Alice Madness Returns Therapy (Intro Extended)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 жов 2024
  • After weeks of searching I also might need some therapy!
    www.mediafire.c...
    I don't own anything. All I did was extend the song, everything belongs to their rightful owners.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 644

  • @CZYA
    @CZYA 10 років тому +406

    "Carry on Alice, now focus, you're floating again, thin as air, now...Go to Wonderland"

  • @MartinFZ94
    @MartinFZ94 11 років тому +675

    It's not a dream, it's a memory... And it makes me sick!

    • @mellowandjello
      @mellowandjello 10 років тому +54

      memory is often more a curse than a blessing

    • @conciencia4687
      @conciencia4687 7 років тому +4

      the memories always back... FOR YOU°°°

    • @RichTheFlop
      @RichTheFlop 5 років тому +4

      I love that quote

  • @tarabahbeh
    @tarabahbeh 12 років тому +289

    On Halloween, I dressed as Alice to go to a party. I had a plain blue dress, a white apron with black Greek symbols drawn with fabric paint, boots with buckles, an old knife with red food coloring, and an iPhone playing these extended mixes the whole time.
    It was AWESOME.

  • @aliealie6879
    @aliealie6879 7 років тому +450

    "I can't. I'm trapped. In my past." this text always give me goosebumps

    • @XxSyl
      @XxSyl 4 роки тому +25

      Yes especially with her accent.

    • @ender8759
      @ender8759 Рік тому

      Yep

  • @yermamuwu6196
    @yermamuwu6196 7 років тому +207

    This song really toes the line between relaxing, melancholy and creepy...

  • @atkvin
    @atkvin 10 років тому +184

    Also you can actually sing along to the intro with the "Man in the Moon" poem :0
    The train is coming with its shiny cars
    With comfy seats and wheels of stars
    So little ones,have no fear
    The man in the moon is the engineer
    (original lyrics from here on lol)
    The locomotive is coming soon
    As children await impending doom
    Sweet dreams,Alice
    Creeping malice

    • @Izzy-mj8es
      @Izzy-mj8es 9 років тому +1

      Holy Shawt that GRrrrrrr8

  • @lelasouk1834
    @lelasouk1834 6 років тому +137

    In the Beginning with Lizzie’s key.
    Dr. Bumby: Come now Alice, It’s only a dream.
    Alice: It’s not a dream, It’s a memory. And it makes me sick !
    Dr. Bumby: Now, focus. Wait. You’re floating again. Weightless. A cipher, relax.
    Alice: Fire ! I’m-I’m in hell !
    Dr. Bumby: Forget It. Abandon that memory. It’s unproductive. Go to Wonderland.
    Alice: I can’t. I’m trapped... in my past.
    Fire onlooker one: Sergeant, this girl is badly burned !
    Fire onlooker two: Call for a doctor !
    Fire onlooker three: Will she be alright ?
    Dr. Bumby: No Alice, discard that illusion. Forget it ! Go to Wonderland.
    Alice: I’d rather not doctor. My Wonderland’s shattered, It’s dead to me.
    Dr. Bumby: Your preference doesn’t signify girl. Now Alice, where are you ?
    Alice: I’m sailing with a friend. It’s... different somehow. Things have changed.
    Dr. Bumby: Change is good. It’s the first link on the chain of forgetting.
    Alice: What’s happening ? Are you mad ?
    Dr. Bumby : I’m not mad.
    Alice: Rabbit !
    Dr. Bumby: That’s not right ! What’s he doing there ?
    Alice: Is something wrong ?
    White rabbit : Something ... Wrong ? RAAAAAAAAAATHER !
    Alice: Oh no ! Not that !
    Dr. Bumby: Don’t struggle, Alice. Let the new Wonderland emerge.
    Alice: Pollution, Corruption, I-it’s killing me ! My Wonderland’s destroyed, my mind is in ruins !
    Dr. Bumby: Forget It, Alice ! Block that dream, Wake at the sound !
    Alice: Ahhh !

  • @niallhoran1869
    @niallhoran1869 10 років тому +147

    'Come Now Alice' , 'Forget it' 'It's Not a Dream it's a Memory ..and it make me stick ! ' OMG *O* I feel it !

    • @mrthunderbros
      @mrthunderbros 10 років тому +31

      Yes, it make you stick Niall.

