlerianeDespins Yeah it's not like well vaccinated country had a delta surge similar to India. They would have without the vaccine.
Still, trying to explain this to the Covidiots is futile. The response will be "I don't do math, vaccines don't work and that's a fact" 🤢
Untrue. The unvaccinated are only 15% of population and account for well over 50% of hospitalizations and even higher for deaths.
Thank you again for a great video doctor, but it would be very interesting to see how many of the unvaccinated who ended up in hospital and in intensive care, were previously infected, as I suspect natural immunity has saved millions of unvaccinated from hospitalisation, but these two groups are never separated unfortunately and those with natural immunity are "lumped in" with those with no previous infection.
How on Earth a car accident can save people from the same car accident?
Similarly, how on Earth a natural infection aka an infection without prior immunity can save a person from the virus which causes the same disease from the same infection?
@@hn5460 I think you are missing the point, what I'm saying is:
are the unvaccinated people who end up in hospital the people who have never had prior infection? Because if that's the case, it means that natural immunity from prior infection does prevent hospitalisations in unvaccinated and therefore I think we need to separate "unvaccinated and naturally immune" from "unvaccinated and no natural immunity".
To use your analogy, it would be the difference between the injuries between somebody wearing a seatbelt and somebody not wearing a seatbelt in a car accident.
@@hn5460 if you want to push such analogies it is more like you learn to ride the bicycle (exposed to the virus and save the pattern of how to do it in your muscle memory) then even if you do not do it for a Year, and you have to use a bicycle Again, you can Relearn it faster ...
If you crash with your bicycle or your car and you need to be fixed in a Hospital, all bets are OFF what happens if you get exposed again to similar traffic accident.
@@CyberSlammer2024 I do not think he knows much about how the immune system works... antibodies ... memory. Ellwood and such ... how can he believe in mRNA or Adenovirus vaccines then which are just as mysterious?
They convinced many to get vaccinated to get impressive vaccine efficiency stats fast.
Unfortunately, the thing about data.....it can be manipulated to prove anything.
Wish we could get a study with the same sample size for individuals who’ve acquired natural antibodies from previous infection.
Search for Qatari study, they've looked at 260k people who recovered and didn't take any vaccine, on the period they studied (approx a year if I'm correct), 1300 got tested positive a second time, 4 needed hospital stay, none went to ICU or died.
O right, cos Joe Boden said 'the only protection was to get your shots and boosters.' could he be spreading...... misinformation?
They literally have a bunch of those.
That sounds like a different study
i object to your use of the term vaccine
Same
You mean we don't get tetanus or hepatitis shots every 4 months?
My siblings and their families all had COVID-19, all were unvaxxed, and all were fine. That's the overwhelming case in general for the vaxxed and unvaxxed alike.
You give great presentation. Thanks.
Can you give a presentation that explains any science of why BOTH Japan (high vaccination rate) and India (low vaccination rate) have nearly NO new case and deaths?
Is this related to the use of early treatment with Ivermectin (Japan approved usage for Covid-19 in mid August 2021)?
I bet it has a lot to do with low BMI’s in those countries. Being overweight is the biggest risk factor and people in China and Japan are trimmer. There’s other variables too, but I’d bet money that’s the biggest one.
@@timmyj2366 high BMI and diabetes are quite common in India due to their genetics, diet and lifestyles.
@@akirahojo2 Just for some reference, Japan and India are among the world’s ten countries with the lowest rates of obesity. As I said, being overweight is the biggest risk factor for covid as it significantly inhibits the ability of the immune system to fight off disease.
While India is middle of the road when it comes to diabetes prevalence when compared to other countries, Japan is amongst the lowest in the world.
Ivermectin isn't being widely used in Japan. I live in Japan and spoke to my doctor about this. Generally speaking, sugar is not a significant part of the Japanese diet. Less diabetes as others day but less inflammation in the body too. Suggesting less impact of the virus perhaps?
Less hysterical testing
Thanks for the clearcut review of these studies... it's sorely missing from the "official" channels
No focus on natural immunity with any of these studies... Unvaccinated but with natural immunity - that's not the same thing as unvaccinated without natural immunity.
