Michael is a phenomenal craftor and caster of words. Half of the message is not just in the words, but in the delivery. Substance and delivery are crucial brought together so well. Separately, I have becoming obsessed with this question of should we be changing the human condition. Transhumanist will argue the change enhances and improves the human condition. It seems that all 'great' civilisations and human projects have strived to 'perfect' the human condition and therefore the perfect human being. From judeo-abrhamic faiths and their moral virtues and guidelines (see moses commandments), to Western enlightenment values of humanism (we don't need God to be and do better, and the rise of self-help literature), to nazi Germany (eugenics and forcing a utopian vision of the perfect human being upon everyone). I believe only we can find our own salvation. The pursuit of perfecting our being is a choice and decision we must make within ourselves. Revolution never starts externally, but always from within. Then we can extrapolate from that to ask will this hurt or benefit my family, my neighbours, town, country, and the world etc...
This is a pretty level headed view I think. Good stuff I wish people would be this level headed when It comes to political things, Its so emotionally strong and knee jerk reaction, people dont really try to hear the other guys argument. I guess you know the argument on either side Is maturing when people can come down enough lol
Me encantaría que todas las entrevistas. conferencias, clases, del profesor Sandel que están en inglés las subtitularan en español; existe un número considerable de personas que no hablan inglés que están interesadas en sus enseñanzas, incluyéndome por supuesto. Gracias.
3:44 "our humanity is not under threat by science", it is under threat by the lack of it. If killing an unborn baby because of down syndrome is what technology is used for, what is humanity if not valuing human life at any stage?
I love the idea that cheating is wrong because it changes the character of the competition. If I can use technology to run the 100 meter dash, what am I really competing for? At issue is whether a human being with nothing else can go reach such speeds in such few seconds. Strap a rocket on your back, put on some wheels, and we're now in a drag race, not a foot race. Lance Armstrong was not competing at the same sport and should not get that sport's recognition.
Kindly share the link of that video. I am a fan of Sandel and I'm digging all his UA-cam videos where he talks about Justice and the moral limits of market.
Absolutely, I agree with every word. However, my concern is that nowadays Western democracies, which I deeply respect and aspire to be part of, no longer have a monopoly on high technologies, including biotechnology. I have little doubt that countries like China, Russia, or North Korea wouldn't hesitate over the moral aspects of the most outrageous experiments. Furthermore, they wouldn't hesitate to apply their knowledge against, say, the USA in the midst of democratic debates. My assumption is based on human history, literature, etc.
The problem with a Human Being is Himself....when he gives up his right to be Human then he cannot be discontent with the result that awaits Him...only at the end of his life does he realise the opportunity given to him to have been Human and the happiness he lost along the way!!!
Science is not "Here is a map of the brain and this is everything we can say about it". There is for example Psychology, that can study questions like "What do people mean when they talk about meaning?". You can study humans from an evolutionary perspective, and ask how we became what we are today. Nowadays you even can study the human mind with introspective data and nobody will cry for calling it science.
WHAT USE IS SUCH BRILLIANCE HERE WHERE IT IS ENTIRELY CLOUDED OVER WITH THIS OBCESSION OF "VALUES" , WHICH SOUNDS LIKE A DEAD END POINT OF FAILURE STULTIFYING TRUELY BETTER POSSIBILITIES THAT AREN'T REALLY EVEN RISKY THAT MUCH ?????
HOW COME YOU ARE ADVANCING SUCH A TITLE OF A SERIES ? WHERE ARE THERE ANY PERFECT HUMAN BEINGS ? HOW ABOUT A LITTLE DEBATE ON THE SERIOUS NEED FOR A MORE APPLICABLE , PURPOSEFUL . ACCURATELY & USEFULLY TIMED DEFINITION OF "MORALITY" & "VALUES" THAN WE HAVE PREVIOUSLY PSYCHIATRICALLY FROUGHT WITH ??? pww
Young children below16 and senior above65 to be vaccination. Leaving the middle age21to50 Whoare tax payers earning for donations to societies... There are questions marks.
NOW DAYS HARVARD PROFESSORS ARE DEGRADED BECAUSE THEY ARE TOTALLY POWERLESS & USELESS IN CRAFTING & SHAPING THE LAW CORRECTLY , YET THE VALUE OF THE FUTURE IS HOPE!!!! SOMEDAY THERE MAY STILL BE A FEW JOBS FEEDING FISH IN THE AQUARIUMS FOR THESE PROFS.....pww
WHAT OF THE POSSIBILITY OF HARVARD OFFERING TO TRAIN WITH WILLIAM & HARRY IN FRENCH & GOVERNMENT CONCERNING THE FUTURE ALLIANCE OF CANADA & THE USA & THE POSSIBILITIES OF WILLIAM OR HARRY RUNNING FOR LEADERSHIP SOMEDAY IN THE FUTURE????? pww
Live and let live, let parents alone, do unto others. If people want a smarter, taller, better looking , healthier child , it is none of your business to stick your nose in and spoil their dreams about their family, If you want dumb, short, ugly, sick children , be my guest, have lots of them and make your dreams come true, But you have no right to tell others what they should do, so but out.
