pixelrscore I think the legalities of two seperate employees of the company need to travel apart, their relationship to each other can’t factor into it. That’s what I gather at least. (Or Marisha is creative director and had been at the studio longer in the day than Matt)
But then imagine once Mat walks through door of their home Marisha is standing behind it saying "Was I right?! Did I get it??!?" with a manic look on her face
A lot of people pointing out Marisha was playing a high INT and WIS character, but so few pointing out this is literally what Cobalt Soul monks are meant to do - put together all the pieces to stomp out corruption where they see it. So the haters had even less of a reason to go after her Pepe Silvia moment
@@Taylor-gb5gf To be fair, she often deserves some hate. Not always, not near as severe as she gets, but some minor hate is definitely deserved often enough.
Great job with the video. The fact that some "fans" were mad at Marisha for this is mind boggling to me. She plays a high INT, high WIS character who pieced together a crapload of plot threads that the DM intentionally put out there for the players to see, it's simply fantastic. How many games have we all DM'd where we practically have to hit our players over the head with clues to get them to move to the next part of the game because they're barely paying attention, so massive kudos to Marisha for being that engaged in the game. Matt must have been super happy as well to know that all he had done had made sense six layers below the surface yet someone could put it together if they tried.
Wait, people got mad over this? I know a certain group of people gets mad at Marisha for litterally every single thing she does, but what's their reasoning for this? "Oh, she spoiled everything for the rest of the group by giving away the plot" or some nonsense like that, I'm guessing?
@@thegreenassassin553 Yes, there's no doubt that a portion (maybe even the majority) of the people who were angry was just because it was Marisha, but even the next day when some people not related to CR at all asked about it on twitter there was definitely some "players like that ruins the fun for everyone" faux-anger was out there on Twitter. But if social media has taught us anything it's that no matter what happens in the world, there are always some people out there who will not only dislike it, but will also be disproportionately angry about it too.
@@andrewshandle Eh, from my experience with the CR community, it's definitely not a majority. Those people are very loud, sure, and it's a larger group than I'd likes, but they're still in the minority in the end. Also, what do you expect? That players are *not* gonna try and solve a mystery that's presented before them? That's like, the whole point of a mystery. If I'd be the DM in such a scenario, I'd be slightly disappointed that you'd miss out on that "big reveal" moment (and even then, only to a degree), sure, but that instantly gets overshadowed by seeing how excited your players get about correctly solving a mystery you set up. Either way, my point being, those people are dumb.
I love that Marisha always tries to avoid asking the DM "Do I know this?" and instead tries to put things together herself. That's a great thing to do as a player.
Matt rarely gives them information they already should know unless it's super obvious. There's been many times that the players go back through their notes. It encourages them to keep notes in the first place. While the players would be perfectly justified to ask the DM since (or if) their character would know it, the players actually knowing these things keeps the story flowing and interesting and immensely helps the players keep interest in the game.
@@bowserbrowser6559 ikr? She is such a good player she doesn't need to engage with the DM directly and can piece it together with her incredible intelligence.
I love this, not just because it highlights marisha's crazy attention to detail, but it also shows how beau is so well suited to what marisha brings to the table. definitely going to keep this in mind the next time I make a character!
IIRC Marisha did mention in the recent Talks that she wanted Beau to have that note-taking trait *because* Marisha enjoys this sort of thing. This also permits her to bring all these ideas to the table without sounding like she's metagaming
Marisha Ray was a private investigator in a former life 🕵️♀️ Like in the 20's she was totally one of those nior detectives that said shit like "Be seeing you around dollface" while putting on a badass trench coat and fedora while smoking a cigar and drinking whiskey.
@@jesterssketchbook _a spectral Charlie Day comes forth with a board filled with potential suspects and clues, string connecting each piece together. His hair is messed up and his clothes wrinkled; his tired eyes fueled with caffeine and possibly 5-Hour Energy._
Well keyleth is the opposite of beau. While keyleth is naive and acts rash, beau is a strategist and think things through to better understand the situation.
she was also the one who put together thatthe woman without the hand was Ripley in the cell! She was always very good at this but Beau finally gave her a chance to amp it up in-character.
In the first campaign I wasn’t a massive fan of Keyleth, and that being my first experience of Marisha Ray I thought that I didn’t really like her… come campaign 2 and Beau is crazy strategic and full of incredible plans and just an absolute badass, which retroactively made me love how well she acted Keyleth in the first campaign purely by the wild juxtaposition between these two characters. Truly incredible
@@_____2219 ik I'm very late but still: I like how you still see parts of this side in Keyleth though, like how in the 'tree moment' with the Briarwoods, you see her frantically flipping through her notes and being the first to express a recognition of what was happening
man i read a comment about how matt tends to hide when hes about to break his poker face by drinking from his mug, and man is he hydrated during this LOL. You can really see the mix of both love and fear in his eyes seeing marisha just break through the and explain everything like an inverse kool-aid man
The best thing is that Matt recently uploaded his marriage proposal to his UA-cam channel, and it turns out he did it via putting himself and Marisha in a Lovecraftian Escape Puzzle Room. That made all of this about Marisha make SO MUCH MORE SENSE.
Boy! I didn't remember this being SO accurate! Talesin's reactions were specially interesting bc he knew absolutely zero of that. (sorry im a bit 2 years late. I've watched the Mighty Nein and ended up never watching this vid.)
As a Dm I can confirm. I absolutely LOVE it when my players figure out what is coming. I will be hinting at it from the start and when they put the puzzle together it shows me not only that they are invested, bus also that the story makes sense. And I love it!
It's the difference between a Scooby Doo mystery and a real one. Instead of having the twist come out of nowhere, there's always a chance you could put it together yourself.
My d&d group did this recently with conspiracy theorizing that this nobleman politician we hated was also an eladrin who served the Unseelie Court's seasons. We wound up being right and lost our minds at the reveal. Our DM was worried it being "obvious" would ruin it, but is putting the prices together only made it more rewarding.
Jonny Sims, the man who's writing The Magnus Archives podcast, said the same thing. Some people actually guessed the main twist and when he was asked about it in a later Q&A, he said you know you're doing a plot set up right when most people guess maybe 75% of it, some people guess all of it, and a few people get it totally wrong.
He talked about this moment in talks machina He basically said he vaguelly knew about 20% of what marisha said, but he was making all those faces because he was messing with travis
Does Tal even know? I thought he just made a character with amnesia and made up the tattoos and the bleeding to go with the blood hunter thing. I thought he gave Matt free reign to do his back story.
The breaking up of Marisha’s ranting with things like “HANG ON IM ALMOST DONE!” And “5 Years. 5 + 4 is 9. 9 eyes. But 2 years, 9 - 2 is 7, like the 7 members if our crew… we *ARE* AEOR!?” Is never going to be unfunny
Sam really is a genius of comedic timing. He can shut up for hours in tense combat or serious roleplay, but if he feels like it gets too heavy or too boring, he just blurts out a genius one-liner as punctiuation. He plays his meta role of comedic relief to perfection.
The way they say it constantly nags me. The name comes from "Schatten", the german word for shadow -Why there's a "c" missing I do not know.- but they prononce it like "Schaden" which is "harm" or "damage" in german. The nail in the coffin was that Liam instructed her to say it like that.
@Aidan Hall Dude, I don't get it either, it baffles me to no end. Marisha is my fav of the cast (love all the cast obviously) and shit like this is why...