This data is up to August for hospitalization and up to September for infection. Delta just started rising in July and became dominant after most of this data was collected. The effectiveness of the vaccines is known to have waned significantly after 6 months.
Please make an in depth video discussing the enormous number of VAERS reports and the failure of the CDC to investigate their own post trial surveillance system to catch serious safety signals.
Thank you for your informative videos.
Does the government make that kind of information available? Can one get reports on what kind of side effects there have been and how many? I agree it needs to be done.
@Jim From VAERS:
VAERS Limitations
VAERS reports alone generally cannot be used to determine if a vaccine caused or contributed to an adverse event or illness. Some reports may contain information that is incomplete, inaccurate, coincidental, or unverifiable. VAERS reports often lack contextual information, such as total vaccinations given or information on unvaccinated groups for comparison. Most reports to VAERS are voluntary, which means they may be subject to biases. Data from VAERS reports should always be interpreted with these limitations in mind.
You should compare countries with vaccination rate below 5% and countries with more then 50% vaccination rate, most of you would be shocked at the result.
I already know the outcome, whats astonishing is the amount of people that actually believe all these numbers and twisted science. It seems like the less you worry about this that better off you are weird huh?
@@unanimousreporting8250 , very true! From mid of this year I have compiled all the data from different countries and came to a conclusion. Since then I have been living a normal life. And I am a true science person.
Thank you Dr. Moran! I always learn something from your videos... you always seem to address the EXACT question that's front and centre in my mind.
I wonder what the data would look like if they separated the participants into 4 groups, like what the Cleveland Clinic study did, where it's not just vaccinated and unvaccinated, but where being exposed to the virus in the past was also taken into account. With natural immunity being such a massive factor for affecting infection and hospitalisation, omitting it seems like a huge oversight.
That would be GOOD science but they're to busy pushing SCIENCE FICTION !
@@blanchecarte782 Yeah. For every one well-made study, there are several sloppy ones which start at the assumption and try to cherry-pick data to fit that assumption.
@@cbot3400 Yeah. Ranges are all different.
@@cbot3400 Yeah, good point. There are vast differences in disease presentation and mortality rate in 18 and 49 year olds.
Until we accept that this is a plandemic, any of these studies will make no sense. Once we realize that this was planned from the beginning, then all these fraudulent studies will make sense.
Hmm, I have some doubt about this study, this is what I'm thinking of.
The graphs showing vaccine efficacy against infection show a more significant drop for the 18-49 age group than the other higher age groups. I think that requires some explaining.
Very few horizontal axis show numbers and units of measurement, which I fund jarring, because I teach 14 year olds to put these in their science reports, and they all do it. Is this data missing from the study, or is this an unfortunate case of video editing?
The graphs for infection (4:35) and hospitalisation (6:28) at ages 65 and greater are the same! Who's trying to pull a fast one here!
There are more factors to take into account. Summer tends to slow the virus down. I wonder what a future study with cohorts june-juli, september-october and december-january would end up like.
Thanks for this video Dr. Moran, it's very timely. I was feeling pressured to get a booster by our provincial government but it's more nuanced than what they're pushing in the media. Based on your information from this video it's up to people to decide what fits with their circumstances and the cost benefit.
Thanks for the commentary Dr. M!
Always appreciated!🙏💖🙏
Thank You once again Dr. Moran! A Blessed and Merry Christmas to You, Your Family, and the Cats... =)
Mery Christmas to you and your family too!!
Uh huh. Thanks. Now where are the cats???
Never ever seen a product so ineffective put on a pedalstol.
What will be the effect on immune systems getting a new vaccine every 6 months for years?
Cancer
Our immune systems respond to colds and other infections all the time. It's what they are supposed to do. The immune system reacts to a vaccine in the same way as it does as an infection. Clearly we don't want this going on for years, but the vaccines have only been out for 1 year so it's a bit early to say what the future might hold.
Aids.
@@mexcanfun4498 wow lie more
Nobody knows. Scary uncharted waters.