There is no perfect human beings. God alone is perfect. And Jesus Christ was/is the only perfect human. The closest perfect humans today are those who have repented and are living for Him.
The fallen man will never figure humanity out, Jesus said to Nicodemus, ' You must be born again.' The newewal of the mind and reproducing a spiritual man with the mind of Christ instead of religion and tradition and greed to be better than they're fellow man, you will see a perfect man. Jesus Christ is the perfect one that can judge us humans and the Holy Spirit who sees through our flaws and absene behavior is able to teach us how to be perfect and Holy as God. Be ye Holy as I am Holy. We are growing from glory to glory and from strength to strength in Jesus name. To God belongs all the Glory and honour. Amen
I love and enjoy everyone of his videos... Sandel makes me think deeper about what happens in society and how we could help...
我感觉更多是让我 如何去看一件事 如何公平 以及我们作为一个平凡的如何贡献自己
Science is a process. Scientism is a belief. Sandel is an excellent speaker. Complex moral problems conveyed on layman's terms.
I bought his books recently ... highly influential person,, thank you Prof. Sandal
Thank you sandels.... Sir, you are the one of the greatest intellectual of this present world who always shatter self declaed liberal delusion.
Liberal delusion?
So glad I've watched this video.
Normally I checked the likes lol, but after I saw Sandel I opened it
Michael is a phenomenal craftor and caster of words. Half of the message is not just in the words, but in the delivery. Substance and delivery are crucial brought together so well.
Separately, I have becoming obsessed with this question of should we be changing the human condition. Transhumanist will argue the change enhances and improves the human condition.
It seems that all 'great' civilisations and human projects have strived to 'perfect' the human condition and therefore the perfect human being.
From judeo-abrhamic faiths and their moral virtues and guidelines (see moses commandments),
to Western enlightenment values of humanism (we don't need God to be and do better, and the rise of self-help literature),
to nazi Germany (eugenics and forcing a utopian vision of the perfect human being upon everyone).
I believe only we can find our own salvation. The pursuit of perfecting our being is a choice and decision we must make within ourselves.
Revolution never starts externally, but always from within.
Then we can extrapolate from that to ask will this hurt or benefit my family, my neighbours, town, country, and the world etc...
Thank you sir
This is a pretty level headed view I think. Good stuff I wish people would be this level headed when It comes to political things, Its so emotionally strong and knee jerk reaction, people dont really try to hear the other guys argument. I guess you know the argument on either side Is maturing when people can come down enough lol
Calm*
Can’t agree Professor Michael Sandel more👍
I highly recommend setting the speed of the video to 1.5x
is this a joke about enhancement or am i looking too much into your comment?
Such am important idea explained so simply
wish i could like a video more than once!
Me encantaría que todas las entrevistas. conferencias, clases, del profesor Sandel que están en inglés las subtitularan en español; existe un número considerable de personas que no hablan inglés que están interesadas en sus enseñanzas, incluyéndome por supuesto. Gracias.
I really wish this man would go testify in front of congress and educate them and make them all question things.
#Here only & only for ""Michael sandel"""
Zlato není budúcnosť 🔮
3:44 "our humanity is not under threat by science", it is under threat by the lack of it. If killing an unborn baby because of down syndrome is what technology is used for, what is humanity if not valuing human life at any stage?
I agree
I love the idea that cheating is wrong because it changes the character of the competition. If I can use technology to run the 100 meter dash, what am I really competing for? At issue is whether a human being with nothing else can go reach such speeds in such few seconds. Strap a rocket on your back, put on some wheels, and we're now in a drag race, not a foot race. Lance Armstrong was not competing at the same sport and should not get that sport's recognition.
Michael J. Sandel is a God, and he can't continue hiding his omnipotence from the public. We know.
I feel like he should talk at davos.
I mostly liked his remarks about scientism which I would call materialism or naturalism. I couldn't agree more.
Kindly share the link of that video.
I am a fan of Sandel and I'm digging all his UA-cam videos where he talks about Justice and the moral limits of market.
Odd that you would conflate scientism with naturalism. They're different things.
I strongly agree
Absolutely, I agree with every word.
However, my concern is that nowadays Western democracies, which I deeply respect and aspire to be part of, no longer have a monopoly on high technologies, including biotechnology. I have little doubt that countries like China, Russia, or North Korea wouldn't hesitate over the moral aspects of the most outrageous experiments. Furthermore, they wouldn't hesitate to apply their knowledge against, say, the USA in the midst of democratic debates. My assumption is based on human history, literature, etc.
