Came here because I was grateful you did the backwards Beatles quiz for David B. Thanks! I didn't get many of these as I only listen to a couple PF albums.
Sheep is one of my favourite favourite Floyd songs. It has such an energy to it. And 'Harmlessly passing your time in the grasslands away' was sung a lot by Pink Floyd before they actually created the sheep song.
Yeah, I don’t know why it’s so unpopular, I made a comment on another video from some other creator saying something like, “Pigs On The Wing 1 and Sheep are my two favorite (the two best) songs on Animals.” And people don’t seem to like that, maybe more people that don’t like Sheep saw that comment than people that do? I don’t know, I don’t really think it’s unpopular either, it’s just that in my experience some people don’t like it but I love it.😂
Same, that song brings tears to my eyes every time I even think about it. The mere peace and tranquility which will never be experienced other than through listening to that record while sitting in a true meadow (be it mentally or physically) :) Also indeed a great song to play (around with) and loop on the guitar!
Pigs on the Wing 2 ✅ Obscured by Clouds ✅ The Narrow Way ✅ Signs of Life ✅ High Hopes ✅ Have a Cigar ✅ Stop ✅ Grandchester Meadows ✅ Sheep ✅ Hey You! ✅ Shine On You Crazy Diamond ✅ Atom Heart Mother ✅ Summer 68 ✅ A Pillow of Winds ❌ (guessed "Welcome to the Machine") Time ❌ (guessed “Brain Damage")
Pigs on the wing ✓ guessed part two correctly Obscured by clouds ✓ love that song The narrow way X was so sure that was echoes Signs of life ✓ the only one with water High hopes X don't listen to it enough Have a cigar ✓ bass is unmistakable Stop ✓ just barely noticed Rogers voice Grandchester Meadows ✓ recognized the birds Sheep ✓ recognized the rolling bass Hey you X thought for sure it was welcome to the machine All the rest were way too short for me
12/15 Didn"t get obscured by clouds, signs of life and summer 68 But as a Pink Floyd fan many of them I guessed litterally a second after I hear it like with pigs on the wind 2, high hopes, have a cigar, stop, granchester meadows or time
Your friend misunderstood the assignment. I think he thought he was supposed to make it as hard as possible. You did pretty darn well with the obscure songs that he picked.
Ugh I was doing so good but those half second ones were so hard I got 10/15 (11/16 including the live version of numb) I missed both the Ummagumma ones. Spoilers below: 1. I got Pigs on the Wing 2. I got Obscured by Clouds 3. I missed this one I, had guessed Us and Them 4. I got Signs of Life 5. I got High Hopes 6. I got Have a Cigar 7. I got Stop 8. I missed this one, I was gonna guess Goodbye Blue Sky, but it wasn't the right key so I guessed A Pillow of Winds and was still wrong. 9. I got Sheep 10. I missed and guessed Welcome to the Machine 11. I got Shine on You Crazy Diamond 12. I got Atom Heart Mother 13. I missed and guessed Pigs Three Different Ones 14. I got A Pillow of Winds 15. I missed and guessed Any Colour You Like
The "problem" with this test is that so many of the songs are not only from albums that most people don't listen to, but albums that people don't WANT to listen to...
14/15, i didnt get Signs of Life. I almost didnt get Summer '68 but i realized that the acoustic guitar sounded swung. I love the 2 Ummagumma tracks and was pleasantly surprised to see The Narrow Way pt3 on here. Id like to do one of these
You got 100% because signs of life is not a f****** Pink Floyd album because it has no Roger. 🙂 I did way better than the host, but I actually thought that Time was actually the guitar solo from the Final Cut (which can also be argued is not really a Pink Floyd album!)
To be fair, grachester meadows and the narrow way pt 3 are the only songs really worth coming back to in Ummagumma. Lol Was 9/10 until the final round. The.5 seconds wasnt registering for me. Good fun though
12/15 ! I just didn't get: - Hey You (literally just 1 chord which is in so many songs, no other sounds around it) - Summer 68 (should've known because of Rick's singing..) - Pillow of Winds (just too short to hear anything in that one idk)
8/15, can’t believe i fumbled on sheep, thought it was one of these days! after getting full marks on the beatles one i thought i would nail this, but i have been listening to the beatles since before i started forming memories haha
When I watched this video, like clicked on it and then watched the whole thing, I have concluded that this is an enjoyable video. Pink Floyd rocks my socks.
The 2 and 1 second clips I got a 100%. Those 1/2 second ones got a little difficult. Got most of those but had to listen to them more than twice. Great job. Fun challenge. I've had 50 years of absorbing Pink Floyd's music into my skull. You being as young as you are did a great job. I gotta share this with my friend. Thanks.
This was a lot of fun. Some of these were very tough choices from the chosen sound bites. I am certainly one that enjoys listening to Ummagumma. Often before bed 💤 Reply
score: 11/15 round 1 1. Pigs on the Wing pt 2 2. Obscured by Clouds 3. The Narrow Way pt 3 4. Signs of Life [X] (tbh I glanced at the comments) 5. High Hopes round 2 6. Have a Cigar (given the drum sound and keyboard sounds) 7. Stop 8. Grantchester Meadows 9. Sheep 10. Hey You [X] (I thought it was "Pigs (Three Different Ones)" given the guitar sound) round 3. 11. Shine On You Crazy Diamond Part VI 12. Atom Heart Mother 13. Summer 68 [X] (I thought it was Mother because of the acoustic) 14. A Pillow of Winds [X] (I thought it was Paint Box due to the sounds of the guitars) 15. Time
i can identify the 1967-1983 stuff, and the post-Waters i can only say that it's something off Momentary Lapse or Division Bell, guessing based off the sound of the production....but no idea what the individual songs are. Deffo gets harder the shorter the clips get. Something like this would be fun as a quiz with multiple fans, who have to smack a buzzer first to shout out the answer, like those old 90's gameshows.