My uncle got covid in the hospital recently. He was vaccinated last spring (scheduled for the booster but got Covid prior). The hospital gave him monoclonal shots. He recovered quickly (he is high risk category - elderly). are the vaccines taking credit for improved treatments? is this being studied?
Thanks again I for your helpful videos. I really get a lot out of them.
For the vast majority of people natural exposure is the best risk/reward. Natural immunity blows vaccine induced immunity away.
This has always been true for millions of years until now with covid science doesn't exist with it for some reason
I'd like to see the all cause mortality in both groups as well, making sure we account for comorbidities to not skew data in disfavor of vaccine, since vulnerable people got injected first and constitute a greater % of vaccinated group.
Thank you again for keeping us informed. I watch all your content but don't remember you talking about the intervals between doses. It makes sense when you said 6 to 12 weeks. Which video was that exactly?
I covered it about 10 months ago in a video, Went to get your second shot, but I’ve said it on numerous videos including this one more recently with supportive data. ua-cam.com/video/nLEPhi_PilE/v-deo.html
@@MedicinewithDrMoran Thank you very much for taking the time out to write that and providing the link. 10 months ago I was not in the market for nor interested in this new drug. Now looking at a second dose, your comment struck home. In my defense, I may have been subconsciously influenced by your other videos saying it. Thank you again for your service.
I love the simplicity of your information and presentation. Thanks again!
My pleasure!
Good Advent Merry Christmas🎄🕊
Thank you Doctor missing your cute cats
@@elijahfluw4347 - 2nd agreement… I really miss the Maine Coon over his shoulder.
Thank you Shanthi! I miss them too! My family went on their first trip in a long time and took our kitties. I'll be with them again soon. We did put a little bit of video of them at the end of my heart risk after vaccination video. ua-cam.com/video/j92lDiWYAPY/v-deo.html
Thanks Doc, but did the study take into account the seeming seasonal variation of infection?
Excellent, easy to understand presentation of the paper.
Thank you Dr Moran. I appreciate your work.
What is your opinion about « non specific effects of vaccines « - the danish study and comfererence . I am very concerned about children .
Always interesting to see that if you compared the numbers against the summer of 2020,,the lines are the same.
Thank you for this excellent information and for explaining it.
Preliminary data suggests that there is vaccine efficacy and reduction in hospitalization among the vaccinated. However this study does not quantify any co-morbidities among the 2 groups And we don’t have lucid data as it relates to short and long term side effects of vaccines and efficacy of natural immunity vs vaccine immunity.
Great work Dr. Moran. Thank you
I'd like to see a study and numbers on side effects.What kind of,how many,how severe.This is the problem,no one's addressing these ?'s.
I'd say not at all. 99.98% survival rate for the vast majority of people would say that people own immune system is quite effective against it.
@@stephenguy3901 and you are not accounting for the hundreds of thousands who got it and never needed any hospitol visit and never got tested
@@stephenguy3901 yeah but influenza disappeared, so those beds that use to have influenza patients in them now have covid patients in them. Go check the yearly death statistics out. Less died in 2020 than did 2019
@@stephenguy3901 ok so I can't respond with factual statements which don't get censored by this Marxist viewing platform
@@stephenguy3901 sorry. I'm sure someone who can find those statistics can find the world's yearly death rates
@@stephenguy3901 I'll leave you with this seeing as you like cherry picking statistics to suit your narrative. 2017 Australia, in 12 months alone over 1200 influenza deaths. Let's compare that to Australia, 16 months into the coronavirus plandemic and we only just hit 1000 deaths.
Can you define hospitalization does it mean on ventilator or just check in? Also what are the commodities on the unvaccinated?
In Quebec, officially anybody who gets a positive test in hospital is counted as a covid hospitalization, so if you've got a fracture unvaccinated they give you a test... when they likely won't give you a test. If course this skews numbers towards "unvaccinated" being hospitalized at greater rates.
Thank you Doctor 😊
ua-cam.com/users/shortsKGHLSsutKGk?feature=share
Why has no-one looked at the efficacy of competent early treatment in reducing hospitalizations?
Thanks for the info . . . 👍
Dr. Moran, what is the efficacy of getting vaccinated with a vaccine that has been temperature compromised?