@Aidan Hall I'm gonna go ahead and admit that for like the first twenty episodes I REALLY hated her character, but as episodes have progressed she has easily slid into my top four favorite characters out of both campaigns. I feel that the "bro I'm a teen rebel bro fuck authority bro" facade that she puts up for the first twenty or so episodes really puts people off. Some of those people, unfortunately, obviously don't have enough mental acuity to see beyond their initial knee-jerk reaction to a character. Which sucks, because she really grew into an amazing character.
I used to run a game for a mixture of friends and work colleagues. One of them had NEVER played an RPG before and found videogames incredibly stressful, she was literally the best detective in the whole group. Ironically, also playing a Monk.
@Aidan Hall true, but I often find that it also depends on how the player weaves that element of management into their character. Ie: Don't just let it be the player that spends all that time micromanaging materials and spells, let it be the character. The way Liam plays Caleb is a good example to me.
There's a lot of back and forth DMing a campaign where you just sit back, listen to your players jabber on...and steal their ideas/thoughts/fears/wants to implant into the campaign later on. And the M9 was a play on words...Nein means "no" so...they're the Mighty No...as in the Mighty...not. LOL
You bet Matt saw all the coincidental 9’s, then when they named themselves the Mighty Nein, he definitely started making the 9 symbolism more of a thing.
Idk, matt has said that it is more rewarding for the players and viewers and better story telling to actually have the clues lead up to a point instead of just throwing everything out just because someone figured it out. But im sure he will put a twist to it that they didnt see coming
@@nonblondified Yeah, GRRM once said it best; If you write a crime thriller and make the butler the killer, with all the clues leading to the Butler, but then change it to the Gardener because someone figured it out beforehand, that reveal and change will be extremely cheap.
no, clues hidden around, someone figures out, means it is so coherent and well made story that you can hear it out without it explicitly being told, just subtly hinted at. If you then just change it at the last minute just to force out "Suprise" You are a shitty writer. No offence. Game of thrones last season if you want a great example of this Of course you could be joking making me just being r/woosh But to what level or extent or even if, Who the hell knows?
People disrespect her for being somewhat of an airhead in the moment! Little do they know is that she's always thinking outside of the game, connecting the dots. She is what I would call a "lucid thinker", someone who delves deeper than the rest, taking notes to solidify her string of thoughts into a cohesive conclusion. Sometimes she overthinks things and comes out as the dumb one, but really she is a slow, methodical thinker who may get overloaded with too many possibilities and outcomes unless she splurges those thoughts onto paper. While others may be quick to think/act like a grasshopper, Marisha does the thinking in retrospect.
That is very insightful. As a person on the Autism spectrum I see similar things portrayed in Marisha. It's true that many people on the spectrum think outside the box, in my case it's because all of the things on the box are confusing. It's just a guess but I think that Marisha may be on the spectrum, which helps her follow these threads of plot that pass the other players by.
@@benjoe1993 A common theme you see from a lot of DMs is basically cultivating the table and game you want by being communicative with your players. Sometime what you want to do and what your players want doesnt match up. It isnt bad or a reflection of character. That's why it can take 10+ years to get a super solid group. (And then they have kids lol)
I really enjoy this clip. All of the flashbacks and Marisha looking like a freak. I'm the note taker in my group and I have done this. Once I stopped midsentence because I had an epiphany about all the blood magic that was happening in our campaign.
I used to take amazing notes plus I remember things very well (I used to have a study group in college and when someone missed a lecture I would recount the important parts and the others would be like omg that is like word for word, and I'd be like well that's what was said so that's how I remember it, I didn't know that was unusual, but I do not have photographic memory, I forget things all the time). Anyway our group voted to move the games from noon to 9 am, now I try to stay awake and my notes are like a name and a species and I keep looking at them like huh?
I'm the galliard and chronist. It's fun, but I have trouble when recounting it. I slip into details, that shouldn't be in summaries. And tipps here? But overall the view and ability to puzzle with the DMs stuff is awesome.
@@MommyOfZoeAndLiam A 9 am campaign is just evil. We have someone who lives in England in our campaign and we routinely keep him up till like 5 am - I have no idea how he does it.
You don't have to be creative to follow the narrative that Matt laid out, just intelligent enough to pay attention to the important things and to put the puzzle together only missing a few obvious pieces. I'll admit, the cast has a rougher time as a whole due to the multitasking involved in playing the game, acting in character, and producing a show, but that doesn't make the plot that much harder to follow. I would just say that Marisha probably puts forth the most effort in note taking and thinking about the story in the off time than the rest of the cast, or maybe that she's just the first one to lay out her theory wholly. Her investment makes a normal amount of sense when you consider that she's married to the worldbuilder and is always engaged. That's all, nothing any more stellar about this than what's come to be expected.
@@eliezeririzarry247 Hey.......can you not rain on someone's parade and just let this person admire Marisha without making a comment that undermines them? Jesus
@@QueenPandanimaniac Nah I don't respect the slide into hyperbolic language that is so common now. Michael Jordan achieved greatness; not every little accomplishment should receive the same word for praise, for example
@@eliezeririzarry247 Who hurt you lmao Just don't yuck someone's yum! It's that easy! Don't go out of your way to invalidate someone's praise, as hyperbolic as it may be! It literally hurts you in NO way!
@@QueenPandanimaniac Hey fair enough. To me its a big enough deal to spend a minute correcting somebody who just uses any word they want without putting critical thought behind it, but I'm not going to change the world doing it, either. If a couple of people read this, pissed or not, and start thinking a bit more before they speak, well shit they're doing that much better. You sound like a positive person though and I don't want to drag this on, so thanks I guess for at least speaking your mind. Cheers Maleny
I truly believe all the best DMs steal little bits from things players speculate. It makes it more fun when it seems like they have been leaving breadcrumbs the whole time.
ive not really had the oppourtunity to do much of this, but i did have a party who started checking a room for traps, so i just quickly went "mm, yes, a trap, but you rolled crap so im not going to tell you about it" and just hit them with a fireball landmine when they thought they were safe. there werent going to be any traps until you reminded me that traps are cool
@@MommyOfZoeAndLiam Yeah I mean, Matt even said (at the end of campaign wrap-up I believe) that he had already planned some kind of enemy with the eyes of nine before Tal even had said his character had 9 eye tattoos, so he just took that and wove it together, because it was coincidentally so perfect. I can barely read through half the "novels" of backstory that a few of my players give me but I really try to make an effort so that I can include it in the campaign in order to reward their participation in the game. Most of my players just play for the escapism once a week, which is fine, but it really makes all the preparation you do as a DM feel like a waste. So I like to give little nuggets for the players that put in more effort.
This is so insanely impressive. Like not even just Marisha's ability to take notes and connect dots, I'm talking about this video and the RECEIPTS. I'm super late to this party but dang homie, well done
Matt, in a state of evenly mixed abject panic and deep admiration for the incredibly intelligent person with whom he shares his life: Maybe... Aeor WAS the friends we made along the way?
Caleb: “A question-“ Beau: “HANG ON DIRT WIZARD, IM ALMOST DONE!” Yasha: “Question-“ Beau: “Yes what is it love of my life beautiful baby shining brighter than anything else in Exandria you hunk of adorable muscle that smells like a sexy crayon?”
Talesin's face the entire time. It's just like Travis throwing in that his character had some sailing experience, then it turns out to be a major plot line.
I just want to imagine him with a checklist behind his dm screen checking off each plot point she is hitting and looking more and more disappointed and so proud of his wife
Look at Matt's poker face while they are guessing EXACT details of his lore XD Watching this after the end of the campaign is a whole new and amazing experience!