I'm a huge PF fan (but I've my preferences within PF... there are a couple of albums that I rarely listen to) and this was quite hard! A little disappointed that there was nothing from the Piper album... or from Saucerful. But great video!
Pigs on the Wing ✅ Obscured by Clouds ✅ The Narrow Way ✅ Signs of Life ❌ (guessed “One of These Days”) High Hopes ✅ Have a Cigar ✅ Stop ✅ Grantchester Meadows ✅ Sheep ✅ Hey You ❌ (guessed “Welcome to the Machine”) Shine On You Crazy Diamond ✅ Atom Heart Mother ✅ Summer ‘68 ❌ (guessed “Wish You Were Here”) A Pillow of Winds ❌ (guessed “Fat Old Sun”) Time ✅ 11/15
Lets do this!!! P. S. - PF is my favorite band 1 - Pigs on the wing pt 2 (cuz double guitars and verse) 2 - Obscured by Clouds (The synth and Guitar line) 3 - The narrow way (Vocals, drums and guitar effect) 4 - Signs of Life (Guitar Effect and Synth thingy in the left) 5 - High Hopes (lyrics and piano) 6 - Have a Cigar (the synth and guitar) 7 - Stop (Piano Line and Echo) 8 - Grantchester Meadows (Birds and Acoustic Guitars) 9 - Sheep (synths and bass riff) 10 - Hey You (The “boom” after the acoustic guitar Em and also the brief “coming home”) 11 - Shine On 6 (cuz the synth tritone) 12 - Atom Heart Mother (F Chord with horns) 13 - Summer 68 (Richard Wright vocals + acoustic and Organ) 14 - A Pillow Of winds (Acoustic and Electric guitars in a maj7 chord) 15 - Time (Guitar solo effects + organ)
Damn ... that was almost impossible... Ummagumma ?!?!? REALLY? And more than 1 track? And Obscured? Come on, man... (I had both albums - I had ALL the albums up to Momentary Lapse), but... I ended up getting almost exactly what you did! The ONLY differences were, I didn't know the track title of "Stop" (though knew it was from The Wall), and I guessed "Money" instead of "Time" on the last track. Of the others we both guessed correctly, all I can say is that I was faster in recognizing / naming them (like Sheep, Atom Heart Mother, Have a Cigar, etc.)... But a lot of that was PRETTY "OBSCURE", pardon the pun! Cheers...
Pigs on A Wing 2 ✅ Obscured By Clouds ❌ The Narrow Way (Part Three) ❌ Signs of Life ❌ High Hopes ✅ Have A Cigar ✅ Stop ✅ Grandchester Meadows ❌ Sheep ✅ Hey You ✅ Shine On You Crazy Diamond Pts. 6-9 ✅ Atom Heart Mother ✅ Summer ‘68 ❌ A Pillow of Winds ✅ Time ✅
Pigs on A Wing 2 ✅ Obscured By Clouds ✅ The Narrow Way (Part Three) ✅ Signs of Life ❌ High Hopes ✅ Have A Cigar ✅ Stop ❌ Grandchester Meadows ✅ Sheep ✅ Hey You ✅ Shine On You Crazy Diamond Pts. 6-9 ✅ Atom Heart Mother ✅ Summer ‘68 ❌ A Pillow of Winds ❌ Time ✅
The last 60 seconds of Sheep (Animals) was my father's all time favorite music moment. BTW, he listened a lot to Ummagumma (and Meddle), mostly as an aid to getting a good nap. I changed my first name to Floyd because of this band. (My last name to Maxwell in honor of James Clerk Maxwell).
🤣 I had the same same exact problem with the bonus question, but you did pretty good ! I only got 7/15 .. I’m a lot older than you, so I got the ones you didn’t get pretty much, but I got the first three from the two second clips, the first three from the one second clips, and then I had a meltdown on the half second clips after the first one, so kudos! 👨🏻
1. Pigs On The Wing Part 2 2. Obscured By Clouds 3. Don't know WRONG The Narrow Way Part 3 4. Signs Of Life 5. High Hopes 6. Pigs (Three Different Ones) WRONG Have A Cigar 7. Stop 8. Grantchester Meadows 9. Sheep 10. Hey You 11. Shine On You Crazy Diamond Part 6 12. Atom Heart Mother 13. Wish You Were Here WRONG Summer '68 14. The Fletcher Memorial Home WRONG A Pillow Of Winds 15. Time Bonus: Comfortably Numb with Rick Wright WRONG Benedict Cumberbatch 11/16
Being an old Floyd nerd I got "Obscured by Clouds", "Narrow Way", "Grantchester Meadows", "Atom Heart Mother", "Summer '68" (Rick's voice is that recognisable), "Have a Cigar", "Sheep", and "Time", (missed "Shine On" v.impressed at you getting that!). Always loved "Narrow Way", it's like a rough-hewn blueprint of a future Floyd song style ("Echoes" and its phased/leslie chords and Dave and Rick's harmonizing, and "Breathe" particularly, with its similar, slow tempo, aerial slide guitar and layered voices.) Should have got "Pillow of Winds", Meddlle was my first Floyd album and still my favourite.
11/15 The ones I missed: •The Narrow Way 3 •Signs Of Life •Grandchester Meadows (partly guess, because I said it is from Ummagumma, but didnt know the song name) •A Pillow Of Winds
7/15 but found only time in 0.5 second. Obscured by clouds 2 seconds is super easy if you know the song well because the sound is very distinct and you can't mistake it with something else. Signs of life too. But they are not famous songs which makes it harder.