Sadly, health is now a political issue!
Very informative presentation. Thanks.
Could you please do a video focusing on long covid? Thanks.
Thanks you dr. Moran. It would be interesting to take i to account what number of vaccinated are asked to go home with medication instead of being hospitalized like the unvacinated
Incidentally, "effectiveness" is a loaded word. If it's based on relative risk reduction, numbers can look great (e.g., 90%). If based on absolute effectiveness, the high numbers can be much lower (e.g., 1%).
True. Absolute effectiveness doesn't generate clicks, fear, and sales.
5 in 1000 get sick without some drug (0.5%) while 99.5% remain healthy.
1 in 1000 get sick with some drug (0.1%) while 99.9% remain healthy.
Of course the marketer/promoter says their product is 80% effective! Rather than report a 0.4% absolute difference.
@@tar170 Exactly. Thanks for the elaboration.
Dr. Moran what are your thoughts on an anti-viral nasal spray that could both prevent illness in the user and prevent virus spread to others? Could this be safer than and take the place of the invasive mRNA vaccine?
I've been using a neti pot every day and a nose spray with grapefruit seed extract and xylitol day and night
ua-cam.com/users/shortsKGHLSsutKGk?feature=share
@@honestnourishment6203 I've been using nothing daily.
"As always there's a link to the study in the description below"
Is there?
Thank you very much!
Well done. A vaccine "advocate" that talks straight, simple, and seems to present facts in a detailed manner.
Britain, National Health Services: For every 10 people who have died with Covid-19 since August, 9 of them have been "Fully Vaccinated"... What do you think?
@@stephenguy3901 them..the vaccine does not immunize... why do i do it, the jab?
@@stephenguy3901 I don`t get vaccinated because it is unnecessary, it says Luc Montagnier, Nobel 2008
Interesting. I'm convinced 8 weeks is the best. Greetings from Australia, Perth..... ///
Your videos are great!,,,But what did you do with the cat?
the cats are on vacation
@@ithacacomments4811 I heard they were taking a "cat-nap".
My bad! I missed the video that stated "cats on vacation". I will pay better attention in the future.
Was this an independent outside source doing the tes with nothing to gain or lose depending on outcome?
These charts are very misleading. Please show how efficacy fades with time since vcc and variant. The studies I've seen show protection against infection and serious illness fades rapidly after 4-7 months. Most other studies show much lower efficacy e.g. US veterans study. UK data shows age 35 to 60 AZ efficacy starts at 55% and slowly declines.
Having 3 to 8 weeks to wait for vaxed do the nonvax time start at the same time?
Got my second Moderna shot a few weeks ago and that night when I went to sleep I woke up after about 4 hours feeling extreme fatigue with severe chills. I had to put on a flannel shirt and turn up my heat. I also had insomnia and only got about one more hour of sleep. The following morning the extreme fatigue persisted and slowly started to improve by the evening but it took until Tuesday to start feeling normal again. This wasn't necessarily an adverse reaction but the symptoms the CDC cautions you may get were quite extreme.
@Jasonv van Heerden Probably a minor case. The extreme fatigue and muscle weakness and pains were the worst of it.
Thanks Dr. M.
Now I see why J&J got a recent black eye from the government. They missed their sales quotas. 🙄
Appreciate your neutral research and reporting. 👍
A study on treating patients too be helpful
Were tests done using the faulty PCR tests?
Which Vseen is the least risky to the injected?
For the infection numbers? Were these adjusted for by the number of tests done? Because if ney york city had a "health" pass like many countries in europe then there would be a massive difference in the number of tests between unvaccinated and vaccinated. Even if there was no pass other reasons could also lead to less testing among the vaccinated.
We already have tests able to detect asymptomatic infections, and it's reasonable to expect tests to get better over time. When they say vaccines are X% effective against 'infection', are they referring to *detectable* infections or *symptomatic* infections?
The whole issue has been so obfuscated as to be meaningless. Far too many unscrupulous people with too much money and ideology involved. I would like true figures on vaccine damage. In the mean time, in 2 yrs I have yet to know anyone that has had the virus or been damaged by it. Many eminent doctors and scientists have endangered their own future to warn against these vaccines and that is what I base my judgement on.