I remember Marisha getting SO MUCH SHIT in the comments while she was literally laying out the entire plot Matt has written behind the screen Edit - Laura also throwing the last piece of the city splitting in there, can’t be overlooked
I still don't get why people got mad. Like, people! The other PLAYERS were fine with it. Liam said "We're here for it!" They love her, enjoy playing with her, and were there for her red string moment! It was EPIC!
I love how Yasha presents one new idea and couple names and Beau just immediately goes “this whole rambling and 90% accurate theory brought to you by Yasha Nydoorin&beau but mostly yasha. Girl was so down bad
What I picture whenever I hear that music after the MCU: The Mighty Nein: "Just focus on facts. Go." Luis: "Yo, that's complicated because I was kickin' it at the Cobalt Reserve, right..."
@@invisiblog as smart as Travis is, he tends to take plot points and what people say at face value often while in the game. Also I don't think he takes that good of notes lol.
Yeah he plays the game to shut off his brain and goes along for the ride, he is a really awesome player, but he and his character aren’t the type to work through the story and plot like this. Beau and Marisha are, simple as that XD
@@aliatheli I think it's great that even though each of the players is so different in what they enjoy / how they play yet they can still all come together and have a great time. The way you described the differences here was very good.
@@forshor1998 exactly! Travis does pay attention enough and interacts with the story (just like everyone at the table does) but like I said, he enjoys it in a different way, and that is what makes this group so great. If we had a bunch of Marisha- Notetakers it would likely be a vastly different campaign.
Better yet, they ask "Where did we go for lunch?" And no one remembers. They take it too far and start looking into their patterns and asking restaurants where they were. Suddenly a whole conspiracy slowly starts to crack open
Yeah and now people are complaining that her Cobalt Soul Investigation based character pieced together a storyline from plotpoints they encountered over the last couple weeks, because it "spoiled" it for the other characters.
@@sonofaquiche6717 You can please all of the people some of the time..... or my own personal line "My mind is already made up, do not try to change it with the truth!"
@@sonofaquiche6717 people will always complain in the end, those people who keep complaining about such trivial things can only be called idiots and should not be part of the CR community
STRONG Luis from ant man energy. "SO I know this guy who used to be someone else who used to work for you as part of a group of tomb raiders who stole a book from you which we think contained information about a flying city that we think chased a god out of the astral plane and onto this island where we held a festival for an archfey pretending to be a different god."
Gotta admit. Never thought Marisha would make a real life History check before our eyes, but this is what it looks like. Making that stat look good. I think she's amazingly found a bunch of dots, and only a few of her conclusions make sense, but the ones that do... matt's sweating. That 2 year thing was big. I can't wait to see how much of this turns out to be true. Even more, how much any of it proves to be useful to know at all :D I hope Matt lets her make a check at the table soon, I mean, that says history check with advantage for good roleplay if I ever saw one.
@@Spaceman2921 While that's probably the OG for it. it's been a few years since i watched oceans. for sure it's become more popular and way more connected to Ant Man. and the Man, the Myth, the Legend...Luis. ua-cam.com/video/p-r3mhlIJi0/v-deo.html
This was really well edited. You didn't just do a highlight, you went the extra mile collecting all the "flashbacks" and setting a tone, music was a great and the grey scaling was an excellent touch. I really enjoyed this, nice job piecing it all together!
Almost like delivery is key to catching the attention of the listener, who else uses good delivery to immerse his players in a world where nearly every npc met dumps exposition in some way? Hmm lol would certainly be a good dm if they exist..seriously tho idk why ppl think this is big brain of Marisha its just maybe the first case of her paying attention lol
Normally when this happens at a regular dnd table, one person is going off and the rest of the table is skeptical at the very least, and usually just full on contrarian. This table? Big respect to Marishas note taking. Also big props to the person who edited this video together.
Marisha is the absolute best, this is some impressive shit yo. Beau is perfect for the way Marisha plays DnD. Her notetaking is so impressive and detailed it's awesome
...it takes place in a vacuum world where nearly every npc encountered is dumping exposition or hints in some way or another towards the plot and the story is on rails lol would be like saying the student is a genius for copying what the teacher wrote on the board.
@@cookiescrazy494 yah totally butt hurt just deconstructing your stupid praise lol marisha is a moron, im sure you think college students are brilliant for copying notes too
I come back to watch this video sometimes because it's one of the best critical role clips I've ever seen. The editing is glorious, Marisha's Jimmy Neutron brain blast is impressive as hell, and I'm blown away by Matt's ability to maintain such long-term narrative consistency that Marisha is able to do this in the first place. It's awesome.
My party did something like this a few sessions ago and I was so fucking proud of them. They figured out stuff from session 1 (and we have been playing every week for 3 years now) that connected to the BBEG’s big plan.
7:40 Corrections about Aeor spoilers aside- >teleports soul to the astral sea >body *appears dead* >body wakes up feeling *empty* >body dies >soul is called back into body >"ALL ACCORDING TO KIEKAKU"
i like where your head's at, but i think saying molly didn't have a soul would be incorrect. in 5e, a body that's had its soul taken would still be alive, just... inert.
@@juliangarciadif eh, that doesn't really make sense to me. consider this, though- if marisha's right about the living city being aeor, and molly's soul got transported there, he was temporarily trapped inside, as matt's described it, a magical "hivemind". maybe the reason molly woke up without an identity is beause aeor ate it?
@@emerson3323 true, if we are talking about 5e. What if the past ages of Exandria were "ruled" using different methods and editions? (This could even be a funny nod about CR starting on Pathfinder)
This has to be in the top 10 times Matt has loved his wife this much. The joy of someone you love showing this much interest and care for your passion and gift to your friends is beyond compare!
Two moments in this campaign so far have been crowning moments of awesome for the players (in extension for the characters). The cupcake and this. Very different talents, but equally brilliantly used.
Polar opposites too. Jester/Laura fooling the Hag was a flash of creativity leveraging the Hag's emotional need for sadism that she improvised on the spot. On the opposite end of the spectrum, Beau/Marisha pieced together her theory using all the bits of knowledge she had gathered over the course of two years in a careful, measured and logical manner, yet equally as brilliant as the Cupcake incident.
Beau getting that circlet that raised her intelligence gave Marisha so much RP fuel to just go nuts with her already thorough note-taking. Brilliant. (also, incredible editing. Stellar)
I cannot believe how accurate this was, having all caught up. I didn't even pay attention when this clip came up in the show cause I was like, "pfft, yeah right. Thats insane, it can't be real!" And then it WAS
I love the looks on the other players faces while this is happening, Talisan is shocked and impressed, Liam is trying to follow her line of thought as best he can and Travis is totally lost lmfao
Maybe aeor is the eyes of nine, but when it was plane shifted, only the city and the people were transported, leaving a huge mass of stone, earth, and artifacts to fall to the surface
Watching this in October of 2022, after all that we know now, it’s amazing how much lore Matt dropped about the calamity and how much Marisha has pieced things together with so so little.
i was SO happy when i found this. i saw tons and tons of people getting so up in arms about the fact that marisha had to have been metagaming, had to have gotten secrets from matt, when no, she just took notes properly and was smart enough to connect them all together! i as the viewer had connected some of the points she had myself! it's not rocket science or cheating, it's just being a damn good player
"Wish to contrust a weapon that would be capable of perhaps even killing a god" watching this back and seeing it TRULY come full circle with the current campaign is crazy
@@TheLionsage No particular requirement, tho RP would be nice. My timezone is GMT+8, but I have a very flexible schedule since COVID. :p I NEED D&D IN MY LIFE
@@hoboodinson It's a shame you're GMT +8. I'm GMT -6. It just wouldn't work out. lol. I played D&D with a couple guys from Denmark for a while and we had to start at like 8AM my time just to be able to get them in for 4-5 hours. There were days when we would play for 6 hours or more and they'd have to go because it was 3AM or so, lol.
it's west-marches but here's a server I dm on: discord.gg/AxSP2PP We have people from UTC -11 to UTC +8, so I believe you'll be able to find someone. Most games are rp heavy or incorporate rp to some extent. While there are pure hack and slash, they are rare on the server.
