The judge was right on with his decision. Maxie needs mandatory counseling I feel in order to get visitation. She made some terrible mistakes which cost Lulu, Dante, and Spinelli pain. This also affected their extended families. Great acting.
I see no fault in the judges ruling. Maxie needed to grow up and Lulu and Dante needed to be knocked down a peg or two. I was so happy for Spinelli. He finally was rewarded for being the innocent one in all this. Maxie and Lulu competition between each other was so toxic to Spinelli using him as a pawn to get back at each other.
If she had lied, then it sounds like the judge made the right decision. Just because you are the biological mother, that doesn't mean you should remain custody of your child - especially if you do not have the necessary ethical background/backbone to raise the kid. Nobody in society would agree that it's right to raise a heathen. And that's EXACTLY what you're doing if you lie and you're willing to lie - even if it may be for good intentions. People think that lying - even with good intentions - will be given exceptions. WRONG!!! The objective is to not lie at all.
This was the smartest decision that judge could have made while I feel bad for Dante and Lulu after falling in love with the baby, Spinelli shouldn't of had to part with his little girl because Maxie's a horrible liar and Maxie needed a parental time out, her decision making at this point was disgustingly self interested and reckless.
Ok. That judge didn't deny custody because Lulu and Dante weren't Georgie's biological parents (and yes, I know during the battle the baby's name was Connie, but Spinelli changed it in honor of Maxie's sister). Biology doesn't always win in custody cases. You could be a biological parent, but a piece of shit at the same time. My friend had a sister who lost BOTH custody and visitation of/with her daughter, and she was the biological mother. The only reason Dante and Lulu lost custody, was because Lulu was more concerned with hurting Maxie, then actually proving she and Dante would be better parents. That's just how I see it.
Honestly, the biology played a part in this. That's why Spinelli go custody despite not being married or having spent much time with the baby. I have seen terrible people in my family and outside of my family win custody of children. It depends on the state you're in, the judge, and usually the biology. In the real world Lulu and Dante probably would have had the same outcome.
You're right, it did. I'm just saying that I think Lulu and Dante also lost because they didn't really show (at least Lulu didn't) that they would be more fit parents to the baby. Lulu just wanted to make Maxie out to be a horrible person. It just would have been interesting if they judge said to Lulu and Dante, 'you guys didn't say anything that would make me think you'd be better parents.' On top of the biology thing. Admitedly, I don't know much about custody, but I have also seen one instance when biology both won over and lost (mom lost custody and visitation, due to her being an alcoholic and no job- what her brother told me, and the father of the child did get full custody.) I guess biology does play a large role. However, I don't think it always should. Just because you're the biological parent, doesn't mean you are fit or capable of raising a child. You said in the real world, Lulu and Dante would have had the same outcome. Is that because judge's tend to favor biology in general?
Now that I think about it, it wouldn't have. In all honesty, talk of custody should have been tossed out the window when Maxie miscarried Lulu and Dante's baby. I don't exactly know how surrogacy works, but I'm pretty sure a written contract is signed. If a contract was signed amongst Lulu, Dante and Maxie, then the contract should have been rendered null and void when the miscarriage happened. Regardless of the fact that Dante and Lulu found out the truth after the kid was born.
If you want to win a child custody case on GH just be willing to share custody with whoever you're fighting with and ride that train till the end. Nice people always get the bebe in the end. Carly, Tony and Bonnie, and now Spinelli.
This judge is such a Karen towards Maxie it's completely unfair and disgraceful to keep her own child away from its mother and he wants to go ahead and say bad things about Maxie. How dare you, if you didn't want lulu to have Maxie's child why did you her full custody of Connie in the first place?
honestly this story and the dante cheating on lulu were the only storylines i liked emme rylan as lulu in. i love her as lulu but they give her horrible stories and writing. since when was being a reporter interesting? blegh. i want ron back. he gave people good stories, and made the show interesting again.
I’ve hated this lulu since the day she started on gh. She’s pathetic and has a flair for the dramatics that destroyed the strong beautiful woman that used to play her
I feel bad for lulu even tho she’s a bitch but maxie did it all out of love to give her Bestfriend a child she was scared but at the end of the day that’s maxies daughter
diane: "your honor, if I may just have a word with my client... maxie sit down and shut up" very comforting!
Danielle Urton I like Diane
The judge was right on with his decision. Maxie needs mandatory counseling I feel in order to get visitation. She made some terrible mistakes which cost Lulu, Dante, and Spinelli pain. This also affected their extended families. Great acting.
But it's okay for parent's like Obrecht and Faison to raise their child?
This is so BS no Maxie don't .
I see no fault in the judges ruling. Maxie needed to grow up and Lulu and Dante needed to be knocked down a peg or two. I was so happy for Spinelli. He finally was rewarded for being the innocent one in all this. Maxie and Lulu competition between each other was so toxic to Spinelli using him as a pawn to get back at each other.