I'm curious as to how this stacks up to previously infected people
Unless I missed it,how can this study be of any value.?.what was the distribution of naturally immune from previous infection in each group.? Was natural immunity not even considered in the various vaccine recipients?Since some previously infected patients may be unaware of previous infection and no one checked prior to immunization how can we conclude anything from this comparison? Sounds like the authors desperately needed to publish something so they through this fatuous paper together to meet the deadline.
Also you're not fully vaccinated a week after any shot. So they decide who's vaccinated. The unvaxed people are vaccinated just fully vaxed. Most people develop symptoms after first jab considered unvaxcinated.
Make sense but they are targeting everybody with boosters, using Omni as the reason.
Is it possible doctor, for several mutations to appear about the same time, l just wouldn't want to become a pin cushion.
Thanks doctor
Thanks for all your hard work. It is very much appreciated. I read the study and supplemental material and learned two things of interest. First, the unvaccinated population was estimated and not actual. Second, the following quote from the supplemental material leaves me confused.
"About half of hospitalized patients in HERDS were reported admitted “for COVID-19”, using nonstandardized definitions."
In each of the two things I mentioned I do not understand how the study was able to accurately assess the unvaccinated results.
I was also unable to find who funded the study although in the disclosure statements they all said they had no affiliations to disclose. In today's politically charged environment I do not trust everything I read. This is perhaps a result of a long life and a lot of reading. Anyway, thanks again for bringing us the current information on this important topic.
If the unvaccinated who landed up in hospital were allowed early intervention treatment with drugs which I cant mention... recommended by qualified doctors I can't mention then about 70%of them would not end up in hospitals
Sent home until they are on deaths doorstep because they need to "save hospital beds and care for the responsible vaccinated citizens ". Traige in our new reality.
2 shots, then 3, now they’re talking 4 and probably 1-2 every year. 🤨
Very interesting video. I am interested to also know whether there have been any surveys done on vaccine damage. This is a topic of particular interest to me.
I have a peer reviewed study from Israel on the side effects from the Covid vaccines in the first six weeks on the channel.
Would be interesting to see. I had a very severe headache after my second dose and could hardly leave my bed from 24h-48 hours after the shot. A more serious problem seem to be that the difficulities I experienced breathing while exercising came back. I had a fairly mild version of covid in the summer of 2020. But the issues of breathing affected my competitive level of running for a long time after the infection. I had just started to feel better in this regard by the time of my second dose in Sepember 2021 by which time the issues breathing came back. I kind of feel the same way running since the infection and the vacination as you do while diving. I know several other competitive runners how say they experience problems after the Pfizer vacinnation as well. Fingers crossed it does feel a bit better now. But I have yet to compete in a serious race so I dont know if I have recovered my competitive edge yet. I have had at least ten other vacination due to traveling and some had had a small affect after the shot, but no one has caused as much problems as the Pfizer.
@@robertalexanderson829 I'm sorry to read that mate and I hope that you recover completely very soon. I too know quite a few people who have experienced "unwanted" side affects and some have been quite severe. I also know of two people from my town who have passed away after getting it. I don't know anyone who's had covid though. As far as what the consensus is, I think I've never been more confused in my life. The way this has all been handled, particularly by the media is so disgusting I don't think many people will ever trust them again. I just don't know what to believe any more so am just going with my gut and common sense atm.
Thanks Dr Moran but this paper seems very complicated and your discussion left me with more questions than understanding. I suppose I should read the paper, but I was struck by how much overlap in confidence interval there was both within and between vaccines - was there really any difference, even J&J seemed only marginally different? Also, given your very good point on timing between injections - how much did this vary in the US (In Australia my AZ shots were 12 weeks apart, but they are giving Pfizer at 3 weeks). Also, what exactly is 'vaccine effectiveness'? Is this some relative effectiveness measure that magnifies actual protection? I understand that relative is easier to use in comparisons, but absolute differences would be nice to know. Also, one would think that the vaccinated group grew continuously over the study, so the total differences between vaccinated and unvaccinated are not very meaningful overall. What one wants to know is the current numbers: is it an epidemic of the vaccinated now?