Hey, whereabouts are you from? I have a group of friends in Australia and we're starting a new campaign soon, if you might be interested. It's homebrew but the second campaign we've played in this world and we typically play on Sundays (We're still learning some aspects so if a bit of fumbling here and there puts you off, might not be for you idk)
Imagine being married to the DM and having Matt just sweating bullets on the car ride home
fun fact they come in separate cars right now because of social distancing, not sure why but they do
pixelrscore I think the legalities of two seperate employees of the company need to travel apart, their relationship to each other can’t factor into it. That’s what I gather at least. (Or Marisha is creative director and had been at the studio longer in the day than Matt)
But then imagine once Mat walks through door of their home Marisha is standing behind it saying "Was I right?! Did I get it??!?" with a manic look on her face
@@shangc2781 and Matt replying, I don't know, you'll see later I guess
Marisha: *goes full Sherlock on a plot*
Matt: _n e w p l o t h o o k s_
"h A n G o N i ' M a L m O s T d O n E"
*is barely halfway done*
the cry of every ADHD person ever XD
“Ma’am this is a Wendy’s drive-thru”
BRUTALITY!
Take my thumbs up
"Hang on, I'm almost done!"
HAHAHAHAHHA
A lot of people pointing out Marisha was playing a high INT and WIS character, but so few pointing out this is literally what Cobalt Soul monks are meant to do - put together all the pieces to stomp out corruption where they see it. So the haters had even less of a reason to go after her Pepe Silvia moment
Beau and Caleb's were my favorites for there worked on figuring stuff out.
I GOT BOXES FULL OF PEPE
@@deansheetsThey had buddy cop energy
critical role haters love hating on marisha for embodying her characters well, from keyleth to beau to laudna
@@Taylor-gb5gf To be fair, she often deserves some hate. Not always, not near as severe as she gets, but some minor hate is definitely deserved often enough.
The part where Ashley names different members of the tomb takers but it's just pictures of Matt was genius.
its not just matt, it's matt in different colored vests.
@@tomaszskowronski1406 woah woah woah... two of them were the same vest.
@@lvlHivemaybe two of them are TWINS! ITS VEX AND VAX!
... I may have gone too far.
@@StormageddonTMS of course its been in front of us this whole time! Matt, and Matthew, Mercers.
@@lvlHive don’t forget Mccree
I love seeing that she’s taking notes every time there’s a flashback
What if we used 100% of our brain?
Marisha:
We get close to exploding, apparently.
We scatter across the rocks
Beau is letting her pull off the big brain moves she couldn't with Keyleth. Happy for her
Great job with the video. The fact that some "fans" were mad at Marisha for this is mind boggling to me. She plays a high INT, high WIS character who pieced together a crapload of plot threads that the DM intentionally put out there for the players to see, it's simply fantastic.
How many games have we all DM'd where we practically have to hit our players over the head with clues to get them to move to the next part of the game because they're barely paying attention, so massive kudos to Marisha for being that engaged in the game. Matt must have been super happy as well to know that all he had done had made sense six layers below the surface yet someone could put it together if they tried.
Yeah, I would kill for a player like Marisha. Or players like any of the whole cast, really.
Wait, people got mad over this? I know a certain group of people gets mad at Marisha for litterally every single thing she does, but what's their reasoning for this? "Oh, she spoiled everything for the rest of the group by giving away the plot" or some nonsense like that, I'm guessing?
@@thegreenassassin553 Yes, there's no doubt that a portion (maybe even the majority) of the people who were angry was just because it was Marisha, but even the next day when some people not related to CR at all asked about it on twitter there was definitely some "players like that ruins the fun for everyone" faux-anger was out there on Twitter.
But if social media has taught us anything it's that no matter what happens in the world, there are always some people out there who will not only dislike it, but will also be disproportionately angry about it too.
@@andrewshandle Eh, from my experience with the CR community, it's definitely not a majority.
Those people are very loud, sure, and it's a larger group than I'd likes, but they're still in the minority in the end. Also, what do you expect? That players are *not* gonna try and solve a mystery that's presented before them? That's like, the whole point of a mystery. If I'd be the DM in such a scenario, I'd be slightly disappointed that you'd miss out on that "big reveal" moment (and even then, only to a degree), sure, but that instantly gets overshadowed by seeing how excited your players get about correctly solving a mystery you set up. Either way, my point being, those people are dumb.
@@thegreenassassin553 Why do people dislike Marisha? She's wonderful.
I love that Marisha always tries to avoid asking the DM "Do I know this?" and instead tries to put things together herself. That's a great thing to do as a player.
She doesn't ask the DM much other than to argue his calls lol
Matt rarely gives them information they already should know unless it's super obvious. There's been many times that the players go back through their notes. It encourages them to keep notes in the first place. While the players would be perfectly justified to ask the DM since (or if) their character would know it, the players actually knowing these things keeps the story flowing and interesting and immensely helps the players keep interest in the game.
@@bowserbrowser6559 ikr? She is such a good player she doesn't need to engage with the DM directly and can piece it together with her incredible intelligence.
@@fellith4295 thank you
@@OneWolfPup ✌🏻
7:30
Caleb: but what if-
Beau: HANG ON IM ALMOST DONE
I lost it so hard
My favorite edit in this! I had to back up to savor it again.
"But she was, in fact, not done at all".
@@dasnurk The fact that you have radiated raw Morgan Freeman through nothing but word choice is flabbergasting
@@TheDangerNoodle lmfao
i can imagine Beau throwing a book at him
I love this, not just because it highlights marisha's crazy attention to detail, but it also shows how beau is so well suited to what marisha brings to the table. definitely going to keep this in mind the next time I make a character!
ALSO THE MUSIC IN THIS VID IS 👌
IIRC Marisha did mention in the recent Talks that she wanted Beau to have that note-taking trait *because* Marisha enjoys this sort of thing. This also permits her to bring all these ideas to the table without sounding like she's metagaming
Marisha Ray was a private investigator in a former life 🕵️♀️ Like in the 20's she was totally one of those nior detectives that said shit like "Be seeing you around dollface" while putting on a badass trench coat and fedora while smoking a cigar and drinking whiskey.
Is this a joke? Is this the usual upside-down SJW fantasy world? Marisha is an airhead with absolutely no attention to anything, let alone details.
@@staceygram5555 why are you replying to every comment??? Are you that obsessed with a woman on the internet? Go outside
Man, this new Marisha subclass is wild!
i cast manic speculation at fifth level
@@jesterssketchbook _a spectral Charlie Day comes forth with a board filled with potential suspects and clues, string connecting each piece together. His hair is messed up and his clothes wrinkled; his tired eyes fueled with caffeine and possibly 5-Hour Energy._
@@jesterssketchbook
that spell has the prerequisite of casting the spell “Expert Note taking” at 8th level and waiting 2 years
@@stahpg5430 I like to think the "expert note taking" spell is a long-play version of Keen Mind
I read that in Henry Crabgrass's voice for some reason skssksksk
I want this animated. With Beau sticking notes to a board with Jester sketches of the people in question.
Do it 😊
There is hope. The Mighty Nein animated series might deliver.