    • @Sodasaman
      @Sodasaman 10 років тому +36

      FEEL THE STICK INSIDE OF YOU

    • @eevonnesim7725
      @eevonnesim7725 10 років тому +3

      ***** I love this quote !

  • @MangaArtistify
    @MangaArtistify 11 років тому +138

    "Diception...corruption...it's - killing me! MY MIND IS IN RUINS!!!!"
    I swear, that was one of the creepiest moments in the game. But on a serious note, this music is epic.

    • @springbonnie4767
      @springbonnie4767 4 роки тому +1

      C-Creepy? For me this song make me reflect about somethings...

  • @castvenus1902
    @castvenus1902 9 років тому +78

    you can feel the corruption, and the sadness...its so amazing, this game goes into my small list of dark games with gorgeous music, along with dead space 2 and fallout 3

  • @Alice_Liddel
    @Alice_Liddel 11 років тому +584

    Madness is not a state of mind, Madness is a place, Lets go there shall we?

    • @Cerise4697
      @Cerise4697 8 років тому +9

      It WAS. At least for the first game.

    • @conciencia4687
      @conciencia4687 7 років тому +32

      Alice Liddel.
      °°------The madness is the only cure for this insane world------°°

    • @AerysVT
      @AerysVT 7 років тому +1

      ._. nah way too cute for me x)

    • @basedaudio1
      @basedaudio1 7 років тому +1

      state of mind..

    • @Koko-hu1om
      @Koko-hu1om 6 років тому

      Alice Liddel Hey Alice! How you doing?

  • @squid-ink74
    @squid-ink74 Рік тому +12

    So sad to see this track isnt on Spotify, i think its one of the kost beautiful, poetic pieces of music on this soundtrack!

  • @takiashii
    @takiashii 8 років тому +77

    I put this on at night before I went to bed, and I was falling asleep but the ending scared the living hell out of me.
    I thought I was in a horror movie about to be murdered, I didn't know the ending was like that HAHA. It terrified me, but was interesting feeling so much fear.

    • @ironicmedic3912
      @ironicmedic3912 8 років тому +1

      +Takiashii same here, i find it so soothing, despite the "corruption behind every note"

    • @PomegranatePomPom
      @PomegranatePomPom 7 років тому +1

      Takiashii ohh you spoil me... XD...well I prefer its midnight and im in the dark.

    • @gothmomcosplays
      @gothmomcosplays 6 років тому +4

      Yeah, I was almost asleep and then I hollered out of bed with a scream fumbling to get my headphones out of my ears

  • @pineapple3564
    @pineapple3564 9 років тому +128

    This song really makes you think what's real and what isn't

    • @weabooofuckboy3351
      @weabooofuckboy3351 9 років тому +5

      like the profile picture you have....

    • @pineapple3564
      @pineapple3564 9 років тому +1

      Thank you

    • @pineapple3564
      @pineapple3564 9 років тому

      thank you very much:)

    • @hansolano
      @hansolano 8 років тому +1

      +Carlos Demanero cute? CUTE??? wtf yo are crazy bitch

    • @angelique2056
      @angelique2056 8 років тому

      +Flexible Danlord it's cute to him/her, shut your mouth

  • @AkiraDesmondes
    @AkiraDesmondes 12 років тому +4

    Just... close your eyes... and hear the creepy parts while a little sick smile is drawn in ur face... it is the best feeling in the world.

  • @necrosiscosplays1875
    @necrosiscosplays1875 10 років тому +30

    this made me tear up. sounds like my life. all twisted and dark.
    all insane

    • @necrosiscosplays1875
      @necrosiscosplays1875 10 років тому

      Aoi Mahou to me, it means the same. i was abused all my life, lost my birth family at age 2, was sexually abused, lost, forgotten.
      Thrown away.

    • @necrosiscosplays1875
      @necrosiscosplays1875 10 років тому

      Aoi Mahou still being abused. i am 18, and i have been thrown away by my family.

    • @necrosiscosplays1875
      @necrosiscosplays1875 10 років тому

      Aoi Mahou its verbal, not physical. and i do have a job. two.
      i am forced everyday to re-live my agony. there are cuts on my arms where my birth father gashed me. when i was 3. thats why i was adopted, but the home i live in now doesnt understand me. so, i lock myself in my room and draw and write poems that are so dark and demented, even i freak. i have no friends.