[SPOILERS] Here's what I got: Round 1: 2/5 (the first two, thought that last one was louder than words lol) Round 2: 2/5 (I was first gonna go with sheep but then I said pigs so I'm not counting that as correct guess) Round 3: 2/5 Bonus: I think I have never heard that one lol Overall: 6/15! This was fun and surprisingly exciting
Pigs on the Wing ✅ Obscured by Clouds ✅ The Narrow Way ❌ (guessed “The Nile Song”) Signs of Life ✅ High Hopes ✅ Have a Cigar ✅ Stop ✅ Grandchester Meadows ✅ Sheep ✅ Hey You! ✅ Shine On You Crazy Diamond ✅ Atom Heart Mother ✅ Summer 68 ❌ (guessed “Dogs”) A Pillow of Winds ❌ (no clue) Time ❌ (guessed “Poles Apart”)
Exactly the same result. But instead of "The Narrow Way" I guessed "Fat Old Sun", instead of Summer 68 - "Comfortably Numb" and instead of Time I also guessed "Comfortably Numb" - I was pretty sure that was near the beginning of the last Gilmour solo.
I only missed the narrow way pt. 3 and summer 68(I got the bonus lmao) I gave myself an extra half point for getting the right half of pigs on the wing. 14.5/16
Yeah i mean i don't think the point should be counted unless one guessed that it was the second because to my knowledge the word stone isn't used in the first one whatsoever
1.Pigs on the Wing 2.Obscured By Clouds(title track or that jam at the beginning) 3.The Narrow Way second part, after the acoustic part(dammit, it was part 3!) First Miss 4 no idea(hadn’t listened to that in 20 years) 5. Division Bell( I get the song names mixed up from that album) 6. Have a Cigar (I can hear that flangey guitar sound) 7. I wanna Go Home! (Wasn’t sure the song title, but I knew the vocal part 8. Grandchester meadows(only song with birds like that) wow, I’ve always spelled it wrong 9. Dogs (I’m leaning to Sheep though) Dammit! 10. Welcome to the Machine(Wow, way off) 11. Missed it 12. Atom Heart Mother for sure(horn gives it away) 13. Another Atom Heart song, but I don’t know which one. Dang it! 14. Pillow of Winds (ha! I know that pedal steel) 15. No clue. Guessing Comfortably Numb, because of the strings (Sonofabitch!) Missed the bonus That was fun So, 8 if I get a half point for the right wing wrong part. 7 because I’m count Stop!, because I knew the song, but wasn’t sure about the title. More sure than the Division Bell song.
Those half second ones were TOUGH! In the first round there was only one that I didn’t at least recognize….but I got most of them throughout at some level; either I at least recognized it, knew the song or album or something….like the last one, I could tell by its sound that it was from DSOTM….. but I couldn’t pick the song before you revealed it. Tracks from Atom Heart Mother, I had no clue……but I love Ummugumma and I had actually just listened to Granchester Meadows, haha! I need to get back to listening to more Pink Floyd, obviously!
Saying that Signs of Life sounds like something off of Piper is kinda embarrassing, ngl. But I didn’t remember what it was called either. I just said, “opening of AMLOR”
The umma gumma one, I knew it was from umma gumma but I didn't know the name of the song. Umma Gumma is a difficult album to listen to, but there are some real gems amongst all the weird noises and pictish rambling
I'm mostly post Dark Floyd fan, so I hardly got 8/15. Definitely the answer is easy when you know it (e.g. the squeeling guitar in the second Shine On build up). Hey You was actually pretty easy for me, so was the Signs of Life... but I didn't get any of the songs I don't listen at all - unsurprisignly.
Oh this is a genius new format. Some of my favourite reactors are getting hassled by the copyright police these days, which is such a nonsense. You must be in the clear for 2 seconds at a time.
I paused after each sample so as not to be influenced by you. Got Signs of Life and High Hopes. Guessed Welcome to The Machine for Have a Cigar. Guessed The Trial for Stop. Got Grantchester Meadows Guessed One of These Days for Sheep :-( Got Hey You No clue with any 1/2 second ones. Too hard for me!
I messed up three songs, and was three easy songs (Stop, Hey You and Summer '68), but I got some songs like Granchester Meadows, The Narrow Way (Part Three) and Obscured by Clouds. Final score: 12/15
Pigs on the Wing 2 - yes Obscured by Clouds - yes Narrow Way 3 - yes Signs of Life - no (not particularly fond of Momentary or Division Bell, but I did happen to get the next one) High Hopes - yes Have a Cigar - yes Stop - yes Grantchester Meadows - yes Sheep - yes (originally thought One of these Days but pulled out Sheep right before you did) Hey You - no (guessed Shine On) Shine On - yes (but you said it before I did) Atom Heart Mother - no Summer '68 - no (bothered I didn't get this one or Atom Heart as it's one of my favorite albums) Pillow of Winds - no (didn't even have a guess, dammit) Time - no (guessed Dogs)
Well. I just did it and did worse than I thought I would. 7/15. (and kinda sorta ish of the last one) And here are my notes so you can see my guesses :P (If anyone is reading this before playing along DONT READ ANY FURTHER!) . . . . 1. Animals. Pigs on the wing pt1 (damnit. it was pt2) YES 2. Obscured by Clouds. The Gold its in the… DAMNIT. it was obscured by clouds. That's one of my favourite tracks and I didn't get it. Awesome. 3. not a clue but Saucerful of Secrets? Hmm. No not a clue. Ummagumma Narrow Way 4. Division Bell. Marooned? Nope. Momentary Lapse, Signs of Life 5. Division Bell. damnit “The grass was greener, the light was brighter…”… High Hopes??? YES! (hah and even had that snippet) 6. WYWH. Have a Cigar. Yep. Before he goes with the answer I’m 100% convinced I’m right. YEP 7. The Wall. omg its the one before The Trial. Stop, I wanna go home, take off this uniform and leave the show. what the heck is it. :( POO. Unreal... I even had the title as i remembered the lyric. 8. Grandchester Meadows. No idea of the album. Don’t need to give the album so fingers crossed… WOOHOO! I ROCK. YES. 9. Sheep. Animals. 100%. No doubt. (I hope) the lord is my shepherd… lamb cutlets baby. YES 10. The Wall. but it was only a fantasy the wall was too high as you can see and the worms ate into his brains… and mine because i can’t remember the name of the sodding track. Is there anybody in there? it’s the bit just before it goes itno the solo. drum fill and solo. gach… oh damnit. Hey You. 11. WYWH. Shine on you crazy diamond. no idea of part. YES 12. Atom heart Mother. Atom Heart Mother. Stupid suite. Better not ask for which part it is. Breast Milky or the like :P YES 13. …. not a clue. guitar and vocal only… guess. WYWH, WYWH? hah. same as him. Hmm. second listen. really not a clue. NOPE! 14. Remember a Day. More? NOPE! 15. … nothing. just total guess because its solo with a heap of backing as Comfortably Numb. DAMN Comfortably Numb live. Not Pulse. (That had multiple vocalists in verse) Delicate Sound of Thunder or… a cover? It wasn’t Roger either. That was rather fun.