The judge has a great voice!
He was dated Monica as well.
Very smart judge and very good choice
If she had lied, then it sounds like the judge made the right decision. Just because you are the biological mother, that doesn't mean you should remain custody of your child - especially if you do not have the necessary ethical background/backbone to raise the kid. Nobody in society would agree that it's right to raise a heathen. And that's EXACTLY what you're doing if you lie and you're willing to lie - even if it may be for good intentions. People think that lying - even with good intentions - will be given exceptions. WRONG!!! The objective is to not lie at all.
This was the smartest decision that judge could have made while I feel bad for Dante and Lulu after falling in love with the baby, Spinelli shouldn't of had to part with his little girl because Maxie's a horrible liar and Maxie needed a parental time out, her decision making at this point was disgustingly self interested and reckless.
EVERYONE in this town are LIARS.
@@d3fault95 what lies did Spinelli ever tell?
Diane is the Saul Goodman of GH
This Lulu is sooo annoying! And Motormouth Maxie should shut up, and let the judge finish talking...
Ok.
That judge didn't deny custody because Lulu and Dante weren't Georgie's biological parents (and yes, I know during the battle the baby's name was Connie, but Spinelli changed it in honor of Maxie's sister). Biology doesn't always win in custody cases. You could be a biological parent, but a piece of shit at the same time. My friend had a sister who lost BOTH custody and visitation of/with her daughter, and she was the biological mother.
The only reason Dante and Lulu lost custody, was because Lulu was more concerned with hurting Maxie, then actually proving she and Dante would be better parents.
That's just how I see it.
Honestly, the biology played a part in this. That's why Spinelli go custody despite not being married or having spent much time with the baby. I have seen terrible people in my family and outside of my family win custody of children. It depends on the state you're in, the judge, and usually the biology. In the real world Lulu and Dante probably would have had the same outcome.
You're right, it did. I'm just saying that I think Lulu and Dante also
lost because they didn't really show (at least Lulu didn't) that they
would be more fit parents to the baby. Lulu just wanted to make Maxie
out to be a horrible person.
It just would have been interesting if they judge said to Lulu and Dante, 'you guys didn't say anything that would make me think you'd be better parents.'
On top of the biology thing.
Admitedly, I don't know much about custody, but I have also seen one instance when biology both won over and lost (mom lost custody and visitation, due to her being an alcoholic and no job- what her brother told me, and the father of the child did get full custody.)
I guess biology does play a large role.
However, I don't think it always should. Just because you're the biological parent, doesn't mean you are fit or capable of raising a child.
You said in the real world, Lulu and Dante would have had the same outcome. Is that because judge's tend to favor biology in general?
Alicia Kistner-King I definitely agree with your viewpoint. I think in real life, Lulu and Dante's case wouldn't have even made it to court.
Now that I think about it, it wouldn't have. In all honesty, talk of custody should have been tossed out the window when Maxie miscarried Lulu and Dante's baby. I don't exactly know how surrogacy works, but I'm pretty sure a written contract is signed. If a contract was signed amongst Lulu, Dante and Maxie, then the contract should have been rendered null and void when the miscarriage happened.
Regardless of the fact that Dante and Lulu found out the truth after the kid was born.
I totally agree &lulu is anoying
If you want to win a child custody case on GH just be willing to share custody with whoever you're fighting with and ride that train till the end. Nice people always get the bebe in the end. Carly, Tony and Bonnie, and now Spinelli.
Who the hell is bonnie lol
@@murdahmammiez Oops I meant Bobbie.
Maxies real name is Mariah Maximillia Jones
This judge is such a Karen towards Maxie it's completely unfair and disgraceful to keep her own child away from its mother and he wants to go ahead and say bad things about Maxie. How dare you, if you didn't want lulu to have Maxie's child why did you her full custody of Connie in the first place?
honestly this story and the dante cheating on lulu were the only storylines i liked emme rylan as lulu in. i love her as lulu but they give her horrible stories and writing. since when was being a reporter interesting? blegh. i want ron back. he gave people good stories, and made the show interesting again.
oh hell no
I never could stand lulu
I’ve hated this lulu since the day she started on gh. She’s pathetic and has a flair for the dramatics that destroyed the strong beautiful woman that used to play her
I cant stand her either shes whiny n controlling
I totally agree
I feel bad for lulu even tho she’s a bitch but maxie did it all out of love to give her Bestfriend a child she was scared but at the end of the day that’s maxies daughter
Maxie is the worst character overall. She is a horrible person. Just everything she has done over the years.
Jennifer Lynn lulus not so innocent either
Exactly!!!
Honey there are a lot of people who have done far worse than maxie... You wanna go there we could get into how Lulu got Nathan killed
And yet everyone likes Carly of course she NEVER lies to anyone
Of course she has made a lot of mistakes but still…. I love Maxie
Can’t stand Maxie and Spinelli……💯💯💯💯💯.