‘Disorderly conduct’: Parliament erupts as Labor MPs shout ‘why’ at Opposition

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 тра 2023
  • Independent MP Allegra Spender issued a point of order on “disorderly conduct” after Labor MPs began shouting “why” in unison at the Opposition.
    Mr Albanese questioned why the Opposition opposed proposals such as the Safeguard Mechanism, National Reconstruction Fund, and the Housing Australia Future Fund.
    The Prime Minister's questions were followed by Labor MPs shouting “why”, directed towards the Opposition.
    “I don’t think this is orderly conduct for the parliament,” Ms Spender said during a point of order.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 160

  • @samueldell5428
    @samueldell5428 Рік тому +56

    What a joke. Do they answer anything! And we pay for this circus with our taxes!

    • @tony-bi1hj
      @tony-bi1hj Рік тому +10

      My sentiments exactly. They're a disgrace.

    • @yogibbear
      @yogibbear Рік тому +3

      Why? WhY! whY; y&@( ReeeeeEEEEEEEEEEEEEEeeee

    • @gingertom56
      @gingertom56 Рік тому

      Didnt you watch question time during the LNP reign Dutton never answer a question.
      Oh that rign rupert Murdoch's lackeys didnt cover it.
      You need to watch the ABC version.

  • @ivansultanoff6719
    @ivansultanoff6719 Рік тому +49

    Labor can't manage a hotdog stand at the game--nodding heads at the back😂😂

    • @richardcarey169
      @richardcarey169 Рік тому +8

      She reminds me of one of those nodding dogs

    • @infidel202
      @infidel202 Рік тому +1

      ​@@richardcarey169 recon she gets dizzy

    • @tony-bi1hj
      @tony-bi1hj Рік тому +2

      @@infidel202 l don't know about her but l get dizzy watching her. Says a lot for WA. She's a nuffy.

    • @infidel202
      @infidel202 Рік тому +2

      @@tony-bi1hj I don't think anyone knows about her other than she's a noddy

    • @tony-bi1hj
      @tony-bi1hj Рік тому

      @@infidel202 she pisses me off. Always bouncing her head around and laughing when Albo stands up to lie. I don't know how they get the job they have. She's pathetic.

  • @Swarm1968
    @Swarm1968 Рік тому +33

    Why are they so out of touch with reality.
    Why do they make a mockery of people in real financial trouble.
    Why do they think it’s funny.
    Why don’t they answer questions put to them.
    Why don’t they realise this country is in real trouble.
    Why is the government a joke on both sides.

    • @wyatthurts1729
      @wyatthurts1729 Рік тому

      These laborians are detached from reality and the prime minister claims he was raised by a single mother in a housing commission flat. A lie from the get go

    • @donotcomply665
      @donotcomply665 Рік тому

      They simply don't care. It's deliberate. There is a slow demolition of the West happening all around us and Western govts in cahoots with globalists, mega corporations etc. are responsible. Everything wrong with our countries is directly because of their actions. When people get their heads around that, they will understand why politicians do what they do

    • @nuggetella
      @nuggetella Рік тому

      It's deliberately orchestrated to derive at ruins...

    • @oldman2800
      @oldman2800 Рік тому +3

      Because almost all of them have lived from the government purse and have had no real world experience

  • @richardtravers8772
    @richardtravers8772 Рік тому +31

    Oh NO Uncle Arthur has been asked a pertinent question and in his usual I don't have a CLUE turns back to his old Opposition position of simply ignoring the Question.

  • @shellyaus
    @shellyaus Рік тому +22

    bloody school children

    • @tony-bi1hj
      @tony-bi1hj Рік тому +1

      Please don't insult the kids. They've got more brains than this lot of lunatics.

    • @srichards5042
      @srichards5042 Рік тому +5

      💯💯💯💯 - worse than kindy gardeners

    • @tony-bi1hj
      @tony-bi1hj Рік тому +3

      @@srichards5042 he wants to know Why. So do l. Why do we have to put up with this shit?

  • @daniellebcooper7160
    @daniellebcooper7160 Рік тому +24

    This is a scene more likened to a kindergarten than a countries parliament.

