Notice how Giselle is talking more and more in these segments? At first people were misinterpreting her being silent saying that the members were ignoring her or didn't want to include her but they forget giselle trained for a short period of time and she doesn't really have much experience in front of the camera, even in their first music show's interviews she was really nervous gripping her mic tightly, but now I'm happy she's slowly getting comfortable and showing us her funny and badass self
Karina’s clumsiness is so endearing. Ningning’s baby voice exudes maknae vibes. Giselle is cute and chill. And my bias, birthday girl Winter, is such a queen! 😍
Karina looks like a model i can see brands contacting her soon and Ning is so charming & giselle so chill and pretty and winter is so beautiful what a group 👏
우리나라 사람들이 얼마나 혐오로 미쳐있는지 이거 해외토픽감임. 이미 닝닝 관련해서 해외 커뮤니티에서 단체로 한국인들 미쳤다고 욕하고 있는거 우리나라 사람들만 모르고 있는게 웃김. 중국 싫어하는 일본인들도 닝닝이 왜 욕먹어야 되는지 이해불가인 반응임. 우리나라 사람들은 국가랑 개인을 분리를 못함. 이성보다 감정이 항상 앞서는 민족임. 대부분은 그냥 중국인이니까 정황을 모르고 욕하고 있음. 여기서 아무리 중국인 욕해봐야 객관적인 시각으로 닝닝이 욕먹어야 될 이유가 없다는게 해외 반응임. 해외 커뮤니티 전부 뒤져봐라 아무도 닝닝 욕 안함. 오히려 우리나라 네티즌들을 욕함. 중국을 그렇게 싫어하는 미국인들도 일본인들도 국가랑 개인을 분리해서 이성적으로 볼줄암. 우리나라 사람들만 기사랑 유튜브에 선동당해서 욕하고 있음. 해프닝 수준으로 끝날일을 왜곡하고 부풀려서 사람죽이려고 달려들고 있는거임. 닝닝은 경기를 안봐서 편파판정인거도 몰랐음. 학교 선생한테 동문이 금메달 땃다고 들은 얘기를 팬들만 볼수 있는 공간에 전한거임. 누군가가 악의적으로 메시지 앞뒤 다 잘라서 유출하고 악의적 기사를 퍼뜨렸는데 마침 우리나라사람들이 우리가 당한 편파판정으로 화가 날 대로 난 상황에서 중국인이 금메달 따서 기뻐했다는 기사를 접해서 욕하기 시작한게 팩트임. 닝닝이 금메달 따서 기뻐했다는 경기는 우리나라 경기랑 관련도 없는 경기 였음. 편파판정으로 논란이 심한걸 알았으면 또 이렇게 욕먹을걸 알았으면 당연히 그런 메시지를 안보냈겠지. 닝닝은 경기를 안보고 그저 전해들은 얘기를 한거임. 닝닝은 심판이 아닌데 닝닝한테 편파판정 따지는거도 웃김.. IOC나 중국한테 따져야지 왜 경기를 안본 개인한테 화풀이 하는지 우리나라 너무 미개함. 그냥 중국인이 금메달 딴거 기뻐했다는 이유로 한 개인에게 화풀이 하고 있는게 팩트임. 수상소감 중국어로 말했다고 욕하는거도 미개함. 일본아이돌들 일본어로 수상소감하고 미국인들 영어로 수상소감 말하고 다 자국어로 수상소감 말하는 경우 많은데 왜 문제임? 닝닝은 항상 한국어로 먼저 수상소감 말했음. 해외 배우시상식 보면 외국배우들 자국어로 수상소감 말하는 경우 많음. 아무도 욕 안함. 그냥 중국인이니까 욕하는거 맞잖아. 절안했다고 욕하는거도 미개함. 절하는거 생소하고 이상하게 여기는 외국인들 많음. 절안하는 문화면 우리문화를 강요할 필요가 없는게 존중임. 절안했다고 욕하는게 미개한거지. 해외 네티즌들은 문화가 다른 외국인이 절안한게 뭐가 문제냐고 그게 욕먹을 일이냐고 우리나라 사람들을 이상하다고 욕하는 중임. 여기서 아무리 절안했다고 중국인 혐오해봐야 다른 나라 사람들 전부 우리나라 미쳤다고 미개하다고 욕하는중임;
@@pessimisticcatto1121 but she lived and went to school in Japan, so I imagine she is more fluent in Japanese in terms of phrases, slangs and expressions
I like how based off the videos, interviews, and radio shows that we seen, you can tell that these girls act like themselves. Which is really rare for rookie groups, especially rookie SM groups. Usually it takes some time for them to loosen up but these girls already give off such good vibes. They aren’t shy to talk, aren’t shy to show aegyo, usually they just cringe afterwords, they aren’t scared to be loud, they aren’t trying to hide their laughs, and they aren’t really shy to be put on the spot ( from what I seen on radio shows) ... these girls are themselves and I love it. Giselle is just really chill but when she does talk she has so much confidence, winter is funny and odd lol, karina is always laughing and also funny, ningning is also always laughing (loudly 😂) and wanting to show off her sexy side, she also has such a cute personality but I also find some of the stuff she says kinda odd 😂😂
They're casual outfits are much better than the fits that their stylist's give. I cant get over with Karina's padlock dress and Ningning's curtain top 😆
U know what i just realise something,i think its some kind of 'revenge'.they had that 'ugly' clothes 'only' on sbs end year event . Look at aespa clothes on mbc end year event,its good.as the result aespa video on mbc had more views bcos aespa had a more good clothes. Sbs deserved that,for not properly apologize to wendy .but im not sure either ,im just suspicious tho. and sorry for bad english :) (if its true its not good tho for using aespa as revenge tools but we all dont know)
if you live in china you will see most millennials and gen-z wear clothes like that haha. wearing clothes like ninging's has always been a trend there.