11/15. I missed: Obscured By Clouds (guessed When You're In) Signs of Life (guessed Cluster One) Stop (Wasn't sure as I don't listen the Wall often) Pillow of Winds (guessed Comfortably Numb, lol)
If this was like guess the song from the beginning and so many notes I could do it in one or two notes on almost every song but playing clips for the middle makes it tough
13/15 my score... In Summer '68 i thought it was something from The Wall or The Final Cut but i didn't guess it... in A Pillow Of Winds i thought it was San Tropez... right album wrong song lol... the other ones i got it right! Nice video...
Yeaahh! I've been digging the ones on youtube for the Beatles, have been waiting for a Pink Floyd one. Think I got 12/15. Didn't get Signs of Life but I knew if was from Momentary Lapse of Reason.
Wow that's hard. 1 didn't get 2 obscured by clouds 3 the narrow way don't know which part? 4 remember a day? [nope] 5 something from division bell or momentary lapse 6 have a cigar 7 stop! I wanna go home 8 grantchester meadows 9 sheep 10 dogs or welcome to the machine [nope] 11 didn't get 12 dogs [nope, still not dogs] 13 us and them [nope] 14 take up thy stethoscope & walk [nope] 15 us and them [nope, 0 for 5 on the half-second clips]
# Pigs on the Wing part 1 childhoods end (the first track from obscured by clouds) # The Narrow way part 3. Terminal Frost (momentary lapse of reason) # High Hopes # Have a Cigar the track before the trial in the Wall # Granchester Meadows # Sheep Welcome to the machine # Shine On you crazy diamond part 6 # Atom Heart Mother one of my bad days # from echoes, a pillow of winds? Hey You. Billy Brag doing Comfortably Numb? I think that works out at 9/15 knowing Umma Gumma was a big help.
10/15 and that was fun. I even pulled the name of Grandchester Meadows out of my ass. I was like “no, it’s not Mandchester… I think it’s Grandchester Meadows maybe?”
@@davidhartley94 I think Pink Floyd is the only band for which I would perform even half as well. That music coursed through my veins for half of my life.
Thanks for watching! Please subscribe and check out my other videos if you enjoyed this one! 🙂
I respect the honesty of the author, instead of studying ahead to attempt to look cool or something. Well done.
Came here because I was grateful you did the backwards Beatles quiz for David B. Thanks! I didn't get many of these as I only listen to a couple PF albums.
Sheep is one of my favourite favourite Floyd songs. It has such an energy to it.
And 'Harmlessly passing your time in the grasslands away' was sung a lot by Pink Floyd before they actually created the sheep song.
"Raving and Drooling"
@@tucor Yeah that's the one.
Mine also.,it's one of the most perfect songs ...and my favorite album is "The WALL"
Yeah, I don’t know why it’s so unpopular, I made a comment on another video from some other creator saying something like, “Pigs On The Wing 1 and Sheep are my two favorite (the two best) songs on Animals.” And people don’t seem to like that, maybe more people that don’t like Sheep saw that comment than people that do? I don’t know, I don’t really think it’s unpopular either, it’s just that in my experience some people don’t like it but I love it.😂
Not a huge PF fan but yeah Sheep is a great song. "Only dimly aware of a certain unease in the air" is a favourite lyric of mine.
I totally got grant Chester meadows! Immediately! I love that song. Learned to play it years ago.
Same, that song brings tears to my eyes every time I even think about it. The mere peace and tranquility which will never be experienced other than through listening to that record while sitting in a true meadow (be it mentally or physically) :) Also indeed a great song to play (around with) and loop on the guitar!
Yes! It’s a great song to just keep playing lol
That and Have a cigar are the easiest ones to guess IMO
For #8, I find it’s not fair play. There are birds chirping in more than one Pink Floyd song. Only a bird expert would know which is which. 😅
I could've sworn Sheep was One of These Days
The main problem with pink floyd is that you listen to the whole album and not individual songs
Pigs on the Wing 2 ✅
Obscured by Clouds ✅
The Narrow Way ✅
Signs of Life ✅
High Hopes ✅
Have a Cigar ✅
Stop ✅
Grandchester Meadows ✅
Sheep ✅
Hey You! ✅
Shine On You Crazy Diamond ✅
Atom Heart Mother ✅
Summer 68 ✅
A Pillow of Winds ❌ (guessed "Welcome to the Machine")
Time ❌ (guessed “Brain Damage")
I have guessed the same on your X-es.
But I had some X-es of my own too 😂
I also guessed Brain Damage for the last one. 8/15 for me.
Pigs on the wing ✓ guessed part two correctly
Obscured by clouds ✓ love that song
The narrow way X was so sure that was echoes
Signs of life ✓ the only one with water
High hopes X don't listen to it enough
Have a cigar ✓ bass is unmistakable
Stop ✓ just barely noticed Rogers voice
Grandchester Meadows ✓ recognized the birds
Sheep ✓ recognized the rolling bass
Hey you X thought for sure it was welcome to the machine
All the rest were way too short for me
i thought grandchester meadows was seamus (that's the dog) for some reason
@@nate5862 yeah this was way harder than I expected. And Pink Floyd's one of my top three bands, so I thought I had it in the bag lol
Sorry to be an arse but it is Grantchester Meadows..(near Cambridge UK)
Yeah this was surprisingly challenging as a massive Floyd fan. I thought hey you was welcome to the machine as well.