Try Dr. Campbell.
It's important to remember that with the lack of testing during the first wave, there might be hybrid immunity that doesn't get captured in studies like this. It would be helpful if you broke down for us what parameters they use in these studies to classify "fully vaccinated" vs "unvaccinated". Calling those who aren't two weeks out after 2nd vaccine, "unvaccinated", is already a fallacy (or intentional misleading) in stats and reporting. It causes those cases to be lumped into "unvaccinated" stats, skewing them. Especially when some information has shown there to be a peak in covid cases in that 2 week window, it's pretty unconscionable imo.
If they way they do stats in New York is like they do in Canada, I wouldn't pay much attention to these numbers. Especially since the number of deaths is greater in other studies for the fully vaccinated vs, the single dose population. Speaking of deaths, which is a more rigorous and checkable parameter, how come they are not listed? Fishy.
Thanks Dr Moran for the valuable information you presented in this video.
Possibly one of the causes of the significant increase in the number of COVID-19 cases may be relying on the false negative results of the rapid antigen screening and the victims believe they are not infected while the fact is the opposite. Some published research articles confirmed the prevalence of false negative results was high indicating these tests are not accurate, not sensitive and therefore not reliable.
What do you think based on published research articles as I believe in evidence based data?
What do you think about people in Israel getting a forth vaccine
Good Job Doc.
Thank you. 🇨🇦
What about natural immunity, especially versus artificial immunity from a vaccine? No one ever talks about natural immunity.
Steven, I have a natural immunity playlist on the channel with a number of videos on it. It is something that people have not been talking about. I just released a video a few minutes ago with a good comparison.
@@MedicinewithDrMoran Thank you, Doctor Moran. You seem to be the most impartial, fact-based source on You Tube about this pandemic. I think people are hungry for facts, not spin or politics. Thanks again. I will check your videos.
Dr. Moran makes a good point that we do not know the side effects of the vaccine are unknown, especially if we need multiple booster shots over a long period of time. Also, what are the risks factors if you are overweight but young, or over 65 but no other issues?
The accepted prevailing opinion is that IF such side effects happen, they are a worth while sacrifice to minimize the direct deaths from the virus. Agree or disagree, that's where policy makers are pointed.
@@kumbawolf Just because the policy makers are pointed that way doesn't make the right. The problem with IF side effects happen is that we don't know because the vaccine has not been around long enough. If you vaccinate my in laws who are in their 90s then it is worth the risk. My 9 year old granddaughter who would need boosters for the rest of her life when at her age the risk is almost non existent, then the vaccine is not a good idea. there is a lot of peer reviewed research which is valid and not seeing the light of day, that questions the policy of vaccinating everyone.Targeted vaccination is the way to go.
Also, there are treatments that no one is using Think Trump who is high risk due to his age and weight and yet he kicked it in a week. Many doctors in places like California are being threatened with loss of license if the treat covid patients with something other that quarantine and then hospitalization. By the time you get to the hospital it is too late
@@JJ-he7yy sealing the documents for 50 to 70 years by the fda is a big red flag that they know something...
Short question: can anyone explain discrepancy with the number of people dying each week in Scotland in last several months (where per one person without procedure dies 7-8 with the procedure) and YET the mort. rates there tell the opposite story? Are they just the mistakes/typos in their tables or tricks in the mort.rates calculation ?
This very informative…and hard to sit through. It’s like taking that professor’s class in college who everyone avoids. However, he did an excellent job at breaking this down for regular people.
How do you know if someone were to get severe disease/death or not if they dont vaccinated? How do they measure it?? Please help me understand this
So, how were the covid positive non vaccinated treated? Were they told, as I was, to go home and rest, but come back to the hospital if I can't breathe? Who was given early onset treatment such as ivermectin?
why don't any of the graphs include a control group?
This study seems invalid. At 1:40 you state that the study is between fully vaccinated and not Fully vaccinated, then directly following that refer to them as the UNvaccinated group? They’re not the same thing