Karina writing "My baby" in her letter for winter is too cute like winrina is sailing y'all🥺..and when i see DUMB again omgg giselleeee🤭and ningning's "baby chick~🐥" omggg they're so cute..🥺💜
@@sooyaself2411 i delte the PH COMMENT OF MINE HEHE(eng trans:we already ship them back then when they made debut..it's not were being delulu but we just ship them as a friend & sister..)
CAN WE TALK ABOUT HOW THEY DID THE HIGHNOTES EFFORTLESSLY?!!!! GISELLE, NINGNING, AND KARINA DOING IT LIKE IN A MUSICAL PLAY HAHAHAHA I CAN'T WITH WINTER.. WAS IT A SPOILER ABOUT THEIR COMEBACK? HMMM
@@normalhumam3250 u r so rude. We dont hate aespa, just the person who is responsible to place english subtitles. And no, i did not dislike this video lol
*i fvcking hate how Aespa shouts GenZ in the title HAHAHAHAHAH LMAO* i mean I do that they are part of GenZ because so am I but I JUST CANT STAND THE *HBD* HAHAHAHAHAH reminds me of me and my friends
우리나라 사람들이 얼마나 혐오로 미쳐있는지 이거 해외토픽감임. 이미 닝닝 관련해서 해외 커뮤니티에서 단체로 한국인들 미쳤다고 욕하고 있는거 우리나라 사람들만 모르고 있는게 웃김. 중국 싫어하는 일본인들도 닝닝이 왜 욕먹어야 되는지 이해불가인 반응임. 우리나라 사람들은 국가랑 개인을 분리를 못함. 이성보다 감정이 항상 앞서는 민족임. 대부분은 그냥 중국인이니까 정황을 모르고 욕하고 있음. 여기서 아무리 중국인 욕해봐야 객관적인 시각으로 닝닝이 욕먹어야 될 이유가 없다는게 해외 반응임. 해외 커뮤니티 전부 뒤져봐라 아무도 닝닝 욕 안함. 오히려 우리나라 네티즌들을 욕함. 중국을 그렇게 싫어하는 미국인들도 일본인들도 국가랑 개인을 분리해서 이성적으로 볼줄암. 우리나라 사람들만 기사랑 유튜브에 선동당해서 욕하고 있음. 해프닝 수준으로 끝날일을 왜곡하고 부풀려서 사람죽이려고 달려들고 있는거임. 닝닝은 경기를 안봐서 편파판정인거도 몰랐음. 학교 선생한테 동문이 금메달 땃다고 들은 얘기를 팬들만 볼수 있는 공간에 전한거임. 누군가가 악의적으로 메시지 앞뒤 다 잘라서 유출하고 악의적 기사를 퍼뜨렸는데 마침 우리나라사람들이 우리가 당한 편파판정으로 화가 날 대로 난 상황에서 중국인이 금메달 따서 기뻐했다는 기사를 접해서 욕하기 시작한게 팩트임. 닝닝이 금메달 따서 기뻐했다는 경기는 우리나라 경기랑 관련도 없는 경기 였음. 편파판정으로 논란이 심한걸 알았으면 또 이렇게 욕먹을걸 알았으면 당연히 그런 메시지를 안보냈겠지. 닝닝은 경기를 안보고 그저 전해들은 얘기를 한거임. 닝닝은 심판이 아닌데 닝닝한테 편파판정 따지는거도 웃김.. IOC나 중국한테 따져야지 왜 경기를 안본 개인한테 화풀이 하는지 우리나라 너무 미개함. 그냥 중국인이 금메달 딴거 기뻐했다는 이유로 한 개인에게 화풀이 하고 있는게 팩트임. 수상소감 중국어로 말했다고 욕하는거도 미개함. 일본아이돌들 일본어로 수상소감하고 미국인들 영어로 수상소감 말하고 다 자국어로 수상소감 말하는 경우 많은데 왜 문제임? 닝닝은 항상 한국어로 먼저 수상소감 말했음. 해외 배우시상식 보면 외국배우들 자국어로 수상소감 말하는 경우 많음. 아무도 욕 안함. 그냥 중국인이니까 욕하는거 맞잖아. 절안했다고 욕하는거도 미개함. 절하는거 생소하고 이상하게 여기는 외국인들 많음. 절안하는 문화면 우리문화를 강요할 필요가 없는게 존중임. 절안했다고 욕하는게 미개한거지. 해외 네티즌들은 문화가 다른 외국인이 절안한게 뭐가 문제냐고 그게 욕먹을 일이냐고 우리나라 사람들을 이상하다고 욕하는 중임. 여기서 아무리 절안했다고 중국인 혐오해봐야 다른 나라 사람들 전부 우리나라 미쳤다고 미개하다고 욕하는중임;
![[🎂] 어때 이 깜짝 생일 파티? 🤭🎉 | Happy WINTER’s Day❄️](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_VmMjltZzvY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[🎂] 어때 이 깜짝 생일 파티? 🤭🎉 | Happy WINTER’s Day❄️](/img/tr.png)
![[EP.01] Better Things To Do with MY Time | aespa 에스파 'Better Things' Sitcom 🏡](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TforiqSzgEo/mqdefault.jpg)
The fact that Winter's Birthday is on Winter season is already cute itself.
She's called Winter because her birthday is in Winter lol
@@MrSteelcity97 but her favorite season is actually fall😂
@@serendipity-v3c Ikr, i thought it will be winter too because of her name 😂