Someone do this please, this looks adorable with Jester tongue out rushing to draw from memory all the people Beau mentions
They better animate this part
DO IT!! i promise so many people will subscribe if you do i don't care if this was 3 years ago
I like to imagine Marisha waited two entire campaigns to unleash this facet of her true self to everyone
Well keyleth is the opposite of beau. While keyleth is naive and acts rash, beau is a strategist and think things through to better understand the situation.
she was also the one who put together thatthe woman without the hand was Ripley in the cell! She was always very good at this but Beau finally gave her a chance to amp it up in-character.
In the first campaign I wasn’t a massive fan of Keyleth, and that being my first experience of Marisha Ray I thought that I didn’t really like her… come campaign 2 and Beau is crazy strategic and full of incredible plans and just an absolute badass, which retroactively made me love how well she acted Keyleth in the first campaign purely by the wild juxtaposition between these two characters. Truly incredible
@@_____2219 ik I'm very late but still: I like how you still see parts of this side in Keyleth though, like how in the 'tree moment' with the Briarwoods, you see her frantically flipping through her notes and being the first to express a recognition of what was happening
man i read a comment about how matt tends to hide when hes about to break his poker face by drinking from his mug, and man is he hydrated during this LOL. You can really see the mix of both love and fear in his eyes seeing marisha just break through the and explain everything like an inverse kool-aid man
The best thing is that Matt recently uploaded his marriage proposal to his UA-cam channel, and it turns out he did it via putting himself and Marisha in a Lovecraftian Escape Puzzle Room. That made all of this about Marisha make SO MUCH MORE SENSE.
Marisha is a lore goblin and a puzzler for sure
I can't get over how 1. Marisha is SO DANG Smart 2. How the music stops during comedic times like name mess-ups 3. Taliesins' reactions
And don't forget the Yasha bit lol
Boy! I didn't remember this being SO accurate!
Talesin's reactions were specially interesting bc he knew absolutely zero of that.
(sorry im a bit 2 years late. I've watched the Mighty Nein and ended up never watching this vid.)
@@Ribula1Same, don't worry about it ^^
(But I'm catching up with Bells Hells :D)
When your players can predict what's coming next.
Your campaign's not bad.
It's Realistic.
"If your players can see the plot twist coming it's not because you're a bad DM, it means _they get it."_
- misquoting the OSP video on Plot Twists
As a Dm I can confirm. I absolutely LOVE it when my players figure out what is coming. I will be hinting at it from the start and when they put the puzzle together it shows me not only that they are invested, bus also that the story makes sense. And I love it!
It's the difference between a Scooby Doo mystery and a real one. Instead of having the twist come out of nowhere, there's always a chance you could put it together yourself.
My d&d group did this recently with conspiracy theorizing that this nobleman politician we hated was also an eladrin who served the Unseelie Court's seasons. We wound up being right and lost our minds at the reveal. Our DM was worried it being "obvious" would ruin it, but is putting the prices together only made it more rewarding.
Jonny Sims, the man who's writing The Magnus Archives podcast, said the same thing. Some people actually guessed the main twist and when he was asked about it in a later Q&A, he said you know you're doing a plot set up right when most people guess maybe 75% of it, some people guess all of it, and a few people get it totally wrong.
This isn't just proficiency. This is _expertise._
This isn’t just expertise, this is reliable talent
This is literally a feat!
you thought orym with alert + perception skill expert was busted? wait till you see marishas loadout
@@Wendeta-hq2cp Marisha took Keen Mind IRL
@@birubu
For real!
Marisha is wicked smart. This clip could only be improved by slowly zooming in on Taliesin's face while she is talking.
My boy's wicked smart but my girl's wicked smarter
Go Sox!
Tales in said he was making wacky faces to fuck with Travis tho lol
@@Donovarkhallumhonestly? That makes it even funnier to me.
Matt and Tal sweating actual bullets
Watching Talison the whole time loving how he keeps trying not to react but looking to Matt!
The cocktail of love, awe, and fear in Matt’s eyes is AMAZING.
They deffo boinked harder than ever that night.
Get you someone who looks at you the way Matt looks at Marissa: love, awe, and most importantly FEAR.....I mean respect.
holy shit man, that's a lot of sifting through vods
well done
is he okay? like that must have took a long time? How's your sanity?
@@rafaelfreire3490well it only took me 48 hours in Premiere nothing major.
@@hoboodinson
boy you dont give yourself enough credit
you gotta look that shit up
lucky flando marks stuff right?
@@SPACEHARICE this community helps each other in strange and wonderful ways, friend
@@hoboodinson MAD RESPECT
*CAMPAIGN 3 SPOILERS*
This only got better when we saw how freaked out everyone got about Marisha not being there with her notes
C3 is legitimately worse for not having a notetaker, no one seems to care
@@antiphon000 I just started that campaign. I hope it got better.
Yo look at Taliesin's face during this. He looks both impressed and panicked that Marisha is putting it all together.
He talked about this moment in talks machina
He basically said he vaguelly knew about 20% of what marisha said, but he was making all those faces because he was messing with travis
@@imkabochan
As the true God of mischief would
Does Tal even know? I thought he just made a character with amnesia and made up the tattoos and the bleeding to go with the blood hunter thing. I thought he gave Matt free reign to do his back story.
timestamp?
She didn't put anything together. She was just stating the painfully obvious.
The breaking up of Marisha’s ranting with things like “HANG ON IM ALMOST DONE!” And “5 Years. 5 + 4 is 9. 9 eyes. But 2 years, 9 - 2 is 7, like the 7 members if our crew… we *ARE* AEOR!?” Is never going to be unfunny
Sam really is a genius of comedic timing. He can shut up for hours in tense combat or serious roleplay, but if he feels like it gets too heavy or too boring, he just blurts out a genius one-liner as punctiuation. He plays his meta role of comedic relief to perfection.
the marisha voice-over w tal and matt talking and the music cuts read like an episode of drunk history its so good
13:55 is a very drunk history moment
“Which isn’t far from Shottengrad... Shattengrod? S H A T T E N G R A D”
The way they say it constantly nags me. The name comes from "Schatten", the german word for shadow -Why there's a "c" missing I do not know.- but they prononce it like "Schaden" which is "harm" or "damage" in german.
The nail in the coffin was that Liam instructed her to say it like that.
@@voidjockey82 probably on purpose lol
@@voidjockey82 it's probably a double-entendre
Honesty every DM should pray to have players like Marisha. That kind of passion and note taking is awesome.
@Aidan Hall Dude, I don't get it either, it baffles me to no end. Marisha is my fav of the cast (love all the cast obviously) and shit like this is why...
@Aidan Hall I'm gonna go ahead and admit that for like the first twenty episodes I REALLY hated her character, but as episodes have progressed she has easily slid into my top four favorite characters out of both campaigns. I feel that the "bro I'm a teen rebel bro fuck authority bro" facade that she puts up for the first twenty or so episodes really puts people off. Some of those people, unfortunately, obviously don't have enough mental acuity to see beyond their initial knee-jerk reaction to a character. Which sucks, because she really grew into an amazing character.
@@ZazzilasArden agreed. It's the same reason why Ebenezer Scrooge is most well known for hating Christmas
I used to run a game for a mixture of friends and work colleagues. One of them had NEVER played an RPG before and found videogames incredibly stressful, she was literally the best detective in the whole group. Ironically, also playing a Monk.
@Aidan Hall true, but I often find that it also depends on how the player weaves that element of management into their character. Ie: Don't just let it be the player that spends all that time micromanaging materials and spells, let it be the character. The way Liam plays Caleb is a good example to me.
Beau, talking to Yasha: "That's Yasha's idea. It's totally brilliant."