    • @necrosiscosplays1875
      @necrosiscosplays1875 10 років тому

      Aoi Mahou I get punished.

    • @necrosiscosplays1875
      @necrosiscosplays1875 10 років тому

      Aoi Mahou for being who i am; Goth.

  • @GrahamChapman
    @GrahamChapman 8 років тому +30

    The rapist therapist's therapy.

    • @ZgermanGuy.
      @ZgermanGuy. 7 років тому +3

      "have you ever tried seeing it from his perspective?"

  • @Sk8terGaMer89
    @Sk8terGaMer89 12 років тому +19

    "I'm sailing...with a friend...what's happening?? Are you mad?!
    Rabbit? Is something wrong?...Oh no! Not that!!"

  • @manubonillaproduc
    @manubonillaproduc 4 роки тому +20

    my god, 2020 and still a masterpiece

  • @pandelianyammata2622
    @pandelianyammata2622 10 років тому +96

    I love! Alice mardness returns is a game very beatiful! I am french. I don't speek english I am sorry :(

    • @hugojust5399
      @hugojust5399 10 років тому +17

      I agree with you ! This game is just amazing and so are the musics ! I love it !

    • @pipistrelle8927
      @pipistrelle8927 10 років тому +5

      L'aurais tu découvert grâce à l'ami Siphano ? En tout cas c'est mon cas :3

    • @pandelianyammata2622
      @pandelianyammata2622 10 років тому +4

      Mama Bou Oui :) C'est un youtubeur important pour moi, c'est le premier que j'ai connu!

    • @pipistrelle8927
      @pipistrelle8927 10 років тому +3

      Pandélia Nyammata Pareil pour moi, un des premiers avec les autres membres de notre regrettée CoopTeam.

    • @yesseniatapia2765
      @yesseniatapia2765 6 років тому

      I also agree with you this game is really amazing and so the music

  • @smashbroslover1
    @smashbroslover1 11 років тому +1

    I HAVE BEEN LOOKING EVRYWHERE FOR THIS!!!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!!!

  • @ProjectRebirth8
    @ProjectRebirth8 11 років тому +1

    Oh my god! i knew you worked wonders!!ive wanted this song for awhile! Thank you!

  • @Draziell
    @Draziell 12 років тому +1

    When I wanna listen to great songs, I came to your channel...

  • @anders19287
    @anders19287 11 років тому +3

    This soundtrack is "purrrrrrrrrrfect"

  • @OpalLily88
    @OpalLily88 10 років тому +17

    "Go To Wonderland"

  • @jennifercarvente
    @jennifercarvente 3 роки тому +6

    Play it with 0.75x speed. It does sound like fear and melancholy trying to trigger craziness...

  • @UneNuitFroide
    @UneNuitFroide 9 років тому +33

    Need a next chapter :(

  • @tomoegozen6602
    @tomoegozen6602 10 років тому +43

    Come now alice...

    • @MartinFZ94
      @MartinFZ94 10 років тому +11

      It's only a dream...

    • @natarthegreatar3515
      @natarthegreatar3515 10 років тому +12

      It's not a dream... It's a memory. And it makes me sick!

    • @KiraUserBK201amv
      @KiraUserBK201amv 9 років тому +3

      Fire! I'm in hell!

    • @Phonyboney
      @Phonyboney 9 років тому +5

      Kíra Usér Forget it! Abandon that memory. It's unproductive. Go to Wonderland.

    • @kumargovin5171
      @kumargovin5171 9 років тому +2

      I can't. I'm trapped...in my past.

  • @spinky6937
    @spinky6937 10 років тому +17

    i have been trying to find this song and i have finely found it

  • @alysonrodrigues1492
    @alysonrodrigues1492 9 років тому +1

    Dark but beautiful. Some parts of this song remind me of the Infernal Train and of drowning (the bubbling water sounds).

  • @johannagustafsson212
    @johannagustafsson212 10 років тому +19

    Don't get me wrong; I still love these games ^^

  • @daniil3275
    @daniil3275 4 роки тому +1

    One of the BEST games in history, so fucking haunting

  • @JulietHasAGun89
    @JulietHasAGun89 12 років тому +8

    "Forget it, Alice. Forget it! Go to Wonderland."
    "I'd rather not, doctor. My Wonderland is shattered!"