Lee sooman named her winter because she was born in winter tho lol
And I'm proud that I have the same birthday with Winter😊
Notice how Giselle is talking more and more in these segments? At first people were misinterpreting her being silent saying that the members were ignoring her or didn't want to include her but they forget giselle trained for a short period of time and she doesn't really have much experience in front of the camera, even in their first music show's interviews she was really nervous gripping her mic tightly, but now I'm happy she's slowly getting comfortable and showing us her funny and badass self
plus the other three members were already together for like 3 years before giselle entered sm, it's natural for the other 3 to be closer
How long was giselle in sm before debuting?
@@michellecampa9850 11 months if I'm not wrong
@@michellecampa9850 she joined sm in december of 2019
@@eady4836 4 years i think
The girls are so cute and clumsy organizing the party for Winter. They are so precious
Vote Aespa in HALLYU LIFE ROTY please!
@@fuadhusnulyaqin2903 Yess
karina's aegyo, giselle's english words, & winter and ningning's cute noises are so cute af.
WINTER BEST GIRL❄️💙✨
YESS❄️💙✨
YES
Yess 🌸♥
Y.E.S
For sure
Karina is LOUD
Giselle is LOUD
Winter is LOUD
Ningning is LOUD
aespa is LOUD AF..!
I LOVE IT!
Now imagine them with snsd and rv in a same room
@rashi LOL
@@madeljoycevarona5098 Imagine them being accompanied by other SM artists...
Vote Aespa in HALLYU LIFE ROTY please!
@Jessica Mae Bitancur Karina = Taeyong, same level of stress for handling 3 : 22 chaotic brats
Karina’s clumsiness is so endearing. Ningning’s baby voice exudes maknae vibes. Giselle is cute and chill. And my bias, birthday girl Winter, is such a queen! 😍
ua-cam.com/video/SmzSaUFM4FI/v-deo.html
I'm here because winter literally spoiled us with their new upcoming single 'forever'.
7:19
SPOILER QUEEN INDEED!
And giselle make it obvious😆
Lmao
The building is so quiet and then AESPA IS JUST SO LOUD LMAO
Happens with every single SM group lmfaoooo SM crackhead rookies AESPA
the entire SM building is chaotic
Karina is loud
Winter is loud
Giselle is loud
Ning Ning is loud
AESPA IS LOUD
@PlayA Channel ew wth
did you really put a women with no bra ew
Imagine put aespa and red velvet in same room and invite nct as a guest😂
I can't with ningning saying "our maknae" to winter, when she's literally the youngest 😂
Hahahahahah. Lol.
Ningning
Ningning as Clown hahaha Lol
when does she say it?
@@lethlead4990 for fun purpose I guess.
3:20
I find their dynamic so genuine, not trying too hard to be funny or cute just like you would act with your friends
One of the reason i stan
ua-cam.com/video/SmzSaUFM4FI/v-deo.html
Right?! I really like that about them
@@Mku-JJ1if same
Yeah ❤❤❤
The fact that they always sang in between makes them more like SM Artist ,it shows that they really love singing😁
Fhko
They are looks so freaking cute I'm like obsessed with them.