    • @gingertom56
      @gingertom56 Рік тому

      Done worry the LNP were the masters of kindgarden when they were in.
      Peter always reply with no then.

  • @corrinefarrell6726
    @corrinefarrell6726 Рік тому +11

    What a pathetic display of childish, unruly behaviour from Labor. Obviously can’t answer the question.

  • @philliplawson2018
    @philliplawson2018 Рік тому +4

    He’s always encouraging his group to laugh with him at the other kid ‘ Albo is nothing but weak little school yard bully “whom doesn’t consider other people mental health.

  • @Mrclinton
    @Mrclinton Рік тому +10

    That made me feel embarrassed for Australia. I’ve heard arguments between children that were more dignified than this mob 😞

  • @fionaforward3358
    @fionaforward3358 Рік тому +2

    Disgraceful behaviour from the labor party to avoid answering the question.

  • @andrewjeni5298
    @andrewjeni5298 Рік тому +7

    Is cost of living crisis a joke to the PM?

    • @gerdsfargen6687
      @gerdsfargen6687 Рік тому +2

      Apparently so. For most mindless Australians, this is the government you voted for.

  • @glenndransfield1393
    @glenndransfield1393 Рік тому +5

    The speaker plumbs new depths of the word pathetic. The labor members are acting like petulant children. This is one of the most disgusting displays from a sitting government. We have been increasingly hit by the effects of inflationary spending by this government since its election.

  • @bradleycanning2146
    @bradleycanning2146 Рік тому +4

    Look at the MP's smiling in gallery while ordinary Australians are struggling due to their absolute mismanagement

  • @patrussell8917
    @patrussell8917 Рік тому +13

    Was this rant expected to be an answer need new PM perhaps we need a new speaker and point of order call overdue Pm talking false truths aided by the useless nodding background Answer the question obviously cant as there's nothing covering it

  • @samuelwright1129
    @samuelwright1129 Рік тому +15

    This is a joke and my taxes pay for their wages. Get rid of all of them!

  • @geoffmcmahon3288
    @geoffmcmahon3288 Рік тому +2

    This is the best we can find to run the country

  • @geoffmcmahon3288
    @geoffmcmahon3288 Рік тому +9

    If Australia is to evolve as a modern productive country, we must change the way we govern ourselves

  • @ShadowMan66
    @ShadowMan66 Рік тому +5

    This is Albasleazy's idea of a nicer and more grown up parliament is it?
    *Bunch of children*
    More relevant question "Why were vaccines mandated and basically forced on people?

  • @stevensteward4637
    @stevensteward4637 Рік тому +9

    Its like a Saturday afternoon pantomime........why? Did albo not answer the question rather than just hurl insults.......why?

    • @virginiacharlotte7007
      @virginiacharlotte7007 Рік тому +1

      I suppose the answer is “it’s behind yoooou!”

    • @norrielivingstone4475
      @norrielivingstone4475 Рік тому

      ALBO DOES NOT ANSWER QUESTIONS. FOR THE LAST 12 MONTHS HE'S BEEN OVERSEAS MORE THAN IN PARLIAMENT. WHEN HE IS THERE HE IS PROTECTED BY HIS MINISTERS. ALBO IS A DISGRACE AND WE WILL FIND OUT HOW MUCH BEFORE HIS TERM IS OVER.

  • @petewest5973
    @petewest5973 Рік тому +3

    This is a disgrace in OUR Parliament House

  • @scottjohnston4392
    @scottjohnston4392 Рік тому +7

    The question was about the $275.00 that he promised before the election and we get a heap of waffle , you wouldn't get a direct answer if you asked what he had for lunch

    • @batmanlives6456
      @batmanlives6456 Рік тому

      When you privatise the electricity… this is what happens
      When you replace cheap coal power with unreliable green rubbish
      This is what happens
      WAKE-UP!!!
      Coal or Nuclear!!!

  • @kentaitchison889
    @kentaitchison889 Рік тому +5

    ALBO the grub never answers questions

  • @davidjohn6466
    @davidjohn6466 Рік тому +5

    Great & true answer Zoe Campbell, our claytons PM always answers a question with a question & never answers anything, same as his "Voice" intension, & reminds me of those little puppy dogs behind him nodding their heads,side to side !!!!