  • @LeBadman
    @LeBadman 8 років тому +25

    Go.. to Wonderland.

  • @Alissa19971
    @Alissa19971 11 років тому +1

    play this game and enter rainy mood in another tab!!!
    IT TURN OUT REALLY AWESOME!!!

  • @MadPropzBaller
    @MadPropzBaller 10 років тому +12

    Is it mad to pray for better halucinations?

  • @Monika23ization
    @Monika23ization 11 років тому +1

    Darkness comes with this music... I can't, I can't to play it... It's too sad

  • @YashamaruSensei
    @YashamaruSensei 11 років тому +2

    Don't struggle ,Alice. Let the new Wonderland emerge

  • @zhongmew
    @zhongmew 12 років тому +8

    Beautiful melody concealed with sadness and creepiness.I never discovered this melody before in the game due to the intro
    dialogue.

  • @GroovyGianni
    @GroovyGianni 11 років тому +1

    Ahh, I always go to this soundtrack when I need inspiration to draw. Always helps.

  • @Dalek-Galvo
    @Dalek-Galvo 2 роки тому +3

    There’s no such thing as true sanity, we’re all quite mad, it’s just that some people don’t realize it until it’s too late.

  • @katblackwell
    @katblackwell 3 роки тому +6

    The best intro with the best music in video game history imo.

  • @JulietHasAGun89
    @JulietHasAGun89 12 років тому +1

    Yeah me too. To pretty much everything.
    I had, and still have an odd emotional connection with this game as well. As well as with other psychological horror games that I've played: Rule of Rose and Haunting Ground were among the ones I had strange connections with. But this game is...amazing. In almost every aspect. So many quotes said by characters in the game made me refer back to myself, and even made me want to be more like Alice: quick-witted and resourceful.

  • @awesomeninja9178
    @awesomeninja9178 10 років тому +58

    if you start at the pic of a good amount of time with this music the knife looks real, the letters on the strings look like they are swaying and i feel like I'm going mad as a hatter

  • @niewinnatv1264
    @niewinnatv1264 10 років тому +26

    Go To Wonderland

  • @Cerise4697
    @Cerise4697 12 років тому

    Oh. My. Effing. God.
    Let me just-I-um-holy SHIT. Where the hell did you find this? Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you SO much for this. My head is just spinning with joy right now.

  • @TheMoonPower
    @TheMoonPower 12 років тому

    They do still use leeches in hospitals nowadays, though. Their saliva has a chemical that keeps the blood constant during long operations, and it's the easiest method of extracting blood without using a syringe.

  • @loth_one
    @loth_one 10 років тому +36

    Come now Alice.. :3

  • @555sarin
    @555sarin 10 років тому +1

    "Did I ever tell you the definition of insanity?"

    • @curebanabanana
      @curebanabanana 9 років тому

      +555sarin That's from Far Cry 3 not Alice:Madness Returns.Btw,insanity is doing the same fuc.king thing again and again/over and over(I don't remember which one).

  • @asiahouseman4897
    @asiahouseman4897 7 років тому

    its creepy to listen to this at night but at the same time I feel so.. at peace when I listen to this?

  • @MorgauxMinx
    @MorgauxMinx 11 років тому +1

    Beautifully melancholic, dark and emotive. Love the game, love the music 3

  • @MewMewGirl212
    @MewMewGirl212 11 років тому +1

    "You're floating again..weightless... a cipher... relax. Alice"

  • @ShiftyMcGoggles
    @ShiftyMcGoggles 12 років тому

    no, hole-in-head is trepany, Lobotomy is where they push an icepick through your eye to deactivate the aggression in your head.
    Or something like that.

  • @karymefraire469
    @karymefraire469 8 років тому +12

    i really like this music......it.......relax me a lot

  • @axonn
    @axonn 12 років тому

    I live in an apartment and I'll always play this when my idiot neighbour is talking loudly outside my door. Now every time she'll haul ass quickly to her door. This works for door to door salesmen too.

  • @wendyneverland2377
    @wendyneverland2377 9 років тому +7

    There is no method in this madness!