Same 😭😭
Same huhuuu
yeahh me too😭
same lol
Vote Aespa in HALLYU LIFE ROTY please!
Ningning said "our maknae". Ningning, you're the maknae 😂
😂😂😂😂
Who is the maknae? Winter or ningning?
@@joy50897 ningning! Hehehhe
@@azra_70s why did she say that winter is their maknae?
@@joy50897 Just Ningning's joke since that was Winter's day! hehe
They're the first SM artist I saw that didn't messed up their cake....
they already messed up the first one they did 🤣🤣🤣 and say thank u to their maknaeline 🤣
Not yet lol😂
Such a exo thing
They kinda did mess up their debut cake😂
they messed up their debut cake sooo
awww the way Ningning kissed Winter's head is just too cute.
Giselle, Ningning and Karina were hiding so that Winter won't notice them but they are too loud and keep laughing that so obviously hahaha
Plus you can see Karina from a mile away
@@spacesoftime yes haha but still Winter pretend that she was surprise hahaa
I mean she obviously could see them and the decorations on the wall but they weren't that loud lmao, what you can hear is the feed from their mics
I like how Giselle started enjoying in front of the camera she started talking a lot, laughing a lot and starting to be noisy🤣🤣
She's slowly getting comfortable in front of the camera
@@spacesoftime Yap, it is true
my girl so brave !
so true !!!
*Winter will always be your bias even if she isn't your bias~*
factsss
Yessss
Yup
She still can be my imouto
So damn true
Karina reminds me of Taemin. Fierce on the stage, cute and adorable outside of the stage.
Same, she's very intimadating in stage but she's really softie 🤗
I'm obsessed with them saying "baby chiiick" that's just freaking cute lol
If someone is this then please watch my videos and edits I hope you like dear and sorry for annoying
..
...
A link to the fmv and edit videos I made for BTS, Sehun ,Baekhyun and Kai. Please watch and like the videos. Can you support me by subscribing?
@@choco6619 lol both of u guys promoting
@@rachaelkim4038 Shameless promoting
i literally keep replaying it 😭
Ningsellerina: winter doesn’t know.,,
Winter: obviously 🙄 pretend don’t know 😅
Lmao
ua-cam.com/video/IImYdIXAz-4/v-deo.html
🤣🤣🤣
ua-cam.com/video/SmzSaUFM4FI/v-deo.html
Vote Aespa in HALLYU LIFE ROTY please!
Imagine coming here after 5 years and saying i am with them from the beginning.
Samee
3:21 Ningning: "our youngest member" (about winter) 😂😂
🤣🤣
Winter:perfect
Karina: perfect
Giselle :perfect
Ning Ning : perfect
Aespa and my perfect
If someone is this then please watch my videos and edits I hope you like dear and sorry for annoying
..
...
@@daissyy8020 sure
Vote Aespa in HALLYU LIFE ROTY please!
Giselle in her every letter for Winter:
To: My Dumb 친구
From: Dumber
Vote Aespa in HALLYU LIFE ROTY please!
@@fuadhusnulyaqin2903 I already did. ^_^
Karina looks like a model i can see brands contacting her soon and Ning is so charming & giselle so chill and pretty and winter is so beautiful what a group 👏
Yesss
7:00 역시...
우리나라 사람들이 얼마나 혐오로 미쳐있는지 이거 해외토픽감임. 이미 닝닝 관련해서 해외 커뮤니티에서 단체로 한국인들 미쳤다고 욕하고 있는거 우리나라 사람들만 모르고 있는게 웃김. 중국 싫어하는 일본인들도 닝닝이 왜 욕먹어야 되는지 이해불가인 반응임. 우리나라 사람들은 국가랑 개인을 분리를 못함. 이성보다 감정이 항상 앞서는 민족임. 대부분은 그냥 중국인이니까 정황을 모르고 욕하고 있음. 여기서 아무리 중국인 욕해봐야 객관적인 시각으로 닝닝이 욕먹어야 될 이유가 없다는게 해외 반응임. 해외 커뮤니티 전부 뒤져봐라 아무도 닝닝 욕 안함. 오히려 우리나라 네티즌들을 욕함. 중국을 그렇게 싫어하는 미국인들도 일본인들도 국가랑 개인을 분리해서 이성적으로 볼줄암. 우리나라 사람들만 기사랑 유튜브에 선동당해서 욕하고 있음. 해프닝 수준으로 끝날일을 왜곡하고 부풀려서 사람죽이려고 달려들고 있는거임. 닝닝은 경기를 안봐서 편파판정인거도 몰랐음. 학교 선생한테 동문이 금메달 땃다고 들은 얘기를 팬들만 볼수 있는 공간에 전한거임. 누군가가 악의적으로 메시지 앞뒤 다 잘라서 유출하고 악의적 기사를 퍼뜨렸는데 마침 우리나라사람들이 우리가 당한 편파판정으로 화가 날 대로 난 상황에서 중국인이 금메달 따서 기뻐했다는 기사를 접해서 욕하기 시작한게 팩트임. 닝닝이 금메달 따서 기뻐했다는 경기는 우리나라 경기랑 관련도 없는 경기 였음. 