  • @johnmay4407
    @johnmay4407 Рік тому +5

    why wont albidenese just answer the question ?????

  • @Cobber2023
    @Cobber2023 Рік тому +7

    Why did AnAl claim cheaper electricity and medication??? Since Labor have been in power my medication has doubled in price I’m a pensioner. Labor have not delivered anything.

  • @MM-mk7gl
    @MM-mk7gl Рік тому +3

    Look at how the so called "leaders" of our nation conduct themselves. How embarassing.

  • @keithmitchell3282
    @keithmitchell3282 Рік тому +6

    sadly it is like watching kids at playschool

  • @robinwood590
    @robinwood590 Рік тому +6

    And albo wanta to put 2000 more if these politicians in parliament hahaha

  • @HalKW
    @HalKW Рік тому +7

    look at the labor disorderly behavior yet no one is closing the Parliament like the council in Lilydale closed the public galery ever though everyone behaved themselves. They didn't like the questions asked ...

  • @kennsharples4389
    @kennsharples4389 Рік тому +5

    Why doesn't the Prime Minister answer the question he was asked?

  • @tizianodelpopolo4985
    @tizianodelpopolo4985 Рік тому +4

    He still didn't answer a single question.

  • @MrDogsledder
    @MrDogsledder Рік тому +5

    How dare you question the dear leader, AnAl!?

  • @hadrian3487
    @hadrian3487 Рік тому +3

    Mr Speaker, you are a disgrace. You lost the house. Your out of your depth to manage the house. I can't believe you let the whole Labor party chant "WHY" like a Collingwood irate footy fans.
    So glad Dutton was cool during this. If I was the opposition leader I would of done a Al Pacino, last scene in 'Sent of a Women".

  • @jamo5468
    @jamo5468 Рік тому +3

    This is pretty pathetic

  • @geoffreyhui830
    @geoffreyhui830 Рік тому +5

    A disgraceful "answer"

  • @meredithisme3752
    @meredithisme3752 Рік тому +1

    We need impeachment and recall legislation

  • @richardcarey169
    @richardcarey169 Рік тому +5

    I have haemorrhoids..........WHY?

  • @lstrabt
    @lstrabt 12 днів тому

    Why did Labor waste $500 Million on the "Voice", why?????

  • @tonyanzellino4359
    @tonyanzellino4359 Рік тому +1

    What disrespectful behaviour by Labor, supposed to be running country for the betterment of the Australian people. Kindergarden children behave better that what was displayed by all Labor politicians. An total and prolific embarrassment, time they grew up.

  • @lyndabignell9660
    @lyndabignell9660 Рік тому +1

    Back in the 90s when i was teaching, most schools in Adelaide had a school council consisting of 2 adult moderators and 2 representatives from each classroom. We met on a weekly basis and discussed issues brought to the meetings and events and notices for the children to discuss back in the classroom. A model of government was learned. At the end of the year our local mp arranged for all the members of the school council to visit parliament house in Adelaide to watch how the state government functioned. What an embarrassing experience for me and the other teacher. As one of the children pointed out when we left 'why don't they listen to each other and respect each other's opinion like we do at school council?'

  • @katakis4525
    @katakis4525 Місяць тому

    If the government is committed to providing cost of living relief, then why doesn't Chalmers stop the RBA from hiking up interest rates?

  • @robpriest9031
    @robpriest9031 Рік тому +2

    Unrepresentative swill now in charge......

  • @JeffreyBrooks1
    @JeffreyBrooks1 Рік тому +1

    So our lives are just a game to these children !

  • @zoecampbell3514
    @zoecampbell3514 Рік тому +1

    this parliament is pathetic - sack them all and put the Indpendents in charge - Rennick - Roberts - Hanson - Antic and anyone else who has some common sense

  • @SA-nv5tc
    @SA-nv5tc Рік тому +1

    Why doesn’t anyone answer the question?

  • @stuartgraham8946
    @stuartgraham8946 3 місяці тому +1

    Why is Albanese PM WHY

  • @piersculley6419
    @piersculley6419 Рік тому +1

    Here we go again, Albo can't answer a question civilly, Albo just shouts abuse at the opposition.
    Oppose??? Isn't this what a opposition is supposed to do.