  • @DamienStarry0w0
    @DamienStarry0w0 9 років тому +12

    separate the e and r from therapist it will say the rapist

  • @BrianDB1990
    @BrianDB1990 10 років тому +6

    I'd totally have a music box made with the basics of this melody

  • @lupine3333
    @lupine3333 11 років тому +1

    they've already made several alice and wonderland films......

  • @serendipity-edits
    @serendipity-edits 6 років тому +5

    wow honestly I keep replying your extended versions and never commented and I don't even know if you're gonna see this but WWOW you really know how to extend the songs so that it doesn't sound weird. Most people just put the same song on repeat.This is art ♥

  • @simonakostudisova1253
    @simonakostudisova1253 10 років тому +11

    Geniality!!!!!

  • @beccapiper6121
    @beccapiper6121 10 років тому +5

    Something wrong? Raaaatherrr! :D

  • @amandamarie5808
    @amandamarie5808 11 років тому +1

    I'm sailing.... with a friend! Hmm, it's.... different somehow. Things have changed

  •  9 років тому +111

    This comment section of full of angsty and edgy teens.

    • @Avyrsoul
      @Avyrsoul 9 років тому +16

      +FanskapsJägar'n Was literally just about to say the same thing. The comments are more edgy and angsty than shadow the hedgehog.

    • @RuSosan
      @RuSosan 8 років тому +18

      +FanskapsJägar'n
      One could make an entire suit of armor and a sword from all the IRONy in your comment, and yet the sheer stupidity of the comment could shatter them both like brittle glass.
      :P
      I mean come on (From your channel info):
      *What is real? What does colour taste like? Are the pillars of Argent Dawn really what they appear to be?*

    • @elizabethstouffer3378
      @elizabethstouffer3378 8 років тому +3

      lol true. Too bad really, this game has a gorgeous soundtrack, but people are more focused on being "edgy" than the breathtaking music. Oh well.

    • @cx0kieisaunicxrnmsp728
      @cx0kieisaunicxrnmsp728 7 років тому +1

      FanskapsJägar'n Its mostly for insane wanabes

    • @toad9978
      @toad9978 7 років тому +3

      wow okay, ppl overuse edgy to much

  • @alexgacha8034
    @alexgacha8034 5 років тому +1

    Come now Alice its only a dream
    It’s not a dream, it’s a memory... And it makes me sick!
    Carry on Alice... you’re floating, thin as air... now go to wonderland
    (Forgot da rest except for this right here)
    I’m sailing with a friend! I guess it’s not so bad after all!
    (Forgot the doctors part)
    Huh? Are you fine rabbit?
    Rabbit? That’s not right
    Are you mad?
    Mad? RAATHERRRRRR
    (Oof forgot again)
    And now that’s all I know in the intro XD

  • @shihoritsukiyomi
    @shihoritsukiyomi 8 років тому +1

    I can't wait to return home and play this game!

  • @seky461
    @seky461 3 роки тому +2

    Everyone: Man, i want to be mad just like Alice :c
    Mad people: ... Who said that?

  • @Irmabe29
    @Irmabe29 12 років тому +1

    Finally! Love this song

  • @elliepadgett4394
    @elliepadgett4394 11 років тому +2

    I'm sailing.. with a friend! Hmm, it's different somehow; things have changed.

  • @kayleigh8611
    @kayleigh8611 11 років тому +1

    "I'm trapped....in my past..."

  • @Solalaugh
    @Solalaugh 11 років тому +1

    Somehow I always have to move my head with the rythmen...
    ♪ ♬ ♪ ♫ ♩ ♪ ♫ ♩ ♬ ♭

  • @alexmark5780
    @alexmark5780 10 років тому +7

    Flawless music

  • @Ashifers-ghost
    @Ashifers-ghost 12 років тому +1

    Absolutely looove this tune!!!!!!!! im learning to play it on the piano ~ its just so nice to listen to :3 you're a legend ;)

  • @ialeniatachibana9969
    @ialeniatachibana9969 11 років тому +1

    I'm sailing. With a friend! Hmmm. It's different somehow.. things have changed.

  • @OpalLily88
    @OpalLily88 11 років тому +2

    You were almost there. Almost free from what you fear. You could have been cured, you could have forgotten..