편파판정으로 논란이 심한걸 알았으면 또 이렇게 욕먹을걸 알았으면 당연히 그런 메시지를 안보냈겠지. 닝닝은 경기를 안보고 그저 전해들은 얘기를 한거임. 닝닝은 심판이 아닌데 닝닝한테 편파판정 따지는거도 웃김.. IOC나 중국한테 따져야지 왜 경기를 안본 개인한테 화풀이 하는지 우리나라 너무 미개함. 그냥 중국인이 금메달 딴거 기뻐했다는 이유로 한 개인에게 화풀이 하고 있는게 팩트임. 수상소감 중국어로 말했다고 욕하는거도 미개함. 일본아이돌들 일본어로 수상소감하고 미국인들 영어로 수상소감 말하고 다 자국어로 수상소감 말하는 경우 많은데 왜 문제임? 닝닝은 항상 한국어로 먼저 수상소감 말했음. 해외 배우시상식 보면 외국배우들 자국어로 수상소감 말하는 경우 많음. 아무도 욕 안함. 그냥 중국인이니까 욕하는거 맞잖아. 절안했다고 욕하는거도 미개함. 절하는거 생소하고 이상하게 여기는 외국인들 많음. 절안하는 문화면 우리문화를 강요할 필요가 없는게 존중임. 절안했다고 욕하는게 미개한거지. 해외 네티즌들은 문화가 다른 외국인이 절안한게 뭐가 문제냐고 그게 욕먹을 일이냐고 우리나라 사람들을 이상하다고 욕하는 중임. 여기서 아무리 절안했다고 중국인 혐오해봐야 다른 나라 사람들 전부 우리나라 미쳤다고 미개하다고 욕하는중임;
aespa’s first video in 2021 was celebrating winter’s birthday omg
it would be really cool if their first videos every start of the year would be winter's birthday videos 😭😭♥️♥️
6:23 gosh Karina's vocal is so good. SM give her more lines that show her potential!!!!
1:11 this one too🤩
at first I thought she is the "weakest" in vocals but after I saw her pre debut video singing, I am so impressed.
We got no visual hole,rap hole,vocal hole,dance hole in aespa
@BANGTANPINK World Revolution try watching her videos singing. she can even sing high notes.
@BANGTANPINK World Revolution try watching her video singing the song FAME. She isn't the weakest
2:07 When the Korean member is asking the Chinese member and the Japanese member which phrase is correct... 😅
Exactly 🤣🤣🤣
giselle is half korean sooooo
@@pessimisticcatto1121 but she lived and went to school in Japan, so I imagine she is more fluent in Japanese in terms of phrases, slangs and expressions
No one:
Literally no one:
Giselle's letter: mY fAvoRitE dUmb 친구
If someone is this then please watch my videos and edits I hope you like dear and sorry for annoying
..
...
Yup. That caught my attention the most. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤘🤘🤘
From: Dumber
timestap please
Me: **reads it FIRST THING**
Who wrote the message "To: Dumb, From: Dumber?" Is it Giselle? That's cute hahaha
yes, it's giselle
@@sarmalinapane5142 funny and cute 🤭😂
Vote Aespa in HALLYU LIFE ROTY please!
In this house, when they laugh we laugh.
I feel your pain lol
...
Hhahah
Hi, please vote aespa on Hallyulife www.hallyulife.com/awards/vote/
(The category is ‘Rookie of the Year’) thankyouu
Vote Aespa in HALLYU LIFE ROTY please!
7:21 WINTER SPOILED "FOREVER" OMGGGGGG Y'ALL
Spoiler queen
Apenas me di cuenta.
"PUI PUI PUI PUI PUI" JAJAJAJA
i can't understand anything except giselle letter to winter "my favorite dumb chingu"
I like how based off the videos, interviews, and radio shows that we seen, you can tell that these girls act like themselves. Which is really rare for rookie groups, especially rookie SM groups. Usually it takes some time for them to loosen up but these girls already give off such good vibes. They aren’t shy to talk, aren’t shy to show aegyo, usually they just cringe afterwords, they aren’t scared to be loud, they aren’t trying to hide their laughs, and they aren’t really shy to be put on the spot ( from what I seen on radio shows) ... these girls are themselves and I love it. Giselle is just really chill but when she does talk she has so much confidence, winter is funny and odd lol, karina is always laughing and also funny, ningning is also always laughing (loudly 😂) and wanting to show off her sexy side, she also has such a cute personality but I also find some of the stuff she says kinda odd 😂😂
They're casual outfits are much better than the fits that their stylist's give. I cant get over with Karina's padlock dress and Ningning's curtain top 😆
The stylists be playing granny
@@boorave may be🤣
Yeah it's more sparkling than stage outfit
@@mutumromola4462 Yes.