Beau, talking to everyone else: "I'm not done yet!"
Man, the whole Mighty Nein name was just a joke in the beginning, but now with all the Nine symbolism, it's becoming pretty fitting for this campaign.
Its kinda creepy.
i wonder how much was planned and how much was matt playing into it
There's a lot of back and forth DMing a campaign where you just sit back, listen to your players jabber on...and steal their ideas/thoughts/fears/wants to implant into the campaign later on. And the M9 was a play on words...Nein means "no" so...they're the Mighty No...as in the Mighty...not. LOL
ah we have the Nine Members of the Mighty Nine.
You bet Matt saw all the coincidental 9’s, then when they named themselves the Mighty Nein, he definitely started making the 9 symbolism more of a thing.
Matt smiling and looking impressed while quietly rewriting the campaign behind the screen.
Idk, matt has said that it is more rewarding for the players and viewers and better story telling to actually have the clues lead up to a point instead of just throwing everything out just because someone figured it out. But im sure he will put a twist to it that they didnt see coming
I mean who wouldn’t be impressed by their wife basically becoming a detective?
@@nonblondified Yeah, GRRM once said it best; If you write a crime thriller and make the butler the killer, with all the clues leading to the Butler, but then change it to the Gardener because someone figured it out beforehand, that reveal and change will be extremely cheap.
@@Hunterfalke that was more well put than I managed and what Matt was referring to, thank you!
no, clues hidden around, someone figures out, means it is so coherent and well made story that you can hear it out without it explicitly being told, just subtly hinted at. If you then just change it at the last minute just to force out "Suprise" You are a shitty writer. No offence. Game of thrones last season if you want a great example of this
Of course you could be joking making me just being r/woosh But to what level or extent or even if, Who the hell knows?
I aspire to be the kind of player that Marisha is.
People disrespect her for being somewhat of an airhead in the moment! Little do they know is that she's always thinking outside of the game, connecting the dots. She is what I would call a "lucid thinker", someone who delves deeper than the rest, taking notes to solidify her string of thoughts into a cohesive conclusion. Sometimes she overthinks things and comes out as the dumb one, but really she is a slow, methodical thinker who may get overloaded with too many possibilities and outcomes unless she splurges those thoughts onto paper. While others may be quick to think/act like a grasshopper, Marisha does the thinking in retrospect.
That is very insightful. As a person on the Autism spectrum I see similar things portrayed in Marisha. It's true that many people on the spectrum think outside the box, in my case it's because all of the things on the box are confusing. It's just a guess but I think that Marisha may be on the spectrum, which helps her follow these threads of plot that pass the other players by.
I aspire to be DM so good that my game allows players to be like Marisha. Or at least have a DM like that so I can be that player :D
@@wanabeguitarguy The majority of humanity is on the spectrum, so that's not much of a guess.
@@benjoe1993 A common theme you see from a lot of DMs is basically cultivating the table and game you want by being communicative with your players. Sometime what you want to do and what your players want doesnt match up. It isnt bad or a reflection of character. That's why it can take 10+ years to get a super solid group. (And then they have kids lol)
I really enjoy this clip. All of the flashbacks and Marisha looking like a freak.
I'm the note taker in my group and I have done this. Once I stopped midsentence because I had an epiphany about all the blood magic that was happening in our campaign.
I do this but in the shower.
I run shit through my head and shower thoughts help me piece the puzzle together.
I used to take amazing notes plus I remember things very well (I used to have a study group in college and when someone missed a lecture I would recount the important parts and the others would be like omg that is like word for word, and I'd be like well that's what was said so that's how I remember it, I didn't know that was unusual, but I do not have photographic memory, I forget things all the time). Anyway our group voted to move the games from noon to 9 am, now I try to stay awake and my notes are like a name and a species and I keep looking at them like huh?
I'm the galliard and chronist. It's fun, but I have trouble when recounting it. I slip into details, that shouldn't be in summaries. And tipps here?
But overall the view and ability to puzzle with the DMs stuff is awesome.
Same! It's such a great feeling and this is pretty much exactly what happens when you lay it all out for the party lmao
@@MommyOfZoeAndLiam A 9 am campaign is just evil. We have someone who lives in England in our campaign and we routinely keep him up till like 5 am - I have no idea how he does it.
More than that, she's incredibly intelligent and creative. She wouldn't be able to make these connections otherwise
You don't have to be creative to follow the narrative that Matt laid out, just intelligent enough to pay attention to the important things and to put the puzzle together only missing a few obvious pieces. I'll admit, the cast has a rougher time as a whole due to the multitasking involved in playing the game, acting in character, and producing a show, but that doesn't make the plot that much harder to follow. I would just say that Marisha probably puts forth the most effort in note taking and thinking about the story in the off time than the rest of the cast, or maybe that she's just the first one to lay out her theory wholly. Her investment makes a normal amount of sense when you consider that she's married to the worldbuilder and is always engaged. That's all, nothing any more stellar about this than what's come to be expected.
@@eliezeririzarry247 Hey.......can you not rain on someone's parade and just let this person admire Marisha without making a comment that undermines them? Jesus
@@QueenPandanimaniac Nah I don't respect the slide into hyperbolic language that is so common now. Michael Jordan achieved greatness; not every little accomplishment should receive the same word for praise, for example
@@eliezeririzarry247 Who hurt you lmao
Just don't yuck someone's yum! It's that easy! Don't go out of your way to invalidate someone's praise, as hyperbolic as it may be! It literally hurts you in NO way!
@@QueenPandanimaniac Hey fair enough. To me its a big enough deal to spend a minute correcting somebody who just uses any word they want without putting critical thought behind it, but I'm not going to change the world doing it, either. If a couple of people read this, pissed or not, and start thinking a bit more before they speak, well shit they're doing that much better. You sound like a positive person though and I don't want to drag this on, so thanks I guess for at least speaking your mind. Cheers Maleny
I had one of my players do this.
Meanwhile I was sitting there taking notes, trying to keep up the illusion that I plan anything.
iam not a DM, but it must be kinda great when your players unknowingly write parts of the story for you.
I truly believe all the best DMs steal little bits from things players speculate. It makes it more fun when it seems like they have been leaving breadcrumbs the whole time.
ive not really had the oppourtunity to do much of this, but i did have a party who started checking a room for traps, so i just quickly went "mm, yes, a trap, but you rolled crap so im not going to tell you about it" and just hit them with a fireball landmine when they thought they were safe. there werent going to be any traps until you reminded me that traps are cool
DM: "That's exactly what I planned"
Life: "Roll for Deception"
@@MommyOfZoeAndLiam Yeah I mean, Matt even said (at the end of campaign wrap-up I believe) that he had already planned some kind of enemy with the eyes of nine before Tal even had said his character had 9 eye tattoos, so he just took that and wove it together, because it was coincidentally so perfect. I can barely read through half the "novels" of backstory that a few of my players give me but I really try to make an effort so that I can include it in the campaign in order to reward their participation in the game. Most of my players just play for the escapism once a week, which is fine, but it really makes all the preparation you do as a DM feel like a waste. So I like to give little nuggets for the players that put in more effort.
This is so insanely impressive. Like not even just Marisha's ability to take notes and connect dots, I'm talking about this video and the RECEIPTS. I'm super late to this party but dang homie, well done
yo! it's never late to make my day! glad you enjoyed it!
Matt, in a state of evenly mixed abject panic and deep admiration for the incredibly intelligent person with whom he shares his life: Maybe... Aeor WAS the friends we made along the way?
Caleb: “A question-“
Beau: “HANG ON DIRT WIZARD, IM ALMOST DONE!”