  • @chadbaillie4839
    @chadbaillie4839 Рік тому +3

    That’s exactly what I reckon why 10 out of 10 on my charts

  • @DanielSmith-zv9yc
    @DanielSmith-zv9yc Рік тому

    This is disgraceful 😡

  • @Zukfew
    @Zukfew Рік тому

    "WHY" are these people getting paid for this rubbish.

  • @barrygathercole6598
    @barrygathercole6598 Рік тому

    This prime minister is a joke. The whole thing is. Sack the lot. So where is the answer. No apology. He thinks he is smart. He isn’t.

  • @BensBreakdown
    @BensBreakdown Рік тому +2

    Every parent who has two or more kids fighting over who's going to press the the button to a elevator knows exactly how the speaker of the house feels. 😂
    Politics is utterly bizzarre, one of the few jobs where you have to constantly talk about why you disagree with your coworkers.

  • @jcampbell6822
    @jcampbell6822 Рік тому

    They never really answer the question! That's Why?

  • @djt7453
    @djt7453 Рік тому

    Parliament has basically become WWE. They’ve replaced the “WHAT” chants with “WHY” chants.

  • @batmanlives6456
    @batmanlives6456 Рік тому

    The greens advised that the green energy (renewable)will save us heaps… so you KNOW that’s not going to happen

  • @moonwolf6074
    @moonwolf6074 Рік тому

    I got a question and that is, why did we vote for labor again???

  • @martinconnors5195
    @martinconnors5195 29 днів тому

    Mr. Speaker Get a Grip. Please, grow a re-enforced spine

  • @barrygathercole6598
    @barrygathercole6598 Рік тому

    Just not going to listen to him. He has nothing for Australians.

  • @MariAmmaSar
    @MariAmmaSar Рік тому

    Albo must be taking lessons from Rishi Sunak on the art of deflection.

  • @mh017509
    @mh017509 Рік тому

    Circus...

  • @aaranjackson2080
    @aaranjackson2080 Рік тому +1

    Fairly competent politician for anyone to be taking on in anthony albanese.
    my grandfather said " if the next power bill goes up you'll be chopping wood and cooking on a pot belly stove cause i'm cutting the power ".

  • @davidgriffin2918
    @davidgriffin2918 Рік тому

    Labor us egg faced no answer for the bull dust lie of 275 dollar s ! Albo is slipperiness than a greasy snake

  • @kathleencook3060
    @kathleencook3060 Рік тому

    Shouting, and screeching sounds like big Bully boy. Union Bully boy tactics.

  • @frankcoates4609
    @frankcoates4609 Рік тому

    The Libs were so impressive, boofhead was dazzling.

  • @peterjohnpj2778
    @peterjohnpj2778 Рік тому

    wow????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

  • @rob6543
    @rob6543 Рік тому

    Why are you never in Australia , why ,

  • @bretloyd8097
    @bretloyd8097 Рік тому +2

    Ask a stupid question. . . Get a stupid answer. . . . We all now that the privatisation of the energy supply market has screwed domestic Australia.

  • @glennrobertson8656
    @glennrobertson8656 Рік тому

    That’s Club Canberra for you………….. Just like a Seinfeld episode….. The Bubble Boy……..🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫😎😎

  • @joanneplumb1778
    @joanneplumb1778 Рік тому

    Children act better

  • @gerdsfargen6687
    @gerdsfargen6687 Рік тому +1

    AnAl should stick to words he can pronounce without that slurpy lisp.

    • @mazilys
      @mazilys Рік тому +2

      Sounds drunk most of the time

  • @mazilys
    @mazilys Рік тому

    At least when the Voice is part of the constitution the First People can challenge parliament or even why does it exist which is pretty easy.

  • @truthtruth456
    @truthtruth456 Рік тому

    Schoolyard baby’s tit for tat

  • @rickandersen707
    @rickandersen707 11 місяців тому +1

    The comedy channel.....

  • @matcole1975
    @matcole1975 Рік тому

    I would not pay any of these people.
    What a mockery of parliament.