U know what i just realise something,i think its some kind of 'revenge'.they had that 'ugly' clothes 'only' on sbs end year event . Look at aespa clothes on mbc end year event,its good.as the result aespa video on mbc had more views bcos aespa had a more good clothes. Sbs deserved that,for not properly apologize to wendy .but im not sure either ,im just suspicious tho. and sorry for bad english :) (if its true its not good tho for using aespa as revenge tools but we all dont know)
김민정 이 세상에서 제일 귀여운 생명체야 엄마는 널 정말 사랑한단다
When you're so early there aren't any eng subs yet:
Edit: Good job SM, you finally put the subs after nearly 2 days -_-
I feel ya
haha
There used to be at time of release in previous vid 🥺🥺🥺
Problem here we go
Lol
Adorable winter, sweet Giselle, baddas ningning, cute karina
Can we talk about ningning style? She look like rich girl:>
if you live in china you will see most millennials and gen-z wear clothes like that haha. wearing clothes like ninging's has always been a trend there.
@Yousr Meso Idk tbh? Her dad is an architect and idk if there’s a mom or not.
ua-cam.com/video/IImYdIXAz-4/v-deo.html
"she look like rich girl "
Me : she already rich
She is rich 😂
WINTER IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO CUTE
"To: Dumb" "My favorite Dumb" queen Giselle everyone 😂✊🏻
she gives me savage bad bitch vibes and I'm honestly living for it😂
Let's Sing Red Velvet "Dumb Dumb"
Is everyone gonna ignore Ningning's highnote at 7:18 that's who we call a true Main vocalist 💛
Karina called Winter "My Baby" on her letter. Who's crying? My WINRINA heart 🤧
ua-cam.com/video/SmzSaUFM4FI/v-deo.html
Karian's grey hair color is gorgeous
*Karina :)
@@leamaytimbol9241 karian*
@@wallaceavila6560 Ooh. I'm sorry. I thought he was referring to Karina?. What's karian by the way?
7:12 aespa be showing off their vocals every time they get a chance and I'm here for it
Happy holiday Winter
Holiday 😭😭
sen türkmüsün
7:17 Karina: *casually hitting the woah* 😂
aespa tiktokerists
Tiktokers what do we expect 😭🤣
aexo they are naturally good at it 😂
i feel like they spend their free time on tik tok lmao
4:33 아 지젤 보면볼수록 귀엽고 고급지고 그러네 참 에스파 흥하자 대한민국대표걸그룹으로
*Did anyone notice that NinhNing was the one who ate the cake the most? Haha she was in the corner eating, Karina also haha*
😂😂😂
guys is it just me or does Karina's visuals give me Irene vibes
YESS for real her chic looking visuals really remind me of Irene
they're both Aries that's why
yes even my mom when she saw aespa she said karina and ningning is the prettiest lmao
Personally I find Karina way more beautiful than Irene
they are both beautiful but not similar (just the black long hair). For me Irene has a cold beauty and Karina is more fresh
happy birthday winter!
Karina hair is so beautiful
Karina writing "My baby" in her letter for winter is too cute like winrina is sailing y'all🥺..and when i see DUMB again omgg giselleeee🤭and ningning's "baby chick~🐥" omggg they're so cute..🥺💜
If someone is this then please watch my videos and edits I hope you like dear and sorry for annoying
..
..
shipping already started lmao........
@@heatherlainevargas2256hahahahahahaha
but can u plz explain wht u just said in english?
@@sooyaself2411 i delte the PH COMMENT OF MINE HEHE(eng trans:we already ship them back then when they made debut..it's not were being delulu but we just ship them as a friend & sister..)
BELATED HAPPY BIRTHDAY WINTER!!!!
the girls: *let's hide here so that winter doesn't see us*
winter from the door: _they were like clowns girls_
ua-cam.com/video/rlmoZXl2nrY/v-deo.html
Not karina and giselle saying "stupid & we fooled yah" to winter🤦♀️
Unnie line izza savage🥴😂
Karina best girl
Winter best girl
Giselle best girl
Ningning best girl
@sri sulastri And all of them are the best women👍✨🌟⭐🔥💥
Don't forget:
æspa best group! ❤️💕✨
I didn't understand most of what they said but all i know is they're loud as heck lol 😂
Happy Birthday Dear Winter 💕
Its the aespa crackhead energy, they got plenty of it. 😂
they're like a sister who like surprising each other, i like their friendship so much 💕
If someone is this then please watch my videos and edits I hope you like dear and sorry for annoying
..