Yasha: “Question-“
Beau: “Yes what is it love of my life beautiful baby shining brighter than anything else in Exandria you hunk of adorable muscle that smells like a sexy crayon?”
Talesin's face the entire time. It's just like Travis throwing in that his character had some sailing experience, then it turns out to be a major plot line.
Marisha: *takes notes and recalls events almost perfectly*
Also Marisha: I will talk to that person that is not there anymore
Welcome to Critical Role, where we fail to success every day
Imagine Matt just tearing up his notes and saying: "Fine babe, you got it, YOU GOT IT OK!?"
I just want to imagine him with a checklist behind his dm screen checking off each plot point she is hitting and looking more and more disappointed and so proud of his wife
I don't think he was tearing them up, I think he was "borrowing" her notes and saying "this is better than what I wrote, STOLEN!"
With the benefit of hindsight and how close to being right she was, I would be so proud if that was in his position.
Look at Matt's poker face while they are guessing EXACT details of his lore XD Watching this after the end of the campaign is a whole new and amazing experience!
Are they guessing the exact detail of his lore or is he quietly rewriting the lore to match their theories? Both would be dope.
I remember Marisha getting SO MUCH SHIT in the comments while she was literally laying out the entire plot Matt has written behind the screen
Edit - Laura also throwing the last piece of the city splitting in there, can’t be overlooked
It's literally the entire plot. The Astral sea not the abyss but close enough
I still don't get why people got mad. Like, people! The other PLAYERS were fine with it. Liam said "We're here for it!"
They love her, enjoy playing with her, and were there for her red string moment! It was EPIC!
Monk: way of the note taking
I love how Yasha presents one new idea and couple names and Beau just immediately goes “this whole rambling and 90% accurate theory brought to you by Yasha Nydoorin&beau but mostly yasha. Girl was so down bad
Least desperate lesbian lmao
2 years of notes. Like holy hell.
I'm surprised if half of my notes make it 6 months
Malice-mar = Molaesmyr.
The Abyss = The Astral Sea.
molaesmyr = mollymog
Isn't it malaismere?
@@amalofoto It's molaesmyr
@@amalofoto criticalrole.fandom.com/wiki/Molaesmyr?mobile-app=false
@@morganmae8396 thank you!
What I picture whenever I hear that music after the MCU:
The Mighty Nein: "Just focus on facts. Go."
Luis: "Yo, that's complicated because I was kickin' it at the Cobalt Reserve, right..."
🤣🤣🤣
Imagine if there was like a live action movie of the Mighty Nine, and they had an info dealer, but it was played by the actor who played Luis.
Imagine the Mighty Nein’s story is just… Luis in Wildemount explaining this to children and adults.
she’s like an anti-travis
I don’t really watch critical role could you explain what you mean by this?
@@invisiblog as smart as Travis is, he tends to take plot points and what people say at face value often while in the game. Also I don't think he takes that good of notes lol.
Yeah he plays the game to shut off his brain and goes along for the ride, he is a really awesome player, but he and his character aren’t the type to work through the story and plot like this. Beau and Marisha are, simple as that XD
@@aliatheli I think it's great that even though each of the players is so different in what they enjoy / how they play yet they can still all come together and have a great time.
The way you described the differences here was very good.
@@forshor1998 exactly! Travis does pay attention enough and interacts with the story (just like everyone at the table does) but like I said, he enjoys it in a different way, and that is what makes this group so great. If we had a bunch of Marisha- Notetakers it would likely be a vastly different campaign.
Matt sipping his drink casually whilst not taking his eyes off Marisha this whole time is hilarious to me haha. "yeah nbd I'm just a little parched"
Imagining a skit of a group of detective friends having a dramatic montage trying to answer the question of 'where should we go for lunch'
Better yet, they ask "Where did we go for lunch?" And no one remembers. They take it too far and start looking into their patterns and asking restaurants where they were. Suddenly a whole conspiracy slowly starts to crack open
@@ihavekalashnikovyoudomath9275 I'd watch both of these
Extreme well put together edit.
For all those who said in campaign one "Marisha is dumb".... Take this!
Yeah and now people are complaining that her Cobalt Soul Investigation based character pieced together a storyline from plotpoints they encountered over the last couple weeks, because it "spoiled" it for the other characters.
@@sonofaquiche6717 You can please all of the people some of the time..... or my own personal line "My mind is already made up, do not try to change it with the truth!"
She is dumb, in that low Wisdom, high Intelligence sense
@@sonofaquiche6717 people will always complain
in the end, those people who keep complaining about such trivial things can only be called idiots and should not be part of the CR community
*Flashbacks to the cliff dive*
STRONG Luis from ant man energy.
"SO I know this guy who used to be someone else who used to work for you as part of a group of tomb raiders who stole a book from you which we think contained information about a flying city that we think chased a god out of the astral plane and onto this island where we held a festival for an archfey pretending to be a different god."
This edit is *chefs kiss*
When Marisha was transposed on top of Matt’s spot I laughed so hard
Gotta admit.
Never thought Marisha would make a real life History check before our eyes, but this is what it looks like. Making that stat look good.
I think she's amazingly found a bunch of dots, and only a few of her conclusions make sense, but the ones that do... matt's sweating. That 2 year thing was big. I can't wait to see how much of this turns out to be true.
Even more, how much any of it proves to be useful to know at all :D
I hope Matt lets her make a check at the table soon, I mean, that says history check with advantage for good roleplay if I ever saw one.
So, how does it feel now that it's over and done?
I love when Yasha is naming the people and its all Matt xD
I feel like robbing a casino, or three in one night after this montage and music
Three in one night, eh? Remember to stay hydrated!
@@GrassPokeKing K I N K Y
you son of a bitch im in
Persona 5 should cover you for a spell
Matt’s gaze lingering on Laura after she mentioned the possibility of the city splitting was HILARIOUS omg
This is why as a dm I love my note takers, what’s the point in having mystery’s without someone who knows what’s happening
My note taker takes better notes than me when I run lol
Exposition Bongo's are probably the greatest thing the Marvel universe ever created.
It's more of an Oceans 11 thing isn't it?
Exposition Bongo's... I'll never refer to it in any other way than that ever again.
@@Spaceman2921 While that's probably the OG for it. it's been a few years since i watched oceans.
for sure it's become more popular and way more connected to Ant Man. and the Man, the Myth, the Legend...Luis.
ua-cam.com/video/p-r3mhlIJi0/v-deo.html
Mission Impossible, kittens. Also, lots of 1970’s procedurals.
Expositor bongos, in this case.
DID ANYONE ELSE JUST NOW NOTICE MATT SAY “the beating heart of the city” BEATING HEART ??? AHHH
Ahhhh
The permaa..... THE hand.... Hallas
The Purma heart was apart of the city
And it spit of in the astrel sea
Everyone kept cracking jokes but I was screaming cause I was like "yeah but what if she's right" and look at us now.
This was brilliant all the way through. But the hard cut to "Yasha, I'm flying." did me in.
Edited like a whole CSI type of episode damm
This was really well edited. You didn't just do a highlight, you went the extra mile collecting all the "flashbacks" and setting a tone, music was a great and the grey scaling was an excellent touch. I really enjoyed this, nice job piecing it all together!