I thought Have A Cigar was Welcome To The Machine😂
12/15
Didn"t get obscured by clouds, signs of life and summer 68
But as a Pink Floyd fan many of them I guessed litterally a second after I hear it like with pigs on the wind 2, high hopes, have a cigar, stop, granchester meadows or time
Floyd post Barret and pre Dark Side are my favorites. This was fun. Thanks!
What about post Dark Side
@@yohannuspistachio Love it, but it's overplayed.
@@zd4v1d yeah true, except Division Bell and Final Cut
I got Grantchester Meadows and The Narrow Way and that's about it.
Your friend misunderstood the assignment. I think he thought he was supposed to make it as hard as possible. You did pretty darn well with the obscure songs that he picked.
Ugh I was doing so good but those half second ones were so hard I got 10/15 (11/16 including the live version of numb)
I missed both the Ummagumma ones. Spoilers below:
1. I got Pigs on the Wing
2. I got Obscured by Clouds
3. I missed this one I, had guessed Us and Them
4. I got Signs of Life
5. I got High Hopes
6. I got Have a Cigar
7. I got Stop
8. I missed this one, I was gonna guess Goodbye Blue Sky, but it wasn't the right key so I guessed A Pillow of Winds and was still wrong.
9. I got Sheep
10. I missed and guessed Welcome to the Machine
11. I got Shine on You Crazy Diamond
12. I got Atom Heart Mother
13. I missed and guessed Pigs Three Different Ones
14. I got A Pillow of Winds
15. I missed and guessed Any Colour You Like
I got 10/15 - didn't get narrow way, pillow of winds, stop, sign of life, summer 68
The "problem" with this test is that so many of the songs are not only from albums that most people don't listen to, but albums that people don't WANT to listen to...
Exactly
7 right, with bonus.
i was sooo sure the 'hey you' was welcome to the machine bruh
14/15, i didnt get Signs of Life. I almost didnt get Summer '68 but i realized that the acoustic guitar sounded swung. I love the 2 Ummagumma tracks and was pleasantly surprised to see The Narrow Way pt3 on here. Id like to do one of these
I mistook the clip of the narrow way for echoes
@@timothyholly1289 they can be easily confused when only a second is played
You got 100% because signs of life is not a f****** Pink Floyd album because it has no Roger. 🙂
I did way better than the host, but I actually thought that Time was actually the guitar solo from the Final Cut (which can also be argued is not really a Pink Floyd album!)
Dude lost any credibility when he missed obscured by clouds.
@@garycitro1674 Shut up Gary
To be fair, grachester meadows and the narrow way pt 3 are the only songs really worth coming back to in Ummagumma. Lol Was 9/10 until the final round. The.5 seconds wasnt registering for me. Good fun though
Love how we were almost trolled with no dark side of the moon until the end
Hi, I'm also a Pink Floyd fan, almost 40 years now. My favorite album is "The dark site of the moon".
You did it very well, congratulations!! 🎉🎉
40 years and you cant even spell the name of the album properly
@@Jack-gb9wx hahahhaha, I actually saw a funnier spelling someone said ''Dark part of the Moon''.
@@Jack-gb9wx yours just looks like a mean offense. Just, why?
@@Jack-gb9wx 40 years ago there weren't phones with these small letters.
@@Jack-gb9wxlet him of
12/15 ! I just didn't get:
- Hey You (literally just 1 chord which is in so many songs, no other sounds around it)
- Summer 68 (should've known because of Rick's singing..)
- Pillow of Winds (just too short to hear anything in that one idk)
8/15, can’t believe i fumbled on sheep, thought it was one of these days! after getting full marks on the beatles one i thought i would nail this, but i have been listening to the beatles since before i started forming memories haha
After getting the first eight right I thought this would be cake but it definitely got harder. Kudos if you got #13. I only ended up with 9/15.
Missed 3 Narrow Way
12 Atom Heart Mother
14 Pillow of Winds
I only missed 3! This was kind of fun and a little easier than I thought it would be! I missed Summer '68, Grantchester Meadows, and Pillow of Winds.
I got 10
How did you get stop and not hey you
haha, i don't know - hey you didn't even come to mind!
When I watched this video, like clicked on it and then watched the whole thing, I have concluded that this is an enjoyable video. Pink Floyd rocks my socks.
This was really fun and challenging. I got 8 - I’m happy with that.
The 2 and 1 second clips I got a 100%. Those 1/2 second ones got a little difficult. Got most of those but had to listen to them more than twice. Great job. Fun challenge. I've had 50 years of absorbing Pink Floyd's music into my skull. You being as young as you are did a great job. I gotta share this with my friend. Thanks.
This was a lot of fun. Some of these were very tough choices from the chosen sound bites. I am certainly one that enjoys listening to Ummagumma. Often before bed 💤
Reply
score: 11/15
round 1
1. Pigs on the Wing pt 2
2. Obscured by Clouds
3. The Narrow Way pt 3
4. Signs of Life [X] (tbh I glanced at the comments)
5. High Hopes
round 2
6. Have a Cigar (given the drum sound and keyboard sounds)
7. Stop
8. Grantchester Meadows
9. Sheep
10. Hey You [X] (I thought it was "Pigs (Three Different Ones)" given the guitar sound)
round 3.
11. Shine On You Crazy Diamond Part VI
12. Atom Heart Mother
13. Summer 68 [X] (I thought it was Mother because of the acoustic)
14. A Pillow of Winds [X] (I thought it was Paint Box due to the sounds of the guitars)
15. Time
That was a fun exercise.
10/15
I’m mad I missed “Hey You” though.
Proud to have the highest so far, 14/15. So annoyed that I forgot A Pillow of Winds, thought it was San Tropez...
Still, not too shabby a score!
Great score, nice one!
I mixed up those two as well!!
i can identify the 1967-1983 stuff, and the post-Waters i can only say that it's something off Momentary Lapse or Division Bell, guessing based off the sound of the production....but no idea what the individual songs are.