..
karina hitting the 'woah' is the cutest thing 7:15
CAN WE TALK ABOUT HOW THEY DID THE HIGHNOTES EFFORTLESSLY?!!!! GISELLE, NINGNING, AND KARINA DOING IT LIKE IN A MUSICAL PLAY HAHAHAHA I CAN'T WITH WINTER.. WAS IT A SPOILER ABOUT THEIR COMEBACK? HMMM
ua-cam.com/video/SmzSaUFM4FI/v-deo.html
No one is going to talk about how giselle starts talking with more confidence? i love them
It's so nice to see her getting more comfortable around cameras. She looks really happy in their recent videos.
Yaasss i'm so happy she's finally getting comfortable with the cameras! I guess the two chaotic maknaes influenced her a lot😂
3:28 Karina being her dramatic self saying Winter has grown up 😂
That's a sign for her actress debut HAHAHA
Giselle looks so much more confident in front of the camera, I'm happy she's less nervous and comfortable now.
the dislikes are from the haters that never had such a nice birthdays like winter's
Hahahahahahahah best comment
Maybe they mad because there's no subtitles.we feel them.
@@zaynmalik6582 haters be haters
@@normalhumam3250 u r so rude. We dont hate aespa, just the person who is responsible to place english subtitles. And no, i did not dislike this video lol
@@zaynmalik6582 then laugh smh
Fun fact : MY is the most sweetest fandom ever they watch the video even if there is no subtitle *RESPECT* 🥺❤️
5:29 “What is your wish?”
Winter: Next birthday celebrant is Karina so how about we celebrate her birthday (party) with MYs.
I love their friendship 💜
Karina is LOUD AF😂😂😂😂👌
Happiest birthday wishes to our winter.
Aespa saranghae.
ua-cam.com/video/SmzSaUFM4FI/v-deo.html
Aespa The revolution of the kpop industry, winner is a goddess ✨💜
5:19 Aespa and Redvelvet sunbaenim first interaction...
😆 red velvet cake
😆 red velvet cake
hhhhhhh🤣
HAHAHHAH
LMAOO
Ningning: *our maknae*
Karina & Giselle: *our maknae*
*So, ningning isn't the maknae but winter is. Belated Happy Birthday Winter❤and Kun (WayV).*
I know this vid is for Winter but i can't take my eyes off to Karina.
Karina your making my heart beat so fast!!!
Lets all sing NCT MAKE A WISH
"ITS YOUR BIRTHDAY MAKE A WISH"
Make a wish...
i can do this all day
seodeullo hit the line
piryo eobseo no more sign~ yeah😉
Nega eodie itteon I can find ya
Nobody: Dear stranger whoever read this, you're such a beautiful human being.
Right back at you, sunshine :з
So we're not gonna talk about Karina's accent here and how good she sounds even with slow sound? 1:14
Why SM doesn't show her vocals?
Be patient they debuted less than 2 months ago 🤣💜
cause she's a rapper??
@@catherineganal2112 she is actually a vocal but her position in her group is lead rapper.
6:23 too 😊😊
She's vocalist too. SM introduce her as someone who is good in singing, rapping and dancing.
3:05 the loudest voice from Giselle I've ever heard... Her laughing is so precious
When they all prepared for winter surprise birthday then there’s winter watching them
Winter:just act surprised lol
watching this 3 years later, it's her birthday again
Ningning's highnote the harmonizations on point yeokssi aespa
Happy birthday winter ♡
TURKİSH MY ♡
a-aa türk buldummm
Bende türküm
@aespa antilerini dayak manyağı yapma derneği kullanıcı adın efsane hfdkdjchvk
*i fvcking hate how Aespa shouts GenZ in the title HAHAHAHAHAH LMAO*
i mean I do that they are part of GenZ because so am I but I JUST CANT STAND THE *HBD* HAHAHAHAHAH reminds me of me and my friends
THEY DO
Giselle LOUD.
Karina LOUDER.
Winter LOUDEST.
Ningning NO COMMENT 💣💥
y'all did you see ningning hit that high note in the end👀, voCal quEeN
They're fashion sense are another level
It’s literally basic
yash especially ningning
If you see this comment, don't forget to stream Black Mamba after this.
Let's get 100 M views!
*hwaiting*
Of course we gonna get 100M views 😎 (Winter favorite emoji)
bro the stream is on fire, we are very good at stanning
@RORA YE r/ihadastroke
@RORA YE Wdym stop streaming?