Technology... is product, and a dissemination of 'wealth' to all who can access it (cost reduced=wealth gained).
The problem with a Human Being is Himself....when he gives up his right to be Human then he cannot be discontent with the result that awaits Him...only at the end of his life does he realise the opportunity given to him to have been Human and the happiness he lost along the way!!!
môžete od povedať na otazku z ktoré univerzity vyšlo druhá svetová vojna
Given unknown Covid-19 vaccines (compulsory 10 more brands countries for new variants, DELTA, ALPHA, BETA..... etc, etc) enhancing body immune system?
Science is not "Here is a map of the brain and this is everything we can say about it".
There is for example Psychology, that can study questions like "What do people mean when they talk about meaning?". You can study humans from an evolutionary perspective, and ask how we became what we are today. Nowadays you even can study the human mind with introspective data and nobody will cry for calling it science.
I AM LIGHT YEARS FROM IT COMPARED TO YOUR LEVEL OF SCHOLARS....
YET THERE WERE OTHER THINGS TO BE SAID..OVER THE DECADES....
WHAT USE IS SUCH BRILLIANCE HERE WHERE IT IS ENTIRELY CLOUDED OVER WITH THIS OBCESSION OF "VALUES" , WHICH SOUNDS LIKE A DEAD END POINT OF FAILURE STULTIFYING TRUELY BETTER POSSIBILITIES THAT AREN'T REALLY EVEN RISKY THAT MUCH ?????
Fully agree !!!
I hope we will demoratically decide together that it doesn't need to be decided together.
HOW COME YOU ARE ADVANCING SUCH A TITLE OF A SERIES ?
WHERE ARE THERE ANY PERFECT HUMAN BEINGS ?
HOW ABOUT A LITTLE DEBATE ON THE SERIOUS NEED FOR A MORE APPLICABLE , PURPOSEFUL . ACCURATELY & USEFULLY TIMED DEFINITION OF "MORALITY" & "VALUES" THAN WE HAVE PREVIOUSLY PSYCHIATRICALLY FROUGHT WITH ??? pww
Yeah, lets have that talk…..when you stop shouting
Then why is scientism dangerous?
Dude looks like Tywin Lannister.
Omg I was searching on my mind to find who this guy is similar with... omg! :D
Young children below16 and senior above65 to be vaccination. Leaving the middle age21to50
Whoare tax payers earning for donations to societies... There are questions marks.
NOW DAYS HARVARD PROFESSORS ARE DEGRADED BECAUSE THEY ARE TOTALLY POWERLESS & USELESS IN CRAFTING & SHAPING THE LAW CORRECTLY , YET THE VALUE OF THE FUTURE IS HOPE!!!!
SOMEDAY THERE MAY STILL BE A FEW JOBS FEEDING FISH IN THE AQUARIUMS FOR THESE PROFS.....pww
WHAT OF THE POSSIBILITY OF HARVARD OFFERING TO TRAIN WITH WILLIAM & HARRY IN FRENCH & GOVERNMENT CONCERNING THE FUTURE ALLIANCE OF CANADA & THE USA & THE POSSIBILITIES OF WILLIAM OR HARRY RUNNING FOR LEADERSHIP SOMEDAY IN THE FUTURE????? pww
Live and let live, let parents alone, do unto others.
If people want a smarter, taller, better looking , healthier child , it is none of your business to stick your nose in and spoil their dreams about their family,
If you want dumb, short, ugly, sick children , be my guest, have lots of them and make your dreams come true, But you have no right to tell others what they should do, so but out.
GOD IS OUR KNOWLEDGE..........
There is no perfect human beings. God alone is perfect. And Jesus Christ was/is the only perfect human.
The closest perfect humans today are those who have repented and are living for Him.
The fallen man will never figure humanity out, Jesus said to Nicodemus, ' You must be born again.' The newewal of the mind and reproducing a spiritual man with the mind of Christ instead of religion and tradition and greed to be better than they're fellow man, you will see a perfect man. Jesus Christ is the perfect one that can judge us humans and the Holy Spirit who sees through our flaws and absene behavior is able to teach us how to be perfect and Holy as God. Be ye Holy as I am Holy. We are growing from glory to glory and from strength to strength in Jesus name. To God belongs all the Glory and honour. Amen
You are an idiot.
@@JuanHernandez-ry9dr Religion is a cheap form of therapy and provides from relief from existential dread.
Those who repented are close to perfection only if perfection is God and close is a relationship proximity. No human is close to perfection.
Requested hellos the
You people need god the most man wow
Michael Sandel Rulez
"it's the false idea that scientism teaches that science is a god" wooooowww
That guy voted for Trump! Blaaaah.
No way! Seriously???
philosophers and psychologists need to go to jail.
okay hitler
So fucking wrong! Keep talking, just talking. Philosophy is the old science, nothing more.