Deffo gets harder the shorter the clips get.
Something like this would be fun as a quiz with multiple fans, who have to smack a buzzer first to shout out the answer, like those old 90's gameshows.
I'm a huge PF fan (but I've my preferences within PF... there are a couple of albums that I rarely listen to) and this was quite hard!
A little disappointed that there was nothing from the Piper album... or from Saucerful. But great video!
6/15, I'll be back and do better next time. Completely guessed on Time btw.
Pigs on the Wing ✅
Obscured by Clouds ✅
The Narrow Way ✅
Signs of Life ❌ (guessed “One of These Days”)
High Hopes ✅
Have a Cigar ✅
Stop ✅
Grantchester Meadows ✅
Sheep ✅
Hey You ❌ (guessed “Welcome to the Machine”)
Shine On You Crazy Diamond ✅
Atom Heart Mother ✅
Summer ‘68 ❌ (guessed “Wish You Were Here”)
A Pillow of Winds ❌ (guessed “Fat Old Sun”)
Time ✅
11/15
I also guessed Welcome to the Machine, I was absolutely certain it was, and was astonished that it was Hey You.
Lets do this!!!
P. S. - PF is my favorite band
1 - Pigs on the wing pt 2 (cuz double guitars and verse)
2 - Obscured by Clouds (The synth and Guitar line)
3 - The narrow way (Vocals, drums and guitar effect)
4 - Signs of Life (Guitar Effect and Synth thingy in the left)
5 - High Hopes (lyrics and piano)
6 - Have a Cigar (the synth and guitar)
7 - Stop (Piano Line and Echo)
8 - Grantchester Meadows (Birds and Acoustic Guitars)
9 - Sheep (synths and bass riff)
10 - Hey You (The “boom” after the acoustic guitar Em and also the brief “coming home”)
11 - Shine On 6 (cuz the synth tritone)
12 - Atom Heart Mother (F Chord with horns)
13 - Summer 68 (Richard Wright vocals + acoustic and Organ)
14 - A Pillow Of winds (Acoustic and Electric guitars in a maj7 chord)
15 - Time (Guitar solo effects + organ)
I got part 2 because I heard “stone”
@@pizzaman4385 SAME
Damn ... that was almost impossible... Ummagumma ?!?!? REALLY? And more than 1 track? And Obscured? Come on, man... (I had both albums - I had ALL the albums up to Momentary Lapse), but... I ended up getting almost exactly what you did! The ONLY differences were, I didn't know the track title of "Stop" (though knew it was from The Wall), and I guessed "Money" instead of "Time" on the last track. Of the others we both guessed correctly, all I can say is that I was faster in recognizing / naming them (like Sheep, Atom Heart Mother, Have a Cigar, etc.)... But a lot of that was PRETTY "OBSCURE", pardon the pun! Cheers...
Pigs on A Wing 2 ✅
Obscured By Clouds ❌
The Narrow Way (Part Three) ❌
Signs of Life ❌
High Hopes ✅
Have A Cigar ✅
Stop ✅
Grandchester Meadows ❌
Sheep ✅
Hey You ✅
Shine On You Crazy Diamond Pts. 6-9 ✅
Atom Heart Mother ✅
Summer ‘68 ❌
A Pillow of Winds ✅
Time ✅
I got 14 out of 15 right. The one I got wrong was Summer 68’.
I got 5/15. All of my correct answers you got as well except I correctly guessed Hey You.
2 obscured by clouds first song on album
Pigs on A Wing 2 ✅
Obscured By Clouds ✅
The Narrow Way (Part Three) ✅
Signs of Life ❌
High Hopes ✅
Have A Cigar ✅
Stop ❌
Grandchester Meadows ✅
Sheep ✅
Hey You ✅
Shine On You Crazy Diamond Pts. 6-9 ✅
Atom Heart Mother ✅
Summer ‘68 ❌
A Pillow of Winds ❌
Time ✅
The last 60 seconds of Sheep (Animals) was my father's all time favorite music moment. BTW, he listened a lot to Ummagumma (and Meddle), mostly as an aid to getting a good nap. I changed my first name to Floyd because of this band. (My last name to Maxwell in honor of James Clerk Maxwell).
11/15, half a second was indeed tough, Floyd is its own universe
🤣 I had the same same exact problem with the bonus question, but you did pretty good ! I only got 7/15 .. I’m a lot older than you, so I got the ones you didn’t get pretty much, but I got the first three from the two second clips, the first three from the one second clips, and then I had a meltdown on the half second clips after the first one, so kudos! 👨🏻
1. Pigs On The Wing Part 2
2. Obscured By Clouds
3. Don't know WRONG The Narrow Way Part 3
4. Signs Of Life
5. High Hopes
6. Pigs (Three Different Ones) WRONG Have A Cigar
7. Stop
8. Grantchester Meadows
9. Sheep
10. Hey You
11. Shine On You Crazy Diamond Part 6
12. Atom Heart Mother
13. Wish You Were Here WRONG Summer '68
14. The Fletcher Memorial Home WRONG A Pillow Of Winds
15. Time
Bonus: Comfortably Numb with Rick Wright WRONG Benedict Cumberbatch
11/16
Being an old Floyd nerd I got "Obscured by Clouds", "Narrow Way", "Grantchester Meadows", "Atom Heart Mother", "Summer '68" (Rick's voice is that recognisable), "Have a Cigar", "Sheep", and "Time", (missed "Shine On" v.impressed at you getting that!). Always loved "Narrow Way", it's like a rough-hewn blueprint of a future Floyd song style ("Echoes" and its phased/leslie chords and Dave and Rick's harmonizing, and "Breathe" particularly, with its similar, slow tempo, aerial slide guitar and layered voices.) Should have got "Pillow of Winds", Meddlle was my first Floyd album and still my favourite.
11/15
The ones I missed:
•The Narrow Way 3
•Signs Of Life
•Grandchester Meadows (partly guess, because I said it is from Ummagumma, but didnt know the song name)
•A Pillow Of Winds
7/15 but found only time in 0.5 second.