7:00 일부러 절 안하네
우리나라 사람들이 얼마나 혐오로 미쳐있는지 이거 해외토픽감임. 이미 닝닝 관련해서 해외 커뮤니티에서 단체로 한국인들 미쳤다고 욕하고 있는거 우리나라 사람들만 모르고 있는게 웃김. 중국 싫어하는 일본인들도 닝닝이 왜 욕먹어야 되는지 이해불가인 반응임. 우리나라 사람들은 국가랑 개인을 분리를 못함. 이성보다 감정이 항상 앞서는 민족임. 대부분은 그냥 중국인이니까 정황을 모르고 욕하고 있음. 여기서 아무리 중국인 욕해봐야 객관적인 시각으로 닝닝이 욕먹어야 될 이유가 없다는게 해외 반응임. 해외 커뮤니티 전부 뒤져봐라 아무도 닝닝 욕 안함. 오히려 우리나라 네티즌들을 욕함. 중국을 그렇게 싫어하는 미국인들도 일본인들도 국가랑 개인을 분리해서 이성적으로 볼줄암. 우리나라 사람들만 기사랑 유튜브에 선동당해서 욕하고 있음. 해프닝 수준으로 끝날일을 왜곡하고 부풀려서 사람죽이려고 달려들고 있는거임. 닝닝은 경기를 안봐서 편파판정인거도 몰랐음. 학교 선생한테 동문이 금메달 땃다고 들은 얘기를 팬들만 볼수 있는 공간에 전한거임. 누군가가 악의적으로 메시지 앞뒤 다 잘라서 유출하고 악의적 기사를 퍼뜨렸는데 마침 우리나라사람들이 우리가 당한 편파판정으로 화가 날 대로 난 상황에서 중국인이 금메달 따서 기뻐했다는 기사를 접해서 욕하기 시작한게 팩트임. 닝닝이 금메달 따서 기뻐했다는 경기는 우리나라 경기랑 관련도 없는 경기 였음. 편파판정으로 논란이 심한걸 알았으면 또 이렇게 욕먹을걸 알았으면 당연히 그런 메시지를 안보냈겠지. 닝닝은 경기를 안보고 그저 전해들은 얘기를 한거임. 닝닝은 심판이 아닌데 닝닝한테 편파판정 따지는거도 웃김.. IOC나 중국한테 따져야지 왜 경기를 안본 개인한테 화풀이 하는지 우리나라 너무 미개함. 그냥 중국인이 금메달 딴거 기뻐했다는 이유로 한 개인에게 화풀이 하고 있는게 팩트임. 수상소감 중국어로 말했다고 욕하는거도 미개함. 일본아이돌들 일본어로 수상소감하고 미국인들 영어로 수상소감 말하고 다 자국어로 수상소감 말하는 경우 많은데 왜 문제임? 닝닝은 항상 한국어로 먼저 수상소감 말했음. 해외 배우시상식 보면 외국배우들 자국어로 수상소감 말하는 경우 많음. 아무도 욕 안함. 그냥 중국인이니까 욕하는거 맞잖아. 절안했다고 욕하는거도 미개함. 절하는거 생소하고 이상하게 여기는 외국인들 많음. 절안하는 문화면 우리문화를 강요할 필요가 없는게 존중임. 절안했다고 욕하는게 미개한거지. 해외 네티즌들은 문화가 다른 외국인이 절안한게 뭐가 문제냐고 그게 욕먹을 일이냐고 우리나라 사람들을 이상하다고 욕하는 중임. 여기서 아무리 절안했다고 중국인 혐오해봐야 다른 나라 사람들 전부 우리나라 미쳤다고 미개하다고 욕하는중임;
@@killer3936 넌 평생 마스크 쓰고 다녀라ㅉㅉㅉ
@@killer3936 즈그 좋아하는 여자 욕 먹으니까 한국인을 미개한 종족 취급하노 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 니가 그렇게 좋아하는 닝닝이랑 얼른 니네 나라로 가라
길거리에 좀 생겼다 하는 여자들 데리고 와서 풀메시켜도 쟤보다 이쁠 거 같은데 왜케 빰?
It's so cute how Karina and Giselle take care of the maknaes
The height difference between Karina and the members are cute af
@@kutakix it's the other way around. Karina is 1cm taller than Giselle 😅
It's like Joy with RV 🤣
@@arvindanielmelevo7269 True 🤣 except Karina is literally tall.. 170cm if im not mistaken
@@AyemJen 1 cm*
@@pessimisticcatto1121 edited it. Thank you for correcting me. I didn't realize I put inch instead of cm 😅
i can't be the only one who's obssess with them😭 they're so cuteee
이때 에스파는 완전 애기들이네❤
1st rule for International Fans : smile when they smile, laugh when they laugh, hhhhhh...
it's the way Karina looks like a supermodel but is so adorable for me
Yaashhhh
They actually funnier than expected trainee, i see snsd in them. Wish they will bring new era for sm like snsd but as aespa. Fighting!!!!!
진짜 멤버들끼리 너무너무 친해보여서 보기좋다ㅠㅠ♡♡
The ending shows me theyre gonna be louder than 23 nct members combined
It's not usually they haven't added subtitles yet..
BTW HAPPY BIRTHDAY MINJEONG🥰🥰