  • @shelby7939
    @shelby7939 12 років тому

    I just restarted the game to walk around the town to see if there was any reason for the posters around town and I nearly flipped shit when I walked to that alley with the kids in it left of the Houndsditch Home. If you walk to the junk heap next to a little girl, that girl will start reciting the same thing Bumby says at the end of the game. Also, I did find that the newspaper name is "Medical Times and Gazette" and there's a bar named "The Flaming Stallion". xD Like Spicy Horse.

  • @MrKlausbaudelaire
    @MrKlausbaudelaire 12 років тому +1

    omg, FINALLY someone found that song D: thank you thank you thank you thank you

  • @EpicZeldaFanCosplay
    @EpicZeldaFanCosplay 9 років тому +1

    THANK YOU FOR THIS!!! love the description btw lol

  • @typingreallyfast
    @typingreallyfast 11 років тому +1

    So the other day I was at the mountain garden, and there's this really cute rabbit. She tried to run away, but I chased her to this hole. Fuck, it's too small for me.
    Any suggestions?

  • @IndieEmpress
    @IndieEmpress 11 років тому +1

    i love the game,especially the intro!

  • @WindWraith5
    @WindWraith5 11 років тому

    It's not a dream, its a memory...and it makes me sick!

  • @Sk8terGaMer89
    @Sk8terGaMer89 12 років тому +1

    When you're on your last rose (health), you'll see a blinking red circle in the top left corner. Press L3

  • @joseluisgonzales4933
    @joseluisgonzales4933 Рік тому +1

    Yo buscando pistas me encuentro con joyas
    Me encanta la música de terror. Y
    Me gusta el paranormal

  • @charliepippinpage1873
    @charliepippinpage1873 11 років тому

    It's not a dream... It's a... a memory

  • @awesomeninja9178
    @awesomeninja9178 7 років тому

    i can see the letters swaying after looking at it for a while

  • @MsDreamcatcher123
    @MsDreamcatcher123 12 років тому +1

    "The train is coming with it's shiny cars. With comfy seats and wheels of stars. So hush my little ones, have no fear. The Man on the Moon is the engineer."

  • @Pie885
    @Pie885 12 років тому +2

    Oh my God that's awesome! Thank you so much for this! I was always wanted to listen to this but, with Bumby and Alice talking through the whole I couldn't listen. And, you extended it! TY so much

  • @HookersFancyMe
    @HookersFancyMe 8 років тому +12

    This piece kind of reminds of of something Nox Arcana would do.

  • @KitsuneHime69
    @KitsuneHime69 11 років тому +1

    It's one of the Dr. Bumby memories in the game, you find it in the card bridge level. Not sure if it was inspired by a quote or not.

  • @celinealalm8385
    @celinealalm8385 10 років тому +6

    BEST GAME EVER!!!!!!

  • @ELCORZO_2001
    @ELCORZO_2001 4 роки тому +1

    Like si vienes por las creepypastas de El Señor Oscuro

  • @Nexils
    @Nexils 11 років тому

    I was so disturbed by the exploding rabbit and the hands ripping Alice's flesh off.
    Yes, I could watch the trailer whatever I wanted but NOOO not the Dead rising off the record trailer because I was too young for that trailer for some reason :p
    I was old enough to watch the horrific Madness returns trailer apparently XD

  • @theblackkat2164
    @theblackkat2164 10 років тому +1

    Added to my favorites

  • @itsmejulia1
    @itsmejulia1 12 років тому +1

    I've been looking for this since I saw the Trailer!!! :'D THANK YOU

  • @Sk8terGaMer89
    @Sk8terGaMer89 12 років тому +2

    "It's not a dream...it's uhh a memory. And it makes me sick!"

  • @AAAAA_9872
    @AAAAA_9872 5 років тому +1

    It kinds sounds like look what you made me do by taylor swift some of the parts

  • @LPxxHU
    @LPxxHU 10 років тому +8

    Siphano :D

  • @crimsoncuttlefish8842
    @crimsoncuttlefish8842 3 роки тому +1

    Reminds me of 'the White Rabbit Question' from Fran Bow

  • @SawaVan
    @SawaVan 12 років тому +1

    goOd i love the music and game is amazing *w*

  • @hauptmann25
    @hauptmann25 12 років тому +1

    So when you have the "villain complex" an inherent desire to harm other , physically or emotionaly whats the case then?