Obscured by clouds 2 seconds is super easy if you know the song well because the sound is very distinct and you can't mistake it with something else. Signs of life too. But they are not famous songs which makes it harder.
9/15, 3/5 on each category, was mad at myself for thinking sheep was one of these days, but what’s worse it you thinking hey you was breath
You did very well. Im a huge Floyd fan since I bought Meddle in 71, but I couldn't guess any song ...
Awesome guesses, thanks for the video!!
Whattya mean "who listens to Ummagumma?"
[SPOILERS] Here's what I got:
Round 1: 2/5 (the first two, thought that last one was louder than words lol)
Round 2: 2/5 (I was first gonna go with sheep but then I said pigs so I'm not counting that as correct guess)
Round 3: 2/5
Bonus: I think I have never heard that one lol
Overall: 6/15! This was fun and surprisingly exciting
Pigs on the Wing ✅
Obscured by Clouds ✅
The Narrow Way ❌ (guessed “The Nile Song”)
Signs of Life ✅
High Hopes ✅
Have a Cigar ✅
Stop ✅
Grandchester Meadows ✅
Sheep ✅
Hey You! ✅
Shine On You Crazy Diamond ✅
Atom Heart Mother ✅
Summer 68 ❌ (guessed “Dogs”)
A Pillow of Winds ❌ (no clue)
Time ❌ (guessed “Poles Apart”)
Exactly the same result. But instead of "The Narrow Way" I guessed "Fat Old Sun", instead of Summer 68 - "Comfortably Numb" and instead of Time I also guessed "Comfortably Numb" - I was pretty sure that was near the beginning of the last Gilmour solo.
I guessed 12/15 right (plus the bonus one). I missed The Narrow Way, Signs of Life and (embarrassingly) Time
I got 4. I don't know Atom Heart Mother and Ummagumma albums. The Wall I know only a little bit, not all the songs.
4 a momentary lapse of reason
12 out of 15, I missed the Narrow Way, Summer 68, and a pillow of winds.
I only missed the narrow way pt. 3 and summer 68(I got the bonus lmao) I gave myself an extra half point for getting the right half of pigs on the wing. 14.5/16
Yeah i mean i don't think the point should be counted unless one guessed that it was the second because to my knowledge the word stone isn't used in the first one whatsoever
1.Pigs on the Wing
2.Obscured By Clouds(title track or that jam at the beginning)
3.The Narrow Way second part, after the acoustic part(dammit, it was part 3!) First Miss
4 no idea(hadn’t listened to that in 20 years)
5. Division Bell( I get the song names mixed up from that album)
6. Have a Cigar (I can hear that flangey guitar sound)
7. I wanna Go Home! (Wasn’t sure the song title, but I knew the vocal part
8. Grandchester meadows(only song with birds like that) wow, I’ve always spelled it wrong
9. Dogs (I’m leaning to Sheep though) Dammit!
10. Welcome to the Machine(Wow, way off)
11. Missed it
12. Atom Heart Mother for sure(horn gives it away)
13. Another Atom Heart song, but I don’t know which one. Dang it!
14. Pillow of Winds (ha! I know that pedal steel)
15. No clue. Guessing Comfortably Numb, because of the strings (Sonofabitch!)
Missed the bonus
That was fun
So, 8 if I get a half point for the right wing wrong part.
7 because I’m count Stop!, because I knew the song, but wasn’t sure about the title. More sure than the Division Bell song.
Those half second ones were TOUGH!
In the first round there was only one that I didn’t at least recognize….but I got most of them throughout at some level; either I at least recognized it, knew the song or album or something….like the last one, I could tell by its sound that it was from DSOTM….. but I couldn’t pick the song before you revealed it.
Tracks from Atom Heart Mother, I had no clue……but I love Ummugumma and I had actually just listened to Granchester Meadows, haha!
I need to get back to listening to more Pink Floyd, obviously!
Saying that Signs of Life sounds like something off of Piper is kinda embarrassing, ngl. But I didn’t remember what it was called either. I just said, “opening of AMLOR”
Haha yeah fairly embarrassing, oops
12/15 missed Obscured by Clouds, Summer '68 and A Pillow of Winds
I think I matched you. I struggled with the Ummagumma tracks too!
Not me being unreasonably proud of myself for getting Obscured By Clouds
Thanks for making this!
I’ve seen this before? What the heck?
The umma gumma one, I knew it was from umma gumma but I didn't know the name of the song. Umma Gumma is a difficult album to listen to, but there are some real gems amongst all the weird noises and pictish rambling
I'm mostly post Dark Floyd fan, so I hardly got 8/15. Definitely the answer is easy when you know it (e.g. the squeeling guitar in the second Shine On build up). Hey You was actually pretty easy for me, so was the Signs of Life... but I didn't get any of the songs I don't listen at all - unsurprisignly.
Exactly the same for me
I got 2 out of 15. My favorite album is "More." Favorite song: "Careful With That Axe Eugene" from "Ummagumma."
How come there was nothing from the piper at the gates of dawn. Genuinely one of their best albums.
I got all the old ones you haven't. Ummagumma is gold!
I got 11/15.
I was going 10 for 10 until the "0.5 second" clips, where I sunk like a stone.
For number 4, I thought it was either part 1 or part 2 of Shine on You Crazy Diamond off the album Wish You Were Here.
Oh this is a genius new format. Some of my favourite reactors are getting hassled by the copyright police these days, which is such a nonsense. You must be in the clear for 2 seconds at a time.
12/15 for me, forgot the narrow way, summer 69, and the one from momentary lapse. and I got the bonus one!
I paused after each sample so as not to be influenced by you.
Got Signs of Life and High Hopes.
Guessed Welcome to The Machine for Have a Cigar.
Guessed The Trial for Stop.
Got Grantchester Meadows
Guessed One of These Days for Sheep :-(
Got Hey You
No clue with any 1/2 second ones.