Ngl the music somehow made me understand this ramble a lot better,
Fast bongo make brain go fast
@@Wingingit.us15 sometimes your brain needs the mood to be set
Almost like delivery is key to catching the attention of the listener, who else uses good delivery to immerse his players in a world where nearly every npc met dumps exposition in some way? Hmm lol would certainly be a good dm if they exist..seriously tho idk why ppl think this is big brain of Marisha its just maybe the first case of her paying attention lol
And two years later, Marisha is out of the room for the first time ever, and everyone panics 😅
10:43
Matt: ‘Aeor was the friends we made along the way’
Also Matt: Took that statement and made an epic finale
"Just wanna give credits where credits due" - que to Beau and Yasha being so fucking gay for each other
Normally when this happens at a regular dnd table, one person is going off and the rest of the table is skeptical at the very least, and usually just full on contrarian. This table? Big respect to Marishas note taking.
Also big props to the person who edited this video together.
Marisha is the absolute best, this is some impressive shit yo. Beau is perfect for the way Marisha plays DnD. Her notetaking is so impressive and detailed it's awesome
...it takes place in a vacuum world where nearly every npc encountered is dumping exposition or hints in some way or another towards the plot and the story is on rails lol would be like saying the student is a genius for copying what the teacher wrote on the board.
@@bowserbrowser6559 Wow, someone is butthurt, get well soon
@@cookiescrazy494 yah totally butt hurt just deconstructing your stupid praise lol marisha is a moron, im sure you think college students are brilliant for copying notes too
Taliesin's look at Marisha this entire time was so entertaining, he was thinking "shit, she's actually putting everything together!"
I come back to watch this video sometimes because it's one of the best critical role clips I've ever seen. The editing is glorious, Marisha's Jimmy Neutron brain blast is impressive as hell, and I'm blown away by Matt's ability to maintain such long-term narrative consistency that Marisha is able to do this in the first place. It's awesome.
The music makes me picture beau in a 1920s detective outfit
Look at Matt trying to hide how much he adores Marisha here. As a DM, having a player pay this amount of attention is the best possible feeling.
i have to admit i must have failed a WIS save or something, because i compulsively danced through this entire video. straight vibin.
I love this and I love Marisha. Goddamn.
My party did something like this a few sessions ago and I was so fucking proud of them. They figured out stuff from session 1 (and we have been playing every week for 3 years now) that connected to the BBEG’s big plan.
Make a video my dude
Tell me the story, what diabolical masteminded operations did they uncover?
I realize three years of info is hard to summarize but can you at least tell us the session 1 shit?
7:40 Corrections about Aeor spoilers aside-
>teleports soul to the astral sea
>body *appears dead*
>body wakes up feeling *empty*
>body dies
>soul is called back into body
>"ALL ACCORDING TO KIEKAKU"
I really like this
i like where your head's at, but i think saying molly didn't have a soul would be incorrect. in 5e, a body that's had its soul taken would still be alive, just... inert.
@@emerson3323 a new soul maybe, like a birth?
@@juliangarciadif eh, that doesn't really make sense to me. consider this, though- if marisha's right about the living city being aeor, and molly's soul got transported there, he was temporarily trapped inside, as matt's described it, a magical "hivemind". maybe the reason molly woke up without an identity is beause aeor ate it?
@@emerson3323 true, if we are talking about 5e. What if the past ages of Exandria were "ruled" using different methods and editions? (This could even be a funny nod about CR starting on Pathfinder)
Jfc, that “Yasha, I’m flying!” clip at 13:47 has me on the floor coughing. Well played.
This has to be in the top 10 times Matt has loved his wife this much.
The joy of someone you love showing this much interest and care for your passion and gift to your friends is beyond compare!
Two moments in this campaign so far have been crowning moments of awesome for the players (in extension for the characters). The cupcake and this. Very different talents, but equally brilliantly used.
Polar opposites too. Jester/Laura fooling the Hag was a flash of creativity leveraging the Hag's emotional need for sadism that she improvised on the spot. On the opposite end of the spectrum, Beau/Marisha pieced together her theory using all the bits of knowledge she had gathered over the course of two years in a careful, measured and logical manner, yet equally as brilliant as the Cupcake incident.
Beau getting that circlet that raised her intelligence gave Marisha so much RP fuel to just go nuts with her already thorough note-taking. Brilliant.
(also, incredible editing. Stellar)
Laura at 12:00 is SPOT on - look at how Matt has to school his features. Love that for her
I cannot believe how accurate this was, having all caught up. I didn't even pay attention when this clip came up in the show cause I was like, "pfft, yeah right. Thats insane, it can't be real!" And then it WAS
I love the looks on the other players faces while this is happening, Talisan is shocked and impressed, Liam is trying to follow her line of thought as best he can and Travis is totally lost lmfao
The conspiracy bongos going off every time she gets back into the theorizing really do not stop being a perfect bit
Conspiracy bongos 😂💙
This is one of my favorite crit role clips. Whenever Marisha mentions any part of her note taking methods I immediately adopt it.
thanks! I did a new one in the style of this one too!
I do color coding now bc of this video. I want this minute
@@ferrous719 wait- wut? You mean my video inspired you?
If I die, I want Marisha to solve my case.
Every few months, I come back to this because Marisha figuring it all out blows my mind, and the editing on this video is just flawless.
SPOILERS:
The best part is that everything they all said was true.
Most of it.
I love how the music stops/starts up again whenever she goes off on a tangent/resumes her train of thought
That little flash of color when marisha said “Four to five years, wow!” Killed me.
Maybe aeor is the eyes of nine, but when it was plane shifted, only the city and the people were transported, leaving a huge mass of stone, earth, and artifacts to fall to the surface
Remember!!!! All of the gods (betrayers and prime) got together to fuck Aeor over!!!!! They cursed the city and yeet it to the Astral Sea
@@juliangarciadif Well its either stop fighting for a sec or let mortals have the power to kill the embodiment of realities themselves
She has mentioned color coding and symbol coding for quick reference.
The backing music being Luis' storytelling riff from Ant-Man is just... {chef's kiss}
I KNEW I RECOGNIZED IT!!!! I’ve been racking my brain trying to figure it out!
Watching this in October of 2022, after all that we know now, it’s amazing how much lore Matt dropped about the calamity and how much Marisha has pieced things together with so so little.
i was SO happy when i found this. i saw tons and tons of people getting so up in arms about the fact that marisha had to have been metagaming, had to have gotten secrets from matt, when no, she just took notes properly and was smart enough to connect them all together! i as the viewer had connected some of the points she had myself! it's not rocket science or cheating, it's just being a damn good player
"Wish to contrust a weapon that would be capable of perhaps even killing a god" watching this back and seeing it TRULY come full circle with the current campaign is crazy
Thanks for the overwhelming love
maybe could assist but it depends on what you're looking for and what your schedule is (also timezones might be an issue I guess)
@@TheLionsage No particular requirement, tho RP would be nice. My timezone is GMT+8, but I have a very flexible schedule since COVID. :p I NEED D&D IN MY LIFE
@@hoboodinson It's a shame you're GMT +8. I'm GMT -6. It just wouldn't work out. lol.
I played D&D with a couple guys from Denmark for a while and we had to start at like 8AM my time just to be able to get them in for 4-5 hours. There were days when we would play for 6 hours or more and they'd have to go because it was 3AM or so, lol.
it's west-marches but here's a server I dm on: discord.gg/AxSP2PP
We have people from UTC -11 to UTC +8, so I believe you'll be able to find someone. Most games are rp heavy or incorporate rp to some extent. While there are pure hack and slash, they are rare on the server.
Hey, whereabouts are you from? I have a group of friends in Australia and we're starting a new campaign soon, if you might be interested. It's homebrew but the second campaign we've played in this world and we typically play on Sundays (We're still learning some aspects so if a bit of fumbling here and there puts you off, might not be for you idk)
This is criminally unseen. I love this so much