Too hard for me!
I messed up three songs, and was three easy songs (Stop, Hey You and Summer '68), but I got some songs like Granchester Meadows, The Narrow Way (Part Three) and Obscured by Clouds. Final score: 12/15
Loved this
Pigs on the Wing 2 - yes
Obscured by Clouds - yes
Narrow Way 3 - yes
Signs of Life - no (not particularly fond of Momentary or Division Bell, but I did happen to get the next one)
High Hopes - yes
Have a Cigar - yes
Stop - yes
Grantchester Meadows - yes
Sheep - yes (originally thought One of these Days but pulled out Sheep right before you did)
Hey You - no (guessed Shine On)
Shine On - yes (but you said it before I did)
Atom Heart Mother - no
Summer '68 - no (bothered I didn't get this one or Atom Heart as it's one of my favorite albums)
Pillow of Winds - no (didn't even have a guess, dammit)
Time - no (guessed Dogs)
10/15 Missed Narrow Way 3, High Hopes, Summer 68, Pillow Of Winds, and Time.
Well. I just did it and did worse than I thought I would. 7/15. (and kinda sorta ish of the last one)
And here are my notes so you can see my guesses :P (If anyone is reading this before playing along DONT READ ANY FURTHER!)
.
.
.
.
1. Animals. Pigs on the wing pt1 (damnit. it was pt2) YES
2. Obscured by Clouds. The Gold its in the… DAMNIT. it was obscured by clouds. That's one of my favourite tracks and I didn't get it. Awesome.
3. not a clue but Saucerful of Secrets? Hmm. No not a clue. Ummagumma Narrow Way
4. Division Bell. Marooned? Nope. Momentary Lapse, Signs of Life
5. Division Bell. damnit “The grass was greener, the light was brighter…”… High Hopes??? YES! (hah and even had that snippet)
6. WYWH. Have a Cigar. Yep. Before he goes with the answer I’m 100% convinced I’m right. YEP
7. The Wall. omg its the one before The Trial. Stop, I wanna go home, take off this uniform and leave the show. what the heck is it. :( POO. Unreal... I even had the title as i remembered the lyric.
8. Grandchester Meadows. No idea of the album. Don’t need to give the album so fingers crossed… WOOHOO! I ROCK. YES.
9. Sheep. Animals. 100%. No doubt. (I hope) the lord is my shepherd… lamb cutlets baby. YES
10. The Wall. but it was only a fantasy the wall was too high as you can see and the worms ate into his brains… and mine because i can’t remember the name of the sodding track. Is there anybody in there? it’s the bit just before it goes itno the solo. drum fill and solo. gach… oh damnit. Hey You.
11. WYWH. Shine on you crazy diamond. no idea of part. YES
12. Atom heart Mother. Atom Heart Mother. Stupid suite. Better not ask for which part it is. Breast Milky or the like :P YES
13. …. not a clue. guitar and vocal only… guess. WYWH, WYWH? hah. same as him. Hmm. second listen. really not a clue. NOPE!
14. Remember a Day. More? NOPE!
15. … nothing. just total guess because its solo with a heap of backing as Comfortably Numb. DAMN
Comfortably Numb live. Not Pulse. (That had multiple vocalists in verse) Delicate Sound of Thunder or… a cover? It wasn’t Roger either.
That was rather fun.
11/15. I missed:
Obscured By Clouds (guessed When You're In)
Signs of Life (guessed Cluster One)
Stop (Wasn't sure as I don't listen the Wall often)
Pillow of Winds (guessed Comfortably Numb, lol)
You have to be a massive Pink Floyd fan to get these lol. I missed on the last few. I only got one of the ½ second clips.
If this was like guess the song from the beginning and so many notes I could do it in one or two notes on almost every song but playing clips for the middle makes it tough
13/15 my score... In Summer '68 i thought it was something from The Wall or The Final Cut but i didn't guess it... in A Pillow Of Winds i thought it was San Tropez... right album wrong song lol... the other ones i got it right! Nice video...
Yeaahh! I've been digging the ones on youtube for the Beatles, have been waiting for a Pink Floyd one.
Think I got 12/15. Didn't get Signs of Life but I knew if was from Momentary Lapse of Reason.
haha it's such a cool game, right? it was really fun to do, sadly didn't do as well as you though!
Wow that's hard.
1 didn't get
2 obscured by clouds
3 the narrow way don't know which part?
4 remember a day? [nope]
5 something from division bell or momentary lapse
6 have a cigar
7 stop! I wanna go home
8 grantchester meadows
9 sheep
10 dogs or welcome to the machine [nope]
11 didn't get
12 dogs [nope, still not dogs]
13 us and them [nope]
14 take up thy stethoscope & walk [nope]
15 us and them [nope, 0 for 5 on the half-second clips]
You did great!
can we agree we all can tell what any pink floyd song is just by the first sound
# Pigs on the Wing part 1
childhoods end (the first track from obscured by clouds)
# The Narrow way part 3.
Terminal Frost (momentary lapse of reason)
# High Hopes
# Have a Cigar
the track before the trial in the Wall
# Granchester Meadows
# Sheep
Welcome to the machine
# Shine On you crazy diamond part 6
# Atom Heart Mother
one of my bad days
# from echoes, a pillow of winds?
Hey You.
Billy Brag doing Comfortably Numb?
I think that works out at 9/15 knowing Umma Gumma was a big help.
10/15 and that was fun. I even pulled the name of Grandchester Meadows out of my ass. I was like “no, it’s not Mandchester… I think it’s Grandchester Meadows maybe?”
I got 12/15. I was doing a perfect run but couldn't recognize the last three.
wow great result, best i've seen yet!
@@davidhartley94 I think Pink Floyd is the only band for which I would perform even half as well. That music coursed through my veins for half of my life.
I was doing so well in the first two rounds 😊9/10, the only mistake being Hey You. But round 3 is seriously mission impossible 😅
I’m just psyched I got Grantchester Meadows.